Follow TV Tropes

Following

Gentle Touch vs. Firm Hand

Go To

"Hey, different kids need different counseling, so I need to be sweet, harsh, like, a total best friend, and sometimes... I need to kick the grades out of the lazy yet smart students!"

In a World... as great and populous as ours, there are naturally many different experiences, beliefs, situations, and ways of looking at things, but one major constant: our responsibility to shape a better world for the next generation. When these diverse mindsets meet this responsibility, an all-important question arises: how do we do it? Should we apply a gentle touch, or a firm hand?

Advertisement:
  • The Gentle Touch favors to keep their charge happy and healthy and offer kind, soft encouragement when helping them understand the situation and the role they play.
  • The Firm Hand prefers Brutal Honesty and Tough Love to knock their pupil out of their comfort zone and onto the right path, and make very clear the consequences of straying from it.

This dichotomy most often rears its head when two parents or Opposed Mentors argue over how to handle the young ones under their wing. The one who favors Gentle Touch (usually the Team Mom) will insist the other Was Too Hard on Him, and a lifetime laden with several harsh lessons and little comfort will do more harm than good in the long run. The other who favors Firm Hand (usually the Team Dad) will insist that everyone has to face the music at some point, and being reluctant to be Cruel to Be Kind means he'll never learn and end up a grandiose lowlife. It gets more heated when things are Exaggerated; an excessively Gentle Touch will accomplish nothing with their kid and pretty much let the Spoiled Brat walk all over them, whereas an excessively Firm Hand creates an unyielding regime of rules and chores with nary a privilege or reward in sight. The common Stock Aesops that arise from this are:

Advertisement:
  1. An irresolute authority figure learning to get firm and lay down the law.
  2. A overbearing authority figure learning to be more gentle and allow more freedom.
  3. Two of the above concluding that Both Sides Have a Point, and that they must learn to strike a balance and apply both when necessary without being excessive.

There's also potential for An Aesop for kids, too. Typically, the kid will have had enough of their authority figure's rules and punishments and wish they had an (excessively) Gentle Touch, leading to a Be Careful What You Wish For moment and the kid begrudgingly realizing the importance of a Firm Hand in his or her life. That said, the duality of this trope allows room for a Double Aesop in which the grown-up may realize that their ward is a lot better than given credit for, and resolve to be a bit more lenient.

Advertisement:

Of course, those are just the stock plots. When you think about it, this trope extends far beyond raising kids and comes into play in any situation where one influences another, and which side is best all depends on just who you are influencing. There are some people who, by nature, respond far better to Gentle Touch, and others who need more of a Firm Hand. The hallmark of Reasonable Authority Figures and Good Parents is the ability to recognize which is needed in the given situation, how much of it to apply, and with whom to apply it. Conversely, ones who apply too much of one (typically Firm Hand) are a ripe source of Parental Issues. The Sliding Scale of Idealism vs. Cynicism often plays a part in this, as storytelling in of itself can be an effective means of imparting one's influence. Different tales will often favor one over the other, be it the understanding nature of Gentle Touch or the challenging nature of Firm Hand.

Harmony Versus Discipline is a Super-Trope. The Good Cop/Bad Cop routine is a Sub-Trope. Another sub-trope is Captain Smooth and Sergeant Rough.

And to anyone looking for advice on tonight's date, look elsewhere, buddy.


Examples:

    open/close all folders 

    Advertising 
  • In one GEICO advert, it's shown that the nature of this dichotomy is exactly why you don't want a Drill Sergeant Nasty as your therapist.

    Anime & Manga 
  • For a case study in how this trope applies to storytelling, there's FLCL and Paranoia Agent, two Mind Screwy Anime of the 2000s. The former teaches that real maturity begins with truth to oneself (while also being open to experiences out of one's comfort zone), while the latter is a hard-hitting Anti-Escapism Aesop / Author Tract against Kawaii culture and its childlike trappings. In essence, it's the difference between encouraging words of wisdom and a harsh Wake-Up Call.
  • In Lyrical Nanoha, this is essentially the difference between Nanoha and Fate's approaches to raising Vivio, exemplified in a mid-season scene in StrikerS, where a 6-years old Vivio trips on a lawn and falls. Fate immediately rushes to her side to make sure she is not hurt, while Nanoha (gently) berates her for being a crybaby and tells her that it's important to stand up even when no one is there to help you. This is reflective of their own childhoods, as Nanoha was forced to become independent at a young age due to the rest of her family being busy dealing with her father being in the hospital, while Fate was horrifically abused as a child and goes out of her way to avoid repeating her mother's misdeeds. By the end of the season, as an exhausted and wounded Nanoha tries to walk over to Vivio, Vivio insists on going to Nanoha by herself. Similarly, in the "Magical Cooking" one-shot of the Magical Girl Lyrical Nanoha Comic à la Carte official anthology book, when Vivio serves up some awful cookies, Fate struggles with how to tell her that, but Nanoha says the cookies were terrible with a smile on her face, before explaining why Vivio's previous batch was much better.
    • Interestingly enough, Nanoha's the Gentle Touch to Vita's Firm Hand when it comes to training the Forwards in StrikerS. While Nanoha gives her recruits intense training, she's careful not to overwork them, and is fairly understanding compared to Vita. After Teana nearly causes a friendly fire incident during the hotel battle, Vita gives Teana a tongue-lashing, while Nanoha gives Teana a calmer lecture (albeit because Vita already scolded Teana).
  • Digimon Adventure: The ultimate conflict of the original anime between Taichi and Yamato is whether to push the team to rid the world of the Dark Masters as quick as they can or to meet the team's needs before carrying on.
  • Digimon Frontier: Seen again between Takuya and Kouji during an early episode when they and Tagalong Kid Tomoki wind up in a theme park-themed land. Takuya wants to let Tomoki play around and de-stress, but keeps getting caught up in things himself, failing to steer Tomoki. Kouji wants to drag the kid along to get back on track, but he's such complete Jerkass about it that he ends up making things needlessly stressful.
  • Hinata and Teru's approach towards Sumino in I'm Here!. One shows his support by offering kind words and being a sweet Nice Guy. The other "helps" by bluntly pointing out her flaws in order to make her stronger.

    Comic Books 
  • This is explored in Batman in relation to the various Robins. Batman himself is naturally a Firm Hand who sternly prepares them for their lives as crime-fighters and the hardships ahead. Alfred meanwhile acts as a Gentle Touch to help them recover from any related trauma and cope with what's happening around them. This is most apparent with Dick Grayson, whose rearing was much rockier than the other Robins, being the "first child."

    Comic Strips 
  • In Calvin and Hobbes, every authority figure in Calvin's life is very quick to apply Firm Hand, as they can see him only as a Bratty Half-Pint. Eventually, babysitter Rosalyn decides to apply a little Gentle Touch; she'll let Calvin stay up an extra half-hour to play the game of his choice on the condition that he behave himself and do his homework. Surprisingly, Calvin is quick to hold up his end of the bargain for a chance to rope Rosalyn into a game of Calvinball. Rosalyn feels that was a mistake at first, until she gets the hang of things and manages to beat Calvin at his own game, getting him to come in to bed with no difficulty.

    Fan Works 
  • Luddy and Amadeus from Pokemon Carnegie, full stop. The former, a kindhearted Turtwig, provides the Gentle Touch, while the latter, a Starly, provides the Firm Hand — er, wing.
  • In Of Blood and Steel, Riko "Erwin" Matsumoto comes off as a Firm Hand compared to Miho's Gentle Touch. While Miho is fairly forgiving of her teammates when they make mistakes, Erwin says, "You don't give a person a medal for failing, you give them a demeaning task to make them mull over their failure." Word of God has it that this is a reference to the real Erwin Rommel's (Erwin's idol) hatred of cowards and deserters.
  • build your wings on the way down has Hughes as the Gentle Touch and Mustang as the Firm Hand. Hughes treats Ed like his actual age, being a caring Parental Substitute to the boy. Mustang treats him more like a soldier, being willing to invoke Cruel to Be Kind gambits to ensure Ed can grow into a better person.

    Film 
  • This the key comparison between the depiction of Mary Poppins in the original PL Travers book, and the version of Mary Poppins from Walt Disney Pictures. Travers' Mary Poppins embodied Good Is Not Nice, being very sharp-tongued and opinionated. Disney's Mary Poppins eventually Took a Level in Kindness and became the gentle, cheery nanny she's known as today. Naturally, that was discussed in Saving Mr. Banks, which revolves arounf the Creative Differences between the two and their vision for the film adaptation.
    Travers: My point is that, unlike yourself, Mary Poppins is the very enemy of whimsy and sentiment. She's truthful. She doesn't sugarcoat the darkness in the world that these children will eventually, inevitably come to know. She prepares them for it. She deals in honesty!
  • Star Wars:
    • In the Original Trilogy, this contrast is played out between Jedi Masters Obi-Wan Kenobi (Gentle Touch) and Yoda (Firm Hand) in the way they train Luke. Obi-Wan acts as a parental figure to Luke, helping him to nurture his abilities while Yoda acts more skeptical within their initial meeting, warning Luke of the inherent darkness he is bound to face.
    • In the Prequel Trilogy, the contrast was played out between Qui-Gon Jinn (Gentle Touch) and the young Obi-Wan (Firm Hand) towards Luke's father Anakin. Anakin finding Obi-Wan too strict played a part in his Start of Darkness, showing that had Qui-Gon gotten the opportunity to train Anakin himself, his turn to the Dark Side might not have happened.

    Literature 
  • In Anton Chekhov's story "A Problem", The Colonel stands for letting Sasha take the consequences of his offense, arguing that preserving the family honor shouldn't excuse shielding a criminal. Ivan Markovitch argues for leniency. Arguing Sasha's poor childhood should serve as extenuating circumstances, he claims it would suit both their moral and civic duties to give him a second chance. The story itself seems to side with the Colonel, if only because Sasha, far from being the innocent penitent Ivan sees, doesn't really care to change his ways.
  • The Villains Series: When it comes to how the interact with Sydney, Mitch is the Gentle Touch to Victor's Firm Hand. Victor is strict and convinced he knows the right course of action, and won't stand for Sydney arguing, though it's clear it comes from a place of concern for her well-being. Mitch is more understanding of Sydney's frustration and loneliness, and attempts to compensate for their restrictive lifestyle by giving her treats and occasionally (gasp!) taking her outside without telling Victor. Mitch also takes it upon himself to homeschool Sydney, while Victor is more concerned with keeping them from being discovered.
  • Kea's Flight: When Brandon tries to interrogate Kea, he threatens her and her friends with harsh punishment over the loudspeaker, then turns sickeningly sweet as soon as he enters her room.

    Live Action TV 
  • This played for Hypocritical Humor on Mom: Christy gives her daughter Violet a harsh enough scolding to leave her in tears, and is tempted to go back and comfort her. Bonnie tells her that as a mother, she needs to stand by her Tough Love, and then immediately goes to comfort her instead, reasoning "I'm a grandma, totally different ballpark."
  • Ned's Declassified School Survival Guide: In her one appearance, guidance counselor Mrs. Splitz embodies both sides to an humorously bipolar degree, able to switch between a rip-roaring Drill Sergeant Nasty to a pleasant, friendly lady (albeit prone to Suddenly SHOUTING!) at the drop of a hat. As she explains, this is because she knows to take a unique approach with each student, such as the Ditzy Genius Cookie or the Brilliant, but Lazy Ned.
  • This is a key element in Wife Swap, along with Bigot vs. Bigot. Typical swaps happen between an Open-Minded Parent willing to allow her kids the freedom to express and enjoy themselves as they please, and a militantly strict matriarch who holds her brood to traditional values and discipline.

    Theater 
  • In Hamlet, this is present in how Gertrude and Claudius get people to do things. Gertrude tends to ask politely, using empathy and diplomacy, while Claudius tends to tell people what to do, using authority and forcefulness. Who responds to who also says a lot about the other characters. Hamlet responds to Gertrude; Rosencrantz and Guildenstern respond to Claudius.

    Video Games 
  • This plays a key role in the Backstory of Fire Emblem Gaiden. The land of Valentia was fought over between the god Duma, who believed the people needed strength and resolve, and the goddess Mila, who believed the people needed freedom and comfort. Eventually, the two struck an accord, with Duma ruling the north and Mila ruling the south. One thousand years hence, coupled with the gods' growing Sanity Slippage, the people of the harsh land of Rigel grew cold and ruthless, while those of the toil-free land of Zofia grew spoiled and debauched.
  • Pokémon Black and White: Contrary to their appearances, the edgy black dragon Zekrom strives for ideals (Gentle Touch) whereas the angelic white dragon Reshiram strives for truth (Firm Hand).
  • Ratchet & Clank has Ratchet as the no-nonsense Firm Hand, and Clank and as the diplomatic Gentle Touch. This is best seen when they confront Captain Qwark for deserting the battle against Dr. Nefarious out of sheer narcissistic cowardice.
    Qwark: Er, let's see. Where was I? Sexy, charming, brilliant, iron hard abs! Ah, yes. But despite my outward appearance of utter perfection, well, umm...
    Ratchet: Deep inside you're a cowardly wuss?
    Qwark: No! Not exactly. When I escaped from that star cruiser cheating death by mere nanoseconds, I suddenly realized something very important: I could have died! Me, Captain Qwark! Imagine, an entire galaxy with no more me. And for what cause? So a few trillion people get turned into robots? Who am I to say who should or shouldn't be turned into a robot?!
    Ratchet: You're pathetic, Qwark! I can't believe I once looked up to you. Let's go, Clank.
    Clank: The people of this galaxy need you, Qwark. They believe in you. You can give them hope. You have a chance to redeem yourself and become the hero you have always wanted to be.

    Web Animation 
  • Dragon Ball Z Abridged sets up this comparison with its take on Android 16's Dying Speech to Gohan. In Dragon Ball Z, 16's speech was more compassionate, understanding why Gohan feared his rage while imploring him to accept it in this dire strait, The abridged version instead calls out Gohan's Holier Than Thou Suicidal Pacifism that will only end up allowing evil to prevail.
  • This briefly comes up in an episode of RWBY. Glynda Goodwitch scolds her students for throwing a Food Fight when they're training for a great and important duty. Professor Ozpin retorts that it is because of that great and important duty that they should be allowed to have a little fun and be kids while they still can.

    Western Animation 
  • American Dad!
    • One episode follows this conflict point by point when Stan and Francine fight over how to raise Steve. They decide things by creating a clone of Steve called Stevearino and raising each their way. Under Francine's lenience, Steve becomes a lazy, ungrateful, entitled Jerkass, while under Stan's strictness, Stevearino becomes a murderous psychopath. Naturally, the two come to see the value in each others' parenting style, and agree to work together more.
    • Another episode sees Stan deciding to go the excessively Gentle Touch route and treat Steve as more of a buddy than a son. Eventually, he learns that parents cannot afford to be Better as Friends with their kid, since they have to shape their well-being, and regains his Firm Hand.
  • Avatar: The Last Airbender
    • This plays a part in Aang's Backstory, mixed with The Needs of the Many. Aang was told of his status as the Avatar four years earlier than usual, due to rumors of war on the horizon. While his guardian, Gyatso, believed that Aang should still be able to take breaks and have fun, the other monks believed that his duty to the world outweighed his personal needs, and made plans to send him to a stricter mentor. Unfortunately, no-one found out which side truly was better since Aang ran away and ended up a Human Popsicle, and war struck his people far sooner than predicted.
    • The episode "Bitter Work" plays Aang's Waterbending teacher, Katara, as the Gentle Touch, and his Earthbending teacher, Toph, as the Firm Hand. This isn't helped by the hard-rooted mentality of Earthbending being in direct opposition to the free-spirited mentality of Aang's native Airbending, causing him to suffer a mental block. Katara asks Toph to be a bit more encouraging in her tutelage, and while she's resistant at first, she does admit that encouragement did help (albeit after Aang learned to stand his ground in a Die or Fly moment).
  • An episode of Chowder is the Trope Namer, in which Chowder starts to look up to Truffles (firm), causing Mung Daal (gentle) to compete with her over Chowder's admiration. Torn between the two, Chowder eventually comes across a Veggie Guru who sings him a song about how "it takes a gentle touch and a firm hand", advising him to seek guidance from both. Of course, Chowder, being the Cloud Cuckoo Lander that he is, starts looking up to Schnitzel instead.
  • The Foster's Home for Imaginary Friends special Destination Imagination has Frankie representing the Gentle Touch (taking the time to understand the current situation and what each friend needs), and Mr. Herriman delivers the Firm Hand (assigning harsh punishments and expecting that to end the problem). Frankie's Gentle Touch proves far more valid when she's able to understand the Woobie, Destroyer of Worlds' issues and help him realize that he doesn't need to act out to protect what's important to him, whereas Herriman's Firm Hand becomes an Interrupted Cooldown Hug that triggers him into throwing a Suicidal Cosmic Temper Tantrum. It's this that gets Herriman to finally concede to Frankie's wisdom on the matter, and she's able to defuse the situation.
  • King of the Hill, being set in suburban Texas and often expressing the idea that Good Is Old-Fashioned, tends to hold Firm Hand more favorably:
    • One episode has Peggy dealing with a particularly disobedient student who pants her in front of the entire classroom, and she responds by spanking him. While spanking isn't technically illegal in her particular school, its frowned upon enough that the school fires her over it. This sparks an odd debate of sorts among the cast, as many of the adult cast members were spanked at school and now openly disapprove of it, though Cotton and the parents of that generation openly think it's a great idea and petition to get Peggy her job back. Once back at school she openly flaunts her new authority before realizing she's only frightening her students and acting like a maniac and beginning to scale things back, resolving to inspire respect rather than command it.
      Dale: Spanking was wrong then and it's wrong now! I say spare the rod and spoil the child!
      Hank: Dale, "spare the rod and spoil the child" means you're in favor of spanking.
      Dale: (Beat) No, it doesn't. note 
    • This happens in the episode where Peggy recovers from a skydiving accident. Her assigned physical therapist is the Gentle Touch, encouraging her to take things at an easy pace and not overexert herself, but it's her Sitcom Arch-Nemesis, Cotton, that proves to be the Firm Hand necessary to get her to push her limits and make actual progress.
    • This also gets Played for Laughs in the episode where Luanne and Lucky look after Bobby in preparation of the kid they're expecting. Since they're friends and Bobby is a generally good kid, they have no problem with the Gentle Touch, but eventually they start to fear they won't be able to effectively discipline, and start exercising Firm Hand... as in, nothing but Firm Hand. When that doesn't work, they realize they need to try for a balance... which they try by rapid-fire alternating between soft and strict, leaving Bobby confused.
  • Steven Universe: This was the dynamic Blue and Yellow Diamond had with fellow Diamond Authority member Pink Diamond. Yellow was the Firm Hand, being a strict disciplinarian who would constantly come down on Pink for not acting as a Diamond was supposed to. Blue was the Gentle Touch, offering emotional support and actually listening to Pink's concerns. Unlike most examples, both are seen to be toxic because they're applied in severely unhealthy ways. Pink wanted to be seen as an equal by the duo but Yellow was incredibly aloof because of Pink's apparent childishness and wasn't above physically manhandling her if Pink stoked her temper. Blue on the other hand was more gently reproachful to Pink's mistakes but her support tended to be about nudging Pink into conforming more with Homeworld's Fantastic Caste System and while she tried to help Pink with issues that she brought up, it tended to come across as Condescending Compassion which hit just as bad as Yellow's straight forward temper to Pink.
  • The Tangled: The Series episode "You're Kidding Me" sees Rapunzel and Eugene become Designated Parents when Cassandra, Lance, and Shorty get hit by a Fountain of Youth. Rapunzel (the Gentle Touch) ends up having to put her foot down when dealing with Cassandra, while Eugene (the firm Hand) has to show a softer side when dealing with Lance.
  • DuckTales (2017): A running theme in Della Duck's character arc is she's Maternally Challenged due to having been stranded away from home and her sons since before they hatched. In particular, Mrs. Beakley espouses the need a Firm Hand while Della would much prefer the Gentle Touch and let the kids be kids. This comes to a head in the episode "Timephoon!", where Louie's actions nearly cause the entire family to be lost in time. Ironically, Mrs. Beakley is among those who are willing to forgive Louie, since everyone knows nothing he did was done out of malice, while Della realizes that she needs to put her foot down and grounds Louie for his actions, with the next episode showing her taking extreme measures to make sure he doesn't try to sneak away when the family leaves the house without him. When Della acknowledges how hard doing that was, Mrs. Beakley commends her and assures her it will make her son a better person in the long run.

    Other 
  • This duality seems to be the core element in the rivalry between Classic Disney Shorts and Looney Tunes. Disney shorts were more sentimental and whimsical to appeal to the viewers' inner child and inspire the best of humanity, while Looney Tunes had more fast-paced and punchy humor to appeal to the common man and make light of the rawer side of life.

    Real Life 
  • There is at least one school that demonstrates the benefits of Gentle Touch: students are not required to attend class, and if they do so, it's entirely of their own volition. Surprisingly, the students on average do better than those of other schools, due to education being something they seek out themselves rather a drudgery forced upon them.

Top

How well does it match the trope?

Example of:

/

Media sources:

/

Report