Studio C is a sketch comedy show produced by BYUtv created by Jared Shores and Matt Meese. One of the major differences from other contemporary comedy shows is that the comedy is intended to be family-safe, focusing on wordplay and absurdist situational comedy with little to no fanservice or swearing. The original cast members are all former members of the BYU Divine Comedy troupe which is an on-campus sketch comedy show by BYU students. Most of the sketches in the show's first season were directly adapted from Divine Comedy sketches the cast had written. The title Studio C refers to the actual studio where the show is filmed.
The show began in 2012 and began its 8th season in 2017, airing its 100th episode in November of that year. It airs on BYUtv, a television station operated by Brigham Young University in Provo, Utah, but it reaches a much wider audience on YouTube; it should be noted, though, that BYUtv is available across much of the United States via many of the big-name cable and satellite providers (excluding Google Fiber).
The Studio C cast has evolved over time:
- The original cast had 10 members: Adam Berg, Whitney Call, Mallory Everton, Jason Gray, Stacey Harkey, Natalie Madsen, Stephen Meek, Matt Meese, James Perry, and Jeremy Warner.
- In May 2017, three new cast members were introduced: Aaron Fielding, Dalton Johnson, and Tori Pence.
- On 9 August 2018, BYUtv announced that the original 10 cast members would depart the show at the end of season 9 and that new cast members and writers would be added.
- On 12 September 2018, the 10 departing cast members announced via YouTube that they have formed JK! Studios, a digital, family-safe comedy network. The new network is a private business venture separate from BYUtv and launched in January.
- On 11 January 2019, Aaron Fielding announced via Instagram that he will not return after the ninth season.
- On 26 March 2019, BYUtv announced 9 new cast members joining Dalton and Tori: Garet Allen, Jessica Drolet, Ike Flitcraft, Matthew Galvan, Tanner Gillman, Jetta Juriansz, Arvin Mitchell, April Rock, and Austin Williams. Unlike the original cast, only one of the new nine members is a BYU student (Allen). Quite a few of them have experience studying at the Upright Citizens Brigade. Veteran producer and writer Jim O'Doherty (3rd Rock from the Sun and Grounded for Life) will be the new showrunner.
To date, the series has won four Rocky Mountain Regional Emmy Awardsnote .
This show provides examples of:
- Abhorrent Admirer: Ann the librarian.
- The Ace: "Jason Bourne" to the CIA's anger, fear and confusion.Matt: Look out he has a piece of pocket lint!
(lights go out for a split second and when turned back on, Jason has untied himself from the chair and tied all 9 members of the CIA up and escaped)
Mallory: (exasperated) HOOOOOOW!?!?
- Edmond (Matt) to Fernand (Whitney) in "Edmond and Fernand: BFFs" is comparatively more successful, more attractive, more well liked and marrying the love of his life, to Fernand's thinly concealed detestation.
- Achievements in Ignorance: Matt has no idea how to play poker and yet he makes it to the final four in a huge tournament in "Poker Face." If he wasn't using Uno cards, he might have gotten lucky enough to win too.
- Added Alliterative Appeal: "Dana's Dead", "Robbing Roger" and "Sam Sloan".
- Adorkable: Lobster Bisque, and Susan Weebers
- Affably Evil: Maniacal Overlord Adam, despite having world domination goals, proves to be a Benevolent Boss to his minions, even if he can't remember Jeremy's name.
- All Girls Want Bad Boys: At least Natalie thought she did in "Bad Boy Rap," until Whitney and Mallory take it too far, and she ends up meeting a perfectly nice and handsome accountant, whom she immediately falls for.
- All Just a Dream: Matt and Whitney try to convince Jason that he's dreaming by pulling off impossible feats that baffle even themselves. Actually, Whitney is the one who's dreaming.
Kyle: Now I have two!
- In "Kyle's Halloween" Kyle's father has a nightmare that his overactive child was able to gain access to his trick-or-treat candy supply. He wakes up, and is relieved to find he still has the key to the freezer where it froze the candy. Only for Kyle to appear behind, and remove the key from his sleeping father's pocket.
- Stephen has a nightmare to find that Whitney, their son, his grandfather and everybody in the world are just pillows. He wakes up to find to his delight that everybody is back to normal, pillows with faces.
- All Women Love Shoes: In "Man On the Ledge," after witnessing her husband about to commit what she believes is a dire act, Natalie believing she drove him to it apologizes for spending over $2,000 dollars on shoes the previous month. Matt was actually unaware of that fact.
- Always Someone Better: In "It's A Wonderful Life..." Stephen is mortified to learn that if he had never been born Whitney would have married a handsome, billionaire, philanthropist, rugby star, who is also named Stephen!Stephen: BOO! Jimmy Stewart's wife became an old hag!
(notices the baby stroller)
Stephen: What!?! Whitney said she never wanted to have kids!
Clarence: Well, not your kids!
- Clarke to Watney in the "Martian VLogs."
- Amusing Injuries: The "Scott Sterling" penalty shootout
- And the sequel, the Scott Sterling volleyball match!
- Artistic License: "Atari's Revenge on Nintendo" plays fast and loose with video game history. Nintendo is portrayed as an American "little startup company" in the 80's, when in reality, it is a Japanese company that has been in operation since 1889. Also, the sketch ignores the existence of the Mario and Luigi characters prior to Super Mario Bros. note
- "Awesome McCool" Name: In the "Alien Invasion" sketch, one star got renamed "Chuck NorrisSaurus Rex". And even though the planet is made of gold and diamonds, and populated by fluffy bunnies, nobody dares bother it. Contrasted with the Atrocious Alias given to another star, "Wounded Lover".
- Awkward Kiss: "Harry Potter Accidentally Kisses Professor McGonagall" has Harry setting up an Under the Mistletoe kiss, with his intended target being Cho, but getting Dolores Umbridge instead. After an awkward peck on her cheek, he resets for Cho, but gets Professor McGonagall. He offers his cheek, but McGonagall goes in for the full-on lip-lock. The next one to come under the mistletoe is a dementor.
- Babysitter from Hell: If Julie Andrews wasn't available for Mary Poppins or The Sound of Music, we might have had Ms. Gerdistein.
- Badass Mustache: Jeremy's 'stache is practically its own character.
- Bad Bad Acting: Matt in Poker Face 2: All In.
- Bad Boss: Matt in "How Are You Feeling Today?" is demeaning to his employees, takes great pleasure in using Whitney's supernaturally powered "Mood Board," to manipulate his employees for negative and humiliating outcomes, and later uses it to manipulate Natalie away from Stacey, and later manipulate Stacey to be okay with someone stealing his girlfriend.
- Bad Future: Jason brings back a 50th anniversary DVD for "Studio C," from the future to show his fellow cast mates, and no, things dont turn out to well. The majority of the Cast and Crew go on strike for three seasons, except for James who runs the show with his Lobster Bisque, however according to Jason these are the highest rated season of the show and James actually wins an Emmy. Stephen dies of an epileptic seizure due to the opening credits, causing Whitney to absorb Ann the Librarian into her personality, and remarries R.L. Stine. Natalie quits after having Octuplets, Mallory is arrested after strangling a Mattory shipper to death, only this time she actually gets caught. Adam is turned into hash browns after a freak accident with a real life portal gun, and then eaten by Jeremy, Adams actually okay with this. Stacey ages surprisingly well, but both a geriatric and senile Jason and Matt seemingly die after attempting a Shoulder Angel, sketch in the 49th season.Matt: (wide-eyed) After seeing this we can all agree we should probably only do another 10 more seasons.
(everyone else equally horrified nods in agreement)
Stephen: (as everyone gets up and walks away) Guy's can we talk about changing the opening credits!
- In "I'm Adopted?", Stacey thinks his parents Matt and Mallory adopted him. Turns out he was Switched at Birth and the parents were too stupid to notice... and his biological parents are Asian.
- "No Work and All Cosplay" has Matt, Jason and James as movie theater employees. When they overhear girls talking about how they find characters from The Lord of the Rings attractive (presumably talking about characters such as Aragorn or Legolas), they dress up as Frodo, Gandalf and an orc in a failed effort to impress them. Later they hear other girls talking about boys from the Harry Potter films, but dress up as Voldemort, Snape and Umbridge. Finally, upon overhearing a girl talk about her attraction to Batman, Jason's face lights up. Since Batman is right in Jason's (the actor's) wheelhouse, we may not be prepared for the boys to come out as the Joker, Robin and Catwoman.
- Bald of Evil: All of the suspects in "Supervillains"— Discussed, Voldemort claims the insecurity makes you evil. Averted with Gandhi.
- Baleful Polymorph: Sorceress Mal turns Jason into a rabbit in "Our Wedding," and he doesn't transform back.
- Zalmuron the Reincarnated.
- Bat Deduction: "Spoiler Alert". (Yes, that was the title of a sketch.) Strangely, the trope has yet to come up in any of the numerous sketches where Jason plays Batman, though this may be because his portrayal is more Dark Knight and less Caped Crusader.
- Belligerent Sexual Tension: "Naturally" takes this trope to extremes when a man and woman start an argument who is more is more organic, only to end up making out.
- Berserk Button: As Mallory learns in "Deal Breakers," never mess with Jeremy's mustache.(Kori Gardner of Mates of States approaches Mal and slaps her across the face)
Kori: That was for Jeremy!
(she storms off, and the crowd parts to reveal Jeremy)
Jeremy: (getting up in Mal's face) WHAT!!!
- Beware the Silly Ones: Ann the Librarian. For all her eccentric flirting, if a person neglects turning in their books on time, they will discover that she is also the ruthless boss of the Librarian's Mafia, and have them punished, all with a pleasant smile on her face.Ann: Tell him to say "A Farewell to Arms."
(Adam grabs and holds Jason's arms down while weilding a knife)
- Big Brother Is Watching: In How to Be a Famous Reality Star, which presents the obvious surveillance as if it is a reality show.
- Big Damn Kiss: Mallory and Adam in "How Are You Feeling Today," after Whitney uses the board to boost Mal's confidence.
- Big "NO!": While not a "No," per se, Matt gives a long, loud, exasperated scream in "Jeremy Isn't Real," after learning Mallory is actually just Jason in a wig.
Matt: Sir! Seems snitcher snatcher the snitch se-sen... OH NO!!!
- Matt and Jason deliver one near the end of "Sam Sloane," when almost near the end of the sketch, Matt uncharacteristically screws up his summary line, forcing them all to restart from the beginning once more. Mallory and Stacey also express their frustration at this.
- Black Comedy: Sometimes steers into this.
- Blessed with Suck: Rotting Flesh, the superhero with leprosy
- Bratty Half-Pint: "Episode 7 Releases Footage of Jedi Class" shows the logical conclusion of having a bunch of kindergarten age kids trying to master the Force.
- Brawn Hilda: Birgitte Gerdestien, who was rejected for the roles of Mary Poppins and Sister Maria.
- Bread, Eggs, Breaded Eggs: In "Most Realistic Video Game of All Time", Matt encounters a baby, a navy SEAL, and a baby seal.Mallory: Matt, you can't just eat bacon for every meal. That's not how cleanses work!Matt: Of course that's how cleanses work: You pick one thing and eat only that thing. Juice, bacon, bacon juice...Mallory: That's grease.Matt: I've heard it both ways.
- Brief Accent Imitation: Usually Jason.
- British Teeth: Matt wears crooked teeth in both International Relations and Republicans VS Democrats as a personification of Britain.
- But for Me, It Was Tuesday: Evil Memory Lapse
- The Butler Did It: Jason tries (and fails) to invoke this trope in "Blame it on the Butler"
- Butt-Monkey: Adam in the two tongue twister skits, "Dana's Dead" and "Robbing Roger". In one Jason spits water in his face repeatedly, in the other Jason tars and feathers him in his face repeatedly.
Adam: (to the viewers) Please leave comments about upping my salary!!!
- In "Kid's School Photo Banned" he gets sent through the ringer again, this time because he didn't look awful in his school photo
- Mixed with Humiliation Conga, Jeremy in Overdue Military Letter. Matt and Jason get great gifts, Jeremy...
- Matt in "Narrator Hater," due to the narrator's (James) unabashed hatred towards him.
- Poor Adam ends up being this in real life among his castmates as in "The Live Million Subscriber Challenge," he ends up being the biggest loser by the end of the tournament, ending with a dead cockroach entering his mouth in the final challenge with Jason. Yuck!!!
- The entire basis of the Scott Sterling sketches, which feature an unlucky soccer goalie who keeps getting hit in the face with balls.
- Call-Back: "College Research Project: The Four Page Zone" references "The Absent-Minded Robber":Jason: Next semester we can study the thing that happens when you walk into a room and can't remember why you're there.Whitney: Oh yeah, my brother had that! He's in jail now.
DaVinci: You guys have no idea how long this take-a to paint. She was a difficult subject!
- In "Marco Polo," Matt's DaVinci pulls out a painting of Mal's Mona Lisa.
- Rumplestilskin and his "children" is one of the "Disgruntled Commoners."
- The Cameo: "Studio C" Co-Creator, Producer and Director Jared Shore appears at the end of "Bad Boy Rap" as the handsome nice guy that Natalie falls for.
- Apparently Matt went to high-school with Ann, thankfully this time around he has a giant Viking familiar when dealing with her.
- Clingy Jealous Girl: Peter Pan's shadow.
- Cloudcuckoolander: Many of the characters
- Matt in "Poker Face"
- John Gibson in "The Treatment"
- S in "Replacement Q"
- Captain Ersatz: Jim Blonde for James Bond.
- Character Filibuster: Senator Warner needs to filibuster, so he pulls out the Twilight books and starts reading.
- Cheese-Eating Surrender Monkeys: Invoked in Foreign Exchange and The Ottoman Empire.
- Chick Magnet: The reason James is able to room with Spencer. The girls all find him adorable, and by extension James.
- Franny (Jason) the 18th century's standard for a Manly Ladies man.
- Christmas in July: Mallory goes completely overboard with the decorations in "Advent Calendar Temptation".
- Classical Mythology: "The Greek Gods" includes some of the more well-known Greek deities...and some other ones. And apparently Morgan Freeman is one too.
- Clown Car Base: Couchville
- Crazy-Prepared: "Gun To A Knife Fight" skit.
- Cross-Cast Role: The show seems to have an unofficial rule that all black characters will be played by the troupe's only black actor, Stacey Harkey, who despite his Gender-Blender Name is male. So every female black character will always be played by Stacey in drag.
- Colossus Climb: The Shoulder Angel when he needed to help Shawn Bradley.
- Corpsing: Jeremy's superpower is that he can keep a straight face through anything.
Whitney: Sir... (covers her mouth to hide her laughter) sir, these... photos prove that you are— (laughs)Jason: It was an overreaction! I'm sorry!Whitney: Calm down! Count to 10 and stand in the corner!(Jason immediately puts his face in the corner.)
- Mallory totally loses it in A Bold New Soap Opera.
- Mallory and Whitney both in A Bold New Telenovela.
- Matt and Mallory both fail to keep a straight face at the end of "Dungeons and Dragons."
- Matt is clearly on the verge of laughter in "Awkward Double Date with Puritan Roommate."
- Matt is visibly smirking and desperately trying to keep it together in "A Friend's Dying Secrets," where he is actually playing a corpse. Jason, who can usually keep it together, lost it as well. Some quick improvisation tried to cover it up.
- "Cheer Up Mix Up" had both Matt and Adam struggling to keep it in. To be fair, Adam was sporting a "LOSER" forehead tattoo at the time.
- Matt has become so well-known for breaking character that Studio C has created a playlist of sketches in which he does it.
- Jeremy finally breaks character in "Atari's Revenge on Nintendo".
- While they all, no surprise, lasted longer than Matt (The Flash), in "Wonder Woman fights for Equality" after Natalie (Wonder Woman) accidentally slams Jason (Batman) harder than she intended too into the desk, all of them, James (Superman) included ended up visibly chuckling and smirking at the circumstances. Too his credit Jason was able to remain his composure longer than the other three.
- Impressively averted by Mallory in "Prince Charming's Awkward First Kiss," in which she remains completely still and in character as an unconscious Sleeping Beauty, despite all the shenanigans Adam's Prince Charming puts her through. The two even mention how amazing this was in the React Series, especially given that neither were able to keep it together during dress rehearsals of the sketch.
- One of the charms of the "tongue twister" sketchs is watching the regular players (Matt, Jason, Stacy, Mal and Adam) crack up after mistaking their lines.
- In "The Worst Blackmail Imaginable", Jason's character is upset and turns away from Stephen, only to accidentally bump into some easels. To cover it up, Jason angrily knocks them aside and faces the wall. Whitney struggles to suppress her laughter in order to deliver her next line.
- Creepy Child: Spencer, the baby who is a college Freshmen.Spencer: Hello, Matthew.
(Matt is freaked out by four scare chords in the music, but his daughter laughs maniacally, causing a wide-eyed Matt to stare at her alarmingly)
- Whitney and Matt's infant daughter, who can only be calmed by slasher music in "Baby's Favorite Lullaby."
Matt: (cautiously calling out to Whitney) Honey...
- Comically Missing the Point: In the Slasher.com skit, seriously? That's romance?Queen Elizabeth: Oh, look, I made BuzzFeed! "The Top Ten Most Irrelevant Old People."David Cameron: Oh, I'm sorry.Queen Elizabeth: I MADE BUZZFEED!
Tori: (singing) I'd rather hug a cactus!
- In "Welcome Back Song," after Jason is dragged down by the audience to what appears his death, the rest of the cast watch in complete horror, except for Stacey who continues rocking out to the song, blissfully unaware of his castmate's demise.
- Green is the only crayon not disturbed by Black's action in "The Crayon Song," absent-mindly bobing along with the song.
- Adam can't understand that Tori is insulting him by the end of "Love Duet," and would literally rather cut off her ear than continue singing with him!
Adam: Ooh, I like what I'm hearing!
- "Dear John" Letter: Jeremy the soldier receives one from his girlfriend in "Overdue Military Letters", saying she's met someone else. A few minutes later, Jeremy opens an invitation to their wedding.
- Death Glare: Mallory and Whitney are both quite good at pulling one out when appropriate.
- Deadpan Snarker: All of them have this potential, but Jeremy is king among them in this regard.
- A Degree in Useless: Subverted in "Practical Philosopher"
- Did I Just Say That Out Loud?: Matt in "Dungeons and Dragons".Matt: Long have I desired to be kissed by a woman... says my character.
Jeremy: I have a tweet from a Whitney Call.
- In real life, during the casts' live stream of the Christmas Special, Natalie accidentally reveals on air that Whitney, who wasn't present after having just delivered her and Stephen's son, has wide feet and needs to get special shoes. She immediately regrets it and apologizes to Whitney whom she assumes is watching. Later in the Q&A at the end of the stream Jeremy gets a tweet from a certain viewer...
(Natalie shrinks back in her seat)
Jeremy: "How much would Natalie liked to get kicked in the bum by my super wide feet?!?"
- Discriminate and Switch: Stacey realizes that Matt obviously couldn't have been his long lost son in "Clue Murder Mystery Scandal" because they have different colored...eyes.
Jason: You of all people should understand. There are different ways to describe peopleStacey: What do you mean by me of all people?Jason: Because you're short.Stacey: Oh, touché.
- Also Stacey in Political Correctness Puzzles Police
- Disguised in Drag: Grandma Tildy
- Disneyfication: Fixing Good, the remake of Breaking Bad about a guy who makes "crystal-clear math"
- Dissonant Serenity: "Five Day Weather Forecast" has Matt calmly explaining the weather as the world ends.
- "Our Wedding" shows a montage of Adam and Natalie's wedding going to hell, all while a peaceful soothing variation of "Pachabel's Cannon" underscores it.
- Drama Queen: Or "King" in "Econ 101" as played by Matt.
- Doom Magnet: may be Implied to be the case with Mr.Eckelstone, who claims that statistically, he should have died 17.5 times and treats generally safe activities such as driving ed, boy scout hunting trip, and Lamaze Class as death sentences, either that or he's just crazy
- Duel to the Death: "James Austin," ends with Matt challanging Jason to one.
- Implied that Alexander Hamilton and Aaron Burr leave to partake in their infamous historical one in "Founding Father's Fraternity."
- Early Installment Weirdness: Season 1 has quite a different feel from what came later. There was No Budget, so there was very little location filming or post-production work; nearly all sketches were shot live before the studio audience. This coupled with most sketches being directly adapted from Divine Comedy routines gave this season a very "stage-y" feel; the cavernous, minimalistic set design further contributed to this. Although Matt, Mallory, Jason, and Whitney continued to be the only billed repertory players until the end of season 4, in the first season there's a much clearer divide between them and the other six; they're the leads of almost every sketch and wrote almost all of them too. The supporting cast members, meanwhile, have yet to find their comedic voice; the contrast is most striking with Jeremy, who comes across bland and generic in season 1 despite having a very pronounced and unique on-screen "brand" for the rest of the series. The theme song "I Wanna Run" is also absent.
- Eccentric Mentor: Mr. Ecclestone.
- Emotion Bomb: Whoever controls the "How Are You Feeling?" board controls the world.
- The End of the World as We Know It: "Five-Day Weather Forecast"
- Matt and Mal deliberately screw up Adam's school photo to prevent this.
- Even Evil Has Standards: In the "Lady Shadow" sketch, the whole reason why no one fights Lady Shadow...because she's pregnant.
- Maniacal Mad Scientist Matt is horrified when Igor accidentally releases One Direction on the world, an evil even he would never have subjected on humanity.
- Fairy Tale Free-for-All: "Disgruntled Commoners," have much to be disgruntled about given that the King has no clothes, the Queen supposedly can spin straw into gold according to her father the town drunk, the grandmother murders young girls her magic mirror tells her are fairer than she is, one princess is under the threat of falling into a death like curse by Maleficent, thus the King burns all the spinning wheels, despite textile being the kingdoms major export, the other Princess felt a pea under several giant mattresses, and the prince was once a frog. That's on top of the King hiring the Pied Piper of Hamlien who made off with not just the rats but the children when the King refused to pay him, and the King traded the entire kingdom for a bag of bean-erm bees!
- Fantastically Indifferent: "Trip to the ER"
- Fat Suit: Matt has worn a fat suit for several sketches, including "The Bacon Cleanse" and the ones featuring the Shoulder Devil character.
- Whitney wears one as "Lady Gordon."
- First World Problems: In "Customer Service Hotline", James calls customer support because his new refrigerator is spilling ice on his floor. After asking a bunch of seemingly irrelevant questions, customer support operator Natalie repeats back to confirm:Natalie: So just to sum things up, you are a healthy, happily married, socially acceptable free man, living outside of any war zones, with a roof over your head, food on your table, and a steady income, calling today to complain about your new, top-of-the-line refrigerator, paid for in cash, that seems to be spilling frozen, filtered water all over your non-dirt floor. Is that correct?James: (sighs, hangs up)
- Flynning: According to "Fencing: Slow-Mo Replay," modern fencing matches are actually like this, but they happen so fast that you need to watch the replay to see them.
- The Friend No One Likes: Plumpy in "Candyland Conference."
- From Bad to Worse: The misfortunes that Lord Capulet experiences in "Romeo tries to Impress Juliet," gets more and more outlandish.
- In "Our Wedding," after Mal reveals herself to be an evil sorceress, she kidnaps Natalie, sics a colony of bats on the bridesmaids, that carry Whitney away, turns Jason into a bunny that she flings at Matt, sends Stacey flying skyward, sets Jeremy and his mustache on fire, and finally turns into a dragon and challenges Adam.
- James attempts to give the audience a tour of the backstage but instead is witness to escalating chaos his cast mates are experiencing.
- The cast thinks that being stranded on a deserted island is bad, until Mark Rober's inventions end up making thier lives so much worst.
- The "Fun" in "Funeral": "Dead Wedding"
- Funny Background Event: "Presidential Shoulder Angel"
- Overtly fueling the "Mattory," craze, during "Shoulder Angel Angel," Mallory is shown having a picture of Matt in her locker, highlighted by four hearts, which she strokes longingly.
- Right beside her in the same sketch, Adam has photos of Whitney, Stacey and James in his locker.
- In "The Wrong Sketch," Adam and Stacey recreate the Shoulder Angel, to the oblivion of the cast.
- "P 90 X," has Matt demonstrating difficult exercise routines, while Mallory shows "adapted" versions of the exercise, and Jeremy works up a sweat, to the point of death.
- Overtly fueling the "Mattory," craze, during "Shoulder Angel Angel," Mallory is shown having a picture of Matt in her locker, highlighted by four hearts, which she strokes longingly.
- Gambit Pileup: In the "Death Bed Repentance" skit, the Livingstone family (a mafia family) and Jose Delgado (the mafia boss who should be dead, and who disguised as a delivery man who Mallory paid to deliver her candy tombstone) pull this off to one another, despite their confession (of not having much time to live) becoming more repetitive and unrealistic as the sketch goes on
- "D&D Revenge", both sides (the guys and Carly) did a great deal of preparation when they meet again
- Gender-Blender Name: Stacey is a guy. Surprisingly, this trope remains unexploited.
- Gentle Giant: Adam in "Little Man Syndrome," who is abused by shorter Stephen and Matt.
- "Gift of the Magi" Plot: Mallory and Stephen recreate the story, only for Mal to be livid that Stephen would have sold his watch, after she sold her hair for a chain for it.
- Girlfriend in Canada: Adam in D&D Revenge
- Girls With Mustaches: The Marvel's Avengers parody song featured Mallory dressed as Thor, complete with mustache and beard.
- Whitney sports a beard while portraying Fernand, of The Count of Monte Cristo fame.
- Grammar Nazi: Captain Literally is a superhero variant, but he is not the only one....
- Good Angel, Bad Angel: Both have showed up in the Shoulder Angel sketches, although only once in the same skit.
- And it seems that Shoulder Angels sometimes need an angel of their own too.
- Good Cop/Bad Cop: There's the good cop, the bad cop, and the ugly cop. And the hot cop.
- Green-Eyed Monster: Fernand (Whitney) to Edmond (Matt) in "Edmond and Fernand: BFFs", all while "graciously" congratulating his "friend", with the thinnest veiled hatred towards Edmund.
- Hard Head: Spoofed in the "Scott Sterling" shorts, where a man suffering repeated head trauma is treated as an inhuman athlete and the hero of the game. Played for Laughs, of course.
- Henpecked Husband: Jason and Matt play these to Whitney (Carol) and Mallory (Jennifer) respectively in the Christmas Cards skit. As the feud between their wives reaches ridiculous levels, the two are helpless in their attempts of reasoning with them.
- In "Celebirthsary" Matt is constantly challenged by Mallory to remember certain dates and events in their marriage, and goes out of her way to ensure he can't pick it up on context clues.
- Hilariously Abusive Childhood: Natalie's in "The Quiet Game."Natalie: My parents and I used to play "The Quiet Game," all the time. It was so much fun. I would play "The Quiet Game,", "The Stay Still in Church Game,", "The Ask for the Cheapest Christmas Present Game." One year I won because I only asked for dirt.
Stephen: Your childhood makes me sad.
- Hitler's Time Travel Exemption Act: "Time Travel Heroes Stop Hitler" sees Jeremy teleport to Hitler's office in the Führerbunker in 1938, only to be joined by Dr. Emmett Brown (Jason), Bill and Ted (Stephen and James, respectively), and Hermione Granger (Mallory). It is Hermione who ends up killing Hitler (played by Whitney, who was five months pregnant with hers and Stephen's first child when this sketch was filmed). The Tenth Doctor (Matt, of course) also shows up, but only to serve Bill and Ted with a notice of a lawsuit for copyright infringement; Spock (Adam) also shows up, but only after Hitler's already dead.
- Hollywood Tone-Deaf: Adam in "Love Duet."
- Hot Witch: Mal turns into a fiery Sorceress, after ditching her beggar woman disguise in "Our Wedding."
- Hunting the Most Dangerous Game: Mal in "Deal Breaker," eyeing an unknowing Adam as her game.
- Huge Guy, Tiny Girl: Anytime any of the girls, besides Natalie, are paired with Adam this applies
- Hypocrite: Mallory in "Shallow Mal," proudly boast to Matt that she cares more for what's on the inside than the outside, yet dumps her hideous yet noble and kindhearted Orc date for the cruel and possibly sociopathic handsome Elf.
- In "Luncheon Lovers," Natalie is disturbed by James finding his bizarre flirting to be creepy, at least she did when she thought he was flirting with Whitney, she changes her tune when he reveals he was flirting with her.
- If You're So Evil, Eat This Kitten: "Ditching Dobby" and "Bourne Dobby" revolve around having to get rid of Dobby.
- I Have Many Names: The entire point of the "Zombies Attack" skit, referring to the zombies. And Whitney's reactions to some of these names are just hysterical.James: Nah, I just call 'em-Whitney: ZOMBIES, thank you!James: Actually, I just call 'em Amy. After my Ex-Wife.
- At the very end when they test their different names on a zombie, Whitney calls it a zombie, which it didn't respond to. Instead, it responded to James calling it "Amy." Coincidentally, it actually was Amy. Huh. What're the odds?
- Informed Flaw: He often plays characters in this vein and it is often stated that Matt is a wimp and a weakling, however multiple sketches, particularly "P90X" and the "Shoulder Angels", often show him demonstrating just how great of shape he is in.
- Inherently Funny Word: Bisque!
- Inner Monologue: Both parts of "The Doorstep" feature the inner thoughts of Matt "Part 1" and Mal "Part 2" at the end of a date.
- The "Poker Face" skits dive into the minds of the players during the world poker tour finals. As it turns out, they're all Nervous Wrecks.
- It's a Wonderful Plot: Steven finds out that if he had never been born, Studio C would never have been started, and all of the other cast members' lives would have been significantly better than they currently are.
- Lame Pun: The entirty of "Puns Upon a Time," is built upon this as a Prince (James) while choosing his bride among the Princesses Lady, Rose, Terresa, aka. Terri, (Whitney, Mallory, Natalie) constantly makes word plays with their names (aside from the Princess Lady which he is stumped), to his father's (Jason) chagrin.
- Lame Pun Reaction: Whenever someone delivers an awful app-based pun in "Apps of the Wild West," Steven can be seen in the background booing each one.
- Namely the King in "Puns Upon a Time," but eventually everyones patience's is tried due to the Prince's annoying takes at humor.
- Large Ham: Well, everybody to an extent, but Matt, Jason, and Mallory take the cake.
- Whitney and Stacey are no slouches either.
- Large Ham Announcer: Just a few of the many examples Jason and Stephen deliver from the Scott Sterling penalty shootout:"SCOTT STERLING! The Man, The Myth, THE LEGEND!!""Look at him beg for mercy, when it's mercy that should be begging for him!!""He has to look death in the eye and say 'Take your best shot', to which death replies by punching him in the face over, and over, and over again!"
"When Armageddon comes, I want to be in a bunker made of that man's face!"
- The volleyball based sequel has this gem:
- Laser-Guided Karma: In "Bad Karma".
- Last Words: "Most Awkward Death Scene of All Time" has Stephen deliver several of these without actually dying.
- The "Famous Last Words" sketches.
- Lazy Husband: The entire premise of "Lazy Man vs Soda," as while partaking in a late night snack, Matt would rather attempt several ridiculous schemes and ultimately text and awaken a sleeping Mallory than simply get up from his recliner to grab the soda he left on the table three feet away from him.
- Least Rhymable Word: The Running Gag for Most Epic Rap Battle Ever
- Leaning on the Fourth Wall: In "Thanksgiving Gone Wrong," Whitney plays a nagging girlfriend to a clueless Adam while everyone is listing off what they are thankful for prompting Stephen to remark...
- Stephen: I'm thankfully I'm not Adam.
(a raging Whitney immediately turn her fury away from Adam)
Whitney: OH DON'T SPEAK TO QUICKLY STEPHEN!!!
(cue both Whitney and Stephen visibly fighting off smirking)
- During "Career Placement Exams" while taking his titular exam, one of the choices Matt gets is "Sketch Comedian."
- Likewise Whitney receive the choice of "Librarian."
- Let's Duet: Tori and Adam attempt one in "Love Duet", too bad Adam can't sing.
- Lights Off, Somebody Dies: Parodied in one sketch. Jason finds out that the lights go off when lightning strikes nearby. He tries killing party guests when he hears thunder, but the others always see him do it.
- Literal Genie: Variation with Captain Literally: you don't wish for something, you merely make a remark using "literally" and Captain Literally makes it true.
- Literal-Minded: See above on Captain Literally
- Also in "Thesis Defense"
- Long List: Matt lists all the Disney characters whose parents are gone in "Disney Plans Hero's Death"
- Love at First Sight: "Love From Afar" points out the issues with this, except for Mal who still is attracted to Jason even after learning he's holding up the kiosk for money.
Mallory: (to Jeremy) Mom wants you to call her!
- Mal and Jeremy initially believe this when they both are ninja turtles, then horrified when the masks come off and realize they're brother and sister. (This was the Cold Open sketch for the show's very first episode.)
- Tori and Adam in "Love Duet". Too bad it wasn't love at first note either.
- The Mafia: "Message from Above"
- Mama Bear: Mallory in "Shooting Booth,".
- Man of a Thousand Faces: Jason takes on several of these including Darth Sidious, the Joker, Bane, Snape, Dobby, Gollum, Gandalf and The Grinch.
- Matt has a few faces of his own, most frequently Voldemort and Mr. Ecklestone.
- The Men in Black: The Shoulder Angel has a bit of trouble getting to the President...
- Metaphorically True: When Matt mentions his and Whitney's dog was stolen to Adam in "Cheer Up Mix Up."
- Mexican Standoff: "Get Up and Walk Out of Here" has the entire cast in a ring, each pointing a gun at the next.
- Mickey Mousing: Lazy Man vs. Soda is done in this style, in live action.
- The Millstone: Played for laughs in Stranded on a Deserted Island with Mark Robernote . All of his inventions would be very genius in most other contexts, but in this case simply sabotage their efforts to survive and/or escape the island.
- Mistaken Identity: No it wasn't "Charlie Chaplin," that Jeremy saved during WWII in Berlin...
- The Missionary: Not explicitly stated, but it's pretty obvious that they're supposed to be LDS missionaries in "Message from Above"
- Mister Seahorse: "The Hard Life of a Male Seahorse"
- James in "The Game of Life: IRL," after landing on a baby space.
- Mix and Match: Many of the sketches can be described as such.
- "Bollyside" is ''West Side Story type dancing meeting Bollywood dancing.
- "Candy Land Character Conference" is CandyLand meeting the childhood obesity problem in an attempt to make a Dolled-Up Installment.
- "Sidious Says So" is Darth Sidious as a roommate.
- "Going Green" is about what the Amish can do to reduce their carbon footprint.
- "State of Mind" takes Everything Is Big in Texas and makes it about Rhode Island.
- "The Truth About Running" turns running into a dangerous activity like drugs and alcoholism.
- "The Game of Life: IRL," is the classic board game meets Jumanji.
- "The True Story of Lewis and Clark," sees Lewis and Clark, their guide Sacagawea, and two previously unknown members of the expedition, a short barefoot fellow bearing a mysterious ring and a hunched over hairless man with a breathing condition, on the journey to the Pacific Ocean.
- Gandalf the Grey and Harry Potter suffer a sequence of mistaken identities when they meet by chance.
- Moment Killer: Stephen and Whitney hire Matt to intentionally be this in "Third Wheel Friend."
- Mal in "Aww Yeah!" continues to screw up Whitney and Stephen's date.
- Later the "Aww Yeah!"girl returns, ruining Matt and Natalie's moment in the house of mirrors.
- Mona Lisa Smile: It turns out that Lisa was just really bad at posing, so the famous smile was the best DaVinci could get out of her.
- Mood Whiplash: The "Accountant Tax Party" sketch shows an incredibly boring party at a tax prep firm to celebrate the end of tax season. Then they clear the room for their fight club.
Matt: What is the first thing you take care of after a car crash?
- The boys are all hanging out backstage before the show begins, listening to Matt read off Laffy-Taffy jokes. What starts out as fun soon turns disturbing as Stephen continually gets more and more aggressive as he keeps getting the punchlines wrong only for...
Stephen: THE WITNESSES!!!!
(everyone stares horrified at Stephen)
Stephen: (awkwardly) I'm going to go get some fresh air...
(the others sit in uncomfortable silence as he leaves)
Matt: (checking the answer) Oh, he was right actually.
- Murphy's Bullet: In Shooting Booth, a ditzy girl manages to hit Matt in the same spot on his hand three times with a BB gun. Subverted, as it is strongly implied that she did it on purpose to get back at Matt for scamming her son.
- Not a bullet, but the basic principle is applied with Scott Sterling. No matter what he does, the soccer ball will hit him in the face.
- My Beloved Smother: Whitney to Jeremy in "A Mother's Overbearing Love," in that she isn't just his Mother but also his Therapist, and can't keep her personal feelings out of their professional sessions.
- Nations as People: in "International Relations"
- It continues in "National Relations: Republicans vs. Democrats," where the Democrat and Republican parties are America's parents.
- No Good Deed Goes Unpunished: During "Our Wedding," after an old beggar woman crashes Adam and Natalie's wedding, begging for a handout, Adam reveals he has no money, and Natalie kindly offers her an orchid from her bouquet. The beggar woman takes offense at this, revealing herself as an evil sorceress who raises some hell.
- No Party Like a Donner Party: In "Lost Plane Crash," Matt immediately suggests cannibalism upon the pilot's "demise."
- After his invention's end up making their life on the island harder, Jason declares to the other survivors they should "Donner Party" NASA Mechanical engineer Mark Rober.
- No Sense of Personal Space: Ann Withers. And commonly, Jason.
- Jason has admitted on his vlog that he regularly invades Matt's personal space in an attempt to get him to break character.
- No Social Skills: Matt in the "Awkward Avoidance Viking" shorts.
- Also everyone featured in "The Center for People that YouTube Made Infamous"
- And the "Flirting Academy" skits
- Jason in "Mafia"
- Not in Front of the Kid: The point of "Protecting the Innocent"
- Not Using the "Z" Word: The The Walking Dead parody sketch "Zombies Attack" involves several characters explaining the various synonyms and euphemisms they use to avoid the word 'zombie'.
- Not What It Looks Like: Used as a Running Gag on New CW Series: The Valley
- Obfuscating Disability: In "New Year's Resolution", Mallory discovers Matt has stolen a wheelchair. When she tries to report this to a police officer, Matt pretends that it's his, when in fact his legs are perfectly functional.
- Obviously Evil: In Evil Asides.
- Obvious Pregnancy: Lady Shadow and the women from "Mother Power"
- Averted in "Matt Center," when Matt mistakenly assumes Natalie is carrying, she's not. Ironically Natalie was pregnant IRL.
- Odd Friendship: Matt and Stephen in "Reunion Robbery," as it appears that back in highs school Matt was one of the popular kids, while Stephen's own sister can't remember who he was?
- Oedipus Complex: Accidentally invoked in "Man on a Ledge", where the mother (played by Whitney) tells the titular Man (played by Matt) that she pretended to be the female high school pen pal he ended up falling in love with, much to his embarrassment.Mother: [talking through an electric megaphone this entire time] Remember your pen pal in high school, Kelly?Matt: [in a "What about her?" voice] Yeah?Mother: That was me.Matt: WHAT?!Mother: I wanted to make you feel good about yourself, I mean, you didn't have any friends, like, at all.Matt: Mom, please don't—Mother: And then, when you told "Kelly" [making an air quote with her free left hand] that you loved her, I knew that I had to stop writing you, 'cause it was pretty weird [Matt says, "Please", but she keeps on going], but I talked to a therapist, and he told me that it's perfectly normal for a son to feel that way about his mother, you know?Matt: Mom, please, stop talking!
- Offscreen Moment of Awesome: Well, More like offscreen moment of painful yet hilarious, in the skit Romeo Impresses Juliet. While attempting to gain Juliets (Natalie) attention Romeo (Jason), inadvertently strikes Lord Capulet (Matt) with a fairly hefty sized rock leads to an absurdly long line of painful and humiliating events that he endures. None of which is ever shown on screen, yet Capulets screams and observations, tied alongside Romeos reactions to viewing the travesties, lead the audience to know it aint good fortune that Lord Capulet had been blessed with.
- Jason and Natalie are viewers to their daughter's very bizarre play, that is never seen on screen.
- Oh, Crap!: Tori, while attempting to have a classic "Love Duet," with Adam has this reaction when she discovers, he can't sing a note.
- The Oner: Exploring Backstage.
- Jason attempts creating a viral proposal through this method, but things keep going wrong.
- "Best Book for 24 Hours of Productivity" is one long continuous shot of a passed out James sleeping for a little over 15 minutes while Stephen does various task and chores in the background.
- One Dialogue, Two Conversations: "Message from Above"
- Only Sane Man: Matt usually plays the Straight Man to everyone else's wacky shenanigans.
- In "Who Wants to Be a Millionaire," everyone is trying to convince Matt that George Washington was the 26th President.
- Also, Matt is the only one who recognizes slang in a Spelling Bee as being ridiculous in "Spelling Bee"
- Whitney in I Call Shotgun.
- Whitney, again, in "Zombies Attack."Mallory: "We figured we'd try our luck in here with the livin'... instead of out there... with Orcs.
Whitney: ORCS! Sure, let's just cross genres willy-nilly, shall we?!
- In "Lost Plane Crash," Jeremy seems to be the only one who can see that their plane has gone down within spitting distance of civilization; everyone else is convinced they're stranded in the middle of nowhere.
- In "Trip to the ER", Matt's arm has been cut off. He's apparently the only one who thinks that getting medical attention is a high priority. Mallory (who is driving them to the ER) waits for ducks crossing the road, and Jason suggests stopping for fast food.
- Matt is the only one who knows what insulin is in "Diabetes Intervention." Not even the 911 operator knows.
- Their spoof of The Great British Bake Off has Jason (as Paul) taking a rare turn as the only sane man, objecting with seething rage as contestants bring him increasingly-preposterous dishes. Mary, however, is delighted with them.
- The Riddlernote , of all people, in "I'm Batman".
- Jason in James Austen initially finds the overly posh Matt and Mallory to be off putting, yet half-heartedly plays along to amuse Whitney, that is until Matt and Mallory insult his relationship with Whitney. After taking on Matt in a battle of Victorian mannerisms he quickly plummets back to normalcy, and the addition of fear, when Matt challenges him to a duel, with pistols... That are REAL!
- Mallory towards Matt in "New Year's Resolutions."
- Jason in "Uncomfortable Christmas Family Traditions".
- Overly Long Gag: Some of the sketches can come off as this, such as "A Star Trek Cliff Hanger", and "Death Bed Repentance"
- Paper-Thin Disguise: Jeremy is not playing a doctor in "Death bed repentance", he's also not a taco vendor
- Potty Emergency: The Holding Back sketch.
- Power Walk: While everyone is trying to do this in "Michael Bay's Slow Motion Epic Fail," James keeps messing it up with a Silly Walk
- Properly Paranoid: In "Thesis Defense", a man takes defending his thesis too far, dressing in armor and putting himself between the committee and his paper. He winds up fighting a duel with the last remaining committee member. And then the guy who lived poisons him, showing that his fear for his thesis was genuine.
- Real After All: Mallory's "Fake Boyfriend," ends up being both real and "Batman," who she must keep secret from Whitney and Natalie.Mallory: Can I tell people who you are yet?
Batman: Not until Gotham is free!!!
- In "Great British Baking" turns out contestant James "invisible tart" really was filled with raspberries.
- Reality Ensues: Miss Frizzle ends up getting fired by the school board after her field trips leave many of her students both emotionally and physically traumatized.
Della: You couldn't leave a note saying, don't cut off all your hair and completely trash your beauty in a misogynistic society where long hair and good cooking are the only things you're good for!
- Studio C's take on "The Gift of the Magi" fully points out the real world ramifications that a woman selling her hair in the late 19th century would have.
- The Evil Queen's Mirror points out that as good as she looks, she's over a thousand years older than teenaged Snow White, and has no chance of remaining "The Fairest of them All," after the effects of aging and gravity, and should just accept she looks incredibly well for her age.
- Revenge: Mallory gets her's on Matt in "Lazy Man vs. Soda" after being awoken from a sound sleep in the middle of the night to hand her husband the soda he left on a table three feet away. She does so after vigorously shaking the can, building up the carbonation, leaving a puzzled Matt stymied as to weather open it or not.
Adam: Sweet satisfaction!
- "Sam Sloan," ends with Adam finally subjecting Jason to a Spit Take.
- "Matt's Revenge" is Matt and the rest of the cast getting their revenge on Jason after he looses a bet that the Hunger Games parodies would reach one million views before Scott Sterling, as Jason is stuck in a goal while the other 9 pelt him with soccer balls.
- Rouge Angles of Satin: In "A Creepy Ghost Writer", Whitney is initially terrified when a spirit begins writing messages in her fogged-over bathroom mirror... but then starts correcting its spelling and grammar.
- The Scrooge: Hating Christmas is seen as a dealbreaker. Interestingly, loving Christmas is also a deal breaker.
- Serial Escalation: "Two Guys On A Scooter". Two guys go to the grocery store on their scooter and end up giving a ride to their friend, his grandpa, a guy escaping an exploding country club, a guy and a girl with a tandem bike, a mannequin (for no apparent reason), a hitchhiker, a homeless guy with his dog, and a police officer. All at once."Four guys on a scooter! With Grandpa!!""Five guys on a scooter! WITH EXPLOSIONS!!!""Seven guys on a scooter! One of them's a girl!""Ten guys on a scooter! Homeless dog! That's my favorite!"
- In "Exploring Backstage," James attempt at giving the audience a tour of Studio C's backstage is instead a look into the escalating chaos of the current events.
- Sesquipedalian Loquaciousness: Usually Matt
- Though in "Presidential Fail" everyone but Matt has this.
- Ship Tease: The fans ship Matt and Mallory hard. Studio C directly acknowledged Mattory with a promotional video titled "Matt + Mallory = Mattory". They also created a playlist of Mattory moments.
- The season 7 opener "Jeremy Isn't Real" mentioned the Mattory phenomenon by name, but turned it on its head by revealing that the role of Mallory has been played by Jason this whole time.
- The "Harry Potter and the Mirror of Erised" sketch has single-handedly doubled the amount of Mattory smooching on the Studio C channel. In the comments, Matt Meese revealed that they had to reshoot a lot of it because they forgot Harry's glasses. The fans, of course, believe that was just a convenient excuse for him to kiss Mallory more.
- In their top 10 list of Romantic Moments, "Naturally" took the top spot with Studio C choosing it specifically for being the start of the "Mattory" phenomenon.
- While not as highlighted as "Mattory," or real life couple Stephen+Whitney, due to Natalie being married and having two kids, thus making it rather inappropriate, the show tends to pair Adam and Natalie together in sketches more often than others, plus their is something of a Running Gag that Adam has an obsessive crush on her.
- Natalie and Stacey's YouTube channel has a video where the cast lip syncs to Hamilton.
- Along with the usual pop-culture phenomenon's (Star Wars, Harry Potter, The Lord of the Rings and so on) the cast, particularly Matt and Whitney, has demonstrated their love for Downton Abbey.
- The hallway used in the Saved by the Bell parody is an exact replica of the iconic hallway set from the show itself.
- Jason seems to shout "HADOUKEN!" while breaking a painting in "The Worst Blackmail Imaginable".
- "A Show About Babies" is an infant version of Seinfeld, with some pretty darn good impressions, especially Jason as Kramer.
- Slap-Slap-Kiss: "Naturally" features a battle of wills between Matt and Mal, as each tries to out do each other in how healthy their organic lifestyles are, progressively getting angrier and angrier before the two end up vigorously making out, to an onlooker Whitney's disgust.Whitney: This is why I never shop at Whole Foods.
Ava: (after slapping Oswold across the face) It just seemed like with all the bickering and getting into each other's personal space it seemed like the next step.
- Likewise Jason and Whitney point out the real downfalls of this trope in "The Classic Movie Slap," as Jason (Mr. Oswald) is constantly slapped across the face by Whitney (Ava) who thinks of it as subtle flirting in the midst of the Belligerent Sexual Tension she shares with her boss. Oswold disagrees.
Oswald: That doesn't make any sense!?!
Ava: It does to millions of movie going young women.
- Sniff Sniff Nom: In "Couchville", Matt is digging around under his couch cushions and gets his fingers coated in an unknown pinkish substance. He reacts with disgust after taking a sniff and a tentative lick, but finding nowhere to wipe off his hand, he sticks his fingers in his mouth and slurps it.
- Sophisticated as Hell: In "Clue Murder Mystery Scandal":Matt: (sinister chuckle) Very good, inspector. Very good, indeed. So you've uncovered the fact that I've been embezzling millions of pounds from my business partner, Lord Branston.Lord Branston: What what? How could you do this to me?Matt: The poor fool had no idea until this night. I must confess that though I've been discovered, it brings me no small amount of joy that he now knows that it was me all along. (laugh)Policeman: Um, I didn't know any of that.Matt: You didn't?Policeman: No, I wasn't going to say that at all.Matt: Ah, well... dang it.
- So Beautiful, It's a Curse: Adam's school photo comes out so well, Matt and Mallory are forced to intervene and nerd/ugly/awkward him up to prevent a world catastrophe.
- Spammer: Variations discussed in the "Facebook Friends Song."
- James likes all of his friends tweets, even the tweet of Stephen being arrested in "Police respond to a Tweet."
- Speaking Simlish: A rare live action version of this trope in "Google Translator"
- Spirit Advisor: Jeremy to Adam in "Poker Face 2: All In."
- Spit Take: Adam gets nearly a dozen of these in his face in "Dana's Dead." And it is awesome.
- Spotlight-Stealing Squad: The other 9, actually 8, actually 7, cast members realized that Matt, as co-creator and lead writer of the show, would be this, thus they created Jeremy, so they could all get more sketches and screen time.
- Stage Magician: There's not even a stage: it's all just done over the phone in "Phone Magician." Stephen is less than impressed.
- Stay in the Kitchen: From "Zombie Attacks".Jason: Are you ladies done being girls, or are you gonna continue playin' dress-up in your (With awkward emphasis) MMMMMINI-Skirts?!Whitney: WHY?! Did that sentence. HAPPEN?!
Jason: I'm sorry, I don't understand every little thing there is to know about baking, okay? It's so stinkin' complicated!Mallory: This is why men are supposed to stay in the garage.Jason: Oh, that is it! I am sleeping on the couch tonight!
- Gender Inversion in Cupcake Wars Interrupted by Jealous Husband
- Strike Me Down with All of Your Hatred: Any sketch with Jason as Emperor Palpatine will inevitably involve this.
- In one episode, Palpatine, desperate to convert someone to the dark side, asks Matt to strike him down with a ''milk jug.'
- Subverted Kids Show: The Crayon Song.
- Switched at Birth: In "I'm Adopted?", Stacey finds out this happened to him. He thought he was adopted, given that his parents are played by Matt and Mallory. His real parents turn out to be... Asian?
- Take That!: Not fans of Twilight.
- The Man on a ledge sketch, where the reason everyone's acting as if the man played by Matt is about to jump off a building isn't because he's sitting on a ledge, but because he's about to eat an Arby's melt.
- This exchange in Photoshop Instructor Crosses The Line:Student: Okay, if the (photoshop) degrees not real, why are you qualified to teach us.Teacher Im the person who photoshops the Arbys sandwich to look edible.Student: Woah, he might be overqualified.
- "My Dad Could Beat Up Your Dad" has a jab at Comcast. In response to the playground threat that "my dad could beat up your dad," Matt starts actually making the arrangements for his terrifying-sounding father to fight James and Stacey's dads:James: My dad works at Comcast.Matt: I see. Then my father will REALLY enjoy this.
- Céline Dion is regarded as a huge attention *** of a diva who literally can't control her urge to hog the spotlight.
- Even the man who intially saved JarJar Binks after his hatred in the Star Wars films admits he killed him out of pure annoyance two hours later.
- In The Worst Blackmail Ever, the presidential candidate says who cares if a picture shows he "Prefers Kidz Bop to the real songs", only to Double Take and agree that it should be destroyed.
- Third Wheel: Mallory is this to Whitney and James in "Third Wheel Song."
- Whitney and Stephen hire Matt to be this in "Third Wheel Friend."
- Time Skip: The main plot of the aforementioned Saved by the Bell parody (see Shout-Out to find the link to watch it): Stacey and Adam play two zany characters whose goofy antics bring each "episode" of the show to a close; this is then followed by the beginning of a new "episode", where time has passed, and the other three characters (played by Mallory, James, and Natalie) all notice this, with each beginning featuring a more shocking twist. It turns out that it was All Just a Dream from Mallory's character, and that the other four characters are dead, something she says to be "normal".
- Token Minority: Stacey (the black guy) and Jeremy (the Ambiguously Brown guy). The group takes advantage of their skin colors as much as possible. Jeremy has played characters that were Hispanic, Native American, and Indian. Stacey has played every black character in a spoof, even if they are female, such as Calpurnia or Rue.
- They're not afraid to point out a cast member's status as a minority, either. The sketch "She Loves You, Bro!" has this gem:Stephen: Dude, Adam, chocolate represents the highest form of attraction.Stacey: Highest, mm-hmm.Stephen: I mean, why do you think girls love Valentine's Day...Stacey: Mm-hmm.Stephen: ...Nutella...Stacey: Oh, yeah.Stephen: (points to Stacey) ...and this guy?Stacey: Oh, they love me.
- In "I'm Adopted?", Matt and Mallory play Stacey's parents. When they sit down to tell him about his true parentage, he thinks he already knows what they're going to say. Turns out he wasn't adopted, but was Switched at Birth and the parents were too stupid to notice. Oh, and his real parents are... Asian?
- They're not afraid to point out a cast member's status as a minority, either. The sketch "She Loves You, Bro!" has this gem:
- Top Ten List: Each member of the cast (excluding Aaron, Dalton and Tori, who joined the cast later) has a top 10 list of their favorite sketches: Adam, James, Jason, Jeremy, Mallory, Matt, Natalie, Stacey, Stephen, Whitney.
- Too Dumb to Live: Everyone in the "The Smiths" sketch, which tells the tale of a man who loses the family farm to his probably adopted evil brother Barnabie by willingly signing away the deed to it for no clear reason. Why does Barnabie want the farm? to grow prescription meds, of course! Barnabie then loses the farm when he throws the deed at Mr.Smith as part of his Evil Gloating. Sketch also includes this:[After having failed to poison everyone due to the poison melting the cups]Barnabie: Time for Plan BMr. Smith: What did you say?!Barnabie: I said....Time for plan CMr. Smith: [Reassured] Oh, okay.
- Took a Level in Badass: Matt in "Poker Face 2", having spent a year studying poker after his Uno-based defeat in "Poker Face 1" and become quite the statistician, though not the best bluffer.
- Trailers Always Spoil: The whole point of "Movie Trailer That Spoils Everything"
- Troll: Adam to Matt in "Cheer-Up Mix-Up".
- Twisted Echo Cut: "Channel Surfing"
- Twist Ending: "What Is Real," ends with the revelation that Whitney and Jason are just dolls that a demented Natalie is playing with.
- "Just Like you Left It", not only was Tori present in all of Mallory's memories Mal's candy coated memories are fake.
- Two Girls to a Team: The reasoning behind Jason masquerading as Mallory in "Jeremy Isn't Real," to offset the boy to girl ratio in the cast.Jason: (to Matt) I'm so sorry, but we only have two girls on the show!
- Ultimate Job Security: What most of the characters in the ongoing "Worst (Insert Occupation Here) Ever" series seem to have. Two standout examples are Matt's doctor character in "Worst Doctor Ever", who does things like telling the interns that one of them could take home the knife that is sticking out of the side of a dead stabbing victimnote , and has a staring contest with a man that he doesn't realize is dead; and Whitney in "Worst Lawyer Ever", who somehow keeps getting hired after failing her bar exam for five straight years, not knowing what legal precedence or "leading the witness" means (she keeps crying out "Objection!" for it in court)note , and believing that the defendant she's counseling (played by Natalie) is guilty of the crime she's accused of.
- Aaron's mechanic character takes the cake, though. He knows nothing about cars, first of all. He loses a customer's car, and tries to offer her another customer's car. He also grills burgers atop a running engine, realizes he's claustrophobic while working under a car, and worst of all, HE FLUSHES USED MOTOR OIL DOWN THE TOILET!
- Under the Mistletoe: Harry Potter attempts to set this up with Cho, but instead gets Dolores Umbridge, Professor McGonagall, and a dementor in "Harry Potter Accidentally Kisses Professor McGonagall". (Of course, Harry and McGonagall are played by Matt and Mallory, respectively.)
- Unfortunate Implications: In-universe in "Chess Prodigy," when a University PhD candidate adult (Adam) takes on a six year old girl (Mallory) in the chess finals, due to the adorableness the little girl demonstrates commentators Jeremy and Matt's biased opinions openly attack every move Adam makes against her in the game, painting him to be a bully in their descriptions.
- Unfortunate Names:
- Agnes, who everyone assumes likes cats and crochets.
- Master Smelly, who is reknowned for his "silent but deadly tactics."
- Unsettling Gender Reveal: "Jeremy Isn't Real" not only reveals that the role of Jeremy is actually played by other members of the cast, but that Mallory isn't real, either, and is played by Jason. Matt is not happy to discover this, having kissed Mallory in several past sketches.
- The Unsmile: There's a reason the Mona Lisa looks the way she does.
- Updated Re Release: Most of the sketches are from the casts former "Divine Comedy" days, only with the addition of sets, costumes and props
- Use Your Head: The "Scott Sterling" sketches feature a hapless athlete blocking numerous soccer and volleyball shots with his face, incurring a series of Amusing Injuries in the process.
- The Vamp: Carlie in the "Dungeons and Dragons" skit, besides being an experienced player in that game, she also used her feminine charm to manipulate her cousin's friends to give her their strongest equipment
- Very Special Episode: The series's 100th episode, which premiered on November 20, 2017, breaks from the traditional format of multiple sketches, and instead, features the entire cast playing people who are on a flight to Seattle.
- Violence Is the Only Option: In "Werewolf", Matt and Stacey accidentally run into each other in an alley. Both immediate confront and threaten one another (with Stacey actually "putting up his dukes"), when it would be far more sensible to simply apologize to one another and walk away.
- Vocal Dissonance
- Matt doing the voice of Spencer, a baby with the (creepily calm) voice of a grown man.
- Natalie and Stacey's YouTube channel has a video where the cast lip syncs to Hamilton. Stacey's the only actor whose character (Aaron Burr) matches his gender. Natalie plays Alexander Hamilton, Mallory plays George Washington, and hilariously, James plays Angelica Schuyler and Matt plays Eliza Hamilton.
- Vocal Range Exceeded: "Graduation Musical Number." Whitney can sing that high. Mal can't.
- The Voiceless: Scott Sterling never says a word in any of his appearances.
- Wacky Sound Effect: Mal resorts to some of these in "Radio Mystery Hour" after an accident she caused.
- Wax On, Wax Off: Matt tricks fashion models Lucky Blue and Canyon Smith into performing manual labor for him under the guise of a photo shoot.
- Welcome to Corneria: Doc in "Mike Tyson's Punch-Out!! Parody", lampshaded.
- What Happened to the Mouse?: Parodied in "The Smiths 2". When Adam is shot by Mrs. Smith, the sketch never mentions him again. The narrator even refers to the rest as "Mr. Smith's three brothers," completely excluding him, after his death.
- Who's on First?: The "Detective Doctor" sketch runs entirely on this.
- Worst. Whatever. Ever!: Currently 10 of them.
- You Have Got to Be Kidding Me!: Said word for word by Matt in the climax of "Lady Gordon's Fainting Spells".