Follow TV Tropes


Administrivia / Permanent Red Link Club

Go To

There are some pages that have been permanently etched into the annals of TV Tropes history by being removed and then locked, so that they may never return. The list of these is below.

Historically, this list was created as a repository for certain stock phrases and wiki memes that were abused to the point that we didn't want them to come back, ever. Even now, it doesn't list every cut, locked article, just the most prominent. See the "Unlisted cut pages" folder below for more details on these.

If you wish to have a page unlocked that is not on this list, you can ask in this forum thread. If it's on this list, don't bother without a really good reason. note 

Use that same thread for asking for pages to be added here.

To see a list of pages that were locked but not removed, go to Locked Pages. See also the list of Recent Cuts, not all of which become members of this club.


    open/close all folders 

    Pages cut and locked for reducing the overall quality of the wiki 
There are Verbal Tics and Overused Running Gags, and then there are these. These are former tropes that were deleted outright for being so misused by having potholes to these pages sprinkled around this wiki on pages for no reason other than perhaps to be funny.

  • Did Not Do The Research: Intended as an index for research failure, it attracted lots of misuse as a way of pointing out a research mistake in a work. It was merged with other indexes and christened the Inaccuracies Index for a few days, until it was determined that we don't need that either. These tropes are now listed at Consistency, under "Lack of External Consistency".
  • Hey Its That Guy: The former name of Role Association. Even after the trope name was changed, people still used the old name as a Verbal Tic.
  • I Am Not Making This Up: Originally created for how fans react to crazy plot twists and the like, it was used as a pothole for absolutely anything that was even the slightest bit outlandish, as if it would make it read as a bit of incredibly hilarious and awesome escapism. Instead, it became a grating Catchphrase (appearing on over 2,500 pages at its peak) that made This Very Wiki look like idiots with an incredibly low threshold of disbelief. Not only were all links to it changed to be permanently red regardless of stylesheet, all instances of the phrase were automatically deleted from the wiki, leaving blank spots where it used to be. In-Universe examples were moved to "Not Making This Up" Disclaimer. Since this is TV Tropes, you don't need to say this; since even Reality Is Unrealistic, there's no reason not to believe such things happened. And it's usually better to link to the proof that you're not making it up.
    • No Really: One of many redirects to the above, and even without that it violates TV Tropes' policy about in-site Verbal Tics.
  • Please Elaborate: Poorly written examples should be rewritten or, failing that, outright deleted, not compounded with more useless junk that also acts as natter.
  • Pretty Cool Guy: A meme that was overly redundant and did nothing but encourage meaningless potholes.
  • So Yeah: Used as a Verbal Tic as an excuse to never finish a sentence. Compounded by its small size making it incredibly easy to Pot Hole, this "trope" infected examples across the wiki like herpes, appearing on over 4,000 pages at its peak.
  • Your Mileage May Vary: The old name for Love It or Hate It (and not to be confused with the index page for YMMV tropes), kept being misused as an expression of subjectivity or even to dispute existing entries despite Examples Are Not Arguable. Neither redirecting nor removing the wicks did stop this usage.

    Deliberate redlink 
A small collection of articles actually do still exist, but the titles have been carefully tweaked to appear red. Like the above, this is a subtle hint that users should not be linking to it (at all) in trope articles, but the articles themselves are just useful enough to keep around for future reference. Most are redirects to a page that has been moved, with the old title kept around to keep inbound links working and to help find and change any remaining wicks.

  • Heroic Sociopath: Attracted massive Trope Decay before a split. The page itself still exists as a disambiguation to help with cleaning up the remaining wicks.
  • If You Know What I Mean: the former name for Lampshaded Double Entendre. This led to tropers potholing their own double entendres to this article, leading to a rename. Kept for inbounds.
  • Hot Dad and Hot Mom: Massive misuse and Zero Context Examples led these to be turned into disambiguation pages for several more-specific tropes that involve the concepts.
  • It Got Worse and It Gets Worse: The trope was defined as "a terrible situation getting some final perfect push over the edge". It attracted massive sinkholes and misuse. Renamed to From Bad to Worse.
  • No. Just... No: Originally created for a character's reaction to a Squicky moment or a highly disagreeable statement, it got misused as a pothole for editors inserting their own reaction to what was in other trope examples. In-Universe examples were moved to "No. Just... No" Reaction.
  • This Troper: The page itself has always said to avoid using first-person writing (the phrase being a euphemism for "me" or "I"), but people linking to it either didn't read the article, or simply rebelled against it. Even in designated areas, it's usually better to Pot Hole it to the contributor page...even if you don't have a contributor page. Better yet, avoid talking about yourself at all.

    Main namespace Darth Wiki and Sugar Wiki redirects 
Due to heated complaining and gushing involving these on the main wiki, as well as unnecessary Pot Holing involving them, we discourage linking to these Darth Wiki and Sugar Wiki tropes and pages outside of those areas. These articles should be treated the same way as deliberate redlinks. Their main page redirects were cut and locked to discourage tropers from using them as such.

    Misused trope name 
Sometimes when we rename a trope, the original name has to be deleted if the misuse was really bad.


    Pages locked for being cut then recreated 
Cut pages sometimes have a habit of reappearing very quickly, usually due to tropers simply being unaware why the page had been deleted though sometimes as part of a trolling effort, so they may be locked to deal with this.

For a time, all cut pages were locked automatically as a preventative measure. Such pages are not listed here, so if you find a locked blank page not listed here you may ask here for it to be unlocked.

    Pages cut and locked due to being nothing but complaining 
Becoming a platform for actively complaining about anyone or anything is basically the worst sin any page on this wiki can commit, short of being created expressly for the purpose of trolling and/or conveying hate speech. With the exception of a few Darth Wiki pages which exist as carefully monitored outlets for this sort of thing, any such page is nuked with extreme prejudice.

    Overly-controversial pages/soapboxes 
Let's just say the Rule of Cautious Editing Judgement exists here for a reason.

  • Abu Ghraib: A controversial Real Life prison which only attracted Flame Wars and Misplaced Nationalism, is neither a trope nor a work, and the article was a stub.
  • Busy Street: The page was locked after a heated argument between multiple parties, and eventually cut when the subject in question underwent a drastic overhaul, causing complications that made it not worth keeping the page up.
  • DarthWiki.Complain About Shows You Dont Like: Topic drift from shows to social, political, and religious targets along with racial slurs and constant back-and-forth between fans and haters. Let's just say things got nasty very quickly.
  • ConspiracyTheories.Coronavirus Disease 2019 Pandemic: Major ROCEJ violations.
  • Dueling Musicians: Caused too much edit warring and debates over who is the "better" artist.
  • Encyclopedia Dramatica: The page was very biased against the site and its members, attracting all manner of negative attention from them. No other efforts stopped this, and we have no interest in Tempting Fate here.
  • YMMV.Feminist Frequency: Even after being locked over constant Flame Bait, the drama didn't stop, so the page has been removed.
  • Flaming Fruit Vendors And Angry Arabs: Intended to be a page on the Arab Spring, it was cut due to its insensitive name and excessive use of "recent" examples due to how soon into the movement the page was made. We have a better page for the Arab Spring now.
  • Narm.New Media: Most of the entries went way overboard, descending into outright attacking and name-calling rather than just describing moments of failed drama. Combined with a massive amount of edit-warring, it became obvious that this page was just too troublesome to be left alive.
  • BlatantLies.Real Life Politics And War: Flame Bait magnet, particularly with political matters.
  • Retakers: Hate speech and death threats directed at Mass Effect 3 fans note .
  • UsefulNotes.Scientology: Even after being locked, the fighting didn't stop. Since it was the only Useful Notes page that doesn't help you understand anything on this wiki better, the page was deleted. Church of Happyology describes when people make up a ridiculous religion, and you don't even have to know anything about Scientology to get the joke, especially not when it's actually making fun of Scientology itself. Besides, if Scientology's in a work, you can always use Wikipedia to see how accurate it is.
  • Stormfront: Neo-Nazis are not really a phenomenon that merits a work article.
  • This Troper: Work impossible to catalog due to clashes with site rules on personal attacks and drama importation. To clarify, it's a series hosted on Youtube, about commenting on the controversial and negative topics of this website through a Dramatic Reading of some articles. WebVideo.This Troper was preemptively locked to prevent the restoration of the page.
  • Westboro Baptist Church: A magnet for religious related arguments and complaining. It didn't really help you understand anything on this wiki better due to the church having less than a hundred members and almost never appearing in any works outside of The Laramie Project and Louis Theroux's documentaries.

    Pages that were cut for being too NSFW/Squickish 

  • Innocent Panties: A trope made separate of Panty Shot by portraying visible girls' underwear as a cue of girlish cuteness with no sexual intent (while Panty Shot is for fanservice). Just like Panty Shot, however, people were listing every random upskirt... of prepubescent girls. Even worse, many examples included pictures. This could have just gotten an Example Sectionectomy, but the pedophilic potential was too great.
  • Naked Shotaro Boy: Was a listing of works featuring nude prepubescent boys. In addition to the generally creepy undertones of the article, it didn't attempt any real insight into or analysis of the trope, leaving no reason to keep it.
  • "Rape is Okay/Funny if..." tropes: Very troublesome names for the "Double Standard Rape" tropes that only encouraged plenty of misandry and misogyny by editors. All five of them were renamed and cleaned, with the original trope pages outright purged.

    Pages that were made to bypass an Example Sectionectomy 
Sometimes when examples on a page become problematic the examples will be deleted. See Example Sectionectomy for more on that. When we delete the examples from a page, we don't want them back.

    Unlisted cut pages 
These groups of pages are too large to be listed individually, but general reasons are given for their lock and deletion:

  • YMMV pages about Real Life people: Your Mileage May Vary subpages about Real Life people, while not forbidden from creation by default, tend to become about the people themselves, which is beyond the scope of this wiki. If a person's YMMV subpage is redlinked and locked, it's for this reason. YMMV pages for creators and musicians can only be about their works, not themselves.
  • Headscratchers articles that were platforms for Complaining: It's just unnecessary to list out all of these. Suffice it to say that if a Headscratchers article is permanently redlinked, it's for this reason. Headscratcher pages for tropes are also cut, with relevant material moved to the Analysis/ tab.
  • Pages affiliated with banned tropers: Perma-banned tropers will have their "Tropers/" page locked and deleted. We won't keep a list of banned tropers, since that's exactly the sort of attention that trolls crave. If these banned tropers are obnoxious enough about entry pimping a work that they wrote, its work page can also be locked and deleted.
  • Troper Tales and Fetish Fuel subpages: Cut for being creepy, irrelevant, or both. Some of this material was transplanted offsite.
  • Pages cut under the Content Policy: Pages for works that violate our content policy will be cut and locked. We don't keep a definitive list of these to avoid creating a directory of porn and paedo-pandering.
  • While many older works (prior to early 2012) have Main/ redirects kept as a grandfather clause, before then some pages had the Main/ redirects removed. There is no intention of bringing them back, and newer Main/ redirects can be cutlisted.

    Real Life subpages for items that don't allow Real Life examples 
If a page that forbids Real Life examples is split and has its examples put into sub-pages, the ban on Real Life examples will extend to the existence of Real Life subpages. If they appear, they will be cut-and-locked immediately.

    Potshot redirects 
While Redirects Are Free, sometimes people make redirects that are nothing but Take Thats.

    So Bad It's Horrible subpages which were just that 
While this is one of the few areas on the wiki where outright derision of a work is permitted, there are certain standards that are expected, and limits as to how much edit warring will be tolerated before it's decided that a subsection just isn't worth keeping around.

    Problematic Image Links 
  • ImageLinks.Bound And Gagged: Technically not against any known policy, and while it has the fetish association, it's not something that needed to be in the NSFW tag. Let's just say the discussions went nowhere, and it was decided that picking an image was too much trouble because nobody would agree on anything.
  • ImageLinks.Kim Kardashian: Most of the images were of her looking "sexy", many of which were NSFW. There was really no reason to have the page on the wiki.
  • ImageLinks.Lolicon: Dubious legality, issues with advertisers, and attracted too much negative attention on other sites.
  • ImageLinks.Shock Site: Created via a null edit as a joke...then a Garbage Post Kid found it and added an actual link.

    Former locations of locked pages 

    Persistent initialisms 
We prefer people not to use initialisms and acronyms as redirects to a page, considering that they're often confusing for non-fans and can have multiple referents. Note that some of these are accidental; initialisms with numbers or lowercase letters count as Wiki Words.note 



How well does it match the trope?

Example of:


Media sources: