Follow TV Tropes

Following

Darker And Edgier / Comic Books

Go To

https://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/untitled-11_2962.png

"It all started in the Seventies with the appearance of "heroes" like The Punisher and Wolverine. Instead of being hurled through a swirling dimensional vortex to seeming oblivion, a super-villain was now more likely to take a bullet to the brain, or a claw through the heart! Committing crimes and fighting super-heroes became dangerous!''

No wonder the bad guys starting acting a little rowdier — can you blame 'em? Suddenly, villains like Doctor Doom — who'd up till now pranced around with an air of menace but never actually did anything to anybody — started bumping off people left and right — some of 'em just for snoring too loudly!
Marvel Year in Review 1993
Advertisement:

  • In comics, this move is most famous for Batman. After the end of the Batman (1966) TV series, it became apparent the campy tone had burnt out, and DC realized a change was needed quickly. With Denny O'Neil's writing and predominantly Neal Adams's gothic and realistic art, Batman was made a darkly fearsome night stalker much like he was in the original stories before he was softened for kids. Later, in the mid-80s, Frank Miller's Batman: The Dark Knight Returns overclocked this to dangerous levels.
    • The shift also carried over to Batman's Rogues Gallery, most notably The Joker, who had been written as a comical "Clown Prince of Crime", but now returned to his psychotic murderous roots and building up one of the largest body counts in the DC Universe (only being outdone by alien societies and villains with near-god level power).
    • In the '90s the Batgirl mantle was passed from Barbara Gordon to Cassandra Cain, a character who came complete with a much darker origin (she's a mute trained from birth to be an assassin) and a costume that wouldn't look out of place at a BDSM club. Fortunately, she was written well enough in her own series to not come off as ridiculous, in particular being one of the most moral and kindly members of the Bat-family despite her grim background and sinister look.
    • Bat-Azrael was a darker, edgier, more brutish version of Batman, created to show what makes the true Batman not a vigilante. However, DC was ready to keep Azrael as Batman, if it sold well enough.
    • Advertisement:
    • Jason Todd as Batman is similar to Azrael: a thuggish, heavily armored Batman who guns criminals down with his pair of pistols. Fans have taken to calling him "Gunbats".
    • From Death of the Family, a number of people might laugh and say that Joker can't possibly achieve this trope at this point. They would be wrong, because his treatment of Harley Quinn is even worse than it was before! Though given who she is...
    • Not even the mantle of Robin is safe from this "dark and edgy" obsession. Tim Drake whose era as Robin is probably most similar to Dick Grayson, gets replaced by the dark and edgy Damian Wayne. Ironically, Tim Drake was an aversion of this trope by replacing the dark and edgy Jason Todd as Robin and right at the cusp of the Dark Age of Comics no less though his costume was physically darker and more practical than those of his predecessors.
    • Advertisement:
    • The New 52 remade Mr. Freeze in this fashion, because apparently his Canon Immigrant status as a Tragic Villain from Batman: The Animated Series didn't work with the rest of Batman's Rogues Gallery being psychopaths and lunatics. In this new iteration, Freeze and Nora were never married; Nora was frozen in cryogenic stasis in the 1920s for a heart condition, Freeze merely worked at the storage facility where her capsule was kept and became obsessed with her, leading to his physiology-warping accident. Also, Freeze's obsession with freezing things and ice manifested when, after his mother fell through some ice and almost died as a little boy, he subsequently took her back and pushed her back into the freezing-cold water.
  • Indeed, The Dark Age was an instance of this for the entire American Comic Book medium.
  • Speaking of Alan Moore, he actually did a Darker and Edgier reboot of UK superhero Marvelman as well. What had originally started out as a British Captain Marvel rip-off, turned into a gritty, Total Recall-ish, what-is-real head trip, that even turned his Freddy Freeman-esque sidekick Kid Marvelman into a sadistic psychopath, with graphic violence that was unprecedented in the genre at the time and is still shocking today.
  • The Transformers: Generation 2 comic books, loosed from even the moderate Contractual Immortality restrictions they had been operating under before, promptly started massacring the cast. Issue #1 cover copy: "This is Not Your Father's Autobot." #2: "Fort Max Gets the Ax." #3: "Killing Frenzy." The characters would also kill without hesitation and use guns that weren't their signature weapons.
  • Here's one way to kill the party: Turn cheerful, bouncy Robbie Baldwin from the playfully heroic Speedball into an apparent murderer with a guilt complex worthy of Angel. Now he calls himself Penance, and wears a suit with 612 built-in points of pain, one for each person killed that day. His new powers can only manifest when he is in pain.
    • In Thunderbolts, however, Penance has come to terms with the Stamford incident not being his fault. He reveals to Nitro the real reason for the suit. The suit wasn't for Robbie, it was for Nitro. Robbie captured Nitro in Latveria to punish him for the Stamford incident, put him in the suit and proceeded to beat the CRAP out of him, after which he removes the last spike from his own chest to symbolize that he's freed himself of guilt.
    • He later returns to the Speedball identity as an instructor at the Avengers Academy, but retains his more serious demeanor. He leaves the school after finally coming to terms with the Stamford incident, and has since appeared in Nova with his previous cheerful personality restored. He still occasionally uses the Penance helmet though, as it's apparently the only way he can access his pain-based powers.
  • Ultimate Marvel deconstructed most of the characters from Marvel Comics, bringing them back to their initial premise and placing them in a Setting Update. In many cases they became Adaptational Jerkass as a result. The superhero team The Avengers was reimagined as a military operation (in The Ultimates) and the supervillain group the Brotherhood of Evil Mutants was reimagined as a terrorist group (in Ultimate X-Men).
  • X-Men were always one of the darker comic books since the 80s, what with their focus on a discriminated minority group who often fought against extremists and genocidal bigots who were A Nazi by Any Other Name, and storylines such as the Morlock Massacre. But in the 2000s, after House of M came the Decimation, where mutant numbers were dropped down to barely past 300, many of whom were immediately murdered, forcing the X-Men to abandon traditional heroics and move towards a more pragmatic, militarised and compartmentalised structure. Not helped was that shortly before this saw Jean Grey, arguably The Heart of the X-Men, be Killed Off for Realnote  and her place as the main female lead being replaced by Emma Frost, who functioned as an Anti-Hero Substitute for Jean.
    • What's commonly pointed to was the Character Development of Cyclops, who started this period suffering from PTSD after an incident with Apocalypse, and then manipulated by Emma Frost into a psychic affair during their therapy sessions followed by Jean's death and Cyclops being psychically forced into a relationship with Emma afterward. This combined with everything the X-Men were going through prompted him to take decisive action to maintain the survival of the mutant race, even as he was forced to make moral compromises other heroes dared. This was best shown by the formation of X-Force, a black-ops hit-squad taking the best and most capable killers among the X-Men's ranks, as well as a Boxed Crook or two. Even Wolverine was a little disturbed by the lengths Cyclops was willing to go to, which eventually caused a bloody falling out between the two.
    • The whole "Professor X is no better than Magneto" creep from the Ultimate to the main universe that was exemplified by Deadly Genesis, where it was revealed that Professor X led a team of X-Men to their deaths in rescuing his original team from Krakoa and just mind-wiped everyone into forgetting that it happened and trying again with another new team. And that Professor X later realized that the Danger Room was becoming sentient, but ignored it, leading to Danger being created years later.
    • This all came to a head with the finale of Avengers vs. X-Men, where Cyclops snapped and killed the Professor while possessed by the Phoenix Force. Now he's on the run with his own team of outlaw X-Men, though this is somewhat zig-zagged, however. With mutant numbers restored, Cyclops' team actually returned to the old 'hated and feared' roots, going out of their way to protect those who would harm these new and re-powered mutants, while Wolverine (who had seemingly became Lighter and Softer after a falling out with Cyclops over the aforementioned extreme actions) regularly comes off as a thoroughly sanctimonious and Holier Than Thou hypocrite considering his past. He's not alone in it either, something which, after Battle of the Atom, Kitty Pryde, moral centre of the X-Men, calls them out for. Indeed, Cyclops' team is arguably still fairly idealistic - specifically, when Magneto reprimands Teen Jean for trying to mind control Teen Angel into staying with the O5, he says, "That is not what Charles Xavier taught you, young lady!" It was overall more a case of the team being subject to a lot of Informed Wrongness from Wolverine and his team that made them seem Darker and Edgier, especially as while Wolverine's book got weirder briefly, also lead to an arc where Wolverine loses his powers and becomes so much of a toxic Jerkass as a result it alienates most of the people who cared about him before he was then killed off.
      • And then there was the whole Terrigen Cloud/M-Pox plot, which led to Inhumans vs. X-Men. This particular era was regarded as such a huge Dork Age in large part because it tried to app the previous Darker turn, when it was barely even old history and most fans were calling it out on repeating the same story beats, only without Cyclops to act as the scapegoat for the X-Men's harsher actions to survive. Not helped was that the Inhumans/X-Men conflict was intended as a Both Sides Have a Point plot, but the Inhumans' desire to force the mutant population to just deal with a painful and uncurable pathogen that was wiping them out and objected to their attempts to stop it because of its cultural importance to them instead just turned the Inhumans franchise into a Villain Protagonist group.
      • Following ResurrXion, however, there was a decided swing to the Lighter and Softer end, with the X-Men being more traditionally heroic. Jean Grey, long-dead during the aforementioned periods, was resurrected and lead an X-Men team that was all about making the world a better place, while Kitty Pryde, the moral centre after her, became their new leader. This unfortunately didn't last and things got even darker with Uncanny X-Men (2018), starting with the Dissassembled storyline and the subsequent run by Matthew Rosenberg which saw Cyclops and Wolverine, back from the dead, struggling to maintain what's left of the mutant community in the wake of the apparent death of the X-Men and the forced mass curing of the mutant population. The series was a lame duck, put out to pass time until Jonathan Hickman's X-Men relaunch, so the creative team just decided to have 'fun' by making everything as depressing and bleak as they can.
  • A 2004 Thunder Cats mini, Thundercats: The Return. Lion-O gets trapped in the Book of Omens for five years, and when he gets out he finds the Thundercats beaten, Bengali killed and enslaved by Mumm-Ra. Like Wilykit and Wilykat. Let's just say that puberty has been good to them, and that Mumm-Ra has the same tailor for his slaves as Jabba the Hutt. There is also implied rape of Cheetara by the Mutants. And then there's Lion-O brutally breaking the neck of an ape mutant.
  • Marvel as much as said at the time that the thinking behind US Agent, War Machine, and Thunderstrike was to have Darker And Edgier versions of Captain America, Iron Man, and The Mighty Thor, without losing the originals. There's even a famous Avengers cover of the two versions facing off. Though created prior to the decade, they would see their heyday as Nineties Anti Heroes.
    • Interestingly, Thunderstrike was probably the furthest from this trope, as he was a man juggling between being a dad and a superhero. The only time he really entered this trope was when he was possessed by the Executioner's battle axe Bloodaxe
  • Superior Spider-Man runs on this trope. The plot involves Otto Octavius becoming the new Spider-Man after stealing Peter Parker's body, and taking up his predecessor's war on crime while ignoring his Thou Shalt Not Kill rule. He's more vicious, brutal, and condescending than Peter, and even sports a black and red outfit in contrast to Spidey's classic, colorful duds. Fun fact, the costume was originally designed by Alex Ross for the first Sam Raimi Spider-Man movie. The suit was mostly black because Ross felt it'd make the outfit more serious and realistic. Ultimately, Superior subverts it by having Otto realize that Peter and his Lighter and Softer approach are superior, making Peter the true Superior Spider-Man.
  • Supergirl:
    • The Supergirl from Krypton is her origin story. In the original Silver Age version, she lands on Earth and is found by her cousin who sees that she is being taken care of (even if his methods are questionable). The Post-Crisis Story Arc involves kryptonite meteors, fanservice, a paranoiac Batman and Darkseid kidnapping her and brainwashing her. On the plus side, Superman immediately wanted to take his cousin in and introduce her to Lois.
    • At the beginning Kara was a naive, innocent, sweet newcomer. However she grows up during the Silver and Bronze Ages, and although she never stops being an idealistic hero, her childlike innocence goes away. This is made clear in Adventure Comics #424, in where she wears sexy clothes while trying to get a scoop.
    • When Supergirl was rebooted in the Post-Crisis continuity, several writers and editors thought the best way to update the character was turning her into a mood-swinger, self-centered, bratty jerkass. This strategy continued until DC realized that Supergirl's fans hated it. Supergirl's earlier characterization was retconned out and she became a troubled, insecure but ultimately good and heroic teenager again.
    • Post-Flashpoint Supergirl started out this way, with Kara being a reluctant hero at best, traumatised and, like most teenagers would under her circumstances, feeling overwhelmed and simply wanting to go home. She also holds a fairly dim view of humanity at large, but considering that they keep shooting at her and have poisoned the atmosphere with Kryptonite. Grief morphed to rage, partly under the influence of being manipulated and betrayed by H'el, and she became a Red Lantern for a little bit. Now, however, she's discarded the Red Lantern Ring, has come to terms with her losses, matured and become that much wiser. She has since accepted Superman's charge to be Earth's hero in his stead in The Final Days of Superman and Supergirl (Rebirth).
  • The DCU's Post-Crisis universe, when it started off, wasn't overall much darker than what came before. Though there was a greater degree of seriousness about this era, DC had already largely moved away from the Silver Age's silliness, and all Post-Crisis did was try to have a consistent continuity in place and stripped the universe of many of The Artefact elements from the wackier days. Notably, DC actually sidestepped The Dark Age in the 90's with only a few books (namely Batman) really suffering from this but had titles like The Flash and Young Justice easily avoiding it. However, in the mid-2000s, under the direction of Dan DiDio, saw DC start painfully grimmifying many elements from the Silver Age, including stories like Identity Crisis that gave a brutal Cerebus Retcon to the Silver Age Justice League adventures, as well as having Wonder Woman kill Maxwell Lord.
  • After that, things got so grim, it drove the Silver Age-inspired Superboy-Prime crazy — causing him to become a mass-murdering fanatic and perhaps the darkest and edgiest DC character of all time. The Superboy-Prime saga, which climaxed in Infinite Crisis, was followed by an even darker and edger storyline called 52, and also saw the relaunching of numerous series with a generally darker tone. A prime example is Checkmate; issue #1 featured a team of superpowered spies infiltrating a Kobra base and leaving no survivors (with the badass heroine of the series, Sasha Bordeaux, shooting the Kobra Big Bad dead, execution style). The series muted its violence considerably after the first half-dozen issues.
    • Wonder Woman (1987) (her Post-Crisis title) Is darker than even the most envelope-pushing of her pre-Crisis stories - sometimes to the title's benefit, sometimes not. The very first issue begins with a dismembered caveman killing his mate, to set up the new concept of all the Amazons (including Diana) as reincarnated souls of women who'd died from Domestic Abuse.
    • The New 52 reboot saw this taken Up to Eleven. Heroes got newer costumes that were more armoured and 'cinematic', as well as grimmer, more dour personalities. Fun elements like the Flash Family or Justice Society of America were Exiled from Continuity and certain Legacy Character heroes were reverted to their silver age selves, who were written as much more serious and grim figures. Heroes also lost their marriages and had their romantic histories erased, as it was believed by those Running the Asylum that "heroes are too damaged to get married". This goes further in some books than others.
      • Blue Beetle was originally a fun book that didn't take itself too seriously - for example, the scarab was played as a Heroic Comedic Sociopath. In the New 52, it was initially just a sociopath, and Jaime couldn't rein it in as much as he used to at first.
      • A literal version shows in Teen Titans, with the character Solstice. Prior to the New 52, she was a cheerful girl with light powers. Afterwards, she had a permanently inhuman appearance and shadow powers. In addition, Kid Flash has become a murderous rebel leader from the future, Raven is secretly working for her demon father, Wonder Girl is now a thief who gets her powers from an Artifact of Doom, and Superboy is the clone of Superman and Lois Lane's evil son from the future - though in his own series, the latter became very much a traditional hero.
      • Billy Batson has become a little brat from losing his parents. While he has still shown a hidden heart of gold, it's still jarring for readers used to seeing him as more of The Cape than Superman.
      • Wonder Woman's increasing willingness to kill since her aforementioned offing of Maxwell Lord reaches an extreme with her becoming a proud warrior who casually and proudly murders criminals and boasting about it. This was especially jarring given attempts to hang onto her status as an All-Loving Hero, which dates back to the days when she was the DC hero most consistently and vocally opposed to killing.
      • Batgirl (2011) saw Barbara Gordon returned to the mantle, but rather than follow in the steps of how she was in the Silver Age, Barbara's story was grim. The Killing Joke was kept canon, and it was used to define every aspect of Barbara's story, with her suffering from PTSD and the recovery and development she made as Oracle after the event completely retconned from her character history. She also faced several villains who took being dark and edgy to an art form, and was regularly and constantly tortured. Notably, this was all mandated by Executive Meddling; Gail Simone wanted to write a lighter and softer take, but was told repeatedly by her editor to make the story grittier until she eventually left (at which point, the editor was changed and the new creative team launched the Lighter and Softer "Burnside" relaunch of the book). To hammer things home, the previous Batgirl run staring Stephanie Brown as the titular character was a critical and commercial success in large part because it was focused on being a light, idealistic book about bringing hope to a grim setting, so the grittiness of Simone's run stood out even more.
    • This ultimately is brought in for a Deconstruction, courtesy of Geoff Johns and DC Universe: Rebirth #1, who shows that no one likes a world filled with Darker and Edgier ideas, especially when it's the heroes who are hit with this. This is driven home with the revelation that Dr. Manhattan of Watchmen is the cause of all of this, having turned the pre-Flashpoint universe into the New 52 universe and seems utterly confused as to why it isn't working. It also serves as a Take That! to those who use the spoilered title as a manifesto to writing comics and not getting the message it was giving out.
  • X-Force demonstrated the trope more than once:
  • Dare, a 1991 take on Frank Hampson's iconic British 1950s space explorer Dan Dare. The 1991 version was written for Toxic magazine by Grant Morrison, and illustrated by Rian Hughes. Dare awakes in the 1990s to find that Britain has become a capitalist society, and that a thinly-disguised parody of Margaret Thatcher has sold Britain to the evil Mekon. During the course of the story all of the main characters are killed - Digby even has his arm blown off - and the final edition ends with Dare blowing up London with a nuclear bomb.
  • The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen is a Darker and Edgier take on all Victorian literature, though said literature was hardly light and fluffy to begin with.
  • Parodied extensively in the Belgian comic De Kiekeboes, where in one issue, The Simstones, a character from the comic buys the publishing rights to the comic (very meta) and introduces a darker and edgier style.
  • Marvel Year In Review 1993 parodied this in their own titles, by taking characters that this had been done for, and then making new characters that turned it Up to Eleven:
    • Spider-Man (Super hero with the proportionate strength of a spider) — Venom (Obsessed lunatic with the proportionate strength of a spider) — Carnage (Crazed serial killer with the proportionate strength of a spider) — Bile (Cannibalistic madman with the proportionate strength of a spider)
    • Captain America (Liberalistic flag-waving symbol of democracy) — U.S. Agent (Extremist right-wing hard-nosed American) — The Patriot Missile ("Blow all them foreigners to hell and let God sort 'em out!")
    • Thor (Norse God of Thunder) — Thunderstrike (Norse God of Thunder from Brooklyn) — Godhead (Convinced he is God. Holed up in his compound, waiting for Ragnarok)
    • Wolverine (Savage killing machine with the soul of a Samurai) — Sabertooth (Uncontrollable, savage killing machine with the attitude of a psychopath) — Clawjaw (Unhousebroken, uncontrollable killing machine with poor bodily hygiene)
    • Iron Man (High-tech armored Avenger) — War Machine (High-tech armored Avenger with an attitude) — Terror Device (High-tech armored Avenger with two attitudes and Plausible Deniability)
    • Green Hulk (Mindless rampaging monster) — Gray Hulk (Intelligent rampaging monster) — New Green Hulk (Intelligent rampaging monster with a big gun) — Red Hulk (Intelligent rampaging monster with a big gun and razor-sharp claws)
  • New X-Men: Academy X. After House of M, the title was hit by Darker and Edgier hard, but the change was especially marked in contrast with the first half of the series. Under Weir and DeFilippis, the book was fairly light-hearted fluff that focused on relationship drama. When Kyle and Yost took over, dozens of students were immediately blown up, and everyone else was left traumatized by their failed rescue attempts. Then a main character was shot in the head and killed. And another main character betrayed the team, was mutilated, and died. They were replaced by a former assassin Tyke Bomb. Succeeding plotlines saw the entire team sent to HELL, one of them tortured and spending a lot of time crying herself to sleep, and so forth and so forth. In fact, most of Kyle and Yost's work falls under this trope. See also: X-Force, mentioned above.
  • DC's Vertigo imprint revolves around material intended for mature audiences. After the success of Swamp Thing, Doom Patrol, Hellblazer, Shade, the Changing Man, and Animal Man, all of which starred fairly obscure characters from established DC canon, up to and including a brooding, psychological take on Brother Power, the Geek. For the uninitiated, Brother Power is a human-sized hippie rag doll given life and super strength by magic sunshine who once ran for a U.S. congressional seat and was last seen orbiting the Earth.
    • Grant Morrison's Kid Eternity is a particularly archetypal example: Kid Eternity was originally a boy who died with his grandpa due to a clerical error in Heaven and was brought back to life with the power to summon any figure from history to help him. Morrison's version reveals that his "grandpa" was an unrelated pedophile he was caught up with, the entire "clerical error in Heaven" story was a fabricated scenario created by cosmic beings of Chaos so they could use the Kid as a pawn against cosmic beings of Order, and the "figures from history" were actually demons from hell that could shapeshift into whatever the Kid wanted.
  • Supreme Power is a darker and edgier reimagining of the original Squadron Supreme.
  • Superman: Earth One was explicitly advertised as being darker, sexier, and moodier, and many standard elements of Superman's story are given a darker spin — for example, Jonathan and Martha are forced to keep Kal-El a secret after government agents secretly impound his spaceship in a secret base, Krypton's destruction was a deliberate act of war, and Superman's more angsty than other portrayals and is distrusted by the public... but despite that, there remains a core of hope, with Clark realising that the people of Earth had a reason to be afraid (after that fear was exploited by Zod (here, Zod-El, Superman's uncle)), and comes to something of an accommodation with the United Nations. The rest of the Earth One line plays it very straight, however, as among other things, Bruce Wayne isn't as skilled as other versions and is originally solely about bringing in the man he believes had his parents killed to justice, Alfred is the family's bodyguard (not their butler) and encourages Bruce to kill, Jim Gordon is a reluctant Dirty Cop, Diana is a Child by Rape between Hercules and Hippolyta and Hippolyta originally kept Diana for the purpose to enact a war against all males, Starfire is the source of several Titans' powers thanks to STAR Labs (led by Cyborg's villianous mother) experimenting on them, the Green Lantern Corps is already gone by the time Hal Jordan gets his power ring—though things improve on that end thanks to Hal, Hal himself is more jaded and cynical, and the last Guardian is insane.
  • Sonic the Hedgehog:
    • Archie Comics' Sonic the Hedgehog:
      • The comic started out as a Gag Series similar to Adventures of Sonic the Hedgehog. Around issue 20 or so, it shifted to a more serious, interconnected tone similar to Sonic the Hedgehog (SatAM). The Endgame arc, where Sonic becomes a fugitive after being accused of killing Princess Sally, and Robotnik is Killed Off for Real, is where it dove off the deep end, and established itself as one of the darkest incarnations of Sonic, dealing with themes such as abusive relationships, birth out of wedlock, drugs, genocide, and bigotry. It stayed that way for 10 years or so, before Ian Flynn took over as writer and returned the comic to a lighter tone, though still not as light as the games.
      • Way back when the comic was humor-oriented, the cover for issue #4 parodied this by promising an "all-new, darker, grittier" Sonic. Turned out he was just covered in dark grit from cleaning the chimney.
    • Sonic the Comic was much darker compared to the games at the time it was being produced. The most well-known aspect is that Super Sonic is a Superpowered Evil Side who eventually splits up from Sonic and becomes basically a physical god. Sonic once believed he killed his friends following one of Super Sonic's outbursts and fell into a Heroic BSoD when he regained control.
  • Parodied in issue #10 of the old Chip 'n Dale: Rescue Rangers comic book. In it, the Rangers are brought to the set of a movie featuring a dark-and-gritty version of a superhero squirrel puppet who originally appeared in a Sid And Marty Krofft-type children's show. The character's creator is shown working as the movie's creative consultant and is not at all happy with the way the movie portrays his creation.
  • Archie Comics, surprisingly enough, has done this several times:
    • Life with Archie: The Married Life presents stories from the "future" in which Archie has grown up and gotten married, and now has more realistic, adult-sized problems to deal with. It's so dark that Archie gets killed in the final issue.
    • Afterlife with Archie sounds like a funny concept: Archie meets the Zombie Apocalypse. The series is anything but funny. You know something's up when there are Cthulhu references in an Archie comic. It's drawn in a dark realistic style and the first issue has Hotdog being hit by a car and dying. Jughead gets Sabrina to bring him back but he's brought back as a zombie. He bites Jughead and...
    • The original Life With Archie series (1958-1991) featured longer, more "adventure" oriented stories than the typical Archie titles, including elements like five-alarm fires, attempted kidnappings, and... mysterious Satanic boxes that melt people's faces off.
    • One of those stories, "Secrets of the Deep", was a pretty standard scuba-diving-shipwrecks-and-sunken-treasure adventure... in which an evil treasure hunter shot at the gang with a spear gun and set an electric eel on them!
    • The above story wasn't even the only Archie comic to feature face-melting action. From 1972 to 1974, Archie published a Sabrina the Teenage Witch spinoff, Chilling Adventures in Sorcery as Told By Sabrina. It had the odd combination of straight-up horror stories with art in the familiar Archie house style. One story in particular stands out, featuring a boy who teases a stutterer at school. The kindly teacher happens to be a witch, and gives him an enchanted book that melts his face off, and possibly kills him! The story probably violated several rules under The Comics Code, but somehow gained the CCA seal of approval (perhaps because Archie ran the CCA?)
    • Chilling Adventures of Sabrina is in a similar realistic art style as Afterlife with Archie and has the same writer. It emphasises the horror aspect of Sabrina The Teenage Witch heavily.
    • In one Josie and the Pussycats story, Josie gets possessed by Satan!note 
    • Archie vs. Predator sees several supporting characters from the series getting gruesomely killed by the titular Predator, firmly planting it in this territory compared to the main books. Interestingly enough it's also something of a case of Lighter and Softer too, since as opposed to both Afterlife and Chilling Adventures it isn't played as seriously and several bits in the book are played for (very dark) laughs primarily from the sheer bizarreness of seeing the Archie Gang mix it up with the Predator of all things.
  • Spencer & Locke parodies the cast of Calvin and Hobbes and pushes it through the lens of Sin City. The result is Hardboiled Detective with a Dark and Troubled Past and a seven-foot-tall blue panther Imaginary Friend.
  • Paperinik New Adventures is a rare case of this done well. Those stories are way darker than the ones on "Topolino" (the Italian magazine where it is usually published): Paperinik stops fighting the Beagle Boys to defend the Earth from aliens, time travelers and crazy AIs, creating a new roost of supporting cast and using weapons which are much more powerful. However, he remains a very optimistic hero, and the comic gives us several funny and heartwarming moments to balance the mood.
    • Disney Italy does this as an habit. Aside for publishing some 'normal' stories with classic characters and settings with darker themes and complete rejection of Family-Friendly Firearms (to the point Scrooge mentioned having at least a 149mm artillery piece and threatened to fire Donald from it), once in a while they bring back Doctor Vultur (a Nazi in everything but the name orango trying to Take Over the World) and a truer to the origins version of the Black Spot, and, in chronological order, they created the following: Paperinik himself (theorically Donald Duck's superhero alter ego. In practice even his lighter stories show the sadistic streak that in two occasions prompted him to set off lynching mobs), Paperinik New Adventures, Mickey Mouse Mystery Magazine (where Mickey is forced to temporarily move in a city more corrupted than Gotham and survive in spite of his very existence being a danger to the men who control the city), W.I.T.C.H. (where the heroes have no qualms in trying and killing their enemies), Monster Allergy (explicitely a horror, and as scary as the authors could get away with) and Double Duck.
  • Godzilla: Kingdom of Monsters is this to the entire Godzilla franchise. How dark is it? Godzilla reduces Japan to rubble in the first two issues. The rest of the series has the monsters tearing apart civilization and bringing out the worst of humanity.
    • However this actually brings it closer to the tone of both the original film and the Heisei era. One of the complaints people had about the series was that, even with that knowledge in mind, it was little too much of a tone shift. Especially in reference to the scene of Rodan eating a child alive. There's another dark scene where Godzilla lets loose his atomic ray on a bunch of people trying to escape Los Angeles which he was currently destroying at that time.
  • The European G1 My Little Pony comics are darker than the toy-line and American cartoons. While they were usually cute and fluffy, they delved into certain stuff other parts of the franchise wouldn't. The most infamous issue had an explanation for the Twinkle-Eyed ponies. They were enslaved by a wizard and forced to live in darkness so long they went blind. Applejack accidentally pushes the wizard to his death and saves the ponies. The rescued ponies end up using the jewels in place of eyes, and that's their backstory for characters like Fizzy.
  • My Little Pony Generation 4:
    • IDW's My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic comic series is noticably darker than the animated show it was based on. Issue #3 starts with Queen Chrysalis (who by herself is portrayed much more sinisterly here) and her changelings invading a little town of cute loving kitties and sucking all the love out of them. One month later the whole land is converted into the new changeling kingdom.
    • My Little Pony: Fiendship Is Magic #1 is perhaps the darkest G4 comic to date. Highlights include the Body Horror of Sombra's transformations, his shattering of Amore after turning her into Crystal, and the Star Crossed Lover story between Sombra and Hope. In contrast to the usual comics and show, there is very little humor in Sombra's tale; it's pure tragedy.
  • Régis Loisel's re-imagination of Peter Pan is most definitely this. Forget the cute Disney version of your childhood, this one is most definitely not for children, as this adaptation has abusive and alcoholic parents, Attempted Rape, and self made orphans.
  • Suske en Wiske now also has it. The new spin-off/reboot series. The first album entitled Amoras features partial nudity, swearing, blood, substance abuse and a mature theme. The series is written als a multi-album story. So far, critics like it. But old time fans expecting the milder tone of the original series will be in for a very unpleasant surprise.
    • The new series was actually announced to the press as an obituary for Wiske, making it very clear that she dies in the first album. In fact, her death scene is the first album's front cover. Look Here.
  • Image Comics' March 1993 one-shot Darker Image is this, featuring the first appearances of Dark Age of Supernames heroes Bloodwulf and Deathblow. It is also notable for containing one of the first appearances of The Maxx.
    • Really, Image tends to be this compared to Marvel or DC. Mainly due to the emphasis on creator freedom, thus there's a lot more leeway for mature content that the Big Two won't allow.
  • Parodied in an Asterix one-shot with the conceit that they were fulfilling reader's suggestions, one of which (pictured) was to add Steampunk elements, give them all guns, draw them in a less childish style, and have them talk in a more naturalistic way rather than just punning all the time. The characters are shown drawn in a hyperdetailed Dark Age style (Asterix's feathered helmet wings are replaced with bat wings) with Gross-Up Close-Up-type details on the normally cuddly characters; Obelix is wearing a Badass Bandolier Pistol Whipping Romans with a BFG in a missile stockpile (Asterix is phoning Getafix to tell him these new gadgets don't work), and everyone is engaging in dreadfully-written Pulp Fiction-esque Buffy Speak, rendered in the UK English translation as Geordie (and still making a wholly unnaturalistic Hurricane of Puns).
    • Before this were a few twists on dark storytelling in the series; Asterix in Switzerland's plot involves the heroes' efforts to save an innocent from murder. Quaestor Vexatius Sinusitus' potential death offered a jarring but refreshing sense of drama to the otherwise frivolous comedy strip. The same story also contains a more serious look at the Romans than usual - normally, Asterix villains tend to be Punch Clock Villains, Ineffectual Sympathetic Villains or just ordinary people who happen to get in the heroes' way (occasionally even Designated Villains, Played for Laughs), but Varius Flavus's actions (corruption, insane decadance and poisoning his opponents) are much more like what evil Roman patricians in history actually did. Oh, yeah, and an actual Roman orgy (if limited to eating like slobs, getting drunk and hideous makeup) is depicted.
    • Stories featuring similar moments of deadly menace include Asterix and Son, where the village is burned to the ground, and the impending threat of Orinjade's execution in Asterix and the Magic Carpet. Also Obelix All At Sea, in which both Asterix and Obelix almost die (and the villain does, breaking Nobody Can Die), and Asterix and the Picts, which involves Scarpia Ultimatum and a much more complicated plot than usual. To a lesser extent, The Roman Agent and Caesar's Gift are both about just how ridiculously awful living in their Quirky Town would be.
    • In Uderzo croqué par ses amis, a compilation album of short stories drawn by various artists about Uderzo, one story is a realistically-drawn, historically-accurate, painfully serious take on the concept of a pair of Gaulish warriors fighting Romans using magic potion. For instance, the magic potion appears to be a kind of religious Magic Feather, they put the skulls of dead Roman soldiers around their village to keep them out (like the historical Gauls did), and they murder Romans with swords. It turns the usually ridiculous little Gauls into something quite dramatic and mystical and badass.
      • Uderzo croqué par ses amis also has another story in a similarly realistic art style, but with the usual characterisations of the Gauls. The story contains a gag where Asterix and Obelix accidentally catch Vitalstatistix in flagrante delicto with a hot blond who is not his wife, which is depicted in intentionally Squicky detail (since Vitalstatistix is both a beloved childhood character and a fat, ugly middle-aged man). Asterix is not exactly sexless but a gag like that would never get into the main stories.
  • The Revolutionary War hero Tomahawk received a pretty good Vertigo reimagining in Vertigo Visions: Tomahawk.
  • A lot of Disney comics are often this. The Little Mermaid and The Lion King have quite a few dark examples. For example, The Little Mermaid comic "Serpent Teen" has Ariel meeting a race called the Moray. They thought that mermaids wee a myth and consider them dangerous. The princess ends up keeping Ariel as a pet, and when Ariel's older sister Aquata arrives to help her she's almost eaten by a monster. Ariel ends up revealing she's a princess and is held hostage. The king of the Moray wants to kill all the merpeople however when Triton appears he destroys a lot of their town to get his daughters back.
  • Jem and the Holograms: Multiple:
    • The comics is this to the cartoon. In the cartoon the main characters nearly died dozens of times but always escape without a scratch. The comics are aimed at a slightly older audience than the cartoons were, so they get away with light curses like "hell" and characters being shown injured. Clash nearly kills Jem in an early issue but Aja pushes her out of the way. Aja ends up with cuts and bruises, as does Jerrica. A few issues later Pizzazz gets into a violent car crash which leaves her unable to be in her band for a while.
    • Played comedically in the second arc. In the "Dark Jem" arc Jerrica and her sisters get brainwashed by Synergy. They start dressing in darker toned outfits, start wearing black makeup, begin talking in monotone, act dismissive about everything, and generally act like stereotypical goths. Their new moody attitudes clash heavily with their typical, sweet and energetic ones.
  • This is parodied in the "Comic Book Carnage" issue of Hack/Slash, set at a comic fan convention. A new comics company is depicted reviving an old comic called Wunderkind (a blatant Captain Ersatz for Captain Marvel) in a ridiculously over-the-top grimdark manner, whereupon a pair of Loony Fans are so outraged that they start murdering the comic's creators (who are real-world writers and artists who were pals of the comic's writer Tim Seeley and didn't mind getting bloodily slaughtered on paper).
  • Parodied by Alan Moore, at about the same time as he was getting a rep for it, in In Pictopia, set in an absurdly darker and edgier version of a Captain Ersatz comic strip setting, with things like not-Blondie as a prostitute, who gets raided by not-Judge Dredd. The main character, Nocturno the Necromancer (Mandrake the Magician) is horrified by what's happening to the place, especially when his goofy buddy Flexible Flynn (Plastic Man) is replaced by a snarling '90s Anti-Hero.
  • In 2016, DC Comics started the Hanna-Barbera Beyond initiative, which involved various comic books giving the grimmer and grittier treatment to several classic Hanna-Barbera cartoons.
    • The adaptation of Wacky Races turns the lighthearted kart series into Wacky Raceland, a post-apocalyptic desert race more along the lines of Death Race 2000 or Mad Max than a campy Hanna-Barbera cartoon.
    • The Flintstones, while still basically The Flintstones, features a lot more adult humor and storylines than what would be allowed in the 1960s cartoon. For example, Fred Flintstone and Barney Rubble are Shell Shocked Veterans, and in one issue Fred and Wilma are ostracized for practicing monogamy. Despite the more adult themes, the comic has a lot of heart, such as the topic of gay marriages (non-breeding pairs aided others in Fred's tribe).
    • Scooby Apocalypse is a much darker take on Scooby-Doo than what was done before by having Mystery Inc. fighting against real monsters in a post-apocalyptic setting.
  • Even though Billy Batson and the Magic of Shazam was generally an all-ages, Lighter and Softer take on Captain Marvel and the Marvel Family, its version of Freddy Freeman was darker than any other continuity's. Instead of suffering from partial paralysis, he's a complete paraplegic; and since Freddy's spine was broken by a building that Captain Marvel imploded, he hates Billy and Mary, and blames them for his injuries. This is a far cry from the original Freddy, whose spine was broken by Captain Nazi, who idolized Captain Marvel for saving his life, and who generally managed to have a fairly upbeat attitude despite his troubles.
  • The Marvel Comics two-issue miniseres by Warren Ellis entitled Ruins, a darker take on Marvels where everything in the Marvel Universe has gone horribly wrong and the few characters who aren't horrifically disfigured or horribly killed by the accidents that gave them their powers in the regular Marvel Universe are corrupt and vile. Notable examples include Bruce Banner becoming a barely living mass of tumors instead of the Hulk, Charles Francis Xavier becoming a corrupt president who imprisons mutants and mutilates them to keep their powers in check (e.g. blinding Cyclops to disable his optic blasts and de-limbing Quicksilver to prevent him from using his super speed), and Peter Parker's radioactive spider bite covering his body with a terminal web-like rash.
  • Amazing Agent Luna is becoming this as of Year 2. Not only does Luna undergo TWO Plot Mandated Friendship Failures in the course of Volume 7, but it's hinted from the brief description of Volume 8 at the end of Volume 7 that she may pull a Face–Heel Turn in Volume 8. In fact, a Face–Heel Turn may be her only option if she wants to win Francesca back, though that's just because she rejoined Elizabeth when she thinks Timothy had dumped her because of Luna.
  • Since his debut Frank Castle, The Punisher had held the rank of Captain of the Dark Age of Comic Books. Then he was the tip of the spear of a darker, gritter run, Marvel Knights that took him and other "heroes" into their own Darker, Edgier works. Then Castle was promoted to full Dark Lord with The Punisher MAX which was a run where, hmm, most may know Jean Grey, she had a Max run that was boarderline lesbian erotica. Now take the Punisher as he was and remove any limits of violence, language, and vigilante gore. Numerous examples were put up as the image source for Pay Evil unto Evil and they were all deemed far too graphic.


Top

How well does it match the trope?

Example of:

/

Media sources:

/

Report