"Satire doesn't stand a chance against reality anymore."The core idea of Poe's Law is that a parody of something extreme can be mistaken for the real thing, and if a real thing sounds extreme enough, it can be mistaken for a parody (all because parodies are intrinsically extreme, in case you haven't noticed it). This can also happen to someone whose picture of the opposing position is such a grotesque caricature that it renders them unable to tell parody from reality. Reality and parody are further blended by the fact that something that started as a parody might turn into a Windmill Political that some people take as gospel and go to a very serious (if not literal) war. According to the Trope Namers, Rational Wiki, Poe's Law was formulated by Nathan Poe, referring to the Flame Wars on Christian forums where Creationism vs. Evolution was discussed: Many users posted parody comments, which were followed by both angry replies and supportive ones. Poe phrased his law thus: "Without a winking smiley or other blatant display of humor, it is utterly impossible to parody a Creationist in such a way that someone won't mistake it for the genuine article." As far as we know, nothing to do with Edgar Allan Poe. While Poe's Law referred originally to religious fundamentalists, it can also equally apply to rigid atheism, dogmatic socialism or communism, excessive capitalism, extreme environmentalism, crazy feminism, hypersensitive correctness, or indeed, absolutely any other debate where controversy runs high and at least one position is particularly extreme, such as the infamous North Korean Twitter feed that got mistaken for the real thing. A similar notion was named "The Harry Golden Rule" by Calvin Trillin: "The Harry Golden Rule, properly stated, is that in present-day America it's very difficult, when commenting on events of the day, to invent something so bizarre that it might not actually come to pass while your piece is still on the presses." See Stealth Parody, which this law tends to undermine. Don't Explain the Joke is one of the possible outcomes of this law. Parody Retcons attempt to appeal to this, as does the "Just Joking" Justification. If a work actually becomes popular as a result of this law, that's Misaimed Fandom. If you are trying to invoke this trope to get people to believe something you just made up to feign legitimacy, it's a Bavarian Fire Drill. Many a "Not Making This Up" Disclaimer is used to avoid this trope. The Horseshoe Effect is closely related, as it concerns statements which are so radical and extreme, it's difficult to tell whether they're coming from the far-left or the far-right. Compare Does Not Understand Sarcasm, Doublethink, Insult Backfire, Isn't It Ironic?, Propaganda Piece, and Some of My Best Friends Are X. To really turn this trope into a brain-twister, compare it with Death of the Author. See also The Tyson Zone.
— Jules Feiffer in 1959
NOTE: When adding an example, please cite a specific instance or instances of the relevant work being either mistaken for a parody or being analyzed to determine whether or not it is serious. Any examples that shoehorn in a work with Weasel Words or the like but without such instances being cited (i.e. something along the lines of "this could easily be mistaken for a parody", "this might as well have been a parody", or "some people have a hard time believing this is real" with little else) will be assumed to be Complaining About Shows You Don't Like and will be deleted as such.
open/close all folders
- "John Clarke and Bryan Dawe" are a New Zealand/Australian comedy duo that satirize politicians and other public figures. A quick glance at the comments on the YouTube page shows how many people think they're for real. Given that each of those sketches involve John Clarke playing all of the political figures without any change in voice, costume, or makeup, anyone who watches more than one should very quickly realize that he is not both Prime Minister Rudd and Senator Stephen Conroy, but is in fact a sketch comedian. Also, he is not Rudd's successor, Julia Gillard.
- Performance artists The Yes Men have made a career out of this, or at least they did during the Bush administration. One of their projects included passing out surveys - http://theyesmen.org/petitions/pdfs/petition-terrorathome.pdf - under their "Yes, Bush Can!" slogan letterhead, urging people at Republican rallies to specify the rights they were willing to waive in the name of the War on Terror. They had assumed people would be shocked, but instead the audiences filled them out and turned them back in.
- Before reaching unavoidable notoriety, the Yes Men had managed to pull off their satire so effectively, that serious business and economic forums were inviting them to speak; of course, they gleefully complied. One such presentation of note, given at an international textile industry conference, had them deconstructing the U.S. Civil War as secretly fought because the North didn't want to lose access to cheap Southern cotton, and ended with them demostrating a prototype employee-monitoring device that hangs off the user and resembles a giant golden penis. The audience ate it up. The Yes Men themselves expressed astonishment at just how far into the absurd they could go and still have so-called professional audiences taking them seriously.
- Swedish humor show Grotesco featured a song called Det är bögarnas fel ("It's the gay men's fault") which became a hit and can be watched here. It's a textbook example of this trope. The song is sung by a reverend who claims that gay men are to blame for every single bad thing in the world and sings that "I don't know the line and verse, chapter or part, but somewhere in [the Bible] it says that it's the gay men's fault." He and lots of other singers then go on to give gay men the blame for things that clearly aren't gay men's fault. One woman sings that "My son shot four people to death with the hunting-rifle. Somehow, I feel that it's the gay men's fault." A man sings that "I once ate porridge and confused curry for cinnamon, and that wasn't carelessness, no, it was the gay men's fault." It's almost impossible to imagine how it could be more obviously satiric, and still, when it was performed live on the family show Allsång på Skansen, somebody reported the show to the police for being upsetting to homosexuals.
- Another Swedish comedian, Ronny Eriksson, wrote a song in the late eighties that parodied racism. The song, titled "Storswänsken" ("the Great Swede") contains lines such as "Don't believe for a second that the earth is round, 'cause some nigger thought that up", "Get rid of the alphabet and all damn numbers" and "down with science". About twenty years later young Swedish racists began to sing the song as their anthem. Eriksson's only comment was that some people are clearly too stupid to realize when they are being insulted.
- Noted by Doug Stanhope in his No Refunds Tour, when he recalls performing at Edinburgh Fringe Festival. When commenting on the Mel Gibson antisemitism controversy, he noted that people shouldn't care what Gibson thinks and the media shouldn't give Gibson any attention. Cue Stanhope noting he actually needs the publicity, he jokingly noted he'd happily say "I hate the Jews" for a little media attention, only for a journalist to take it as an antisemitism admission, before quoting him saying "I hate the Jews."
- The HMS STFU copied the Harry Potter section that was on our own Warp That Aesop page circa January 2011 as seen here. Most of the commenters took it as real Fan Wank with only a few considering that it might be a joke. Then again, The HSM STFU usualy deals with people who have similar or worse positions in total seriousness - they were the ones who discovered The Girl Who Lived, Hogwarts Exposed, The Last War, and the complete works of pstibbons and Robst, after all.
- There were some posters who suggested The Last War to be a Troll Fic, noting Harry and Hermione's choice of theme song and that it's like a perfect Harmonian Cliché Storm.
- The infamous Zelda video The Light of Courage has an interesting case of something being both incorrectly mistaken for a parody and something fully serious at the same time. The animation behind the videos was purposely kept bad, as was the voice acting. However the dialoge, grammatical errors, and storyline the videos were based on are all real and was done with the serious attempt to get them made into a movie. Aside from the few who know the story behind The Light of Courage, most people can't seem to figure out whether it's real or not. It was based on a horrible fanfic that its creator took completely seriously, then someone else created the parody by adding purposefully badly done animation and voice acting. Also the case for the infamous Half-Life: Full Life Consequences video, though this one is more universally recognized as a joke. At least, it was believed to have been written seriously, until a Something Awful goon called Mattimer came out and revealed that it was in fact a Troll Fic written by him.
- Nobody really knows if My Immortal was written seriously or if it's just the work of a troll of legendary prowess.
- The Prayer Warriors is a troll, but since it focused on common targets of Everyone Is Satan in Hell, including Harry Potter, people weren't sure if it was a troll or some actual bigoted hypocrite Christian who can't spell.
- Some people think that My Little Unicorn must be written by a troll. It's not. The author really, really isn't kidding.
- Hogwarts School of Prayer and Miracles (found here). Allegedly written by a Christian mom. Some believe that the author is dead serious, while others are convinced that it's blatant satire.
- The final chapter reveals it all to be a troll though, with the author (through Voldemort) not-so-subtly calling out everyone who thought it was legit.
- The plastic soldier scene in Toy Story was intended by the filmmakers to be funny, since it was a cliche war scene played straight with toys instead of humans. When it was shown to test audiences, they took it just as seriously as the real thing.
- Many people think Bee Movie is unintentionally stupid when a stupid movie was actually what Jerry Seinfeld was going for.
Live-Action Film and Documentary
- In his review of the film Bamboozled, Roger Ebert noted that most movie-going audiences wouldn't catch onto the film's satire about how black people are portrayed in modern media; people would simply get pissed off at the mere use of Blackface. Indeed, the film ended up a box-office bomb as a result.
- In documentary Religulous, Bill Maher disguises himself and starts preaching the actual tenets of Scientology on a park; naturally, most people laugh at him and call him crazy, unaware that those were Scientologists' real beliefs.
- The jury is still out as to whether Timecube is real or a parody of schizophrenic antisemitic conspiracy theorists. It doesn't help that Gene Ray is a Reclusive Artist.
- A minor example of this happened after Tina Fey made Mean Girls. She commented later, with some surprise, "Adults find it funny. They are the ones who are laughing. Young people watch it like a reality show. It's much too close to their real experiences so they are not exactly guffawing." She apparently meant it to be parody, but didn't take it far enough and it was too realistic for kids to get the joke.
- For that matter, Heathers (of which Mean Girls is a sort of Lighter and Softer Spiritual Successor) was originally meant to be nothing more than a spoof of high school shooting cases, even taking place in suburban Ohio to make things all the more ridiculous. Many people, however, interpreted the film as a genuine deconstruction of high school cliques and teen movie cliches, and it was soon branded a top-tier high school movie.
- Prior to the release of James Cameron's sci-fi epic Avatar, a curious blog popped up called "Stop Avatar Movie." The blog's editor claims to be a transgender woman who is offended by the "heterosexual themes" found in the movie (namely, the apparent lack of non-heterosexual, non-cisgender characters), and urges people to boycott it. She goes so far as to make Avatar the scapegoat for anything in the wider culture that is or could be remotely construed as homophobic/transphobic, regardless of whether or not the thing or incident being discussed has anything to do with the film. The political and social views expressed on the blog are so extreme that even actual gay people are divided on whether the author is just a very dedicated troll, or legitimately insane. For all we know, the blog could have been started to covertly help the film; at one point, the writer actually encourages the offended to buy tickets and then not see the movie.
- CSA: The Confederate States of America is a mockumentary based on an alternate history where the Confederacy wins the Civil War. Said mockumentary details an America, with slavery as part of modern way life, bat-shit crazy politics dictated and decided in part by the desire and need for human chattel, and numerous fictional, parody products with extremely racist overtones. Then the mockumentary comes to its conclusion, and you find out that a lot of those ridiculous, over the top products that couldn't possibly exist, actually did, and were actually being sold for decades. The whole totalitarian plot to conquer the entire New World from top to bottom, that sounds like the alternate ending for The Wild Wild West, or possibly Code Geass: yeah, that was actually the plan all along, and something the Confederacy would have attempted had they won the Civil War. Suddenly, the mockumentary, while still a bit ham-handed in presentation, becomes a little more uncomfortable to watch...
- Beyond the Valley of the Dolls is an infamously over-the-top parody of sexploitation films. However, when screenwriter and director Roger Ebert and Russ Meyer later met the Sex Pistols, they were nonplussed when Johnny Rotten expressed his admiration for the movie because it was so true to life.
- Borat was criticized by the Anti-Defamation League and the European Center for Antiziganism Research for its depiction of Borat's racism and anti-Semitism. The film is actually parodying such beliefs and attempting to expose acceptance of them in Borat's unwitting interview guests. In fact, Sacha Baron-Coen is himself a practicing Jew.
- At one point, there was a popular image macro making the rounds on Facebook which made fun of fans of Fight Club who supposedly contradict Tyler's "don't talk about Fight Club" mantra by... well, talking about Fight Club. Of course, in the film itself, Tyler coins that saying specifically because he knows people will disobey it, and thus expand his sphere of influence.
- Some audiences complained that "the actor playing Joseph McCarthy" in Good Night, and Good Luck. was "too over-the-top". The film used actual archived footage of the real McCarthy.
- When it was released in 1997 Starship Troopers was very easy to mistake as a genuine attempt at making an ultra-patriotic action movie that turned out rather poorly. A decade later its actual nature as a pure and unrestrained satire became painfully obvious as the entire plot of the movie turned out to be frighteningly prophetic. note Meanwhile, the director of the film in question (who wasn't American and had an entirely different cultural background) still nods politely at interviewers who "discover" the parody in the movie. It is fairly certain that Paul Verhoeven knew full well what he's been shooting, considering the movie itself has a number of straight visual quotes from Nazi propaganda and newsreels from both sides of the war, and arguably recreates a typical, infectious Soviet cinema plot about "new country" builders coming from Komsomol youth, overcoming their personal shortcomings (not only ideological, but emotional and professional) in the battle for the bright future of mankind. It helps that the screenwriter of the film is E. Neumeier, the author of equally snarky and incisive RoboCop (1987).
- Rock: It's Your Decision is supposed to be a Christian propaganda film, but the way it plays out it feels like the writer is as mentally unhinged as the protagonist or the writer trolled the Christians who hired him to write their film and they never caught on.
- James Nguyen claims his film Birdemic is a masterpiece, despite the poor editing and writing, among other flaws. Nobody can tell whether he genuinely thinks it's good or he's just trolling.
- There are still people who have to have it pointed out to them that A Modest Proposal is not intended literally. A Modest Proposal was Jonathan Swift's satirical essay that suggested solving the problem of working-class children in Ireland being a drag on their parents by selling them for food to rich people. Most interpretations read it as a satire of British attitudes towards the working-class of Ireland. It created a scandal because some people didn't get the joke (Swift intended a scandal, but not like that). Modern readers who take it seriously justify their stance with Swift's misanthropy and deteriorating mental condition later in his life. At the time of the writing, however, he had no such attitudes or problems.
- Similar misunderstandings occur with modern tributes, such as this letter◊ commending Miami University for expelling a student for this poster◊ which was created to replace a poster put in the men's bathroom which characterized rapists as males. It referenced a "Johnathan S" (name withheld for privacy) who advocated baby-eating, and advocated the burning of his book (held in the Miami University library) by the same principle under which the poster was removed.
- Niccolò Machiavelli's most well-known piece, The Prince, has been argued to be a satirical Take That at the Medici who had recently had him brutally beaten—all his other writings advocate almost the exact opposite viewpoint.
- Bernard de Mandeville, a Dutch physician in the XVIII century, wrote a poem named The Fable of Bees, which was a satire to the moralist campaigns of the time. The poem caused public commotion in the time, because he wrote that the vices of the people can be useful to the society, but today is regarded as a serious economic tract and many economists complain that it's hard to interpret him. It's hard because Mandeville wrote it as a satire; he didn't have any pretension to make a scientific tract.
- In his short story collection Famous Monsters, Kim Newman mentions that Penguin Books asked him to tone down the politics of his story "Pitbull Brittan", a savage satire on Conservatism based on the question "What would it look like if everything the Daily Mail said was true?" To his bafflement, their objection was on the assumption that he was saying the world was like this.
- What exactly Kurt Vonnegut's Harrison Bergeron is a satire of continues to be argued over to this day. Those on the right claim it's a satire of egalitarianism. Those on the left claim it's a satire of the right's views of egalitarianism.
- The Viridian Saga is a parody of Paranormal Romance novels based on the Cthulhu Mythos. It was written by The Nostalgia Chick and her friends, crowdsourced in a series of online videos and aided by ghostwriters. It was self-published under the alias "Serra Elinsen," who also serves as a sock-puppet for the authors to create online drama. Part of the point of the experiment is to see how people would react to it, and the authors were quite pleased when the novel caused some kerfluffle among Lovecraft fans and got some serious literary reviews.
- Flatland is part geometric fantasy, and part satire of Victorian classism and sexism. Unfortunately, it can be hard for modern readers to tell that the author was being satirical.
- Reviewers of Steven Grasse's The Evil Empire: 101 Ways That England Ruined the World are unsure if Grasse truly believes the book's premise that the United Kingdom is responsible for all the world's problems since the eighteenth century or if he is just pointing out the hypocrisy of the scapegoating of the United States that was so common when the book was written, by satirically applying the same attitude to a different country which has also had a history of intervention in foreign affairs. The book's article on The Other Wiki explicitly calls it a comic portrayal, however, which is circumstantial evidence for the "it's a joke" interpretation, despite the author appearing serious in interviews.
- The Houyhnhnm's way of life in the final voyage of Gulliver's Travels was meant to satirize the Age of Enlightenment of the 1800s. A few centuries later, scholars would misinterpret it as Jonathon Swift's idea of a perfect society.
- Inverted, discussed, and Played for Laughs in the German novel Er Ist Wieder Da ("Look Who's Back"). In it, Adolf Hitler somehow ends up in present day Germany and ends up becoming a media sensation because everyone mistakenly thinks he's just a hardcore method actor/comedian. He repeatedly goes on massive spiels expressing his old views and is completely serious, but everyone thinks he's satirizing his own ideals by acting like a Large Ham Unsympathetic Comedy Protagonist. Near the end Hitler even ends up getting assaulted by a group of Neo-Nazis who think he's mocking the real Hitler's legacy.
Live-Action TV and Radio
- The Colbert Report. Colbert plays a right-wing pundit, but the show in general is against right-wing pundits. Many conservatives were convinced that Colbert was a real neoconservative and the show was a parody of the way the left views the right.
- This Ohio State University study examines the topic.
- Averted at the 2006 correspondents' dinner. The organizers didn't mistake Colbert for a right-wing pundit who was going to praise Bush. Colbert was supposed to roast Bush, but the organizers didn't expect him to do it so harshly.
- In March 2014, Colbert drew the ire of social justice online advocate, Suey Park, who started the Twitter hashtag #CancelColbert, over a tweet Colbert made that was parodying the issue of Washington Redskins owner Dan Snyder and his launch of the Washington Redskins Original Americans Foundation. (It must be noted that the tweet in question consisted entirely of the punchline and none of the setup or context). Colbert answers back here.
- Brass Eye, which hoodwinked British celebrities into participating in fictional public information films, culminating in a Member of the British Parliament raising a question in the House of Commons about the ludicrous made-up drug "cake".
- The Power Rangers franchise works by taking action sequences from Sentai series, dubbing them and inserting their own footage, at least two Sentai: Gekisou Sentai Carranger (Power Rangers Turbo) and Bakuryuu Sentai Abaranger (Power Rangers Dino Thunder) were total or partial parodies of the Sentai genre respectively, and made into completely serious Power Rangers series.
- The cancellation of Chappelle's Show and Chappelle's subsequent Creator Backlash response was due to a growing Misaimed Fandom of racist white viewers.
- Housos is a Black Comedy of Australia's working-class bludgers (i.e. the working-class who don't work). Two current affairs programs aired hard-hitting 'exposés' on this offensive new Reality Show. Interestingly, when they realised the show was fake they tried a new angle, complaining about tax-payers money being used to subsidise filth. The show's home channel, SBS, raised all the funds itself. All in all, the Housos creator was happy at the hilarious free publicity, while the current affairs shows got publicity of the wrong kind altogether.
- Radio host Phil Hendrie makes a living on this trope. His radio show consists of a stable of guests that he regularly interviews (the president of a home-owners association, the owner of a restaurant that supposedly sponsors the show, the head of a local activist group, etc.) discussing a current event of some sort, with the guest having some wild, ridiculous, and sometimes offensive opinion on the matter. This prompts listeners to call the show and incredulously berate the guest, whose rhetoric becomes more and more ludicrous as the segment goes on. The joke? All of the guests are voiced by Hendrie, who essentially is having a conversation with himself using a phone handset in the studio.
- Hendrie is very very good at doing two distinct voices, keeping them straight, and "interrupting" himself realistically, so those who tune in to the program in the middle without ever having heard of Hendrie before can be excused for not realizing he's performing both the host and guest parts. However, there's also a meta level to this; it's sometimes difficult to discern whether the callers actually believe the guests are real or whether they're just playing along (given Hendrie's vocal talents, it wouldn't be impossible that he plays some of the more ridiculous callers himself).
- Penn & Teller: Bullshit! does this often to ridicule the topic they are covering in a particular episode, for example polling hippies on banning water (identified as the scary sounding Dihydrogen Monoxide) or asking for donations to fight global warming with no proof the funds will be used legitimately.
- Batman was a very popular comedy show in its day, but a surprisingly large number of modern-day viewers assume that it was meant to be a serious adventure show. This included Neil Hamilton, the portrayer of Commissioner Gordon, who would get annoyed if he saw other actors cracking up on set.
- Adam Carolla and Jimmy Kimmel set up a petition to "End Women Suffrage" with a hidden camera across the road. Footage used in The Man Show depict men and women alike signing the petition and the two of them actually getting a lot of signatures, the signers not understanding what "suffrage" means.
- From the 24/3/14 episode of Media Watch: Two of the following headlines about the missing Malaysia Airlines jet are from genuine newspapers, while one is from a spoof - "Pastor Predicted Disappearance of Jet", "Missing Jet in North Korea", "Plane Stolen by Aliens". Which one is the spoof? The correct answer is "Missing Jet in North Korea"
- A The Kids in the Hall sketch "Kitty History" parodied many historical conspiracy theories. As seen here, many commenters thought the video was seriously supporting those theories.
- Salvador Dalí once sent a telegram for Romania's dictator Nicolae Ceauşescu, for his adoption of a scepter as part of his regalia. Dalí's intent was to mock him, but Ceauşescu, who had one of the biggest personality cults ever, took it seriously, and the text was published in the Party's newspaper. When he did find out it was a joke, he fired the editor who published it. Never mind that he was the one who ordered it to be published.
- Roger Ebert went political and wrote a blog post giving a statement of creationist beliefs, with the intention of making a point about people's inability to recognize irony. While many people did see the satire, a significant number of readers either thought he was being serious or assumed the site had been hacked. PZ Myers criticized the article, pointing out that when there are so many people making the same claims without irony, the joke becomes undetectable to anyone who doesn't already know Ebert's stance on the issue.
- A little known example with Erwin Schrodinger. His infamous Schrodinger's Cat thought experiment was actually made by him as an absurd scenario to point out the flaw with the Copenhagen interpretation of quantum mechanics, which claimed that two systems (such as two subatomic particles) which interacted but then separated would each have to be in a non-definite state until observed. Schrodinger thought this was silly and so came up with a scenario so absurd that it would show the flaws in the Copenhagen interpretation. His scenario was that if you locked a cat in a box with a gas vial of poison that would be smashed upon the decay of a radioactive isotope, then left the box closed and unobserved for a half-life of the isotope, the isotope would be in a superposition of being (i.e. "both or neither") decayed and not decayed, the gas consequently in a superposition of being released and not released, and the cat in a superposition of being both alive and dead. Many laypeople today know Schrodinger's name only from this thought experiment, and assume that he believed (or perhaps even "proved") that quantum mechanics meant that you could have a cat simultaneously alive and dead, when in fact this was intended as an absurd implication of an interpretation of quantum mechanics that Schrodinger wished to discredit.
- There were "scientific" papers and conferences that swallowed and processed nonsensical, but imitating their style and language papers, only to discover they were punned:
- Transgressing the Boundaries: Toward a Transformative Hermeneutics of Quantum Gravity by Alan Sokal. Alan Sokal, a physicist who was severely annoyed at scientifically-illiterate deconstructionist philosophers trying to work quantum physics into their philosophy, submitted a paper to the journal Social Text which declared "quantum gravity"—and ultimately reality itself—to be a social construct, and that somehow this was beneficial for left-wing politics. Social Text accepted it. No peer review, no attempt to verify the scientific 'facts'. Right after printing it he notified them it was a logically inconsistent rambling as bad as he could write without using mushrooms. Oops. Social Text was annoyed. According to the journal editors, they didn't agree with his argument and thought the paper was badly written, but at no point had it occurred to them that it wasn't a sincere effort. Sokal concluded that they had printed his paper because it came from a respected academic and flattered their political views.
- WMSCI 2005 accepted an article Rooter: A Methodology for the Typical Unification of Access Points and Redundancy. The only value it has for computer science is the fact that this garbage wasn't even written by a human, but by a pseudorandom text generator. Then these pranksters went to the conference, held a "technical" session and read a few more randomly generated speeches with straight faces. It's all there — along with the Open Source text generator.
- The Bogdanov Affair is a reversal of the above. Igor and Grichka Bogdanov published their papers in reputable scientific journals claiming that their calculations could puzzle out what things were like in the Planck era (the point immediately after the Big Bang). Subsequent criticisms of the papers by scientists and in Internet forums claimed that the poorly-written papers, filled with many commonly used scientific buzzwords used in nonsensical contexts, were meant as a big hoax. The controversy is frequently called the "reverse Sokal hoax" because A) the material was submitted to scientific journals rather than liberal arts journals, and B) the Bogdanovs consistently maintained that they were completely sincere.
- In 1985 MIT pranksters managed to get a sculpture included in an exhibition at MIT's List Visual Art Center. Titled "No Knife", it consisted of an overturned wastebasket on which was a dining hall tray, plate, bowl, glass, fork and two spoons. It was accompanied by an artist's statement describing it as "a study in mixed media earth tones", and going on to praise and interpret it ("The casual formalism of the place setting draws upon our common internal instincts of existential persistence to unify us with the greater consciousness of human bondage") in a parody of the style of art criticism. It took the gallery staff several hours to discover it was not actually part of the exhibition.
- Valerie Solanas, infamous for shooting Andy Warhol, was also known for her SCUM Manifesto, (with SCUM believed to stand for Society for Cutting Up Men, though she denied this) her infamous rant about how the world would be a better place without men. Even though The SCUM Manifesto is generally taken at face value, Solanas did claim that it was satire, with academics such as Laura Winkiel arguing on her behalf.
- She still shot and nearly killed a man (she shot someone else also, but only Warhol was seriously injured) for having "too much influence over her life". Being objectively crazy blurs the line between "things you really believe" and "things that are so insane they must have been intended as satire" considerably.
- In a strange case, creationist speaker Kent Hovind earned the P.T. Barnum "One Born Every Minute" Award when he incorporated information of the finding of man and dinosaur fossils co-existing and the government cover-up of this discovery, from a website into his lectures as evidence against evolution. In reality, the website was a fake one (and somewhat conspicuously so) that the New Mexicans for Science and Reason (NMSR) had set up as an April Fool's Day prank.
- Older Than Feudalism: Scenes from Aristophanes over-the-top parody of Socrates, The Clouds, were cited in Socrates' trial as if they were real evidence against him. You know, the one that ended with him forced to drink hemlock?
- Sarah Palin mocked the way her opponents obsess over minor misstatements of hers by releasing a blog post consisting entirely of erroneous statements made by President Barack Obama. At least some of her detractors criticized the new "mistakes" from Mrs. Palin. Reimagined with common knowledge that Sarah Palin said, "I can see Russia from my house!" ... via Tina Fey's parody.
- There's a minor political party in Russia called "Communists of St. Petersburg and Leningrad Oblast" (CPLO), that is best known for their public appeals, written in an over-the-top style of mock Soviet propaganda. They sent a hate mail to Steven Spielberg over Indiana Jones and the Kingdom of the Crystal Skull, and accused Avatar of ripping off from Strugatsky Brothers. Recently, they claimed that European probe Philae is a 'space pirate' and should pay for landing on a 'Soviet' Churyumov-Gerasimenko comet. Their philippics have been picked up by media and taken too seriously, so that the real Communist Party had to remind they have nothing to do with that. There's still a debate is CPLO parodying Communists Just for Fun, as an advertisment strategy, or if they're really nuts (which is unlikely).
- As a satire of excessive capitalism, an artist made a bench that you must pay to sit on; overstay your purchased welcome and the bench will impale you with steel spikes. And now, a Chinese park owner who didn't get the joke actually wants to install these in his park to prevent hobos from hanging around on the benches.
- At the First West Coast Computer Faire, Apple engineer Steve Wozniak had made several gag brochures for a successor to the MITS Altair called the "Zaltair." The ad copy was filled with absurd claims, like having 18 expansion card slots, a new "BAZIC" programming language that could be rewritten by the user, and a case that will "add to the decor of any living room." People bombarded the MITS stand with questions about the new model, and it wasn't until late in the day that anyone caught on to the joke. Today, these brochures are highly sought-after collector's items. What made it plausible was Woz's unorthodox sense of humor and that everything listed there did really exist at that time — the fictional computer just had little to do with those features. Except maybe 18 expansion slots — this was how many slots were in the full-feature Altair 8800 MB, though not all of them could be used for expansion.note The first Programming Language that could be rewritten on-the-flynote was actually invented back in '55, but was virtually unknown in the microcomputer world, and a case might be successfully built that the case that will "add to the decor of any living room" was present in Woz's own work — the fair was a venue where the Apple ][ was first unveiled, and it was the first fruit of Steve Jobs' famous "computer as appliance" philosophy.
- After years of secrecy English crop circle makers Doug Bower and Dave Chorley decided to fess up to their pranks in 1991, only to find many UFO-believers deciding that although the circles were man-made, the two must have been possessed by aliens who had made the circles through them. As Skeptoid sums up in an episode on crop circles:
It is an interesting world we live in, where you can tell a group of people that you made a crop circle with a rope, even show them how you did it, and they still insist that an unknown paranormal intelligence did it. You can tell them that two plus two equals four and they'll insist that it's five.
- During a game in longtime New York Yankees shortstop Derek Jeter's final season (2014), the opposing Minnesota Twins featured a hilariously effusive "scouting report" graphic on their TV broadcast, which led to sportswriter Joe Posnanski musing on his blog about how perfectly said graphic could work as satire.
- An "actual news that could be mistaken for satire" example, on Australia Day 2015, when Australian Prime Minister Tony Abbot (who already had a horrific approval rating as it was) decided to have Prince Phillip of England made a Knight of the Order of Australia (knights and dames being something he re-introduced with much mockery from the general public and the media), media writers checking their sources was a common mention in comment articles that day, Abbot's own ministers and the entire media went "WTF? Seriously?!", and First Dog on the Moon decided that Tony had pretty much transcended satire. He hasn't quite entered The Tyson Zone yet, however, despite this currently being the high point of a long string of gaffes and bungled politics that has been going on for longer than a year.
- "Text Me Merry Christmas" by Straight No Chaser is either a sincere song about lovers texting each other at Christmas because they can't be together or a satire about how vapid people who text each other constantly on their phones instead of interacting in more human ways are. The lyrics never directly wink at the audience, but both of the singers are depicted as being alone on Christmas rather than being with family which would keep them apart, and there are a few lines which are difficult to stomach. Naturally, the audience is split between those who think it is satire, those who believe that it must be satire because the alternative is too depressing, and those who think that it is a sweet modern-day Christmas song about being apart at the holidays.
- "The Fox (What Does the Fox Say?)" by Ylvis was made by a pair of talk show hosts and was supposed to be a parody of runaway formulaic pop hits that became... a runaway formulaic pop hit.
- People taking Anal Cunt's songs literally. Or for that matter, anything fronted by Billy Milano (S.O.D. and M.O.D. most notably). Flame wars have been fought over whether songs like "Speak English or Die" are satire or serious.
- Toby Keith:
- The song "Courtesy of the Red, White, and Blue." Is it a genuine (if a little overheated) expression of Patriotic Fervor, or an ironic glorification of the Eagleland (Flavor 2) mentality? It's really hard to tell. The song starts off sincere and heartfelt enough, but the abrupt shift from "melancholy" to "kickass" is bizarre enough to inspire at least a few self-aware chuckles. It gets even more confusing if you watch the music video, which backs up the lyrics with an intense montage of various U.S. military bombs, missiles, and fighter jets, looking almost like a Technicolor Dr. Strangelove. On balance: since most country songs don't feature so much violent or militaristic imagery, it's easy to see this as a spoof; however, the song's Crowning Music of Awesome and throat-grabbing finale make you want to take it at face value. So, all things being equal, it's all probably being played straight. According to Keith himself he originally wasn't going to record the song at all; it was intended to be used only in live shows for military personnel until he was talked into recording it when they loved it. So it's almost certainly dead straight, but the context changes it. Glorifying America's military wrath to the military itself isn't quite the same as just shouting it in the street.
- There's also his more overtly satirical "American Ride" from 2009, which got him considerable heat from both the political right and left for its political barbs. But as several music critics and even Keith himself pointed out, the song pokes funs at both sides of the political spectrum. (It should also be noted that it's one of the only singles in his career that he did not write.)
- In a combination of this and Stealth Parody, Jethro Tull recorded the album Thick As A Brick as a deliberately over-the-top parody of concept albums and the Progressive Rock genre, after the previous album Aqualung was mistakenly called a concept album by the music press. It is widely considered one of the best progressive rock albums ever made, by music fans and journalists likely unaware that the work was a parody. Bandleader Ian Anderson still gets remarks from fans about how much older the fictitious child prodigy poet (Gerald Bostock) depicted in the cover art and album credits who "wrote" the lyrics to the album must be now in the present day.
- However, the follow-up album A Passion Play is apparently a straightforward example, despite having the same structure.
- Years later, Anderson also claimed that it was a parody of the concept albums by Yes and Emerson, Lake & Palmer however at the time Thick as a Brick was released, neither Yes nor ELP had even released one (Yes' would come two years later with "Tales From Topographic Oceans" and ELP would never release a concept album in their history) so it is quite possible that Anderson is being a bit of an Unreliable Narrator. He would finally embrace the concept in June 2012 when he released "Thick as a Brick 2." Though ELP had the album Tarkus and King Crimson made Lizard (both of them having sidelong epics) and Yes and Genesis had a penchant for long songs since the beginning. Maybe the success of Thick as a Brick helped bring it out further into the mainstream, essentially encouraging the trend of concept albums.
- Biz Markie's "Just a Friend" made two VH-1 Top 100 lists and was praised for its "sincerity" even though Biz is not only a rapper but also a comedian, and the song's Stylistic Suck is played for humor.
- Jimmy Cross' "I Want My Baby Back" was meant to be a mockery of those morbid Teenage Death Songs from the '50s and '60s, but was voted one of the worst songs of all time by listeners who didn't realize this and mistook it for a dead-serious necrophiliac love ballad.
- The Rap Critic states this as the problem with Kesha: She's supposedly a parody of current music, but when "serious" artists are making songs that are just as ridiculous, it's hard to tell.
- U2's Zoo TV tour was intended to be an overt parody of mass media, but ironic content was so subtle that may fans believed their appreciation to be genuine. Their subsequent Pop Mart Tour upheld the theme of parody. This time, the target was consumer culture; and fans were just as baffled as they had been by Zoo TV.
- The Beastie Boys claim that their "You Gotta Fight for your Right to Party" song is actually meant to mock partygoers and the whole 1980s party scene, but it's universally appreciated as a party song.
- An entire genre of music, called disco polo was created in Poland as a parody of disco music in the 80s and remains popular to this day (especially at parties). Not many people get the joke anymore, but it doesn't stop millions of people around the world from enjoying it.
- Bruce Springsteen's "Born in the USA" is a bitterly sarcastic song about an emotionally scarred Vietnam veteran who can't find work and is pissed at Uncle Sam for screwing him over. People who don't listen to anything beyond the chorus, however, assume that it's a patriotic song. More than one War Hawk politician has tried to use it for their campaigning.
- One look at SongMeanings.net should give you a pretty good idea of how an over-the-top spoof can be mistaken for reality. The Offspring song "Cool To Hate," for example, is very clearly meant to be a parody of over-the-top teen angst. Yet, many commenters take it at face value and interpret it as a literal "call to arms." Of course, whether or not those are real or just trolling is another matter entirely...
- In one of the darker examples of this trope, Dead Kennedys started getting neo-Nazis at their shows after they wrote a sarcastic song entitled "Kill the Poor". They wrote the song "Nazi Punks Fuck Off" in response. Napalm Death later covered it for the same reason: because neo-Nazis and boneheads started appearing at their shows as well and they wanted them to know in no uncertain terms that they were not welcome.
- Katy Perry did an over-the-top spoof of Hollywood Satanism at the 2014 Grammy Awards. Unfortunately, many people missed the joke and assumed she was a real life satanistnote . It probably didn't help that, around this same time, her "turbulent" relationship with her fundamentalist Christian parents was being extensively covered by the media.
- German "Neue Deutsche Welle" band Geier Sturzflug and their greatest hit "Bruttosozialprodukt". It was meant as a scathing critic of capitalist work ethos. Promptly it got played at a party convention of the CDU (who thought it was a hymn to capitalist work ethos).
- Liturgy had always been a polarising band, but by the time of the release of their third album The Ark Work, even the relatively positive reviews of the album said they couldn't tell if the album was intended completely seriously, or if the band were trolling their listeners.
News and Columns
- The Onion and its sister site ClickHole is the embodiment of this trope, their satirical articles often being mistaken for real ones, while real extremist articles are often suspected of being Onion articles.
- An article called "Harry Potter Sparks Rise In Satanism Among Children", in which six year old girls claim that "Jesus died because he was weak and stupid", was copied into a furious chain letter and circulated about the web. Commentators noted that many of the article's more obviously parodic passages were excised from the letter, suggesting that the poster may not have believed it him/herself. Regardless, it worked, triggering a panicked reaction among fundamentalists, in spite of (or perhaps because of) it ending with J.K. Rowling praising Satan. The very same article led to a concerned parent sending mail to Reader's Digest, criticizing them about interviewing Rowling. After a bit of back-and-forth, the reader mentioned reading about it on The Onion whereupon Reader's Digest pointed out that it's a humor paper, and Rowling is not really a Satan worshiper.
- Their videos have also undergone this trope, one of the most infamous cases being the video "Martial Law Plans Revealed?" taken seriously by some conspiracy sites.
- The AV Club posted an article about how Glenn Beck loved the Spider-Man musical. Since both Glenn Beck and Spider-Man: Turn Off the Dark are polarizing topics which often spark fierce discussions, a lot of people thought this was just The Onion making stuff up, even though the AV Club is the non-satire section. It's not a joke. He really did enjoy the musical.
- The blog Literally Unbelievable chronicles people taking Onion and ClickHole articles at face value and posting about them on Facebook. It is as hilariously depressing as it sounds. Poe's Law applies recursively here, as it's impossible to tell whether the Facebookers are just playing along with the joke.
- The most controversial Onion example is their "Kelly" political cartoons, which still have people arguing about whether they're expressing or parodying conservative ideas. Although the real focus of the cartoons is less ideological than parodying the artistic cliches of bad, lazy political cartoons independent of any specific viewpoint.
- A high-profile victim of The Onion is US Congressman John Fleming (R-LA), who posted a link to the "Planned Parenthood Opens $8 Billion Abortionplex" story on his Facebook page.
- Iran's FARS news agency fell for an Onion article that said more Americans would prefer Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad to be president than Obama. This is somewhat understandable from a country that believes Hollywood is controlled by Washington.
- China's People's Daily Online reported as straight news the Onion story declaring North Korean leader Kim Jong Un the "sexiest man alive for 2012."
- The British newspaper The Independent printed a "CNN statement" on their saturation coverage of a "shocking" dance routine by Miley Cyrus that was actually a satirical Onion column speculating on their motivation.
- 42 Million Dead In Bloodiest Black Friday On Record. Given that such a massive death toll would easily dwarf not only 9/11 but all US wartime deaths combined, and would result in a significant change in our way of life, one would think that no one could believe such a ridiculous story. Cue readers e-mailing Snopes and other sites, wondering if this story was true. It raises the question, which was an example of this trope, the original article, or the people wondering if it was true?
- When FIFAgate happened, one of the fourteen FIFA executives indicted tried to reject those charges and claimed they were part of a U.S. conspiracy against FIFA. How? By citing an Onion article headlined "FIFA Frantically Announces 2015 Summer World Cup In United States".
- While The Onion is perhaps the most famous satire newspaper on this list, other satire newsletters and satire news sites like The Daily Currant and Weekly World News can also fall victim to this. One famous example from the Daily Currant happened when marijuana was legalized in Colorado on January 1, 2014. They published a story titled "Marijuana Overdoses Kill 37 in Colorado On First Day of Legalization", which naturally got well circulated on social media and elsewhere. Apparently, it was so convincing that Annapolis, Maryland Police Chief Michael Pristoop cited it when testifying in front of the Senate Judicial Proceedings Committee about the legalization, having overlooked the three clues that it was a satire:
- The article was published in 2014, but it cited The Rocky Mountain News as a source. The Rocky Mountain News went out of business in February 2009.
- The article also cites an interview with a Dr. Jack Shepard. That's the name of a character on LOST.
- One of the supposed 37 victims was a guy named Jesse Bruce Pinkman. Jesse Pinkman is the supporting lead on Breaking Bad.
- Snopes has numerous examples of rumors that were sparked by articles from these and more.
- The Borowitz Report is a satirical news blog hosted on The New Yorker's web site, which frequently confuses people (especially their right-wing US satire).
- The Mirror released an article in 2011 listing ten reasons why One Direction was better than the Beatles. Several months later the same writer wrote an article titled "Hey dude, get a sense of humour: How I got death threats for joking that One Direction are better than The Beatles"
- Syndicated columnist Jack Kilpatrick once wrote a column purporting to be an interview with an ACLU leader named Eton "Si" Eritas. Eritas claimed he was determined to remove all traces of religion from America, going so far as to change the names of any cities with religious connotations, such as San Francisco and St. Paul. This column shocked many people and sparked countless columns and letters to the editor flaming the ACLU. The only problem? Eritas didn't exist. Eton "Si" Eritas, spelled backwards, is "Note: Is Satire."
- When Private Eye ran a mock-up Daily Telegraph cover, parodying the MP Expenses Scandal the paper broke by targeting its proprietors, the reclusive Barcley Brothers, they received a letter threatening them with libel action. Their response was that it was in the "joke" section of the magazine, it clearly wasn't a real news story, and they didn't think there was a case to answer.
- Private Eye gets this from many newcomers who don't know where the cut-off points between the 'investigative journalism' pages and the 'parody' pages are. There are a lot of otherwise intelligent people who think From the Message Boards (a parody of Internet arguments which contains everything you'd encounter in a real Internet debate) is genuine.
- The Guardian:
- The newspaper finally pokes fun at the long standing leftist idea that promoting humans rights in totalitarian hellholes is the modern definition of "imperialism". Doesn't it?
- They parodied social justice warriors in a column about how Thomas the Tank Engine is racist, sexist, and transphobic, right?
- Michael Savage debates a pro-amnesty liberal over the Arizona immigration laws, and outright lampshades this.
—"Of course you're pulling my leg."
- Right-wing British paper "The Daily Mail" printed an article about a study which demonstrated that, on average, right-wing voters are less intelligent and more racist than left-wing voters. While many chose to believe that the article was satire (as no paper would be stupid enough to flat out insult their readers), a number of upset readers were very upset by the article, which prompted Guardian writer Charlie Brooker to deconstruct it.
In what has to be a deliberate act of "trolling", last Friday it carried a story headlined "Rightwingers are less intelligent than left wingers, says study". In terms of enraging your core readership, this is the equivalent of Nuts magazine suddenly claiming only gay men masturbate to Hollyoaks babes.
- Many people mocked the intelligence of those who believed that the article was real, believing that they were clever enough to see that it was satire. They were wrong. The study is real and was reported on by other news sources, and the result is not surprising to social scientists - a number of studies over the years have indicated the same thing. As was noted by the study, it is not that being conservative makes you stupid and racist, but that people who are stupid and racist are more likely to become conservative. This does not mean that those on the left are necessarily smart and unprejudiced, as the effect is relatively small and there are plenty of stupid people to go around. The authors of the study noted it may also be an artifact of extremist views appealing to the stupid, with extremist views being more often associated with the right than the left in the US and UK.
- In an Onion-like newspaper in Mexico named El Deforma, there was a note about Samsung paying 1 billion dollars to Apple in coins of 5 cents. The note spread among other newspapers, one of them, from Yahoo News (already deleted). There was another article making further fun about it.
- This story from NPR's The World. The Serbian satire website NJUZ (pronounced "nyews", and self-admittedly The Onion IN THE BALKANS!) ran a fake story about a Serbian man who got drunk and jumped in the ocean, and landed on a shark, killing it. Macedonia's official news agency got hold of it and ran it as a real story, and things went downhill from there.
- Iranian news saw an image by satire site The People's Cube showing Iran Hearts Jews, and took it for realz
- The Duffel Blog is essentially a military version of The Onion, and as like The Onion some of the satirical articles on the site have been mistaken for real news stories. One of the more notable examples, given the "victim", is US Senator Mitch McConnell, the Minority Leader in the Senate, took seriously an article about GI Bill benefits being given to prisoners being held at Guantanamo Bay.
- Douglas G. McGrath had a regular humor column in The Nation which was supposed to be the fictionalized diary of a high-ranking bureaucrat in the George H.W. Bush White House. In one column, he had then-Vice President Dan Quayle giving a speech to the Veterans of Foreign Wars where he said, "The Civil War was the best war we ever had because when you're fighting with yourself you're always going to win." In Paul Slansky and Steve Radlauer's 1992 book Dan Quayle: Airhead Apparent, he claimed that the newsletter The Quayle Quarterly, dedicated to his mistakes, had contacted him because people had been contacting them to find out if the quote was real or not. McGrath said that if you were to put that fake quote on a page of real Quayle quotes, "you wouldn't even blink. It's the most interesting thing I know about Quayle: you can make up any quote, the more ridiculous the better, and it'll sound real." In fact, if you Google the quote, you will find it listed on pages of actual political quotes.
- In July 2013, a Spanish website known as Ciencia Seminal (Seminal Science) claimed that Shigeru Miyamoto leaked during an interview about Pikmin 3 hints about Mario and Luigi being, instead of brothers, a gay couple (you can read it here). The way the news was written was so realistic that a large number of Spanish-speaking sites and even radio programs had echoed it as something real. As it turns out, the offending website is satirical. Kotaku has more info on here.
- A lurid story alleging that North Korean leader Kim Jong-un had executed his uncle by having him eaten alive by dogs was printed as potentially true by many English-language news outlets but turned out to derive from a Chinese-language comedy blog.
- A February 18, 2014 opinion piece in The Harvard Crimson called "The Doctrine of Academic Freedom – Let’s Give Up On Academic Freedom in Favor of Justice" has the author argue that, instead of allowing academic freedom, universities should instead enact a policy of "academic justice" that actively bans and impedes any research that might be deemed offensive. "It is tempting to decry frustrating restrictions on academic research as violations of academic freedom. Yet I would encourage student and worker organizers to instead use a framework of justice. After all, if we give up our obsessive reliance on the doctrine of academic freedom, we can consider more thoughtfully what is just." The almost entirely negative responses in the comments include numerous accusations that the author is a troll or a satirist, with one guy saying "Was this cross-posted on The Onion?" while another person says "There's something grimly admirable about an article that manages to be its own parody."
- Brazilian philosopher Luiz Felipe Pondé published an article in of the most known Brazilian newspaper claiming that the reason why the Brazilian Right isn't relevant is because it doesn't know how to seduce women. Naturally, lots of person misinterpreted the satire: on the Left, people thought it to be mysoginistic and a misrepresentation of the Left, and on the Right, people thought it to be a ridiculous reason for their lack of relevance.
- The National Report is a political Onion-like satirical newspaper, whose articles sometimes have been picked by the American religious right as legit:
- Renew America's far-right pundit, Austin Miles, reported in a column that Obama spent his 4th of July of 2014 at a Mosque and invited Muslims to be with him at the White House, as well as saying that Michelle Obama is a transsexual woman originally named "Michael LaVaughn Robinson", his sources turned out to be a satirical article of National Report and this joke website.
- An article about a San Francisco school suspending a nine-year-old student for wishing a "Merry Christmas" to an atheist teacher caused a similar-named school to be inundated by intimidating calls and violent threats.
- This article about a Colorado pot shop accepting food stamps, was taken seriously by many people.
- Since the end of 2013, there has been a lot of debate in the Netherlands regarding the jolly helpers of their depiction of Saint Nicholas, since these helpers look like a toned down blackface◊. Without further analysis in this example, let's go on to the actual example. In early September 2014, the manufacturers of Playmobil dropped the production of figures that depict this helper. In response to this, a newspaper columnist proceeded to write a faux news article claiming that some people managed to ban a chocolate spread from a Dutch supermarket chain because they found it to symbolize Apartheid by having brown and white spread divided in 6ths in one jar, rather than being one uniform blend. The article states that the ficticious protesters argued that the higher ups of the store chain "wouldn't argue that it was a harmless kids spread if Hitler would have had it on his sandwiches" and were actually taken seriously. Many people have already taken this seriously, likely by taking the article's header and its presence in a newspaper at face value without noticing it was a column.
- Tends to happen often with Venezuela's News Parody website El Chigüire Bipolar, but one example that stands out is the article "Chávez is Venezuela's salvation" says 1992's opposition, whose fake newspaper page was used in state television and even textbooks, as the updates show.
- Kyra was able to convince many other wrestlers who didn't know just how outlandish her gimmick really was that she must have been supremely arrogant and merciless in real life. Even fans couldn't decide amongst themselves if Empire Wrestling and Ultimate Pro were presenting her as a parody of the Action Hero or a straight as an arrow example of one. Ditto for Melina's Alpha Bitch role in WWE, though Gail Kim didn't like when Melina admitted they didn't really have a feud, how legit her spat with Candice Michelle was remains a mystery.
- The now defunct blog AntiSpore (a parody blog from supposedly a Christian Creationist taking issue with the themes Spore had on Evolution) fooled many gamers and even websites like Kotaku and Joystiq, at least until some very obvious notes on the blog's "Real About Page" were added, like the following:
But the Bible teaches us that God was not done with man. For we were His creation and He then spoke to Noah in Genesis 8:21-27 after the flood.
"21. The LORD smelled the pleasing aroma and said in his heart: "Never again will I curse the ground because of man, even though every inclination of his heart is evil from childhood. And never gonna give you up. 22. Never gonna let you down. 23. Never gonna run around and desert you. 24. Never gonna make you cry. 25. Never gonna say goodbye. 26. Never gonna tell a lie and hurt you. 27. Never truly believe anything you read on the Internet. There will always be cases of Poe's Law."
- Even after this, people kept up arguing against him for over a thousand comments; there are over 2500 total, and the balance slowly shifts to people actually getting the joke, but toward the end there are still one or two condemning him as a bigot. Most of them apparently didn't even read the entry, and some of them who did read it, and pointed out he'd gotten the Bible verses wrong.
- When G4 held their 2011 VideoGame Deathmatch and pitted The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim against The Legend of Zelda: Skyward Sword, the Zelda Universe fansite posted an article sarcastically imploring their readers to help Skyrim, "our favorite game," help win the vote. So many people in the comments took it at face value that ZU had to post another article explaining that it was meant to be a joke. Incidentally, the comments themselves exhibit this trope as well; site members who got the joke tried to partake of the sarcasm in their own comments and got said comments voted down to as low as -20.
- The "Laughing scene" in Final Fantasy X, which was intentionally made to sound fake and over-the-top in-context, was mistaken as a legit attempt at acting and is frequently held up as an example of poor-English voice acting.
- BioShock Infinite is filled with in-universe propaganda posters. It's pretty clear these are all intended as satire. This didn't stop a Florida Tea Party group from posting one of the posters on their Facebook page.
- A Facebook page impersonating Satoshi Tajiri posted the following: "You all think you have great ideas for Pokemon games, but if I actually listened to all of you and we combined all of your ideas into a game, it would be an unplayable monstrous game. You want a game with all the regions, but only the first generation Pokemons, yet all the legendary ones and such silly things. Whenever I receive one of these rants, I go to the development floor and read it out loud to all the Game Freak employees in a mocking voice, and we all laugh at you." Fans were shocked that the creator of something they loved so much was such a dick - those who didn't realize that even if Tajiri spoke English this well, he'd darn well know that "Pokemons" isn't a word, anyway.
- Grabbed by the Ghoulies was released as a parody of the Haunted House trope. However, a lot of people criticized the game for taking tropes it parodied completely straight. IGN even listed it as one of the worst "Survival Horror" titles ever. Yes, they put a parody of many Survival Horror games as a straight example of a bad one. (Even if it is IGN.)
- In late-1998, an AOL message board called N64 vs. Others had a "writer" from Electronic Gaming Monthly under the name of "EGM Editor" visit the board, claiming to be famed Real Life editor Dan Hsu. His first post was a poll asking what posters believed would be the top selling game of 1998, claiming that the results would be published in the next issue of EGM. It was believable enough that many were fooled into thinking it was the real "Shoe." A couple weeks (and a few more posts) later, he revealed himself to be a fake. Yet the joke succeeded enough that, a couple months later, the real Electronic Gaming Monthly printed a letter from the imposter in their "Login" section and responded by commending him for the prank.
- Every year, the April issue of Game Informer prints several pages of "Game Infarcer", with PARODY clearly stated at the bottom of these pages, that include ludicrous articles and reviews. Without exception, the next month's issue's letters columns is always full of letters from either people who didn't get the joke, or who did and are playing along. It's impossible to tell the difference between the two.
Web — Misc
- Popehat closed their fake Twitter account for North Korea's propaganda ministry after legitimate news agencies started picking up stories from it.
- When Internet Infidels Discussion Board decided to start a contest of making parodies of the creationist organization Answers in Genesis cartoons, they received a cease and desist letter from the latter claiming that the parodies "clearly (are) likely to cause confusion as to the affiliation between your client and my client..." Here's an example: original◊ and parody◊.
- A viral marketing ploy for the movie Hell's Half Acre created the WUCP, an organization that represents the What Do You Mean, It's Not for Kids? mentality to the most logical extreme by acting shocked when they see the movie trailer and are appalled that this is being passed off as children entertainment and call for it to be banned. It's so over the top that no one would believe it was real, right? Well, as a look at the comments will point out, many people took it seriously. On a plus side, the movie producers did get quite a bit of free publicity.
- The Bonsai Kitten web site, which admittedly was a very sick joke, was a joke nevertheless (close inspection of several of the photographs revealed that they were obviously posed, such as a kitten supposedly "in" a bottle being actually behind it). Still, the site drew tons of protests, including several chain letters, from those who failed to grasp the parody.
- Even for those who accept it's parody, the argument goes that those who take it for real might try and do that to actual kittens.
- The ManBeef web site garnered similar reaction. The joke was the site claimed to sell human meat and provide recipes for cooking human meat. The site had nowhere to actually begin human meat transactions, just in case someone was crazy enough to try (and there were a few).
- Tech parody site BBspot ran an article claiming that the MPAA was lobbying Congress to pass a law requiring anyone who owns a home theater setup to purchase a home theater license, and additionally, that they would require people to install surveillance devices to make sure there were no unauthorized home screenings. Even though the site only runs parodies and not actual news, they had to run a second article explaining this fact to all the people who read it and thought it was real.
- A group parodying the Tea Party released videos advocating a boycott of Disney's Aladdin on the grounds that it was Islamic propaganda. Many were confused as to whether the videos were serious or not, but in this case the fact that it was believable as a Tea Party position was part of the point of the parody.
- PolitiChicks, a right-wing "answer" to The View, has led to endless discussion in the comment section (as well as on a number of other sites) about whether it's serious or a parody, with the fact that Saturday Night Live alumna Victoria Jackson is involved causing the impression that it's all a skit. Of course The View has comedians as part of their panel too, and if Victoria Jackson's not genuinely the conservative tea-partier that every bit of public speaking she's done in the last four years indicates, then she's reached Andy Kauffman levels of Stealth Parody.
- Similarly the Radical Feminist blog "Femonade" is widely regarded as an inspired parody due to its relentless use of feminist tropes ('all heterosexual sex is coerced', 'all of the internet is porn', 'all men are bad', 'all transsexuals are men subverting women') taken to an unsustainable extreme. Comments against the blog consist of trolls trying to outdo each other, although including the occasional poster who is not in on the joke and would seem to believe it to be real.
- Regretsy, a website that makes fun of ridiculous Etsy products (its tagline is "Where DIY Meets WTF") has a column called "Etsy or Regretsy?", where they intersperse actual bizarre Etsy listings with parodies created by the Regretsy staff, and have the readers guess which are real and which are fake.
- Yahoo! Answers has Colonel Jack Fessender (Ret.), a longtime poe who has achieved some degree of infamy with way too many people thinking that he is for real. He is also running for President so he can redesign the letter C so it doesn't so much like an Islamic crescent among other insane things. Another indication of his satirical nature is that he named himself after a hoax from a chain email, obviously as a Take That towards the group he's parodying.
- The "Amanda Bieber" Twitter account (more info here) is notorious for criticizing other musicians in praise of Justin Bieber. Her(?) comments are so full of ignorance (e.g. Kurt Cobain is inferior to Bieber because he never got big on Twitter, France is an Islamic country) and hateful vitriol (nonwhite people need to leave America, gays shouldn't have rights) that she must be a Troll. Right?
- The Twat-O-Tron was created as a parody of many semi-coherent and angry commenters in the BBC website's "Have Your Say" section. It produces randomly generated rants formed from careful analysis of the HYS comments, and the results are not unlike the "From the messages boards" section in Private Eye: often sadly indistinguishable from the real thing. The source database has sadly not been kept up to date.
- Project: Free America is a website that advocates for the legalization of homicide and cannibalism. They do, however, Think of the Children! by saying that those under the age of 18 would not be able to legally kill or be killed.
- Conservative state senator Steve Martin (not that one) made a Facebook post in which opposed abortion, calling it wrong even if "the child's host (some refer to them as mothers) wants to kill it". This caused outrage for apparently dehumanizing pregnant women as mere "hosts" rather than human beings in their own right. His actual intention was to sarcastically use the same language that a few pro-choicers have used, whereby an embryo/fetus should be considered a parasite and the mother the host. But this line of pro-choice argument is sufficiently obscure, and Martin's wording sufficiently awkward (the tone switches mid-sentence from "what I really believe" to "what the other side believes"), that it came across differently. (Plus, the word "host" can imply circumstances of hospitality rather than parasitism.)
- This regularly happens to internet memes, particularly anything based around parody of a certain subculture. For instance, "le monkey face" was originally created as a parody of derivative and formulaic "rage comics," but it didn't take long for it to be unironically adopted. And then there's the phenomenon of MLG montages, which were designed to mock overproduced and obnoxious gameplay videos, but quickly developed a fanbase of people who viewed it as simply being the same as those videos, but with more of the stuff they liked (namely, lots of editing and effects combined with loud and unpleasant music).
- There's a Twitter account belonging to Steven Smith, Tea Party member and Representative of Georgia's 15th Congressional district, who's been known for making outlandish remarks such as calling Barack Obama "George W. Bush in blackface". He's also completely made upnote . That hasn't stopped people up to and including Senator Claire McCaskill from believing that he's real and completely serious; when called on it, most people who fall for it claim some variant of this trope, saying it's impossible to tell facetious versions of conservatives from the real thing.
- Jmantime (some images and language NSFW) is most certainly a parody of bad Deviantart "artists", what with the insane pairings of anime characters/Western characters/mascots and celebrities, the use of topical and/or controversial themes (including ISIS-chan and Hetalia OCs), the poor spellings (including the forced catchphrase "Oh Fuck Muffin's") and the use of an edgy Sonic recolor as an avatar. On his Tumblr he states to be half-serious and half-parody, for what it's worth.
- After a French police dog was killed in a raid on a terrorist safehouse in Paris, believed to be linked to the November 13, 2015 terrorist attacks in the city, a Twitter user with the handle SupaSchweppes created the hashtag #jesuischien ("#iamdog") as a parody of sentimental hashtag slacktivism in response to terrorism. It was then taken up by many Twitter users who thought that it was sincere.
- Pokey the Penguin: Is there anyone who actually likes the comic, or is the strip and its fandom just a decades-long experiment in mob-mentality that has Gone Horribly Right?
"Fun game: try to post a YouTube comment so stupid that people realize you must be joking. (Hint: this is impossible.)"
- Popehat's North Korean Twitter news hoax, mentioned above, was reactivated. Five years after the revelation it was a hoax, it could still take in American television talking heads. And Buzzfeed. And Newsweek. And the Washington Post.
- Wheel of Fortune Host Pat Sajak tweeted "I now believe global warming alarmists are unpatriotic racists knowingly misleading for their own ends." after outrage Sajak claimed it was parodying climate change deniers and was hyperbole. The original tweet in question was so close to what some of the crazier climate change deniers are saying telling the difference between sincerity and parody is almost impossible.
- Endemic at Conservapedia, a site created by right wingers as the Moral Substitute for Wikipedia. As soon as it was founded, people descended on it writing completely-over-the-top articles (to the point it's now considered a Flock of Wolves), which some people took seriously. Their serious projects include a translation of the Bible into Conservative language. For instance, the whole "easier for a camel to pass through the eye of a needle, than for a rich man to enter into the kingdom of heaven" thing is apparently socialist, and "blessed are the meek" should really be "blessed are the God-fearing".
- Religion: Claims to be Christian- As of May 25, 2012, says Religion: probably Muslim- On April 27, 2011 Obama officially released his long form birth certificate, which many experts have determined to be a fake and no legal body has determined its authenticity.
- Here's a particularly funny example of (apparent) stealth-parody vandalism.
- Or read their page on Barack Obama, or any Democratic president of the 20th century. But especially Obama.
"Clearly, the cause of the mistake is not that the genuine article is no better than a mockery; rather, the cause of the mistake is that some people lack the critical thinking skills and/or experience to differentiate the two."
- See also the second iteration.
- The Conservapedia article on George W. Bush once said that he was "one of the greatest presidents in American history," that he was "successfully able to salvage the Hurricane Katrina rescue effort after it was sabotaged by a Democratic/Islamo-Fascist conspiracy", and that his unpopularity is entirely due to him being forced by the Democratic Congress to push through bank bailout packages.
- The root of the issue is that the site's proprietor, Andy Schlafly, keeps the site under tight control. The number of satirists has led him to become ever more paranoid and ban-happy... the result being that only the parodists remain◊, driving him ever-deeper into his mad spiral of paranoid banning.
- Rational Wiki speculates that this is the first living example of a "Poe Paradox" — that in any given fundamentalist group, any new person/idea sufficiently fundamentalist to be accepted by the group will come off as being so ridiculous as to risk being called a parodist or a parody.
- This evolved into meta-humor once this entry made its way on there — particularly with this laughable assertion:
- The caption below the picture of the Black Cat and number 13 on that page is even more hilarious. It quotes a Wall Street Journal article to claim that Christianity reduces belief in superstitions, yet the "unlucky 13" pictured is a superstition that has its origins in Christianity.
- This is the basic premise of Rick Mercer's Talking to Americans where he travels around the US asking people about fake Canadian news stories. The show even got the better of some soon to be well known American politicians here.
- Cracked.com has two articles about "Satirists Attacked by People Who Totally Missed the Point," here and here.
- Also, see this article about how the blogger meant to come off as so ridiculous that nobody could take it seriously... and the media thought he was being literal.
- This cracked article is about movie trailers of 2011 summer movies - a romcom, a comedy and an action movie - that can be interpreted as parodies of their respective genres. They aren't.
- It shouldn't take long to realize that this article about Lord of the Rings is a parody. But according to the comments, some people still didn't get it.
- Cracked.com has also argued that the Reaganite fantasy Red Dawn (1984) is actually a parody of resurgent Cold War paranoia, claiming that the film actually used Getting Crap Past the Radar to be highly critical of the United States.
- Yet another article from the site was about a woman who had created a fake online dating profile to see if the rumor that men on that site would overlook personality flaws and mismatched tastes if the woman in the picture was "hot." Even though the profile depicted someone who was very rude and immature, she got a lot of replies.
- There was also a woman on Craigslist who pretended to be a cow to see how many men wanted to date her anyway. About 20 sent in serious responses without reading the ad. 
- During The Second Google Incident, several works were cutlisted in protest to say "This zero-tolerance policy will likely cut this". While obvious ultrafamous works like Romeo and Juliet* had little risk, Black Bird ended up being cut for real (it was restored afterwards).
- One recurring segment of The Chaser's War on Everything played subtitled clips from more extreme Middle-Eastern television shows which decried the west in the most ridiculous ways possible, including Tomorrow's Pioneers, a Palestinian childrens' show ripping off Mickey Mouse but encouraging hatred of the west in children. Given what the War on Everything is normally like, one would expect the subtitling to be a Gag Sub, an exaggeration for comedic purposes. It turns out it's legit — they had to put in disclaimers establishing that The ABC had independently confirmed the legitimacy and accuracy of the subtitles.
- Not Always Right and other such "true story of human idiocy" collections are just plausible enough that it's impossible to know for certain how many of their submissions are genuine, though at least one is a known Urban Legend.
- The government of Malaysia took issue with Unclyclopedia's entry on the country. It's not certain if they were displeased with the site while thinking it's a for-real or a parody.
- There is a wide-spread rumor found around the web that says that TV Tropes features works pages for at least anime series that are completely fraudulent. The "series" in question contain so many of the stereotypical anime tropes and they are described in such a fanboyish way that its impossible to actually tell these pages from the ones featuring real anime series. Presumably, this is meant as tropers engaging in Self-Deprecation. Ironically, it's also possible that this rumor is another example of this trope. This may be based on Ichiban No Tempura, a fake anime mentioned in the "Just for Fun" section, which at one point was mistaken for real and a troper added it to the Sliding Scale of Anime Obscurity page.note Or possibly it could be inspired by TV Tropes The Webcomic, a "webcomic" purportedly starring Trope-tan and being highly Troperiffic, with all the references to its nonexistence being concealed in spoiler tags. Regardless, it means that this example actually has some basis in fact.
- The now-defunct website marryourdaughter.com was a website purporting to sell teenage girls (some as young as 13) to prospective husbands (provided they submitted a "suitable" proposal). It was presented as a way for parents to earn some money, get rid of Bratty Teenage Daughters, and as a way for fundamentalists to marry daughters off Biblically. The website was all a hoax, intended to point out inconsistencies in US marriage laws regarding age of consent and such.
- This article from the satirical newspaper The Daily Currant claiming that Ann Coulter stormed out of a showing of Star Trek Into Darkness yelling that Star Trek had "too many minorities". At least half the comment section missed the joke, although a possible explanation is that after some of the stuff Coulter really has said, it's easy to believe.
- SF Debris is fond of creating exaggerated parodies of Star Trek characters, particularly the captains. Two notable aspects are that Picard loathes children, and Janeway is an insane, capricious tyrant. Both of them managed to exceed his parody versions of them in the show; Picard when he praises Riker for letting a little girl die (rather than save her with his Q-granted powers), and Janeway when she wipes all records of a crewmember and bans the crew from ever speaking of her again (to resolve an issue with the Doctor's programming).
- After the public backlash against celebrities like the King of Spain and several other people who posted pictures of themselves posing with dead animals they killed on hunting trips, Jay Branscomb posted a picture of Steven Spielberg posing with the sick Triceratops model from his film Jurassic Park, adding the caption: "Disgraceful photo of recreational hunter happily posing next to a Triceratops he just slaughtered. Please share so the world can name and shame this despicable man". Despite the fact that dinosaurs have been extinct for over 65 million years, many people took the post seriously.
- The popular short fan film Power/Rangers is a Stealth Parody mocking the idea of True Art Is Angsty by showing that applying Darker and Edgier to something doesn't automatically make it any less goofy or dumb (in this case applied to, obviously, Power Rangers; with the insane grittiness and ridiculously serious tone, all the stupid stuff just stands out even more). However due to the high quality of the film's presentation (it looks like something you'd see on primetime TV), some people didn't catch onto the joke, thinking that the creators were actually serious about making a full-length movie like this. Even Saban themselves mistook it as being serious and tried to have the movie taken down for copyright infringement (thankfully it was put back up later). Word of God says that this was the intention of the project, and the irony was how people enjoyed the entire thing genuinely.
- There's a satirical article by a Polish blogger which claims that the popular Polish cartoon for children Reksio is actually a Satanic propaganda piece. Despite the fact that the article is clearly not serious (the claims are deliberately as over-the-top and absurd as possible) and meant as a parody, plenty of readers took it at face value and most comments around the Polish internet are along the lines of "man, the fundamentalist Christians who wrote this must be insane!"
- There is a loose group of German Web sites collectively known as "Die Redlichen" ("the upright ones"), who are Moral Guardians Up to Eleven. Decrying Diablo II as satanic or relating how they caught their grandchild playing Call of Duty and gave them Corporal Punishment, they successfully provoke angry guestbook entries and irritated discussions on other forums over whether they're serious or not. They also tend to translate each and every foreign word by hook or by crook, such as "online" becoming the nonsensical word "anschnur"; this even extends to the titles of the works they are discussing (they may add the original untranslated term/title in parentheses to avoid confusion but will call it "unredlich" rather than "englisch"). Such habits, as well as egregious individual posts such as somebody ranting that he didn't need to get dirty with his wife for them to have children make it rather obvious that these people are not being serious, but they will never admit it, so a few of them might just be actual kooks, and there is a rumor that a child protection group actually filed charges against one webmaster.
- In light of the controversy surrounding the Ghostbusters (2016) reboot, this Reddit post from r/ghostbusters, where an user asks how to best "filter out" positive reviews of the movie, caught a lot of attention from the media (including outlets such as BBC.) It was widely circulated as proof of how mysognistic haters are seeking to censor all positive reviews of the movie. However, it was a sarcastic troll post, and even the user who posted it admitted as much (and mentioned he was dismayed by how many people took it seriously.)
- The Fairly OddParents: The show's 10th season has introduced yet another character named Chloe who was written to be a Parody Sue as she's blatantly, unrealistically perfect in many ways from knowing 12 languages to having a Nobel Prize. Despite this, she was still given the rights to Timmy's fairies half the time. It was later revealed that she was perfect to a fault as she often tried so hard to make everything great that she ended up overcompensating and ruining everything instead which led to people ostracizing her. Unfortunately, her sue qualities got played so straight that many people (even accomplished cartoon critics) mistook her for an outright Canon Sue and decried her inclusion and how she able to get fairies despite being "perfect". Later episodes would downplay her sue qualities and show more of her flaws.
- South Park:
- This also showed up in the episode "Trapped in the Closet" when an official narrates Xenu's origin story. The phrase, "This is what Scientologists actually believe" was put in because it would've been indistinguishable from the show's weird humor to those who didn't already know the story. Even then, some people still didn't believe it, because even that sounds like something South Park would do.
- When My Little Pony: Friendship Is Magic released a teaser image for an upcoming episode ("Testing Testing 1 2 3") featuring Pinkie Pie as a rapper, more than a few people assumed that the show was charging headlong into Totally Radical and We're Still Relevant, Dammit territory. Fortunately, when the episode actually aired, it quickly became clear that the rap was intentionally ridiculous, as it was a parody of Totally Radical edutainment from the 90's. In particular, it's a rather direct spoof of the rap segment from the infamous Don't Copy That Floppy PSA.
- The Simpsons: "The Simpsons Spin-Off Showcase" satirized the trend of TV networks trying to make spinoffs and successor series that are frequently inferior to the original show (this episode predated Futurama and Seth MacFarlane's animated shows), with all three segments deliberately badly scripted, bland and cheesy. However, some fans mistook the Stylistic Suck for actual bad writing, even thinking the show was finally Jumping the Shark, something Matt Groening was worried would happen.
- A YouTube user named Tamtampamela had a channel on which she posed as a satire of fundamentalist Christians, but when she put up a video thanking God for the Japanese earthquake, saying that he had caused it to punish Japan's atheist population, it immediately went viral and she started receiving death threats, causing her to eventually come clean that it was a parody.
- Just as YouTube user potholer54 was about to nominate a creationist for his 2008 Golden Crocoduck Award (given to the creationists who knowingly and most effectively lied to support their arguments), the creationist outed himself as a satirist. Despite this, potholer explained that one of his arguments (the rings of Saturn prove a young solar system) is actually used by some creationists. Watch for yourself here.
- Matt Harding of Where The Hell Is Matt fame did a joke video claiming that his Where The Hell Is Matt videos were just an elaborate hoax, involving robot backup dancers and other such absurdities. Soon news articles around the Internet were lambasting Matt for this terrible deception, to the point where he had to make a public announcement that the hoax was a hoax.
- Several videos, such as the famous "Angry German Kid" video were originally made to satirize how German politicians saw gamers. Unfortunately, if you ask around today, most people won't actually know it's faked because of how easy it is to put on a show for the camera.
- Another famous video, the Greatest Freakout Ever: At least 3/5 of the comments were "Boy, this is what World of Warcraft does to people?!?", ignoring that you can replace "World of Warcraft" with "Xbox Live" or "EverQuest" and it'd still make sense... or that. The internet still seems to be divided between those who think it was fake and those who think it was real, without any conclusive proof one way or the other.
- Detractors often point to the over-the-top reactions of Steven (the freakout kid) as clearly being acted.
- Some cite the interview of Steven by Daniel Tosh on his tv show Tosh0 as definitive proof that the video was fake. The episode involves Tosh interrogating Steven, with the help of Michael Winslow (You know, that guy who makes the funny noises), eventually using a polygraph machine, and finally resorting to a threat to shove a remote up his butt if he doesn't tell the truth. This is a comedy show, and it's not known what occurred back stage.
- P.Z. Myers fell victim of this in this blog post where he rants about an anti-feminism YouTube video while labeling it as "Our Opposition", it should be noted that some of the commentators of his blog started invoking this law pointing out that it was so over-the-top it had to be a parody, only to be dismissed by the rest of the commentators and P.Z. himself. Then the original poster of the video made a response video MSTing and mocking P.Z. and his commentators for taking it at face value.
- The maker of this "Cinema Trailer Sins" video criticizing the teaser for Godzilla (2014) had to post a comment stating that his extreme nitpicking and Insane Troll Logic were never meant to be taken seriously after Godzilla fans lashed out at him and got the video downvoted really low. (It should also be noted, however, that this channel is also a parody of the (massively) more popular and (slightly) more professional CinemaSins channel, thus accounting for many of the downvotes.)
- Third Rate Gamer, a Stylistic Suck parody of Caustic Critics (The Irate Gamer in particular) is often mistaken for a legitimate, awful reviewer. His Nintendo DS "review" begins with a disclaimer that says that the show is a parody, but if you read the comments to some of his other videos, you can still find people confusing him with an actual reviewer.
- A few days before the 2014 Isla Vista Massacre, the perpetrator, Elliot Rodger, posted a video espousing his beliefs and plans for "revenge." The video ended up being posted to reddit's r/cringe subreddit, where commenters had a hard time telling whether he genuinely wanted to kill people or was just a massive troll.
- YouTube user 1stkirbyever ran into this while simultaneously demonstrating a glitch in the Sonic Generations demo and parodying Sonic's infamously Unpleasable Fanbase. After seeing that some people missed the joke, he add a disclaimer to the sequel stating, in large, bold letters, "I AM NOT SERIOUS." There were still people who missed the joke, even with the disclaimer. You can tell he's basically given up on the parody part with the third installment.
- Islamic State of Donbass and Lugant, a parody of jihad videos by pro-Russian insurgents in eastern Ukraine, complete with nasheed (Islamic acapella chants) & their flag modified to include Islamist symbolism. Ukrainian & other commenters mistake them as an actual Islamist terrorists, while the Russians are joking about their Orthodox "jihad".
- There are Muslim volunteers fighting in the pro-Russian side, but NONE of them are radical Islamists related with the jihadist movements.
- During the Caustic Critic boom of 2007, when everyone with a camcorder was jumping on the Angry Video Game Nerd bandwagon, one particular user named Armake21 chimed in. According to himself he was supposed to be riffing on reviewers who wanted to be the AVGN but had no idea how to write jokes beyond "swear at the TV". In terms of viewership, he was moderately successful. In terms of the parody... not so much: after a review of Shinobi for the NES he had to post a follow-up video demonstrating his previously-poor skill was actually Stylistic Suck.
- The video shown here was posted by a user who intended (he claimed) to make a political satire. The video consists of a real Arabic newscast with phony subtitles. President Obama's detractors quickly took the video as fact and posted it on several conservative blogs, until the poster, - who admits to being conservative but quotes the Trope Name directly (as shown) - cleared it up.
- Mc Juggernuggets falls into this a lot - one of the major questions fans and haters have is "Is this real or not?". The depiction of a dysfunctional family, an abuser losing people to dominate and becoming less rational as time goes on, multiple abusive relationships, nobody thinking to help (Especially not the police), as well as the fact that the title character (Jesse) regularly moves back to a house where he's clearly abused brings up a lot of people to suspect both.
- A passage in What Th—?, Marvel's parody comic, has a hypothetical story in which the Fantastic Four meet Superman. The writer of the story comments in a footnote that it is impossible to write a parody of The Thing's dialogue that doesn't sound exactly like something he would really say.
- In one Sid the Sexist strip, Sid managed to score a bird on Blind Date because she thought he was a comedian and only pretending to be a perverted Geordie stereotype.
- Leo and Max's 'Springtime for Hitler' gambit in The Producers; they aimed to produce the biggest flop ever so they could make off with the investment money, so they took in a story glorifying Hitler and made it as offensive as they could. Unfortunately, the actor playing Hitler himself was so terrible that the audience assumed that it was a parody, and the show sold out. The director deciding to throw in some catchy musical segments didn't help.
- In the musical version the former Nazi Franz who will be playing the part of Hitler breaks his leg just prior to curtain, and is replaced by the director — who turns flamboyant up to eleven. The original version had him played by a beatnik.
- Roger Ebert noted that this is what actually torpedoed Leo and Max's scam. If they had gone all out (i.e., featured the Holocaust or Operation Barbarossa in their pro-Nazi musical), then their plan would actually have worked, as nobody would want to see satire that distasteful.
- Exploited and combined with Refuge in Audacity in the Honor Harrington book On Basilisk Station through the "big lie" theory. After the Republic of Haven gets their hand caught in the cookie jar regarding their schemes with Basilisk, Honor hopes that Havenite civilians will see through their government's outrageously false Propaganda Machine, which paints themselves as the real victims of the debacle, just as easily as the Manticorans have. Unfortunately, as gets explained to her by experts on such matters, the fact that said propaganda is so outrageously false is also what leads the Havenites to accept it at face value; they would never believe that their governing authorities would deliberately lie to them in such an audacious manner, so they end up believing them even when they are lying.
- Darrel Bristow-Bovey's self-help satire I Moved Your Cheese complains about how hard it is to write a self-help satire:
When it comes to the self-help genre, the line between satire and the real thing is drawn in water with a blunt pencil.
- In P. G. Wodehouse's short piece "How Kid Brady Broke Training", Kid Brady, after reading a magazine, goes off meat and starts an all-fruit diet under the belief that it will make him a better fighter. He later meets the article's author, who tells him that it was meant as satire, "[b]ut so subtle and delicate is my humor that apparently the thing is misleading".
- In Erasure by Percival Everett, an intellectual black author, sick and tired of his philosophical books being passed over for publication because they're not suitably "Black," writes a way, way over the top parody of thuggish ghetto-chic blaxploitation called My Paffology and has his agent send it out as a protest. Random House accepts the book at face value as a fierce portrayal of the Black experience and pays six hundred grand for it. The book, now renamed Fuck, goes on to win the National Book Award.
- This is what got the Bill of Life, which allows parents to have their children's body parts be divided and used as transplants once they reach age thirteen, passed in Unwind; it was proposed in order to make both sides in the Heartland War realize how ridiculous they were being. What wasn't expected was both pro-choice and pro-life people to embrace it as the only way to compromise.
- An episode of Murphy Brown had Murphy passing off a painting her infant Avery had created, with the fake name of "A. Very". One critic thought it was brilliant. The other thought it was child scribblings. An art buyer bought it for an obscene amount because the two critics were arguing over it.
- Taken to something of a logical extreme in Homestuck, where Sweet Bro and Hella Jeff, Dave's Stylistic Suck webcomic, is described as "a webcomic ironically maintained through a satirical cipher" with "legions of devoted fans, most of whom are totally convinced" of his sockpuppet persona's sincerity. A bit of meta irony kicks in when you consider that in real life, Sweet Bro and Hella Jeff actually is much better known than Homestuck and MSPA, and genuinely does have legions of devoted fans (though most of them are well aware of its ironic Stylistic Suck value).
- In a Checkerboard Nightmare arc, the titular character creates a children's show centered entirely around promoting himself and his merchandise. Said Merchandise-Driven nature is so transparent that the show becomes a hit amongst teenagers and young adults who mistake it for biting satire (the fact that Chex could only afford for the show to be run on a 4AM timeslot didn't help).
- Saturday Morning Breakfast Cereal parodies this here.
- This comic from the Australian version of The Guardian claims that it is no longer possible to satirise Australian Prime Minister Tony Abbott.
- The Nostalgia Critic:
- In their review of Scooby-Doo, his younger self defends the movie by claiming that it's making fun of the show's pointless celebrity cameos. The Critic responds that no, the movie just has pointless celebrity cameos.
- Sometimes the Critic's opinions are mistaken for those of Doug Walker's, one such misunderstanding lead to a short feud between the the character of the critic and Mara Wilson, when Wilson had mistaken the Critic's vitriol for Doug Walker's honest opinion.
- A common problem on blogs like "White Whine" and other collections of First World Problems — for every entry that is a genuine example of someone engaging in over-the-top and unnecessary complaining about a trivial issue, there is another which is clearly either a parody of that type of person or someone who is perfectly aware that their current issues are trivial but are simply exaggerating for humourous effect or to vent.
- Cracked's The 5 Most Epic Backfires in the History of Bad Jokes. From the lead: "The problem with sarcasm is that you can do it so well (or so poorly) that people don't realize you're joking."
- Discussed on Zero Punctuation. More than once (such as in his review of Deadpool) Yahtzee states that video game violence is already so extreme and ridiculous that its nearly impossible to parody.
- Invoked in a devastating satire by Australian comedian Craig Reucassel, in which he said that the controversial climate-change skeptic Lord Monckton note was a satirical character played by Sacha Baron Cohen— and proceeded to interview an unsuspecting Monckton himself about it, asking such questions as "Will we ever see Ali G or Borat come back?" Monckton was bewildered, to say the least.
- As its owner has pointed out, the GOP Teens Twitter account is often mistaken for serious at first glance. Actual GOP Senator Rand Paul is apparently a fan, although it's not known whether it's because he finds it funny or because of this trope.
- South Park
- The episode "The Tale of Scrotie McBoogerballs" has this happen: Upon finding out that The Catcher in the Rye is overhyped, the kids write an offensive story about nothing in particular, solely to be more offensive than The Catcher in the Rye was claimed to be. The adults find it, and believe that it's a great literary work, even after the kids explicitly tell them that it is nothing more than a string of gross-out attempts on paper, and that there is no actual story in it.
- The 16th season episode "Sarcastaball" revolves around a game which Randy invents as parody, but which everyone else takes seriously.
- In the Beavis and Butt-Head episode "Buttniks," they wander into a coffee shop and witness a poetry slam. Butt-Head goes on stage and deliberately stinks up the joint to the annoyance of the crowd. Beavis drinks lots of cappuccino (or, as he called it, "Crappuccino") and turns into the Great Cornholio and goes off on an insane incoherent rant. The audience loves it and call it "ground-breaking stuff," instead of recognizing it as the babblings of an overcaffeinated psycho.
- The Simpsons: One episode has Marge finding a copy of The Onion on her neighbor's coffee table. Upon reading it, Marge is surprised at the headlines only to be informed that it's satire. Next, Marge opens the paper and upon reading the movie reviews, laughs at what the critics say about the movies only to find out the movie reviews are real.
- In the Family Guy episode "Brian Writes a Bestseller", Brian manages to pull this off with a hastily-written self-help book called "Wish It, Want It, Do It", which he wrote as a statement on self-help books in general. However, it winds up becoming a bestseller, and he ultimately buys into his own hype. It ultimately takes Bill Maher to get Brian to admit the truth and be shooed off the set.
- In the Phineas and Ferb episode "The Secret of Success", Doofenshmirtz holds a telethon to fund his evil schemes. Lawrence, watching from a dentist's office, believes it's "a brilliant work of satire" and declares it his new favorite show.
Ha, you fell for it! This isn't a TV Tropes article at all, it's a scathing parody of one.