First Aired - 1/12/1997
In this tale narrated by Leonard Nimoy, Homer sees an alien in the woods, and while everyone else writes it off as yet another drunken hallucination (since Homer tested "Boris Yeltsin" drunk on Moe's Breathalyzer), Agents Mulder and Scully from The X Files come to Springfield to help Homer solve the case.
This is the first of four episodes produced by Al Jean and Mike Reiss instead of the current showrunner (in this case, Bill Oakley and Josh Weinstein). Jean would return as showrunner starting in season 13.
This episode contains examples of:
- Alien Episode: Homer sees an alien, and the quest to be believed starts.
- Based on a Great Big Lie: Parodied in Leonard Nimoy's introduction. See By "No", I Mean "Yes".
- Big "NO!": Homer shouts it when he hears Bart's ghost story about college costs for Maggie.
- Biting-the-Hand Humor: When Bart asks what Homer will do if they can't get proof of the alien's existence, Homer says they'll make up something and sell it to FOX Network. The two laugh at how they buy anything.
- Blatant Lies: Homer tries to pull this trope to make his actions the night he saw the 'alien' sound better. Scully quickly calls him on it.Mulder: All right, Homer. We want you to re-create your every move the night you saw this alien.Homer: Well, the evening began at the gentleman's club, where we were discussing Wittgenstein over a game of backgammon.Scully: Mr. Simpson, it's a felony to lie to the F.B.I..Homer: We were sitting in Barney's car eating packets of mustard. You happy?
- Book-Ends: The episode opens on Leonard Nimoy sitting in shadow before the camera zooms in on him, and ends by zooming away from the Squeaky-Voiced Teen and fading into shadow.
- Breaking the Fourth Wall: Leonard Nimoy does this in both his cutaways, then the Squeaky-Voiced Teen does the same at the end.
- Brick Joke: After Mulder reveals to Moe that he and Scully are FBI agents, and informs the two men in his back room that they have to return the killer whale in there to Sea World. After Mulder finishes his monologue later, the three men can be seen behind him trying to carry the orca, then run off after they spot Mulder, still carrying the orca.
- By "No", I Mean "Yes": Leonard Nimoy begins with, "The following tale of alien encounters is true. And by true, I mean false. It's all lies. But they're entertaining lies, and in the end, isn't that the real truth? The answer is no."
- Call-Back: Once again, Moe abandons a criminal scheme because he mistakenly thinks people are onto him.
- The Cameo: As well as the multiple aliens from other companies that appear on the line-up, someone who may be the Cigarette Smoking Man is shown to be looking at Homer when Scully tries to give him a polygraph test.
- Character Filibuster: Parodied, as Mulder gives a long rant about "the truth". He started during daylight hours, but it's night by the time he's finished. And Scully left as he was getting started.
- According to the DVD commentary, they just left the microphone on and let Duchovny ramble about whatever he wanted. He went on for two hours before he ran out of steam.
- Chekhov's Gunman: Mr. Burns appears early on in the episode, then it's revealed at the end that he is the "alien", after undergoing treatments allowing him to cheat death for another week, which leave him twisted and disoriented, and the green glow comes from his lifetime of working at the power plant.
- Comically Missing the Point: Homer, not long after being told by the guy selling shirts that the "Homer is a Dope" ones are already sold out, orders two of them.
- Couldn't Find a Pen: A non-bloody example, Homer runs away from the alien screaming "Yahhh!". As we watch from above we see him run through a field spelling out the word "Yahhh!" in cursive (including the exclamation mark, which he dots).
- Crop Circles: Homer runs through a field of crop, screaming "Yahhh!" and creating the pattern Yahhh!, in crop circle fashion.
- Crowd Song: At the end, the town spontaneously sang "Good Morning, Starshine" together. Nimoy, Mulder, Scully and Chewbacca joined in as well.
- Dark Lord on Life Support: The Reveal of who the alien is: it's Burns, who undergoes a weekly treatment to stay alive another week and wanders around high from the industrial-sized dose of painkillers he receives as part of it.
- Department of Redundancy Department: "The unsolved mysteries of...Unsolved Mysteries!"
- Epic Fail:
Homer:I saw this in a movie about a bus that had to speed around the city, keeping its speed over fifty, and if its speed dropped, the bus would explode! I think it was called "The Bus That Couldn't Slow Down."
- Grampa Simpson ended up lost in the woods while trying to get the morning paper (which is odd, since "The Old Man and the Lisa" revealed that the retirement home no longer has newspapers as the news angries up the elderly residents' blood and there's a sign outside the home that reads, "Thank you for not discussing the outside world.") and is found again days later, trying to get his dentures back from a turtle (without success).
- When Homer gets his reflexes tested. It takes him two hours for his knee to respond.
- Homer is unable to correctly recall a movie's title in spite of having repeatedly used the title's only word while describing the plot.
- Homer is given a polygraph test to see if his alien sighting is true. The polygraph machine explodes when Homer just answers "yes" to Scully asking him if he understands.
- Et Tu, Brute?: Homer is upset that even Marge would buy and wear a "Homer is a Dope" shirt. He changes his mind upon seeing how good the job of sewing "Dope" on the shirt was.
- Fake Crossover: With The X-Files. Unlike the debacle that happened with The Critic, Matt Groening's name was in the credits and he actually was cool with having The X-Files cross over to his show, since it wasn't a 20-minute advertisement for the show. Whether or not this episode can be considered canon to The X-Files (albeit taking place much earlier in its timeline) depends on how you interpret a line by Mulder a year earlier, describing a character played by the legendarily odd-looking Michael Berryman as "Homer Simpson's evil twin."
- Have a Gay Old Time: In the opening, Mr. Burns casually asks Smithers if he has any gay plans for the night, meaning light-hearted and fancy-free.
- Hoist by His Own Petard: Grandpa is bitten by a turtle with his own dentures.
- Humans Are Morons: Discussed.Lisa: Dad, according to Junior Skeptic Magazine, the chances are 175 million to one of another form of life actually coming in contact with ours.
Lisa: It's just that the people who claim they've seen aliens are always pathetic low-lifes with boring jobs. Oh, and you, Dad. (laughs nervously)
- Left the Background Music On: Homer, pretty scared and paranoid, stumbles along the road in the forest and is scared when a vehicle approaches him from behind accompanied by the theme from Psycho. It turns out it's actually the Springfield Philharmonic Orchestra traveling by bus.
- Leit Motif: The "alien" gets the main theme of The X-Files as one.
- Lie Detector: Which Homer causes to explode after claiming to understand Scully's explanation of how it works.
- Low-Speed Chase: This happens when Abe tries to catch the turtle that took his teeth. (It is currently the page image).
- Maybe Magic, Maybe Mundane: Not in the actual episode, but the original script ended with the alien's true identity unrevealed, implying Homer really did encounter one.
- Mundane Ghost Story: Bart's "ghost story" about how much college will cost for Maggie (which freaks Homer out). In a deleted scene, the original "ghost story" was about the ingredients to an Oscar Meyer weiner (which still freaks out Homer).
- Noodle Incident: Scully says this is the worst assignment they've ever had, to which Mulder asks if it's really worse than that time with the flesh-eating virus.
- What led Moe to steal a killer whale from Sea World? And, more to the point, how the hell did he get it in his back room?
- We never see Homer and the barflies in Barney's car eating packets of mustard.
- Oh, Crap!:
- Played for Laughs when Homer sees a billboard that reads "Die" on his way home from Moe's, which he screams at, then he screams again when a gust of wind moves a tree in front of the billboard, revealing it actually says "Diet".
- When Mulder introduces himself and Scully as FBI agents, Marge goes into a panic thinking it's about the pen she took from the post office.
- Moe has two. The first is when Mulder introduces himself and Scully to him, and he thinks they're onto him for stealing a killer whale from Sea World. The second is later during the payoff of a Brick Joke while he and the two men are attempting to carry the orca, then they see Mulder and, still carrying the orca, they run for it.
- Homer has one when he attempts to talk to the alien and he suddenly realizes he's standing in the campfire. His panic causes the alien to retreat. Luckily, Bart recorded the whole thing.
- Police Lineup: Homer is asked to identify the alien he saw from a lineup which consisted of Chewbacca, ALF, Marvin the Martian, Gort and Kang (or Kodos) from the various "Treehouse of Horror" installments.
- "Psycho" Strings: The Psycho shower scene music is actually playing on a bus carrying a traveling orchestra.
- Rule of Three: The alien appears three times over three Friday nights.
- Screw This, I'm Outta Here!: Leonard Nimoy concludes his tale after Homer and Bart confirm the alien's existence and recording it during their stakeout.. Upon being informed the episode still has ten minutes left, he is surprised, and says he needs to get something out of his car. Cue him running out and the sound of him driving away. The Squeaky-Voiced Teen then appears and says, "I don't think he's coming back," and is forced to take over. Nimoy does appear later when the town is gathering and preparing for the alien's appearance.
- Leonard Nimoy's role in the episode references his old hosting gig on the late-1970s/early 1980s supernatural documentary series In Search of..., counting as Actor Allusion.
- On the line-up of aliens, there is ALF, Marvin The Martian, Chewbaccanote and Gort (according to the DVD commentary, all of the characters were used without permission from their creators [with the exception of Kang/Kodos, since that's property of FOX and Matt Groening], making it "the most illegal shot in animation." In fact, the worst the staff received was a call from the voice of Alf, who wasn't brought in to voice his character).
- Reverend Lovejoy does a Bait-and-Switch Comparison of Jesus and ET The Extraterrestrial.
- When the whole of Springfield gathers on the point where the alien appears, the Springfield Elementary band is practicing the Leitmotif from Close Encounters of the Third Kind.
- Jimbo Jones holds a sign, "ALIEN DUDE: Need Two Tickets to Pearl Jam."
- Donkey Kong makes an appearance at the Noiseland Arcade, which turns out to be a bust. He ends up throwing a barrel at the Wise Guy, complete with sound effects.
- Homer uses the camera trick from Speed to skip work.
- Sickly Green Glow: Mr. Burns's explanation for the glowing, after he was revealed to be the "alien", is that "a lifetime of working in a nuclear power plant has given me a healthy green glow...and left me as impotent as a Nevada boxing commissioner."
- Signs of Disrepair: An already frightened Homer sees a large billboard that says "DIE." He screams. Then the wind shifts, moving a tree branch and revealing that the word is "DIET." Homer screams louder and flees.
- Skewed Priorities: Mulder is more concerned about the rumored alien sighting than the drug and weapon smuggling ring.
- Special Guest: Leonard Nimoy As Himself (just like in season 4's "Marge vs. the Monorail"), Gillian Anderson as Agent Scully and David Duchovny as Agent Mulder.
- Spinning Clock Hands: When Scully performs tests on Homer, she does also the patellar reflex test. It takes one hour till Homer says "oh" and his knee moves a bit. The time is shown with three different shots of the clock.
- Take That!:
- Milhouse plays a Waterworld video game, which costs 40 quarters ($10) to play, and after you deposit it, it only goes one move before you need another 40 quarters to play, in reference to the film's over-expensive budget and box-office failure.
- The highest level of drunkenness in Moe's carnival game-style breath analyzer is "Boris Yeltsin".
- Tempting Fate: After Homer's videotape of the alien is broadcast, Lisa thinks the town won't be won over by three seconds of videotape. She's Instantly Proven Wrong when the doorbell rings and Homer finds half the town on his lawn.
- Time Passes Montage:
- First done with Spinning Clock Hands and gradually added Mulder's emptied coffee cups.
- When Homer was explaining where he'd been to Scully and Mulder at Moe's. One beer turned into 10 before Scully got frustrated.Homer: (drunk) And so I says, red M&M, blue M&M, they all end up the same color in the end!
- Mulder rambled about the truth and the mysteries of our world: he started when it was a clear blue day, but finished hours later at night.
- Tongue on the Flagpole: Channel 6 News uses a file photo of Homer that shows him with his tongue stuck to a lamppost.
- Torches and Pitchforks: The crowd pulls them out when the alien, later revealed to be a monster and even later to be Mr Burns, appears in the final act.
- Uranus Is Showing: Bart dresses up as an alien and yells, "I am the thing from Uranus!" the morning after Homer first sees the alien.
- We Come in Peace Shoot to Kill: Parodied when the alien greets the people of Springfield.Alien: I bring you love!
Lenny: It's bringing love! Don't let it get away!
Carl: (welding a baseball bat) Break its legs!
- Where the Hell Is Springfield?: Agents Mulder and Scully's first Springfield scene has a caption describing the place as the Simpsons' home in "Springfield, U.S.A.".
- You Won't Feel a Thing: Dr. Nick claims that his scary procedure will not hurt.Dr. Nick Riviera: Don't worry. You won't feel a thing [exhibits a swirling mechanical device]...till I jam this down your throat!