All of us here know that there's a diverse array of titles within any one medium. Not all video games are Pac-Man or Wii Sports or Grand Theft Auto or Super Mario Bros. or Pokémon or Tetris or Halo. There are games like the Silent Hill series, which tries to immerse you in an environment through the use of incredible attention to detail and lots of optional internal monologue, before gradually creeping the living daylights out of you over time. Or The Elder Scrolls series, which presents to you a wide-open world and several big choices you can make in it, giving you unprecedented freedom to experiment and explore.
The general public doesn't (always) know that, though — people who don't play video games think that all games are like the ones they hear about on TV, which would tend to be either Wii Sports (due to the Wii showing up in retirement communities all over the place), Super Mario Bros. (due to Mario's recognizability as a Series Mascot), Pokémon (due to the "Pokémania" fad of The '90s and the much later success of Pokémon GO), or the latest "controversial" violent game that the media love to shove in people's faces. If these people are older, expect their perceptions of video games to be even worse.
Likewise, comic books are not all about poorly-written superheroes in garish spandex costumes fighting one-note supervillains with outlandish plots (ironically, people are usually thinking of the 1950s/'60s era of comics, which most of them have absolutely no living memory of), nor are they essentially printed versions of superhero movies where Iron Man is exactly like Robert Downey Jr. and Wolverine is exactly like Hugh Jackman. In fact, they haven't even been primarily about the former since before most of today's comics fans were born. There are a great many comics telling other kinds of stories, such as the numerous indie Slice of Life comics like Seconds or Amelia Rules!, the surreal dreamscapes of Little Nemo. The Japanese manga scene has many well known titles from different genres, ranging from heartwarming love stories such as Kimi ni Todoke, to cute family comedy like Yotsuba&!, to Action-Adventure series such as One Piece, to even horror fare like the works of Junji Ito. Certainly the Super Hero genre itself is much better written than what is stereotypically attributed, and can also differ greatly from your typical Hollywood superhero action-fest: Watchmen and Batman: The Dark Knight Returns should be proof enough of that. Good luck explaining that to the average person on the street. If you say you like comic books, they'll respond with something like, "So you like Superman, Batman and Spider-Man?"note Some comics (usually ones dubbed "graphic novels" to eliminate this very problem), like the autobiographical Fun Home or the aforementioned Watchmen, have won awards for their artistry and originality. But the general public doesn't know about that, and thinks that the only "artistic" superhero thing in existence is The Dark Knight Trilogy. note
And of course, cartoons. We know all about the Animation Age Ghetto and All Adult Animation Is South Park. Cartoons can only be funny, right? The sheer number of non-comedic cartoons says otherwise. On the other hand, many companies seem convinced that kids will watch cartoons only if they are funny, and add extraneous humor that sometimes clashes with the mood just to fulfill their comedy quota. There have been non-comedy cartoons for adults, but they haven't done terribly well. Unfortunately, the Animation Age Ghetto lives. Often, animators have to start with an R-Rated Opening in order to warn young audiences and their parents that what they're watching isn't a Disney animated flick just because it had cartoon people on the cover.
This is especially true for anime. On the public eye, anime is either associated with the Animation Age Ghetto and series that were marketed to kids - Sailor Moon, Dragon Ball and Dragon Ball Z, Pokémon, Yu-Gi-Oh!, and maybe Naruto, My Hero Academia, and the Studio Ghibli Library if you're lucky - or with sordid, lecherous hentai. Thanks to the spiked interest during the 2010s, it now also has the stigma of being for geeks shelling out half their paycheck to get two episode's worth of content. And the dialogue is either poor dubbing along the lines of Speed Racer, or blatant "Blind Idiot" Translation.
Tabletop RPGs used to be nigh unknown except in general nerd circles, and only Dungeons & Dragons had any real recognition factor, mostly due to the moral panic about it in the 1980s in the US. However, the release of 5th edition D&D, the popularity of Stranger Things, and the rising attention to projects like Critical Role and The Adventure Zone have made D&D more popular than ever, making it much more well known than it was at the end of the 2010s. Though, you'd still be hard pressed to find your average person who can name a tabletop RPG that isn't D&D.
The public at large has these prejudices and preconceptions. But this trope can also be an example of a prejudice in itself against the general public. In some cases this trope can be true, but it is also equally possible the larger public is aware of diversity and just isn't blabbing about it with the people who really love it. In the past, we determined what was known by what people actually sat around talking about. Nowadays, when you can gather with people that do all want to talk about this or that, the line between what is a majority/minority and what the general public knows is blurred beyond repair.
These works are often prime targets of Snark Bait and Hate Dumb. "Common Knowledge" is usually ignored in these situations. Works that fall into this have a high tendency to suffer from an Audience-Alienating Premise. Exposure to a Gateway Series can certainly be very helpful to break these prejudices. If a significant title stands out from the perceived "ghettoed" group, No True Scotsman is often applied to try and distance a well-liked entry from it, with Hitler Ate Sugar being applied to reinforce the ghetto back onto that entry. Related to Pop-Cultural Osmosis Failure. See also Mistaken for Index.
Tropes associated with this:
- All Adult Animation Is South Park: The belief that all animated works aimed at adults will feature excessive swearing and vulgar jokes.
- All Animation Is Disney: The belief that all noteworthy animated works were made by Disney.
- All Anime Is Naughty Tentacles: The belief that all anime is nothing but women getting raped by tentacle creatures.
- Aluminum Christmas Trees: Something obscure but real is mistaken to be something invented for the work of fiction.
- Animation Age Ghetto: The belief that animated works are only for children.
- Audience-Coloring Adaptation
- Beam Me Up, Scotty!: A popular catchphrase either doesn't really exist or is actually a misquoted variant of what the character really said.
- Classical Music Is Boring: The belief that classical music isn't considered interesting.
- Comedy Ghetto
- Cowboy BeBop at His Computer: A documentation of a work gets their facts about the work blatantly wrong, to the point that people familiar enough with the work will know that the source didn't do their research properly.
- Dead Horse Genre
- Franchise Original Sin: Fans complain about a flaw that is present in the later installments when the flaw was actually present earlier in the series, just not as prominent or severe.
- Furry Fandom
- Girl-Show Ghetto: Male audiences aren't interested in works that star and focus on female characters.
- God Never Said That: People misinterpret what the creator said about the work or believe the creator said it when the creator did not.
- It's Not Supposed to Win Oscars: The argument that a work doesn't have to win awards to be considered good.
- It's Popular, Now It Sucks!
- Made in Country X
- Mainstream Obscurity
- Minority Show Ghetto
- New Media Are Evil: The belief that modern forms of media are bad.
- The New Rock & Roll
- Nostalgia Filter: People are so stuck in their ways that they only like what they grew up with and dismiss works of today as garbage not worth giving a chance.
- Obscure Popularity
- Old Media Are Evil
- Older Than They Think: A concept believed to be new to the franchise was actually present much earlier in the franchise's history.
- Oscar Bait
- Pac-Man Fever: Outdated ideas on what video games are like.
- Pop-Culture Isolation
- Praising Shows You Don't Watch
- Quality by Popular Vote
- Rated M for Money
- Reviews Are the Gospel: People judge the quality of a work on someone's review of it rather than by their own viewpoints.
- Rock Me, Asmodeus!
- Sacred Cow: A work is so popular and well-regarded that saying anything negative about it is guaranteed to make everyone hate you.
- Sci Fi Ghetto
- Small Reference Pools
- True Art: Beliefs on what qualities make a work worthy of merit.
- Two Decades Behind
- Word of Dante can easily become this when it's confused with Word of God.
- Wrongfully Attributed: Credit for a work or achievement is wrongly given to individuals or companies that actually had nothing to do with or weren't truly the first to accomplish.
Browsing TV-Tropes? So you are a nerd!