Follow TV Tropes

This entry is trivia, which is cool and all, but not a trope. On a work, it goes on the Trivia tab.

Following

Orphaned Reference

Go To

An Orphaned Reference is a scene or line that refers to something that has been cut from the final version. In milder cases, this only means that what was supposed to be a Meaningful Echo loses its additional meaning; in more severe cases, the lost background information can cause apparent Noodle Incidents, Plot Holes or Ass Pulls.

Compare The Artifact, The Other Marty. See also Dub-Induced Plot Hole and Adaptation-Induced Plot Hole; all adaptation and dub examples go there. When the reference is found in licensed material, it's Early Draft Tie-In. Some video game examples may overlap with Dummied Out and Missing Secret. Development Gag is when this is done deliberately as a meta joke.

Advertisement:


Examples:

    open/close all folders 

    Anime and Manga 
  • Hilariously lampshaded in Dragon Half, when Dug Fin is horrified to discover no one knows who he is. He gets a hold of the series' first episode on videotape and reviews it, only to discover all his scenes were cut from the final version!
  • Tengen Toppa Gurren Lagann does this, possibly unintentionally, in the first Compilation Movie, Gurren-hen. When Kittan and his sisters show up to help the heroes, Kamina reacts with "Wait, who the hell are you?", which seems an appropriate reaction considering that the movie edited the scene where Kamina and Simon first encounter them into a Travel Montage, making this their first real appearance in the movie. "Unintentional" because this same line is present in the original series (which devoted an entire episode to meeting Kittan), but in the Movie it's made funnier.

    Comic Books 
  • Archie Comics' Sonic the Hedgehog: In the issue following the Endgame arc, where Sally had suffered an almost fatal fall, Sally suddenly starts acting out-of-character, which Sonic notes, but then it gets dropped and never comes up again. It was supposed to foreshadow a twist that Sally really had died during Endgame and her body had been replaced with a robot duplicate.
  • The Transformers
    • In The Transformers: All Hail Megatron, during a rant, Starscream briefly mentions Scourge as a Decepticon who could potentially overthrow Megatron. Scourge was originally supposed to appear in the miniseries as a kind of Evil Counterpart to Kup, but Hasbro rejected the idea. To make things more egregious, later issues contradicted the line by showing Scourge as part of the non-Decepticon aligned Dead Universe faction.
    • In Issue 12 of More Than Meets the Eye, it's briefly mentioned that Rewind is allergic to ultraviolet light, which was meant to foreshadow a reveal that never came to pass: Chromedome had used mnemosurgery to alter Rewind's memory—mnemosurgery scars having been established as only being visible under ultraviolet light—so that he wouldn't remember the fate of Dominus Ambus (who had infiltrated the Decepticons as Agent 113).

    Fan Works 
  • In the Good Omens work "I Shall Endure to The End!", A.A. Pessimal speculates on the nature of the lost book of The Bible, the Book of Enoch (see "Mythology and Religion" below), which only exists by inference - St Paul makes approving references to a great book of a prophet of old which the believer must read. But which did not make the final cut of Biblical canon. All you get are two or three enigmatic orphaned references to a prophet called Enoch who is held to be one of the greatest and mightiest ever. Pessimal speculated that the contents of the Book of Enoch were such dynamite that the angel Aziraphale was charged with hiding it and ensuring humans never got to find it again. Ever. Aziraphale, who is temperamentally opposed to burning books, hides it in his library of manuscript scrolls, but ensures enough plausible forgeries claiming to be the Book of Enoch are released into the world to divert the wrong sorts of human minds and stop them doing anything dangerous. There is also an inference in a later Discworld fic that Aziraphale has thought creatively about this problem and has handed the Book of Enoch into the safekeeping of the Librarian of Unseen University - also opposed to book-burning and who can be relied upon to keep it both safe and "lost" - on a different world completely, thus ensuring that it remains lost on Earth and an orphaned reference forever.
  • Queen of Shadows has an example brought about by the original author, Nocturne no Kitsune, disappearing offline and leaving his partner Eduard Kassel to pick up the slack in writing. Early in the story, Jade finds a severed kitsune tail in a cabinet in the Queen's antechamber to the Generals' meeting room. Apparently, Nocturne had plans for it later in the story, but failed to share them with Eduard before falling out of communication. As such, the latter has had no idea what to do with it, beyond a passing reference of Jade pondering why it's there.
Advertisement:

    Film — Animation 
  • The commentary for Atlantis: The Lost Empire tells a story about how there used to be a mystic named Zoltan (who used to speak in the third person, for some reason) along for the ride. At one point everybody sounds off after falling down a hole. For the longest time he was still there shouting "Zoltan is okay!" even after his character had been written out of the script.
  • In Brave, Merida was originally supposed to end up with Young MacGuffin, hence his name being a reference to the plot device. In the final film, his name no longer has any meaning.
  • Final Fantasy: The Spirits Within gives a lot of attention to Aki telling a story about extracting the fifth spirit from a little girl with a terminal illness. This girl was a supporting character called Meg, who had a much larger role, but was dropped from the script.
  • In the Rankin/Bass The Hobbit, the Elf King and the Dwarves argue about how the dwarves scared off a party of elves and stole their food. This happens in the book, but they didn't add that scene to the animated film. This also leads to their very first mention being the narrated line "the Wood Elves had returned..."
  • The full-length version of "Great Big World" in Hoodwinked! contained the line "They say that goodies make the woods go 'round" and a shot of Red being carried across the river by a flock of birds. While the general theme of pastries being Serious Business was kept, the exact line doesn't come up again until the climax as part of the Goodie Bandit's Villain Song. In between, Red explains the importance of her delivery job by saying "woods don't go 'round by themselves", which makes little sense without the setup. The scene with the flock of birds also comes up twice later — it's the part of the song the Wolf sees from another angle in his retelling of the story, and the detective Nicky Flippers mentions that she was "flying a flock of birds without a permit".
  • Many fans of The Lion King II: Simba's Pride noticed that Zira seems to be smiling as she falls to her death. That's because it was originally supposed to be a suicide; however, that was deemed too dark. They added in Zira struggling, removed the most obvious parts of the suicide, and added screaming to make it seem like she accidentally fell. Unfortunately, they failed to change her expression as she fell.
  • In Little Nemo: Adventures in Slumberland, Nemo has a dream where he goes down to the pantry and sees a note on the ice box saying "You promised", before water bursts out and floods the house. Viewers watching the old VHS cut would make the connection that Nemo had just broken his promise to King Morpheus, but miss out on the double meaning because of a deleted scene while Nemo was awake where he promised his mother he'd stay out of the ice box and not eat the pie she'd baked.
  • Pocahontas:
    • The titular heroine's love of the water and hobby of canoeing originally came from a plot point where she received advice from a river spirit called Old Man River. The actor they planned to voice this character - Gregory Peck - said Pocahontas needed a motherly figure instead. Thus they created Grandmother Willow. In the film the canoeing is justified by having Grandmother Willow's tree be near the water, and Pocahontas has to row there to visit her.
    • The end credits have a pop song called "If I Never Knew You" playing over them. This is in fact a cover of a song that was originally a romantic duet between Pocahontas and John Smith right after he has been captured, and a reprise would be sung in their final scene together. The tune of the song can be heard elsewhere throughout the movie's score.
  • In The Road to El Dorado, when Tulio asks why Chel would help him and Miguel steal from her own people, she says, "You've got your reasons, and I have mine." Originally, there was going to be a scene of her almost getting sacrificed to the gods, and then escaping. This is why she is seen being chased by the guards when Tulio and Miguel first meet her. This was cut out of the film for being too dark, but was left in some promotional media, like the tie-in book on tape.
  • Sleeping Beauty was originally going to give the three fairies powers based off their names — Flora had powers over plant life, Fauna had powers over wildlife and Merryweather powers around the weather. These were eliminated from the final film, but are still referenced a couple of times - Flora's plan to turn Aurora into a flower, her transforming arrows into plants and the fairies' gifts to Aurora (Flora's sequence shows flower motifs, Fauna's birds and Merryweather the sun coming out from behind a cloud).
  • The closing credits sequence of Tangled includes references to scenes that were cut from the movie, including Flynn encountering a bear and Rapunzel consulting a psychic monkey.
  • Up:
    • At one point, Carl unknowingly scares away Charles Muntz's dogs with the feedback from his hearing aid, which was supposed to set up Carl doing it deliberately later in the movie, but the filmmakers couldn't find a place to fit it in.
    • Muntz talks about how easy it is to get lost inside the labyrinth where Kevin lives, and that you can't get out once you're inside. This was the setup for a dropped ending where Muntz follows some balloons he thinks are Kevin into the labyrinth and ends up getting trapped inside.
  • Zootopia features a meta example. One scene depicts various bootleg DVDs parodying Disney films. Pig Hero 6, Wreck-it Rhino, Meowna, etc. One of them is called Giraffic. This was a case of Production Foreshadowing, however, one year later Gigantic was officially cancelled. This means the reference doesn't make any sense to people who aren't knowledgeable about Disney history, because the film it parodies never came out.

    Film — Live-Action 
  • American Beauty opens with a home movie of Ricky asking Jane if she wants him to kill her father, to which she replies yes. We see the full scene later in the film and it turns out they're just being sarcastic. But this is a remnant of a large subplot that was filmed and cut. The video would incriminate Jane and Ricky for Lester's murder.
  • Scott Pilgrim vs. The World has some milder ones:
    • "Is that seriously the end of the story?" — Originally, this was Kim's response to Scott's flashback about how he met Knives on the bus (she dropped her books, he picked them up), later echoed by Ramona when she hears it from Knives. The flashback scene was cut in the final version.
    • In an early, discarded version of Scott and Ramona's first date, Ramona was seen lighting a cigarette, saying she smokes only on special occasions. Scott was supposed to be echoing her after his battle with Roxy, when he says he only drinks on special occasions.
  • In The Sixth Sense, when the protagonist realizes he's a ghost, there is an echo of the boy saying "I see people". The line "I see people" was not used in the final cut (he only says "I see dead people").
  • Several in Monkeybone.
    • Harry Knowles of Ain't It Cool News has two cameos as a next-door neighbor, wearing shirts that said "Lucky" and "Stiff"; one of the cameos was cut.
    • The stain on Stu's Grim Reaper costume is explained from a deleted scene, that showed him stealing it.
  • In The Goonies, there is a deleted scene with an octopus. At the end of the film Data says "The octopus was scary!" while he's being interviewed, despite the fact it was cut. The octopus scene is included in the TV version of the movie, however.
  • An example of this trope is actually in the title of Batman Forever. The title seems odd to many audience members until they realize it is in reference to a line of dialogue that was in a deleted scene. Though the word "forever" was used in two different dialogues:
    Two-Face: (believed Batman was killed) Farewell forever to that pointy-eared night rat!

    Bruce: (to Chase about his Dark and Troubled Past) I fell. I fell forever.
  • Monty Python's Life of Brian originally had a whole subplot about King Otto, who was to have been A Nazi by Any Other Name. The only mention of Otto in the finished film is when his crack suicide squad show up in the final scene.
  • In The Wizard of Oz, there's a scene where the Wicked Witch is giving instructions for her flying monkeys to intercept Dorothy's party, and she says, "They'll give you no trouble, I promise you that. I've sent a little insect on ahead to take the fight out of them." This was in reference to a deleted scene where a bug called the Jitterbug stings the main characters, and they break into a dance number.
    • Dorothy telling the Scarecrow "I think I'll miss you most of all" makes a bit more sense if you know about a cut subplot where Scarecrow's "real world" counterpart, Hunk, was Dorothy's close friend and Implied Love Interest. Both subplots are described here.
  • Suspiria (1977) was originally planned to have twelve-year-old girls as the protagonists, but changed them to twenty-somethings to avoid being banned. The script was not changed, leading to...
    • When Olga is introduced, she childishly says that Suzie and Sara have the "names of snakes" and sticks her tongue out. Sara follows suit.
    • Suzie prefers to rent a room at Olga's rather than stay at the school, because she doesn't want to feel "like a kid" at boarding school. You'd be hard pressed to find a twenty-something student who'd pass up a free room in the name of maturity.
  • Who Framed Roger Rabbit:
    • Eddie scolds Roger for dancing for the bar patrons and potentially blowing his cover while "I'm out there risking my neck out for you." It's a fairly generic line, except that the immediate events don't warrant it; Eddie went from leaving Roger in the hidden room at the bar straight to his office, where he meets Jessica, and then back out to find Roger dancing. The line makes more sense when one considers the deleted scene (included in the comic version) that would have followed Roger's drop-off, where Eddie is caught snooping in Jessica's dressing room by Judge Doom and is sent to Toontown, where he is given a "tooneroo", a toon pig painted on top of his head. He goes back to his office to wash it off, which then segues to his encounter with Jessica.
    • An early draft of the scripted included an extra scene where Eddie visits Marvin Acme's funeral, which would feature more animated cameos. Then, Eddie would be spying on a private conversation between R.K. Maroon and Judge Doom, which further raised Eddie's suspicions of the former's involvement and led to him snooping into Jessica's dressing room.
  • Star Trek: Generations had baddie Soran make a hammier than usual remark about Geordi's heart just not being in a conversation. Which made no sense on its own, but referred to a cut scene that involved him torturing Geordi by repeatedly stopping his heart. You can see the cut scene here. It also has Dr. Crusher saying "I removed the nanoprobe" (that Soran used to stop Geordi's heart), leaving the audience to wonder "what nanoprobe?"
  • In National Treasure, there's a quick moment where one character is seen grabbing a knife. It was never put to use later; the production team was planning on it, but cut that element out (partly for ratings reasons).
  • For National Treasure 2: Book of Secrets, they filmed a scene in which the bad guy stabs the protagonist's father; however, they took this out because they felt it crossed the Moral Event Horizon and undermined his Death Equals Redemption moment later. However, there is still a shot in the film in which the actor is acting like he's injured because they didn't re-shoot that scene.
  • The song 'When Love Is Gone' was cut from the theatrical version of The Muppet Christmas Carol, but several references to it still appear. Most obvious are the reprise 'When Love Is Found' and the pop song version during the closing credits. It is also prominently featured in the soundtrack's overture. This applies to the Blu-ray release too, which ported over a behind the scenes extra from the extended cut DVD showing the recording of 'When Love Is Gone', even though the song is completely absent from the Blu-ray.
  • In The Lord of the Rings, Faramir's lines "A chance for Faramir, captain of Gondor, to prove his quality," and "Tell him I send a mighty gift" were supposed to be Meaningful Echos of what his father Denethor says to him earlier, in Osgiliath. The scene in Osgiliath was deleted, though it can be found in the Extended Version of the film. Granted, Book!Faramir did say the first line at about the same point in the story and Book!Denethor did refer to the Ring as "a mighty gift" that Boromir would not have let slip by in Return, so the references are merely demoted to "shout-outs to the source".
  • In the Richard Lester cut of Superman II when Clark sees General Zod taking over the White House, Lois tells Clark "You didn't know", only for Clark to reply "He knew". Clark is referring to Jor-El telling him about the Kryptonian villains, but those scenes were removed from the Lester cut.
  • Three Men and a Baby has a deleted plot thread about Jack Holden (Ted Danson's character) appearing in a dog food commercial. This explains the cardboard standees of him that pop up in a couple spots in the final cut that inspired a famous Urban Legend.
  • In Wing Commander, the Pilgrim is asked at one point about his pilgrim pendant, to which he replies that he doesn't have it anymore. The reason why he lost it is never explained in the movie. The reason for that is because a scene where he stabs a traitor with the pendant was filmed but cut from the final version of the movie.
  • There's a deleted scene from Kung Pow! Enter the Fist where an old man writes "MOUTH" on the Chosen One's face. There's a scene or two in the final cut where this writing is still visible.
  • The Viral Marketing for Iron Man 2 included a fake commercial for the Stark-Fujikawa subsidiary, which made little sense in the overall context of the film. This is because the character Rumiko Fujikawa (a Japanese businesswoman and one of Tony's love interests from the comics) was supposed to appear in the film, but was cut when the script was rewritten.
  • In The Avengers, Banner's line that "you could smell the crazy on [Loki]" was supposed to set up a Brick Joke of the Hulk doing just that — Loki would use duplicates but Hulk would find the real one by his scent.
  • In Four Rooms, Tim Roth's character is given five warnings: "Stay clear of night clerks, kids, hookers, and married arguments" and "Keep your cock in your pants." Over the course of the film he violates each of these... except the one about the hookers. They just never show up.note  Other evidence (some of the animations during the opening credits, and a group of naked ladies fleeing the room at the beginning of the last segment) suggests a fifth story was cut out late in the game.
  • In Terminator 2: Judgment Day they cut all the scenes of the T-1000's shapeshifting malfunctions before release. Only one was left in, after he neutralizes the Terminator and a single ripple of silver runs up his body, which confused audiences until the Director's Cut was released and explained what was going on.
  • X-Men:
    • At one point, Senator Kelly mentions that Jean Grey is a mutant, despite no prior indication that he knew her secret. The original script had a scene where Jean would've accidentally outed herself as a mutant in front of Kelly, which was cut just before filming was to begin. This is also why there's a deleted scene on the DVD release where Xavier scolds Jean for losing control of her powers in public, something that doesn't actually happen at any point in the movie.
    • The official prequel comic book shows a photo of Logan with a mysterious woman that he knew before his memories were erased, and the woman in question even appears in some of his dreams. This was going to be a minor subplot in the actual movie (and was even referenced in one of the script excerpts Hugh Jackman read for his audition), but was ultimately removed from the script.
    • Storm's Pre-Mortem One-Liner against Toad was meant to be the anticlimactic punchline to a Running Gag of Toad arrogantly boasting about "what happens to a toad when [x]". All of Toad's dialogue setting it up was taken out of the script, leaving us with Storm making a really weird quip out of nowhere before she blasts him with lightning.
  • X-rays of wings can be seen in Stryker's lab in X2: X-Men United. This is because the movie was originally going to have a subplot where Stryker would've kidnapped Angel from the Xavier Institute and forcibly transformed him into Archangel through experimentation. Though Angel was removed from the script, the X-rays were retained.
  • Dogma has Cardinal Glick place an odd emphasis on God being male, considering the final cut has nobody telling him otherwise.
    • And before that, Mallrats had a metric crapton of them-like when Mr. Svenning meets with some network executives about his game show, they mention "trouble (he had) at the Governor's Ball", referring back to a whole opening scene that was replaced due to running too long in focus testing (and in turn, a whole subplot that got removed); some dialogue elsewhere in the movie had to be ADR'd in post and new scenes were filmed to remove further references- but some were still left in (as were references to other, unrelated scenes that got cut).
  • The 1995 film of Casper had a Cut Song called "Lucky Enough to Be a Ghost", which would have ended with the Ghostly Trio hoisting Dr. Harvey up to the ceiling just as Kat walks in to ask him about having the Halloween party at Whipstaff. This explains Kat's line in the finished film about her father having "hit the ceiling" when he found out about the party. Christina Ricci does deliver the line in a dry enough way to make it non-obvious that this it's supposed to be a pun, but it's still hard to imagine the mild-mannered Dr. Harvey hitting the ceiling in a figurative sense either.
  • Upon its initial release, the 1932 film Rasputin and the Empress featured a scene which implied that Rasputin had raped Princess Natasha, who was a No Celebrities Were Harmed version of Princess Irina Yusupov. In 1932, the real Princess Irina Yusupov was still alive and feeling litigious. Along with her husband Felix, she sued and won, which led to the This Is a Work of Fiction disclaimer. The offending scene was removed from the movie, creating a plot hole in which it's not explained why Princess Natasha changes from supporting Rasputin to being afraid of him.
  • The matador scene in The Cat in the Hat was the setup for a deleted verse which can be heard on the soundtrack CD and accessed on the "Deleted Scenes" feature on the DVD. It was removed and thus it's a Big-Lipped Alligator Moment.
  • A New Hope:
    • Han's parting words to Jabba in Mos Eisley, calling him a "wonderful human being," made more sense in the scene as originally filmed and then deleted. At that time, Jabba was not yet the giant sluglike alien canonized in Return of the Jedi and digitally edited over the original footage when the scene was restored in the Special Edition. Though it could easily be considered a sarcastic remark.
    • During the Death Star battle, one of the pilots says "Red Six, can you see Red Five?" after Porkins (Red Six) has been killed.
  • In Bill & Ted's Bogus Journey, the Evil Bill and Ted say "Good luck getting to the concert!" to the originals; while it comes off as petty mockery, in the original script they actually followed up on it by siccing real-world versions of Bill and Ted's Ironic Hells (the Easter Bunny, Bill's grandmother, and Colonel Oates) on the boys to try and stop them. This scene still occurs in the novelization and the comic book adaptation of the film.
  • Back to the Future:
    • The first film: Ever wonder why George had peanut brittle for dinner in 1985? Originally, after meeting with Biff, Marty tries to urge George to stand up for himself when a child selling peanut brittle shows up. Instead, he caves, buying all of it, with the child's father saying "See, I told you we'd only have to stop at one house."
    • Back to the Future Part III: Originally, Buford Tannen and his gang were supposed to encounter Marshall Strickland with his son before Buford's duel with Marty. Strickland lets them go until Buford shoots him in the back, killing him, saying "I Lied!" before riding off. It got dropped because it changed the tone of the duel. This act was so heinous that it wasn't right that Buford not die (and he can't, because Buford needs to live long enough to extend the Tannen family line). This explains why Strickland's deputy, now wearing a Marshall's badge, arrests Buford and his gang, with the line "You're under arrest for the murder of Marshall Strickland" redubbed to "You're under arrest for robbing the Pine City stage!"
  • Shanghai Noon: Originally, there was a whole sequence where Chon Wang's fellow Chinese guards are discovered by a conman named Bulldog Drummond, played by Curtis Armstrong, who tries to showcase them to audiences. When they realize what's happening, he gets beaten and they take his wagon, which is what they used to travel to the church. Drummond is subsequently mugged by Wallace and the gang, who reveals where the guards are going, which explains how they show up there in the end.
  • Stripes: In the theatrical cut, Sgt. Hulka tells the platoon that some soldiers left the base without permission, and threatens to punish the entire platoon before John and Russell reluctantly fess up to that. If you watch the extended cut of the film, you'll find that they tried to desert during Basic, and somehow end up parachuting into somewhere in South America, before running into a group of rebels, accidentally dumping a bunch of LSD into their stew, almost getting killed, and sneaking off before getting put back on the plane and sent back to Basic.
  • Titanic has one hour of Deleted Scenes, so it isn't surprising that the final cut has several of this.
    • When Jack makes Rose "fly" at the bow, he starts singing the popular 1910 song Come Josephine In My Flying Machine and she laughs. This is a throwback to a deleted scene that came after Jack brought Rose to a party in steerage. As he accompanied her back to First Class, the two were singing Come Josephine.
    • When Cal finds Rose at the lifeboats, he is disgusted to see her in a poor chequered blanket. In a deleted scene, she got that blanket from a generous couple, after they entered the main hall in steerage. You see the same steerage couple swimming in the freezing water after the ship goes down.
    • Lovejoy can be seen with an open gash on his head as the ship breaks apart. A deleted scene had him and Jack coming to blows in the dining saloon and having his face thrown through a glass pane.
    • As the ship is going down, Rose can be seen sharing a look with a blonde girl also holding onto the rails. This girl Helga appears in the deleted scenes as a love interest to Fabrizio and a Foil to Rose - she would choose her family over Fabrizio to their downfall. She can still be seen dancing with Fabrizio at the party in steerage, explaining why Rose would recognise her.
  • Bright:
    • Jakoby and Darryl's first ride together has the former say that Darryl doesn't know anything about love. This is a leftover from an early draft, where Darryl was separated from his wife. In the final film, he is still Happily Married - so the line makes no sense.
    • Tikka's childlike behavior makes more sense when she was written to be a child - but aged up because a scene required her to go into a bar.
  • The first death in Final Destination featured Tod getting startled by a shadow in the mirror, and the water he slipped on in the bathroom retreating back into the toilet to make his death look like a suicide. This is left over from when all the deaths were planned this way, but the filmmakers changed their minds to have the others as accidents.
  • In the climax of Carrie (1976) boulders can be seen crashing through the ceiling of the house. This ties in with a planned opening showing Carrie as a child making stones rain down on the roof that was cut. Additionally the scene would have had the house getting buried by falling boulders. But the machine malfunctioned and they had to just burn the house instead. This is also why Carrie's grave is under a pile of stones.
  • Hook has a scene where Peter's daughter Maggie sings a song for the pirates. This is a leftover from when the film was planned as a musical. The school play also has a song called "We Don't Wanna Grow Up".
  • The Lovely Bones originally adapted the subplot from the book where Abigail has an affair with the detective. There's a lot of chemistry between the two characters in a scene at the police station - which was clearly meant to start the subplot off. And later in the scene where Jack hugs the detective, he can be seen looking a little guilty.
  • Similar to Hook, the Technicolor remake of Imitation of Life was planned as a musical - hence the plot point of Lora becoming a Broadway star instead of a businesswoman, the cameo of Mahalia Jackson singing at Annie's funeral and Sarah Jane becoming a dancer and chorus girl instead of a waitress.
  • Kingdom of Heaven's final battle features Queen Sibylla cutting all her hair off before going incognito to tend to the wounded. This act makes much more sense with Ridley Scott's planned ending where the character would become a nun - who traditionally cut their hair off as a symbol of giving up their old life to serve God now. But Executive Meddling wanted Balian and Sibylla to end up together at the end. In the Director's Cut the haircut still makes some sense too as Sibylla chose to poison her son as a Mercy Kill when she discovered he had leprosy - so it could be seen as an act of mourning.
  • The World of Suzie Wong's eponymous heroine speaks in broken English - which comes from her original actress France Nuyen having limited English (and having to learn her lines phonetically). Midway through filming she was replaced with Nancy Kwan - who spoke perfect English.
  • (500) Days of Summer has a flashback to the teenage Summer cutting her hair. In the original script, Summer is described as having short hair (making it a Visual Pun that she has a pixie haircut). But Zooey Deschanel wears her hair long, so the flashback seems like a Non Sequitur (although it does fit in with Summer's impulsive personality).
  • In America:
    • Christy narrates over her parents sleeping together "and that's when the baby was conceived". It's implied that she's narrating in the present tense at the same age she is now. She's ten. In the original script she was written to be a thirteen-year-old - explaining why she would know about conception. Sarah Bolger (who was ten) simply gave the best audition and you can just assume that Christy knows more than she should.
    • The film also has a couple of holdovers from when it was going to be set in the 1982.
      • The first is the family going to see E.T. in cinemas - and the film having a recurring significance for them (Johnny nearly bankrupts everyone getting an ET doll from a carnival, another character dying pretends he's going to his home planet like ET). The filmmakers lucked out when ET was re-released in 2002 to celebrate its 20th anniversary.
      • Mateo's death from AIDS given that 1982 was during the crisis, especially the film's New York setting. Given that Jim Sheridan based the film on his own experiences in New York in the 80s, it's likely a fictionalisation of someone he knew with the disease.
      • A minor one is the Sullivans not knowing what trick-or-treating is when they move to New York. Halloween was never a particularly big deal in Ireland (ironically it was Irish immigrants who introduced it to America in the first place), and there wasn't much of an industry for costumes (especially in the poor economy of the 60s and 70s when the parents would have grown up) - explaining why they make their own. So in 2002 (when the movie takes place) the family not knowing about trick-or-treating is especially odd. Making their own costumes however is justified by their poverty at the start.
  • Laurel and Hardy: The short Twice Two has one of the wives mention a "surprise" for Ollie. We never learn what this surprise was in the film. According to the notes on the Laurel & Hardy Essential Collection DVD set, the script states the surprise as being a 16mm home movies projector. Back in 1933, such a device would have cost a lot of money!
  • House of Wax (2005) had an alternate opening featuring a girl called Jennifer being killed on the side of the road. It was cut from the film, but a waxwork of Jennifer is still given special attention in the third act - as the winner of the 'Miss Ambrose' Beauty Contest. The pageant is discussed a couple of times earlier in the film at least.
  • Scooby-Doo:
    • Right before she's kidnapped by the villains, Daphne is seen running out of a building and slamming the door shut. This is because of a cut scene that took place inside the girls' locker room - where Daphne encountered a possessed Velma and several other girls. They're who she was running from.
    • Shaggy knows to look for Daphne's soul in the pit after he's found Fred and Velma's. The reason is that he would originally stumble into a scene Daphne's soul being extracted from her body and a monster inhabiting it. This scene too was deleted.
    • Old Man Smithers/The Luna Ghost was originally meant to be the main villain of the movie. In the finished product, he only appears in the film's prologue, but the Luna Ghost was still featured prominently on the movie poster.
  • Harry Potter:
    • Justin Finchfletchley is Demoted to Extra in Chamber of Secrets, and Harry knowing who he is right before the snake incident in Duelling Club appears to be Remember the New Guy?. An extended version of the scene had Harry meeting Justin in the club and chatting about him being Muggle born.
    • In the attack on the Burrow in Half Blood Prince, Ginny inexplicably does nothing once Fenrir Greyback shows up. As shown in the trailer, he disarmed her from afar. Ginny can be seen picking up her wand as soon as Lupin and Tonks get there too.
    • Order of the Phoenix has one to the original plan to break into Umbridge's office after Harry's vision - where Luna, Ginny and Neville are brought in because they helped. In the film it's just Harry, Ron and Hermione breaking in.
    • In the same film, Percy Weasley is shown restraining Harry in Dumbledore's office. The movie cut down his subplot that he got a job at the Ministry and disowned his family.
  • Halloween H20: Twenty Years Later:
    • The opening credits show a newspaper picture of a pair of bloody scissors - referencing the ending of the fourth film. Originally the fourth, fifth and sixth films were going to be acknowledged in a scene where one of Laurie's students gives a report on 'the Haddonfield murders'. The finished film ended up being a Soft Reboot that ignored the previous three movies.
    • Michael Myers notably has no burn scars, despite having been in a fire at the end of the second film. While it seems like a simple Series Continuity Error, it was originally a hint to the planned reveal that it wasn't the real Michael, but a copycat killer.
  • A Knight's Tale: When Kate is teaching William to dance she asks what he's planning to do with his hair for the evening. Originally William was supposed to appear at the banquet with his hair slicked back and covered in silver after Kate restyles it for him. A single scene, which ended up being cut, was filmed with this hairstyle before the crew realised it looked ridiculous. The rest of the banquet was shot with William's usual blonde curls which leaves Kate's comment as an odd non-sequitir.

    Live-Action TV 
  • Angel:
    • Season 1 gives focus to Kate's father being killed by vampires, which drives a huge wedge in between her and Angel. This was meant to be the start of a dark character arc for her in Season 3, where she would become Holtz's disciple dedicated to destroying Angel for revenge. Elisabeth Rohm however was too exhausted filming both Angel and Law & Order, so she opted to leave in Season 2. Thus Kate and Angel part on amicable terms, and the storyline is given to a new character called Justine - who gets a similar Freudian Excuse of a twin sister killed by vampires.
    • In Season 5 Lindsey shows up pretending to be Doyle from the first season to act as a fake mentor to Spike. This is because Doyle was originally going to return, now as a villain, but his actor had passed away beforehand.
    • In "A Hole in the World" Angel is having a phone conversation with Giles, trying to get a hold of Willow to help solve the Fred/Illyria problem. Before the show was cancelled, Willow was planned to show up in Season 6 to help separate Fred and Illyria's souls.
  • Charmed's fifth season premiere has Phoebe and Cole mutually agreeing that their relationship is over - which is very inconsistent with Cole's attempts to win her back for the rest of his time on the show. This is because the episode was going to start an arc with Cole falling in love with Paige instead. When both actors protested the storyline, it was dropped.
  • When the first few hour-long episodes of Cheap Seats were cut down to a half-hour, a few references and jokes were left orphaned. Example: in the "Superdogs/Superjocks" episode, there was a warning in "What 2 Look 4" for an obscene number of dog-puns. The subsequent edits chopped out the majority of them. (there were still some groaners, but not enough to justify a warning.)
  • Doctor Who:
    • Dialogue in "The Macra Terror" refers to the Macra as being "insects", having apparently not been rewritten when they were changed to giant crabs (or in a couple of cases rewritten as "an insect like a crab"). Parodied in Doctor Who Magazine's "Blogs of Doom" feature, in which the Pilot says that Medok's claim he saw a giant insect that looked exactly like a crab is perhaps less likely than that he saw a giant crab. (Although he didn't see that either, obviously.)
    • In "Castrovalva", the newly-regenerated Fifth Doctor mentions sensing an malevolent presence at the center of the Tardis. This would've been followed up on later in the season, but the planned story got dropped, leaving the reference sticking out as an odd aside.
    • In "The Doctor Dances", when Captain Jack arrives at the climax, the Doctor shouts to him "Change of plan!", but they never actually made a plan. In the script book, Steven Moffat explains that the plan was in an earlier draft of the script and got cut because it was slowing the episode down.
    • In "Twice Upon a Time", during the Twelfth Doctor's speech for his future self, he tells them to "never ever eat pears". This is a reference to "Human Nature", where the Tenth Doctor leaves a list of instructions behind for Martha to follow to make sure his human self doesn't do something bad, including a very passionate speech about how much he hates pears and to never let him eat one. The only problem being that this speech was never audible in the final episode, and ended up in the fast-forwarded bit. This is a bit of an edge case, though, since "Human Nature" aired years before "Twice Upon a Time" was written, and so the reference was already "orphaned" even before it was written. The writers may have intended it as a Mythology Gag, since the full cut of Ten's "pears" speech has become quite popular online, and originally came from the much shorter list in the Doctor Who New Adventures version of Human Nature.
  • Game of Thrones:
    • Season 1 features a cameo for Jeyne Poole and a couple of lines alluding to her. She gets a big role in the book A Storm of Swords where Littlefinger passes her off as Arya and marries her to Ramsay Bolton. By the time the show came around to adapting this plot, the writers had decided to give the story to Sansa instead, and thus this Early-Bird Cameo amounts to nothing.
    • In Prince Oberyn's first appearances, he writes a poem for his daughter Elia and tells Cersei he has eight bastard daughters. This is true in the books, but when the show introduced the Sand Snakes next season, they only used the three eldest (Obara, Nymeria and Tyene). Tyene is also combined with Elia, who never appears in the series.
  • Parodied in Garth Marenghis Darkplace. The theme song of the Show Within a Show includes an inexplicable clip of the protagonist running away from an exploding ambulance while cradling a baby. We never see any sort of context for it, until one of the interview segments reveals that Garth somehow managed to blow the budget for an entire episode on that one shot, forcing the crew to cut the episode.
  • The Haunting of Hill House originally had the "Where Are They Now?" Epilogue revealed as just another illusion created by the Red Room - showing that they were all still in the house. This explains why the sequence is a lot more sentimental than the show is known for.
  • Once Upon a Time:
    • Season 1's "Skin Deep" has a flashback to Regina walking into Rumpelstiltskin's castle saying she has a problem with a certain mermaid. This is because Ariel was down in the plans to show up in Season 2, but had her debut pushed back to Season 3. In Ariel's actual episode, her flashback doesn't involve Rumple at all.
    • Another Season 1 episode "Fruit of the Poisonous Tree" mentions that the genie is from Agrabah, which was meant to be Foreshadowing to Aladdin's planned debut in Season 2. Like Ariel, he was pushed back and didn't show up until Season 6!
    • The Season 5 "Broken Heart" has a flashback where Snow White sends Lancelot to get help from his mother, who is the Lady of the Lake - and Lancelot's debut episode was indeed titled "Lady of the Lake". He's never seen again. There was a deleted scene showing him seeing the Dark Curse being cast from far away, but be powerless to help anyone. The next episode cut all scenes resolving the Camelot arc, and it went in a different direction in the second half of the season.
  • The producer's cut of the Parks and Recreation episode "Halloween Surprise" includes a scene where Chris recommends that Ann try "dating herself" instead of getting involved with any more men, but this was cut from the aired version. In the next episode, "Ben's Parents", Ann mentions that she can't date Chris because she is dating herself. Although she explains what she means, it comes slightly out of nowhere.
  • Person of Interest: In "Aletheia", when Finch tells Shaw to plan an escape route like Reese would, he says, "As you've said, you're a hammer." Shaw did refer to herself as a hammer, back in "Liberty"...or at least, in its trailer.
  • Sabrina the Teenage Witch's "When Teens Collide" is about molecular instability causing things to go haywire in the Spellman house - including the sofa sucking in anyone who sits on it, and a black hole opening in the kitchen sink. When Hilda references these things, she mentions keeping their guests "out of the chair" - referencing another case of molecular instability that was presumably cut for time.
  • The Sarah Jane Adventures: In "Whatever Happened to Sarah Jane?" Maria is wiped from time and only Alan remembers her. Chrissie pays Alan a visit after time has been altered and tells him they never had a daughter. Alan protests that Chrissie was at their house earlier and saw Maria. This refers to a cut scene earlier in the serial where Chrissie does indeed visit the house and sees Maria.
  • This can occasionally happen on Wheel of Fortune, of all shows. Typically, the producers will edit out a cycle of turns if it doesn't affect the score or the puzzle (for instance, if all three players consecutively call wrong letters, hit Lose a Turn, and/or hit Bankrupt when they have nothing that they can lose to it). In some instances, host Pat Sajak has made reference to such turns — most often in the form of telling a player that a letter was already called, when the first such instance was edited out; saying that a player hit Bankrupt X amount of times; or making some comment conducive to finally uncovering a letter after several wrong ones were called, even though the home viewer only saw one or two at best.
  • One episode of Zyuden Sentai Kyoryuger has a Callback to a deleted scene from The Movie. Apparently someone didn't get the message that that scene would be important later on.

    Mythology and Religion 
  • In The Bible, St. Paul refers approvingly to a work called the Book of Enoch, which he recommends to true believers as an edifying work of faith and religion which can only deepen the reader's understanding of the ways of God and His working in the world. In context, Enoch was a prophet of old Israel - there are several stray references to him in the Old Testament as one of the mighty prophets of old who was righteous in the sight of G-d and who is seen as in the next tier down from Abraham and Moses. But go to the Old Testament to look for the book which St. Paul all but says is indispensable to an understanding of faith... not a trace. Not there. Just these orphaned references to a lost prophet and a lost book of the Bible. Luckily the Ethiopian church kept some copies around (originally dismissed as fakes but confirmed as genuine when fragments were found in the Dead Sea Scrolls) so it's widely available now, although most churches don't consider it canon.
    • There is also the lost "Book of Jasher", which is mentioned in Joshua 10:13, which talks about a time when the sun stayed up longer than usual and ends with "Is it not written in the Book Of Jasher"? as a rhetorical question, implying said book would be well-known to the original audience (the ancient Israelites). Alas, nothing of the book has been found, other than what is almost certainly a forgery.

    Tabletop Games 
  • BattleTech fans were left scratching their heads over the Liberator, a mysterious 40-ton 'Mech that showed up in the assignment tables in early sourcebooks, most notably the first edition printing of the Mechwarrior RPG. Unlike all the other 'Mechs that appeared in the source books, no reference sheet for the machine ever existed, nor could anyone actually place where the thing came from. Some argued that it was meant to be an early version of the Sentinel, but the Sentinel did not appear in any form until nearly 3 years later. Someone on the design team caught on to this mystery 'Mech and finally gave it an identity after twenty-seven years: the Liberator ended up being a Flawed Prototype that suffered from such devastating Overheating problems that it violently exploded from an ammunition rack detonation within a minute of firing its weapons in earnest.
  • The Margaret Weis Marvel Heroic Roleplaying books mention certain characters as being included in supplements that either only existed briefly in PDF format (Professor X in Civil War: X-men Supplement), or never appeared at all (Black Bolt in Annihilation: War of Kings).
  • Mutants & Masterminds Second Edition Silver Age book has a reference to A villain's handbook that never materialized.
  • The Avalon sourcebook for 7th Sea has a Destiny Spread that grants the character a "1 Point Druidic Secrets Advantage." But Druidic Secrets didn't make it to the printed book.
  • The Second Edition Warhammer 40,000 Codex: Imperial Guard made reference to allying with units from Codex: Squats. The Squat race were an embarrassment that Games Workshop struggled to make work, and were unceremoniously removed from the setting with their planned codex canned just after the Imperial Guard codex came out in print. Something similar happened in fifth edition; Ultramarines (and no other Imperial armies) had a rule that they could ally with Tau to the same degree as with other Imperial armies. GW never did really explain what that was supposed to be about.
Advertisement:

    Theatre 

Creators:

  • William Shakespeare had to deal with it (or at least his literary executors did): In the First Folio there are various references to things which were changed from the original "final" texts. For example in Henry IV there's a reference to Oldcastle in the stage directions, which is the name Falstaff first had until some descendants of the real Oldcastle complained. There's also a punny line that only works with the name Oldcastle.
    • There is also Hamlet's "I am but mad north-northwest. When the wind is southerly, I know a hawk from a handsaw". None today has any clue what he is referencing, but scholars figure that it reference something common in the 1600's that has been lost to time.
    • In The Merry Wives of Windsor, the Host of the Garter Inn repeatedly references a subplot about three German guests at his Inn. These German characters are never seen in the play, but oddly enough, they eventually steal the Host's horses, thus providing poetic justice for the Host's earlier pranks on Caius and Evans. This detail is so odd that it is only reasonable to assume that some material was cut. Either these Germans befriended Caius and Evans, or, as many scholars theorize, they were simply Caius, Evans, and perhaps Bardolph in disguise.

Works:

  • In "Wonderful Music" from 110 in the Shade, Lizzie ecstatically sings, "Now I'm no longer alone" on a soaring phrase that seems to have been inserted to cover a modulation. In fact, it derives from one of the show's many Cut Songs, File's "Why Can't They Leave Me Alone?"
  • Usually, Anne of Green Gables has Matthew sing a song called "The Words," which is reprised by his sister Marilla near the end. However, an alternate song is provided with the book for amateur productions to use as needed if they want to buy more time for a wig swap for Anne in the next scene. Productions that use "When I Say My Say" instead of "The Words" often keep the latter's reprise intact without any context to what it's supposed to be alluding to.
  • Trekkie Monster from Avenue Q was originally a Trekkie but this was changed to avoid copyright problems. The name remained unchanged.
  • Charlie and the Chocolate Factory had a scene deleted after the show had been up and running for a while that resulted in this. Willy Wonka's introductory song "It Must Be Believed to Be Seen" has the lyrics "Beyond this door's a factory/Begat from just a bean". Originally, the phrase "just a bean" — referring to the humble cacao bean that serves as the first ingredient in chocolate — turned up in the Opening Narration of the animated prologue "Creation Overture", so the lyric was a Meaningful Echo further strengthened by the audience realizing that the offscreen narrator was actually Mr. Wonka. "Creation Overture" was cut when the show had its first major cast change, so the echo is now lost.
  • In Gypsy, while most of the music and lyrics of "Rose's Turn" are based on or allude to earlier numbers, the "Momma's talking loud" section is a reference to the Cut Song "Momma's Talkin' Soft".
  • In the second act of Lady in the Dark, Liza picks up a book on astrology Allison had left for her, and starts hearing voices mocking her: "Astrology! The stars! And you're clutching at it! Helplessly! You're clutching at anything!" The third Dream Sequence soon ensues, and Liza was originally to have defended her indecisions in a Western Zodiac-themed Cut Song.
  • In the finale of Little Shop of Horrors, Audrey and Seymour (now part of the plant) sing, "We'll have tomorrow!" This was the title of a Cut Song.
  • Madama Butterfly has a modulating theme heard at two different points in the Intermezzo, which derives from a usually-cut portion of the love duet where Butterfly sings it to the Italian lyrics: "Ma, vi dico in verità, a tutta prima le propose invano."
  • In On the Town, the verse to "Lonely Town" begins with Gabey singing, "Gabey's comin', Gabey's comin' to town." Both the words and the tune of this were an ironic Call-Back to a song cut from the original Broadway production, though later productions have frequently reinstated it.
  • The Ring of the Nibelung: Drafts of The Young Siegfried had Alberich bringing a horde of Nibelungs with him to claim the Ring after Fafner's death, and Siegfried, once he emerges from the cave with the Ring, using its power to order the Nibelungs to disperse (as Alberich does in Das Rheingold). Wagner ultimately decided not to include a Nibelung ensemble in Siegfried, but this helps explain Hagen's otherwise mysterious explanation in Götterdämmerung that the Nibelungs have become slaves to Siegfried.
  • Ruddigore: Originally in the second act, Old Adam was to have changed his name to Gideon Crawle when he turned evil along with his master. This change of name was undone, but one reference to Gideon Crawle inexplicably remained.
  • Due to time constraints, many stage productions of Sweeney Todd cut the second part of the contest scene between Todd and Pirelli, where they compete to pull a person's tooth quickly and cleanly. However, few if any productions alter Todd's line before the contest, that he "can shave a cheek and pull a tooth with ten times more dexterity" than Pirelli.
  • In Vanities; The Musical, the intro melody of "Fly Into the Future" is a vestige of the cut song "Nothing Like a Friend". Likewise, the coda of "Looking Good" from the Off-Broadway production and cast album has the line "Hey there, beautiful", the title of another cut song.
  • Wicked:
    • One Cut Song was called "I Hope You're Happy". "Defying Gravity" contains references to the song at the start and end with the "I hope you're happy!/I hope you're happy now!" lines.
    • Another deleted song, "Making Good", is referenced by Madame Morrible in the intro of "The Wizard and I", the song that replaced it.
    • The line "We deserve each other" in "Dancing Through Life" is a leftover reference to its precursor, "Which Way is the Party?".

    Theme Parks 
  • To this day, Disney's Animal Kingdom contains several references to Beastly Kingdom - an area in the park that was going to be themed around mythical animals, but was scrapped at the last minute. References to this area include a "Unicorn" section in the parking lot, a dragon silhouette appearing in the park's logo, a stone dragon head on the entry gates, a dragon-shaped fountain that can be seen from the bridge to Pandora – The World of Avatar, and lastly a dragon cave that can be viewed along the long boardwalk from Pandora to Africa.
  • In E.T. Adventure at Universal Studios, Bontanicus tells the guests to bring E.T. home with either a spaceship or their bikes. When the attraction first opened, there was a special vehicle for wheelchair-bound guests that resembled E.T.'s mothership, which is what Bontanicus is referring to when he says "spaceship". For unknown reasons, the special vehicles were taken out at some point, leaving this part of his holographic distress call a bit of a headscratcher.
  • The queue music for Splash Mountain includes an instrumental version of "Sooner or Later", the Cut Song that was replaced by "Burrow's Lament".

    Video Games 
  • The Elder Scrolls
    • Morrowind has an Imperial Legion quest which is only partly removed. It is possible to have the dialogue options for the quest appear when speaking with the quest giver, but as the rest of the quest has been cut, you can never actually complete it.
    • Oblivion:
      • There's a quest hook that can be added to your list about the Black Horse Courier needing more staff. The quest itself was never added to the game.
      • There are also references scattered in odd places (a journal entry here, a sign there) of a town called Sutch, near Kvatch. Sutch never made it into the final game, but not all references of it were scrubbed before launch.
  • Final Fantasy IX:
    • The optional Memoria boss Hades has a lot of eye imagery on his design - which resembles the motifs found in Terra and Memoria. This is left over from when Hades was planned to be the final boss, but he was replaced with Necron late in development.
    • Mt Gulug uses a remixed version of the theme of Gurgu Volcano from Final Fantasy I. This is because Gurgu was mistranslated as 'Gulug'.
  • In Portal 2, while fighting Wheatley, he will comment that he didn't expect you to survive up till then because all the others he tried to escape with died. Word of God says that this was a reference to a subplot that was ultimately dropped, but they kept the line because they thought it sounded fitting and might incite curiosity into what happened while Chell was asleep.
  • In Escape Velocity Nova, the Universe Chronology included in the bundled documentation mentioned something called TCTLIDS being discovered and used to create a Fantastic Drug called FATE. The game's FAQ reveals that TCTLIDS was supposed to stand for "The Creature That Lives In Deep Space" before being removed from the Nova universe during its development.
  • Resident Evil:
    • The original had an entire subplot dedicated to the architect behind the Spencer Mansion, George Trevor, which was completely scrapped from the game, though the developers left his (now nameless) tombstone to be found after defeating Yawn the Snake. His entire subplot was restored in the 2002 Nintendo GameCube remake.
    • Similarly, numerous additional areas were all planned that weren't able to be included due to limited disk space and never actually saw the light of day. The only remnant of these was during a pre-rendered cutscene where you can catch a glimpse of the door on the entryway stairs that would have led to the graveyard which is missing in the actual game. Again, like Trevor's subplot, these areas (and then some) were restored in the remake.
    • The description of the Colt Python informs you it is loaded with "magnum" rounds, implying there to be different kinds of ammunition like the Bazooka. While there are fully functional "Dum Dum" rounds in the game, they were Dummied Out and are only accessible by hacking them into the inventory, and are a slightly more powerful version of the already very powerful magnum rounds (presumably they were removed for being redundant). Oddly, the 2002 remake contains the same description on the weapon, and the same fully functional but dummied-out rounds.
    • There is a bed in the 2002 Remake that, when examined, informs you there are footprints that appear to pass right through it. Rumor is there was originally an escape route that came out from under the bed that was ultimately scrapped. A common Fan Wank is that the mansion is riddled with secret passages only accessable by Wesker and this is one of them.
  • Resident Evil 2 has Sherry remark that she can hear "the monster", a mutated version of her father, calling her name. Originally William was to be able to speak but this was Dummied Out, instead leaving fans to wonder if perhaps he was able to speak before they showed up or if Sherry was just imagining it. The remake expands on this by having his roars very vaguely sound like he's screaming for her, and adding gestures and body language like clutching his head that make it clear he's still somewhat conscious and trying to resist the influence of the G-Virus (you also hear roars that sound somewhat like "help me" as well).
  • The Legend of Zelda:
    • The instruction manual in the English version of the first game states that the Pols Voice enemy hated loud noises. Most players had assumed that the monster in question was weak to the Recorder, but when they used it, the monster wasn't affected. This is a case of a literal translation from the Japanese version of the game where Japanese players had to shout into the microphone on one of the Famicom's controllers in order to defeat Pols Voice, a feature that American NES controllers did not have. This was changed in the American and European versions so that a single arrow can kill a Pols Voice instantly and you can kill multiples at once if they're lined up.
    • In the original version of Link's Awakening, one part of the Chain of Deals has you returning a bikini top to a mermaid, and if you try to dive underwater in the area immediately around her before getting it, she'll call you a pervert. In the English translation, the bikini top was bowdlerised into a pearl necklace, and her message for diving underwater near her has her instead simply tell you that she's already checked the immediate area for it. The narration text still stutters and acts embarassed when you acquire the pearl necklace, however.
    • Although the Fire Rod was scrapped from The Minish Cap in favor of the Flame Lantern, the European version of the Ice Wizzrobe's figurine still advises you to "hit them with your Fire Rod!"
  • The Lion King contains several levels and enemies inspired by concept art that never made it into the film, including the scenes that were eventually truncated into "Hakuna Matata". You can see a bit about it here, with Louis Castle of Westwood Studios (who worked on the game).
  • Pokémon:
    • The Goldenrod Pokémon Center in Pokémon Crystal was originally a large building called the Pokémon Communication Center which allowed pseudo-online trading and battling via a mobile phone adaptor. Because mobile phones weren't nearly as widespread outside of Japan at the time, this entire feature was cut and the PCC became a regular Pokémon Center. However, a few characters still mention the Goldenrod Pokémon Center having been renovated recently, and all dialogue from the PCC was fully translated into English, just Dummied Out.
    • Pokémon Diamond and Pearl: The Hall of Origin is an unused location where you can find (and catch) Arceus, which was meant to be accessed via the Azure Flute, an event item that was never distributed because it was thought to be too confusing to use. However, the Wonder Card for the 20th Anniversary Arceus distribution, nine years later, explicitly mentions that "Arceus could first be encountered the Hall of Origin in Diamond and Pearl".
    • Pokémon Black and White has an NPC in Castelia City named Mr. Lock, the "magical clown who can open anything." He has no function in the final game, but he was supposed to be part of a scrapped download event that would've started in HeartGold and SoulSilver. The event would give players an item called the Lock Capsule, which could be transferred to BW via the Relocator, where Mr Lock would open it, giving the player TM95 Snarl. The event was never released, not even in Japan, so Snarl remained an elusive Dummied Out move, until Black 2 and White 2 gave the Snarl TM through normal means.
    • Several Pokédex entries in the first two generations reference cut elements that were removed during development. For example Ledyba is the "Five Star Pokémon" because it originally had a star pattern on its back, Umbreon's entries mention poison because it originally was a Poison-type rather than a Dark-type, and mentions of Vulpix being born with one tail, apart from being a reference to the mythology which inspired the Pokémon in question, were also there because Vulpix originally had a pre-evolution with three tails.
    • The finalized designs for Remoraid and Octillary don't look particularly like they have anything in common besides being water creatures, and although their English names are derived from "raid" and "artillery" and Octillery's Japanese name is often romanized as Okutank (and it learns the move Octazooka), they barely look like they have any connection to military stuff even if you squint. The connection was far clearer at an earlier point in the design process, when they more obviously resembled a gun and a tank, respectively. The Hoppip line, meanwhile, was heavily based not only on dandelions as per their final designs, but also cats, explaining why Hoppip itself has some vaguely catlike traits (which its evolutions now lack) and why its Japanese name includes the word "neko".
  • Fire Emblem: Radiant Dawn features a localization-only example. In a base conversation explaining the weapon forging system, the merchants mention selling unneeded weapons for scrap metal, and offer to not charge you for the materials of the first forged weapon you make. In the Japanese version, forging weapons required "forging points" in addition to gold, these were obtained by selling weapons. The English version decided to remove the forging points mechanic entirely, but didn't alter this conversation. Similarly, the description of the Silver Card item (buy items at half price) says "Does not earn any Training Points" in the English version, which is a reference to an Obvious Rule Patch on the item in the Japanese version (otherwise you could get infinite forging points by buying a weapon, selling it, buying it again for the same price, repeat) that is meaningless with the system removed.
  • One of the scrolls in Splatoon prominently features an unused shirt.
  • Sonic the Hedgehog:
    • The intro to Sonic Adventure shows an early version of Windy Valley that looks very different from the final version. That version was removed a few months before release and replaced with the finalized version.
    • In Shadow the Hedgehog, Shadow proclaiming "This is who I am" in every single ending would have made more sense if they had kept the original theme for the game. Alas, Executive Meddling by the band's producer prevented Sega from using "Who I Am" by Magna-Fi, leading to "I am... All of Me" by Crush 40 becoming the game's theme at the last minute.
    • The animated cutscenes for Sonic the Hedgehog CD show a scene where Sonic jumps from tile to tile in an area not seen in the game. The scene is from a cut level (dubbed "R2" by fans, due to the naming scheme of the folders used by the PC version of the game).
    • Sonic Boom contains several echidna and hedgehog statues that no one comments on. These are remnants of an older plot for the game that delved into Sonic's backstory and the history of hedgehogs. Sega vetoed it because they prefer for Sonic to have a Mysterious Past.
  • Spyro the Dragon:
    • Spyro: Year of the Dragon contains an unused island out in the distance of the Midnight Mountain home level. The only thing on it is three butterflies (life-ups). The island was originally supposed to have a bonus round on it accessible via a tall whirlwind after beating the Final Boss, but the artist went on vacation, the round was moved to another location, and no one ever bothered to delete the leftover island. The island was made accessible again in the remake, though the Super Bonus Round still retains its original location.
    • One NPC in Spyro 2: Ripto's Rage! accidentally calls Cloud Temples by its original name "Mystic City".
  • Noki Bay from Super Mario Sunshine contains a book that doesn't do anything and is mostly hidden from view. The book was originally meant to serve as a way to get a Shine Sprite but was replaced with getting red coins instead. The book itself was never removed. Despite urban legends, the book is also left unused in the Japanese version.
  • The "Special Video" in Super Smash Bros. Melee shows unused elements of the game, such as the Temple stage including an extra platform.
  • The 2003 game of The Hobbit originally featured a boss fight with a cave troll near the end of "Over Hill and Under Hill", which was scrapped although references to it are found throughout the level.
  • Through no fault of the developers, this is now the case with Uber Jason and the spaceship Grendel being accessible in Virtual Cabin 2.0 of Friday the 13th: The Game. Because of a lawsuit surrounding the legal status of the franchise, all future expansions and content for the game have been cancelled, among them a stage based on Jason X and its particular incarnation of Jason.
  • In Rainbow Six, the Red Wolf mission originally involved the Free Europe terrorist group taking hostages in a Belgian bank. In the Nintendo 64 port, Free Europe was replaced in this mission with the Phoenix Group, but the building still sports a "Free Europe" banner on its front colonnade. The N64 manual also has a screenshot of the mission briefing for Blue Sky, which was cut from this version.
  • Vexx originally consisted of 6 worlds with three levels each, until time and budget forced only 9 of the 18 levels to make it in and the world idea to be scrapped. However, one of the cutscenes has Reia tell Vexx that he has to "activate the outer three structures of Astara," with those outer structures most likely being the three outer worlds of Astara that would be unreachable until a way was found somehow.
  • Forza Motorsport 4 Dummied Out Forza 3's Rally di Positano course, which was a 7.5-mile tarmac rally based on Amalfi Coast, but reassigned the Rally di Positano name to the normal Amalfi circuit for some reason.
  • In Wonderboy III The Dragons Trap, the Sega Master System sequel to Wonder Boy in Monster Land, the Mouseman dungeon reuses the cave theme from the arcade version of its predecessor, which was absent from the SMS port.
  • In Fe, singing near one of the stranded fish in the drained swamp brings up a song icon that doesn't match any of those that the titular protagonist learns, likely indicating a Dummied Out animal language.
  • In Driver, the music tracks "Los Angeles Day" and "Los Angeles Escape at Day" are never used for their intended purpose, as LA lacks a daytime setting in-game due to graphical limitations, though they still play during certain Undercover missions in the other cities.
  • There were two different versions of Splinter Cell: Double Agent, one on sixth-generation consoles like the Nintendo GameCube and one on PC and seventh-generation consoles like the PlayStation 3, each with distinctly different plots and some characters that are In Name Only to one another. Only the seventh-generation version features Enrica Villablanca's Anti-Villain qualities that make her sympathetic and her budding friendship/romance with Sam, but both games have Sam's fierce objection to killing her and his Heroic BSoD when she dies. This makes it seem completely out of character and out of nowhere when Sam suddenly cares immensely about her well-being in the sixth-generation version.
  • Tomba! had a number of levels removed from the game late in development, and notably did a poor job cleaning up any leftovers:
    • Early in the game you find a telescope and peer out over the water, seeing a pair of Koma Pigs rowing toward an ominous-looking pig-shaped island that just screams out loud Very Definitely Final Dungeon. This entire area was removed from the game, and instead you face the final boss in The Underground Maze. "Pig Island" is never so much as mentioned ever again, unless you have the Japanese version of Tomba where it's visible on the world map (it was removed from the US and European versions).
    • Masakari Jungle and The Village of Civilization were hit hard by this. There's an entire village visible on the map in the jungle that can never be visitednote , and an entire underground area in the Lumberjack Factory that is blocked by an invisible wall and contains only a single berry.
  • Super/Return of Double Dragon, which was rushed out as an Obvious Beta, has several.
    • The glass elevator in Mission 1 is cracked when you board it. The enemies jumping onto the lift to attack you were supposed to break the glass.
    • Mission 2 takes you through a baggage claim area with several idle conveyor belts. These were planned to move and drop the player into pit traps similar to the conveyors in earlier DD games, but the coding was lost.
    • At the end of the truck ride in Mission 4, Duke and his henchmen show up, but then disperse without further word. A cutscene would have taken place here, followed by a boss fight with Jeff, who is reduced to a Mini-Boss in the final game, after McGwire fled the scene.
    • In Mission 5, you enter a building at the end of an alleyway, and immediately exit into another alleyway. A indoor factory area was designed for this section, but left unimplemented.
  • In the last mission of Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas, main villain Tenpenny angrily calls CJ a "motherfucking piece of shit gangbanging cocksucker." While funny on its own, it was originally a Call-Back to a Dummied Out line in the first cutscene of the game where after hearing Carl swear in anger, Tenpenny sarcastically replies with "Don't swear Carl, you motherfucking piece of shit gangbanging cocksucker." Since the prologue line was dummied out, the final mission line becomes this.
  • Journey to Silius was originally developed as a Licensed Game of The Terminator, but converted to an original IP after the rights were yanked. A few references to the license remain in the game, including the intro cutscene and music, the helicopter boss resembling an Aerial Hunter-Killer, and the SkeleBot 9000 Final Boss.
  • One of Marathon's manual images is a Hunter accompanied by a rejected creature known as the Hound. A wall texture resembling this creature can be seen in the Pfhor Ship levels.
  • In Halo 2, the chapter where the Flood first appear is titled "Juggernaut", which was the name of a Dummied Out Flood monster.
  • Child of Light's map includes the Isle of Nereida, which was supposedly planned to be the location of the Very Definitely Final Dungeon, but was left out of gameplay due to the game being Christmas Rushed. In the released game, following the battle with Nox in the Palace of the Sun beneath the Cynbel Sea and Aurora's death/resurrection cutscene, the party goes straight to fighting the Final Boss Umbra in some sort of airborne castle ruin.
  • Yo-Kai Watch: The important-looking orb on Jibanyan's collar is a remant of an old ability of his. He originally could transform into humans using a "Transform Orb". In another case of this, his haramaki/belt was originally made of cursed seals that could be peeled off like sticky notes. Jibayan using seals was scrapped, however his Japanese inspirit still mentions that he uses paralyzing seals.
  • In Duke Nukem 64:
    • The gun shop in the second level, which was originally a porno bookstore, still has a peep show in its back hall, albeit with more modestly dressed women.
    • The Alien Queen is Adapted Out, but her Protector Drones appear as "Alien Beasts" in a few levels.
  • Warcraft III: In the game, several missions gave you hints on what to do, such as loading Goblin Sappers into Zeppelins or throw a Storm Bolt at a mechanical ship. Being major Game Breakers, this was removed in the expansion, and trying it with the expansion installed gets an error message even as the hint is being displayed.
  • Dawn of War: In the first game, stealth units couldn't attack while hiding, and could be detected by squad leader units along with minefields (as the tooltips said). In the second expansion (Dark Crusade), stealth units can attack invisibly, but there are only a few units capable of detecting them (and few commanders among them), but the tooltips still say heroes and commanders can detect stealth units and minefields.

    Visual Novels 
  • The eighth Episode of Umineko: When They Cry makes a reference to Land of the Golden Witch, an arc which was supposed to be the original Episode 3 of the series. When the author saw that everyone found both Legend and Turn to be too difficult, he scrapped Land and released Banquet of the Golden Witch instead. In-universe, Land of the Golden Witch is the third message bottle from Rokkenjima that was never found.
  • Partway through the final trial of Phoenix Wright: Ace Attorney – Dual Destinies, the Big Bad tries to escape from the courtroom, Phoenix yells at them, and they stop the attempt and say "I'm not going anywhere". This is a reference to an earlier draft of the script, where they did escape the courtroom, which would've led to another investigation sequence.

    Web Games 
  • You get much advice on how to fight Kofo-Jaga scorpions in the Mata Nui Online Game, even though their minigame has been scrapped from the final release.

    Web Original 

    Web Video 
  • Aaron has Adam comment on Chris's house being messy. This line was written for the original house they were going to film in, but they had to change locations at the last minute. The kitchen itself is much cleaner and tidier.
  • In season 4 of Red vs. Blue, when Church asks Sheila where Simmons - who had defected to the Blues earlier - had gone to, she tells him to ask their captured Warthog jeep in an agitated tone. This is a nod to an earlier plot point where Sheila would have been upset at Church for valuing collecting the team's vehicles instead of worrying about the other Blue Team members who were on their own plot. The vehicle scene in question was in the episode proper for the web release, but was relegated to a deleted scene in the home video version as the plot point didn't go anywhere beyond that.

    Western Animation 
  • In the Danny Phantom episode that introduces Vlad Masters, Danny somehow knows that he uses "Plasmius" as a supervillain name, though Vlad never calls himself that in the version that aired. This and many other things about Vlad (both names, plus the overall look of his ghost form) are leftovers from the original plan of him being a vampire.
  • Futurama: In "Parasites Lost", Hermes is shown scooping some of Amy's popcorn with a cesta (a scoop-like device used in the sport of Jai alai), referencing a deleted scene where he announces that the crew will be using alternative utensils due to the kitchen's plates going missing.
  • In the Invader Zim episode "Tak the Hideous New Girl", we get a commercial break after The Reveal that Tak is an Irken trying to conquer the planet. Afterwards, we get a few seconds of Zim defeating a ham demon. It's a kind of non-sequitur you might expect from the show normally, but originally they wanted this episode to be an hour-long special, and this was a reference to a subplot that got cut.
  • Jem:
    • In one episode, Stormer has a line that love has been hard for her. This was originally supposed to lead into a song, however the song was scrapped.
    • In "Culture Clash", Pizzazz records "Surprise Surprise" in a studio and sings "Wait'll see, what's in store for you". This line isn't in the actual song. It was originally in the song and exists on the mastertape, but the song was shortened in development and the line was cut.
  • Scooby-Doo: Velma and Shaggy were originally intended to be brother and sister. It's why Velma has Shaggy's cough medicine with her in "What a Night for a Knight" and why Shaggy is the one carrying Velma's spare glasses in "A Decoy for a Dognapper".
  • South Park: The episode "An Elephant Makes Love to a Pig" has a scene where Stan is lying down in a puddle of water. This is a reference to a deleted scene where his sister Shelley set him on fire and threw a bucket of water to douse the flames, only for her to repeat the process over and over again.
  • Steven Universe: Despite the Crystal Gems generally distancing themselves from humanity and getting around by Warp Pad, Pearl knows how to drive a car without explanation. This is a remnant from an abandoned idea where the Crystal Gems would hang out among humans incognito, and Pearl drove them around.
  • The Transformers:
    • "It's a miracle we survived that blast," says Optimus Prime in the episode The Key to Vector Sigma, Part 1, in reference to an explosion that was cut from the finished episode.
    • When Rodimus Prime appears to be dying in "Five Faces of Darkness, Part 2," he says to his comrades that his "time in the light is short," which Arcee remarks is what Optimus Prime said on his own deathbed... except he didn't say that. This is meant to be a Call-Back to a line from an early version of Prime's death scene in The Transformers: The Movie—it was cut from the film, but not the show.
    • The episode "Starscream's Ghost" contains a number of odd lines and sequences that seem to indicate the episode was originally written to star Blitzwing, but which was hastily rewritten to feature the newer character Octane instead. Most notably, when the eponymous specter first appears, a frightened Octane becomes stuck in a malformed state halfway between his truck and robot modes, which is consistent with Blitzwing's official bio but has no basis in Octane's. Starscream also disparagingly refers to Octane as an "older model", which works as a bit of meta humor in regards to Blitzwing (his action figure was over a year old at the time) but seems a bit inexplicable for Octane.
      This isn't mentioning the fact that the episode is meant to follow on from the end of "Five Faces of Darkness, Part 5", which concluded with Galvatron banishing Blitzwing from his ranks (Octane even quotes this dialogue word-for-word when discussing his own banishment); the final episode references the events of the episode "Thief in the Night" instead, which had yet to air and didn't actually end with Octane leaving the Decepticons in bad faith. It all makes for some pretty significant Continuity Snarl in a series that tended to be very light on continuity anyway.

Top

How well does it match the trope?

Example of:

/

Media sources:

/

Report