Follow TV Tropes

Following

Vile Villain, Saccharine Show

Go To

https://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/changelingqueen_9992.png
Nothing illustrates friendship better than hopelessness, Nightmare Faces, and green slime.

"[The game has] a sense of timeless nostalgia... there's innocence to it as well, Cosmic Horror not withstanding."
Advertisement:

Okay, so you have villains who are legitimately intimidating and frightening. Maybe they try to destroy all positive emotions, maybe they turn people into twisted shambling abominations, or maybe they're plotting genocide. Point is, they're creepy villains. The irony is that they're stuck in a Sugar Bowl.

As one could tell, this trope is about villains in normally lighthearted fiction that are so disturbing, so terrifying, that they clash harshly with the tone of the work. Because of this type of villain's ability to alter the mood of the story they're in, this trope overlaps with Knight of Cerebus (if the character causes a tonal shift in a series), or even Complete Monster. In fact, vile villains in general are exaggerated Knights of Cerebus, since the contrast with the rest of the setting leads to an even stronger contrast with the mood, while a Knight of Cerebus isn't necessarily in a saccharine show at all and may even be right at home in a darker realm, if he is the crowning example of its darkness. If a series has a lot of villains like this, then it's taking a ride on the Cerebus Rollercoaster. Done well, it provides a powerful contrast. Many family-friendly and Slice of Life shows have episodes that choose to take a turn down Nightmare Road by presenting disturbing imagery, creepy characters and dark situations as a figment of some character's imagination or nightmares. This doesn't count, however, as the characters aren't real in that universe either; they merely represent the fears and the anxieties of some individuals.

Advertisement:

A violation of Genre Consistency. Compare and contrast the Crapsaccharine World, where it's not just the villain, but the entire world that is rotten to the core albeit sparkly and sweet on the surface. Also compare What Do You Mean, It's for Kids? and What Do You Mean, It's Not for Kids?. A major cause of Sugar Apocalypse and Surprise Creepy.


Examples subpages:

Advertisement:

Other examples:

    open/close all folders 

    Anime & Manga 
  • Castle in the Sky has a really notable case with Colonel Muska, especially for a Hayao Miyazaki film. For most of the film, the antagonists were Dola and her fairly comical crew, and even later on, General Muro was a bit of a blowhard. Colonel Muska has no comical traits, being a Faux Affably Evil government agent treated very seriously by the protagonists. What makes him truly qualify as the evilest and most despicable Hayao Miyazaki antagonist was massacring an entire army that helped him conquer Laputa, laughing maniacally as he watches them die.
  • Digimon Adventure starts off fairly lighthearted, then we meet Devimon, a cunning, devil-like monster with the power to brainwash friendly and peaceful Digimon into rampaging, savaging berserkers.
    • Myotismon is even worse. A sinister, Vampiric Digimon with a sadistic streak a mile wide. Myotismon treats his underlings awfully, having taken Gatomon in when she was young and abused her until she was a killing machine. When his henchmen fail him, he eagerly destroys them. When two harmless minions couldn't bring themselves to harm children, Myotismon declared them useless and killed them immediately. When he invaded Tokyo, he proceeded to destroy much of it and held a number of children captive to identify the final child connected with Gatomon. Not only that, but he figured that if it took too much time, he'd simply kill them all. Myotismon also proceeded to attack multiple young women and drain their blood. Any minions he hadn't already killed were cannibalized to fuel his Mega transformation. Myotismon's spirit survived to return as the final villain of the next season as MaloMyotismon. Using Oikawa's sadness and despair to make him a pawn, he proceeded to consume him from within and upon manifesting anew, Myotismon repaid his perfectly loyal ally Arukenimon by sadistically torturing her to death and brutally killing Mummymon when he tried to avenge her.
    • Machinedramon is a cold-hearted, brutal, gigantic Killer Robot who speaks, though rarely, with a growling, hateful, metallic voice and mostly acts like a lifeless machine, unless he's on a murder rampage, which is when his true sociopathic nature is shown, ordering a massive bombing over his own territory and telling the hero's 8-year-old sister he's going to kill her as painfully as he can. It makes him one of the scariest villains in the show, and if that wasn't bad enough, the Wonderswan games reveal he survives his fight with Wargreymon and becomes Millenniummon.
    • Puppetmon has shades of this despite being Laughably Evil. He's a dark version of Pinocchio who thinks he can make friends by killing and enslaving everyone around him, and uses a revolver to "play" a cruel version of hide-and-seek with T.K. and kills his minions, Mushroomon and Blossomon, with it because he thought they lied. Some countries edited the scenes with Puppetmon killing Mushroomon and Blossomon and holding the gun during the TV run of the series. It's a living puppet pointing a gun at an eight-year-old child!
    • And then there's Piedmon, a psychopathic, sadistic, childish Monster Clown who enjoys toying with his opponents and sadistically inflicts pain and fear upon them before finishing them off, which culminates in him transforming the kids and their Digimon into keychains one by one in a series of sequences that seem to come straight out of a horror movie. It's no wonder his voice in the English dub was intended as an impression of Tim Curry in It (1990).
  • Dragon Ball:
    • Most villains were dealt with comically, and only a few were shown to pose a serious threat to Goku and his friends. Then came Tao Pai Pai, a Psycho for Hire who cares only about profit and ruthlessly and remorselessly wipes out anyone who gets in his way with his bare hands. After he murders Upa's father and defeats Goku in battle, he laughs at Upa and tells him that he's lucky that he's still alive, meaning that he has absolutely no problem killing children. When he returns to Karin's Tower to look for the one Dragon Ball he neglected to find, he grabs Upa and throws him against the tower (fortunately, he was saved by Goku). One time he forced a tailor to overwork on making an outfit for him in about three days... which he rewarded by killing him. After his defeat, he was rebuilt into an Ax-Crazy cyborg who wanted nothing more than the deaths of both Goku and Tenshinhan.
    • King Piccolo and his children. King Piccolo's arrival marked the series's complete shift to a much more serious tone, which carried over into the Sequel Series Dragon Ball Z.
  • Fruits Basket is an adorable series about a cute high school girl who befriends a lot of pretty boys and the hi-jinks that ensue. Then we are introduced to Akito, who we learn has been committing various forms of physical and psychological abuse on various family members, and has no problem with doing the same to any "outsiders" who look like they're butting in. Later, Akito actually becomes sympathetic when her mother, Ren, is revealed to be even worse.
  • Although it's about World War II, Hetalia: Axis Powers manages to be pretty goofy while focusing on the general incompetence of the nations. While there is fighting, it's portrayed as comical punches and cartoonish damage. In the movie Paint it, White!, we are introduced to invading aliens called the Pictonians. The Pictonians quickly conquer nearly all of Earth, transform most of humanity into their species, and abduct them as slaves. Everything the nations do to fight them fails, and they very nearly lose at the end, when all of them but Italy are turned into Pictonians. While screaming.
  • Little Witch Academia (2017): Croix Meridies is entirely responsible for the second cour being Darker and Edgier than the first by a long stretch and episode 21 doesn't help matters. She wants Chariot to suffer, all for no reason other than Croix not having the Shiny Rod and seeks to destroy "her last dream" by messing with Akko's quest for the words. She even attempts to make Akko distrust Ursula and later has her machines attack Akko while she's trying to prevent Chariot from helping her, and her reveal provides a Cerebus Retcon to Akko's previously goofy inability to keep up.
  • Mobile Fighter G Gundam is known for its campiness and can also be kinda cheesy at times. The main threat is a vile Eldritch Abomination known as the Dark Gundam (AKA Devil Gundam in Japan) that can take control of people and animals via metallic cell replication that covers the victim's body over time. Not to mention it can mutate its own body into grotesque forms and grabs people with creepy tentacles that sprout out of it. Its master plan is to rid the world of humanity all to save the planet.
  • Mon Colle Knights is cheerful and wacky and the enemies usually are the Terrible Trio. When they're not, there's Reda, with his bloodstained wings and a fondness for driving people to suicide and subjecting things to splooshy transformations. The English Gag Dub toned him down and edited some scenes.
  • Phantom Thief Pokémon 7 starts out as a cute story about a Phantom Thief boy and his Lucario. That is until we learn about an especially aggressive Team Galactic. We find out his twin sister who was kidnapped years ago has been brainwashed and is one of the strongest Galactic grunts. As she doesn't remember him she has no issues beating him and his Pokemon to a pulp. She gets better though.
  • Pokémon: Diamond and Pearl Adventure! is about a Wild Child named Hareta, who has more than a few resemblances to Goku, going on a journey. It's all fun and games except for Team Galactic, who is presented just as intimidating as they are in the games and then some. It doesn't help that his best friend Mitsumi is an ex-Galactic member (and a ferociously strong one at that) who is blackmailed into rejoining and gives his Pokemon a No-Holds-Barred Beatdown.
  • Pokémon Origins plays this trope straight with Team Rocket as a whole, in a stark contrast to their general depiction in the anime. Just like the games, they actually kill Pokémon, and they're shown conducting horrible experiments on them, too. Giovanni's reasoning for doing all this? Because a Pokemon-based society is a business, and Pokemon are tools for business.
  • The Pokémon anime has a goofy and incompetent Terrible Trio composed of two delinquents and a talking Meowth as the primary antagonists most of the time, but it still has:
    • The coldhearted Diabolical Mastermind Giovanni, the non-so-incompetent Rockets Butch and Cassidy, and the psychic Gym Leader with a split personality Sabrina, in the Kanto Saga.
    • The intimidating Mewtwo in Pokémon: The First Movie, who, while eventually redeemed, has a body count, mind-controlled people, and planned to commit total human and trained Pokemon genocide leaving only his clones remaining.
    • The merciless Pokémon Hunter J, the Omnicidal Maniac Cyrus and his evil organization Team Galactic, and the abusive Jerkass trainer Paul in the Sinnoh Saga.
    • The Iron Masked Marauder, Grings Kodai, and Alva in the 4th movie, 13th movie, and 19th movie respectively.
    • In Black and White, the usually goofy, incompetent Terrible Trio isn't so goofy and incompetent anymore, and the Episode N arc has Ghetsis, Colress, and Team Plasma. Whenever they show up, expect the mood to drop dramatically and the battles to get more intense.
    • Team Flare in the XYZ arc of the anime are this as well; largely eschewing the campier aspects of their game counterparts in favor of a darker rendition more in line with that of Big Bad Lysandre, who is portrayed accurately. They are even the first villain team in the anime to devastate a major city on screen.
    • The Sun and Moon series is very much Denser and Wackier than previous shows...until the likes of Nihilego or Necrozma show up, upon which things get nightmarish, and fast.
    • The race of Unown, which are a borderline Eldritch Abomination. In the third movie they absorb a person alive and befriend a lonely girl which lets her do quite scary things, like turning the entire city into crystal (and, it was hinted, spread the crystallization over the entire planet), as well as kidnapping and brainwashing the hero's mother into thinking she's her Missing Mom.
    • Pokémon: Jirachi: Wish Maker, otherwise the fluffiest pokemon movie made, has an Eldritch Abomination that absorbs any lifeforms nearby to sustain itself and looks like Groudon.
  • The Big Bads of the Pretty Cure franchise are usually like this. One of them is an entity that existed before everything and wants to plunge everything into nothingness, another is a life-hating Eldritch Abomination that turns every planet he visits into sand dunes, yet another is a monster born out of humanity's collective negative emotions, still another is a jilted ex-lover from the future who wants to stop time to prevent suffering, etc etc... This is a series that is (supposedly) for little girls in elementary school.
    • Smile Pretty Cure!: The Joker/Rascal, is The Heavy of the story and The Dragon to Emperor Nogo/Pierrot. Unlike many villains of the franchise, including the others on the same series, Rascal doesn't have any sympathetic backstory or reason for doing what he does, he is simply a totally evil, sadistic, and psychotic being that takes pleasure in inflicting despair in the world. In keeping with the intent behind the series, which is to be simpler than others of the franchise, Rascal is a simple villain, who does things simply because he is just that evil.
  • Sword Art Online's second arc features the characters in Alfheim Online, which is full of cute elves who are trying to rescue the princess from an evil villain, until the princess discovers that he has been experimenting on 300 people in real life, he sexually assaults her, tortures Kirito when he comes to save her, and attempts to kill him in the real world with a knife.
  • Despite Tenchi Muyo! GXP being a lighthearted adventure comedy, Tarant Shunk still tries to behave as a real and scary Ruthless Modern Pirate, though it doesn't help him much. Kagato from the original OVA and Tenchi Universe was no slouch himself.
  • Tomica Hyper Rescue Drive Head Kidou Kyuukyuu Keisatsu is a very lighthearted anime aimed at preschoolers, and that just makes The Evil AI seem all the more horrifying. Aside from the fact that its ultimate goal is to Kill All Humans, the way that it turns the humans it assimilates into metal looks particularly gruesome.
  • The Fantastic Adventures of Unico is a lighthearted film about a baby unicorn who wishes to make friends and thrives on The Power of Love. The second half quickly becomes darker once Baron De Ghost is introduced, who gives Unico's friend Katy drugged wine in order to do God knows what to her, and the climax has him turn into a giant demon that attempts to kill the heroes.
    • The sequel, Unico in the Island of Magic, gives us Lord Kuruku, an abused marionette brought to life through The Power of Hate whose presence makes the film much darker and creepier than one would expect, especially since his plan involves turning people into living puppets that are used for building the walls of a castle.

    Comic Books 

    Fan Works 
  • Both versions of Battle Fantasia Project, by virtue of being crossovers between series which abound with these. The above-mentioned villains from Pretty Cure? They're in the story, and they're not the most evil guys around here.
  • Vasile, a particularly murderous kind of poltergeist, serves as the Arc Villain for the third story of the Contractually Obligated Chaos series. He takes both his villainy and his political status very seriously, and is targeted by the heroes because he's killed children. Unfortunately for him, this is a Beetlejuice fanfic, which means he has to put up with an awful lot of nonsense - both from his surroundings in general and that character in particular.
  • The Big Bad from the crossover story, The Bridge. True, one half of said crossover is far from a sugar bowl, but isn't so mature that it's not safe for kids. So what is the villain for a crossover between Kaiju and Equines? A demonic, Reality Warping, Eldritch Abomination who's an Omnicidal Maniac with millions of kills under his belt. Considering it's Bagan, this should be expected.
  • Citadel of the Heart:
    • Darigus; a Physical God Muck Monster whose body is composed of an ink/slime/sludge substance which smells like a rotting corpses, is at least partially acidic, and Darigus barely even making a sound unless he needs to speak, which his regular idle sounds being just an unusual pulsation of his own body as he "feeds" off of the air and poisons whatever is in range with his otherworldly body composition. Darigus is effectively unable to truly be killed when introduced; only be warded off to which even Ultimorian Deity Grandis needed to intervene because otherwise Darigus would've cheated and tried to kill someone flat out; a risk that's always present with Darigus' status as a Hero Killer in his conceptual appearances, due to that being a traditional role associated with Darigus, alongside his Satanic Archetype nature in addition to being the son of an Eldritch Abomination who in the lore of his own universe of origin is Satan himself. To make matters worse, in the description of the picture linked above, he's being discussed as having been actively stalking two girls who have been having nightmarish encounters with Darigus in their own homes, or have had nightmares directly fueled by Darigus' presence if they still slept through him showing up.
    • Ruki's biological father in the form of an O.C. Stand-in with a massive case of Adaptational Villainy to the point he's a Walking Spoiler. In terms of human villains in the overall continuity, when compared to Roy, Megalodon, or Enric, Roy is a Large Ham, Megalodon is a Funny Foreigner, and Enric is a Comedic Sociopath, all of which are attempts to provide some levity into their characters; all of which Besiege lacks because he's described by those same three characters as a "joyless Sociopath" who engages in Ephebophile Date Rape and normally is a Professional Killer who just wants to fulfill his Blood Lust in killing people, and his lust for his own daughter while leading her into a deliberately designed Clueless Mystery which is meant to manipulate her into being his successor and future bedmate. He's effectively Digimon Re: Tamers' answer to the Mysterious Man from Digimon Adventure tri..
    • Greater-Scope Villain Dr. Devoniak also qualifies due to how uncannily Stoic he is when compared to all of the other antagonists, who in some ways fall victim to the Series Fic's nature of being a partial World of Ham; Dr. Devoniak isn't hammy in any way whatsoever, not even when engaging his Arch-Enemy Grandis. Considering he's Nigh-Invulnerable to mostly everything, he exploits The Slow Walk very often as he doesn't fear or gets fazed by anything that crosses his path, and as a near 10 foot tall humanoid he tends to intimidate people simply by standing next to them. He's also more of The Spook than other villains in the fics, considering so little is known about him despite being a Time Abyss who has existed since the original incarnation of the Greater Multiverse, and even other Knight of Cerebus characters in the series outright fear Dr. Devoniak in particular. It's a testament to how dark of a villain he is when you also consider he's the only character whom Grandis outright killed on purpose. Did we mention his design resembles a reanimated corpse?
    • Blackheart, the Omegamon Zwart D that represents Raiga's long-term desire to maintain her Fusion indefinitely. While it is true that Blackheart is depicted as a mindless, genocidal killing machine at her most reasonable, in any other Digimon fic within this Series Fic, Blackheart would normally be nothing out of the ordinary in regards to villains. However, as Blackheart is the resident Knight of Cerebus in Digimon Re: Adventure, which is mostly Porn with Plot and Slice of Life at most, Blackheart's existence forms the catalyst to the entire Myth Arc that forms the actual plot part of the aforementioned genre this fic is.
  • Five Nights at Freddy's fanartist Kosperry often reimagines the the story in a Don Bluth style, and in true Don Bluth fashion, this trope is in full effect. While the main four (Freddy, Bonnie, Chica and Foxy) are depicted as good guys and Mangle is portrayed as an Ineffectual Sympathetic Villain, the same can't be said about Purple Man and Springtrap, who are portrayed as being every bit as vicious and evil as they are in canon.
  • A Future of Friendship, a History of Hate is yet another My Little Pony: Friendship Is Magic example. It maintains the Original Flavour of the show very well, but Ruinate is a rather horrifying Eldritch Abomination who intends to turn Equestria into a Crapsack World before destroying it, and even manages to temporarily destroy Twilight Sparkle's soul. Also, his heralds, who know perfectly well his final goal and serve him anyway, are willing to do terrible things in his name.
  • Getting Back on Your Hooves is a My Little Pony: Friendship Is Magic fanfic that strongly goes for Original Flavour with the original series. The Big Bad, Checker Monarch is based off real life Sociopaths. This was intentional on the part of the writer to emulate how the TV series has disproportionately dark major villains.
  • Pom Pom's Eleven features the main Homestar Runner characters trying to get back at Homeschool Winner for stealing from them. Since it's Homestar Runner we're speaking of, one would expect them to be as comedic as ever and Homeschool Winner to be an Ineffectual Sympathetic Villain. Though the Homestar Runner characters are as comedic as ever, Homeschool Winner turns out to be a legitimate and rather cunning threat to the cast. For starters, he was responsible for their website closing down as he had secretly been embezzling from their website for years, and he had also stolen precious possessions from the cast when they were forced to sell them to pay off their debts. If that wasn't enough, he also turns out to have tricked Marzipan into breaking up with Homestar. And when his crimes have been revealed, he proceeds to stab Homestar Runner in the chest with a knife.
  • Moonstuck is a story about a pony on the moon meeting lots of friends and going on silly adventures that you shouldn't take seriously. Its villains are a usurping, tyrannical regent who fully intended to kill Woona and her friends, Woona's Enemy Without that delivers multiple Curb Stomp Battles and vicious Breaking Speeches, and Discord, who is just as nasty as his canon self with none of the comedy, often falling into full-blown Eldritch Abomination territory.
  • Magna Clades, a Steven Universe fanfic, gives us Zoisite, an Evil Chancellor who is willing to exterminate humans because he thinks of them as dirty animals. At one point, he even rapes Connie!
  • One Wish For Nothing is one of the more light-hearted stories in Songs of Lost Children, even being the only story in the 99 Worlds Verse to have a comedy tag. However, its main antagonist, Stronghold Halfdragon, is one of the most dangerous and vengeful villains in the entire series.
  • Siegmund Schnee, Weiss' grandfather from Weiss Reacts- a Card-Carrying Villain who outright attempts to kill Weiss and her team- and that's not even going into what he did in the backstory. Keep in mind that the Reactsverse tends to be Slice of Life oriented, and that up until then, the villains had Poke the Poodle evil and acted like jerks at best.
  • Persona: The Sougawa Files, while having its dark moments, is generally lighthearted in tone, with the Shadow Selves even having comedic quirks that keep them from getting too dark. However, all that goes out the window with two villains:
    • Nobuyuki Itou is the biggest crime lord in Sougawa and seeks to seize control of it, controlling the Shadows and ruling with an iron fist. He's played seriously each time he's onscreen, and proves how dangerous he is by trashing Rina's house and beating her sister to near-death.
    • Yuudai Honda, the true antagonist of the story, initially seems like a Laughably Evil bumbling idiot meant to play comedically off Nobuyuki, but it turns out he has greater ambitions than his boss ever did. While his motives are understandable and to some extent agreeable, he's hands down responsible for some of the darkest moments in the story, including the reveal of everything he did to Satomi, his brutal Curb-Stomp Battle against Rina, and his gruesome final battle. At the very least, he's a Graceful Loser.
  • Dragon Ball Z Abridged: While still somewhat played for laughs, Cell is treated as a more serious threat than the other villains and is given a creepy and unnerving rapist vibe. The episodes leading up to his introduction play his arrival with a lot of menace, with a character outright noting a change in tone.

    Films — Live-Action 
  • A Very Brady Sequel: Trevor Thomas was the associate of archaeologist Roy Martin, Carol’s first husband. Trevor resorted to cutting the fuel line to their boat and leaving Roy and the six others on board to die (though from the sound of things, they may have been stranded on a desert island instead). He later poses as Roy to get into the good graces of the Bradys and resorts to kidnapping Carol and threatening people with a gun to get what he wants, which is their antique horse valued at about $20 million.
  • The 1995 Australian kid's film Napoleon is mostly about a cute puppy's adventures in the Australian outback...except when it's about an insane feral cat trying to murder him.
  • Children's Party at the Palace has some seriously devious villains compared to the lighthearted romp it is for the most part, though most of them had pretty lukewarm plans (as Burglar Bill planned to steal the Queen's handbag, not the Queen herself). Even the Grand High Witch had some malicious intents, even mentioning about "boiling children".
  • Chitty Chitty Bang Bang is for the most part lighthearted - but the Child Catcher more than makes up for that lightheartedness. Seriously, his name kind of says it all.
  • Clock Stoppers: Henry Gates. This is a movie about kids freezing time and not a sci-fi thriller about manipulating the device to be used by an Evil Corporation, yes? No? Gates is dead serious in pretty much all of his scenes and clearly cares nothing for what the potential consequences of manipulating time could be. He's willing to use anyone who is of value towards his goals and is more than capable of having those who interfere stomped out if he deems necessary.
  • Daigoro vs Goliath certainly has its dramatic moments (such as the death of Daigoro's mother or trying to deal with the kaiju's growth and difficulty keeping him fed), but is overall lighthearted and comical...until the title villain Goliath enters the picture. Not only is his introductory scene ominous, with a storm appearing out of nowhere and the music taking on a darker air, but Goliath promptly beats Daigoro nearly to death before rampaging across Japan, all of which is treated much more seriously than the first half of the film.
  • Dennis the Menace: Switchblade Sam is a dirty, dark and crooked thief who through the course of the movie steals money and jewelry from people's houses, steals a little girl's antique doll, steals a kid's apple right out of his hand and threatens kids with his knife in general. Even though he was made the Butt-Monkey at the end of the movie, he was so dark for an otherwise very whimsical comedy that Siskel & Ebert each cited him as the main reason why they weren't recommending the movie. One would think with the performance that Christopher Lloyd gave in this movie that he thought he was auditioning for Cape Fear!
  • Galaxy Quest is a lighthearted Actor/Role Confusion comedy with endearingly innocent aliens and the cast of a Star Trek Expy... and the villain Sarris is a sadistic, genocidal maniac, not above murdering underlings who fail him, who takes a specific glee in forcing Jason to Break the Cutie.
  • Ghost Busters 1984: A classic lighthearted 80s comedy with a fun bunch of characters—at least, until Gozer and company start to show up. Then again, Gozer's manifestation ends up being, while giant, a cartoon junk food mascot.
  • Good Burger: Kurt Boswell, though somewhat over-the-top and a little bit of a Large Ham, is incredibly vicious and uncompromising in how he deals with his business, insubordinate employees and crushing any unwanted competition. In a movie based on an All That comedy sketch of all things, he goes as far as to try to poison Good Burger's customers in order to ruin the business. In a sketch it might have been a small thing, but in the movie, the consumption of that poison was likely to either cause severe illness or death. While there were villainous characters on All That who would threaten others and succeed in taking lives, it was always Played for Laughs. In this case, it's not.
  • The Fratellis in The Goonies are quite dark and cruel for a PG-rated film that has become a family-friendly cult classic. Not only do they point guns at, and quite credibly threaten to shoot each other with, over minor disputes, at one point they actually start the process of putting Chunk's fingers in a blender to make him give them information.
  • The villains in The Love Bug movies are usually laughably evil, but the 1997 TV movie introduces Horace the Hate Bug, Herbie's downright sadistic Evil Twin who was created with The Power of Hate.
  • Marvel Cinematic Universe:
    • Guardians of the Galaxy is generally pretty lighthearted and fun... with the exception of Ronan the Accuser who is introduced with him literally bathing in the blood of executed Xandarians like some kind of perverse baptism. He is a genocidal maniac and brutal zealot who thinks that wiping out an entire planet as retribution for two deaths is a totally acceptable course of action.
    • Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 2 amps up the comedy and features Ego the Living Planet, who killed thousands and thousands of his own children, murdered the woman he loved by giving her cancer because she was distracting him from his master plan: to assimilate and absorb all planets in the universe and turn them into an extension of himself.
    • Thor: Ragnarok is a lighthearted, 80s-inspired space opera for the most part, but Hela is a blood-crazed, ultra-violent galactic conqueror and Omnicidal Maniac who quite literally lives for nothing except razing everything to the ground and slaughtering everyone in sight, and it is clear that once she gets her revenge on Asgard, she will set her sights on the entire universe.
    • Considering how Spider-Man: Far From Home is the first movie set after Avengers: Endgame, it is still quite lighthearted and is generally a coming-of-age tale much like its predecessor. Unlike Vulture (who was a decent, honest man given a raw deal who just wanted to give his family a comfortable lifestyle and ensure that his employees could do the same for their own, who, at worst, lost his way), however, Quentin Beck aka Mysterio is a disgusting human being who is all too willing to commit mass murder and wide-scale destruction just to satisfy a ridiculously petty personal grudge and shit all over Tony Stark's legacy, all while being completely and utterly unrepentant.
  • The Mask is a comedy mostly focused on the zaniness of its "live-action cartoon" protagonist. Yet the antagonist, Dorian Tyrell, is a ruthless mobster who would be welcome in the very violent bordering on comedy horror comic, particularly in how scary he gets once he puts on the mask.
  • Moonraker is probably the campiest, most lighthearted film in the James Bond franchise. And yet, its Big Bad, Hugo Drax is possibly the most diabolical villain in the franchise. As a cold, snobbish, understated executive, Drax wishes to exterminate the human race, except for those he considers "superior beings", being A Nazi by Any Other Name where his character in the novel was an actual Nazi. To this end, Drax captures men and women whom he sees as physically perfect, planning to keep these people in his giant space station while he covers the Earth in a rare toxin that will kill every human being on the planet.
  • The Muppets:
    • The Muppet Movie is a silly, good natured road movie that tells approximately how The Muppets got started, when Kermit meets Fozzie, Gonzo, Miss Piggy, etc, as they join him on a cross country road trip to Hollywood. Then we meet Doc Hopper, a greedy restaurateur who wants Kermit to be the new spokesperson for his struggling chain of frog leg restaraunts. After Kermit refuses his offers, Hopper relentlessly pursues him for nearly the whole trip, resorting to increasingly vicious means such as holding Piggy for ransom, hiring a Mad Scientist to have him brainwashed, and finally hiring assassins to hunt him down and kill him. Even as Kermit gives a heartfelt speech to try and reason with him, Hopper is unmoved and still orders him killed. He might have succeeded had not Animal, having grown to the size of a giant, thanks to Dr. Bunsen Honeydew, appeared and let out such a Mighty Roar at Hopper and his men that they flee for their lives.
    • Muppets Most Wanted has Constantine, a criminal mastermind who bears a strong resemblance to Kermit (save for a mole on his left cheek). He escapes from a maximum security prison in Siberia, Russia, sets Kermit up to look like Constantine and have him arrested, and replaces him for the Muppet World Tour, in order to fool the Muppets and use them for his Evil Plan to steal the Crown Jewels of England and frame them for the crime. Eventually, to get closer to the Crown Jewels, he proposes to Miss Piggy and has the wedding held at the Tower of London, and later attempts to kill her with a time bomb disguised as a wedding ring.
  • In Oz the Great and Powerful, there is Evanora, The Wicked Witch of the East, who manipulates her formerly good sister Theodora, turning her into the Wicked Witch of the West.
  • Paddington introduced a Cruella to Animals villain who wanted to kill Paddington and stuff him, leading to a newspaper article complaining in general about why film versions of gentle kids' stories always seem to introduce a murderous villain to make the story "bigger".
  • Romancing the Stone: Ira and Ralph, even if they kidnapped Joan's sister and just appear to be the Big Bad Ensemble of the movie, are pretty much Those Two Bad Guys in threat level (Ira, even if a Dirty Coward and a drug dealer, is also a man of his word and lets Joan and her sister go the moment he has the stone, as he promised). Zolo, however, is a homicidal psychopath that uses the country's Secret Police as his private army and Ira and Ralph both repudiate and are afraid of him.
  • While SHAZAM! (2019) is easily the most lighthearted entry in the DCEU, things take a turn when the demonically-enhanced Dr. Sivana is on-screen. The Punch Catch he performs on Billy in their first encounter signals that shit is about to gets real following Billy's goofy antics. His very presence turns the movie from a wacky coming-of-age comedy into a supernatural horror movie.
  • Something Wild is a quirky comedy - til Ray Liotta makes his entrance.
  • Superhero Movie is an irreverent, Seltzer and Friedberg-esque comedy (actually from Scary Movie alumni Craig Mazin and David Zucker) which spends most of its time pastiching and lampooning 2000's-era superhero movies, up to its idiotic protagonist being an expy of Tobey Maguire's Spider-Man. Despite this, the villain — a Life Drinker named Hourglass — is taken very seriously, having very few comedic beats and played as an actual threat with legitimately imposing powers. He's competent and original enough that he probably could make a decent villain in a more dramatic, non-parodic superhero film.
  • For the most part Thoroughly Modern Millie is a happy-go-lucky musical in the vein of Singin' in the Rain. "For the most part" means "except for the parts with Mrs. Meers, a woman who kidnaps people and sells them into a human trafficking ring."
  • The Ultra Series have several movies of its own, and while some of the movies are Lighter and Softer, they tend to feature rather horrifying villains.
    • The Ultraman Zearth movies are basically a parody of the archetypal Ultramen show, featuring the inexperienced Ultraman rookie, Zearth bumbling around through his day job as a janitor, getting into trouble, being an accident-prone Butt-Monkey and a Hypochondriac that hilariously freaks out at the slightest sign of dirt, and being a complete klutz in both movies. Yet the villains of each movies are the Benzene aliens, a husband-wife team of planet destroyers and universal conquerors. Benzene of the first movie intends to suck up all the gold resources in the world to be fed to his monster, Cotton-pope, which will make the monster powerful enough to unleash an Earth-Shattering Kaboom that reduce the entire planet into debris; while in the sequel Lady Benzene is capable of hypnotizing and abducting entire populations of cities, and intends to turn everyone on earth as her own army of brainwashed, mindless drones.
    • Ultraman Gaia: The Battle In Hyperspace is a spin-off movie of the Ultraman Gaia series, and a Slice of Life movie that is set in our world instead of the Ultramen universe. Yet it features the dangerous monster, Kingmons, who almost wipes out the entirety of Tokyo in an exceedingly long city destruction scene, with the movie's climax featuring children nearly getting killed by the monster's rampage.
    • Ultraman Cosmos 2: The Blue Planet: A spin-off movie from Ultraman Cosmos, probably the lightest and most optimistic installment in the series at its time, and yet the Big Bad of the film is Sandros, an Omnicidal Maniac and Planet Killer who had wiped out entire populations of every planet it has ravaged, is a Plaguemaster of a monster who instantly turns entire oceans on Earth into wastelands, and is the most powerful and dangerous monster Cosmos and the earth has faced at that point of the series.
  • Judge Doom from Who Framed Roger Rabbit. The film initially seems like a classical family movie until we meet him. We discover that not only is he responsible for all the bad things that happen in the movie, but he's also the same psychopathic murderous toon who killed Eddie Valiant's brother long ago and he was planning the genocide of his own species to profit him.
  • The 1939 film version of The Wizard of Oz portrays the Land of Oz as a Sugar Bowl, but the Wicked Witch of the West is even worse than her literary counterpart, openly planning to kill Dorothy and with much more powerful magic.

    Literature 
  • Birdsong, a children's picture book by Gale Haley, is as saccharine as they come, being the story of a Heartwarming Orphan who can communicate with birds, illustrated in beautiful watercolor paintings. Its villain, Jorinella, has no humorous or light-hearted aspects whatsoever. She's a sadistic poacher who deceives and abuses the heroine to boost her bird-trapping operation.
  • Charlie and the Great Glass Elevator, by Roald Dahl, has the sudden intrusion of a Horde of Alien Locusts into an outer space sequence that until then is mostly whimsical.
  • Goosebumps is one of the biggest examples of "kid-friendly horror" out there, and as such most of the antagonists tend to have sad backstories, goofy quirks or are generally watered down. A few, however, manage to be even more disturbing reading into the series as an adult.
    • Mr. Toggle from Piano Lessons can Be Murder initially appears to be an eccentric, goofy janitor who helps out Jerry when he can't find his way around his new school. Come the third act, we discover he's been luring people to the piano school with the robotic Dr. Shreek as a teacher, before murdering them and turning their hands into piano-playing machines. He "never" stops acting polite and friendly, though, and claims he just feels music sounds so much better without human mistakes. Finally, it's all but implied that he gets Dragged Off to Hell by the angry ghosts of his victims.
    • The titular Mutant of Attack Of The Mutant is a comic supervillain brought to life, and most of his book is a parody of 90s superheroes. Near the end, though, we actually meet him in person. It turns out he's been posing as Skipper's friend and manipulating the boy into finding his lair. He reveals that he transformed Skipper into a comic book character like himself, and is always seeking out new "heroes" that he can fight to the death in his comic stories. The Mutant also melts his henchman alive and makes it clear he intends to do the same to Skipper.
  • Gorgo the Ogre is, overall, a child-friendly story, but the King of the Black Ogres is really a despicable, childishly cruel sociopath willing to kill his subjects on the slightest whim, even when they're doing the right thing, and tries to disintegrate the protagonist with a series of magical stones. Not to mention his horrible appearance.
  • J. R. R. Tolkien's works about Middle Earth from the POV of hobbits and everything related to the Dark Lord can be seen like this. Let's remember that hobbits are a peaceful people, mostly farmers, cattle breeders, small merchants and like that who love simple life and food above all else. Sauron's forces are totally the opposite, specially the Nazgûl in The Lord of the Rings. Also the dragon Smaug from The Hobbit.
  • Tove Jansson's The Moomins take place in Moominvalley which is, at least at a very quick glance, somewhat of a saccharine world in the early novels and some of the adaptations. Then we are introduced to the Groke. The revelation in later stories that she's a Tortured Abomination rather than consciously evil may make her less, or even more, horrifying depending on your taste.
  • Redwall; it seems like a happy fluffy world full of cuddly talking animals. Then you meet the villains, who made this the first book series to get its own Complete Monster page.
  • In some fairytales by Sofia Prokofieva, especially nasty villains can appear in especially unexpected surroundings.
    • The Island of Captains. There is the Fairytale Ocean, full of lovely islands such as the Lunch Break Island, on which everything is ringing, the Hide-and-Seek Island, which dives underwater whenever a ship approaches it, or the titular Island of Captains, populated by the captains and crews of toy ships. And there is a ruthless pirate leader who prepares to take over the Island of Captains and slaughter the crew of every toy ship that comes there.
    • Freckle is a lighthearted tale of a sun ray that comes alive and makes friends with a girl, and the main antagonist is the heroine's unpleasant neighbor who can do little actual damage. However, the ray decides to explain how he got torn off the sun. That story involves a Fat Bastard of a duke who tries to rape a peasant girl and only agrees to let her go if her fiancé brings him a chest of gold before the sun sets; thanks to that duke, the ray clings to a bell-tower and painfully breaks off from the sun.

    Live-Action TV 
  • The Aquabats! Super Show! is a surreal children's show that runs on pure silly camp. Then in the season finale Space Monster M shows up murders superheroes before the team's eyes, devastates a city, and vows to destroy the earth.
  • Batman (1966) had Mr. Freeze. Unlike all the other villains, who merely wanted to rob banks and play pranks and the like, Freeze only wanted to kill Batman out of revenge - in his first appearance, anyway.
  • Big Bad Beetleborgs had Shadowborg, who appeared in the much more lighthearted first season of the show. Whereas most of the Magnavores were Laughably Evil Harmless Villains, Shadowborg is powerful, frighteningly competent, and has little to no humor except for sarcasm and deadpan one-liners mocking the heroes. He not only curbstomps the Borgs in his first appearance without even trying and served as an Implacable Man for most of his arc, his attack on the town is portrayed as dead serious as opposed to the more petty crimes his fellows committed, with him actively trying to hurt innocent people, resulting in Heather being hospitalized with a broken leg. Until Nukus showed up, Shadowborg was the most serious villain the show got.
  • Brooklyn Nine-Nine:
    • Jake's cellmate in Florida, Caleb the Cannibal, who moved across the country multiple times and killed and ate children. He refers to their blood as "sauce". In a twist, however, he isn't actually the villain of the episodes where he appears; he's rather friendly and helpful to Jake, who is a little disturbed by how likeable he finds Caleb.
    • Dr Tate in Season 6's "The Therapist." He slept with his patient, murdered her husband and framed him for it, and reveals in a single offhand remark that he murdered a previous couple after sleeping with the wife and "nobody misses them."
  • Yogoshimacritein - The true Big Bad in Engine Sentai Go-onger. Not only is he more evil than his son, but he's also a very Bad Boss, killing off his two minions once they double-cross him to help the Go-Ongers. He also has access to a device that deletes people from existence.
  • Guest from the Future is a sweet story about friendship, kindness, loyalty, a bright utopian future, time travels and two murderous space pirates who don't hesitate to torture a child and plan to take over the world. Actually lampshaded in the torture scene by one of the pirates, who provides quite a bit of Comic Relief in the earlier episodes:
    We are not so funny after all...
  • Kamen Rider Fourze is a Lighter and Softer High School version of Kamen Rider. The monsters, known as Zodiarts, are actually fellow students—many of them having lots of psychological issues—alongside the teachers who actively are giving them the means to become evil. It has the most amount of monsters out of all the Kamen Rider Series with a total of at least eight that are trying to kill teenagers.
  • Kickin' It's Sensei Ty started out this way; in The Pilot he ordered a student to break Jack's leg. Let me restate that - he ordered a teenage martial artist to break another, younger one's leg in tournament play. He's gotten broader and sillier since.
  • Malcolm in the Middle has Grandma Ida. While she is Played for Laughs, there's no denying that she's probably the most evil character on the show.
  • Odd Squad: Most of the villains seen on the show aren't terribly evil. While they most definitely Would Hurt a Child and frequently antagonize agents, a majority of their attacks are harmless and their motives are more or less to cause oddness For the Evulz. However, there have been villains who are far more threatening and actively seek to harm Odd Squad and its agents.
    • By far the biggest example is Odd Todd. A former diligent agent of Precinct 13579 who was also the former partner of Olive, he is an Evil Genius whose skill in the realm of mathematics exceeds that of his coworkers. Back when he was an agent named Todd, he was so skilled at solving cases that he got bored and did a Face–Heel Turn, going to the side of oddness. Eventually he was fired for intentionally letting Tiny Dancer cause oddness, which was the final nail in the coffin for him to become a villain and attack Precinct 13579. He is the catalyst for Olive's trauma and constantly bullied her when the two worked at the precinct, he was known as The Dreaded among the agents of the precinct before his debut, and he has no problem going after and physically harming other agents as well as citizens of the town. Even after his Heel–Face Turn, he still keeps some of the traits he had as a villain, and Odd Squad: World Turned Odd shows exactly how terrifying the world would have been had he succeeded in defeating Odd Squad. He is easily the most iconic villain in the entire franchise, and it shows.
    • The Season 2 finale has Otis and his duck family. While they don't have any powers, Brother Quack, the leader of the ducks and ostensibly Otis' adoptive father, and the rest of the duck family managed to build a machine that would bring the Earth closer to the sun in an attempt to permanently stop winter from coming. Otis, realizing that this would kill everyone on the planet including the ducks, betrayed his family and worked together with Odd Squad in order to stop them, pulling a Heel–Face Turn. As a result of his betrayal, Otis suffers from an Absurd Phobia of ducks that lasts throughout the season, as he is afraid that his family will want vengeance on him for what he did. Luckily, they aren't vengeful and all and come to realize that Otis was only protecting them, and Brother Quack reconciles with his adopted son, pulling a Heel–Face Turn of his own.
    • There's also Ohlm from Season 2. A seemingly-harmless agent who's loyal to Odd Squad and is by far the biggest ditz around. However, it's merely a facade. His true personality is that of The Smart Guy who faked his stupidity in order to take over Odd Squad because he wasn't immediately promoted to the position of the Big O upon graduating the Odd Squad Academy and was instead made an Investigation agent. He made a Face–Heel Turn and became an Evil Genius instead, vowing to use his smarts to destroy the organization and stealing practically anything of benefit he could get his hands on in order to give it to various villains so they could commit acts of oddness and break into Precinct 13579's Headquarters. Despite numerous setbacks, he gains the upper hand when Oprah and Otis gets themselves fired and exiled from Odd Squad, as he is promoted to the Management position of the precinct in place of the former. In his new position, he enacts his ultimate plan to build a black hole out of every single gadget in the precinct's possession — 10,000 of them in total — and suck every single agent into it, effectively killing them. It's very telling that he's the only Big Bad of the franchise that doesn't get redeemed in any manner, as when he's defeated by Olympia, Otis, Oprah and Oona and has his life saved by them, he refuses to give up, doesn't even thank them for saving his life, and ends up being placed in the hands of his parents, who ground him and send him to his room.
    • Season 3 has The Shadow, yet another Enfant Terrible Big Bad who could easily stand toe-to-toe with Odd Todd for just how nasty and clever she is. Her first major appearance has her hacking into the Odd Squad Mobile Unit van and attempting to drown it in the Lake of Goo, while also attempting to take the Mobile Unit themselves down with it. When that fails, she decides to change course and uses Odd Squad's modus operandi against them, forming the Villain Network comprised of every single villain in existence in order to take down the organization using the power of teamwork. Opal, confused as to who "The Shadow" is, eventually finds out her true identity and her true name: Olizabeth, her younger sister. However, having her identity exposed doesn't deter the villainess in the slightest, as she continues to push on with her plan to have the villains in the Villain Network release oddness through the tubes at Tube Central Station to reach all of the Odd Squad precincts in the world by funnelling their powers into a single cube connected to the tubes. Even when Opal tries to convince her to stop what she's doing, admitting that she was too overprotective and telling her sister that she has lots of potential, she refuses to listen...that is, until Opal plays an entry from her Captain's Log saying how she is "the smartest person Odd Squad has ever been up against", at which point it finally sinks in. While she does pull a Heel–Face Turn and reforms, she's easily considered one of the most threatening villains the show has ever had and gives Odd Squad quite the difficult time.
  • Once Upon a Time in Wonderland is notably Lighter and Softer than the series it spun off from. The Big Bad, however, is Jafar, bastard son of the Sultan of Agrabah, Evil Sorceror, and all-around monster. Every episode has him doing something despicable: torture, murder, attempted murder, manipulation, and turning his lover into his serpent staff. He also has a particularly dark backstory that features his equally horrible father attempting to drown him when he was a child among other things.
  • Polish Soap Opera Plebania (eng: presbytery) was an optimistic and kind, sometimes to the point of naivety, show about daily lives of people in small village and efforts of a local parson and his new vicar to solve their small problems. Yet not only it had a recurring villain, it was one of the vilest characters in Polish TV, a sadistic, petty, ruthless gangster with a bone to pick with God, who loved to crush peoples hopes and dreams while rubbing in their faces he is rich enough to get away with it. Years after the show went off air he achieved Memetic Badass status due to how over-the-top cruel he could be.
  • Power Rangers:
    • Mighty Morphin' Power Rangers tried this with Lord Zedd, contrasting the ineffectual Wicked Witch Rita Repulsa with a seriously villainous and terrifying boss. Moral Guardians complained that he was too evil, and he was repeatedly toned down and softened through various devices until his villain family had become a comedy sketch act. Later villains are even darker than Zedd.
    • Queen Bansheera was a cruel ruler who obsessed only on restoring her kingdom and punished anyone who failed her, even her own son. When he was seemingly destroyed, she laughed it off, something even the demons who hated him were unsettled by.
    • In a season with a robot armadillo being kicked like a soccer ball or the leader of the rangers who was raised in the jungle, Master Org was the first villain in the series to get away with onscreen murder of humans that was never undone.
    • Power Rangers Megaforce is notoriously known to be one of the more panned seasons, yet it has another disturbing villain in the form of Vrak. Vrak is a sadistic sociopathic Chessmaster who also happens to be the youngest son of a Galactic Conqueror. He is known to cheerfully manipulate and use his own allies like pawns, and frequently tricks them to their deaths, even his own admiral. His menacing cyborg form only shows that he has become delusional and egotistical enough to be totally uncaring towards the people who have been nothing but loyal to him, as shown when he practically told Metal Alice, who did nothing but rebuild him and serve him faithfully, that she meant nothing to him and left her to die without any remorse, an act which especially disgusted the Rangers.
  • Even though Seinfeld is not exactly a cheerful show (it's actually quite cynical), Joey "Crazy Joe" Devola still adds a surprising dash of darkness to it.
  • An in-universe example appears on Star Trek: Voyager with the Show Within a Show The Adventures of Flotter, a series of fantasy holonovels for children. One of the title adventures involves a character called the Ogre of Fire, who shows-up, vaporizes the main character in front of the child's eyes, and then torches the setting to the ground.
  • Thunderbirds has the Hood, who regularly causes disasters that could potentially kill hundreds or thousands of people, just to force International Rescue into action so that he can try to copy their technology.
  • Victorious is a typical Kid Com, albeit with slightly more risqué humour than usual. However, one episode involved the protagonists going to the country of Yerba, which was ruled by a dictatorial Chancellor. Said Chancellor ends up arresting the protagonists after he is accidentally blinded. Also, the country is in the middle of a Civil War. The audience is shown this when the military arrests a man off the street and the sound of gunfire can be heard at times. While the show does treat this humorously, this isn't the typical villain you'd expect from this kind of show.

    Podcasts 
  • Pokemon: Adventures in the Millennium starts with Starr, who is incredibly cruel to her allies and enemies and is implied to have killed her abusive father. She's later usurped by The Logos Corporation, who believe humanity and Pokemon can only be saved by culling the weakest of the population.

    Professional Wrestling 

    Tabletop Games 

    Web Animation 
  • The first three volumes of RWBY are fairly light in their overall tone, but still features as villains career criminal Roman Torchwick, and merciless killer Cinder Fall. When the series' true Big Bad, Salem, is introduced at the end of volume 3, the entire tone of the series shifts to more serious.
  • Battle for Dream Island:
    • Flower was a huge Jerkass since episode 1, however, in the finale she destroyed all the Recovery Centers (which are the reason Death Is Cheap in that universe) and promptly killed Bubble, making the latter the first person in the series to be Killed Off for Real (although she is back alive 3 episodes later). She is crushed by a UFO moments after.
    • Leafy also undergoes a Face–Heel Turn in that episode, stealing Dream Island from the winner note , nearly turns into Evil Leafy, and later throws knives at several character for disturbing her.
    • Evil Leafy also deserves special recognition, being a murderous, silent, on-the-brink-of-Eldritch Abomination and just generally disturbing creature who eats people she catches. It’s notable as unlike the two above, she has nearly, if not, absolutely no comedic moments, which is surprising considering BFDI is a comedy.

    Webcomics 

    Web Original 


 
Feedback

Video Example(s):

Top

Clockwerk

Not just for the first game, but for the entire series. The Sly Cooper series is a cartoonish, Lighter and Softer series than most. And though it has its dark moments, its villains are typically Laughably Evil, have some altruistic qualities, and some even reform. Clockwerk, however, is the exact opposite of every other villain in the series, as he has no redeemable qualities, is never played for comedy, and is for all intents and purposes, a Serial Killer played competently, completely, and horrifyingly straight in a kids game.

How well does it match the trope?

4.92 (13 votes)

Example of:

Main / VileVillainSaccharineShow

Media sources:

Main / VileVillainSaccharineShow

Report