Follow TV Tropes

Following

YMMV / Judge Dredd

Go To

The Comic:

  • Alternative Character Interpretation: Due to how the comic is written, the characterization of Dredd tends to vary wildly. In more serious stories he's an extremely strict but ultimately fair and dedicated law enforcer who wants to protect Mega-City 1 and its inhabitants. In the stories focused more on black comedy, as well as some of the longer fiction such as the Democracy storyline, he comes off as a deliberate Jerkass who goes out of his way to make the citizens life a living hell. In the early stories, Pat Mills considered him a straight up hero, whereas John Wagner went with Anti-Hero at best and Villain Protagonist at worst.
  • Advertisement:
  • Awesome Music: His "unofficial" theme song, "I Am the Law" by Anthrax. It's "unofficial" in the sense that it wasn't commissioned as such by then-owner of 2000 AD Fleetway Comics, but both fans and creators recognize the song as Dredd's song, period.
  • Catharsis Factor: Judge Anderson managing to wipe Judge Death from her mind in A Dream of Death after having tormented her for so many years.
  • Complete Monster: See Judge Death and the others here.
  • Creator's Pet: PJ Maybe. A psychopathic, child genius serial killer who never matured. His signature tool was SLD-88, a mind control drug that was incurable, undetectable, and used almost exclusively by him. He constantly outsmarted everyone around him in increasingly implausible ways, even becoming the mayor of Mega-City One and working closely with the Judges, undetected, while still carrying out his habitual murders. When he was finally gunned down by Dredd decades after his first appearance, parts of fandom rejoiced while other parts were trying to figure out how he'd fooled the Judges THIS time.
  • Dork Age: For the most part, Garth Ennis' run on the strip wasn't all that well received. Ennis himself feels that his own reverence for the character meant he didn't take the piss like in a lot of his other work.
      Advertisement:
    • To be fair most consider that Ennis's stories were fairly well written with a few gems but that they simply did not live up to the potential Ennis had already shown and would shortly demonstrate when he went to America.In any case at this time John Wagner was still writing the strip in the Megazine and it was during this period that he created both America and the Mechanismo series, both of which are considered classics. To an extent it largely depended which comic you read as to how much of a Dork Age there was.
    • However the follow up run by Grant Morrison and Mark Millar is almost universally despised and considered the strips absolute nadir to the extent that even 2000AD's official history Thrill power overload had nothing good to say about it.
    • Its usually accepted the Dork Age began to come to an end with John Wagner's return to the Prog with "Wilderlands" in 1994, and that it ended completely with is his full time return later in the year and the publication of the classic "The Pit" in 1995.
  • Ensemble Dark Horse:
      Advertisement:
    • Judge Death repeatedly proved to be the comic's most popular villain, to the point where fans complained that he wasn't the Big Bad in the film Dredd.
    • Public Defender 314's habit of hilariously calling his pauses for emphasis and other actions have endeared him to the fans.
  • Foe Yay: Judge Death mockingly kisses Judge Anderson after defeating her in a comatose nightmare. He's a corpse, by the way. Then there's his constant reminders of the psychic "bond" they share since he was holed up in her mind for a year.
  • Growing the Beard: "The Cursed Earth" is the story where the world really comes together, and was the first of the epic stories that lasted about half a year.
  • Harsher in Hindsight:
    • One villain in an early story (from 1977) destroys the World Trade Center.
    • Muzak Killer: Live!, written in 1993 has a scene where an Expy of Richey Edwards, one of the infamous "27 Club" commits suicide through his own stupidity. Fast forward two years and the Real Life Edwards disappeared and was later presumed dead.
    • The comic's satire of zero tolerance policing with a future police force that shoots first, asks questions never has become a lot less absurd with the increase of militarization of police forces in the United States and police shooting controversies.
  • Hilarious in Hindsight:
  • Iron Woobie:
    • Nate Slaughterhouse. He is a Space Corps veteran who is wounded in the line of duty (Read: Loses most of his body, apart from his head and one shoulder) and is given a cybernetic body. He quits the Corps along with his wife and they take their son to the Big Meg. After some problems with local gangs, Nate's wife is kidnapped and her brain wiped and replaced with a slave module and his son is murdered. This causes him to snap and become a Vigilante Man, culminating in him attacking the local crime boss' hideout on the Canadian border in a Mini-Mecha.
    • Tweak, an alien Dredd rescues in the Cursed Earth. He's strong enough to eat rocks and diamonds and his race are more intelligent than humans, something he hides from them. His family is kidnapped and sold into slavery before they're put down by their human slavemasters. Tweak is just looking to give them a decent burial and fights alongside Dredd because Dredd stands up for him. He finally gets to go home when Dredd promises to keep the secret of his homeworld.
  • Jerkass Woobie:
    • Chief Judge Thomas Silver ruthlessly crushed the Democracy movement, and made an appalling number of bad decisions that ended in Necropolis, a nightmare that cost the lives of 60 million people. Return of the King makes him rather pitiable when we see the sheer magnitude of the suffering he went through at the hands of Judge Death and his cohorts, who turned him into a zombie pet so they could torment and humiliate him indefinitely, constantly reminding him about what they were doing to his city.
    • Judge friggin' Fire actually managed to achieve this for a split second, who for the record is as much of a genocidal walking corpse as his brothers, who has actually burned alive hundreds of children in one day on the excuse of "noise pollution". In Dreams of Deadworld it's shown that he was in love/obsessed with a female Dark Judge who killed herself rather than submit to him. He just keeps staring at her skull for decades to relive the memory, constantly reiterating that as a Dark Judge he shouldn't have feelings anymore.
  • Love to Hate: The Dark Judges are evil inhuman monsters, and their leader Judge Death in particular is an unmitigatedly horrible sociopath. However, their over-the-top sadism, hammy-ness, and dark humor makes them very entertaining villains at the same time.
  • Magnificent Bastard: Yevgeny Borisenko is a veteran and survivor of the Apocalypse War who vowed revenge against Judge Dredd after witnessing the nuclear destruction of East Meg One and being permanently blinded in the process. Borisenko forms the terrorist cell the Fourth Faction, spending decades building up its ranks with devoted followers, infiltrating Mega-City One, and develop and release the Chaos Bug inside the mega-city through his carrier agents, all the while misdirecting the Justice Department to keep the Fourth Faction's plans concealed. Despite being captured in the Mongolian Free State, Borisenko arranges his own murder ahead of time to avoid being interrogated, and through stoking public distrust against the Judges to subvert quarantine measures, causes the plague to envelop and nearly wipe out the entire city and emerge utterly victorious over the formidable Judge Dredd himself.
  • Memetic Badass: Judge Dredd. When the Face of Fear kills anyone who gazes into it, Dredd is the only one it can't kill. Fear is not so resistant to the Fist of Dredd. Also, he once got an entire army to back down by simply appearing on a comm screen. Even amongst those with barely a casual knowledge of the comic knows of him as the living embodiment of the law.
  • Memetic Mutation: Dredd's Catchphrase "I am the law!", to the point that it occludes the fact to the general public that he's one of the more sensible Judges patrolling Mega-City One instead of a borderline psychotic lawman.
  • Misaimed Fandom: There are a lot of people who don't realise that the strip is a satire and think that the judge system is actually a good idea.
  • Never Live It Down: Due to the sheer memetic-ness of his dedication to THE LAW, it can be surprising to new readers to find that Dredd is actually one of the more sensible Judges. Judge Dredd is fairly unique among long-lived comic book characters in that he ages in real time and his personality gradually changes over the years as he increasingly questions his role. Despite this fans still often portray him as being obsessed with THE LAW and arresting criminals.
  • Values Dissonance: Early issues showed Dredd punishing victims of crimes for 'incitement' because they displayed wealth that tempted the criminals. That works as 1970s satire on heavy-handed law enforcement, but can rankle with today's awareness of victim-blaming.
  • Values Resonance: As stated in Harsher in Hindsight, the theme of police's relation with society became more relevant under controversy of Police Brutality and Police Shootings in US. This is more pronounced in Democracy storyline and other stories dealing with questioning on the limits of the Judge's power and the effectiveness of Judge system.
  • The Woobie:
    • Many citizens fall into this category. Bennett Beeny stands out though. He spends his life pining for America Jara. When he finds her again, she's become a terrorist and later ends up being shot by a judge and winds up brain dead. He later transfers his consciousness to her body and has a daughter. There's a good reason America is considered one of the best stories. His suffering doesn't end there either, as America's body starts to reject his brain and he agrees to voluntary euthanasia. At least his hope that their daughter could reform the Justice Department from within by enrolling her at the Academy of Law after his death still lives on.
    • Jess, the psychic little girl from Deadworld. Sees her entire family get murdered by a gang of apocalyptic zombie-cops, but develops an odd friendship with the grizzled Fairfax and has some adorable moments with their motorbike AI and a group of muties.


The 1995 Movie:

  • Canon Defilement: This film has Dredd removing his helmet and showing his face not once, but multiple times. In fact he spends more time with it off than on. This is considered just a step short of heresy by many fans. It arguably doesn't help that the removal of the helmet isn't handled dramatically in any way - if it had been kept on until the moment he was exiled and stripped of his rank, it might have gone over better. But they paid for Sylvester Stallone and by God they were going to use his whole face, not just that iconic jaw of his.
  • Complete Monster: Rico Dredd is Judge Dredd's megalomaniac of a half-brother who, as a Judge, degenerated to murdering people based on the possibility they might commit a crime in the future. Too much for even the decadent Mega City One, Rico Dredd breaks out of the penal colony he's trapped in while leaving a slew of bodies behind him, murdering a store clerk to steal a powerful robot and teaming up with the corrupt Judge Griffin to bring order to the city. Rico betrays the law by gleefully massacring Judges by the dozens and causing explosions to go off through the city, even brutally murdering Griffin when he no longer suits his plans to instead create an army of clones to take over the city. Rico finally attempts to throw his own brother off the Statue of Liberty on the charge of being a man "when we could have been gods!"
  • Ensemble Dark Horse: Even though his role was pretty much a mindless robotic brute, Hammerstein is considered to be one of the better things about the film for his effects, badass voice and for being somewhat of A Colbert Bump for the ABC warriors
  • Ham and Cheese: Sly and Armand Assante's performances. The actors playing the assorted thugs as well. Even Stallone admitted the movie was terribly hammy.
  • Harsher in Hindsight: The plot revolving around Stallone's character being falsely accused of a serious crime (in the film, murder) and getting prosecuted for it became this trope when Stallone himself was falsely accused of sexual assault in 2017.
  • Hilarious in Hindsight: The unfinished Janus Project clones, with their blue skin and exposed hearts, look a lot like Tyrants.
  • Memetic Mutation:
    Dredd: You-betrayed-the-LAW!
    Rico: "LOOOAAAWWW!"
    • Sylvester Stallone's delivery of "I AM THE LAW!"
    • As well as his infamous charge of "TAWANTY YEERSH!"
  • Misaimed Marketing: The movie had a range of action figures. The movie was toned down significantly from the ultra-violent and cynical comic, but was still hardly for kids. More bewildering was the fact that in order to bulk the range out, it included several decidedly kid-unfriendly characters from the comic who didn't appear in the film, including Judge Death, an Omnicidal Maniac whose favourite modus operandi consists of ripping people's beating hearts out of their chests and who murders kids for fun.
  • Narm: Any time Dredd or Rico have to say the word "law". Since the movie deals with the law, this happens quite often.
  • No Problem with Licensed Games: An interesting example in that the SNES/Mega Drive adaptation was more faithful to the source material than the film. Also, Fergie isn't in it.
  • The Scrappy: Fergie.
  • So Bad, It's Good: As... off-kilter as it is, it's fun to watch, taking into account Armand Assante's bombastic acting, the poor drama and the fact that no one can seem to say "law" properly.
  • Took the Bad Film Seriously: Armand Assante looks like he's actually about to cry when he gets to the "That's your family! I'm your family! I'm the only family you ever HAD!" Careers are built on less sincere performances. (Especially notable since he actually manages to combine it with its supposed foil Ham and Cheese- that line comes almost right after "LAAAAWWWW!")
  • Visual Effects of Awesome: Whatever else about this film, the sets are impressive and capture to look of Mega City One very well.
  • WTH, Casting Agency?:
    • Chief Justice Fargo played by Max von Sydow, presumably in a case of Money, Dear Boy.
    • Ilsa Hayden played by Joan Chen?
    • Stallone as Dredd. He has the requisite chin, but with such a big-name star they simply couldn't afford to conceal his face the entire film.
    • Ian Dury?!
  • WTH, Costuming Department?: While the judge uniform is quite close to the comics, that codpiece drew plenty of criticism (Not to mention laughs).
  • Watch It for the Meme
  • What an Idiot!:
    • Fergie casually walking into a broken-into apartment in the middle of a block riot, mere hours after getting paroled. It's like he wanted to get arrested again. To be fair, it is supposed to be his apartment. He just figured he could ride out the block war inside.
    • Fergie repeatedly blurts out Dredd's name in circumstances where it would be smart not to call attention to him.

Top

How well does it match the trope?

Example of:

/

Media sources:

/

Report