Sometimes a Hunter of Monsters ends up really hitting it off with... well, a monster. Be it vampires, werewolves, demons, or some other traditionally monstrous creature given the Hotter and Sexier treatment; as long as they end up romantically or sexually entangled with someone who's supposed to be hunting them down, they qualify. Note that while this pairing is between a human hunter and a supernatural prey more often than it's not, it is entirely possible for it to be between two supernaturals.
This trope tends to play out in one of two ways; either the Bob and Alice fall for each other with one or both of them not realizing that Bob is a vampire and Alice is a Vampire Hunter, or Bob and Alice already know they're sworn enemies but are either forced to work together for long enough, or have been fighting each other for so long, that they develop an Inconvenient Attraction. This obviously leads to much drama, as Alice and her friends might have killed Bob's vampire buddies, or vice-versa. If Bob turns out to be a pretty decent guy who acts nothing like what Alice has been lead to believe about vampires, she may come to question the morality of her past vampire slayings. If Alice was Dating Catwoman, Bob may begin to feel wrong about preying on people no different from his beloved and decide to become Friendly Neighbourhood Vampire or even a Hunter of His Own Kind. Grey-and-Grey Morality may come into play if both sides of the conflict have equally valid and/or invalid arguments.
Often leads to Defecting for Love, HeelFace Turn, Love Redeems, and is almost guaranteed to accompany a boatload of Character Development. Subtrope of Forbidden Love and may lead to Maligned Mixed Marriage. Can overlap with Starcrossed Lovers if their relationship is strained. Compare In Love with the Mark, Predator Turned Protector, Boy Meets Ghoul, Vampire-Werewolf Love Triangle, Interspecies Romance, and Romantic Vampire Boy.
- The backstory of Inuyasha. The titular character is a half demon who attempted to steal the Shikon Jewel but is thwarted by Kikyo, a priestess. The two ended up falling in love. Sadly, it doesn't end well.
- The manga Mr. Monster has the titular Mr. Monster (possibly an oni living as a human) get into Oblivious to Love antics with various youkai (who he doesn't so much subdue as just be nice to), while a monster hunter named Oliver rescues an artificial angel who tries unsuccessfully to get him to go along with a Rescue Romance.
- Twin Star Exorcists has a complicated example. Exorcists are humans who use enchanted powers to exorcise monsters made of corrupt energy known as Impurities. The titular couple, Rokuro and Benio, are exorcists who must marry and give birth to a child who is destined to end the war between exorcists and Impurities. Later in the manga, Benio must undergo a ritual that transforms her into an Impurity because the prophesied child must inherit the powers of light from Rokuro and darkness from Benio. Rokuro and Benio still love each other despite her now being an Impurity, but both hide her transformation from other exorcists out of fear that Benio will be treated as yet another monster and hunted down.
- The protagonist of UQ Holder! is an artificially created immortal demon/pseudo vampire, and one of his love interests is a practitioner of the Shinmei-ryuu ("Gods' Cry School"), a sword style developed specifically to exorcise demons and handicap immortals.
- In Yuuna and the Haunted Hot Springs, the protagonist Kogarashi is an exorcist who arrives at the Yuragi Inn to get rid of the ghost haunting the place. Said ghost turns out to not only be friendly, but a pretty girl named Yuuna. Since Kogarashi doesn't hit women, he decides he will help Yuuna clear her regrets before she becomes an evil spirit. Kogarashi and Yuuna end up falling in love and both stop wanting her to go to the afterlife so they don't have to be separated.
- In Hotel Transylvania 3: Summer Vacation, Drac falls in love with Ericka who is a Van Helsing. While at first she wants to kill him and the other monsters on the cruise ship, she too falls in love with him.
- Hansel & Gretel: Witch Hunters: Hansel and Gretel have vowed to hunt down all of witchkind to avenge the death of their parents, but Hansel later falls in love with Mina, who's a White Witch. As it turns out, so are the two leads—their mother was a White Witch as well. Mina is eventually murdered in the climax by Muriel, the Grand Black Witch, for "betraying her kind".
- Lucien and Sonja in Underworld: Rise of the Lycans. Sonja, the daughter of the powerful vampire elder Viktor, regularly hunts down and kills feral Lycans despite being in love with Lucien, an enslaved Lycan.
- Averted in The Last Witch Hunter. There were plans to have Chloe fall in love with Kaulder, the eponymous Witch Hunter, but this was rejected because the age gap between them was seen as too large and Kaulder still being haunted by the death of his wife made it seem inappropriate.
- High School D×D has a harem example. One of Issei's, a reborn devil, haremettes is Irina who works for the church to exterminate demons and who later became a reborn angel. Though, by the time they get romantic the relationship between heaven and hell are much better.
- Strike the Blood has Kojou, the Fourth Progenitor vampire, and Yukina, a Sword Shaman sent to observe and potentially eliminate him should she deem him dangerous. Unbeknownst to Yukina, the Lion King Organization actually sent her so she would become Kojou's lover. Besides their obvious feelings, the appearance of their Kid from the Future clears any doubt that they eventually become a couple.
- The Max Gladstone story, "A Kiss With Teeth" is about a formerly murderous vampire named Vlad (yes, that one), who in the backstory, fell in love with and married the Buffy-like vampire hunter who pursued him. When the story opens, he's become a Retired Monster and is living a normal suburban life with his wife and raising a child, and finding the situation kind of stifling, especially his son's seeming complete normality.
- In Carpe Jugulum, young vampyr Vlad de Magpyr becomes infatuated with Witch Agnes Nitt. This is despite knowing right from the start that the Lancre witches see the Vampyrs note who have usurped the kingdom as an infestation to be wiped out, and Agnes has several times expressed her own desire to kill Vlad. Right at the end, while Agnes does not kill him, she says she'd gladly hold somebody's coat while they get a hammer and stake together. Nevertheless she effectively "dates" him on the advice of the older and wiser witch Nanny Ogg, who points out this makes men of any sort easier to manipulate.
- Den of Shadows features a romance between Sarah Vida and Christopher. Christopher is a Friendly Neighbourhood Vampire who doesn't kill humans while Sarah Vida is part of a witch line which famously hunts and destroys vampires.
- In Hex Hall, Sophie is a half-demon who finds herself falling for her classmate Archer, who is secretly a demon-hunter.
- In Sofie Jordan's Firelight series, Jacinda is a draki; dragon-like creatures that have a human form as well as a draconic form. She ends up falling for Will, whose family—not realizing the draki are sentient people due to The Masquerade—hunts draki for sport and profit.
- Cat and Bones, the protagonists of the Night Huntress series start off their odd relationship when Cat, an erstwhile vampire hunter, stakes a vampire whom Bones, a vampire himself, had been stalking for information about a human trafficking syndicate who the latter intends on taking down.
- In the Night World series, book 5 The Chosen revolves around Vampire Hunter Rashel Jordan realizing her soulmate is none other than Romantic Vampire Boy John Quinn.
- In The Serpent & Dove Trilogy, Lou (a witch) and Reid (a witch-hunter) end up in an Arranged Marriage and eventually fall in love. Lou knows that Reid is a witch-hunter, but Reid doesn't know that Lou is a witch. When Reid finds out about, he initially turns his back on her, but he changes his mind later and realizes that not all witches are evil.
- In Alexandra Christo's To Kill A Kingdom, after being cursed by her mother to live as a human, siren princess Lira winds up on the ship of siren hunter Elian and they slowly end up falling for each other.
- In Buffy the Vampire Slayer, Fully Embraced Fiends-turned-Friendly Neighbourhood Vampires and Hunters Of Their Own Kind Angel and Spike both end up dating Buffy... the vampire slayer.
- Charmed: Cole Turner, the source of all evil, marries Phoebe Halliwell, a good witch who is tasked with fighting evil.
- In Grimm, both Adalind Schade and Juliette Silverton end up doing this with protagonist Nick Burkhardt since he's a Grimm (a human being capable of seeing and hunting wesen), and both of them are hexenbiests (although only the former was born that way). And by the end of the series, Nick and Adalind end up the endgame official couple (to the point that they even have a son together).
- Supernatural: Sam and his brother Dean are both hunters, but the former has had relationships with a werewolf, a kitsune, and a demon, and the latter with an amazon who used him as a Glorified Sperm Donor and an angel who later experienced a FaceHeel Turn and tried to kill both of them before they were born. However, this is subverted when Sam has a fling with a female doctor who is suspected to be a siren, but turns out to be a Red Herring.
- In What We Do in the Shadows, Guillermo is a modern-day descendant of the Van Helsing clan. He's also the long-suffering but devoted familiar of vampire Nandor the Relentless.
- Divinity: Original Sin II: Mihaly, a Magister devoted to fighting demons and the Black Ring, and Almira, a succubus sworn to the Black Ring, had A Match Made in Stockholm while Almira is in Magister custody. They deserted their respective factions and ran away to be together.
Almira: Love will set you free.
- The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim's Dawnguard expansion introduces Friendly Neighbourhood Vampire Serana, who, while not marriageable, supplies copious amounts of Ship Tease with the Dragonborn. The Dragonborn originally meets her while a member of the titular vampire-hunting guild, the "Dawnguard".
- Havenfall Is for Lovers has an organization of vampire hunters, the Helsing Order, with one of their members, Vanessa Helsing, being a potential love interest. On her route, the heroine, who is human when they first get together, is later turned into a vampire.
- The protagonist of Kisses And Curses is a witch, and one of the potential love interests, Anastasia, is a witch hunter who has been raised to think of her kind as evil.
- Played with but never played straight in Charby the Vampirate. The hunter George was dating a human girl who was changed into a vampire by vamps seeking revenge against him, and she retained enough of her personality that they continued dating. Victor was courting a fellow hunter who was changed and who pretended to be into him in order to get close enough to try and kill him. At Samrick's party one of the members of the Vampire council is noticeably interested in Victor and flirts with him, but the chaos that soon unfolds prevents them from interacting again.
- In American Dragon: Jake Long, Jake falls for a girl from school named Rose. She's later revealed to have been raised a member of the Huntsclan, who are an organization of ninja warriors specializing in the slaying of magical creatures.
- In Extreme Ghostbusters, Roland falls in love with a ghost called Syren. The feeling is mutual, but sadly she ends up getting capture in a sort of Heroic Sacrifice to stop her evil sister.