1980s
- 1980: Brooke Shields (as Emmeline Lestrange in The Blue Lagoon)
- Nancy Allen (as Liz Blake in Dressed to Kill)
- Faye Dunaway (as Barbara Delaney in The First Deadly Sin)
- Shelley Duvall (as Winifred "Wendy" Torrance in The Shining) note
- Farrah Fawcett (as Alex in Saturn 3)
- Sondra Locke (as Antoinette Lily in Bronco Billy)
- Olivia Newton-John (as Kira in Xanadu)
- Valerie Perrine (as Samantha Simpson in Can't Stop the Music)
- Deborah Raffin (as Lena Canada in Touched by Love)
- Talia Shire (as Emily Hollander in Windows)
- 1981: Tie
- Bo Derek (as Jane Parker in Tarzan, the Ape Man)
- Faye Dunaway (as Joan Crawford in Mommie Dearest)
- Linda Blair (as Marti Gaines in Hell Night)
- Brooke Shields (as Jade Butterfield in Endless Love)
- Barbra Streisand (as Cheryl Gibbons in All Night Long)
- 1982: Pia Zadora (as Kady in Butterfly)
- Morgan Fairchild (as Jamie Douglas in The Seduction)
- Mia Farrow (as Ariel in A Midsummer Night's Sex Comedy)
- Kristy McNichol (as Mabel Stanley in The Pirate Movie)
- Mary Tyler Moore (as Charlotte Dreyfus in Six Weeks)
- 1983: Pia Zadora (as Jerilee Randall in The Lonely Lady)
- Loni Anderson (as Pembrook Feeny in Stroker Ace)
- Linda Blair (as Carol Henderson in Chained Heat)
- Faye Dunaway (as Barbara Skelton in The Wicked Lady)
- Olivia Newton-John (as Debbie Wylder in Two of a Kind)
- 1984: Bo Derek (as Lida "Mac" MacGillivery in Bolero)
- Faye Dunaway (as Selena in Supergirl)
- Shirley MacLaine (as Veronica in Cannonball Run II)
- Tanya Roberts (as Sheena in Sheena)
- Brooke Shields (as Dale in Sahara)
- 1985: Linda Blair (as Sue Perman in Night Patrol, Daly in Savage Island and Brenda in Savage Streets)
- Ariane (as Tracy Tzu in Year of the Dragon)
- Jennifer Beals (as Eva in The Bride)
- Brigitte Nielsen (as Red Sonja in Red Sonja)
- Tanya Roberts (as Stacey Sutton in A View to a Kill)
- 1986: Madonna (as Gloria Tatlock in Shanghai Surprise)
- Kim Basinger (as Elizabeth McGraw in 9½ Weeks)
- Joan Chen (as May-May in Tai-Pan)
- Brigitte Nielsen (as Ingrid Knudsen in Cobra)
- Ally Sheedy (as Annie Rayford in Blue City)
- 1987: Madonna (as Nikki Finn in Who's That Girl)
- Lorraine Gary (as Ellen Brody in Jaws: The Revenge)
- Sondra Locke (as Nikki Morrison in Ratboy)
- Debra Sandlund (as Patty Lareine in Tough Guys Don't Dance)
- Sharon Stone (as Jesse Huston in Allan Quatermain and the Lost City of Gold)
- 1988: Liza Minnelli (as Linda Marolla Bach in Arthur 2: On the Rocks and Della Roberts in Rent-a-Cop)
- Rebecca De Mornay (as Robin Shea in And God Created Woman (1988))
- Whoopi Goldberg (as Vashti Blue in The Telephone)
- Cassandra Peterson (as Elvira in Elvira, Mistress of the Dark)
- Vanity (as Sydney Ash in Action Jackson)
- 1989: Heather Locklear (as Abby Arcane in The Return of Swamp Thing)
- Jane Fonda (as Harriet Winslow in Old Gringo)
- Brigitte Nielsen (as Lisa in Bye Bye Baby)
- Paulina Porizkova (as Nina in Her Alibi)
- Ally Sheedy (as Maggie DeLoach in Heart of Dixie)
1990s
- 1990: Bo Derek (as Katie in Ghosts Can't Do It)
- Melanie Griffith (as Maria Ruskin in The Bonfire of the Vanities)
- Bette Midler (as Stella Claire in Stella)
- Molly Ringwald (as Betsy Hopper in Betsy's Wedding)
- Talia Shire (as Adrian Balboa in Rocky V)
- 1991: Sean Young (as Ellen Carlssonnote in A Kiss Before Dying)
- Kim Basinger (as Vicki Anderson in The Marrying Man)
- Sally Field (as Betty Mahmoody in Not Without My Daughter)
- Madonna (as herself in Truth or Dare)
- Demi Moore (as Marina Lemke in The Butcher's Wife and Diane Lightson in Nothing but Trouble)
- 1992: Melanie Griffith (as Linda Voss in Shining Through and Emily Eden in A Stranger Among Us)
- Kim Basinger (as Holli Would in Cool World and Heather Evans in Final Analysis)
- Lorraine Bracco (as Dr. Rae Crane in Medicine Man and Ellen Schofield in Traces of Red)
- Whitney Houston (as Rachel Marron in The Bodyguard)
- Sean Young (as Dana Greenway in Love Crimes)
- 1993: Madonna (as Rebecca Carlson in Body of Evidence)
- Melanie Griffith (as Billie Dawn in Born Yesterday)
- Janet Jackson (as Justice in Poetic Justice)
- Demi Moore (as Diana Murphy in Indecent Proposal)
- Sharon Stone (as Carly Norris in Sliver)
- 1994: Sharon Stone (as May Munro in The Specialist and Sally Eastman in Intersection)
- Kim Basinger (as Carol McCoy in The Getaway)
- Joan Chen (as Masu in On Deadly Ground)
- Jane March (as Rose Dexter / Bonnie in Color of Night)
- Uma Thurman (as Sissy Hankshaw in Even Cowgirls Get the Blues)
- 1995: Elizabeth Berkley (as Nomi Malone in Showgirls)
- Cindy Crawford (as Kate McQuean in Fair Game)
- Demi Moore (as Hester Prynne in The Scarlet Letter)
- Julia Sweeney (as Pat Riley in It's Pat!)
- Sean Young (as Helen Hyde in Dr. Jekyll & Ms. Hyde)
- 1996: Demi Moore (as Erin Grant in Striptease and Annie Laird in The Juror)
- Pamela Anderson (as Barbara "Barb Wire" Kopetski in Barb Wire)
- Whoopi Goldberg (as Harriet Franklin in Bogus, Edwina "Eddie" Franklin in Eddie, and Katie Coltrane in Theodore Rex)
- Melanie Griffith (as Betty Kerner in Two Much)
- Julia Roberts (as Mary Reilly in Mary Reilly)
- 1997: Demi Moore (as Lt. Jordan O'Neil in G.I. Jane)
- Sandra Bullock (as Annie Porter in Speed 2: Cruise Control)
- Fran Drescher (as Joy Miller in The Beautician and the Beast)
- Lauren Holly (as Jennifer Robertson in A Smile Like Yours and Teri Halloran in Turbulence)
- Alicia Silverstone (as Emily Hope in Excess Baggage)
- 1998: Spice Girls (as themselves in Spice World)
- Yasmine Bleeth (as Jenna Reed in BASEketball)
- Anne Heche (as Marion Crane in Psycho)
- Jessica Lange (as Martha Baring in Hush)
- Uma Thurman (as Emma Peel in The Avengers)
- 1999: Heather Donahue (as Heather Donahue in The Blair Witch Project)
- Melanie Griffith (as Lucille Vinson in Crazy in Alabama)
- Milla Jovovich (as Joan of Arc in The Messenger: The Story of Joan of Arc)
- Sharon Stone (as Gloria in Gloria)
- Catherine Zeta-Jones (as Virginia Baker in Entrapment and Theo in The Haunting)
2000s
- 2000: Madonna (as Abbie Reynolds in The Next Best Thing)
- Kim Basinger (as Maggie O'Connor in Bless the Child and Kuki Gallmann in I Dreamed of Africa)
- Melanie Griffith (as Honey Whitlock in Cecil B. Demented)
- Bette Midler (as Jacqueline Susann in Isn't She Great)
- Demi Moore (as Martha Marie / "Marty" Talridge in Passion of Mind)
- 2001: Mariah Carey (as Billie Frank in Glitter)
- Penélope Cruz (as Mirtha Jung in Blow, Pelagia in Captain Corelli's Mandolin, and Sofía Serrano in Vanilla Sky)
- Angelina Jolie (as Lara Croft in Lara Croft: Tomb Raider and Julia Russell / Bonny Castle in Original Sin)
- Jennifer Lopez (as Sharon Pogue in Angel Eyes and Mary Fiore in The Wedding Planner)
- Charlize Theron (as Sara Deever in Sweet November)
- 2002: Tie
- Madonna (as Amber Leighton in Swept Away)
- Britney Spears (as Lucy Wagner in Crossroads)
- Angelina Jolie (as Lanie Kerrigan in Life or Something Like It)
- Jennifer Lopez (as Slim Hiller in Enough and Marisa Ventura in Maid in Manhattan)
- Winona Ryder (as Babe Bennett in Mr. Deeds)
- 2003: Jennifer Lopez (as Ricki in Gigli)
- Drew Barrymore (as Dylan Sanders in Charlie's Angels: Full Throttle and Nancy Kendricks in Duplex)
- Kelly Clarkson (as Kelly Taylor in From Justin to Kelly)
- Cameron Diaz (as Natalie Cook in Charlie's Angels: Full Throttle)
- Angelina Jolie (as Lara Croft in Lara Croft: Tomb Raider – The Cradle of Life and Sarah Jordan in Beyond Borders)
- 2004: Halle Berry (as Patience Phillips / Catwoman in Catwoman)note
- Hilary Duff (as Sam Montgomery in A Cinderella Story and Terri Fletcher in Raise Your Voice)
- Angelina Jolie (as Queen Olympias in Alexander and Illeana Scott in Taking Lives)
- Mary-Kate and Ashley Olsen (as Roxy and Jane Ryan in New York Minute)
- Marlon Wayans & Shawn Wayansnote (in drag) (as "Brittany and Tiffany Wilson" in White Chicks)
- 2005: Jenny McCarthy (as Rebecca Sommers in Dirty Love)
- Jessica Alba (as Sue Storm / Invisible Woman in Fantastic Four and Sam in Into the Blue)
- Hilary Duff (as Lorraine Baker in Cheaper by the Dozen 2 and Holly Hamilton in The Perfect Man)
- Jennifer Lopez (as Charlie Cantilini in Monster-in-Law)
- Tara Reid (as Aline Cedrac in Alone in the Dark)
- 2006: Sharon Stone (as Catherine Tramell in Basic Instinct 2)
- Hilary Duff and Haylie Duff (as Tanzie and Ava Marchetta in Material Girls)
- Lindsay Lohan (as Ashley Albright in Just My Luck)
- Kristanna Loken (as Rayne in BloodRayne)
- Jessica Simpson (as Amy Renfro in Employee of the Month)
- 2007: Lindsay Lohan (as Dakota Moss and Aubrey Fleming (separately) in I Know Who Killed Me)
- Jessica Alba (as Sam Lockwood in Awake, Sue Storm / Invisible Woman in Fantastic Four: Rise of the Silver Surfer, and Cam Wexler in Good Luck Chuck)
- Logan Browning, Janel Parrish, Nathalia Ramos and Skyler Shaye (as Sasha, Jade, Yasmin and Cloe respectively in Bratz)
- Elisha Cuthbert (as Jennifer Tree in Captivity)
- Diane Keaton (as Daphne Wilder in Because I Said So)
- 2008: Paris Hilton (as Cristabel Abbott in The Hottie and the Nottie)
- Jessica Alba (as Sydney Wells in The Eye and Jane Bullard in The Love Guru)
- Annette Bening, Eva Mendes, Debra Messing, Jada Pinkett and Meg Ryan (as Sylvie Fowler, Crystal Allen, Edie Cohen, Alex Fisher, and Mary Haines respectively in The Women)
- Cameron Diaz (as Joy McNally in What Happens in Vegas)
- Kate Hudson (as Tess Finnegan in Fool's Gold and Alexis in My Best Friend's Girl)
- 2009: Sandra Bullock (as Mary Horowitz in All About Steve)note
- Beyoncé (as Sharon Charles in Obsessed)
- Miley Cyrus (as Miley Stewart / Hannah Montana in Hannah Montana: The Movie)
- Megan Fox (as Jennifer Check in Jennifer's Body and Mikaela Banes in Transformers: Revenge of The Fallen)
- Sarah Jessica Parker (as Meryl Morgan in Did You Hear About the Morgans?)
2010s
- 2010: "The four gal pals" (The main cast of Sex and the City 2):
- Kim Cattrall (as Samantha Jones)
- Kristin Davis (as Charlotte York Goldenblatt)
- Cynthia Nixon (as Miranda Hobbes)
- Sarah Jessica Parker (as Carrie Bradshaw)
- Jennifer Aniston (as Nicole Hurley in The Bounty Hunter and Kassie Larson in The Switch)
- Miley Cyrus (as Ronnie Miller in The Last Song)
- Megan Fox (as Tallulah Black / Lilah in Jonah Hex (2010))
- Kristen Stewart (as Bella Swan in The Twilight Saga: Eclipse)
- 2011: Adam Sandler (in drag) (as Jill Sadelstein in Jack and Jill)
- Martin Lawrence (in drag) (as Big Momma in Big Mommas: Like Father, Like Son)
- Sarah Palin (as herself in The Undefeated)
- Sarah Jessica Parker (as Kate Reddy in I Don't Know How She Does It and Kim Doyle in New Year's Eve)
- Kristen Stewart (as Bella Swan in The Twilight Saga: Breaking Dawn – Part 1)
- 2012: Kristen Stewart (as Snow White in Snow White & the Huntsman and Bella Swan in The Twilight Saga: Breaking Dawn – Part 2)
- Katherine Heigl (as Stephanie Plum in One for the Money)
- Milla Jovovich (as Alice in Resident Evil: Retribution)
- Tyler Perry (in drag) (as Mabel "Madea" Simmons in Madea's Witness Protection)
- Barbra Streisand (as Joyce Brewster in The Guilt Trip)
- 2013: Tyler Perry (in drag) (as Mabel "Madea" Simmons in A Madea Christmas)
- Halle Berry (as Jordan Turner in The Call and Emily Browning in Movie 43)
- Selena Gomez (as The Kid in Getaway)
- Lindsay Lohan (as Tara Lloyd in The Canyons)
- Naomi Watts (as Princess Diana in Diana and Samantha Miller in Movie 43)
- 2014: Cameron Diaz (as Carly Whitten in The Other Woman and Annie Hargrove in Sex Tape)
- Drew Barrymore (as Lauren Reynolds in Blended)
- Melissa McCarthy (as Tammy Banks in Tammy)
- Charlize Theron (as Anna Barnes-Leatherwood in A Million Ways to Die in the West)
- Gaia Weiss (as Hebe in The Legend of Hercules)
- 2015: Dakota Johnson (as Anastasia "Ana" Steele in Fifty Shades of Grey)
- Katherine Heigl (as Mona Champagne in Home Sweet Hell)
- Mila Kunis (as Jupiter Jones in Jupiter Ascending)
- Jennifer Lopez (as Claire Peterson in The Boy Next Door)
- Gwyneth Paltrow (as Johanna Mortdecai in Mortdecai)
- 2016: Rebekah Turner/Mikaela Krantznote (as Hillary Clinton in Hillary's America: The Secret History of the Democratic Party)
- Megan Fox (as April O'Neil in Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles: Out of the Shadows)
- Tyler Perry (in drag) (as Mabel "Madea" Simmons in Boo! A Madea Halloween)
- Julia Roberts (as Miranda Collins in Mother's Day)
- Naomi Watts (as Mary Portman in Shut In and Evelyn Johnson-Eaton in The Divergent Series: Allegiant)
- Shailene Woodley (as Beatrice "Tris" Prior in The Divergent Series: Allegiant)
- 2017: Tyler Perry (in drag) (as Mabel "Madea" Simmons in Boo 2!: A Madea Halloween)
- Katherine Heigl (as Tessa Connover in Unforgettable)
- Dakota Johnson (as Anastasia "Ana" Steele in Fifty Shades Darker)
- Jennifer Lawrence (as mother in mother!)
- Emma Watson (as Mae Holland in The Circle)
- 2018: Melissa McCarthy (as Connie Edwards in The Happytime Murders and Deanna Miles in Life of the Party)
- Jennifer Garner (as Riley North in Peppermint)
- Amber Heard (as Nicola Six in London Fields)
- Helen Mirren (as Sarah Winchester in Winchester)
- Amanda Seyfried (as Judy in The Clapper)
- 2019: Hilary Duff (as Sharon Tate in The Haunting of Sharon Tate)
- Anne Hathaway (as Josephine Chesterfield in The Hustle and Karen Zariakas in Serenity)
- Francesca Hayward (as Victoria in Cats)
- Tyler Perry (in drag) (as Mabel "Madea" Simmons in A Madea Family Funeral)
- Rebel Wilson (as Penny Rust in The Hustle)
2020s
- 2020: Kate Hudson (as Kazu "Zu" Gamble in Music)
- Anne Hathaway (as Elena McMahon in The Last Thing He Wanted and the Grand High Witch in The Witches)
- Katie Holmes (as Liza in Brahms: The Boy II and Miranda Wells in The Secret: Dare to Dream)
- Lauren Lapkus (as Missy in The Wrong Missy)
- Anna-Maria Sieklucka (as Laura Biel in 365 Days)
- 2021: Jeanna de Waal (as Princess Diana in Diana the Musical)
- Amy Adams (as Anna Fox in The Woman in the Window)
- Megan Fox (as Rebecca in Midnight in the Switchgrass)
- Taryn Manning (as Karen Drexler in Karen)
- Ruby Rose (as Victoria in Vanquish)
- 2022: The Razzies Themselves for nominating Ryan Kiera Armstrong for the award
- Ryan Kiera Armstrong (as Charlene "Charlie" McGee in Firestarter) (nomination rescinded)note
- Bryce Dallas Howard (as Claire Dearing in Jurassic World Dominion)
- Diane Keaton (as Mackenzie "Mack" Martin / Rita in Mack & Rita)
- Kaya Scodelario (as Marie-Josèphe in The King's Daughter)
- Alicia Silverstone (as Jaelyn in The Requin)
- 2023: Megan Fox (as Alana Hart in Johnny & Clyde)
- Ana de Armas for Ghosted as Sadie Rhodes
- Salma Hayek for Magic Mike's Last Dance as Maxandra "Max" Mendoza
- Jennifer Lopez for The Mother as The Mother
- Helen Mirren for SHAZAM! Fury of the Gods as Hespera
