Follow TV Tropes

Following

Headscratchers / The Simpsons

Go To

    open/close all folders 

     Homer's Baldness 
  • In Simpson and Delilah, after Homer lost all of his hair why couldn't he just get a wig? I don't see how they can be that expensive.

     Elvis is White 
  • In the season 4 episode, The Front, Bart and Lisa write the Itchy and Scratchy cartoon, Little Barbershop of Horrors and they show Scratchy getting blasted into a tv where he gets shot by Elvis. How is Elvis white when the only white characters are Asians? We know it's Elvis because the Simpsons wiki page on the cartoon short has not only his name, but the actual event it was based on under the trivia section. Since we know Elvis exists in this universe, how can he be white? Then again in New Kids on the Blecch, we see a picture of Elvis getting his hair cut while he was in the army and he looked like a combination of yellow and white.
    • Has any other human ever appeared in Itchy and Scratchy? I think they live in a Funny Animal world were everyone else is some other variety of furry and Elvis was the only exception, and considering that in the Simpson white humans are represented as yellow it would make sense that in-universe is the other way around (if it was voluntary and not just that the animators overlook it then is a very clever thing).
Advertisement:

     Manjula in Mensa 
  • In "Frink Gets Testy", why is Manjula in Mensa?
    • Apu works all the time, so she may have joined so she can get some social time with other adults.

     Vice Principal 
  • Does Springfield Elementary School even have a Vice Principal? If not why don't they have on
    • Springfield E is constantly cash strapped, Seymour can't afford to employ one. He's also more than a little controlling so probably enjoys or feels compelled to be taking on their duties himself anyway. Either that or it is Willie.
    • In a "Doylist" sense, Law of Conservation of Detail. A recurring Vice-Principal character would probably not add that much or have any more of a role that couldn't be filled by either Principal Skinner or the regular teachers we see. Same reason we don't see any other teachers for other years that often despite the fact that they presumably also exist. If you need to, just handwave it with the assumption that they probably exist, they're just not interesting or relevant enough for us to focus on in any great detail.

     What Kind of Saxophone? 
  • Can anyone tell me what kind of saxophone Lisa uses (alto, baritone, etc?) And how can you tell (if you can) from the drawing of it? Thanks.
    • It is a baritone and you can tell by the drawing. A baritone sax has the largest bell, a tenor has a medium sized bell, an alto has a small bell, and a soprano has no bell (it's straight like a clarinet.) You can also tell by the pitch, a baritone sax is the lowest and soprano is the highest, just like with singing voices. Confirmed in show in some episodes (such as the one where Homer prepares for the end of the world and meets up with other doomsday preppers.)

     Abe's Hair 
  • Does Abe have blonde hair despite having brown hair in the past... or does he have a weird shaped bald head?
    • He's gone mostly bald, with just a little tuft of very lightly-coloured hair remaining. His hair is drawn/coloured like that to match Bart, Lisa and Maggie's seamless skin-hair transition.

     How Would the Law Punish Springfield? 
  • Me and my friend were debating this... if Reality Ensues in the episode The Simpsons S18E18 "The Boys of Bummer", how exactly would the LAW punish the ENTIRE town of Springfield for the crime of harassing and bullying Bart to the brink of suicide... and continue this treatment once he survived the suicide attempt. Besides Chief Wiggum being fired and blacklisted from Law Enforcement due to you know... BEING A F**KIN' COP AND CONTRIBUTING TO BART'S SUICIDE ATTEMPT, How exactly would actual competent law enforcement penalize a entire town for this heinous crime?
    • One thing for sure is that Springfield would be permanently blacklisted in sports, with all of its teams being forced to disband, and anyone originating from the town banned from joining other teams. Wiggun would be fired, indeed, and probably charged with attempted murder. Tourism would be hit very badly, as people would not want to visit a town full of people who are willing to hurt children, mentally or physically, for petty reasons. And the Simpsons would be placed into Witness Protection for Bart's safety, maybe even forced to change their names.
      • And then there's Joe LaBoot. He's cited as an example of someone who made a similar mistake as Bart, but still became famous. But when Bart goes to meet him, and LaBoot finds out who he's speaking with, he joins in on the bullying, driving Bart towards the Despair Event Horizon, and telling Lisa off when she calls him out on his hypocrisy. End result: LaBoot is disgraced. He'll be hated by everyone, stripped of all of his titles, become an Unperson and Acceptable Target, and will most likely have criminal charges laid against him, especially if he attacked other children. He'll become baseball's Jimmy Savile.
Advertisement:

     Dealing with the Dummies 
  • How exactly can Marge and Lisa deal with the stupidity of Homer and Bart? They treat it like it's the norm and don't do a damn thing to end it.
    • Homer is stupid because of a genetic trait, and Bart's not stupid-just naughty. They can deal with it because they like Homer.
    • Depending on the Writer Homer’s stupidity is more naive, especially in early seasons making him kind of innocent and lovable, he later became more sociopathic in later seasons due to Flanderization. Bart is not stupid, his intelligence is average or he may even be more clever than normal he just doesn’t use it for good deeds or academic achievements.
    • They often don't put up with it. Many episodes where Homer and Bart screw up really badly upset Margie and Lisa, causing conflict and Homer and Bart being punished for their antics. As for why Marge sticks around despite Homer being a gluttonous, accident-prone oaf, she knows that Homer really cares for her and has demonstrated his loyalty to her on multiple occasions. Lisa also loves Bart deep down even though he's teased/pranked her a lot over the years because she knows he cares about her and would never attempt to seriously hurt her (besides "Lisa on Ice" where they were both trying to hurt each other).

     Presidents 
  • In The Simpsons, the episodes always take place in the year they were produced. Early in the show we see that Bush Sr. was President, and it's been shown Obama's president in recent episodes? The Simpsons Movie obviously takes place in 2007, so why is Arnold Schwarzenegger president? It was even said he was elected. Does this mean the movie is the true finale or what?
    • One of the staff said they didn't want the movie to become dated, so they substituted Bush for a fictional president, which will only become dated when Schwarzenegger dies.
    • Which could have been completely sidestepped if they had just used Rainer Wolfcastle
    • They probably picked Schwarzenegger because he's like a hippogriff, something that is literally impossible and it was somewhat topical as there was discussion about him becoming President. note 

     Have You Seen These Exes? 
  • In "Moonshine River" Bart goes back to his old girlfriends just to get rejected. How come they didn't feature Laura Powers, Jessica Lovejoy, Greta Wolfcastle, or Shauna from "Beware My Cheating Bart?" Could they not get the voice actresses to return or was the guest star list at maximum capacity?
    • The guest stars probably didn't want to have to come all the way back to the voice recording studios just to say one short line. Also, I agree that the guest star list was at maximum capacity.
    • Laura never dated Bart because he was too young for her. He broke it off with Jessica, she didn't reject him, so dating her wouldn't go against Lisa's claim that all his girlfriends left him. Shauna I had to look up, but from what I remember she had loose morally like Jessica and is also Laura's age, something he could have realized when thinking about his old girlfriend's as a whole. I can't think of an in universe reason to skip Greta.
    • Laura was more of a one-sided crush. He did have a picture of Jessica. No idea about the others.

     Futurama but No Simpsons 
  • It's well established that Matt Groening exists in the universe of The Simpsons, where he's the creator of Futurama. This mostly averts the Celebrity Paradox, but it makes you wonder...would Futurama still have gotten made if Groening hadn't become famous as the creator of the mega-hit The Simpsons? Also: if he wasn't occupied with The Simpsons early in his career, did Futurama come out a lot earlier in this universe? Did Futurama start out as shorts onThe Tracey Ullman Show? (Kind of makes you wonder what the 1987 versions of the cast look like...)
    • Plausible answer: his career started with a different show in The Simpsons that, unlike The Simpsons, eventually ended at, I dunno, season 7, and was fantastically popular. Futurama came afterwards, on a different network, that cancelled it after...say...fourteen episodes, just long enough for it to become a cult sensation.
    • Probably the above scenario with the different show being Life in Hell, the idea Groening originally intended to present to The Tracey Ullman Show before deciding against it at the last minute. Supported by the Life in Hell merchandise sometimes seen around Springfield, and offering an interesting take on What Could Have Been.
      • It is explained in the infamous "That '90s Show" episode: Matt Groening was poor, but made "Futurama" in 90s.
      • What if he threw together the Futurama characters to pitch to Fox instead of The Simpsons?

     Logic Behind the Ballet Mistake 
  • In "Marge on the Lam," why did Homer get ballet confused with seeing a little bear driving a mini-car at the circus?
    • Hell, he's not the only one. Lenny had exactly the same misconception.
      • Because they're stupid, and that's funny.
      • Bear + Valet = Ballet?
Advertisement:

     Who Evolved from Whom? 
  • In the Homer's Evolution couch gag showing Homer going through evolution (with Moe devolving into a rat creature): Does this mean Moe evolved from rats or did the rats evolve from Moe?
    • Yes.
      • Probably the latter, considering he's devolving, but it's probably just a sight gag about Moe's ugliness and primitive nature.
      • It also could have been because he was going in the opposite direction.

     Did Bart Really Die? 
  • Does a lost episode called "Dead Bart" really exist?
    • No. It was made up by people on the internet.
      • Whew. That's a relief.

     Not-So-Special Guest Voice 
  • Why does Marcia Wallace keep being called a special guest voice in the credits? Shouldn't she be in the Also Starring category?
    • I asked this question in real life a few years back, and the answer seemed to be because of name recognition. People know who Marcia Wallace is and so they don't want to relegate her to the "also starring" category, because the "guest star" category is more prominent. Of course, as someone who knows far more about Tress MacNeille and Russi Taylor than Marcia Wallace, it does seem strange.
      • Marcia Wallace was known for her live action role on The Bob Newhart Show, so she was probably more well known to the general audience, while the others mainly just did voice roles.

     Baby Translator 
  • Why didn't the Simpsons buy one of those baby translators for Maggie?
    • Why didn't Herb give them one free? Why NO ONE has one in later shows? Why? WHY? WHYYYYYY??? (Maybe weekly reset, or they don't care about Maggie enough.)
      • The baby translator, as previously said, had ramifications so far-reaching and society-altering that the writers placed in under Negative Continuity.
      • Would you want your baby's cries, coos, and gurgles translated in Uncy Herb's voice?
      • The translator doesn't work on pacifier sucking noises.
    • See Reed Richards Is Useless.

     Too Many Doctors Spoil the Surgery 
  • While the episode "Round Springfield" was a superb episode, one part seemed a little strange. Why are both Dr. Hibbert and Dr. Nick performing surgery on Bart? Isn't that like mixing oil and water? On the other hand, it did give us this:
    Dr. Nick: Hey, I smell gas. Pleasant gas. Night-night gas.
    • Maybe the surgery was so complex that it would have required two doctors to perform.
    • The Question should be why two General Practitioners, one of them a Paedatrician, are performing complex surgery in the first place.
      • The question was more why Dr. Hibbert and a certified quack ("Calm down, you're going to get skin failure.") are doing surgery.
      • There are several episode where it's hinted that Hibbert is a bit of a quack himself.
      • Even if so, it's not nearly as blatant as Dr. Nick, and as the original poster said: oil and water.
      • I'm assuming Riviera was only there for sedation, not as actual surgeon.

     Too Smart for His Own Genes 
  • If there really is a "Simpson Gene" that makes the male Simpsons into complete idiots age age 8, then how does that explain Bart when he is shown to be clever with pranks at age 10? Is this really a non-canon episode?
    • It seems like the writers forgot about it. Another later episode (HOMR) proved that Homer was actually a genius, he just had a crayon lodged in his brain. Bart is also shown to be extremely smart when he's on Focusyn.
      • I also noticed that this episode is written by Ned Goldreyer, who also wrote the non-canon Treehouse of Horror VIII.
      • Goldreyer only wrote one segment. Beyond that, are you seriously thinking that any Treehouse of Horror episodes are canon? How could "Bart Simpsons Dracula" be considered more canon than this?
      • It could be that the gene does not make you dumb per se, but make you a loser, intelligent people can be unsuccessful in many ways and Homer even after the crayon is removed is still unable to adapt and becomes socially ackward, not dumb but still without enough social skills. In Lisa’s Wedding episode Bart is shown to be a demolition worker with three divorces that expends his time at Moe’s but there’s no indication that he’s dumb. However, the most likely explanation is that the episode is non-canonical. And yes, non of the Halloween episodes are canon.

     Weird Idea of Dignity 
  • Maximum Homerdrive: "Maybe it's time we ditched the high tech gizmos and went back to driving like our daddies did... Using our hands and our wits... it has meaning and dignity... Nah. Let's just find some other scam."
    • So in this world, there really is a chip that can drive a truck for you, flawlessly, around windy cliff roads? And the "dignified" thing to do is to hide its existence from the world and continue to make a living driving with your flawed (and speed-addled) brains and hands? I'm pretty sure that *is* another scam.
    • Reed Richards Is Useless.

     Marge the Prude 
  • Don't get me wrong; I loved the episode "Homer to the Max", but one part of it was a little confusing. Why was Marge grossed out, or at least very weirded out, by the idea of actually having sex with Homer instead of just snuggling with him? Remember the escapades of "Natural Born Kissers"?
    • It was Homer changing his name to Max Power that weirded her out, not the sex.
    • And it was also Homer describing sex with Max Power as "Strap[ping] yourself in and feel[ing] the G's." It was Marge basically reacting to how out of character Homer has become due to his name change.

     Disliking Her Own (Partial) Creation 
  • This troper has always been annoyed by the ending of the episode "The Front". Grampa wins a writing award for the Itchy & Scratchy episodes Lisa and Bart wrote with his name on them, and at the ceremony he goes off on a rant about how sick and horrible the cartoons (which he'd never seen before) are, and gets booed off the stage. Okay, whatever. But why does Lisa agree with him about a cartoon she helped write?
    • Maybe she wanted to express her creativity in a way that the public would see. As a child, and a fan of Itchy and Scratchy, she saw the medium of ghost writing episodes as a way of doing that. Sure the show goes against her morals, but at least her work got on TV. I watch some things that I wouldn't agree with in the real world, but that doesn't mean I'm going to stop watching them. And before you go on about how she doesn't get any credit on the work, she's a child. Children don't get credit for writing professionally! Haven't you read Ender's Game?
    • Didn't she satisfy her goals? Wasn't the basis of the plot that Lisa and Bart thought they could write better episodes than the ones they had been watching?

     Correctly Crazy 
  • Why did Homer and Marge take Bart off of the Focusyn? Sure, it was making him crazy, but he was completely correct about everything he freaked out about. Plus overdosing didn't appear to have any negative side effects.
    • Because they were being good parents and decided that Bart's happiness was more important than grades?
    • He might have been right, but he went completely insane. I mean, he steals a *tank* for God's sake, I'd take him off the drugs too.
    • Even in the real world, drugs can have good effects but be unsuitable for a person. Birth control can regulate hormones and make periods less severe and painful but can worsen depression, OCD medication can reduce destructive thoughts but cause a person to have migraines, mood stabilizers for Tourette's syndrome can cause kidney damage. Sometimes the risks outweigh the benefits.
    • Bart may have been right about everything, but in the universe of The Simpsons being right isn't actually worth all that much. It's a recurring theme in the show that intelligent, talented people are doomed to failure and misery while idiots blunder their way into success and happiness (see "HOMR", "Lisa's Rival", "Homer's Enemy"). That's what's going on here: Bart uncovered Major League Baseball's diabolical conspiracy, but no one cared so long as they got to watch a guy hit some dingers. The Simpsons live in an insane world, and Focusyn made Bart far too sane to survive in it.

     No Mensa for Martin 
  • Why isn't Martin Prince a member of MENSA? His IQ is 216, which is higher than the other members.
    • Maybe he was planning to after he heard that Lisa had joined, but after the crazy stuff the MENSA members did, he figured it would just be better just to settle for the Super Friends (the local school's nerd group, not the super hero one).
    • Funny enough, in the game Tapped Out, he is a new member of MENSA.
    • When Bart reveals he cheated on the IQ test, he doesn't say how he cheated, just that he cheated, so Martin's intelligence goes unnoticed at the time. They probably just never bothered to administer a second IQ test.
    • Being in the top 2% of intelligent people only qualifies one for MENSA. It doesn't make one a member automatically. Just because he can doesn't mean he'd choose to — especially with the local chapter being very tiny and entirely adults until Lisa joins. It doesn't really have much to offer him.

     Only One Church 
  • When Reverend Lovejoy and wife leave Springfield, why does Marge say, "It's as if God has left Springfield"? Is it possible that their church is the only church in the whole town, even only considering Presbyterians?
    • Because, as seen in "Homer the Heretic", "She of Little Faith" and "The Father, The Son and The Holy Guest Star", Marge has absolutely zero respect for other religions or alternative forms of worship. Reverend Lovejoy's departure probably means that the one true way to worship or contact God is gone, at least to Marge.
    • It's possible. Springfield only has a population of about 25,000. Unless the writers need it to be bigger, of course.
      • Wait. Springfield has a set-in-stone population?
      • My town of 8000 has more than fifty churches. Just sayin'.
      • 1400 people. At least 4 churches, maybe more.
      • 1600 people in my hometown. 2 churches that I knew of when we moved, now there's a new one. May be more besides those three.
    • Presbylutheran. To be more precise, Western American Reformed Presbylutheran. Anyway, other episodes have established E-piss-copal (Lovejoy's phrasing, not mine) and Catholic churches. I can't remember if "She of Little Faith" included other Christian places of worship, but it's clear that other ways of finding God, as it were, exist in Springfield.

      Though to answer your question, it's possible that Lovejoy is one of the most highly influential men of faith in Springfield of any faith and that's how losing him would be like losing God.
    • Dr. Hibbert began attending a more "boisterous" church.
    • It's not just the only church, it's the only religious building in Springfield. I mean, Krusty attends the church despite being Jewish, because there is no other way to worship God in Springfield. The only problem with that is the Catholic School Bart once attended.
      • Actually, it's been shown in other episodes that there's not only synagogues, since Krusty's father is a rabbi and his temple has been shown several times, but also a Buddhist temple. Like so many other Simpsons things, it's simply a matter of what is convenient for the plot. Lovejoy's church is a common scene for the show, since it's the one the Simpsons and Flanders attends, and rather than filling up the seats with generic background characters, they put in supporting characters, even if it makes no sense for them to attend, like Krusty and Apu.
      • Yeah about that, why is Apu seen in that church even though he is Hindu? I bet someone got fired for animating that mistake!
      • Again, it's not a matter of consistency, characters frequently appear in settings that makes no sense, it's simply a matter of having familiar characters wherever the main characters go rather than having to design a dozen new ones. Apu and Krusty have no reason to be in Lovejoys church, but go there anyway because they're among the most recognizable supporting cast.
      • "For no reason, here's Apu."

     Why Doesn't Lisa Know About PETA? 
  • Lisa and PETA. You'd think a girl like her would know about them. Then again, she does go back and forth between being wise beyond her years and having the mindset of a child. Plus, not that many people know much about PETA.
    • Maybe Lisa believes all those crazy stories about PETA are just propaganda made up by the conservative media?
      • Didn't Bart say that Lisa was in PETA, after Marge refused to let him sign up for the army? "I think she just answers the phone", was Marge's response.
    • Easy: PETA are jerks. Now, I agree that animals have no right to be treated bad because they are not human beings. But they are not the best people on the most part when it comes to be talking about what's right in my mind. So after Lisa joined (as the troper above pointed out), she saw how bad they were: their leader using insulin (something that was invented using ANIMAL TESTING), trying to Call a Rabbit a "Smeerp" by naming fish "Sea-kittins," trying to get McDonald's to treat their animals better by flipping them off (yes, because a multi-Billion dollar company is going to change the way it does things because a bunch of people give their employees the bird) and about 96% percent of the animals they get are put down. And and that's just the REAL LIFE PETA. Since this is the Simpsons (who exaggerate things), they would be the type who burn down half a town, knock out a family, take their kitten and 'free' it by dumping it off in the woods. Lisa, wanting people and animals to share the Earth without trouble, quit after seeing what PETA really is. FYI, no offense to PETA, but I just don't think they are effective at what they try to do.

     Gonna Run All Night... Why? 
  • In "In Marge We Trust", why did Ned keep running from the bullies throughout the night? Surely it would've been better to just give in and just let them beat him up?
    • It wasn't just the fact that he kept running that was weird. Apparently, Ned's impressively ripped muscles are just for show.
      • Impressively ripped muscles or not, Ned is a total sissy. He wouldn't consider letting himself get beat up, or beating up the bullies as an option.

     Why Don't Ralph & Martin Change Grades? 
  • If there was an episode about Bart and Lisa both being in the third grade, then why not have an episode about Ralph Wiggum in the first grade and Martin Prince in the fifth grade?
    • Because the entertainment from that episode comes from the conflict of Bart and Lisa being in the same grade. It also has quite the plot twist with Bart actually doing a lot better than Lisa.
    • It isn't like Springfield Elementary has a stellar track record for consistency.

     Wrong Voice 
  • In "The Homer of Seville," why does Homer play Rodolfo and Count Almaviva although they are both tenor roles and Homer is clearly a baritone?
    • Also, why on earth would Homer take part in an opera or any kind of musical theater judging by his obvious bias - he called the Phantom 'the gayest supervillain ever', and made fart noises during a performance.
    • I am more pissed off by the fact that Homer, before that episode, has said "D'oh!" in a lying position so many times, and his wonderfully musical voice is only noticed in this particular episode. And of course, it has no continuity whatsoever: he just keeps d'ohing in his regular voice after that.

     Where are All the Teens? 
  • Why oh why, aren't there many teenagers shown in The Simpsons? I'd just thought of that, other than the bullies at Springfield Elementary (Dolph, Jimbo, and Kearney (even though later episodes reveal that Kearney isn't a teenager; he just looks like one), Laura Powers, the Squeaky-Voiced Teen, and the college geeks from "Homer Goes to College" and "Faith Off," the teenage population seems to be extremely low for a small town. It bothers me especially when later episodes show evidence of Springfield University, not to mention Homer/Marge's high school flashbacks.
    • Possibly because there are no teenage Simpsons. There's a baby, some kids, adults, and seniors, but no teens.
    • On the audio commentary for the short-lived cartoon series Mission Hill, Bill Oakley and Josh Weinstein state that they created the show as a response to exactly this (well, not just teenagers, but also young college graduates. Close enough).
    • Law of Conservation of Detail.

     Ned Drives Illegally? 
  • In the episode "Hurricane Neddy", it's stated that the Flanderses don't have insurance because Ned considers it a form of gambling. This wasn't a throwaway gag - the family's lack of insurance meant they couldn't have their house rebuilt, and the shoddy job the townsfolk did when they rebuilt it out of charity broke the dam and caused Ned to unleash all his pent-up anger. However, Ned is shown driving a car in several episodes. Maybe America is different, but don't you need insurance to drive?
    • Ned probably has the legal minimum required insurance for his car. But it still doesn't make sense that he doesn't have home-owners' insurance unless he owned that house free and clear. Mortgage lenders require the buyer to have property insurance as a way of protecting the lender's investment.
      • Who says Ned didn't buy the house in full in the first place? If he thinks insurance is wrong, surly he finds something wrong with loaning money.
      • It's also possible that he inherited the house.
      • Possibly, but keep in mind that he has at least ONE mortgage on it, since the failure of the Leftorium in When Flanders Failed caused the bank to repossess the house.
    • America isn't different. You need insurance and your license on you to drive. This doesn't stop people.
      • Yeah, but Ned has always been shown to be incredibly law-abiding. Driving without insurance strikes me as exactly the sort of thing he wouldn't do.
      • Well it looks like he's got a moral de-diddly-lemma there. What do you do when your moral system says you should follow the law, yet the law goes against your moral system? He probably read over Matthew 22:15-22 a few dozen times, then called Reverend Lovejoy in the middle of dinner to resolve that doozy of a choosy.
      • Marry me.
      • In California at least, you have to have proof of insurance or a certain amount on deposit. Also, maybe Ned sees a difference between insurance-against-acts-of-man versus -against-acts-of-God.
      • We're talking about Ned Flanders, here. He sees EVERYTHING as an act of God.
    • It's established in one episode that Ned is actually a senior citizen - chances are that he's already paid off any mortgage he originally took out on the house; and while he had a mortgage, he would've been required to have a certain minimum amount of insurance on the place by his mortgage lender, which he would have abided with; ditto with needing to have minimum insurance on his car. But he doesn't get any more insurance than is absolutely necessary (obviously he doesn't have any life insurance then).
    • Real-life Muslims are against insurance for similar reasons, and usury is outlawed in Islamic countries. What do Muslims in the US do when buying a car? If they're super-religious, maybe they feel a little guilty while signing the papers. In Ned Flanders' case, just make that "very, very guilty".
      • Or they may set up a surety-bond, or certified deposit which many states allow as an alternative. It's also common for many Christian groups. Even the Amish.
      • There's actually no dilemma. The compulsory insurance required for driving is liability insurance i.e. the type that protects the other guy in case of an accident.
    • Along with everything else, remember that the show has never been strong on continuity in the first place. In one episode, Rod and Todd tell Lisa that Ned considers dice to be wicked, and they only move one space at a time when playing "Good Samaritan". And yet, in another episode that includes a flashback to the 1980s, Rod, Todd and Bart are shown playing the same board game with dice.
      • Well, Ned's religious fanaticism has increased so much over time that he's the namesake for Flanderization. It's possible that in the past he wasn't extreme enough to think that playing board games with dice is a sin. And even if we're supposed to think he's always been as extreme as he is, it's possible that it never occurred to him that it would be problematic to use dice for any reason - even for pure entertainment (as opposed to gambling)- until, say, he heard a televangelist say so.
      • Also note that in the flashback, the dice were in a plastic bubble that was shaken to move the dice, that is to say, kept the children from touching the wicked dice directly.

     *Homer* the Mother? 
  • I heard that the plot for "Bart the Mother" was actually a B-story that had been unused for a long time due to it having no place in the plot. The original story was Homer finding a bird's nest in one of the nuclear plant towers and trying to find a home before the winter comes. Did they ever use that plot? Will they ever use it?
    • Yes, they used it in "Bart the Mother."
      • He meant the original idea, with Homer.
      • Probably not, since they used it in "Bart the Mother".

     Yellow Skin 
  • Why does everybody have yellow skin?
    • That's just how the show portrays Caucasians. If you watch some of the early episodes (like the one where Marge goes to jail for a month), the show's Asian characters are depicted as having pale white skin.
    • Because if they were blue and white, they'd be Smurfs.
    • Alternate universe where man evolved slightly differently?
      • Then why do the Hills (of King of the hill, in their cameo appearance) and the Archie gang lack it?
      • Because that's what they look like in their home media; I guess that's honored when it comes to fictional guest stars.
      • Besides, this troper remembers the promos for 'Bart Starr' depicting the Hills with yellow skin, and it just looked weird.
      • Then why did The Critic's Jay Sherman appear yellow during his two guest appearances?
      • The Critic was a Gracie Films production. They were keeping it in the family; they might have considered animating the Hill family in the classic style an insult.
      • Because the whole joke with the Hills was that it was a split-second cameo from a rival cartoon series, and they wanted to make sure people got recognised them as quickly as possible. With Jay, since he was a guest character throughout the episode, they could use him for longer without worrying that people might not recognise him.
    • Because Matt Groening can't draw.
      • The Animation Studio is the one that originally did that, not Matt.
    • Or he lost his peach colored crayon.
    • If they were flesh colored, some "hair" would actually be pointy bits of flesh, especially for Bart.
    • I think they said it was originally to catch viewers eyes, and it stuck
      • This is true, they did it because they wanted people to think the color on their TV was off.
    • Groening has also stated that he felt flesh-colored cartoon characters looked weird, noting the creepiness of Mickey Mouse being made Caucasian in Fantasia, when he had always been a cartoony literal black and white. I guess he got over this by Futurama.
    • IMDB.com says the characters were made yellow to catch the attention of anyone flipping through channels, and IMDB never lies.
    • It was caused by radiation from the Nuclear Power Plant and waste run-off from the other polluting industries that Springfield seems to hold.
    • Actually, the way I heard it was that all the Simpsons' odd anatomical stuff, like yellow skin, overbite, and hair that's indistinguishable from skin, were because Groening's original drawings were intended just to give the animation crew a general idea. He was actually surprised when they copied his rough designs exactly.
    • Matt's original drawings for The Simpsons (which he came up with in ten minutes while waiting outside James L. Brooks' office) were in black and white. It was the idea of one of the original color designers on The Tracey Ullman Show (her name escapes me) to make them yellow. The idea was so they would look different from anything else on television. Matt loved the plan and considers it one of the keys to the show's early success. Conversely, he refused to color the Futurama cast yellow because he wanted to send the message that the show wasn't just going to be "The Simpsons in space."
    • I said SKIN (as in the muzzle, arms, and belly), not fur (the blue and possibly white stuff)!
      • There's a video on Youtube where David Silverman explains why the Simpsons are yellow. See here.

     Hair 
  • If Homer has brown hair, and Marge has blue hair, how are Bart, Lisa and Maggie all blonde?
    • Marge dyes her hair. She could be blonde, but I think she was brunette in a flashback episode.
    • Homer's mom has red hair, and Marge's hair is naturally blue(but turned gray at 17). Marge once burned her hair brown with an iron and made her whole hair brown for the rest that night.
      • Actually, (as far as I know) Marge's natural hair color is unknown. The reason her hair is blue is explained by Homer in the episode "Secrets of a Successful Marriage"; "She's been as grey as a mule since she was seventeen".
      • In "Fear of Flying" Marge is depicted as a 4-7 year old to look exactly as she does today, except smaller. Same hair style, hair color, dress and pearls.
      • Didn't women that went grey used to dye their hair blue? Around the time Matt Groening's mother would have gone grey?
      • One of my older aunts did, a very dark blue, so you might be onto something.
      • I don't think it was on purpose. I swear there's a trope for that... also other characters on the show have blue hair, like Milhouse and his parents. And a lot of children who are blonde as kids end up with brown hair as adults.
    • Blonde hair is a recessive trait. In real life, two brown-haired people can produce a blond child, so Marge and Homer doing so isn't that unusual.
    • According to "No Loan Again, Naturally" Bart is actually a redhead, and the sun bleaches it blonde. Might just be a one-off gag, but there you go.

     No One "Dug" This Idea 
  • In The Simpsons Movie, why didn't anybody try to get out of the city by digging under the dome?
    • This was lampshaded by Lou in The Fool Monty.
    • Springfield has an average IQ of about 60, and that would be lower without Lisa, Martin, Dr. Hibbert and Professor Frink pulling them up.
      • Plus there were helicopters, soldiers and Jeeps around it to ensure no-one got out. If everyone tried to burrow through the same hole, half of them would be drugged and shipped back in by the end of the day.
      • Yes, but let's not forget that Springfield has its own Mensa chapter; you'd at least expect them to come up with some sort of plan...
      • I remember the episode where Mensa featured. The members probably started arguing about whether to use the giant laser or the giant drill, and got all into a sulk.
    • Frink had an acid drill that could get trough anything. It was just outside the dome.
    • They could've done when no one's watching like in The Great Escape. They were able to rescue Bart from the well by digging to the bottom.
      • Only because they had Sting to help...
      • I doubt they would have been concerned about soldiers and such catching them and sending them back if they had dug. At one point they were doing all they could to break the dome, in clear view.

     How Did Moe Become Emperor? 
  • I have another question about the Movie. While it was a funny joke, how did Moe become Emperor of Springfield? It seems more like something Mr. Burns or Sideshow Bob would do.
    • Wasn't Bob in Italy at the time? As for Burns, when the situation went to hell, maybe the people decided to rise up against him and bring him down from his power for once. Heck, maybe Burns did become Emperor, but then got overthrown by Moe.
      • I forgot about the Italy part. Now that I think about it, maybe it's a good thing Sideshow Bob didn't become Emperor; he probably would have turned Springfield into an Amish community.
      • On the other hand, if Bob had been around, Springfield probably would have prospered under the dome. If only to get them to take off the dome so he could go find Bart and kill him.
    • Um... was Moe ever Emperor according to anybody other than Moe?
      • Well that dome was making them all crazy.

     Don't Ditch the Ditz 
  • For 400 episodes, how come Springfield still allows Homer Simpson to live? As far as I can remember, one of his few good accomplishments to the city was preventing a nuclear meltdown he himself caused by being careless. And, if you wish, in The Movie, he was not only the one to blame for trapping the city in the dome and condemn the whole population to be exploded with it, but also ruined almost everyone's chance to escape the dome. Back to question: what is keeping people of Springfield from throwing him away of town(or even killing)?
    • To be fair, most of the really outrageous stuff only occurred in the later seasons, when they turned Homer into a Jerkass. Before that, his blunders were mostly personal or low-key, and not to the level of sheer lunacy he climbs to in later seasons.
      • They did try to kill him in The Movie. Also, did you watch the episode with Frank Grimes?
      • Yep, I know. But it's still too few times for my common sense to bear. Actually, every time I watch the series lately I think to myself "Yep, I know exactly how Frank Grimes felt now..."
    • There was the 500th episode where they kicked the Simpsons out of town for property damage, but of course it didn't last long, and they can't have the same plot twice. As for killing, maybe they just don't have a death penalty?
      • Yes, they do. It's come up several times over the course of the show.
      • So is that the only thing stopping them from killing Homer?
      • Springfield does have a death penalty.
    • If you're referring to "Homer Defined", Homer didn't cause the meltdown(s). He just averted it by randomly pressing buttons until something happened.
    • If it helps, there’s a fan theory that says that every season of The Simpsons is one year in their lives in different universes (and that also would explain why the characters do not grow old and Bart and Lisa are always in the same grade), thus the most outrageous things Homer does (which I agree with other tropers is partly because the writers really ruined what was a dumb but still likeable character in earlier seasons) would only happen once for the rest of the town.

     Crass Cap 
  • Did the offensive baseball cap actually say Show Me Your Tits?
    • The commentary says that the baseball cap says Show Me Your Tattoo, but you can take that as you wish...
    • In the Spanish- Spain dub (I mean, not the Spanish-Latino), Rod and Todd start reading "Te...", which the viewers assume is "Tetas" (tits). Flanders then drives his kids away while assuring them it says "Teteras" (teakettles).

     Why Not Eat It? 
  • In the episode "Yokel Chords", if Bart was able to get spaghetti to fake a Dark Stanley murder, why couldn't he just eat the spaghetti instead of making up the story about Dark Stanley?
    • Maybe he wasn't in the mood for spaghetti.
    • They explained this, Bart himself came to the realization he made up Dark Stanley because he crazes the attention (more then spaghetti).

     No Scars 
  • Something really bugs me about the episode Moms I'd Like To Forget: Negative Continuity aside, how come we've never seen those scars on Bart and those other kids before? It doesn't seem canon, like The Principal and the Pauper mentioned below. Even in other parts of the same episode(especially earlier on), it's not there.
    • That kind of stuff is hard to animate, so they only show that kind of stuff if it's needed. Krusty has a number of things on this chest (a third nipple, a scar), but has been see shirtless without those.

     Worthless Waiting to Watch 
  • In the episode "Itchy and Scratchy the Movie", couldn't Bart just get the Itchy and Scratchy Movie DVD instead of waiting forty years to see a replay in the theater? On another hand, why would Homer go as far as to ban Bart from seeing the movie ever? I think that was the first sign of Homer being a jerkass.
    • Not if you take the ending as canon. Homer preventing Bart from seeing the movie made him straighten out and become Chief Justice of the Supreme Court instead of a sleazy male stripper. Or maybe Bart became both, like the late Earl Warren.
    • DVDs weren't around when that episode was written.
      • VHS then, same concept, really.
      • Because they had a Beta, and Snake stole it.
      • He probably did see it on DVD/VHS when he moved out, but pretended not to for Homer's sake.
      • He probably just wanted to finally see it on the big screen. It's unlikely Homer was willing or able to prevent him from never ever ever seeing it, but sometimes for some people a film on DVD just isn't the same as at the cinema, especially one hyped up so much like this one — there's old movies I've seen that I'd drop everything to see at the cinema if I happened across a screening. He wasn't exactly hunting out the movie; they just happened to come across it, got to reminiscing and decided 'what the hell'? As for Homer's line, he could simply have been joking.
      • Homer still allowed Bart to watch TV. What if he saw it on TV when Homer wasn't there?
      • Debunked! Tonight's new episode ends with The Simpsons seeing the re-released 3D version of "Itchy and Scratchy: the Movie" at a Drive-In and Bart was there and wearing 3D glasses too!
    • This is a case of both Society Marches On and Technology Marches On, in fact there’s a similar episode of Married... with Children around the same time with Al trying to watch one of his favorite John Wayne movies (Hondo) and there’s a similar Seinfeld episode IIRC. People in the 80s and even at some point in early 90s just didn’t have the same concept as we have today of watching a movie whenever they wanted, there was no Internet, no Netflix, nor DVD or Blue Ray, no buying on Amazon, nor Internet piracy if there’s no other alternative, and although VHS and Beta existed the movies last much more longer to be available on it and the quality was never the best, so people really really was dependent on watching the movies they liked on cinemas or television. Is just that the episode didn’t aged well.

     What Happened to the Pig? 
  • In the movie, whatever became of the pig?
    • I assumed it was killed and eaten by the mob.
    • In a deleted scene, it shows the pig, Santa's Little Helper and the mutated chipmunk helping rebuild the Simpsons' home, and the pig shows up in one of the couch gags at the beginning of the next TV season. So it's probably still alive.
      • It does appear in the next Halloween episode, so it's probably alive somehow. Not that it counts as solid evidence, but still...
      • In one of the comics, Krusty tries to find the pig as his commercials were popular. He gets disguised as Ploptimus Prime and escapes with the family. I forget where he ended up. I think Cletus's farm?
    • It still makes cameo appearances every now and then, usually for a quick visual gag.

     Homer Should be Heavier 
  • Why do the writers always give Homer such a low weight? According to one episode he is 239 lbs. That might sound a lot, but for a heavily built man over six feet tall and given how much he eats it isn't actually particularly much.
    • Must be his metababolism.

     Fat, but Fine 
  • This annoys me too. He says he has to reach 300 pounds to get put on disability. I weigh close to 400, and I don't have to wear a muumuu.
    • When he says he had a glandular condition, he's not in denial. He is only slightly overweight, but his glandular problem swells him out and makes him look fat.
      • What about the episode "King-Sized Homer" where Homer purposely gains weight so he can work from home? That wasn't a glandular problem.
      • Because he deliberately gained 61 pounds of pure fat in days?
      • The glandular problem described doesn't make any sense. If you have a glandular problem, it causes you to gain weight, not weigh the same and look plump. If something is swollen, what is it swollen with?
      • There are plenty of developmental disorders, congenital conditions, and drugs (primarily steroids or other therapy to treat autoimmune disorders) that result in low muscle tone and high relative body fat. Not to mention edema, which is essentially fluid buildup (an extreme version of this is actually the cause of elephantiasis). I've always imagined him to have a cartoon-surrealist version of lost muscle tone and edema brought on by extreme inactivity.
      • There's also the fact that, during the series' early days in the late 80s and early 90s, obesity wasn't as much of an issue as it is now. Obviously, obesity still existed at the time, but it's only in relatively recent years that obesity (both in America and elsewhere) has become a major problem. When the series first started, a weight of 239lb would have been considered much larger than today.

     The Stench of Confusion 
  • Major Fridge Logic in the episode "24 Minutes" (the 24 parody episode): how could Jimbo stay unmasked with the stink bomb opened, if one single drop made the hamster suffer that way?
    • Jimbo has no doubt set off a lot of stink bombs in his time (why else are they making a much more potent one?), he's probably built up an immunity to it.

     Levels of Legality 
  • In Girly Edition, how come Kidz Newz got replaced with the Mattel and Mars Bar Quick Energy Chocobot Hour even though that was barely legal as it is? Was the Kidz Newz even less legal because of child labor laws? And why was the Mattel and Mars Bar Quick Energy Chocobot Hour barely legal in the first place?
    • Probably copyright issues.
      • No, it looked like an advertisement for Mattel in what we saw. It may be more along the lines of excessive chocolate plugging. Or a recurring villain themed on dental hygiene.
    • Kidz Newz probably got replaced for the same reason it was put on the air in the first place: clueless Executive Meddling. The execs wanted more educational programming, but they made Bart into a co-anchor and allowed him to do his sappy human interests stories for ratings, which shows they weren't really interested in education anyway. In the end, they likely concluded that the Chocobot show would draw in more ratings. That, or Bart's influence crushed the educational value of the show so much, that the Chocobot Hour really did become more educational in comparison.
    • The implication is that the ratings for Kidz Newz completely tanked after the Lisa-Bart revamp. It doesn't matter whether the show's more legal than the Chocobots, if no one's watching then it's gonna get taken off the air and replaced.
    • The 'barely legal' part probably comes from the fact that the FCC has strict laws on shows that advertise toys and junk food to children. Namely, the show cannot actually portray the toy as is, otherwise it is classified as a commercial (this is why the dub of Yu Gi Oh changes the card layouts, among other reasons). Realistically, that shot of the "entertaining Mattel products" would get it canned in a heartbeat.

     Homer's Changing Weight 
  • In Homer the Whopper, why wouldn't they look at the Polaroids that compare Homer thin and fat in the Everyman costume and not have his weight constantly changing in the shots?

     Shoe Shopping 
  • Not something that bugs me, but is rather strange. In the beginning of the episode "The Last Temptation of Krust", Marge takes the kids shoe-shopping. Since when did Marge acknowledge the necessity of buying new shoes? In other episodes, she seems to think you only need one pair of shoes and you're set for life.
    • When did Marge ever say that having just one pair of shoes for life was good enough? I don't remember anything like that.
      • It is suggested in the "Homer against New York" episode. Marge and Lisa are watching a pair a shoes in a store window. Lisa comments on how they are nice despite being made of an animal's hide, and Marge adds in a pitiful tone of voice: "If only I didn't already have a pair of shoes", which implies that she won't buy new ones until she wears out the pair she already has.
      • In one episode, she did react to someone having three pairs of shoes as "unnecessarily extravagant". But keep in mind that those shoes belonged to a fully grown woman; I'm sure she wouldn't object to buying her growing children a new pair of shoes occasionally. Also, keep in mind that she buys the shoes ridiculously over sized, so she probably only buys one pair every few years.
      • Owning three pairs of shoes at the same time is extravagant; buying new shoes when your existing shoes wear out is normal.
      • The quote above implies she's frugal, not that she'll only ever buy one pair of shoes in her life ever. Marge is the kind of woman who won't spend money on unnecessary fripperies if she can help it, and if she's already got one serviceable pair of shoes, then she's not going to buy another pair of shoes she doesn't need. She might have took the plunge and bought them if she'd happened upon them at a point when she needed new shoes.
      • And of course, in a Doylist sense it's a meta-joke about how the Simpsons family have styles that never change.
    • New CHURCH shoes. Marge goes all out when it comes to looking nice at church, probably for public opinion reasons.

     Forgetting the Helicopter 
  • In Bart's Comet, the airport may have been on the other side of the only bridge out of town (which of course begs the question of how would they drive to outside places on the other side of town. Yeah, yeah, flexible geography but that still bugs me) but clearly there is at least one working helicopter that Arnie Pye was flying, so wouldn't that be a way to airlift some people out of town? They could have just as easily had him saying something like "And as I own the only helicopter in town, I'm outta here!"

     "Can" We Solve the Mystery? 
  • What was really in that mystery can, according to Word of God?

     Surrounding Celebrities in Springfield 
  • Everyone is forgetting one thing that bugs this troper: how are The Simpsons able to go up to the celebrity guest stars without being pushed away by bodyguards and such, and what are all these celebrities doing in Springfield?
    • Wouldn't you want to visit a town that seems to have everything? As well as that, when a celebrity visits Springfield and consequently, the Simpson family, they have a chance to meet the most interesting characters on telly. Imagine the stories the family could tell!
    • It's especially odd considering the fact that in the episode "When You Dish Upon a Star" from the tenth season, Homer was court order to never be allowed within 500 miles of a celebrity.
    • Not to mention it is small town hell, maybe they may heard of them but the insane fans are almost non existent. Annoyances maybe but when you are famous it is nice to be pushy for once and not worry about the Hollywood biz on your ass.
    • Homer (and Barney, Apu and Skinner) was a world-wide famous musician at one point, don't forget, Lisa is probably genious-level intelligent and Bart is probably nation-wide known for his antics and is the "Wasn't Me" kid. They are probably small-level celebrities in some way. Not that is ever handwaved though.
    • That's an interesting idea - Homer has also been an astronaut, an agent to performers, a fairly successful boxer, a choreographer to football players, a food critic, a television and film producer, an incredibly successful hairdresser, opera singer, assistant to celebrities, paparazzo, softball player, a voice actor, and a TV show host... it's almost more surprising that more celebrities don't know him.

     Homer Knows the Schedule? 
  • In "The Springfield Files" how how HOW does Homer know the "alien" appears every Friday night after only seeing it once? I've tried wrapping my head around it every which way, but I just don't see how he could have possibly known that.
    • Homer's an idiot who based his hypothesis on insufficient data. He just happened to be right.
      • Not to mention that he said he saw the "alien" on Friday night, but he actually saw it at 1:00 AM, so technically it was Saturday morning.
      • And remember, there's a time frame, so they probably couldn't show Homer and Bart seeing the alien again. But you're probably right. Rule of Funny, yes?
    • He was basing his theory on the alien's resemblance to Urkel. Which means there is no way he could have been wrong.
    • That's great!
    Homer: The alien has a sweet, heavenly voice... like Urkel! And [ergo] he appears every Friday night... like Urkel!

     Was the Rapture Real? 
  • So did the rapture actually occur or was Homer dreaming? It's possible that Moe may have sold his sushi place and gotten his bar back, and Marge, Bart, Lisa and Maggie could have been looking for him the whole time he was up there. Also, when did Bart and Lisa no longer have to wear those hairpieces that Marge made for them? Remember, we didn't see what happened to them at the same time when Homer was going up to the Mesa, or otherwise at 3:14-3:16 AM on Thursday, May 19th, 2005. Also, before we see Homer ascending into heaven, it's nighttime, and when we see God undo the apocalypse, it's sunrise.

     Bowling Skills or Lack Thereof 
  • There was an episode where Homer headed up a bowling team, and Mr. Burns became a member because he sponsored it and could use his position to do so. With the exception of Mr. Burns, both teams seem to roll nothing but strikes. So, there comes a point where Homer's team is two points behind and Mr. Burns is the one that has to score the points. How does that work when it was shown that each of the Holy Rollers were as good as the good members of Homer's team?
    • Homer's team seemed to have improved greatly over the course of the season. They might actually have been better than the Rollers when you consider that they made it to the league championship despite the handicap of having Burns on the team.
    • Speaking from experience, two really good bowlers can lift a mediocre bowler quite a bit. WE tied for second place and I was scoring just over 100 points a game. This is not as far fetched as it seems.

     Frank Grimes's Son Questions 
  • The son of Frank Grimes. That bugs me on several levels. Firstly, that Frank Grimes has a son in the first place. Secondly, he looks just as old as Frank at the time of his death. What, did Frank sire him at the age of three? Thirdly, we discover that the long-suffering, inspiration-TV-snippet-inspiring Frank Grimes sired his son because he happens to like hookers. And finally, if Junior is an illegitimate child of a hooker and a good man too busy trying to improve his sad lot in life, how is it that he knows anything about his father's misfortune? I would have accepted the motivation of "Homer is a Jerkass and is deserving of killing" better than this "avenge my father" bullshit.
    • Frank seems like he was an absentee father to me. Junior probably has all sorts of dad issues, and Frank's death just brought it all to the surface and cause him to snap (insanity seems to run in the family.)
    • As surprisingly dark and edgy as "Homer's Enemy" was for The Simpsons, I got to admit it was kind of funny when Frank Grimes, Jr. said his father happened to like hookers. So, Mr. Perfect had a dark side.
      • It sounds more like a thoughtless Hand Wave. You can imagine some exchange between producer and writers: "Wait, but how does Grimes have a son? Wasn't he lonely in that episode he appeared?" "Um... he liked hookers?" "Well, that'll have to work..."
      • Possibly, he was born of a hooker and a man who might have looked like Frank Grimes, but wasn't. So therefore, his mother tried to pass it off as being born to Grimes because Grimes was a hard worker. Hey, Wild Mass Guessing, why not?
      • Grimes' life has been miserable. Being alone and not getting any respect, he visited a hooker to relieve stress.
    • Again, time may pass differently on the outside. Grimes, Senior and Junior may have spent most of their lives outside Springfield and only came in when the former found work and the latter had the opportunity to avenge his father.
    • I think what bugs me most is the fact that Junior would call himself by the last name Grimes, rather then his mother's last name.
      • Either Frank Jr. is ashamed of his mother for being a hooker (wouldn't you be?), he was raised in an orphanage and never knew his mother (in which case how did he learn about his father and Homer, yeah yeah, I know), or he took his father's name out of sentiment and/or so Homer would know damn well who he was avenging. Take your pick.
    • My two cents: Perhaps, to explain the age thing, Frank was really young, say, thirteen-fourteen? Bad schooling or growing up poorly, friends all had girlfriends who put out, he didn't, hired a hooker to compensate? Then, few years later, hooker came back and dumped the kid on him? Then, unable to hold him, a friend looked after the kid while Frank tried to keep in his son's life, but had to transfer to Springfield. Maybe the friend was a mechanic, and Grimey Jr became one while living with them.

     Why Hasn't Ned Become a Man of the Cloth? 
  • Why hasn't Ned become a man of the cloth himself? He obviously knows the Bible cover to cover and does the best he can to live by it. He isn't even Catholic so being married and having children isn't a problem. What is stopping him?
    • A lot of gags hinge on his "Christian humility" being grotesquely hypertrophied; he really doesn't think much of himself. Why else would he treat Reverend Lovejoy as an authority on anything at all?
    • Maybe he just doesn't have the time? He's a single father running his own business, after all.
    • Ned isn't that much of a Bible expert. He forgets which animals the Four Horsemen ride and he seems to think God will flood the Earth again. Played for laughs, of course.

     Why Take the Babysitter Home? 
]
  • In the episode "Homer Badman" he had to take the babysitter home. Why? She showed up at the house without his help. She's a college student so she's definitely old enough to take care of herself. It doesn't seem likely that she walked to the house, since it looks like Homer's driving her through down town to get her back home, so it isn't an issue of letting someone walk home in the middle of the night. The only reason for it is to set the plot of the episode in motion. And usually that's just fine with me, but I woke up this morning with this gnawing on my brain and it's really, really bothering me. Let the most-likely-over-age-21 babysitter take her damn self home!
    • Perhaps it was meant to be a kind gesture for looking after the kids. Also, things can get rougher in some places when it gets dark.
    • It was a cheap way to get the plot going (i.e., the plot of Homer being branded a pervert when he takes the missing Venus candy off the baby-sitter's butt and the baby-sitter mistakes it for sexual harassment). The Simpsons does this a lot.
    • Possibly she had a ride to the place (say her friend) but no ride back. Or maybe she took the bus which only ran till a certain hour. Or perhaps she took a taxi and Homer was just being nice for taking care of the kids. Or maybe...

     Why Does Homer Not Believe in God? 
  • I know this might not sound like much of a Headscratchers entry, because I also know Homer isn't exactly the brightest bulb in the hardware store, but one of his running gags does just bug me. Why does Homer keep saying God doesn't exist when he's actually met Him? Sure it was by way of dreams, but still.
    • Negative Continuity.
    • The fact that he only met god in dreams seems like a pretty good reason to me.

     Why Didn't Smithers Lend a "Hand"? 
  • In the episode "When Flanders Failed", Mr. Burns is attempting to open a can but cannot because he is left-handed. All this while Smithers, who is right-handed, was just standing around doing nothing. Why didn't he just ask Smithers, considering Mr. Burns doesn't usually have any problem admitting to having trouble doing basic tasks that he could be expected to do, let alone one that would require some seriously counter-intuitive torquing?
    • Burns eventually does give in and ask Smithers to open the can: it's possible that it was a point of pride for him.
    • And this was well before "Homer the Smithers".

     Poverty and Alcoholism and Resurrection, Oh My! 
  • What's with Gil's poverty, Barney's alcoholism and Moleman's many deaths?

     What Became of Colin? 
  • What happened to Colin after The Movie and the 19th season premiere's opening?
    • Maybe Bart was right when he sang, "Lisa's got a boyfriend, that's she'll never see again!"
    • This one really bugged me, too. It would have been neat to see how Lisa would be like with a boyfriend. My guess is that it would change the series too much. He probably moved after the whole dome fiasco. A guy like that must've had a girlfriend back where he came from, too. If his dad's a musician he must move a lot.
    • Bart and Lisa always having different girlfriends/ boyfriends and dump them, or being dumped, is just a recurring gag. For instance, in "Trilogy of error", Lisa also met a boy she liked, Thelonius, in West Springfield Elementary. They promised they would meet again in high school. Thelonius hasn't been mentioned again so far, though they both live in Springfield and Lisa could have easily meet him again before high school. I assume she just forgot Colin too.

     Non-American President 
  • In The Movie, how can Arnold Schwarzenegger be president? You have to be a natural-born U.S. citizen to be president and Schwarzenegger wasn't.
    • Simpsons universe had a constitutional amendment which eliminated that requirement? That's how they got him to be president in Demolition Man.
    • For that matter, why not make Rainer Wolfcastle president? It's the essentially the exact same character. And I think there are very few people who wouldn't get the joke (same goes for the EPA guy sounding exactly like, but not being, Hank Scorpio).
      • Scorpio was going to be the villain, but was dropped for some reason. Must have been pretty far in if they brought Al Brooks back in to the voice. Also, Schwarzenegger was actually going to modeled after the Real Life version, but, again it was cut. Seizing control of the East Coast is probably a better ending for Scorpio than becoming head of the EPA, anyway.
      • Hank Scorpio is one of the most fan-beloved characters of all in The Simpsons (Despite being in only a single episode), mostly due to his combination of ruthless supervillain and Benevolent Boss. To make him the straight-up villain, actively working against the Simpsons and the rest of Springfield, would have been a massive kick in the teeth to all the long-time fans.
      • This would make sense. In the episode he was in, Scorpio and Homer got along extremely well, and he was sorry to see Homer leave (and it seemed out of genuine affection). So it would be very off-putting to have him act so antagonistic toward the Simpsons. Plus, why would a guy determined for global conquest settle on being the head of the EPA?
      • In the case of Schwarzenegger probably fear of Small Reference Pools meet Viewers Are Morons: they expected the movie to be watched by a broader audience including non-fans or casual viewers who may not known who Wolfcastle was and would get confuse. Whether this worry was justified or stupid, is up to you.

     Only a Mostly-American Man 
  • Hmm, how and why would Mr. Burns, a self-proclaimed all-American man, have Red Chinese masters?
    • I'm guessing it's a reference to The Manchurian Candidate, so maybe Mr. Burns underwent the same kind of brainwashing procedure as the soldiers in that movie? Even if there's no brainwashing explanation, this is still the same man who expressed no guilt about stealing a trillion dollars from the U.S. government, nor for his actions that resulted in the trillion dollars going into Fidel Castro's hands (just as he was about to give up on maintaining the communist regime because it was bankrupt.) If the Chinese paid Mr. Burns off, it fits with his character that he would do their bidding.
    • You do know that Burns also made shells for the Nazis, like Oskar Schindler, don't you? Except that his worked, dammit!
      • I still like him more than George Steinbrenner.
    • Mr. Burns is also an asshole and hypocrite who would sell out his own mother if he thought he'd get a decent profit from doing so. The fact that he might not be so patriotically wedded to his country that he wouldn't sell it out for his own benefit should not come as a huge surprise, it must be said.

     Attracted to Someone Much Older? 
  • Seriously, what's the deal with Smithers? I'm not talking about his being gay—that's perfectly normal. What I'm scratching my head over is the fact that he's attracted to a 100+-year old trilobite, as Snake once aptly described Mr. Burns. Is he one of those people who's just attracted to much older partners?
    • I don't think he is ever being shown as finding other old men attractive, so that's probably not it. More like, working with Mr. Burns and having to do everything for him gave him a lot of time to get to know him and spend with him, and seeing his power and personality and himself liking to be subservient... something clicked.
    • "As you can see, the real deal with Waylon Smithers is that he's Mr. Burns' assistant. He's in his early forties, is unmarried, and currently resides in Springfield. Thanks for asking!"
    • He might be attracted to Burns' power as well as the man himself. Then add on the fact that Burns is personally and professionally dependent on him...
    • Meh. As far as this troper is concerned, that's Smithers' business and his alone.
      • Just remember that Burns is Smithers' substitute father (after indirectly causing the death of his real father). He loves his "daddy", a little too much.
      • No evidence of him being a substitute father. Burns probably sent him to live with a foster family until he was old enough for boarding school. He was probably a mentor figure for the young Waylon.
    • Love doesn't have to be rational.
      • That was actually kind of sweet.
    • Word of God says that while Smithers is gay, he's really attracted to Mr. Burns, "if Burns was a woman, Smithers would be straight, he's a "Burnsexual"
      • Doesn't explain his dates with John and other gay men.
      • If It's You, It's Okay. Smithers identifies as gay and is presumably attracted to other men, but his attraction to Burns trumps his homosexuality to such a degree that if Burns was female, he'd still be attracted to her.
    • Seems that Burns just melts Smithers in the right way, but Smithers is aware that Burns is (presumably) uninterested. He'll always love Burns, but Smithers has still got his own life, and he's living it.

     What's Wrong with Marge's Sundaes? 
  • What is wrong with Marge's sundaes?
    • Cyanide. Or maybe it's the fact that she actually wants them to eat it. Would spinach have been so bad if your mom didn't dog you to eat it so much?
    • Or maybe it has blue hair in it, like the soup from the Mary Poppins parody or the casserole on the episode where Marge goes to jail for shoplifting.
    • On the subject of food, in the episode "Grade School Confidential", what was wrong with the oysters that it gave Martin's party guests terrible stomach-aches?
      • Seafood in general goes bad very easily if it's not properly refrigerated. The weather might have been too warm, and considering the Crapsack World this series is set in, the people handling the oysters probably didn't do a good job storing and transporting them.
      • That would explain why Martin's father was annoyed: "I told you we should have served cake instead of oysters!"

     Where Did the Others Go? 
  • In "To Surveil With Love", the British guy they hired brought together seven people to monitor Springfield to keep crime down. Seconds later, when we see the surveillance room next, only Marge and Ned Flanders are left. What happened to the other people who were supposed to monitor things?
    • And how was it that nobody ever thought of knocking out the cameras until the end? The clearly didn't like the cameras being there.
    • The others got bored with it and quit. They were volunteers; the city didn't have the budget to pay full-time officers to man the station. And the citizens were either too afraid to knock out the cameras or didn't want to. Remember the cameras were approved by nearly everybody at the town meeting.

     The Pen Didn't Pay 
  • In the episode "Springfield Up", Homer fakes being rich by borrowing Mr. Burns' summer home, and explains that he did it by inventing a condiment pen. How on earth did he not get rich with that pen? It was a genius idea!
    • He was too dumb to actually try patenting it, and by the time someone pointed out what a good idea it was someone else had already stolen it? Or maybe he didn't actually invent one, and was somehow faking it when he demonstrated? I thought the same thing.
    • What bugs me is that no-one has made it in Real Life.
    • Challenge accepted.

     Why Not Sell the Recipe? 
  • In the episode "Flaming Moe's", when Moe steals his idea, why doesn't Homer just sell the recipe to someone else? (OK, Homer's not too bright, but he tells his family, so any of them could have had the idea).
    • I think that's the theme of the episode. Homer is so enraged at being betrayed that he'd rather destroy Moe than profit himself.
    • Also, Bart gives a show and tell in which he intends to make Flaming Moes for the class, so clearly he didn't recognize the value of the recipe. Furthermore, Mrs. Krabappel confiscated the ingredients Bart brought, so she should known the recipe too.
      • She only confiscated it because it was alcohol. She told Bart he could "have what's left at the end of the day". Even though he did bring enough for everyone.

     Lisa Eating Pepperoni 
  • Everyone's talking about the couch gag for the most recent episode ("MoneyBART"), but what's with Lisa eating pepperoni pizza with the Little League team to celebrate their recent win?
    • It was an animation error. After the initial shot, Lisa's pizza appears to be topped with mushrooms and green peppers like what would make sense.
    • Speaking of MoneyBART, during the couch gag in the sweatshop we see the laborers painting on cells. Why? The Simpsons has been painted digitally for years, making all their labor pointless.

     Running for Hours 
  • In "Trilogy of Error", Bart's story eventually connects with Lisa's story (specifically, when he exits the sewer and is bumped on the head by Marge's car). This basically means Bart and Milhouse were running away from Fat Tony and his goons in the caves for HOURS until he crossed paths with Marge. Seems pretty unlikely, unless both parties agreed to take a breather before resuming the chase a few times. This plot hole was even addressed in the audio commentary on the season 12 set.
    • You answered your own question.
    • This plot made no sense! Tell the people!

     Living on Water 
  • "I'm a level five vegan. I won't eat anything that casts a shadow." So... he just drinks water and that's it?
    • Well, it could be water with vitamins, minerals, and other nutrients dissolved in it at low enough concentrations not to make the water opaque. I suppose it depends to some extent on how you interpret "casts a shadow."
    • Keep in mind he also says he was into Yoga "before it was cool". Either he's in his 40s or he enjoys making things up to sound impressive.
    • Given how he acts in his reappearance in Tapped Out, I have my doubts about him making stuff up.

     Waylon's Age 
  • Is Waylon older or younger than Homer? In one episode we see Waylon Smithers as a baby and Homer is 12. But Troy McClure said that Waylon was in his forties. Mutation from the plant?
    • Older, I bet. His dad's body was partially decomposed.
      • That doesn't happen over a few days or weeks? He was hardly preserved, especially where Homer discovered him.
      • It doesn't help that some episodes show Smithers and Homer in High School together.
      • Your argument is moot. Waylon Smithers Sr. was killed prematurely. If it helps, Waylon Jr was an infant when Waylon Sr. died.
      • Smithers Sr. was found by Homer at age 12, but it didn't happen instantly after Smithers Sr. was dumped in the pipe, the debris probably built up around his body over the years, then years later, the water dried up on a hot day and Homer found the body.

     A "Dog Gone" Mystery 
  • In the episode where Santa's Little Helper gets a mate and impregnates her, The Simpsons give away the puppies, but what happened to their mother? (Also, why did they let Mr. Burns make money off the Puppies racing? Homer says at the end he's depressed he gave them away, but they didn't, Burns stole them!)
    • They were giving the puppies away for free, actually. They just didn't want to give them to Burns, hence his dastardly scheme or stealing them out of the box while the Simpsons' backs were to him. In the end Lisa and Bart could see that Burns loved the puppies like any good owner, so they let him keep them. Homer was depressed because they turned out to be champion racers. As for the female greyhound, I'm guessing she eventually was given away as well.

     How Much Does Homer Actually Know About Music? 
  • It bugs me that Homer starts out not knowing a thing about music, but as the show progresses, Homer is seen to have musical talent in several forms: he was in a boys' choir, he could sing opera if he was flat on his back, he was in a barbershop quartet that won a Grammy, he could play a rake with a leaf and make it sound like a guitar, he went to some kind of rock and roll camp and he was in a grunge band for several years after high-school. Many of these examples mess up the continuity of the show. For example, if Homer was a grunge rocker, then why didn't anyone recognize him when he was doing the thing where he gets shot in the stomach with the cannon? If he can sing along with a quartet, why does he sound so bad when he sings by himself?
    • Why, it's almost as if the writers are making things up as they go along!
    • I'm gonna go with the guess that every season has a different continuity. It would make sense that Homer doesn't remember - what with the brain damage and all. And he could be insecure and feels the need to sing with others.
      • Not really. Several events are alluded to across-seasons, like Sideshow Bob's escapades, Homer being an astronaut, Maggie shooting Mr. Burns, Bart owning Stampy, Maude dying etc. etc. That said, the show mostly adheres to Negative Continuity.
    • It's the same as Homer being able to speak french in a high school flashback, yet unable to understand Bart when he speaks it (and I wouldn't be surprised if the show forgets that Bart can speak french as well). Consistency and the Simpsons rarely make for good bed partners. Generally speaking, if the show doesn't bring it up again later such as the examples the above troper mentions, it's probably best ignored. They could have just as easily had Sideshow Bob show up in the very next episode as Krusty's sidekick and had nobody in the cast bat an eye.

     Marge's Misaligned Morals 
  • Why is it that Marge tries to be a Moral Guardian (at least in the earlier seasons), but in one of the Halloween episodes, she has no objection to Bart dressing up as Alex deLarge?
    • It's a classic film. That makes it okay.
    • There's also the possibility that Marge just doesn't know who he is. Marge never struck me as the type of person who was very well-versed in movie trivia.

     Very Speedy Delivery 
  • Here's a bit of Fridge Logic from the third season episode "Black Widower," when Sideshow Bob and Aunt Selma are married. During the episode, the Simpson family is seen watching a VHS recording of Bob and Selma's honeymoon ("And after we watch this, we can tape over it! Heh heh heh."). The events on the tape, which portray Sideshow Bob's need for a gas fireplace (plot point), ends with Selma asking that they make love. This cuts (almost immediately, if I'm not mistaken) to Bob running to the bathroom to clean up after having sex with Selma. This implies that little, if any, time was allowed for the VHS tape to travel from the hotel to the Simpson's home. Like most of the inconsistencies in the show, I presume this is another case of Rule of Funny.
    • It's possible they were having sex on another occasion. Bob would have to continue playing the role of loving husband, after all. But the way it was cut just makes it funnier.

     Unprotected Stomach 
  • In Homerpalooza, why doesn't Homer wear something to protect his stomach? sure it would've ruined the act he was doing but he wouldn't of ended up having donuts from HFIL
    • Because apparently, part of his act is to appear topless to prove that he isn't cheating and protecting his stomach. It is a freak show...

     What are the Un-Smelled States? 
  • In Homer's Paternity Coot, a sign near the tire fire says it's now smelled in 46 states. What are the four states that it's not smelled in? I'm pretty sure it might include Alaska and Hawaii, but I'm not sure what the other two could be.
    • Maine and Florida? They're both on the longitudinal extremes of the Eastern Seabord, so a smell that can be smelled elsewhere might not be smelled there.

     Where's Mr. Largo? 
  • In "Flaming Moe", what happened to Mr. Largo? He found his soul-mate, got replaced and then... his replacement moved away but... he didn't come back. What becomes of the music class? Unless there was a scene showing him coming back and I just missed it...
    • You didn't miss anything. He's back as the music teacher (showing up as recently as Season 30), but how and when has never been so much as alluded to.

     No Voiceover 
  • Can we find a version of Diatribe of a Mad Housewife without the voiceover? Like, maybe on the Season 15 DVD?

     Why Spend Money on People with Housing? 
  • At the end of "Old Money", Grandpa Simpson decides that the money he'd inherited from a short-term romantic partner should go towards improving the facilities at the retirement home. This is after having selflessly decided not to spend the money on himself, after Lisa convinced him that those who really deserved the money were the homeless/sick/needy, and after visiting a casino in an attempt to increase the total amount available (figuring that he could help more people that way). So why does he still spend the money on people already living in private accommodation and who are being looked after by full-time carers, when he'd previously decided there were people far more deserving of the money?
    • To be fair, the treatment the people in that home receive has been consistently shown to be terrible. It's a little selfish to spend it on his own home, yes, but those old people must have pretty miserable lives, living in the cheapest retirement home their families could find, and apparently hardly ever getting visits. Grampa seems better off than the rest of them.
    • You obviously didn't watch the episode. Grandpa's rest home suffered from a leaky roof, damaged furniture (the pool table didn't have any netting in the pockets, for example) and was generally falling apart. Like the previous poster noted, Grandpa and the other rest home tenants were living in squalor, something which is often Truth in Television, sadly enough. Fixing the retirement home allows the residents to live in comfort and dignity, something that Grandpa Lampshades in the last line of the episode when he invites the other residents into the Beatrice Simmons Memorial Dining Hall.
    • AND it's shown in later episodes that the staff are all either lazy (Destroying the "Zii" so the old folks would go back to being listless, and therefore easy to care for; A nurse swapping an IV drip and a full colostomy bag in order to speed up the end of his week...) or negligent ("Okay, let's start by doubling your medication!"). The episode itself depicts one member as a two faced "bloodsucker" who admits to being apathetic to Grandpa besides his newly gained money. At least the BUILDING is nice for the old folks.
    • He'd previously decided to spend the money on people more deserving rather than just spending it solely on himself. As the episode (and the tropers above) make abundantly clear, spending the money on renovating the retirement home is both spending it on people other than himself and spending it on people who would benefit from it. He doesn't spend it on the homeless/sick/needy etc. because even with his wealth he still doesn't have enough to solve the problem in a way he considers satisfactory, and by gambling it he risks losing it all.

     Why Did Bart Wuss Out? 
  • In the episode where Marge starts hanging out with some old friends, and Bart has to hang out with her friend's children, they pressure him into sliding down a hill on an ice cube or something. And Bart has DOUBTS about it, finding it "too dangerous", and doesn't want to hang out with the other boys much. Seriously, Bart is supposed to be a "bad boy". Hell, past episodes have shown him doing MUCH more dangerous things. What was the deal with that?
    • It could be a sign that Bart is starting to mature, or remember that Even Evil Has Standards. Or he knew that sliding down the hill was obviously dangerous and didn't realize how dangerous some of the other things he has done were.

     Why Kill Selma? 
  • There's something I've never been able to figure out about the episode, "Black Widower", and this, why? Why did Sideshow Bob want to kill Selma? The episode indicate that it was premeditated, but what was the motive? I doubt it was revenge because Bart doesn't strike me as someone who would miss Selma too badly.
    • It's said earlier in the episode that Selma won a lot of money in a lawsuit. Sideshow Bob probably didn't plan her murder until sometime after they met and fell in love.
    • Possibly it was a long con. As soon as Sideshow Bob found out who Selma's family was, he was probably planning her death. As soon as he marries her he's technically part of the family. After her tragic death, he was probably counting on the Simpsons being kind and hospitable enough to allow him to stay with them while he "grieved". Voila, instant access to Bart.
    • He seemed genuinely happy with her until he discovered her MacGyver obsession. So while its incredibly petty, especially for him, it looks like he just grew to hate her over a TV show.
    • Bob's pettiness is absolutely legendary, probably second only to his ego. One or the other trait powers all his schemes. Probably just knowing that she loved MacGyver as much as she loved him would do it.

     Why Two Versions of the Credits? 
  • Why are there two versions of Treehouse of Horror XVII? I noticed there's a normal credits version and a halloween credits version.

     Why Worry About Homer? 
  • While I enjoyed the episode "Homer the Great", there was one part about the ending that was a little confusing. #1 laments that "As long as we are Stone Cutters, he will control our lives." Wait a minute, what are they worried about Homer controlling their lives for? He can barely run his own.
    • I think that's the point. Instead of being the power behind the scenes, they're going to spend all their time re-enacting the civil war with monkeys.

     Why Not Skip Church? 
  • The episode where Homer decided not to go to church - Marge and the kids go to church, despite it being so cold that they end up being trapped inside the church due to the ice. Why couldn't Marge just skip one day of church? Why would she risk the lives of her and her children like that?
    • Honor Before Reason.
    • Also, it's not like she goes to church knowing that the church's heating is on the fritz and it's going to get so cold her family is going to be locked inside.

     What Race are the Simpsons? 
  • What race are the Simpsons? It seems that "Yellow" is the equivalent to "White" for Caucasian people in the Simpson's universe, for example Jessica Lovejoy refers to part as "Poor yellow trash" and prior to her birth Homer says it doesn't matter if Maggie is a boy or a girl as long as she has "Yellow skin and four fingers and toes" or something to that effect but the show has referenced "White" people on a few occasions, such as a black comedian on TV comparing white and black drivers and I think on a few other occasions as well.
    • Speaking of this, why did they add the notion that their art style is the actual anatomy of the people? Most cartoons make it seem like an art style, but they're supposed to look like we do in real life.
      • Probably by the time celebrity cameos and other people that were not the original cast started to be depicted in a more-or-less realistic manner. In fact, the Simpsons(the family) might be the only people in the show with that anomaly where your hair and your forehead are indistinguishable(yes, I know, a lampshade was hung).
      • Technically, apart from albinos, no one is really "white", at least in the literal sense, what is commonly known as White in the Anglo-Saxon world is kind of pinkish skintone, similarly it might depend on the country, some people in Latin America or Mediterranean Europe would be considered "brown" by US, Northern Europe or Russia's standard but they are called white in their home countries. Is the same case as how Asians are not really Yellow by any means nor Native Americans have really red skin, they just have close enough skin colors.
    • Back to the original question, its probably impossible to know where the Simpson family really come from, thanks to a mix of Grandpa's senility and Negative Continuity. Having said that, from what little we know about "The Old Country" that Grandpa grew up in as a boy (see: 'Much Apu About Nothing'), its implied to be Ireland, Scotland, or perhaps Wales.

     What's Wrong with Staying Inside? 
  • In the episode "The Ned-Liest Catch" (season 22 episode 22) what exactly is so bad about Krabappel having to stay in a room all day with pay? I'd use that time to catch up on my books and TV shows. Or, if I was feeling more ambitious, it sounds like the perfect time to study and change into a career that's not so soul crushing.
    • Maybe I need to watch it again, but I think they didn't allow any such thing to be brought in. It's punishment, after all.
      • They were allowed. The rules were - shoes remain on, cellphones remain off, and no Wi-Fi.
    • Not everyone likes cooping themselves up inside with books and TV as their only partners?
      • True, but in the episode, people were resorting to staring at cracks in the wall. I think anything else would be better than that.
    • A simple thing called cabin fever. The longer you spend in the same small, confined space without being able to leave, the more you want to leave. And no matter how much you like reading or watching TV, eventually you're going to get sick of doing that and are going to want to do something else — preferably outside the room.

     Conning Your Companions 
  • It just hit me: how can Homer and Bart start playing con tricks on Kent Brockman, Dr. Hibbert and the salesman when pretty much everyone know them? It really hit me with that trick where Bart pretends to be blind. And to have a deaf sister. And apparently be Homer's brother. Yes, what.
    • They're just idiots. Next!
      • You know what the real headscratcher here is? Did they actually plan for Willie to be arrested and not tell him about it?

     Ned Knows Kramer? 
  • From "The Ned-Liest Catch" that kind of bugged me: How can a straight-laced, ultra-vanilla conservative Christian like Ned know who Aerosmith drummer Joey Kramer is, especially to the point that he recognizes him by sight alone? Just doesn't make sense.
    • Ned has Guilty Pleasures like the rest of us, he was once shown liking sitcoms, and he is a fanboy of the Beatles. Rock music is probably another one of his hobbies he does not like admitting.
    • Lots of Conservative Christians enjoy rock music.
    • Or he just learnt about Aerosmith on a Christian Parent's Guide To Sinful Music website.

     Why Attend a Concert You Hate? 
  • In "It's a Mad, Mad, Mad, Mad Marge": If Becky hates heavy metal, what was she doing at a concert during Otto's flashback?
    • It may have been a music festival with metal and other types of music.
      • Correct. The episode says that they met specifically at Woodstock '99, which was most definitely not just Metal acts.

     Maggie's Only Smarter for Now 
  • In the episode where Maggie is believed to have an IQ higher than Lisa, why is it someone as smart as Lisa is unaware that age is a factor in calculating someone's IQ?
    • Because she's 8?
    • Very few people know how IQ is actually calculated (and even fewer know how discredited it is, though the episode may have come out before that). Even if the writers knew, they probably figured that Viewers Are Morons.

     Why Do the Kids Still Help Krusty? 
  • I've had one that's been weighing on my mind since I was 12: Why is it that Bart (and, to a lesser extent, Lisa) still helps Krusty out of every single problem that he has (one or two choice exceptions aside)? Krusty can't even remember Bart's name, let alone all he does for him, which is actually referred to in one episode where after Krusty asks his name, Bart tells him how he saved him from jail, reunited him with his estranged father AND saved his career, none of which Krusty can remember. True, Krusty is a jaded drug addict and cares little for anyone, but you'd think he'd remember such monumental occasions, and you'd also think that Bart would begin to see his "Hero" as not all he's cracked up to be (As I recall, he shrugs off the occasion that Krusty smoked crack in front of him). This may seem nitpicky, but am I really the only one who's been wondering?
    • Bart knows how bad Krusty is, but chooses just to idolize the character he plays on Krusty the Klown Show anyway. In what episode its shown that Homer is such a bad father that Bart looks for father figures everywhere, including Krusty. As for the second problem, the drugs might be affecting Krusty's brain, and Krusty spends most of his time drunk and not able to remember anything anyway.
    • In Like Father, Like Clown, Bart does lose faith in Krusty after refusing to come to dinner.
    • Bart helps Krusty for the same reason Hank Hill still helps Buck Strickland. In Bart's mind everything Krusty does is at worst a minor inconvenience, as Krusty at his worst is still in Bart’s eyes exponentially better than Homer who repeatedly ignores him, physically abuses him, and constantly tells him he’s an unloved accident.

     No Ageing 
  • Are the characters ever going to age, even a little?
    • In Season 1, Marge had a birthday. Homer's had a few birthdays. Bart and Lisa both had birthdays in season 3, plus others later. Yes, I know this barely helps.
    • I mean that's true, but they keep having the same birthday over and over.

     Assuming Milhouse Loves Lisa? 
  • Ok, this is bugging me for a long time and I have no idea how it even works. Ok, in "Homer Scissorhands", Taffy breaks up with Milhouse because she thinks that Milhouse is still in love with Lisa just because Lisa stalked them? WTF!!! I mean there isn’t a single scene, nor even a single line of dialogue, where Milhouse shows himself to still be in love with Lisa, he never mentions her in front of Taffy and he doesn’t even let out a swooning sigh when Lisa intrudes on them at the end. Just what is wrong with Taffy? I mean if I introduce someone I was once with to my fiancee' then this wouldn't happen. I'm guessing Taffy really is so thinly conceived and her story so flat that she’s only in three scenes... and they couldn't even spell her voice actress' name right. But seriously she breaks up with Milhouse just because Lisa stalked them... EXPLAIN EPISODE, EXPLAIN!
    • Two Things: Seasonal Rot and Fanon Discontinuity. Remember them.
      • I actually don't know that those mean. Explain please.
      • Have you tried clicking the links?
      • Seasonal Rot is when fans hate a particular season. Fanon Discontinuity is when they pretend something didn't happen because they dislike it.
    • Alternately, Status Quo Is God.
      • I still say that is the worst excuse for a break-up ever. Also they never reveal why Taffy liked Milhouse in the first place.
    • Would you want to date a guy whose kinda-ex creepily stalked you through the woods? I'd blame him and say he was still in love with her just so I didn't end up buried in somebody's basement.
      • I like to think she had a crush on Lisa, saw that her plan to get Lisa jealous was upsetting her, and she just wanted her to be happy.
      • Actually the problem is why didn't Taffy get mad at Lisa for stalking them while instead she blames the whole thing on Milhouse who had nothing to do with Lisa's meddling?

     Ridiculous Reason for Dumping 
  • In that one flash-forward episode, why did Bart's girlfriend dump him just because he was leaving to save his sister?
    • Bart's girlfriend wanted somebody who could do something with his life and well Bart just can't do that. The reason why he saved his sister, was because she had a brighter future than he did.

     One Flop Costs a Company 
  • What kind of terrible car company only has 82 thousand dollars between it and bankruptcy? Granted the "Homer" was a massive flop, but that one prototype cost Herb his entire company?
    • I'm not sure that it was the cost of the car that ruined Herb's company, it was the fact it was so god awful. He was effectively saying that he's ruined because said car was going to absolutely wreck his reputation on top of costing a huge amount of money to make.
    • Further, when Herb reappears one senses we are meant to take at face value the fact that Homer ruined him. But in a very real way, Homer was a bystander to those events. There was no malice in Homer's actions, just ineptitude, but the true ineptitude was Herb's, since he entrusted the fate of his company to a virtual stranger and even ignored all advice to the contrary. I find I watch the later episode with more sympathy for Homer than Herb, who is being vindictive while ignoring the fact that the real blame is his.
    • You're misunderstanding the episode. Herb's company didn't only have $82,000 left, but each "Homer" car would be priced at $82,000. That's an absurd amount of money to be paying for any car, even a high-class one. The price, combined with the fact that the car was so ridiculous that no one would ever buy it, meant that Herb's reputation was ruined. There are also signs that Powell Motors was in trouble long before Homer came along. In a few conversations with his executives, Herb mentions that Powell Motors is losing ground to the Japanese and "getting killed on the foreign market." Chances are that this was Herb's make-or-break effort to save his company.
    • High R&D costs. All those weird features mean an entirely new chassis design, so producing the prototype probably cost five to ten times that. Given that Herb didn't even bother looking at the thing until the public reveal, he may already have started pre-production, which sends the waste into the millions.

     Stupid Before the Crayon 
  • In HOMR, it's explained by the researchers that Homer sticking crayons into his nose must have been the cause for his stupidity. Seems reasonable at first, but he would have to be stupid enough to shove sixteen crayons into his nose in the first place. Especially at age six.
    • Maybe he was experimenting something and it backfired.

     Headscratcher Blues 
  • In "Bart The Fink", Krusty apparently dies in a plane crash. At the funeral, Troy McClure announces more funeral services later, adding "You must be over 18 for the ten o'clock. It gets a little blue." What does this mean?
    • "Blue" can mean "obscene".

     Why Care About the Church? 
  • Lisa is an atheist, right? But wasn't there an episode where Mr. Burns bought out the town's (only?) church? And then Lisa goes on a crusade to end Burns' control of the church, right? But if she's an atheist, why should she care?
    • She's a Buddhist IIRC.
    • That was actually the episode where she became a Buddhist. Before that her religious beliefs were basically whatever suited the episode best.

     90% Dumb, 10% Geniuses, Why? 
  • Why exactly is 90% of Springfield's citizens idiots and there is a handful of smart ones like Lisa and the members of the Springfield Mensa. Oddly enough the African American citizens are shown to be more smarter and competent with their work like Carl, Officer Lou, and Doctor Hibbert, and they don't pull similar mistakes the other citizens would pull.
    • The Simpsons world is a Crapsack World that doesn't have the same secretly alluring awesomeness that the Warhammer 40,000 universe does.
    • Most of the time when the citizens of Springfield are acting truly, woefully stupid, they're doing so en masse as part of a mob or a fad. Like Agent K said, "A person is smart. People are dumb, panicky dangerous animals and you know it."

     Lisa Can't Have Wine, But with Bart, it's Fine? 
  • How come Marge objects to Lisa having wine yet is okay with Bart?
    • Because Lisa has a hope in hell of being successful.

     Inconsistencies 
  • What's with the increasing inconsistencies in the show? Throughout the series, Homer's dead dream to be a rock star was mentioned from time to time. He was never able to fulfill the dream because of family, and there was even an entire episode dedicated to this. Yet in a newer episode, Homer was shown as inventing the Grunge genre and being a successful rock star for a period of time. What?

     How Did Ned See the Fire? 
  • In "Homer the Heretic", the fire which burns the Simpson's house takes place during church, so how could Ned (who attends the same church as the Simpsons) see the house on fire?
    • For that matter, when is church in Springfield? Other episodes have it taking place on Sunday morning, but in "Lisa the Greek", church is seen happening the same time as the Superbowl. The Superbowl doesn't usually start until early evening, and even pregame coverage isn't until the afternoon.
      • Some churches hold evening services.

     Why Did Homer Jump the Wormhole? 
  • Homer's unbelievable stupidity aside, in the Treehouse of Horror VI vignette Homer³, why did he try to jump across the massive & ever-expanding wormhole in the 3D plane, when he could have at least attempted to run around it and reach Bart safely?
    • Because Bart told him to?
    • Not counting his idiocy, Homer's brain functions in a very bizarre manner. My position is that Homer realized it was a shorter distance to go straight across the hole. It would be longer to go around. On a more logical level, Homer may have thought the hole would have sucked down the sides by the time he ran around. Maybe it was just a gamble on Homer's part.
    • Child in danger = Papa Wolf = precipitous, thoughtless action.

     Speed Bike 
  • In "Girly Edition", it's established that the junkyard is a long distance from the studio, long enough that Lisa wonders if Bart will be able to make it in time on his bike. So how did Lisa get to the junkyard so quickly on her bike?
    • Because she rode it very fast?
      • We're talking a distance so far that Bart would rather take the chopper instead. Is it really likely that Lisa was able to make it to the junkyard on a bike before the Bart's People segment concluded? I doubt it.
      • Or maybe the junkyard isn't that far and Lisa was just goading Bart because she knows who Bart will encounter when he gets there. Claiming to have a chopper could have been Bart goading her right back. Did we ever actually see it?

     Mixar 
  • Why is it that in-universe, there's the movie company "Mixar", but Lisa says she's all their movies... Except Cars?!
    • Presumably in this universe, Cars was made by Mixar. Since it's a transparently obvious Bland-Name Product stand-in.

     Reference? 
  • In the Halloween segment "Time & Punishment", Homer says "I'm the first non-Brazilian person to travel backwards through time!" What's that a reference to? Admittedly, when I was a kid, I thought he said "brilliant."

     Why Not Ask Lisa? 
  • In "Marge's Son Poisoning", Marge is sad that nobody wants to ride her tandem bike with her, yet she only asked Homer, Bart, and Maggie. Why was Lisa left out?
    • Knowing Lisa, some silly ultra-liberal reason.
    • She secretly hates Lisa for being a vegetarian. Remember her mentioning that she slips a little meat into Lisa's food?
    • Uh, I think Lisa could simply be busy at that moment and we just don't see what she was doing when Marge asked her. Man, you overcomplicate something that could be easily responded.

     Nedna's Status 
  • So Nedna's official. But I'm confused on the status: are they married, engaged, or simply dating?
    • Dating.
      • No, they're married now.
      • Edna died, remember? Ned’s single now.

     Having a Cow 
  • The Treehouse of Horror episode "Don't Have a Cow Mankind" makes no sense to me. How many supplies did the Simpsons have to last almost a month trapped in the house? Why did the writers make a real illness like Mad-Cow Disease the cause of the zombie apocalypse? Why wasn't the burger at Krusty Burger spoiled from sitting there for a month? Why didn't the military just take a sample of Bart's blood to make a vaccine? Why was Bart immune in the first place? Why was Shelbyville a safe zone? Why was it that Marge didn't know about communion? Was that a shot at Christians? Did Seth McFarlane make that joke? How does Bart bathing in soup make a cure? How was the cure administered to the munchers? Why the heck wasn't Homer cured? It just raises too many questions.
    • Okay, let's try to answer these in order:
      • The Simpsons have been seen to have a bomb shelter, as in the Tracey Ullman shorts, plus marge has been seen to stock up on literally hundreds of cans of soup from their version of Costco; not to mention that as long as they can force homer not to eat it, their fridge probably has weeks and weeks worth of a normal person's caloric intake contained within.
      • The same way that 'mutated rabies' was the cause of 28 Days Later. It's specifically mentioned that the mad cows are ground up and fed to OTHER mad cows, and then again a THIRD time. So possibly the virus may have mutated as a result of that.
      • Tainted meat being the source of the virus is a reference to Zombieland
      • It's a KRUSTY burger.
      • Because the anti-muncher enzyme probably requires Bart to be continuously made.
      • Because he eats so much Krustyburger that he's immune?
      • Because all the remaining nuclear radiation from the NUKE going off there in 24 Minutes stopped the virus from manifesting?
      • Communion is a Catholic tradition, and Marge has been shown not only to not understand Catholics, but openly despise them. My guess is that the Western Branch of American Reform Presbylutheranism doesn't practice it.
      • Skin and hair flakes, possibly they contained the materials needed to stop people catching the disease.
      • Probably because immunisation doesn't mean it's a cure.
    • The Halloween episode doesn't make sense? Surely not.

     Pointless Food Wife? 
  • Did they make "The Food Wife" just to say "WE KNOW WHAT VIDEO GAMES AND FOOD BLOGS/FOODIES ARE!"?
    • Was this question even needed to be asked?

     Name Inconsistencies 
  • The Simpsons occasionally decides to slightly misname celebrities (as "Woodsy Allen," for example) and licensed characters, but does this so rarely that it's jarring. In one episode, Marvel characters are renamed "The Thung"(The Thing) and "The Mulk"(The Hulk)... why? I'm guessing Stan Lee, who has guest starred on the show, will not sue!
    • Especially when weighed against the startlingly accurate portrayal of D.C. copyright characters like Plastic Man and Marvel ones like Iron Man in "Homer the Whooper."
    • Marge saying "Woodsy Allen" was just a joke about her not knowing his name.
    • The show frequently mentions the real franchise Star Wars. Yet in "Co-Dependent's Day", Star Wars apparently doesn't exist and is replaced with an expy franchise called Cosmic Wars. I know it's done for the purposes of parody, but it's still very strange.
    • To address this and the point above about "Mixar", if you want to refer to another property not owned by your production company directly, you generally have to get explicit permission or pay royalties to the actual owners to use their stuff. Especially for something like Star Wars, this can potentially get expensive. So while the occasional one-off reference might slip under the radar or might come pretty cheap, or the original owner might be fine with you using their character, it's usually even easier, cheaper and less of a headache to come up with some kind of Bland-Name Product Expy that tweaks things juuuuuuust enough so everyone knows what's really being made fun of while simultaneously working out a bit cheaper for you in the long run. Presumably whether they use the real thing or not varies depending on the above.
    • Stan Lee ... doesn't own Marvel Comics ... it wouldn't be up to him to make that call.

     How Many Boys vs. Girls? 

     How Famous is Krusty? 
  • Krusty. On some episodes he's practically unknown local low budget kid's show host, in other episodes he's a media empire on par with Disney.

     Lisa in Denial About Friends 
  • Why does Lisa constantly say that she has no friends despite her friendships with Janey, Ralph, and Alison? it doesn't make sense! Or she just forgets she has friends.
    • Janey has recently suffered Chuck Cunningham Syndrome, possibly due to being a Flat Character.
    • Lisa seems to have a lot of emotional problems. Perhaps she just can't manage to commit to friends. Or perhaps she's really very shy and only acts pedantic to hide her shyness.
    • They were never very consistent with that part of her character. One episode she has friends, the next she doesn't. In the same season no less.
    • Lisa is just happier thinking that she is way too smart to have friends. It has been shown several times that she can't stand meeting a girl of her age that is as smart or smarter than herself. So even if she meets some intelligent, sensible girl she could be easily friends with, she decides not to, so she can keep thinking of herself as a tragically sensitive misunderstood child.

     Bart's Too Bad a Boy for the Baby? 
  • It may be just me, as I haven't seen every episode, but have Bart and Maggie ever had any sort of character interaction at all?
    • Well, he gave her that teddy bear...
    • In "Homer Defined", Milhouse's mother forbids him from playing with Bart, so Bart tries playing with Maggie instead.
    • How many ten year old boys do you know that enjoy spending time with babies?
    • Took 'em two and a half decades, but yes. Season 27's 'How Lisa Got Her Marge Back' has them star in the B-plot together.

     How is Moe Poor? 
  • I don't get how Moe can be completely poor when he runs his own business. He has a pretty damn successful bar with many regular customers, and yet he resorts to using a rope for a belt in one episode?
    • He only has about half-a-dozen regulars - Homer, Lenny, Carl, Barney, Sam and Larry and there doesn't seem to be much drop in trade, judging by the reaction when someone new comes in. And he probably owes a lot of money to the bank for those times he has re-vamped the bar into an English pub, a theme restaurant and a hangout for hipsters.

     Other Multi-Job Characters 
  • Now we know why Lindsay Naegle has different jobs (She's a sexual predator) and with Gil it's obvious, but is there a excuse why Squeaky Voiced Teen, Sarcastic Middle Aged man, and "That jerk who always says "M'yeeeesssss"?" have different jobs every time we see them? This is never explained yet Lindsay and Gil are the only ones with reasons behind their different jobs.
    • The man who says "yeeeesss" is identical to a character who appeared many times on The Jack Benny Program, where he was played by Frank Nelson. So if you want to know why he's had so many jobs, ask Jack Benny.
    • The man who says "yeeeeeesssss" revealed in one episode that he talks that way because he once suffered a heart stroke. If he has a condition that forces him to be in medical leave often (as a heart condition may be), it may be difficult for him to keep a job.
    • Perhaps they're Identical Strangers?
      • I don't think a teenager can hold one job for long thus explaining Squeaky Voice Teen's changing of jobs. As for the other guys, I don't know.
        • There are at least three different Squeaky Voiced Teens, at one point we see all three together.

     Why Didn't the Kids Talk with Their Principal? 
  • In the episode "You Only Move Twice", wouldn't Bart and Lisa have met with their new principal and discussed their strengths and weaknesses before heading to class? Or do the teachers at that school use the "sink or swim" approach? The remedial class notwithstanding.
    • Meeting with the principal is actually very unusual. Generally school officials would just glance over their records and throw them into gen pop.
    • What you're describing is very unusual for an American school. I've never heard of a Principal meeting and discussing anything like that with a new transfer student. They'd just look at the student's file, assign them to a class, and they'd be told what classroom to go to, and that's it.

     A Very Bad Prank 
  • Pranks and Green: This episode has one annoying problem. Why did Andy prank Skinner so badly in the origin for Skinner's strictness? I could understand if it was a small friendly prank, or if Skinner was an a-hole, but he trapped him in a pool full of worms for three days, and turned the cool principal the kids actually liked into a super strict militant principal.
    • Andy's shown to be a huge dick.
    • Yeah, but still, that was a massive Kick the Dog moment. Principal Skinner was shown to be an awesome and fun loving guy who actually made school fun for the kids, and he decided to lock him without food or water in a pool full of worms for DAYS. Just replacing the water with worms was enough, he didn't have to then close up the pool to keep him trapped.
    • It was so distant from the original, fun tone of the Simpsons' Golden Age and Dude, Not Funny!

     What More Proof Does Skinner Need? 
  • In "The Boy Who Knew Too Much", why does Skinner need Bart to admit he was at the Quimby party as proof that he was skipping school, when he *saw* him skipping school, *and* they have his forged letter giving an excuse?
    • He may have not realized he could prove it with those things.

     Why a Million Years? 
  • In Homer Goes To College, why wasn't Krusty allowed to show ''Burning Down The Mouse'' (the one where Scratchy wins for a change) again in a million years?
    • It might have just been an exaggeration on Krusty's part.
    • It might have been too unbelievably violent and gory even for an Itchy & Scratchy cartoon. It's not uncommon; a lot of Looney Tunes cartoons are permanently banned from television for various reasons, too.
      • It's pretty much just the Censored Eleven, and almost entirely for racism.

     Why Didn't Someone See Homer's Face? 
  • In "The Computer Wore Menace Shoes", when Comic Book Guy clicks onto Homer's website (which is meant to be confidential as to who is running it), you can clearly see Homer's face in the frame for a second, until the bag goes around his head. Why didn't someone see Homer's face and figure out that he was running the website? It bugs me.
    • Most Springfieldians are idiots and that bugs me as well. I mean if Springfieldians were smart then they would know "El Barto" is Bart but with a "El" and a "O" added to it.
      • Yeah, but in an earlier episode, Comic Book Guy was shown in Springfield's Mensa group. You'd think he would notice.
    • This requires about as much explanation as the fact that Apu's mother is never suspicious of Marge's claim to be married to Apu on the grounds that the children don't look remotely Indian, or the fact that the patrons of Lollapalooza characterize Homer as a "fat Jamaican guy" solely because he's wearing a Rastafarian hat. In other words: part of the joke.
      • In the case of Apu's mother, it seemed she was suspicious but went along with it because she knew Apu would not be able to keep up the charade for long, and he would have to confess that he was not married after all.
      • So you mean that the sheer stupidity of Springfield is played for laughs, it just horrifies this troper if there really was a entire city full of morons and the stupid have power while the smart are outcasts... then again can the "smart" characters be funny too?
      • What do you mean? The "smart" characters are often hilarious for many reasons, just not for dumbness, Skinner and Professor Frink are two of the funniest characters, especially Skinner with all his quirks, his Norman Bates-like relationship whith his mother and his Vietnam background. That said, as other tropers point out, most of the citizens are not stupid, they're just average and the humor comes from things like cynicism, satire, dark humor and other stuffs that may be confuse for stupidity for the not very careful viewer.
      • I'm not sure if depicting a character (or everyone) as comically oblivious is the same thing as depicting them as stupid.
      • Maybe Comic Book Guy doesn't know who Homer is?
    • Why has everyone failed to mention just how exactly did Homer's actual face show up on the website? We're expected to believe that he put a picture of himself on the website, then went to all the trouble of finding a picture of a paper bag and layering that over the picture of his face? Why didn't he just use a picture of himself wearing the paper bag mask that he clearly owns? And why, oh why, oh why, doesn't Comic Book Guy have a faster internet connection? In the episode where Homer sets up his Hypo-global-mega-net company, he's shown to have a very advanced knowledge of computers, and I'm fairly sure he plays MMORPGs, which would require a decent internet connection...
      • I know I'm the original poster, but I'm fairly sure that this was part of the joke. Homer is so stupid that he would do that. And about the internet connection, in the Compu-Global Hyper-Meganet (I looked it up) episode, it took him about a minute to download a pornographic image. The Computer Wore Menace Shoes was made 2 years after this episode. I know The Simpsons uses Negative Continuity, but he could have got a bit faster. Also, as a website programmer, I'm sure that you can't layer pictures on top of one another.
      • Maybe it was a .gif?

     Why Isn't Martin at the Gifted School? 
  • In Bart the Genius, Bart wrote his name on Martin's intelligence test papers, which allowed him to attend a gifted school. At the end of the episode, he admitted to cheating on the test. So shouldn't Martin be attending the gifted school instead of continuing to attend Springfield Elementary?
    • Maybe because he personally doesn't want to?
    • Bart admitted to Homer that he cheated on the test; we don't know if the school board was ever informed. It's possible Bart just dropped out of the gifted school without publicly coming clean about having cheated.
      • He told the psychologist.
    • Maybe he never said how he cheated, and the school didn't pursue it? If they didn't know what he did, they wouldn't know there was another boy who qualified at Springfield Elementary. Skinner certainly wouldn't have helped them, as he's desperate to keep his good students where they are.

     Employee Name Amnesia? 
  • This troper and a friend are still debating about this, now Mr. Burns is known for constantly forgetting Homer's name, now she thinks it's because Burns is a evil boss and evil bosses are known for forgetting names on purpose For the Evulz, now I believe the reason he forgets his name is because Mr. Burns is senile, he is so senile that he believes Greta Garbo is still alive... so which one of us is right?
    • It has been well establish that Mr. Burns is senile. He also seems to be stuck in the late 19th century.
    • He also has hundreds of employees and he doesn’t care for them at all, nor seem to remember the names of any other than Smithers, in fact this is shown in the episode when he develops a crush on Marge. Of course you would think he would remember after all the protagonism that Homer had in several episodes but that's part of the joke, that he cares so little about even him.
    • Homer has so often antagonized or humiliated Burns, sometimes in spectacular fashion you'd think would cause a permanent grudge (e.g. "Two Cars in Every Garage"), it doesn't make sense why he wouldn't remember him. That's why I've interpreted his failure to remember him more as a continuity-reset gag along the lines of "They killed Kenny!" from South Park.

     Why Do Only the Octuplets Age? 
  • Why is it that Apu's children age (going from newborn babies to toddlers attending preschool) when no one else does?
    • Same thing with Sideshow Bob's son, Gino. It's probably because toddlers are easier to work with - they can do a few things older children can do, but still require the same amount of care and attention babies do.

     Ralph & Milhouse Aren't Smart, Right? 
  • In "Bye Bye Nerdie", Lisa concludes scientifically that school bully Francine Rhenquist, purely on instinct, only beats up the smart kids. Then why did she also pick on Milhouse and Ralph Wiggum? Milhouse may be nerdy, but he's not particularly smart, and Ralph Wiggum...well, he a former trope namer for the exact opposite of "smart".
    • Well if Lisa's theory about Francine is true then why do the bullies pick on Bart? Bart is not a nerd he's a bad boy just like them but with standards.
    • Personally, I think that Francine would just beat up almost anyone she didn't like and that Lisa's explanation was a coincidence.
      • Milhouse's intelligence varies depending on the episode. In certain episodes it shows Bart calling him book smart and has him applying Chemistry analogies to every day situations. And in others, he's not. And Ralph Wiggum was in the locker with Milhouse, but he never said that Francine put him in there. For all we know, Ralph stuck himself in the locker on his own.
      • Doesn't help that it's mentioned and implied three times in the series that Milhouse is inbred and that can explain why he's a dumbass.

     Why You Little *What*? 
  • One would wonder what comes after "Why you little.." every time Homer shouts it?
    • In Wedding For Disaster, Homer says, "Why you little bastard!"

     How was Skinner a Soldier? 
  • In Sweet Seymour Skinner's Badass Song, Skinner is shown to be a trained soldier and decorated sergeant. This would count for his records, his reputation with his fellow soldiers and senior officers as well as some numerous mementos from his days in Vietnam, including a photo of him and his platoon. So if The Principal and the Pauper is to be considered canon, how the hell did Skinner get away with flying so low under the radar within the army that not one single person ever realized that they were leaving the lives of many soldiers in the hands of a single untrained punk from the streets with no actual experience in command, even if his own men hated him?
    • Simple. They don't. Skinner, who had been reached and changed by the real Skinner, says he asked that he be one to notify Mrs. Skinner that her son was dead, and when she mistook him for her son, it's only then that he pretends to be Skinner. But aside from a one-off joke when Lisa, after losing Snowball II and her replacement cats, decides to save on new dishes when she finds a cat identical to Snowball (Skinner questions the morality of this, Lisa calls him by his real name, Skinner drops it), it doesn't seem canon due to the show's severe Negative Continuity.

     Why Audition in the First Place? 
  • Radioactive Man deals with Milhouse's hatred of being an actor. However, that pretty much starts immediately after the audition where he's chased home by a swarm of would-be fans. Clearly Milhouse never wanted anything to do with acting, so why did he audition?
    • I haven't seen the episode for a while, but I'm pretty sure it's explained that Milhouse's mother made him audition. Problem solved?
    • Maybe he decided to audition just for a laugh and didn't expect to actually get the part. Or maybe he didn't quite realize how much of a pain the hard work and the fans would be.
    • Yes, Milhouse's mom pushed him into it. And he only happened to get hired because he was there during Bart's audition- he never actually read script.
    Milhouse: Mom! Don't make me do this! I don't wanna be an actor.
    Luann: Nonsense. You're going to be great. Now take off those glasses, so they can see your beautiful eyes.

     Why Weren't They Suspicious? 

     Homer & Marge Tracking Bart Questions 
  • A lot of the sequences with Homer and Marge tracking Bart on the website in "Lost Verizon" bug me. First, Bart is tracked by his own face. How weird is it that they somehow hacked the website to show Bart's own face wherever he was? Second, the website was upgrading Bart's position about 100 times a second. How? Third, Marge somehow was able to continue tracking Bart via the Internet while she was in a car. How? HOW? Fourth, the bullies have their own position on the map. Invasion of privacy, much? There's a couple of others, but those are the ones that stand out...

     Why is Homer's Life Great? 
  • What I don't get about the Frank Grimes episode is why does Frank say that Homer's life is so great? I mean, if he looked into Homer's life a bit more, he would know: His mother left him when he was young (giving him major issues for a good part of his life), his house is falling apart, his car is a shoddy jalopy made from old Soviet tanks, his wife was going bald from stress, his son is failing in school, his oldest daughter is a bullied outcast, working at the plant has killed his sperm, he has massive head injuries and a heart problem, when he was sent into space a carbon rod stole his thunder (for the SECOND time), he when he met Smashing Pumpkins it was through a mix of his kids calling him old and almost KILLING HIMSELF in a side-show, had a long, drawn out fight with former president Bush, and dropped out of the public eye after winning a Grammy.
    • Maybe it's because of all the Jerkass and idiotic things Homer has gotten away with why Frank says that Homer's life is so great.
    • That's just it; he didn't look properly into Homer's life. He saw Homer getting away with idiotic stuff, and when he was at the Simpsons house, they were trying to win him over, so everything was presented as best they could; Frank was already too angry at Homer to realise they were making an effort for him, and assumed that the kids were always polite, and they always had the best, and he didn't ask for the stories behind the pictures. If he'd got to know more about Homer, he'd have realised how things really were, although even then, Homer still has more than he does, for less work, and no matter how being an astronaut and winning a Grammy turned out, those were both still amazing experiences for Homer. Basically; Frank didn't see everything about Homer's life, and even if he had, it was still better than his.
      • Its true that Homers life is better than Grimes, but not nearly to the extend he seems to think
    • (a) Consider the source of the complaint. Frank Grimes was abandoned at the age of four, spent most of his life either working in menial drudgery or studying, was once blown up in a silo and had to teach himself how to use his body and feel again, is nevertheless single, ignored, overlooked and downtrodden, and lives below a bowling alley and above another bowling alley. He's bitter and resentful, and compared to what he's had and got, anything is an improvement. (b) Grimes isn't exactly wrong here. Homer's still got a pretty great life and family, has won a major music award, toured with some of the biggest acts of the 1990s, met two former Presidents and been to space. Regardless of the chaos involved in all of them, that's still nothing to sniff at.

     More Incompetent Than a Carbon Rod 
  • How did the carbon rod steal Homer's thunder in Deep Space Homer twice? Why did the carbon rod become worker of the week and take all the credit for saving the day? I guess everyone must really hate Homer, and they felt that he never deserves to be happy or succeed/achieve at anything.
    • Well, it's kind of a good metaphor for real life. Lots of people don't get credit. There's the man who works hard all the time but stays in the same low-level job, while some idiot who doesn't know what he's doing gets onto the chairroom board just because he's related to someone. Or take a movie. This is something even this show pointed out; the director, lead actors and guys like that get awards, but not the boom-mic operators or guys like that. Sure, their names are in the credits, but most people don't read all of them. Or take history. We celebrate Columbus for finding the new world, but native people had been there since the stone age and vikings landed in Nova Scotia in the Dark Ages. Thomas Edison got credit for the inventions, but he had hundreds of men helping him make prototypes. Elvis is famous for Blue Suede Shoes, but Carl Perkins sang it first. Lots of people don't get credit for their hard work, (albeit, most of them were likely not as big of jerkasses as Homer), and some of them are OK with that, just being happy that they worked hard to make something great.

     Carbon Rod, Part 2 
  • Why, in God's name, does Burns give the award to an inanimate carbon rod??
    • One, it's Rule of Funny, two, it's a running gag of how Mr. Burns doesn't know who Homer is (even after the many times he's crossed paths with Homer and his family), and three, it shows that Mr. Burns only cares about money and material goods rather than people (like when he hired a rescue dog to be vice president in "Homer's Enemy," how he had a brick replace Homer while he was in the hospital on "Homer's Triple Bypass," and how he nearly pulled the plug on Homer because it was costing Burns too much money to keep him on life support in "So It's Come to This: A Simpsons Clip Show.")
    • We simply could not function without his tireless efforts.
    • It's also a joke at how shit Homer is at his job. He's so bad at it that an inanimate piece of carbon is more deserving of being named employee of the month than he is.
]

     Forgetting Bart and Lisa? 
  • How did Mrs. McConnell forget Bart and Lisa on the field trip to Capital City when they were going back to school? Wouldn't she have noticed if they weren't there?
    • She's an adult in The Simpsons. She may be smarter academically than most of the others, but she still has idiotic tendencies; her's being that she relies completely on the buddy system, and therefore only notices when one child is on their own. If everyone is paired up, she assumes everything is fine.

     Why Blow Up Springfield? 
  • Aside from becoming the most polluted city in the history of the planet, why exactly else did Springfield deserve to be blown up in The Movie?
    • I thought it was because Cargill got scared some more citizens would escape, or someone would spot this doomed city and wonder what was going on, and since he was insane by this point, decided the best solution was just to destroy the place altogether.

     Kang and Kodos are Canon Now? 
  • The Man Who Came To Be Dinner. What are Kang and Kodos doing in a canon episode? Have the show makers forgotten their own rules?
    • They also appeared in Gump Roast.
      • Yes, but I heard that that episode is also considered non-canon. Maybe this episode will also be!
      • In The Springfield Files, the FBI asks Homer which alien did he see (Kang or Kodos was among them) and in Sideshow Bob's Last Gleaming had a small yellow alien with a probe. So at this point I think it's safe to say that aliens do exist in canon episodes.
      • Actually, The Springfield Files is also non-canon, so the only alien known to exist in canon episodes so far is the one from Sideshow Bob's Last Gleaming.
      • There is nothing to suggest 'The Springfield Files' is non canon except for Mike Reiss describing the single scene showing Kang as "the most illegal shot in Simpsons history". Also, there is an alien featured in Homer The Great, named Number 51.
    • Also, while we're on the subject, given that The Simpsons is notorious for Negative Continuity describing any episode as a "canon" episode quickly starts to put us on shaky ground.

     American Kid, Indian Accent 
  • In the Season 16 episode Future-Drama, Apu and Manjula's son Anoop talks to Bart. Why does a child born and raised in the United States speak English in an Indian accent? It's highly unusual for second generation Americans not to have American accents. Unless he's spent his entire life in a room with only his parents speaking English to him, he would develop an American accent at school and from public and media. I say this as a second-generation Australian. I have a general Aussie accent. My parents don't.
    • As a fellow Australian, you must have met young Vietnamese and Chinese children that speak english with an accent due to learning their parent's native language at home before learning english later on. Presumably Apu and Manjula speak Hindi to each other at home (and have been shown to in episodes). The children would pick up on that, as well as the accent; they would probably lose it as they start coming into contact with more American-accented children, such as in preschool. But at such a young age, it's not strange.

     Lisa in the Woods 
  • What's up with Lisa in "You Only Move Twice"? She seems to be out in the woods (without a grown-up, I might add) at the same time Bart is in school. What's up with that?
    • Perhaps the second grade class is on holiday?

     Why Does Marge Sell Expired Meds? 
  • In "We're On The Road to D'Ohwhere", Marge is perfectly happy to sell expired prescription drugs - but how could someone like Marge even consider doing something like that?!
    • She might be consider it a good thing, to be giving people who need medication at far cheaper prices than normal, and too naive to realize people were abusing them.
    • Marge may be naive, but she'd usually have enough sense to realise that selling expired medication to others is extremely dangerous.

     Marge's Hair Length 
  • Watched the episode The Way We Was a year ago, Marge's hairdo was just as tall when she first styled it the way it is for the senior prom as it is in the show's present. Earlier in the same set of flashbacks, though, it was shorter and straight. Even with filling, there is no possible way it could have reached as high back then as it does nowadays.
    • Extensions?

     Same Field Trips, Different Grades 
  • Why do Bart and Lisa go on the same field trips? They're two grades apart, and there aren't any third or first graders with them.
    • The plot of that episode was Bart being moved down to grade three and Lisa being moved ahead to grade three.

     Cast of Amnesiacs? 
  • I've been meaning to ask this but why do characters contradict themselves and forget events from previous episodes and in turn create lots of series continuity errors? Such examples are when Marge thought Grandpa was gay just to brag to Helen Lovejoy, why doesn't she remember that her sister Patty is a lesbian, also in "Fear of Flying" Marge had a fear of flying the whole time yet she flew to Washington in "Mr. Lisa goes to Washington" without throwing that fit. Or why was Sideshow Bob watching "That 30's Show" on TV yet in his previous appearance he almost nuked Springfield unless they get rid of all television. Plus there's the whole issue of Cosmic Wars existing in the Simpsons verse even though Star Wars has existed the whole time and was parodied and mentioned by name hundreds of times. Why do they allow Continuity errors to happen? Aren't the writers afraid of being fired of making a continuity error so bad that it might confuse a viewer and die hard fan? The only time someone pointed out a continuity error is when Comic Book Guy pointed out that The Simpsons did have a horse and Marge did have a gambling addiction.
    • I've said it before and I'll say it again: Negative Continuity.
      • The question is why does Negative Continuity even happen, let alone allowed to happen?
      • A better question is why is continuity important?
      • So they would remember the things they did in the past and it would make sense. It's like the only time Continuity is canon is if a character died and they stay dead... yet Dr. Marvin Monroe and Dr. Nick Riviera somehow survive their "deaths".
      • Negative Continuity happens because The Simpsons is fundamentally absurdist, depends mainly on Rule of Funny, has been running for almost thirty years while the characters haven't aged at all, and the same people writing it today aren't necessarily the same people who were writing it two/five/ten/twenty years ago. For these reasons, adhering to a strict continuity would probably only make things worse, or at least harder than they had to be. At least the writers are honest about it.
      • Well, I recommend you the Youtube channel The Real Jim and his "The Simpsons Mysteries" episodes were he examines some of these stuffs. One fan theory is that every episode of The Simpson happens in the same year, if you take every single episode and take away the episodes where all the family is together some episodes may have happened simultaneously (for example, those starred by Bard and/or Lisa and those starred by Homer and/or Marge), another theory is that The Simpson actually exist in a multiple universe reality with different seasons and/or different episodes been in parallel realities which would explain things like having Bart passing to the same grade more than once or having them celebrate the same X Mas several times, and an interesting declaration from the current showrunner that if the show ever ends he would like for the last episode to have them preparing for the X Mas school event that they went in the first episode thus ending the show in a eternal loop, so in short, their timeline make no sense and we can't even be sure if the episodes are concurrent (for example, if Lisa Goes Washington is after Marge got over his fear of flying).
    • The writers think that continuity is disposable if it hinders the story. Thankfully they only get rid of it either when it would seem like nitpicking or when it would conflict with a decent story. That's good...unless we're talking about "The 90's Show." That's bad.
      • But it comes with a free froghurt!

     Why Aren't Futures Canon? 
  • Why are futures even considered non-canon in the first place?

     Two Questions Regarding Lisa 
  • You know what grinds my beans about Lisa, are two things: First, she thinks failing gym class will stop her from becoming President. Hasn't she heard of Franklin Roosevelt, who was secretly crippled due to polio? Second, in the ending of Pranks and Greens, she called Andy a loser, even after getting a writing job for Krusty. I mean, what the heck?
    • Hypocritical Humor, Soapbox Sadie, and Know-Nothing Know-It-All. We might as well combine all three and call it The Lisa.
      • Can you be more specific please?
      • Read the tropes. Lisa is practically a poster child for all three.
      • The way this Troper sees it, with the first point, Lisa hates failing anything. She feels that any blot on her permanent record will stop her from succeeding in the future- remember when she pitches a fit because she gets less than an A for conduct at the end of the year? Also, at the end of Pranks and Greens, she calls Andy a loser because she views him as being unoriginal, as he is planning to use the exact same material he was using back in Elementary school, meaning that he hasn't grown up in the slightest. It's been a long time since this troper saw that episode, though, and with many other episodes in between, it may be a bit fuzzy now. Feel free to argue, the recollection of the episode Pranks and Greens may be less than perfect.
    • Remember, Bart and Lisa are 10 and 8 years old. They are prone to having overactive imaginations (Bart thinks $500 was a fortune after all) because they are very impressionable. So just because what they think is true, doesn't mean it is.
      • Would her attitude on University of South Carolina ("I will not be a Gamecock!") and thinking people from Brown wind up as frequently wasted bus drivers like Otto add up to that?
    • Following on from a couple of the above points, think about Lisa's position. She isn't exactly the most popular child at Springfield Elementary, and she's been shown being bullied. Certain previous episodes have explored her feelings that she's not as pretty or mature as her classmates, and she's prone to developing crushes on boys who may not reciprocate her feelings (which is completely normal for an eight-year-old girl). All she feels she has left is her intellectual ability, which is far beyond that of her classmates, and even some of the students older than her. She's set herself impossibly high standards for academic achievement, because she feels like it's the only thing she's good at (with the exception of her sax), and if she fails in that, then she must be a failure in general.
    • Lisa, like a lot of rather neurotic people, has a tendency to catastrophize. In her mind, any problem will automatically have the worst, most disastrous outcome rather than a rather more likely, less disastrous outcome.

     Video Game Characters Turning Evil? 
  • In "Marge Be Not Proud", when Bart is thinking about stealing the Bonestorm video game, why are Mario, Luigi, Donkey Kong, and Sonic, the good guys, persuading him to steal?
    • Because the point wasn't that they're good guys, but that they're video game characters.
      • And they're Bart's imagination, likely his way of justifying stealing the game.

     Karl 
  • The character Karl in "Simpson and Delilah" really baffles me; I mean, he basically shows up out of nowhere, throws his entire life under the bus for Homer, a man he's only just met, and then disappears forever. One could say it's Rule of Funny, except his character, by Simpsons standards, is played pretty seriously. Seriously, does anyone have ANY ideas about the logic behind his actions?
    • It's been suggested that he's gay; the Simpsons Wiki at least has a lot of info on the subject matter. He was also supposed to reappear with his male lover in a later episode, but his voice actor declined. To summarize, he's probably an extremely intense man who also happens to have a serious crush on Homer, and probably vanished after he realized his advice did Homer wrong.
    • He got fired from his job, probably realised that Homer wouldn't return any feelings he had for him, and decided to just leave town and start anew somewhere else. He wouldn't be the first.
    • A popular fan theory is that he was Homer's guardian angel. Presumably before he decided it would be better to appear as Colonel Klink.

     Burns is Younger Than Abe? 
  • Abe Simpson is generally somewhere in his 80s, bordering on his nineties. If Mr Burns isn't treated super-ancient for laughs, he's a centenarian. If so, why in "Curse of the Flying Hellfish" is WWII-era Burns treated quite younger than the 40-year old looking Abraham? Not just in appearance, but in attitude as well.
    • Negative Continuity. This was before they decided to make Burns a one note joke about being incredibly old (it was around this time that he told Homer that he was only 81). As to why Burns looks 20 years younger than Abe in the flashback, it could be that Abe is older but takes somewhat better care of himself in his senior years, and in general is built differently than Burns. It could also be that Burns, in his youth, just looked young for his age.

     Nonsensical Line Writing 
  • Now we know in the opening Bart would write messages in the chalkboard because he is being punished by Mrs. Krabappel but why are there times Bart writes things that make no sense and have nothing to do with bad behavior such as "I am not a 32 year old woman", "All work and no play makes Bart a dull boy", "There are plenty of businesses like show business", "This is not a clue... or is it?" (this made people think Mrs. Krabappel shot Mr. Burns), "I'm so very tired", "Does any kid still do this anymore?", "Je ne parle pas français ("I do not speak French.")", "Have a great summer, everyone", "I will not wait 20 years to make another movie.", ""End of Lost: It was all the dog's dream. Watch Us." and "It's Kristen Schaal, Not Kristen Schall". Now why would Mrs. Krabappel make Bart write these nonsense messages?
    • Because it's a credits gag joke and nothing more.
    • In some cases (such as him claiming to be a 32-year-old woman), it's likely a combination of Bart Simpson insisting on making outrageous claims and Mrs. Krabappel looking for any excuse to punish him. It's also possible that she leaves for a smoke before Bart starts writing so he's free to write whatever he wants.
    • As for the "I am not a 32 year old woman" one, it's obviously a reference to Nancy Cartwright, Bart's voice actor, a female who was in fact 32 years old at the time that gag aired!
    • "All work, no play" might've been because he was slacking off and just happened to resemble The Shining, "There are plenty of businesses like show business" might be because Bart was saying, "There's no business like show business" over and over to be annoying, "I'm so very tired" might've been because Edna asked Bart to take a break and he said no on account of not being tired, "Je ne parle pas français" might've been because he falsely claimed he could speak French to be impressive, and the Kristen Schaal one might've been to correct his spelling. Still no clue on "This is not a clue", "Does any kid still do this anymore?", "Have a great summer", "I will not wait 20 years", and "End of Lost", though.

     Why Does Marge Affect the Chick Vote? 
  • In Homer Alone, Mayor Quimby demands that Marge be released from prison because otherwise he would "kiss the chick vote goodbye". While it's obvious Quimby would care about the chick vote, why would Marge being in jail affect how the chicks voted? And Marge's opinions usually don't seem to be popular with the public (like in A Star is Burns when Marge has a reputation for suggesting ideas that the townspeople don't like, or in $pringfield where they all expect Marge to be against legalized gambling, though those instances came after this episode). Although before that she was successful with her SNUH campaign in Itchy and Scratchy and Marge, but for the most part it seems the townspeople (especially the women) don't really respect her enough.
    • It's not so much Marge that the other women sympathize but the situation that got her arrested — too much pressure from the relentless demands of being a stay-at-home mother. Other stay-at-home mothers often feel overwhelmed by the burden of putting the rest of the family above themselves and it especially galls them when they think their sacrifices are not appreciated.
    • Quimby doesn't seem to have a lot of respect for women in general, given what a sex-obsessed sleaze he comes off as, so he probably figures all women would stand together and didn't account for individual different opinions. Also, like about 99% of Springfield, he's not particularly smart.

     Why are Bart and Grampa Idiots? 
  • If the Simpson gene is now considered non-canon and it's a crayon up Homer's brain that makes him dumb, then what explains why Bart and Grampa are idiots? They can't have crayons up their brains too!
    • Grampa's senile and Bart is actually shown to be quite clever on occasion, he just can't be bothered most of the time.
      • Bart also uses television as an excuse for not remembering things. And for the same reason as Naruto, Bart was neglected and put down one time too many by a heartless kindergarten teacher. As a result, he had to focus more on making a spectacle of himself just so he could be noticed. Whoa.....
      • So Bart is dumb by choice? Is it even possible to be dumb by choice?
      • Barts intelligence varies depending on the episode, but most likely its a combination of ADD, poor attention span, and plain old "just does not give a shit". Bart doesn't care about school, he doesn't care about learning, or much of else for that matter, which translates into what looks like low intelligence.
    • I don't really understand the question. Why would you need a specific explanation for why Bart and Grandpa are stupid? Some people are less smart than others—isn't that explanation enough?
    • Not being academically smart doesn't make you an idiot, that way of thinking was over like in the 60s, by psychology, neuroscience and pedagogy at least. The multiple intelligence theory (and theory in the scientific sense of fact, not hypothesis as is commonly thought) says that Albert Einstein and Michael Jordan are equally smart, just that one has high logical-mathematical intelligence and the other has high bodily-kinesthetic intelligence. That said, Bart shows examples of high bodily-kinesthetic and social intelligence, much more than Lisa who obviously has logical-mathematical and musical intelligence. The Grandpa was not dumb by any mean in any of the flashbacks and is technically not dumb in the present, he's just too old and borderline senile.

     Live-Broadcast Soap Opera 
  • In Pygmoelian, why is a daytime soap opera being broadcast live?
    • Maybe it was a special episode, like (fairly) recent episodes of Eastenders and Coronation Street which were broadcast live.

     Why Kill Maude? 
  • When Maggie Roswell quit the show, why did the writers specially kill off Maude Flanders and not Helen Lovejoy, Luann Van Houten, or Ms. Hoover?
    • Better yet, why kill her off at all?
    • Word of God states the writers liked the idea of Flanders dating. They were also aiming to get some emotion out of the story. Other than being Flanders' wife, she didn't have much of a personality and was a Satellite Character. The other characters mentioned are more developed than she is.
    • Because she contributes much more to the show dead than she did alive. There have been several episodes about Ned trying to move on—there's her death in "Alone Again, Natura-Diddily," and there's the amusement park dedicated to her in "I'm Goin' to Praiseland." Then there's Ned dating a new woman in "A Star Is Born Again." That's three entire episodes that only were made possible thanks to her death.

     Why Was Lisa Jealous? 
  • Another Lisa-related question: Any reason why she was jealous when Milhouse was dating Taffy, despite snubbing his advances numerous times?
    • While we're on this subject, why did Taffy think that Milhouse was still into Lisa? Because Lisa was stalking him?
    • Maybe she just enjoyed the attention?

     What Was in the Room? 
  • What was in that one room at the box factory that made it the most popular part of the tour?
    • It's impossible to know, that's what makes it funny.
    • Consider also the sheer dullness of the man making this claim. It probably wasn't any more exciting than any other room in the factory except for a TV playing adverts for boxes or something.

     How are Uulmer and the Leprechaun Canon? 
  • If the Treehouse of Horror episodes are strictly non-canon then how did Üter (he was introduced in Treehouse of Horror VI) and the Leprechaun end up in the main canon?
    • There's no reason why elements that start out as non-canonical need to stay that way. We have a trope for this: Canon Immigrant.
      • But the Leprechaun clearly came from a Simpsons canon that is supernatural and surreal, but normal Simpsons canon is supposed to be normal and surreal, oh let me a guess... a wizard had something to do with it!
      • This is a different matter to canonicity, and comes close to transgressing "Headscratching is not complaining."
      • Canonicity, especially multiple canons, are not that useful of a concept when it comes to The Simpsons, as it takes place in this extensively plastic universe (try to resolve "The Computer Wore Menace Shoes," for example, with the rest of the series). By and large, it works on the concept of Broad Strokes — broadl fect.) Ignoring the inaccuracy of the statement, why would Marge say this, when she is (in and out of universe) one of the few characters known not to have shot Mr. Burns?
    • I guess Marge is as dumb as the other Springfieldians after all because DNA does NOT work like that at all!
    • Lisa rolls her eyes when Marge says it, because she knows Marge is wrong.
    • This is the joke. Marge clearly doesn't understand DNA (although it's a bit harsh to call her "dumb" — DNA is pretty complex).

     So Do They Just Want Homer or Not? 
  • In the Movie, when Homer worries that the angry mob will kill Marge too, Carl responds, "No we won't, we just want Homer!" But then, a few minutes later, the mob is preparing five nooses for the entire family anyway?
    • The other four are "helping" Homer by way of not joining the mob at that point.

     Calling Your Father-in-Law "Grandpa"? 
  • How come Marge always calls Abraham Simpson "Grandpa" and never "Abraham", she never refers to him by his actual name and that's a strange way to address her father-in-law. Well this trouper finds it weird she does that!
    • Force of habit and, perhaps, she considers him "actual" family rather than an in-law? My Grandfather is an in-law but I refer to him as Grandfather, as does my Mother who is similarly (and biologically) unrelated to the man.
    • I know a lot of folks who refer to members of the family by their "titles", even if that title doesn't apply to the person speaking. For example, my grandfather will call his wife "Mom" if he's asking a question for their daughter, and my mom will refer to her parents as "Grandma" and "Papa" if she's talking about them to my siblings. Marge probably calls Abe "Grandpa" in front of the kids because that's what he is to them, and doing so avoids confusion.

     What Was Edna's Maiden Name? 
  • I've heard somewhere that Edna Krabapple's last name is actually that of her ex-husband, and that she kept it even after he left her. Bearing that in mind, what was her original last name?
    • Krabappel probably is her real name. She made reference to a "Mister" Krabappel to make it easier for the children to understand because there probably is no point in identifying her ex-husband.

     Why Didn't Bart Check Out the Leftorium? 
  • Despite being left-handed, Bart never checks out The Leftorium in When Flanders Failed. Made all the more odd considering he was at the mall several times for (allegedly) his karate lessons. He probably didn't know about the left-handed nunchucks.

     Why Did Burns Lose Approval So Slowly? 
  • "Two Cars in Every Garage and Three Eyes on Every Fish": Why did it take until Burns spitting out the three-eyed fish for his approval ratings to drop? Earlier in the episode, he was caught on camera saying "When this announcement's done, every Johnny Lunch-pail in this state will be eating out of my hand.", which should've easily been enough to sink his campaign. Think Mitt Romney's 47% remark.
    • Well, not that The Simpson are a realistic show to begin with, but that's exactly the joke, that people from Springfield nor even notice or care for what he said.

     Took Them Long Enough 
  • Why the hell did it take over 25 years to FINALLY touch upon how Clancy Bouvier died... and somehow Marge and her sisters never knew the full details? Now I know the reason why Mona Simpsons was finally introduced is because many people asked whatever happened to Homer's mother but why did it take even longer to finally answer the whereabouts of Marge's father?
    • The writers probably didn't find it worth bringing up the reason since neither he, nor Jaqueline were major characters and he was rarely bought up.
[

     Casper 
  • Found this on Simpsons Wiki but did it actually happen? Sounded very plausible too since Simpsons veterans starred in the Casper cartoon at one point:
    Homer and his family goes to Casper's house on Casper (voice by Nancy Cartwright), Fatso (voice by Dan Castellaneta), Stretch (voice by Dan Castellaneta) and Stinkie (voice by Rik Mayell) on Casper in the house, Casper with slidestair, Casper: Hi I'm Casper, Homer's scream, Casper is too late, Ghosts around, roaring ghosts, Family screaming, Ghosts's laughing.

     Buddhist God? 
  • In "Homerland", when Marge prays, she says "thank you Christian God", after which Lisa objects loudly. It's weird, since I thought Buddhists didn't have a God? And the Christian god is the same as the Muslim and Hebrew God... And Lisa has been told to respect other religions beforehand. So, what, is this a fluke on the writer's part, or just another jab at Christianity that the show loves to do?
    • Whether the Christian God is the same as the Muslim and Hebrew god is debatable. For instance, the Christian God is also Jesus, while the God that Muslims pray to and the God that Jews pray to is not. On-topic, Marge sounds like she's passive-aggressively specifying that she only wants to thank the Christian god and none of the others—that is to say, she's doing it as a jab at other religions. Of course that would annoy Lisa. (Also, perhaps Marge thinks that Buddhists worship a god and means it as a jab against that guy too.)

     Why Comic Book Guy and Not Apu? 
  • In "The Girl Code", doesn't having Apu join CONRAD as the token male (and person of colour) make more sense than Comic Book Guy? I mean Apu did graduate at the top of his University with a degree in Computer Science.
    • With the type of people they were lampooning, they wouldn't dare to kick out an ethnic minority.

     Why Did Jamsheed Age? 
  • OK... HOW THE F**K DID APU'S NEPHEW JAMSHEED AGE 20 YEARS WHILE NO ONE ELSE ON THE SHOW AGED?!?
    • WMG says that Springfield exists in a world of its own where no one ages, he could've aged since he left town. That doesn't explain why Ling and the Octuplets age while Maggie stays the same age though.
    • This was amusingly lampshaded in Tapped Out.

     What's The Town's Beef with People Who Don't Eat It? 
  • OK, in "Lisa the Vegetarian", why exactly does the town and the school have a hatred towards vegetarians anyway? This made little to no sense...
    • For the school, it's not so much her vegetarianism in and of itself; it's the fact that she's refusing to conform. Note how when she refuses to dissect a worm, and later on asks for a vegetarian option at lunch, both Miss Hoover and Lunchlady Doris press the "Independent Thought Alarm." Which is why Skinner later shows the Troy McClure propaganda video on how eating meat is the right thing and vegetarians are ignorant — it's an attempt to repress the "independent thought" and make Lisa conform and accept that the school doesn't cater to vegetarians, rather than go through the trouble of actually having to provide a vegetarian option. The other kids buy into the propaganda, so they begin mocking Lisa because Kids Are Cruel.
    • For the rest of the town, they don't hate vegetarians; it's just that they have a negative reaction to Lisa being really pushy and annoying, just taking it for granted that everyone will see things her way ("Good news, you don't have to eat meat! I've made enough gazpacho for everyone!") and then ruining Homer's BBBQ with her pushing away the roast pig. After that, nobody except Homer really seems to care about her being a vegetarian, it's just that she keeps running into reminders that most Springfieldians eat meat (like the ad for the "beef-flavored chicken") and in her mind that's the world telling her that she should eat meat too.
    • Vegetarian options were a lot less common in the 1990s than they are now (towards the end of the 2010s decade). Tofu was still largely seen as a gross health food, nobody had heard of quinoa, and faux meats had not become common grocery options, unless one happened to live in an area where there were large populations of vegetarians. Springfield is clearly not one of those places.

     Sideshow Bob's Accent 
  • What accent does Sideshow Bob have? I've heard him use words like "rubbish", but he doesn't sound particularly British to me.
    • Sounds upper east coastish to me. I think "rubbish" etc. are just used to show how sophisticated he is.
    • Sounds more Mid-Atlantic to me.
    • Kelsey Grammer uses the same voice for Sideshow Bob that he does for Frasier, who is from Boston. Grammer himself grew up in New Jersey and south Florida, and the accent sounds nothing like either.

     How Did Homer Survive the Blowfish? 
  • In "One Fish Two Fish Blowfish Blue Fish", Homer ate a poison piece of blowfish, and is told he will die in the next day. However, at the end he survived. How did Homer survive the blowfish?
    • The characters said that they had reason to believe that he had eaten the poisonous part of the blowfish. Clearly, the part he ate wasn't poisonous.
    • Hibbert never says it was certain, he always says it was a big possibility like 99% chance.

     Is it Really an Error? 
  • A lot of people say the episode, "The Blunder Years", has a massive continuity error when it come to the age of Waylon Smithers Jr. relative to Homer's, but does it really? We don't know how long his father's body was down in that sewer pipe. For all we know, it could have been down in the sewer pipe for years before Homer found it.
    • Also the episode itself doesn't confirm when the accident happend. Then again in moisture place a human corpse rots more faster and Smithers Sr's body looks relatively fresh...

     Why Didn't the Parents Sue? 
  • In "Worst Episode Ever", when Comic Book Guy banned Bart and Milhouse from his store for talking Martin Prince's mom out of selling him Martin's rare and invaluable Star Wars items for only five dollars, why didn't they have their parents sue him for banning them on such a petty charge (similar to Homer being kicked out of the Rusty barnacle before he had all he could eat).
    • Because Homer's all-u-can-eat lawsuit had a semi-logical basis—he had not gotten all he could eat. But it's perfectly legal for Comic Book Guy to ban the kids from his shop. There's no law saying that his reason was too petty.

     Why Live in a Bad Town? 
  • If Springfield is such a Crapsack World, why are there so many people living there?
    • Most of them are too stupid to move anywhere else. The rest of them are either too stuck in their ways, they have something that ties them to the town, or they're children who can't move anywhere else on their own.

     Why Not Become a Sex Worker? 
  • If Lindsay Naegal is a sexual predator (which explains why she constantly keeps changing jobs). Why doesn't she get a job where sex is required like a prostitute?
    • It's a very risky job. Usually pays worse than her kind of businesswoman jobs, too.
    • Prostitutes are not sexual predators.
      • Indeed. It's not like her self-description is "sex-crazed" or something.

     How Talented is Lisa? 
  • Can somebody who knows something about saxophone tell me how talented Lisa actually is, in general and for her age? Thanks.
    • Considering the fact that Lisa is depicted as being 7-9 years old (7 in the earliest episodes, 9 in the newer episodes, and 8 in most episodes), she's ridiculously talented, almost a child prodigy.

     "Like Father, Like Clown" Questions 
  • In 'Like Father, Like Clown' - We see Krusty is meant to come to the Simpson home for dinner as thank you to Bart. Surely Bart having saved him from prison means Krusty should be hosting him or doing something? Also, in the same episode, Marge waits until Bart has dressed in a suit and psyched himself up for Krusty coming to dinner to tell him it's not happening. Why'd she wait?
    • For the former, while I imagine either would probably satisfy, it is perhaps a little bit more special to have a major celebrity visit your humble home, and demonstrates a bit more effort and respect on their part.
    • Marge probably waited to tell Bart because she knew that telling him would break his heart, and she just couldn't bring herself to do that again. Or maybe she was hoping that Krusty would come after all.

     Treehouse of Less Horror? 
  • Is there a reason why the Treehouse of Horror episodes have gotten more comical and less scary over the years? The tone is different now. In the early seasons, the stories were a lot more scary and disturbing such as the one where the school staff were eating children. Is it censorship and executive meddling?
    • I highly doubt it's either. Imagine for a moment you've got the task to write Halloween Specials for almost 30 years. That will undoubtedly take damage on a horror-imaginative mind, and eventually you can't afford too much experimentation. You'll just have to think of anything before reaching the deadline if you want your paycheck. Later Specials aren't as frightening, but it's something. (However, if you ask me, some newer episodes, like Sideshow Bob finally killing Bart in the 2015 special, was really creepy).
    • Treehouse of Horror is pretty much an excuse to write episodes that ignore established rules the show has set. Also, I'd like to argue that King Kong isn't necessarily a horror and the Monkey's Paw segment wasn't suppose to be scary.
    • Also, the show in general has become a lot more surreal in general. In the early days, while not without an absurdist side The Simpsons was always a lot more down-to-earth, and the "Treehouse" episodes were an opportunity to cut loose and do more off-the-wall things. Since the show in general is a lot more surreal and absurdist, the "Treehouse" episodes don't really stick out as much, but they just do them out of tradition.

     Why is Homer at the Tavern? 
  • So I'm watching "Principal Charming" as I type this, and when Skinner ordered Bart to call Homer, why does the card that lists Homer's number show Moe's Tavern? And why was Homer at the tavern when he would normally be at the Nuclear Power Plant?
  • Was it just coincidence that when Bart prank called Moe that Homer happened to be there?
    • That's the joke. Homer is a known alcoholic.
    • Considering how much of his time Homer spent at Moe's probably not. In fact, making the call when his father was at Moe's would make it less likely that his father would catch him making the prank phone call to begin with.

     Why Didn't Bob Quit? 
  • If Sideshow Bob was tired of Krusty treating him like a Butt-Monkey, why didn't he just quit his job?
    • Because he didn't just want to quit; he wanted to take over Krusty's place as the beloved children's icon. As well as being sick of putting up with all of Krusty's bullshit, he felt that Krusty's low-brow Lowest Common Denominator programming was poisoning children's minds, and he initially wanted to be a better role model to children than Krusty.
      • The thing is Bob didn't want the job in the first place. It was later revealed he only went to ensure Cecil became Krusty's sidekick.

     How Did Willie Know Bart Did It? 
  • In "Girly Edition", upon getting taken away on a stretcher after his shack was destroyed, Willie was all "You did this, Bart Simpson!". How did Willie know Bart destroyed his shack? Willie was sound asleep when Bart put the creamed corn hose into his shack.
    • Taking into account what a reputation Bart has for being a trouble-making little menace, it's not that farfetched an assumption he did it.
    • You forget Willie had just taken Bart's skateboard. Willie also knew Bart had motive.

     How Did Lisa Know the Shack was Destroyed? 
  • In the above episode, Lisa gave a letter to Bart, claiming him to be one of "Bart's People", later revealed to be Willie. How did Lisa know Willie's shack was destroyed let alone where Willie had been ever since?

     What was Skinner's Plan? 
  • In the famous "Steamed Hams" sketch from 22 Short Films About Springfield, what was Skinner's plan when he went into the kitchen after saying "Excuse me for one second"? Presumably, he went in and saw the fire, then quickly changed plans and tried to rush Chalmers out the door before he saw the fire, but what was Skinner going to do before then?
    • Pretty sure he just planned to gather himself and hope for something that would allow him to rally, saw the fire and knew he had to get Chalmers out of the house.

     How Did They Kill the Boar? 
  • In Das Bus, how did they kill the boar? These are still children going after a wild animals after all.
    • You have to read Lord of the Flies or watch the movie adaptation for that, as the episode is a parody of it.

     Do White People Exist? 
  • So, is every white person on the planet yellow? The Family Guy crossover seems to suggest both yellow people and peach people coexist on earth.
    • I know is often said but, the Family Guy crossover is by far non-canonic, almost as non-canonic as the Halloween episodes.

     Why was Chalmers Suspicious? 
  • Regarding the "Steamed Hams" segment, why was Chalmers suspicious about his burger being grilled? He'd already accepted Seymour's claim that "steamed hams" is a regional dialect term for hamburgers, so he shouldn't have expected his food to actually be steamed.

     Was the Will Plan B? 
  • Ok, so Mona made a perfect Plot Tailored to the Party scheme with multiple uses of the Chekhov's Gun that she left behind on her will... so we may accept that the missile to the Amazon jungle is maybe not the first time Burns has used the silo (so Mona may have obtained the intel for the plan)... was the will Plan B all along or she actually always factored her death in the scheme? Either way you see it, it just makes her die-hard Granola Girl attitude more monstrous towards Homer.

     Why Does Ned Mind Being Locked in Church? 
  • In "Homer the Heretic", why is Ned of all people so horrified that the church door is unable to be opened? One would have thought that he would have been pleased to be locked in Church. Is the idea that the weather is so cold that even Ned wants to escape the heating-free Church? Or are we perhaps seeing an example of the 'classic era' Ned, the one that wasn't quite as much of a Religious Right caricature?
    • Even Ned, church lover that he is, probably isn't big on the idea of freezing to death.

     Why Does No One Mistake Homer for Mr. Sparkle? 
  • In "30 Minutes Over Tokyo" how come no one mistakes Homer for Mr. Sparkle when the family's in Japan? Comic Book Guy's wife Kumiko in "Married to the Blob" noticed the resemblance off the bat.

     Not Knowing Your Own Middle Name 
  • Rule of Funny aside, why wouldn't Homer know his own middle name? Surely he'd have a birth certificate somewhere.
    • He's a fool, you can't expect him to remember his middle name or where he put his birth certificate to look it up.
    • Given what his middle name is, he probably heard it a million times growing up and just assumed that he was hearing an initial.

     How Did Skinner Get Bart to Go to the Movies with Him? 
  • Exactly how did Principal Skinner get Bart to come to the movies in "Grade School Confidential"? If he had thrown rocks at the window to get his attention, then surely he would have been more dressed (even though Seymour seems more of the type to ring the doorbell.) Plus, how willing was Bart to attend the movies with him? Skinner was more or less pushing him to watch with them. Given that, Bart's reluctance and sleepiness and the wonder of how Skinner got the boy out of his home in the middle of the night, then thinking about it too long might become Fridge Horror...
    • He could've told Marge and Homer that Bart got in trouble and had to help him out with a task, like when he made Bart learn astronomy in "Bart's Comet." Bart does get sent to his office later in the episode with a love note from Mrs. Krabappel, so it's not far fetched that was the case.
    • Be that as it may, why wasn't he wearing shoes?

     Why Does Duff Go Out of Business? 
  • In "Homer Vs. The Eighteenth Amendment" why does Duff Beer go out of business due to prohibition in one town? Isn't the Duff Brewery in Capital City? Other episodes have shown that Duff is distributed in other areas around the world.

     Why Does Skinner Look Like His Mother? 
  • If Principal Skinner is really Arman Tanzarian, why does he show a family resemblance (in the face) to his mother?
    • Tanzarian is an orphan. Agnes Skinner did not want Skinner to go to college, and her going along with him wouldn't work because of her implied promiscuous habits in a college town. What if Skinner really was Agnes's biological son that she (must have) abandoned after birth for reasons?
    • A bit more plausible is that they just happened to look similar, and it's part of what drove him to pursue the ruse in the first place. Of course, the real reason is that this particular episode was a massive Ass Pull, and the creators almost certainly intended originally that Agnes and Principal Skinner were biological family.

     Why Does Ned Celebrate Halloween? 
  • If Flanders is a hardcore Christian, why is he shown celebrating Halloween in several episodes?
    • Halloween is 'All Hallow's Eve', the day before All Saints Day. It'd make sense for a hardcore Christian to be engaging in what has roots in Christian tradition. Plus, he's one of the nicest guys in Springfield, it isn't out of character for him to play the role of candy-charity for the sake of children.
    • Pre-Flanderized Flanders probably didn't think it was a huge deal and just harmless fun. Kind of like what Hank Hill thinks Halloween is despite being so uptight all the time.

     How Did Weird Al Obtain the Prank Call? 
  • How did "Weird Al" Yankovic obtain one of Bart's prank phone calls to Moe (used in his song "Phony Calls") before he even met the Simpsons? For that matter, "Why Does This Always Happen to Me?" mentions actually watching The Simpsons. How is that even possible?

     Lying Waiter 
  • In 'The Boy Who Knew Too Much', the waiter is apparently perfectly happy to lie in court and say Freddy Quimby beat him within an inch of his life. Aside from the final hilarity of falling out a window into a truck of mouse-traps, we don't know that he is properly punished for his lies, how is this not brought up?

     Smithers' ID? 
  • What happened to Smithers' ID card? It has not been seen in latest episodes.

     How Did Bleeding Gums Murphy Die? 
  • How did Bleeding Gums Murphy die? Why was he in the hospital in the first place? It was never explained.
    • The guy was called "Bleeding Gums" and was over weight, the guy obviously had a lot of health problems. FWIW the Simpsons Wiki says it was due to an unspecified cardiac problem, but it could just as well be scurvy.

     How is a 59% Possible? 
  • In "Bart Gets an F", Bart skips a snow day just to study REALLY hard for his history exam (possibly even harder than Lisa) and not repeat his grade again. After asking Mrs. Krabappel to immediately grade the exam, he receives a 59%. What I don't get is, I counted 15 questions on the exam itself, so how would a 59% be mathematically possible? The exam would have to consist of exactly 100 questions and Bart would've gotten exactly 41 of them wrong to receive that grade. I doubt partial points are possible since it's a multiple choice exam, and I didn't see any other papers consisting of more exam questions, either. Also, I counted exactly 5 incorrect answers, not only from the number of times Mrs. Krabappel marks an answer wrong with her red pen, but also the number of X's on the exam paper itself when Homer was taping it onto the refrigerator. Bart really should've gotten a 66% (67% if you take rounding into account), which, based on this troper's assumed grading system, should've qualified him for either just a neutral D or barely a D+.

     Nobody Believes Homer? 
  • When Homer reveals the secret ingredient for the Flaming Moe, why would anybody believe him? Even if he wasn't being a nutjob, from everybody else's point of view, how did he figure it out, and he didn't have knowledge of the recipe so to them, what credibility does Homer have?
    • Maybe they didn't. But figured it was worth a shot.

     Why was Homer Relieved to See Gil? 
  • In "Natural Born Kissers" why was Homer so relieved to see Gil when he and Marge were in the nude? Gil hadn't been established as a friend of the Simpsons at that point, and he seemed more interested in selling them a car than being of any practical help.
    • Familiar face, I guess.

     Blaming Bart 
  • When Groundskeeper Willie puts rats to ruin that school festive. Why does everyone immediately accuse Bart. I know his record, but certainly Willie must of been acting suspicious, and they could of at checked all possibility.
    • It was just Skinner and Lisa. Homer was upset about Bart getting expelled. As for why they accused Bart. Bart was given an uncool role as a barrel maker (the barrel burst open spilling its beverage all over Bart) and he was sent to a dungeon or something. The embarrassment would serve as a motive for ruining the festival. Bart's smart aleck comment when the rats were released didn't help him either.

     Crayons up your nose 
  • The episode HOMR reveals that Homer's low intelligence is caused by putting crayons up his nose, one of which got stuck in his brain. If Homer is so smart, why would he put the crayons up his nose in the first place?

     The Only Store In Town? 
  • Another thing about "Hurricane Neddy" - everyone rushes the Kwik-E-Mart for panic buying before that big storm. But why did nobody go elsewhere in town for supplies? What about that supermarket or even that Monstromart from "Bart Gets Famous"?
    • If a mere convenience store was that crowded, the big stores would be even worse. Similar to Black Friday. Target and Wal-Mart are packed, but a regular grocery store with food and possibly a pharmacy wouldn't be so bad.

     When Bob frames Krusty 
  • When it comes to body types between Krusty and Bob, Krusty looks more or less like Homer, while Bob is more lanky and skinny. So when he robs the Kwik-E-Mart, how exactly did Bob get the Homer body-type? Wouldn't that Krusty be lanky too?
    • Bob probably put a pillow or something under his shirt so it looks like he has a potbelly like Krusty.
    • But look at the other portions of the body besides his stomach. The Bob Krusty has fat arms and legs and the Homer headstyle, and Bob is much skinnier all around and has a tall and thin head, and that's not going into their vastly different hairstyles.
    • Remember that Bob works for a TV studio and is a classically-trained actor, so he probably has connections in the costume and makeup department. He might have worn padding or a fat suit for the arms and legs, hunched his body to appear smaller, and used a wig cap to keep his own massive coif in place while wearing a hairpiece. Alternatively, since Krusty loves to stick his name on every kind of product imaginable, there might be a regulation Krusty the Clown costume out there; Bob bought or stole one for his disguise. There's proof of this in the episode where Homer goes to clown college and becomes an "official" Krusty; he and all of the other students get costumes and makeup to closely resemble the real thing.

    HOMR 
  • Considering that removing the crayon made Homer smart, why on earth does he send his safety report to the nuclear regulatory commission instead of giving it to Mr Burns as usual? Surely that’s the kind of thing that he would have done while dumb considering that the plant is a death trap and would inevitably get shut down if the NRC knew how unsafe and badly run it was.
    • That’s the whole point. Homer is now smart enough to see the Plant is a death trap and knows Burns will do nothing about it, so he sends it to someone who will.
    • Alternatively, even when smart, Homer is still an idiot. The more things change, the more they stay the same.

    Baptism 
  • How come the Simpson kids haven't been baptised if Marge is a Christian? (Technically, Homer is too but he's less spiritual than she is).
    • They're not as extreme as the Flanders, plain and simple.
    • In addition to personal choice, plenty of denominations don't baptize.
    • Another question— When Marge gets Maggie, she says, "You're a Simpson again!" and the kids tease each other by saying, "You're gonna be so-and-so Flanders!", but does baptism really change people's surname? This is purely anecdotal, but my dad claims he was born agnostic, was Catholic for a while, then went back to being agnostic and while he was Catholic, he got baptised but he still has the same surname now as he did at birth and we were having a long conversation about our family history and talked a lot about our relatives who'd changed their names, so I think he would've mentioned it if he had a different surname during his time as a Catholic.

     Reading Chinese newspapers 
  • In King of the Hill, when the executives tell Homer the energy bars are made out of apple cores and Chinese newspapers, Homer is able to read them. Disregarding how he's able to read newspapers in an energy bar, how is he able to read another language?
    • Ruleof Funny. Homer will always be as smart or as stupid as he needs to be for the purposes of a joke. Recall 'Simpson Tide', where Homer could actually speak Chinese (and Mexican, and...penguin).

     Bart being sent back to Kindergarten 
  • In Sideshow Bob Roberts, after Bob becomes Mayor, his revenge on Bart is to,,send him back to Kindergarten? Seems like an odd from of getting even, especially since in his previous and later appearances he tries to kill Bart (admittedly, he also tries to destroy the Simpsons house as well).
    • As stated elsewhere on this page, Bob is incredibly petty. Alternately, he's starting small, ruining Bart's life in minor, subtler ways as build up to just killing him. ALTERNATELY alternately, he knows that as Mayor, he actually can't kill Bart (or would have significant trouble getting away with it), so petty torture is the next best thing.

     Mona's Dilemma 
  • Why was Mona on the run for that long? Her hair has turned gray and there are wrinkles around her mouth due to aging and she has her hair in a different style now. How would anybody have been able to recognize her? Not to mention the trampling Mr. Burns incident which made her a fugitive. How does Burns know she was part of the attack on his germ lab and not just a simple passerby?

     Brother From The Same Planet  
  • The Bigger Brother company let Peppy stay homeless, apparently they were saving Tom for a kid that really needed him. They end up together at the end, but geeze.
    • The office clerks aren't the most competent people around. He told the receptionist that he had no father and even dressed up like a street urchin. Its also implied that Tom knew Homer was alive and thus Bart was lying about being fatherless given his "If I ever meet your father..." comment at the baseball game yet stayed with him anyway. They also accepted Homer's reason of wanting to be a big brother as "revenge" (and the checklist consist of other reasons including spite, malice, profit, and boredom). For all of Tom's competence, the office department has some screwed priorities. Plus, Bart did all this because Homer was late picking him up from soccer practice, albeit during a storm.

     Olmec Head 
  • The Simpsons (particularly Homer) are very disappointed when Mr. Burns' gift to them is an ancient Olmec head instead of a monetary sum. But Burns spent several thousand dollars on the artifact! Why doesn't the Simpson family sell it to a museum or a collector and reap the benefits?
    • The giant Olmec head is a very large and conspicuous artifact. If the Simpson family did sell it to a private collector or museum, this would most likely show up in the news, even in a niche, specialized news source. It's possible that the Simpson family never sold the Olmec head because they know that if they did so, Mr. Burns would find out somehow, and would either be extremely pissed, or offended by this, or both. So they kept the Olmec head to avoid incurring Burns' wrath any further. (Plus, at least Bart likes it- and he was the one who donated blood to Mr. Burns in the first place. Perhaps keeping the Olmec head was Homer and Marge's way of throwing Bart a bone, so to speak.)

    "So, why did he burn his pants?" 

  • Pransta Rap** (Season 16, Episode 9)
  • The question is raised in episode to why after destroying the evidence Homer then proceeds to burn his pants but is never addressed.
    • The usual - Rule of Funny , Homer is a doofus and has shown a desire to burn his pants before. [1]

     Mr. Burns' Noodle Kugel 
  • In "Two Cars In Every Garage And Three Eyes On Every Fish," Mr. Burns attends a televised family dinner with the Simpsons, and brings a small casserole dish of noodle kugel. Kugel is a popular Ashkenazi Jewish dish. Why would Mr. Burns, who's pretty well-known for being anti-Semitic at best and a former Nazi at worst, bother to make/bring a Jewish dish for this dinner? It's not like the Simpsons writers would be stupid enough to not realize the implications of making Mr. Burns Jewish-coded.
    • Considering how insulated he is from inconvenient facts, if he likes kugel, it wouldn't be out-of-character for him to not be aware of its origins. Either nobody mentions it to him, or he ignores it if they do.

     "Who's Drederick Tatum, anyway? Is he another hobo?" 
  • Homer recognizes Lucius Sweet as "one of the biggest names in boxing," but the name of the champ Lucius is managing doesn't ring a bell?

     Why does everyone call Charles Montgomery Burns 'Monty?' 
  • Why does nobody (even Mr. Burns himself) refer to Mr. Burns by his first name? I think there's only been a handful of times when his first name was ever stated- everyone refers to him almost exclusively by his middle name instead for some reason. Even odder, in the episode "Frinkcoin," when Smithers refers to him as "Monty," Mr. Burns scolds him for thinking he can be on a "first-name basis" with him.
    • My guess is that Burns doesn't like his real first name Charles, since it's not as fancy like Montgomery.

     Sterilize an already clean needle? 
  • Why in the episode Blood Feud Smithers even asks Dr Hibbert to sterilize needle, since blood transfusion catheter needles are disposable and therefor don't even need that?

     "Don't make the same mistake I made." 
  • Near the end of "Rosebud," Mr. Burns says this line as he fails to get his teddy bear from Maggie and resigns himself to letting her keep it. The grave seriousness in which he says this line makes me wonder- was the "mistake" he was referring to giving away Bobo? Or was he maybe hinting at something a bit deeper- as in, "don't squander away the love and innocence in your life for money?"
    • Or alternatively; "don't throw your childhood away too early". I think Burns was referring the latter.

     That headline... Yeesh 
  • In "A Star Is Burns," it's stated that at one point, Mr. Burns somehow won a teen beauty pageant by bribing the judges. A headline of a newspaper shows Burns in a gown and sash, with the headline "Incontinent Old Man Wins Miss Teen America." It's also shown that Mr. Burns has at least some control over the media as well as his publicity, given how much money he has. So how/why the hell did he allow that embarrassing headline to be published?

     The Be Sharps Gold Records 
  • In The Simpsons S5 E1 "Homer's Barbershop Quartet", Homer never answers the questions about his time in the Be Sharps. While it can be implied Homer spent or wasted all the money made, that doesn't answer the question about his ensemble's gold records. How come we never see those hanging on the wall or in a display case? You'd think Homer would be proud of them given how he displayed his past achievements for Frank Grimes to see.
    • Even with all the cartoon absurdity and Negative Continuity on the show, this episode stands out in its level of incongruity with the rest of the series. You have to believe that Homer, Skinner, Barney, Apu, and Wiggum are all not just skilled and trained at harmonic singing, but good enough at it to become world famous—despite never showing the slightest evidence of such an ability in any other episode (in fact often heard singing off-key in other episodes). You have to believe Homer in particular (who is otherwise shown to be consistently lazy as well as stupid) has the discipline to learn a skill this complex and to live a lifestyle as intense and demanding as that of a professional performer. You have to believe they must all have somehow quit their day jobs, left their families for extended periods of time, and then later returned to their original blue-collar existence while no one (least of all Bart and Lisa) seems to have any memory of it, and the supposed former bandmates never make any references to the shared experience and seem to barely know one another beyond acquaintance. It almost leads you to suspect Homer made the whole story up—though that leaves the mystery of why the record exists. All in all, it's probably just a case of the writers wanting to tell this particular Beatle-esque story and deciding to ignore any incongruities it created. Homer's refusal to elaborate is, to my mind, a way of lampshading this fact and casting doubt on the accuracy of his account.

     Herb ruined 
  • Homer's car destroyed Herb's car company, but why would that put him out of a job? I don't know how business works, but given the company was under new management under a different company, he wouldn't be the president anymore, but couldn't he still work there as a slightly lower executive or something?

     Homer in the intro 
  • During the intro, why is Homer even gets to handle a rod of uranium with tongs if he's supposed to be a safety inspector?
    • Because he didn't get that job until episode 3.

     Another musician in the family 
  • In "Covercraft", Homer learns to play the bass, which makes Lisa happily say "It's so cool to have another musician in the family!". Appearently, Lisa has forgotten at this point that Homer already plays the piano and the guitar, has had his own grunge band and his barber vocal quartet, and wrote the song "Everybody Hates Ned Flanders", that became a hit. She also omits the fact that Bart, although having failed at the guitar, proved to be a very talented drummer (until his wrist was ruined by one of Lisa's rescues). She also forgets that Abe Simpson also plays the piano occasionally. So, "another musician in the family" much? She already should be used to most of the family being musicians.
    • Occasionally playing an instrument isn't enough to make you a musician.

     Skinner's Eyes 
  • How come most characters have their eyes stuck together unless they're Asian, but Skinner's eyes are separate and he doesn't look Asian?
    • Skinner's not the only non-Asian character with that feature. Look at Moe, Carl, Dr. Hibbert, or for those closer to Skinner, Edna and Chalmers.

     Did Riviera just cut his own arteries? 
"The red thing's connected to my wristwatch, uh oh." What did happen exatly?
  • One of the body's red things got caught in his wristwatch.
Top

How well does it match the trope?

Example of:

/

Media sources:

/

Report