Follow TV Tropes

Following

Reality Ensues/Surprisingly Realistic Outcome cleanup

Go To

We don't want to clog this thread since Surprisingly Realistic Outcome is an Overdosed Trope. Before posting here, check if the example you're analyzing qualifies for summary deletion from the three criteria below by keeping this trope's rigorous definition in mind.

  1. Does the example involve Applied Phlebotinum (Functional Magic, Science Fiction, Artistic Licence) or a character reaction? If so, it instantly violates the definition's second bullet point's realism requirements, and you should delete it without question.
  2. Is the example a Discussed Trope or an instance of Conversational Troping? If so, it violates the definition's third bullet point's emphasis on only counting outcomes, and you should delete it without question.
  3. Considering the definitions, would the example qualify better for Deconstructed Trope or Deconstructed Character Archetype from the trope page's rules? If so, move it to the appropriate one on the spot.

If the example survived all three tests, it satisfies the second and third bullet points, so you don't need to change it immediately. If you feel like it meets the first bullet point's requirements for being surprising, you can leave it. However, if you believe it doesn't meet the first bullet point or aren't sure, talk it over in the cleanup thread before deciding.

Many Stock Phrases you'll see used in this thread describe a particular type of misuse:

  • Not surprising. — The outcome described isn't a Bait-and-Switch and merely follows expected genre conventions.
  • Plot happens. — The example merely describes an event or series of events but not why we would expect something different.
  • Too fantastical. — The causes/outcome described included the presence of stuff Impossible in Real Life such as Applied Phlebotinum, Functional Magic, or Science Fiction, meaning they're too unrealistic by default.
  • No character reactions. — The outcome involves a character reacting in a certain way or having certain emotions, which we can't gauge the realism of because people's emotional reactions vary far too much.
  • Not realistic.Exactly What It Says on the Tin, but this one requires you to write a short description for why it isn't realistic.
  • Too implausible. — The outcome describes an outcome that happened because of things too unlikely to count as relatively realistic compared to what they were subverting.
  • Cuttable ZCE.Exactly What It Says on the Tin.
  • Not an outcome. — The example is either a Discussed Trope, Lampshade Hanging, Conversational Troping, or happens over too much time to be momentary.
  • Too unclear. — The example is too convoluted or obtuse to judge.
  • Irrelevant. — The example describes stuff utterly irrelevant to the definition of SRO.
  • Bad indentation.Exactly What It Says on the Tin.

    Old OP 
I've been noticing a lot of Surprisingly Realistic Outcome misuse lately, from instances of Gameplay and Story Segregation to Awesome, but Impractical, and I thought a cleanup thread could help out a little.

A big thing I've noticed is that it's often used for anything remotely realistic, or something that's realistic but doesn't necessarily affect the story. Another problem is that the trope seems to be cherry-picked, where any instance of reality ensuing is put there, as well as when another trope could serve the example better.

Problematic examples from one sample page, SurprisinglyRealisticOutcome.Disney Animated Series:

"Despite his attempts Wander can't make friends with Dominator who constantly rebuffs his friendly gestures throughout season 2. Even at the end of everything, she still refuses. Sylvia even lampshades it, telling him some people are just like that."

"Spider-Man's fight against Sandman and Rhino, where Spidey uses Rhino's weight against him. rather than fighting him directly."

"Beshte gets sunburns all over his body and is easily exhausted while he is lost in the Outlands. Justified due to the fact that hippos need water to survive to avoid sunburn and overheating."

"It's heavily implied that being the leader of the Lion Guard has taken a toll on Kion's social and private life."

"Milo Murphy's Law is about a boy named Milo Murphy whose entire life is centered around Murphy's Law. In another cartoon, being The Jinx would cause people to be afraid of them, resulting in an unsocial lifestyle. That does not apply here. While everyone does watch their step around Milo, they do not hate him for it. Being The Jinx does, however, give everyone Paranoia Fuel, given that Murphy's Law can happen at any time, so chances are you might need insurance, a phone in case of emergencies, among other things. Milo himself (as well as his friends Melissa and Zack) just learned to adapt to his condition, being prepared for anything. He has lived with Murphy's Law his entire life after all. That being said, that does not mean that they don't panic all the time. Examples include Milo panicking over his monthly doctor's note, and Melissa panicking over riding a rollercoaster with Milo."

" Hiro is initially not allowed to use Tadashi's former lab, as it can only be accessed by upperclassmen who earned the privilege. Subverted in the second half of the pilot when Professor Granville decides Hiro using the lab would benefit him. On a related note regarding Granville, she is tough, but fair when interacting with the students. She might be, as Wasabi describes "a hard case", but Granville being a complete sadist and picking on Hiro would be unrealistic. She is actually a decent person."

-Edited with permission from the OP-

Edited by lalalei2001 on Aug 10th 2022 at 5:47:25 AM

CelestialDraco from Florissant, Missouri Since: Jan, 2014 Relationship Status: Singularity
#2001: Mar 28th 2023 at 9:53:45 AM

  • Zambot 3: Kids being pilots of a Humongous Mecha can actually be psychologically straining, and immaturity can lead to deaths. Also, cities do not get magically repaired after getting smashed down during a battle between giant robots, and often the cast has to fight on the ruins of a city destroyed in an earlier battle. Super Robot Deconstruction
  • Zoids: Chaotic Century:
    • When Van steals his Shield Liger back when it was confiscated by the Republic, he tries to use its missile launchers only find there is no ammo. As Irvine points out, confiscated Zoids have their weapons disarmed. Zoids and the Republic aren't real so we don't know what the protocols would actually be.
    • The Geno Saurer has to anchor itself to fire its Charged Particle Cannon due to the recoil. Van realizes this weakness in his fight with Raven at the end of the first season, and when Raven tries to turn the Geno Saurer to aim at Van, the recoil damages his Zoid. Too fantastical. Geno Saurer isn't real.
    • After Rudolph is kidnapped by Rosso and Viola, he makes an attempt at escaping. Rosso doesn't even make much effort to stop the boy as he runs away. He just walks after Rudolph and lets him realize that if he were to escape his captors, he would leave himself stranded in the middle of nowhere with almost no chance of rescue. Not an outcome
    • The main characters want to avoid getting involved with the Republic or the Empire. In fact the military of the Republic is initially hostile to them, though this fades after they assist in stopping a battle with the Empire. Character reaction
    • The Guylos Empire is called The Empire but that doesn't mean it's evil. Beyond Prozen and his followers, the characters from the Empire are good people just like in the Republic. Subversion of The Empire
  • Zombie Land Saga:
    • After succeeding in their first two shows purely by Kotaro and a few of the girls' improvisation, the girls try to crunch in as much practice as they can for their first proper idol performance in Episode 3. The results are that Lily accidentally trips over herself and Sakura completely forgets her lines in the middle of the song, causing the few people they managed to attract to disperse without a second glance. Although the highly experienced Ai and Junko step in and the rest of the show goes off without a hitch, the concert is largely a failure and only manages to attract a single fan, albeit a very invested one, in the end. Plot happens
    • In Episode 6, Ai's flashback shows her getting struck by lightning when she points to the sky, which is also Truth in Television, as pointing up in the middle of a lightning storm is considered to be very dangerous. Not realistic
    • In Episode 7 shows that while as zombies that girls don't physically need sleep, it's still important for their mental health as Ai starts to hallucinate after going a month without it. Too fantastical
    • In Episode 8, the girls acknowledge that people will recognize the similarities each girl has to who they were prior to becoming zombies, after meeting with Lily's father who says that Number 6 bears a resemblance to his daughter. By first season's end, the reporters who were covering the group likewise notice the similarities between Ai, Junko, and Lily's past and present selves. This continues in the second season in which people do comment on the fact Ai resembles herself. Not an outcome
    • Saki died due to her reckless riding, which is mentioned early on and shown in a flashback in Episode 9. Even if you are a badass biker gang captain, riding too fast is dangerous. Valid
    • In Season 2 Episode 1, Kotaro is left in a depressed state and just spends his time drinking somewhere else. The girls have to earn money to pay the huge debt incurred after their failed concert in the Ekimae Real Estate Stadium. But it turns out they can't replicate Kotaro's proper make-up skills, and as a result, they still look very pale and their Creepy Shadowed Undereyes are still visible in public. Without a producer, they also find it hard to resume their idol activities. Plot happpens
    • Also, Kotaro breaking out of his funk to support Franchouchou by shouting "Encore!" only results in him pissing off the unimpressed audience and starting a brawl. Even as the girls find their confidence and pull off their song perfectly, the concert was largely a failure. Character reaction
    • In Episode 4 of Revenge, Franchouchou put on an incredible performance as Iron Frill's opening act, winning the respect of their lead singer Shiori. Despite this they're easily outshined by Iron Frill, the group the audience were actually there to see, and until Shiori declares Franchouchou their rivals in an interview their performance is considered little more than a footnote to the number one idol group's tour. Plot happens

Dramatic Since: Jun, 2012
#2002: Mar 28th 2023 at 6:16:39 PM

From Licence to Kill:

  • Surprisingly Realistic Outcome:
    • Krest essentially ends up having to be the unfortunate mook who has to explain to his unimpressed boss exactly what happened when James Bond performed one of his awesome-but-completely-unbelievable stunts that completely fouls up the Big Bad's operations. This ends for him as you'd expect it to — namely, in his unpleasant death.
Not even remotely surprising. You Have Failed Me is not only an extremely common trope, but the Bond series is famous for frequently playing it straight.
  • Krest's death pulls no punches in exactly both exactly how gruesome and vicious a death by explosive decompression can be (it's interesting to compare this with Kananga's death in Live and Let Die) and what kind of vicious psycho would do such a thing (and thus become the type of villain James Bond opposes to begin with). Notably, even Bond himself is kind of freaked out by it.
This film has already established itself as being Darker and Edgier, so I don't think the gore here being played more realistically is surprising. I think the nod to Live and Let Die is a valid one though, and could probably be reworded as a Bloodier and Gorier entry.
  • Fearful that this might attract the attention of his bosses, M revokes Bond's licence to kill after admonishing Bond for his Roaring Rampage of Revenge against Franz Sanchez, who attacked Felix Leiter in retaliation for having him arrested for narcotics smuggling.
Plot happens.
  • Truman-Lodge's angry ranting also showcases the fact that, yeah, all of that crap Bond blows up is expensive and very hard to bounce back from in a financial way. Same as Krest, he has the bad luck of pointing this out to his boss at a very bad time...
Bond villains of the 'evil organisation overlord' kind have always been shown to have strong financial backing, so I don't think that this counts as surprising. I don't think "now I'm broke" is the main thing that needs to be said out loud when they're defeated and/or killed

Tabs Since: Jan, 2001
#2003: Mar 29th 2023 at 6:57:28 AM

[up], [up][up] Those analyses look good to me.

Jobyrdthegamerbyrd Since: Aug, 2017
#2004: Mar 31st 2023 at 9:17:29 AM

Wanted to add this example from Amphibia:

  • Amphibia: In the episode "Hopluck", the Planters and Anne make a dish that the mayor claims to be the best dish they’ve ever brought to the yearly potluck. Sprig thinks that means they actually won until the Mayor corrects them and says they didn’t. It’s the same gross recipe they use every year but with a tomato slice on top, so while it’s better than usual, it’s still terrible and comes in last place.

I feel it fits cause it seems to play up them actually having a victory before subverting it with a more realistic outcome

Edited by Jobyrdthegamerbyrd on Mar 31st 2023 at 9:19:59 AM

CelestialDraco from Florissant, Missouri Since: Jan, 2014 Relationship Status: Singularity
#2005: Mar 31st 2023 at 12:49:27 PM

  • She's Not So Famous: After triumphantly reclaiming her camera from Chris, Millie tries to escape back out through the vent like Annie did... but she lacks Annie's height and upper body strength, so she can't jump up there by herself and gets accosted by security. Valid

Someoneman Since: Nov, 2011
#2006: Mar 31st 2023 at 1:11:59 PM

[up][up] That might just be a normal Bait-and-Switch or Exact Words. Taste is subjective, and the show is about frogs who have different tastes than humans, so it's hard to objectively say that it's a realistic outcome.

Jobyrdthegamerbyrd Since: Aug, 2017
#2007: Mar 31st 2023 at 1:57:31 PM

Guess it's just as well. It has been stated that the Plantars lose every year so

CelestialDraco from Florissant, Missouri Since: Jan, 2014 Relationship Status: Singularity
SoyValdo7 I mainly fix indentation issues from La tierra de lagos y volcanes Since: Sep, 2022 Relationship Status: THIS CONCEPT OF 'WUV' CONFUSES AND INFURIATES US!
I mainly fix indentation issues
#2009: Mar 31st 2023 at 4:33:46 PM

I agree with you. It sounds valid.

Edited by SoyValdo7 on Mar 31st 2023 at 6:43:45 AM

Valdo
CelestialDraco from Florissant, Missouri Since: Jan, 2014 Relationship Status: Singularity
#2010: Mar 31st 2023 at 5:33:19 PM

  • Tales from the Borderlands:
    • The series really likes to point out the physical weaknesses of the protagonists Rhys and Fiona. In the first episode, Rhys tries to kill a bandit with his bare hands, only for the bandit to be amused by the attempt and later be annoyed by it. Rhys is a corporate businessman turned janitor, he's out of his element on Pandora and has had no reason to train for this sort of thing. Character untrained
    • Fiona is just as unprepared physically, as she is mainly a con-artist and scavenger. When she tries to shoot Vallory (who is incredibly strong and is effortlessly holding a missile launcher) in mid-air, Vallory simply throws the gun at her, causing Fiona to be knocked to the ground and pinned by the sheer weight of it. To further elaborate on how heavy it is, both Sasha and Fiona had to hold it, just so Fiona can have a steady aimed shot. Character physcially weak
    • In the episode "Catch a Ride" the gang is caught in a car chase. While laying on the hood, face to face with August pointing a gun at him, Rhys assumes he was going to fire and quickly rolls out of the way. Only for August to stare at him in confusion and point out how futile and naive it is to try to dodge a bullet at that distance. Not an outcome
  • Tales Series:
    • Tales of Symphonia: Dawn of the New World shows the after effects of the heroes' actions from the previous game by showing how they saved the worlds, but made many new problems by not warning either world of their intentions. Since the worlds of Sylvarant and Tethe'alla were separated with minimal contact or understanding, when the two worlds are merged together suddenly, the people of both worlds suddenly become afraid and form military groups to defend their ways of life from what they see as basically aliens. Also, while the protagonists are hailed as heroes by some, just as many despise them because their actions caused problems unaddressed in the original game; Marta's mother was killed when the Mana Tree rampaged in Palmacosta, and none of the heroes did anything to stop it nor save them, so from her perspective, she has every reason to hate Colette for her failure because she was supposed to prevent events like that. Oh, and the racism Half-Elves endured? It doesn't go away at all, instead now pushed aside to a degree by the new racism found by the two worlds merging. Character reaction
    • Tales of Berseria:
      • The game likes to shine a harsh light on the collateral damage Velvet causes. One of the biggest examples is Hellawes, where early on, Velvet has the entire port firebombed as cover for stealing a ship. Most games would go the Inferred Holocaust route or show the town bouncing back from the damage - not here. The town remains inaccessible for over half the plot because it simply doesn't have a dock big enough to moor the Van Eltia anymore. Even once the port is repaired, it's still only barely functional because sunken wrecks are blocking most of the docks, and they can't be moved from the arctic waters. The destruction of the merchant fleet cratered the town's economy to the point they're limping along on relief supplies and being lucky enough to have an older generation who have the know-how to resurrect the fishing industry. Austerity measures are in place, and the town has been all but cut loose by the Abbey for no longer having a worthwhile export. And things go From Bad to Worse late-game, when Velvet commits an act of terrorism in the sister village (as in, terrifying the population to get something from the government) causing it to be evacuated and the Abbey to declare it a no-go zone, meaning Hellawes is now flooded with refugees and cut off from its only cheap source of fuel. It's stated that if not for another upheaval waking the Emperians and undoing a decade of global cooling every settlement on the landmass would have been abandoned. Subversion of Inferred Holocaust
      • The Abbey of Innominat, and especially its leader Shepherd Artorius, practice The Needs of the Many as their absolute philosophy. It's repeatedly shown that this isn't just unsustainable, but morally abhorrent. Artorius is a sociopath with a Lack of Empathy who murders, deforms, imprisons, tortures, and exploits his own family for the "greater good" and relies on being a Villain with Good Publicity. The Abbey itself tests its new members' potential and then assigns them a permanent rank based on performance, with no hope of promotion and limited horizontal mobility - consequently, they have serious manpower issues as most people aren't fanatical enough to consider this a viable career, and those that are tend to notice how stagnant the job is and quickly develop motivation issues. People and even entire communities can be cut loose to starve or get eaten by Daemons, and they're expected to like it since it's for the greater good (but the people who are kept comfortable have a convenient blind spot to this bit of logic, and the Abbey knows it). Since all needs are accounted for, the prices for goods and licenses to trade are strictly controlled in a command economy - everyone on the ground can see how fragile this is and both price gougers and a black market are already well-established. The party frequently comments that things are only going so well because the Abbey maintains an illusion of peace, has a charismatic leader who looks like a Messianic Archetype, and has the royal family in a stranglehold, but peel back the surface and their world-spanning power structure is a house of cards that won't outlive the Shepherd. This is one of the first and most obvious signs that there's far more going on - the Abbey is aware of all this and their endgame involves brainwashing the entire planet to make this madness sustainable. Not an outcome
      • On a subtler note, Easy Communication is averted. The ability to teleport meaningful distances is extremely rare, and far-speak artes are the domain of only one or two mages like Melchior. This means the party, as distinctive as they are, have no trouble going wherever they want once they obtain some reasonably legit ID - news travels slowly, and when their reputation does precede them, the reports are an exaggerated mishmash of all the individual party members that doesn't even resemble them individually. Too fantastical
    • Tales of the Abyss:
      • What happens when you take a ten year old noble who recently lost all of his memories, motor skills, and general knowledge about the world, throw him back home and tell him he can't leave until he's almost twenty? As the game shows us with Luke, it causes them to grow up into a Jerkass with no social skills, no friends, and nobody to truly turn to. Then, when Luke gets teleported outside the city, he's completely ignorant about simple things, like buying food requiring money. Not an outcome
      • Also, being totally sheltered and ignorant about the world around him makes Luke incredibly easy to manipulate. This is exactly what Luke's sword teacher, Van, was counting on. By setting himself up as the only person Luke could trust, Van makes Luke into an Unwitting Pawn. Plot happens
      • Luke ends up killing a soldier when the Tartarus gets hijacked in the beginning of the game. And while he was acting in self-defense, he still thinks of it as murder, and ends up incredibly traumatized. He's practically catatonic in the immediate aftermath and starts shaking like crazy, when the full impact of having taken a human's life hits him. Even post-battle quotes of his when fighting human enemies is that he doesn't want to take their lives. During the last arc of the game, talking with Jade has him mention that he knows that Luke sometimes lies awake at night or wakes up in a cold sweat after they have had to fight other people. Luke completely averts the idea of It Gets Easier. Character reaction
      • Luke refusing to own up to his mistakes, even if he wasn't entirely responsible, doesn't mean his new friends will just ignore his behavior, forgive him, and be happy to talk to him. Instead, they abandon Luke in disgust for his attitude, and partly because they can't afford for him to emerge from his coma. While Luke does genuinely start trying to make up for his mistakes later in the game, and becomes much nicer and respectful, not everyone forgives Luke for what he's done. For a while, even Luke doesn't think he ought to be forgiven, no matter how much he tries. His depression and guilt briefly turns him borderline suicidal. Character reaction
    • Tales of Vesperia:
      • Out of the all the recipes, including the new ones from the Updated Re-release, Repede hates a resounding 18 out of 42. Those recipes are either sweets or include onions, both of which are toxic to dogs. Character reaction. Dogs will usually eat anything given to them.
      • Estelle being a princess is revealed early on in the game, and save Karol, all the heroes already knew. Not only did Yuri find Estelle in a castle, but her mannerisms, naive outlook on things, and her obviously sheltered life made it clear she was someone important. Plot happens
      • As skilled as Yuri is, he is still only a young adult with a few years of combat training under his belt. When he tries to duel Don Whitehorse in the Updated Re-release, Whitehorse easily overpowers Yuri and defeats him. Whitehorse might be a bit old, but he's an incredibly skilled swordsman with many years under his belt. Curbstomp Battle
      • A lot of Karol's actions before his Character Development fall into this. He's a twelve year old kid in a world with monsters and many other threats; naturally, he grows up being scared of them and being a bit of a coward. He's fighting things even grown adults would struggle with, after all. Character reaction
    • Tales of Xillia:
      • What happens when Milla loses the Four Spirits of the Elements, on whom she has relied for all sorts of things, ranging from being able to swim, fight or use magic? She can barely do things on her own. She can't swim, has no idea how to properly use her sword and can't do any proper combos during battle, until she gets a little instruction from Alvin on how to fight. Once she gets that part down, her natural ability lets her improve very fast. Not surprising
      • Alvin has repeatedly backstabbed the party, but keeps getting let back onto the team. While this mostly is allowed and shrugged off by Jude, who is rather idealistic and naive, the rest of the party keep their suspicion about Alvin. Eventually, they do allow him to return, but only because they know that he'd follow them anyway and willingly taking him in would give them the advantage of being able to keep a close eye on him. As such, he is not Easily Forgiven. The sequel proves that he is still trying to better himself, so that people can trust him again. Characcter reaction
      • Once again for Alvin, he is trying to shake Jude out of his Heroic BSoD while on the cusp of one of his own by trying to egg him on into getting angry. During this event, Alvin accidentally shoots Leia and almost kills her. Contrary to it being dropped after Leia is healed up, their interactions become extremely awkward, stilted and they try to avoid each other. Things take some time to get better between them. Character reaction
      • The shooting has another aspect of this trope to it as well. Despite being a trained marksman, Alvin was emotionally distraught at the moment and waving a loaded pistol around. It was only a matter of time before someone took a bullet. Valid
  • Tekken:
    • In one pachinko cutscene Asuka Kazama attempts to pick a fight with Kazuya Mishima. For all of Asuka's bravado, combat expertise and her ability to subdue the Devil Gene, she still is fighting a grown man far more experienced than her, who is willing to go (and just had gone) One-Winged Angel without hesitation, and who is quite clearly an active threat. She quickly realizes that she's outmatched and attempts to flee - too late to prevent herself from getting brutally curb-stomped, neck lifted and thrown off a rooftop, where she almost certainly would have been reduced to little more than a splatter on the pavement without Jin's intervention. Character weaker than another character
    • The Final Boss fight of Tekken 7 is a Duel to the Death between the above-mentioned Kazuya and his Archnemesis Dad Heihachi, who for all of his Charles Atlas Superpower is still in his twilight years. If you guessed that the younger, legitmately superpowered participant wins, then you are spot on. Anti-Climax Boss
  • Temtem is a Spiritual Successor to the Pokémon series, and plays with this by subverting the typical expectations of the average Pokémon game. When the local Nebulous Evil Organization known as the Belsoto Clan invades the island of Kisiwa, rather than the teenage player doing all the work ousting them, the player arrives to see a full-on war break out with a La Résistance filled with Child Soldiers trying to protect their families with their mons. A refugee crisis ensues, casualties mount on both sides, and when the player confronts the Belsoto's General Ripper he kills The Rival before inflicting a Hopeless Boss Battle on the player, being the far more experienced combatant. The battle is a Pyrrhic Victory for him as he's already lost the war and in the midst of retreating, but he states that if this weren't the case he'd kill the player as well. Not an outcome
  • ThanksKilling Day: In the latter half of the game, the kid can attempt to escape from the pilgrim killer by driving away on the farm's tractor. However, since he's a kid who's probably too young to be able to drive, he ends up swerving the tractor all over the cornfield and crashing it into a fence. Valid
  • In the Thief series, Garret is, well, a thief, and not equipped or trained for a stand-up fight, something the player will painfully learn if they try going One-Man Army like in so many other games. Valid
  • Trials of Mana:
    • Angela's prologue has her thrown into the aptly named Frostbite Fields wearing nothing but a highly Stripperiffic leotard. Less than ten minutes later, she starts coming down with hypothermia. Valid
    • In contrast to the Lovable Rogue type of mercenary, Duran is loud, brutish, uncouth, and smells bad. Also, the first time Duran goes up against the Crimson Wizard, he gets curbstomped, because Duran's never faced anyone who uses magic before. Too fantastical
    • Hawkeye is a thief in a gang of them. Once Hawkeye decides he no longer wants to be part of the gang because of their growing corruption, they don't graciously let him leave; they try to have him killed (it didn't help that he was framed for the murder of one of their own). When he returns to the gang as a hero trying to stop the end of the world, only two of them side with him and the rest are all Mooks who have to be cut down. Character reaction
    • Kevin can transform into a werewolf and kick major amounts of ass, but he can't control it. The first time he transforms, Kevin kills his beloved pet Carl (or so he thinks), and spends the rest of the game hating his power. Too fantastical
    • Both Kevin and Charlotte are Half-Human Hybrids whose genetics give them significant abilities, but also cause a fair share of problems. Both of them have some sort of brain deficiency as a result of being a mix of two species, with Kevin talking in Hulk Speak and Carlie still having the mindset of a small child (and looks to match) despite actually being fifteen. Too fantastical
    • Riesz is an Action Girl, but she's not a One-Man Army. When raiders invade her kingdom, kill her people and kidnap her brother, she has to run in order to find help. She also never gets a chance to go on a Roaring Rampage of Revenge, instead having to find ways to stop the plans of the Big Bad while putting her kingdom's reconstruction on hold. Unsure
  • Tomb Raider (2013) depicts Lara's transformation from an optimistic university student to a Shell-Shocked Veteran after besting the horrors of Yamatai. The trailers for the sequel Rise of the Tomb Raider show Lara in therapy to treat her PTSD. Character has truama
  • Touhou: Mountain of Faith's plot is all about this. The stated job of a shrine maiden is to protect human settlements by battling youkai; Reimu is too lazy to even investigate all but the most dangerous youkai incursions, so the human village doesn't like her very much or pay tribute to the god she represents. When the Moriya gods move in with a shrine maiden who actually does take youkai-hunting seriously, they are instantly popular and nearly put Reimu's shrine out of business entirely. Character reaction to fantastical situations
  • In Tropico 3, pissing off the USA or the USSR too much will result in them invading you. As the military of a small island republic would be hopelessly outmatched against either of the Cold War superpowers, this causes an instant Game Over. Preventing this requires either allying with the other superpower (and angering the Nationalists), or developing the capacity for nuclear weapons. Character reaction
    • Dystopia Is Hard is also in full effect, especially in later games. Anger one faction enough and they unite to make your life miserable: the Capitalists will crash the economy, the Communists will send constant rebel attacks, the Religious will turn church attendants against you, the Militarists will attempt a full-blown coup, etc. Plot happens
  • Trillion: God of Destruction:
    • The eponymous antagonist is a world-destroying mass of a trillion curses. Your Overlords are going up against it solo, with short-notice training and limited opportunities to retreat. They're going to die. It is hammered into the characters, and then the player, that going up against Trillion is a true Suicide Mission and the best they can hope to do is do enough damage before their inevitable demise that they might be able to wear it down before they run out of time or candidates. This realization, especially the first fatality, horrifies everyone and morale starts to become a serious problem. Too fantastical and character reaction
    • The training the Overlords go under would be considered overkill in any other game (blocking large, steel balls being launched at them at Mach speeds, dancing around a storm of blades in a literal whirlwind, dodging fire raining down from the sun, withstanding the near-boiling temperatures of a hot spring, etc.). Even being Fallen Ones won't stop them from becoming exhausted, and as their fatigue rises they have an increasing chance of getting badly injured during a training session, which will sideline them for several days as they recover (and as time is limited before Trillion awakes, this is bad news all around). Cuttable ZCE

Edited by CelestialDraco on Mar 31st 2023 at 7:35:20 AM

CelestialDraco from Florissant, Missouri Since: Jan, 2014 Relationship Status: Singularity
#2011: Apr 1st 2023 at 8:01:53 AM

Need some consensus on these, especially on the unsure one and valid ones, because I'm not entirely sure about them.

Edited by CelestialDraco on Apr 1st 2023 at 10:02:01 AM

costanton11 Since: Mar, 2016
#2012: Apr 1st 2023 at 8:50:37 PM

Seems like fair assessments.

CelestialDraco from Florissant, Missouri Since: Jan, 2014 Relationship Status: Singularity
#2013: Apr 2nd 2023 at 2:04:28 AM

    Resident Evil 
  • Resident Evil:
    • In most video games, a weapon with a Laser Sight will always be steady as a rock so the player can see where the laser is pointing at. In Resident Evil 4 and future installments, like in real life, attaching a laser sight doesn't magically remove the hand sway. Not surprising since it happens in multiple games
    • Resident Evil (the Gamecube remake):
      • In the beginning, it takes Barry a whopping three shots from his .44 Magnum from point-blank to fall a zombie, and even that's not enough to kill it. As Barry is a seasoned veteran police officer, he is aiming center of mass (the dead center of the chest) like police and military in real life actually do, and so his shots are barely effective. When other characters get their hands on Magnums they instead aim for the head, killing the zombies in one shot. Since zombies don't exist, there's no way of knowing how many bullets it would take to kill one
      • Chris, being the more experienced soldier and a firearms enthusiast (explicitly stated to be the best marksman at STARS) has much better weapon-handling than the comparably inexperienced Rebecca, or even Jill who is ex-Delta Force but specialised in Explosive Ordnance Disposal rather than combat/marksmanship. He knows how to fire high-caliber handguns and thus doesn't stumble with each shot, and he's capable of shooting a shotgun from the hip to fire more effectively in narrow hallways, unlike Jill who must take aimed shots from the shoulder just to handle the recoil. When Chris is facing a boss in an open area, he takes aimed shots instead. Not an outcome
      • When Chris discovers the chemical room in the Residence, he refuses to touch anything noting how he lacks the training to safely handle dangerous chemicals. The player might know, but he does not. Getting Rebecca, the field medic who's a trained chemist, to make it for him is his only option to make V-Jolt. Character reaction
    • Resident Evil 2:
      • The zombified Brad Vickers wears a bulletproof vest, and so he takes a lot of bullets to fall. Unless you score a headshot or knock him down and stomp his head, which kills him in one shot. Not surprising
      • A quick look at a Licker will reveal that they don't actually have eyes; the entire top halves of their heads are exposed brain. Most games would simply ignore this and have their AI sense and attack you like regular enemies. Here? It's canon that since Lickers are completely blind, they rely on their hearing to hunt their prey. As such, it's completely possible to sneak right past them just by walking slowly and not bumping into them. In the same vein, Claire's bowgun in the original game and her SMG with the silencer upgrade in the remake are the best weapons to fight them with, since they don't make noise when they fire. Which means you can pelt a Licker to death with zero effort while it blindly flails around trying to figure out what's killing it. Too implausible and too fantastical
      • Flash grenades can stun Lickers despite them being blind. Because they're blind they wouldn't be affected by the flash, but those grenades are designed not just to let out a blinding flash to incapacitate opponents, but a deafening noise as well, which the Lickers would be especially susceptible to. There's a reason those weapons are called flashbangs after all. Not surprising.
      • The remake is essentially Capcom updating classic survival horror mechanics for modern times. As such, they've made it so that several conveniences people have been asking for in older-style survival horror games actually work against you. Hate the static camera angles? Say goodbye to auto-aim to compensate for your ability to make headshots. Hate the loading screen doors? Now every door can be easily opened and walked through in one second, but just about every single enemy can now follow you through them. Reconstruction
      • Leon was a rookie cop in the original game, but in the remake, it shows heavily. He has trouble handling his first zombie because he's unprepared, he nearly has a breakdown when he fails to save a fellow officer, and has to be reprimanded by Marvin because his training and heroic mindset will get him killed in a situation where 99% of the people he finds in the city are now mindless monsters. This is also seen when he meets Ben; he refuses to let him out of his cell before checking with Chief Irons, even when Ben tells him that Irons can't be trusted, simply because he's following protocol, which results in Ben's death when Mr. X breaks through the wall and crushes his skull. Character reaction
      • Leon arrives in Raccoon City in his civilian clothes, instead of his police uniform, which he receives upon arriving at the police station. Uniforms are almost never issued before the first day, so Leon wouldn't have had it with him until after he reported for duty. He still has his gun from the beginning because, as was already implied in the original, it's his personal carry gun rather than anything the department issued him. Plot happens
      • Claire is just a regular civilian with some gun training for self-defense. Like Leon, she is unprepared for what's happened in Raccoon City, especially because unlike Leon, she was never expecting to run into a dangerous situation like this. Like Leon, Marvin has to reprimand her because if she hesitates, she's as good as dead, but he's noticeably gentler about it than he is with Leon, since she's just a concerned citizen looking for her brother. This can also be seen in how Claire and Leon often react to certain traumatic moments; whereas Leon tends to give a sad sigh or restrain his anger, Claire nearly breaks down in tears, and is more vocal with her frustrations. Plot happens and character reaction
      • Leon's fellow officers were planning a welcoming party involving a puzzle for him to figure out to open his desk for the first time. When the outbreak happens, the party decorations and puzzle remain in place because with how chaotic things were, removing them would be a pointless waste of time better spent reinforcing the building. Plot happens
      • With the exception of Resident Evil 3: Nemesis, previous games rarely show children being victims of a B.O.W. attack. In the remake, parental fears is on full display; Robert Kendo refuses to let Leon and Ada come near his infected daughter, who is implied to have been bitten by her mother, whom Robert may have already killed. Moments later, when he takes her back inside to "put her to bed" with her mother and they hear a gunshot, even Ada is left in Stunned Silence for a moment. Character reaction
      • Unlike almost every single game in the series, the knife can break after being used too many times. Using the knife to break things or stab enemies will naturally have it lose durability. Even worse, it's possible for it to be stuck in the enemy if used to escape - if you want the knife back, you still need to kill the enemy and get it back. Furthermore, unlike in the first game's remake, the knife is used to stab zombies in the torso when used as a defensive move. And if a zombie attacks you from behind, you're unable to use your equipped subweapon to free yourself. Happens too frequently to be surprising
      • As opposed to being crushed by debris or attacked by G-Birkin like in the original game, Annette gets slammed against a concrete wall. Claire tags in to finish off her husband in her scenario, and Annette survives long enough to get back to Sherry and cure her of the G-Virus, but dies from her injuries moments later. Valid
      • Unlike in the original game where Leon blindly accepts Ada and puts his trust in her, Leon is rightly skeptical of Ada for a while, and it isn't until she tells him she's going after Umbrella that he even remotely begins trusting her. Ada is being suspicious, knows more than she's letting on, and is skilled enough that she's been able to survive where others haven't. When Annette later warns him about Ada, Leon drills her for answers. Because what reason would Annette have to lie to him when she's dying? Character reaction
    • Resident Evil 3 (Remake):
      • In the original game, it's implied that Jill's investigation into Umbrella was going on relatively unimpeded until the outbreak hit its peak. In the remake, Chief Irons and Umbrella swiftly swooped in to stonewall Jill, with Irons suspending her from the force and placing her under house arrest with 24/7 surveillance. Considering he's on Umbrella's payroll and how fast Nemesis gets to Jill's apartment, it's likely he was just keeping her contained so she could be silenced. This is because she's one of the surviving S.T.A.R.S. members of the Spencer Mansion incident, so naturally she's a person of interest to Umbrella. In fact, Nemesis' deployment container is shown having landed just up the street from her apartment, confirming this. Plot happens
      • Jill's nightmare and the notes in apartment reveal that she is worried that she and the rest of the S.T.A.R.S. are infected, since they were likely exposed to the T-virus during the events of the first game. Character reaction
      • Besides the horrendous nightmares, there is uneaten food all over Jill's kitchen, and enough pills on her bedside cabinet to knock out an elephant. Jill is a tough cookie, but it shouldn't be so surprising that the events at the Spencer Mansion played a serious number on her mental state, and she's not coping very well with the PTSD. Character has trauma
    • Resident Evil 4:
      • Used amusingly at the beginning. How is the evil Umbrella corporation finally destroyed? Through a daring black-ops raid with soldiers fighting its myriad monsters in one final battle? The heroes of the previous games banding together and taking out its leaders one by one? Nope! The U.S. government freezes its assets in retaliation for their involvement in the destruction of Raccoon City, and the highly publicized disasters plaguing the company cause its stock prices to drop, sending it into bankruptcy! One statement from the developers in a Nintendo Power article says that there was no way the US government would have allowed Umbrella to continue operating after being responsible for a disaster that forced them to nuke one of their own cities. This too gets a dose of realism on the other end: Simply removing Umbrella from business does not magically evaporate all the data, personnel, research data and equipment. Their B.O.W.s and viruses are sold to the highest bidder on the black market, the highest level researchers are able to continue their viral weaponry without a traceable line, and the BSAA is formed to counteract the outbreaks that follow. Character reaction
      • The fact that the BSAA is an NGO also results in this, as the US Government decides to have its own group to deal with it, the FBC (Federal Bioterrorism Commission), leading to Interservice Rivalry. Later, the FBC is replaced by the Division of Security Operations after the FBC is dissolved due to them giving bioweapons to terrorists in a plot to get rid of the BSAA. Plot happens
      • Apparently, Salazar believes Talking Is a Free Action. Too bad for him that Leon does not. Both times that Salazar tries Evil Gloating, Leon makes him pay for it, first by damaging his hearing with a bullet to a listening horn, and second by pinning Salazar's hand to a wall with a thrown knife. First time sounds valid
    • Resident Evil 4 (Remake):
      • When Leon is captured at the beginning of the game, he awakens later on chained to the ceiling with Luis and missing his jacket and all of his weapons and gear, necessitating a brief stealth section before he can recover his equipment. This was a glaring oversight in the original game, where he was only missing his jacket while still armed. Valid
      • The traumatic injury potential of shotguns has been drastically upgraded from the original, to more accurately reflect how devastating shotgun blasts can actually be. At the right gauges, and certainly at close range, a shotgun blast would make human flesh look like shredded hamburger meat and would take big chunks out of one's body. While there is some exaggeration for gameplay effect, the wounds shown are not far off from what a shotgun would actually do to a human body. Not an outcome
      • While the knockback effect of shotguns is still sort of there — in randomized instances — the majority of the time shotgun blasts typically just stun enemies if they don't manage to kill them. Shotguns are powerful, but they're not magic gravity gun weapons that fling a target 20 feet across the room, which was the exaggerated effect the original game had for them. No an outcome
      • The first time Ashley has to jump down from a high spot into Leon's arms, she doesn't simply jump down directly into a Bridal Carry, she has a mild panic attack at the very idea of it and has to be coached into it by Leon. And his knees realistically buckle a little bit when he catches her because even though Leon is in excellent shape, it's still upwards of 120ish pounds landing on him from fifteen feet up. Of course, they accomplish this feat repeatedly over the course of the rest of the game with no issues after the first time. Valid
      • The advanced stage of the Plagas infestation takes a far more serious toll on Leon's body than it did in the original. Despite some convulsions, and the occasional slip up of insanity where he became hostile, Leon in the original game was able to power through these episodes and stay focused on the mission. The removal of the parasite with Luis's machine was treated as a fairly benign situation where there was no rush to get them out, outside of being something they needed to do before they went home. In the remake, the infestation is so severe and painful it causes Ashley to pass out with black veins all over her arms and face and it's obvious that if this is not removed now, she will be irreversibly infested. Leon suffers the same throughout the game, including occasional convulsions and hallucinations, and even towards the end of the game, the same black veins Ashley has. After rescuing Ashley from Saddler's sanctuary, he uses the last of his strength to remove the parasite from Ashley, and the only reason he gets his removed is because Ashley got him on the chair while he was passed out. Massive parasites wiggling around inside your torso are no joke, action hero or not. Too implausible. Plagas isn't real
      • Whenever he's confronted face-to-face by any of the major villains and has a clear line of fire on them, Leon tends to just pump them full of lead at the first opportunity rather than trade banter with them. Both Mendez and Saddler's human forms are unfortunately Immune to Bullets until significant trauma is inflicted upon them, but with Salazar, Leon rarely has a clean shot on him until just before his boss fight, resulting in them trading a lot of Snark-to-Snark Combat in the interim, and it's clear Leon is extremely by being unable to decisively shut him up. Happens too frequently to be surprising
      • A journal found after defeating the first El Gigante explains why it's so difficult to raise a large beast as an attack dog aside from its aggressive behavior. Within a year of its creation, it had eaten nearly all the livestock in the village. This would also explain why you only fight one before entering the castle, as there's no way a village this small can feed it indefinitely. Too implausible. El Gigante's aren't real
      • Ada's prior manipulation of Leon in the RE2 remake has made him bitter, wary, and distrustful of her when they next meet again here. Rather than lowkey express any desire to reconnect like his 2005 portrayal did, Leon now keeps his distance and gives Ada the cold shoulder every time she tries to get back in his good graces, albeit still showing appreciation for her help by returning the favor when he can. Character reaction
      • Ada bails on Wesker upon learning that he plans to kill billions of people just to see his eugenics utopia become a reality. Far too often in fiction, henchmen stay loyal to their bosses long after it's become apparent they've gone off the deep end or worse, have genocidal intentions that would likely cause their own demise. Ada realizes her paycheck from Wesker doesn't mean much if his plan causes the collapse of society; a collapse that would likely kill her in the process too. Character reaction
      • Leon isn't aware that Ada is working with Wesker in the remake, which suggests Wesker did a better job of covering his tracks. Per Code Veronica, the authorities still know he's alive, since Chris would have filed a report, but Wesker has clearly been more secretive since Rockfort Island. Making it worse is in the original, Ada didn't even try to deny that she was working with Wesker, and Krauser let it slip that he was working for Umbrella (assuming Krauser still works for Wesker in the remake, he's much more professional about keeping it a secret). Wesker may be superhuman now, but why take even the slightest risk that the authorities might be able to alter the outcome of his plans? Better to play it safe. Plot happens
    • The BSAA take massive casualties in both Resident Evil 5 and Resident Evil 6. The next time they show up, they send a single agent leading operatives that are part of "Blue Umbrella", a PMC dedicated to bioweapon containment and disposalnote . Turns out, all military or paramilitary groups have limited amounts of personnel and resources, so if they keep taking large amounts of casualties, they'll eventually need to rely on others to provide manpower for their operations. Plot happens
    • Resident Evil 7: Biohazard: the deputy's conversation with Ethan seems to hand him the Idiot Ball, considering that he doesn't seem to listen to Ethan at all. However, from his perspective, a man appeared in the window of the house admitting that he trespassed on the property before rambling fairly nonsensically about being kidnapped in a way that leaves his mental faculties in serious doubt. While the player may support Ethan because they know the whole situation, the deputy has no such background knowledge. Moreover, the situation does not matter: a cop is not going to hand over his gun to a civilian just because the civilian asked him to. The fact that Ethan even got a pocketknife is nothing but lucky. Ethan's attitude also becomes a bit more realistic if you take in consideration he has just been through utterly surreal events such as his wife calling him for the first time after three years, showing up half-brainwashed, cutting his hand off, and being kidnapped by a family after getting it healed back up by staples and an unknown medicine. He's bound to be at least a little unhinged from all that. Character reaction
    • Resident Evil Village retroactively applies one to the previous game; namely, Jack Baker's infamous "Hey, You!" Haymaker actually killed Ethan. He was a walking bioweapon with Super-Strength after all, and Ethan was, at the time, just a normal guy. The only reason Ethan's still walking around, let alone fighting, is because the Mold effectively rebuilt his body. Too fantastical
    • Resident Evil: Outbreak: Al Lester, the axeman is the one of the main antagonists of the "Flashback" scenario. He lures Alyssa and three other survivors to his hunting grounds, hoping for an easy kill, but turns out that being attacked by four capable survivors does not work when all you have is an axe while the others can either have guns, makeshift weapons, or even an extra axe the survivors can find. Plot happens

Someoneman Since: Nov, 2011
#2014: Apr 2nd 2023 at 11:30:02 AM

[up] Thanks for looking at these. I was analyzing the Video Games R folder, but the Resident Evil examples were so numerous it was putting me off from it. However, there's one example I disagree with:

  • When Leon is captured at the beginning of the game, he awakens later on chained to the ceiling with Luis and missing his jacket and all of his weapons and gear, necessitating a brief stealth section before he can recover his equipment. This was a glaring oversight in the original game, where he was only missing his jacket while still armed.

I'm not sure this one is valid. It's a realistic outcome to lose your weapons after being captured, but the No-Gear Level and Stealth-Based Mission tropes are common enough that it's not necessarily a surprising outcome. It's a remake, so something being different from the original version doesn't automatically mean it's surprising, either.


EDIT: Speaking of which, here are the rest of the R examples, except for the Red Dead Redemption and Red Dead Redemption 2 examples, which are also numerous enough to warrant their own post. Also, I swear someone already made a post about them.

    R 
  • Radiata Stories.
    • At the start of the game, Jack is defeated easily by Ridley in their duel. Ridley is a noble with access to the best trainers, money to buy better gear, and in general the conditions to make it into the knights without issue. Meanwhile Jack is a peasant with nobody to really teach him, and little resources on hand to use. Naturally, the more skilled fighter easily wins. Plot happens. The Hopeless Boss Fight trope is common enough to not be surprising.
    • If the player goes with the Non-Human route, Jack gets labeled a traitor who kidnapped Ridley, the princess. Although Ridley left on her own, and Jack only went along at first to protect her and try to convince her to return home, because he was the last person seen with her, and was leaving with her, he gets labeled a traitor since for all the people know, he really did do it. After all, Ridley didn't tell anyone she was going to leave. Plot happens. The example explains why it's realistic for Jack to be mistaken for a traitor, but not why it's surprising.
    • When Jack and Gantz try to join Theater Vancoor after being kicked from the Knights, they both fight Jarvis, arguably the second best fighter in the guild in a Secret Test of Character. While both lose, Jack is given the okay to join from Gerald, while Gantz is rejected. His reasoning is because Jack has the aptitude for the group, while Gantz, who was a sheltered nobility, would not fit in well at all. Not helping is that Gantz applied just after drinking heavily in response to being kicked out of the knights, whereas Jack, being younger, doesn't drink and thus is able to at least seem professional despite his younger age. Plot happens
  • Radiation Island: Since it's a survival game, many common sense rules apply: starvation, infection, and radiation can all kill you; falls can break bones; sleep means you aren't eating, so you're going to wake up hungry; water will drown you if you stay submerged for too long. Other nasty realities: Unexpectedly Realistic Gameplay. All of these are just the game as a whole being realistic, rather than messing with expectations when players would expect unrealism.
    • Taking too long to root around in your pack or loot a chest gives mooks a fine opportunity to sneak up on you.
    • Escaping mooks by taking to the water in a canoe won't work—crocodiles just swim after you, zombies follow you by walking along the bottom.
    • Everything is out to kill everything else, not just you. It's common to wander the island and find random Organ Drops from animals killed by mooks. And what do you get when zombies can infect animals? Poison-spewing zombie beasts that are much worse than their mundane versions, and travel in packs. Not realistic
  • Rainbow Six: Vegas 2, while the final villain of the game is delivering his Motive Rant, he pulls his gun on you, you pull yours on him in return... and then he continues ranting at you for a few more minutes before shooting, at any point during which you can shoot him in the face. This contrasts with the confrontation with one of the Co-Dragons much earlier in the game, where you're not given control back until almost the very end of the interaction with him - if you shoot him at any point before he pulls his gun on you, you fail the mission and have to restart; but at the same time, you've got maybe half a second to react once he does pull the gun before he blows you away with it, because he knows he's not going to have time to dick around and keep taunting the three heavily-armed SWAT-type people already pointing their guns at him. Just Shoot Him
  • Ratchet & Clank (2002): You can use the Gagetron PDA to order ammo on the go if you can't access ammo crates or a regular vendor. However, what the game does not tell you is that the ammo will be more expensive, which you won't realize until you actually use it. This is presumably because you are being charged for shipping and handeling. Unexpectedly Realistic Gameplay
  • Ratchet & Clank: Rift Apart: When Rivet lost her arm, it wasn't blown clean off. Rather, it was burned to a crisp by an energy weapon, and needed to be amputated. Not realistic. Energy weapons don't exist.
  • What happens when you put structures designed with mostly Rule of Cool in mind under real-world physics? According to Red Faction Guerrilla and its extremely robust destruction engine, they collapse. The game designers had to take a crash course in real-world architecture to create buildings that would stay up long enough for the player to destroy them. Unexpectedly Realistic Gameplay. Also a real life example, since it's about the devs having to design their buildings realistically.
  • Resistance: The alien Chimera have a metabolism roughly 12 times faster than that of a human's, which grants them the ability to healing much faster but also significantly raises their body temperature. Chimeran creatures are thus given cybernetic cooling devices to keep them from roasting to death in their own body heat, and part of their plan for Earth involves terraforming it into a much colder environment. Not realistic. Chimeras don't exist.
  • Rhythm Doctor is a game where you operate a remote-control defibrillator to treat your patients' abnormal heart patterns. Although Artistic License – Medicine is in full effect, it's mentioned that stabilizing someone's heartbeat once doesn't automatically mean they're okay. This is especially true in Act 2, which focuses on Cole and Nicole, two patients whose health problems are caused by an addiction to caffeine and cigarettes, respectively. Even though you can stabilize them, their long-term health won't improve unless they can overcome their addiction. Probably not surprising or an outcome since it's something that's just mentioned.
  • In Rimworld:
    • Assigning a colonist with poor cooking skills as the town chef or using a filthy kitchen can result in food poisoning from tainted meals. Realistic, but not surprising.
    • A colonist receiving poor medical care can have an infection and die, or be left with a scar that causes them pain and loss of motor control for the rest of their lives. Infections are much, much more deadly than the wounds that cause them, and sometimes amputation is the only option to a bad one. Same.
    • Smoking too much smokeleaf can lead to asthma and lung cancer, and likewise, too much alcohol consumption can lead to cirrhosis of the liver. Same
    • Make a body purist wear a cybernetic limb? They will most likely revolt or be upset. Character reaction
    • Colonists with the Nudist trait will strip at every possible chance and only put clothes on (begrudgingly) if you directly force them to. That said, when the weather outside gets too hot/cold for them to go out without getting sick, they'll put clothes on unprompted. They may be free spirits, but they're not stupid enough to let themselves die of exposure (they'll complain about it the whole time though). Character reaction
  • Riven: Gehn taught himself the Art, and as a result, his understanding of it is flawed. While he managed to successfully write Ages, writing an Age does not necessarily mean that it's a stable Age, and as a result, Riven is on the verge of collapsing. Not helping is that Gehn treats the Art more like a science than a creative process, relying on "formulas" and not inputting "unnecessary" words in order to save link. As you might expect, this has disastrous results on his Ages, because large swathes of necessary descriptive text just aren't there (Atrus compares Riven to looking at a tapestry someone sliced to ribbons and stitched together blindly). Atrus has to stay behind so he can edit the Riven descriptive book enough to keep it going while you're in there. Not realistic
    • If you use the Trap Book to trap Gehn, and then link into it again, Gehn will just leave you in there. Why the hell would he free you, knowing what the book does? Not realistic.
  • In R-Type Delta, the strongest ship in the game is the Cerebus, a prototype ship fused with Bydo techology. This makes it twice as powerful as the other more traditional R-Type ships in the game. As a result, many of the challenging levels in the game are easier to complete. However, the final level takes place in the Bydo dimension, and when the ship tries to escape after killing the final boss, the Bydo dimension is able to absorb it before it can break free, because of the Bydo fused inside the ship, causing the game's only Bad Ending. The other ships are able to escape, because of the lack of Bydo in them - the game's covert way of punishing you for taking the easy way out. Not realistic

Edited by Someoneman on Apr 2nd 2023 at 11:36:37 AM

costanton11 Since: Mar, 2016
#2015: Apr 2nd 2023 at 11:37:54 AM

Thoughts on these entries from Ghostbusters II?:

  • Surprisingly Realistic Outcome:
    • While the Ghostbusters did save the day in the first movie, this movie revealed they were forced out of business due to getting sued for property damage (they did blow up an uptown high-rise to stop Gozer) and getting an injunction barring them from investigating the supernatural.
      • Once the positive PR wore off and the team got hit with said lawsuits, it's also unsurprising that the political support they received from the mayor's office evaporated (as Lenny, as a politician, would naturally focus on protecting his political interests first and foremost).
    • In an aversion of Omnidisciplinary Lawyer, Louis completely botches his defense of the team in court because he's only studied tax and probate law and knows nothing about criminal defense.

Noaqiyeum Trans Siberian Anarchestra (it/they) from the gentle and welcoming dark (Time Abyss) Relationship Status: Arm chopping is not a love language!
Trans Siberian Anarchestra (it/they)
#2016: Apr 2nd 2023 at 11:45:15 AM

The first two are Status Quo Is God and a character reaction. The third point seems valid.

The Revolution Will Not Be Tropeable
costanton11 Since: Mar, 2016
#2017: Apr 2nd 2023 at 2:52:25 PM

In the third case, it’s made clear immediately that he’s out of his depth in the case, so the fact that he initially fails to win the case doesn’t seem that surprising.

Paperfly Buzz from On The Wall Since: Jun, 2022
Buzz
#2018: Apr 3rd 2023 at 4:49:47 AM

On SurprisinglyRealisticOutcome.Western Animation

    American Dad! 
  • In one episode, Francine fakes a kidnapping of Roger to prove that Stan really cares for him. Stan reveals at the very end of the night that he knew the whole time since he has Caller ID, and Francine foolishly called Stan on her own cell phone. Not an Outcome

  • In “Stanny Tendergrass” Stan has been working a summer time job as a country club groundskeeper in the hopes he could save up to earn a membership there. However in the past three decades since he’s started part timing, the membership cost went up from $7,000 to $200,000 thanks to inflation, meaning he’s spent the better part of thirty years saving up for an obsolete membership payment. Not an outcome

  • In the B-plot of "The Life Aquatic with Steve Smith", Stan and Roger realize that having a boat is a waste of time and money, since neither of them are experienced at maintaining and sailing a boat. Also, when Roger discovers that the life jackets have cocaine in them, he excitedly asks Stan if he knows what this means. The comedic version of this would have Stan and Roger team up as cocaine dealers who sell the stuff to pay off the boat. However, since Stan is a CIA agent and has dealt with drug smuggling busts, he immediately places Roger under arrest for intent to sell cocaine. Possibly valid

  • In "Enter Stanman", Stan tries to cut his steak, but inadvertently cuts his finger in the process. Seconds later, he ends up passing out from blood loss. Surprising element not clear

  • In "A Piñata Named Desire" Stan and Roger are playing lead roles in a play in order to prove who's the better actor. When it comes time for their characters to kiss, they go off script and escalate their actions out of sheer pettiness, to the point that it ends with Stan and Roger's characters having sex in front of a live audience. The audience members are grossed out and Stan and Roger are arrested for public indecency. Based on character reactions

  • In "Faking Bad", Stan finds out about Hayley and Steve's fake I.D. operation. When Hayley confesses, Stan says "I can't arrest my own daughter" making it seem like Hayley's getting off the hook. Instead, he asks Bullock to arrest her and she ends up going to jail. Just describes plot

  • In "The People vs. Martin Sugar", Stan tries to have Roger arrested so that he can finally be held accountable for his misdeeds and when all else fails, he takes matters into his own hands and tries to personally arrest Roger, but does this by knocking out a Marshal, stealing his clothes and impersonating him, thus becoming a vigilante. When he finally corners Roger, Stan is arrested. Stan may have been trying to rightfully make Roger be held accountable, but he broke many laws when doing so. Furthermore, Stan sent a letter requesting to be on the jury pool; even if he was an unbiased observer, he wouldn’t have served in any jury.note  Not an outcome

  • "Crystal Clear" shows the reality of dealing with a Loan Shark. After Stan and Roger blow the money they owed Mike Donkey, a loan shark, on a giant crystal, Roger offers it to him as compensation believing it to be a Power Crystal giving off good vibes; given they relied on crystals to win more than enough money to pay back Mike, and claim they can do it again ten times over. Mike and his goons simply break Steve's legs as they stated in their loan terms and leave. Mike even states that he never really had to go the route of physical violence before since most of his victims are smart enough to pay him back; the fact that Stan and Roger really thought that was going to work outright baffles him. Based on character actions and reactions

  • In "Hurricane!", Klaus jumps into the water flooding the house after gloating that he will be able to survive due to being a fish unlike the rest of the cast. The only flaw in that plan is that Klaus is a freshwater goldfish while the aforementioned water is saltwater from the ocean, resulting in him almost immediately jumping back out flailing in pain begging to be put back in his fishbowl. Sounds valid

Thoughts?

Plan to go through the other subfolders soon

Edited by Paperfly on Apr 3rd 2023 at 4:50:49 AM

Image Pickin' Backlog
maxwellsilver Since: Sep, 2011
#2019: Apr 3rd 2023 at 5:23:52 AM

[up][up][up] I'm not so sure. I think a realistic outcome would be Lewis saying "Dammit man, I'm a tax lawyer, not a defense attorney!" (tongue) and them hiring a criminal defense lawyer, or using a court-appointed lawyer if they can't afford one, and that's assuming a tax lawyer would be allowed to represent someone in a trial.

CelestialDraco from Florissant, Missouri Since: Jan, 2014 Relationship Status: Singularity
#2020: Apr 4th 2023 at 11:11:21 AM

Just noticed this was added to the main page. What are your thoughts on this?

  • The Dragon and the Butterfly: Chapter 43 involves the Vikings of Berk fighting the Madrigal family. One might expect the Madrigals to overwhelm them with their magic, and the battle does starts out that way... however, none of the Madrigals are fighters and are one-trick ponies when it comes to using their abilities defensively, while the Vikings are all stronger and have more fighting experience. Basically, all they have to do is tough it out until the Madrigals exhaust themselves.

Paperfly Buzz from On The Wall Since: Jun, 2022
Buzz
#2021: Apr 4th 2023 at 12:33:24 PM

Magic is unrealistic and Vikings no longer exist. Example can be cut

I think the main page should be locked to avoid addition of misuse. I'd suggested it a while back, but I think it got overlooked

Any feedback on this?

Edited by Paperfly on Apr 4th 2023 at 12:34:55 PM

Image Pickin' Backlog
Tabs Since: Jan, 2001
#2022: Apr 4th 2023 at 8:06:54 PM

They look fine. I guess one could argue that sentient goldfish aren't real, but the valid part (freshwater goldfish being unable to survive in saltwater for more than a few minutes) does fit SRO.

SoyValdo7 I mainly fix indentation issues from La tierra de lagos y volcanes Since: Sep, 2022 Relationship Status: THIS CONCEPT OF 'WUV' CONFUSES AND INFURIATES US!
I mainly fix indentation issues
#2023: Apr 4th 2023 at 8:10:04 PM

[up][up][up] I kinda see the point. Vikings are warriors, they train to fight wars. And the Madrigals are ultimately normal people with zero real combat experience. That said, it seems like the example has nothing to do with actual combat neither, so yeah, I guess it doesn't count.

Edited by SoyValdo7 on Apr 4th 2023 at 9:10:34 AM

Valdo
CelestialDraco from Florissant, Missouri Since: Jan, 2014 Relationship Status: Singularity
#2024: Apr 7th 2023 at 7:33:49 AM

  • The Dark Side of the Moon (Zootopia): While asking about the history of the Lang Family, Jimmy is led to believe that they've been around for centuries based purely on the number of Alphas they've had. Morty has to explain that A), they're not a literal family that passes on leadership over generations, and B), they were mostly a crime family, meaning that a lot of their Alphas ended up dead or arrested before their time. Not an outcome

CelestialDraco from Florissant, Missouri Since: Jan, 2014 Relationship Status: Singularity
#2025: Apr 7th 2023 at 9:36:29 AM

  • Abyss: In the first issue, Eric tries to hurry through the dispensation of his father's will. His father's lawyers point out that Eric is inheriting an entire company with multiple divisions, and the subsidiaries alone will probably take three weeks to review. When he finds out that his dad's company owns a baseball team, he asks a question about one of the players, only to have a lawyer tell him that he's not yet legally entitled to that information, as the team is company property, not his personal property, and he has not been fully recognized as the new owner yet. Valid?
  • Action Man: As Bestley points out, the terrorists' "X" belt buckles — which led Ian to go in against them guns blazing — count for nothing as evidence that Doctor X is still alive. It's a letter. Not an outcome
  • Adventure Time: In issue 30, Marceline and Bubblegum drink 15 year old milk and spat it out since it went bad. Not surprising
  • Alix: Turns out reuniting with the father you thought was dead for ten years doesn't immediately turn you into a happy family again. Character reaction
  • Amethyst, Princess of Gemworld: While Amethyst's heroics are loved by people, her actions make delicate diplomacy with Dark Houses she keeps picking fights with a nightmare, to the point her own mother considers her a political liability. Turquoise is her only political ally and is constantly pressured by other houses to stab her in the back. Character reaction
  • Apama - The Undiscovered Animal:
    • Apama's battle with the Lawn Mower Man goes about the way one would expect for a fight where both combatants are idiots and one of them is drunk. Ilyia tries to deliver a haymaker to Jesse, but because the latter is wearing armor and super-durability is not part of the Apama power set, Ilyia screws up his arm. On the other end of things, Jesse tries to retaliate by using his flying rods' acceleration powers to turn himself into a living tornado, but since his internal organs aren't designed to withstand that sort of force, he ends up winded and vomiting. Unsure
    • Trina Kukula is initially introduced as an Intrepid Reporter who's bravely seeking out Regina and her cult. Her near-death experience at Regina's hands leaves her with severe PTSD, killing any lingering inclinations she had to seek out more stories. Character has truama
  • Archie vs. Predator:
    • Archie may have got a huge dose of Super Serum that makes him stronger than Predator but he is still a huge klutz with no fighting experience, he only lands two sucker punches before the Predator kills him. Too fantastical
    • Veronica admits that at seventeen years old, if Betty lives she will be able to move on past Archie. Not an outcome
    • Colonel Keller brought his son, Reggie, Chuck and Midge with him to combat the Predator. Never mind the Predator is a One-Man Army, none of them except Kevin have military training and all of them are easily killed by the alien. Not surprising
    • In the final chapter, Betty is forced by Veronica to wear a gown before the Predator attack and easily trips over the long skirt when she attempts to run. Valid
  • Armageddon 2001: In the Action Comics annual, in a future where Superman is elected President, Lex Luthor (at the time posing as his own "son") is caught on tape vowing to kill him. Luthor is, of course, used to weaseling out of such threats against Superman...but threatening the life of the President of the United States has him immediately arrested by the Secret Service. Valid
  • Astro City:
    • The man who would become Mister Drama tried robbing a theatre he'd failed an audition at, and made no attempt to hide who he was. The stick-up was successful, but the victims remembered his name and face and told the police, who quickly went to his house. Only the fact that he wasn't in prevented him from getting arrested. Valid
    • A heartbreaking example from the story of G-Dog. Most dogs, even if they have superpowers, are going to get old long before their humans do. Too fantastical
    • Quarrel and Crackerjack are forced to face the fact that two people, as amazingly gifted athletes as they may be, just can't keep crime-fighting as they did in their 20s when they're hitting 50. Characters age
  • Atomic Robo:
  • Avatar: The Last Airbender – Imbalance: Occasionally a problem for Robo.
    • Just like the real industrial revolution, the creation of machines to replace jobs that previously required human workers leads to a massive job shortage, with many of those out of work forced to turn to crime. Satoru highlights this from the business man's perspective: Noting that because of the improvements made to technology, he had no reason to keep the benders around and spend money on them, yet he never intended to put people out on the streets. Plot happens and too fantastical
    • Change occurs, but change is constant. What was once a blessing for a small town to prosper ended up turning it into a Wretched Hive because of the sudden downturn in employment thanks to Satoru. Yes, change was going to occur, but not all of it is good; especially as a town can go from the top of the heap to down in the dumps in less than a few years. Plot happens
    • Though much more prevalent in The Legend of Korra, it was only going to be a matter of time before people with the ability to shoot fire or throw rocks at whim would start to use their abilites as leverage and superiority over those who can't. Despite the practice growing traction, Chi Blocking isn't widely used or readily available to non-combatants and it's difficult to stand up to benders who can cause massive damage at whim. Too fantastical
    • Aang realizes that it would've been easy to energybend away the power of Liling; but doing so would've been fruitless; for the racism she spouted wasn't only hers but shared by hundreds of benders and it would've been nearly despotic to remove the bending of hundreds of people, fueling their rage even more so. The bigotry of the people is awful; but it's something that can only be changed by changing the minds and hearts of the people; and brute force wasn't going to solve that problem. Too fantastical


Total posts: 2,437
Top