That's what makes you beautiful!"
A character who, for some odd reason, doesn't seem to realize how attractive they are. Despite all the attention their good looks bring them, they will either not notice it or interpret it as anything other than the fact that they're really good looking.
While an Innocent Fanservice Girl can generate this effect due to a lack of a nudity taboo, these characters are often sufficiently attractive that they can cause traffic accidents even when fully clothed. While cunning characters will usually seek to take advantage of this phenomena, and innocent or shy characters will be embarrassed by it, on occasion a character won't even understand what's going on. They may even lampshade it by wondering aloud why they are a Weirdness Magnet.
This obliviousness is usually the result of one of the following:
- Background: the character is extremely naive or innocent.
- Culture: the character is from a society that has different standards of beauty that they don't conform to. For example, an inexperienced shapeshifter who chose their form to blend in may wonder if people are becoming suspicious.
- Lack of Intellect: in comedies, these characters are sometimes portrayed as simply being mindbogglingly unintelligent.
- Personality: an adorkable character, Broken Bird, etc., might incorrectly presume their awkwardness hides any beauty they might have. For a Cloudcuckoolander, their own attractiveness might be just one of many things they find confusing. Then there are those characters that are too humble to notice or remember how attractive they are to others.
Regardless, a character who fits this trope is portrayed as startlingly attractive in-universe, and yet they seem to be completely unaware that others find them so.
Super-Trope to I Am Not Pretty where an attractive character thinks they're ugly. Contrast Proud Beauty and Indifferent Beauty, both of whom are well aware of their beautiful appearances, but one will actively flaunt it while the other simply doesn't care.
- Chihaya of Chihayafuru is described by her fellow students as "Beauty gone to waste" or "Beauty in vain" because of her tomboyish lack of interest in using her good looks for anything. In this case, it's because a) she's focused on competitive karuta, and b) she thinks of her Cool Big Sis as the pretty one.
- In Episode seven of Dragonaut: The Resonance Machina and Akira are looking for the main characters in a spa resort. Machina doesn't realize that every male there has their eyes on her. Akira, who's less curvaceous and more body-conscious, does notice and sighs in disappointment about her figure.
- Yura from Futari Ecchi attracts a lot of male attention but she's very shy and already married so she tends not to notice the attention she gets.
- Maken-ki!: In the anime, Ms. Aki honestly has no idea why she gets so many visits to her office, despite it being obvious it's because of her K-Cup breasts and figure, along with the skintight miniskirt she wears. Which contradicts her manga portrayal, where she's perfectly aware of how the male students think of her and is shown to be self-conscious because of it.
- Ranma ½: The Battle for "Ms. Beachside" episode had Kasumi wondering why guys kept asking her out, even though she wasn't participating in the pageant. And was genuinely surprised to hear that she won, regardlessnote .
- Scrapped Princess: Racquel is a bit of a ditz, so she fails to realize the effect she has on men, including when she was helping peddle Mr. Soupy buns, in the third episode. Even though her dress only showed a modest bit of leg and cleavage, it didn't stop onlookers from staring and being drawn to her like flies. Yet, it never occurred to her that it was her looks that was raking in the customers. Likewise, she never notices Mr. Berkens' crush on her and only sees of him as a fatherly figure, because of his striking resemblance to her dead father.
- Kanade "Majime" Ninomae from Wasteful Days of High School Girls is so attractive to her classmates and so effortlessly cool that Lily is left befuddled at her innate ability.
- Melody from Josie And The Pussy Cats is very beautiful but not very smart. She often misinterprets the reason why men are interested in her.
- One issue of◊ Doctor Strange has the eponymous character's colleague Dane Whitman (a.k.a. Black Knight) attracting a large amount of attention while doing a morning run on a cruise ship. Dane's worried it's because people can see Strange's Astral Projection accompanying him, and Strange has to point out that no, he's quite invisible, and the real explanation is that Dane's an attractively built young man running around in a T-shirt and some very short gym shorts.
- The Game of the Gods presents an exaggerated example with Deirdre, the bastard daughter of Lúthien and Mandos from The Silmarillion.
She went walking through the camp like a fallen star, and all around her Elves and Men bowed and gave way. Some who had never yet stopped marveling at the risen star of Eärendil turned to her, looked on her beauty, and began to weep, casting themselves to their knees, marveling that Eru himself in female form had descended from the heavens.
Deirdre did not notice the adulation; she was too modest for such things.
- In The Parselmouth of Gryffindor, Hermione is (as in canon) somewhat plain-looking as a human, and makes no attempts to make herself look prettier. She is quite surprised (and embarrassed) to discover that her snake form is apparently extremely attractive.
- In Liar Liar, Jim Carrey's character talks to a very attractive and large breasted woman who mentions that everyone has been (seemingly inexplicably) nice to her. Due to his curse he comments that he figures it is probably because of her large breasts. His attempts to backtrack under the curse actually make him say increasingly worse things until he gets an offscreen smack for making literal baby sucking faces at her cleavage.
- Jerin Whistler from A Brother's Price is this at the beginning of the novel. This is mostly due to his being extremely sheltered — his sisters would not approve of strange women telling him that he's pretty, and he doesn't see many men to whom he could compare himself. Only when his old teacher warns him to not walk around unveiled on the ship on which they are traveling, as some women could be tempted to abduct him, does he realize that he is not just average looking.
- Honor Harrington spent many years stuck in an extremely awkward adolescence which came to define her self-image even though she's pretty much grown out of it by the time the books begin. She doesn't really begin to take note of her own personal beauty until the third book, which incidentally is after she's had half her face blown off and rebuilt.
- Rare male example with Cayleb in Safehold. He's confident that he looks awful, despite Sharleyan's and Nahrmahn's claims to the contrary. The latter even gets Height Angst and Weight Woe when he meets Cayleb for the first time.
- Remedios the Beauty from One Hundred Years of Solitude is so beautiful that men get themselves killed over their lust for her. Due to her childlike mentality, she has no idea of the effect she has on men, and qualifies them as simple and dumb.
- Harry Potter gets a surprise in the sixth book when he wonders why there are suddenly so many girls interested in him. Hermione bluntly tells him that it's because he's grown about a foot over the summer, becoming attractive in addition to his fame.
- Mr. Knightley praises this particular quality in Emma when discussing her with Mrs. Weston. Mrs. Weston, who was Emma's nursemaid and raised her after the death of her mother, raves about how beautiful the young woman is; Mr. Knightley agrees with her, and also adds that "as handsome as she is," she doesn't seem to pay much attention to it.
- Justified with Beauty in Beauty: A Retelling of Beauty and the Beast. Growing up with two extraordinarily beautiful older sisters, she's always been considered plain (Beauty being an Ironic Nickname rather than her actual name), and at the time she leaves home she's still regarded as the least attractive of the three. The Beast's castle has no mirrors in which she can observe herself, so it comes as a shock when she finally sees her own reflection at the end of the book and discovers that not only has she become perfectly lovely, she bears a very strong resemblance to her late mother.
- Tawneenote is an exotic dancer for the Pink Pussycat in Thud! who believes she's so popular because she's a very good dancer, while thinking she's actually quite unattractive since nobody will ask her out. When in truth the customers couldn't care less about her dancing and the reason they don't ask her out is because she's so over the top beautiful that no man with even half a brain would ever think they would ever have a chance with her so don't even try. It takes Cherry and Angua telling her this, then proving it to her by having her destroy a pub by showing interest in one of the patrons does she realize the truth.
- In the 30 Rock episode "The Bubble," Liz realizes that her boyfriend, Drew, is unknowingly benefiting from his good looks. He's a doctor who doesn't know the Heimlich maneuver, can't play tennis despite having worked as a tennis coach, can order ridiculous items like roast duck soaked in Fanta at restaurants, and gets other kinds of preferential treatment that he perceives as normal... at least until Liz decides to reveal to him what's really going on.
- The Munsters: Marilyn Munster, as a consequence of believing her family's standards of beauty; although in Marilyn's case, she originally looked similar to the rest of the family and changed to her current appearance after Grandpa bit her.
- Angel: Male example with the Groosalugg, a human man raised in the demon society of Pylea, considers himself hideously ugly. This is because the same features that make him handsome and attractive by human standards are considered ugly by the demons' standards.
- Country singer Sammy Kershaw has a song called "She Don't Know She's Beautiful." The song's subject walks down the street and goes to a party and is baffled each time with the stares she attracts. Even in the morning when she wakes up and her hair is a mess, she still doesn't understand why the singer can't take his eyes off her.
- The One Direction song "What Makes You Beautiful":
You're turning heads when you walk through the door...
Everyone else in the room can see it
Everyone else but you...
You don't know you're beautiful
That's what makes you beautiful.
- Miranda from The Tempest is so beautiful that one character mistakes her for a goddess. She's unaware of her beauty because she and her father have been exiled to a deserted island since she was three years old, so for as long as she can remember, her father has been the only other human she's known.
- In BlazBlue Noel is pretty surprised when Litchi compliments her on her looks.
- Priestess Rao from Ōkami seems oblivious to her effect on men and is baffled by Issun's comments about "melons" and being "stacked to the ceiling". Ostensibly it's because she is a holy woman and too innocent to understand. In reality it is because she is the demon Ninetails in disguise.
- In Persona 4 Yukiko Amagi doesn't seem to realise how interested most of the male students are in her and tends to shoot them down without realising that she's been asked out (to the point that asking her out's known as "The Amagi Challenge"). Similarly, her best friend Chie has a few admirers but keeps assuming that they're interested in Yukiko.
- Fir of Fire Emblem: Binding Blade is shocked that Noah fell in love with her at first sight, and even The Stoic Shin defrosts enough to say that she has beautiful eyes. This isn't due to a lack of self-esteem, but due to her focus on training in the sword so she can live up to her mother's legacy making her rather single-minded.
- Didi from Ménage à 3 is unaware about just how stunningly attractive she is. Exemplified when she strips to a tiny bikini in a park and didn't notice all the men bumping into things because they're distracted looking at her.
- Ingrid from spin-off comic Sandra on the Rocks describes herself as "far too plain-looking" to be a model, which causes both Sandra and Marie's (the former of whom is herself a model) jaws to drop as they both wonder if this is false modesty or just sheer ignorance, since she is most emphatically not plain-looking.... at least by Parisian standards. As a Sexy Scandinavian in a Sex Comedy universe, there's a distinct possibility that the average person in her home country is even prettier than her, and thus she actually would be considered plain-looking by those standards.
- Erika from Living with Hipstergirl and Gamergirl has claimed in so many words that she averts Nerds Are Sexy, all while showing her off in skimpy clothes is a large part of what the comic's all about.
- Emma from My Deepest Secret is, by anyone's standard, a very pretty girl. However, she's desperately insecure, and is genuinely surprised that her boyfriend thinks she's beautiful, or even agreed to go out with her.
- In the King of the Hill episode "The Good Buck," Luanne starts a Bible study class in her backyard swimming pool. She thinks that she's genuinely reaching out to her students, all of whom are male, when they really just want to see her in a bikini and enjoy the hugs she gives when you demonstrate "progress". Ironically, the only exception to this is Buck Strickland, who really is just there for Bible study.
- Played straight and later averted in the South Park episode "Bebe's Boobs Destroy Society". For most of the episode, Bebe can't seem to figure out why all the boys in her class suddenly find her cool and smart and want to hang out with her. When she finds out it's because of her breasts, she tries to get them reduced so they'll take her more seriously.
- My Little Pony: Friendship Is Magic: Fluttershy. (Or, at least, to the extent that she knows this but she'd rather forget, because she REALLY doesn't like attention.) In one episode, a fashion photographer asks Fluttershy to model for her, and she detests the ensuing social pressure and lack of privacy.
- An episode of Duckman plays with the concept by having the women involved aware that they're beautiful but apparently unaware of the consequences. It centers around Duckman being hired by a pair of cartoonishly sexy twins, who can't figure out why 'men are only interested in our bodies' and are trying to figure out why they can't attract nice guys who are interested in their personalities.
- Evangelyne from Wakfu is extremely modest about her attractiveness, to the point where it seems that she isn't even aware that at least three separate characters carry a torch for her. A good example is in the fourth episode where she attempts to disguise herself as an "ugly" cursed princess by... wearing a dress, which only has the effect of making her look gorgeous.
- Teen Titans: Starfire's Day in the Limelight episode "Transformation" starts off with the narrator pointing out that she's "very beautiful, but thinks nothing of it". The entire time her transformation (Tamaranian puberty) occurs, she's less concerned with being pretty and more concerned with simply going back to normal. Eventually she does, with the bonus of having laser eyes now. In general, she doesn't seem to notice when people are physically attracted to her, and in fact responds violently whenever a villain tries to pull the I Have You Now, My Pretty routine on her.
- Scooby-Doo! Mystery Incorporated has an episode in which the gang meets a town full of ugly looking people. Any deformity is seen as normal and even beautiful, while beauty is viewed as the opposite. Daphne becomes infatuated with the resident known as "Ugly Jimmy," a handsome man who laments that he was born so "ugly." Daphne tries and fails to tell him of his beauty several times. Eventually, Jimmy takes a nasty tumble and ends up so disfigured that everyone in town starts calling him "Handsome Jimmy." He proudly asks Daphne what she thinks and she's at a loss when it comes to words, though she nearly vomits.
- In a documentary in which British celebrities were shown never-before-aired interviews of themselves from The '60s, Maureen Lipman is moved to tears by the sight of her younger self and admits: "I never knew I was pretty."
- In a 20/20 interview after revealing she had MS, Annette Funicello said she wasn't the most talented or the most attractive and wondered how she was so popular and succeeded in show business.
- While beautiful may be a stretch, it's sadly common in reality for kids to believe that they're ugly due to being told so by their peers, despite research indicating that a child who is told they're ugly by peers rarely if ever actually is unattractive.
- Taken Up to Eleven with Audrey Hepburn, despite being a strong candidate for the title of "Most beautiful woman who ever lived" supposedly never thought she was that great looking, at least according to her son.