Luna, in the mistletoe scene in the Room of Requirement: Legitimately worried about Nargles, or covering for her dashed hopes that she could finally snag a kiss from someone?
Because of how little characterization she had, Marietta Edgecombe is subjected to this. Was Cho telling the truth that she only ratted out the DA because she didn't want her mother to lose her job, or was Cho lying in order to cover her ass? Or, like Cho in the movie, was she finally forced to crack under the effects of Veritaserum?
When Sirius encouraged Harry to set up the DA, what was his main reason for doing so? Was it to make sure Harry and his friends could protect themselves against Voldemort, or was it the chance to rebel against The Man once again, through his godson? Or maybe a little bit of both?
Molly asked Moody to find a Boggart in Grimmauld Place with his magical eye, and he found it. Did Moody see the Boggart in its (if such existed) true form? Or did Moody see it shapeshifting into a form of his own greatest fear? Considering Boggart only shapeshifts when it sees its victim, it could very well be the former, which means Moody might be the only known character ever in the franchise to see Boggart in its true form! Too bad it's never mentioned again.
Cho mentions that Marietta is a "lovely person". It's been said that Cho was previously shown to be surrounded by friends in previous books. But in this one she's by herself. Have all her Girl Posse abandoned her due to her grieving for Cedric? If so, is Marietta the only one who stuck around? It is heavily implied that Marietta only went to the DA because Cho made her, so maybe she was trying to support her grieving friend? And perhaps that is why Cho is so keen to defend her.
Sirius mentions that his parents agreed with Voldemort's ideology, but never were Death Eaters themselves. Was this a case of Even Evil Has Standards, or were they just not willing to get their hands dirty? Also with Sirius's mother: was she always as Ax-Crazy as her portrait makes her out to be, or was this a result of losing both of her sons in the first war against Voldemort?
Harry's Jerkass behavior in this book is one of the reasons this entry in the series is so divisive. It's likely that he has PTSD in this book. He watched a classmate die, was tortured, and forced to fight an older wizard with over 40 years and a lot of power on him. His angst is perfectly reasonable, but was still an annoyance to many readers, mostly because he takes his anger out on his friends, acts paranoid about them secretly trying to gloat about how ignorant he is or keeping him willfully ignorant, and fails to control his temper throughout an entire year despite countless insistence by everyone around him that he do so.
Subverted in the film, a rare instance where some prefer the film's portrayal to the book's. Harry's angst is downplayed to relative hesitation and uncertainty of himself as a leader. One little pep talk later and he gets over it.
Cho too. She's frequently attacked for being clingy and crying all the time. Try getting over a loved one being murdered at the age of fifteen, and falling for the person who was with them when it happened. Hermione's speech to Harry and Ron almost feels like Leaning on the Fourth Wall.
In the film adaptation, the DA sign-up sheet Jinx, which was a controversial moment for Hermione's character, was removed, although some felt it should have been there since they either didn't see anything wrong with it and felt it emphasized Hermione's personal conviction and commitment to opposing Voldemort rather than doing so because Harry is her friend.
Fans had taken issue with the characterization of Ron in the previous four films — giving many of his better lines to Hermione and turning him into more of a bumbling sidekick. This film shows him publicly defending Harry in the common room, staying up to watch over Harry in his sleep and getting other little moments throughout the films (he's shown conjuring a Patronus, whereas in the book he wasn't able to).
In response to using Positive Discrimination between Hermione and Ron, two little moments in the latter part of the film subvert it. When Umbridge prepares to use the Cruciatus curse on Harry, Ron tries to fight off his captor. He also tries to do the same when they're held by the Death Eaters in the Ministry, whereas Hermione just cries in pain.
Was Umbridge raped by the centaurs? If she was, did she deserve it?
And the matter that wracks many an entry in the Headscratchers page: was the Prophecy worth all this convoluted cloak-and-dagger stuff that forms much of Harry's angst throughout the book and ultimately got Sirius killed?
The scenes cut from the movie. Some people think this bastardizes the source material. However, some were actually okay with it since one of the criticisms about the book was that it had a lot of subplots that could have been left on the cutting room floor.
Can't Un-Hear It: Evanna Lynch as Luna. Notably in the audio books, Stephen Fry had given her an English accent and she's said to be from near where the Weasleys are. But Evanna's portrayal was so spot on that they had Rhys Ifans do an Irish accent too when he appeared as Xenophilius. JK Rowling even says that she wrote Luna with Evanna's voice in her mind after that.
Captain Obvious Reveal: If you can believe it, Umbridge being responsible for the Dementor incident at the start of the book was actually meant to be a big reveal.
Contested Sequel: Opinions vary from 'interesting, dark and edgy plot,' to 'overly padded and melodramatic.' The interesting elements (Sirius' backstory as a White Sheep, the Marauders getting a Cerebus Retcon, the Department of Mysteries, the backstory of the Order, Occlumency, the DA) are among the best in the series, but many lament how little of it carried over into the next book, making it feel superfluous on the whole.
Snape has a very sympathetic backstory, but Fandom sometimes will go out of its way to blame every one else and sugarcoat his part things that went wrong in his life.
Marietta as well to a smaller extent (since we know very little about her). The fandom often likes to imagine her as a tortured girl afraid of her mother losing her job at the Ministry — when there's very little evidence pointing to that in the book. Whatever her motivations, she still went to Umbridge of her own free will knowing people would be punished.
Ensemble Dark Horse: Luna Lovegood. Originally only to have importance in this book, by the end of the series she is the sixth member of the True Companions group and the only non-Gryffindor to be in it. Luna's so popular, she managed to make her Quibbler critters a popular source of Arbitrary Skepticism jokes in the fandom, and many fans were disappointed that she never discovers a Crumple-Horned Snorkack during her time as a Magizoologist. Evanna Lynch also became one of the cast, as JK Rowling found her casting so perfect she said that whenever she wrote Luna, Evanna's voice played in her mind.
During Harry's trip to the Ministry of Magic, one of the passengers on the elevator is carrying a fire breathing chicken, a reference to the basan of Japanese mythology.
Growing the Beard: This did it for the remaining critics, if POA and GOF failed to do so. The film adaptation, as the first one where David Yates took the helm, was noted to be a real step in the right direction.
Remember Molly's Boggart? Fred dies during the Battle of Hogwarts.
Harry tells Sirius that Umbridge is no different than a Death Eater with some of her tactics. Guess who she ends up siding with two books later?
Fred and George shoving the unpleasant Slytherin Montague into a Vanishing Cabinet is funny at the time, but less so after Half-Blood Prince, where we learn that this incident alerted Malfoy to the Cabinet's abilities, so he spent the year fixing it in order to let Death Eaters into Hogwarts, including Fenrir Greyback, who mauls Fred' and George's brother Bill.
After the death of Sirius, Dumbledore tells Harry, "I know how you're feeling". In Deathly Hallows, we find out that he has also suffered the loss of family members largely through his own fault.
Seeing Cho get shunned by everyone after she is forced to out the DA is even more uncomfortable when Katie Leung revealed that she suffered so much jealous fan girl hate for getting to kiss Daniel Radcliffe that she quit acting for a few years.
Likewise the fact that a lot of the book is about lies created by the media to discredit people - Katie Leung was also the victim of photoshopped nude photos of her.
Evanna Lynch also plays Luna's oddball nature and quirkiness for much darker drama in the Irish film My Name Is Emily.
Zacharias Smith's "I don't think Expelliarmus is exactly going to help us against You-Know-Who, do you?", given that this spell is what finally brings Voldemort down.
Harry says sarcastically to Malfoy, Crabbe and Goyle: "I'm terrified now. I suppose Lord Voldemort's just a warm-up act compared to you three?" In Deathly Hallows, those three are a warm-up act before the final confrontation with Voldy.
Regarding the Ordinary Wizardy Levels tests, there's one concerning the grades. The lowest grade possible is "Troll", presumably meaning that the student has the aptitude level of a regular in-universe troll. Time marched on and the concept of the Internet troll arose. This gives the grade a wholly different but still perfectly applicable explanation in that a student reaching that grade has got to be doing it on purpose to get a laugh at the examiners' expense, i.e. trolling them.
Ginny's patronus, which wasn't revealed in the books yet, is shown to be a horse. In the next book, Ginny becomes Harry's love interest. Daniel Radcliffe would later star in Equus — as a stable boy who has a fetish for horses.
In the film, when the Order show Harry a newspaper showing the Ministry slandering him and Dumbledore, the quotation of Fudge on the headline is All is well. Possibly intentional on the part of JK Rowling, who had written the epilogue well in advance.
Harry invoking Everyone Has Standards on The Quibbler accusing Fudge of having goblins cooked into pies becomes way funnier with the casting of Imelda Staunton (Umbridge) as Mrs. Lovett. What's more is that Helena Bonham Carter played Mrs Lovett in the film version.
Also serves as a Stealth Pun: there's a TV dinner line in England that is called Little Goblin Pies.
Dumbledore actually resorts to violence when Umbridge physically shakes Marietta down during her interrogation, and warns her to never mistreat his students like that ever again. Then the Goblet of Fire movie came out two years after this book was published, featuring the legendary "Dumbledore asked calmly" scene in which movie!Dumbledore does the exact same thing his book counterpart reprimanded Umbridge for.
Cho for calling Hermione out on disfiguring her only friend and pointing out that she should have told the members of the DA that the sign-up sheet was jinxed.
Sirius is submitted to a lot of this in Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix with many characters mocking him for his "uselessness" to the Order while Hermione and Mrs. Weasley note how reckless he is. From what we see, Sirius was capable enough to be two years on the lam, disciplined enough to keep his sanity while imprisoned in Azkaban and his recklessness stems mostly from being cooped up in the house he hated and being submitted to Condescending Compassion from everyone around him, with Hermione expressing doubts about the advice of a full-fledged wizard. Indeed, had Harry listened to Sirius instead of Dumbledore or others, by using that Mirror he could have verified Sirius being safe and alive instead of charging at the Ministry. Dumbledore outright admits that Sirius was right for wanting to involve Harry on information with the Order.
Launcher of a Thousand Ships: Since this introduced some new characters, it also launched a few new ships. Most prominent was Harry/Luna and Neville/Luna.
Memetic Mutation: Umbridge's "I will have order!" She says it once in the movie and never in the book. Tellingly, by the time the next film was made, they saw fit to include an Umbridge doll in Weasleys' Wizard Wheezes which constantly squeals "I will have order!"
Memetic Psychopath: Between the jinxing of Marietta and the popular theory that Umbridge was gang-raped by the centaurs with her having a victorious smile afterword, some fans like to think there's a sociopathic side to Hermione. The film even has a scene where Hermione giddily says "it's sort of exciting isn't it? Breaking the rules."
Moral Event Horizon: Dolores Jane Umbridge has long since passed over it. She starts by cheerfully calling Harry a liar, forcing him to cut into his own flesh and do lines with his own blood, tries to sabotage Gryffindor's chances of winning the Quidditch Cup by removing three of their best players, cruelly mocks Hagrid's teaching, gleefully tries to sack Professor Trelawney (and thoroughly enjoys her despondency), takes over from Dumbledore, tries to arrest Hagrid for no reason, nearly kills McGonagall in a sneak attack, and finally tries to used the Cruciatus Curse on Harry. Oh, and it turns out she was the one who set Dementors on Harry and Dudley in the beginning. So, take your pick. Oh, and guess what? She gets worse in Deathly Hallows. In the movie, there's even a scene that shows that she forces first years to use the Blood Quill.
Some found Harry's meltdown in Dumbledore's office after Sirius died to be this. It looked less like he was venting his anger and more like one of Dudley's temper tantrums in the first book. The earlier rant in Grimmauld Place is like this too, with most of Harry's dialogue in block capitals — and some fans have jokingly nicknamed it 'Caps Lock Harry'.
Umbridge is so blatant and sometimes cartoonish with how evil she is, it's any wonder it took so long for her to meet her downfall.
Harry earns a "nice one, James!" for knocking Lucius Malfoy's wand sheath out of his hand. Not the wand. Just the cane that serves as its sheath.
The film version of the duel between Dumbledore and Voldemort; visually stunning? Absolutely. Intense? Oh, yes indeed. But there is that one part where Voldemort looks like he's belching a giant fireball at Dumbledore...
Then in the possession scene, Voldemort makes some weird faces in front of what looks to be fast-moving grey clouds, like he's in some 2000s music video. We also see him as Harry's mirror image, wearing Harry's hoodie and all.
The Black Quill, where students have what they write down carved into their skin. Some people think that this came off as the book trying too hard to be Darker and Edgier. Adding to the Narm was Harry's Wangst phase in the book, which makes it hard not to picture him believing that being forced to cut himself is actually an Unishment.
The release of the fifth book and the "Snape's Worst Memory" chapter has become the defining image of James Potter's character among the book's fans and especially Snape's fans, rather than the positive way he was regarded and described in the first four books as a great wizard, loyal friend and good father. The fact that Rowling never bothered to flesh out James's life with more flashbacks showing him in a more positive light (after he "grew out of" his bully phase) doesn't help.
Similarly, Snape being portrayed in the same chapter as both a loner and a victim during his Hogwarts years is usually how fans tend to portray him. Despite multiple characters mentioning that he had some friends and not just Lily Evans and was highly skilled in magic even then (in fact, it's obvious that the only reason he's alone in this scene is so he can study in peace), fans more often than not ignore this in favor of a friendless defensive Snape.
Hermione jinxing the DA sign-up sheet so that it permanently disfigures potential traitors has made some readers see Hermione as a sociopath with a Judge, Jury, and Executioner mentality.
Harry himself. Fans never got past his personality as Caps!Lock Harry, and to the extent that he's not remembered as a Vanilla Protagonist, he's remembered as a Wangst-y perpetually complaining Emo Teen, who while having genuine problems, comes off as incredibly immature and petulant, so much so that Alan Mooresatirized him this way.
Moody being the first Order member to fall during the final battle. Due to this fans often question the validity of his reputation as a legendary Death Eater catcher. Although it also is likely to do with having spent most of the previous year in a trunk.
The Ministry's claim that they need to interfere in Hogwarts in order to fix various problems with the way the school is run. They're doing it more for personal gain and paranoia about Dumbledore, but some argue that if a real school was run like Hogwarts (for example, letting a teacher bring dangerous animals to class), it probably would have been shut down.
Harry snaps at Hermione and Ron for always being at each other's throat, and demands to know if they can't give it a rest for once, before storming off. He's supposed to be seen as wrong because he's taking out his frustration at his friends, and with Ron and Hermione pointing out that they are on his side and believe him. Thing is, Ron and Hermione have been arguing with each other since they struck up their friendship. After a good four years of being stuck in-between these two butting heads with each other, any friend would eventually have enough.
After more than a book length's buildup of the Department of Mysteries, which was foreshadowed in Book 4 and mentioned suggestively like many Chekhov's Gun in Harry Potter's books, we get a spooky chapter describing the various weird rooms and the possible secrets they may contain. Then it ends up being a simple background for a fight scene and is never mentioned again in the later books. First time readers expected complex World Building and more details about the magical lore from the place but it becomes entirely marginal despite the buildup.
Despite being the titular group, very little of the book focuses on the Order or its backstory beyond tantalizing Noodle Incident. The novel mostly focuses on Harry's Emo Teen phase and Sirius' backstory as the White Sheep of a Pureblood family. Many felt disappointed that the book, and later books, don't tell us more about how effective they were, what they actually do to help people and most importantly when and how the Potters and Longbottoms thrice defied Voldemort.
The start of Book 5 introduced the idea and possibility that Harry could be expelled by the Ministry on flimsy charges and instead spend time at Grimmauld Place with Sirius and hang out with the Order. Many fans felt that this would have made a much more interesting plot, and it would have been cool for Harry to spend more time with Sirius, especially since Harry never does complete Hogwarts and drops out of Year Seven anyway and his wand snaps anyway, which likewise could have provided an avenue to seed the wandlore World Building earlier and far more organically. Furthermore, Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them the Prequel had a hero who was a Hogwarts reject who became a magic scholar proving that one can have a career after being expelled. Many felt that it would have compensated for the general frustration of the parts in Hogwarts under Umbridge's tyranny and provided a more interesting story and would likewise have made Sirius' death at the end even more impactful. The fact that the author has Hermione mocking Sirius for secretly, possibly, expecting this, only made some readers wish for this plot only more strongly.
The whole build-up in the middle part of the book, that Voldemort could be possessing Harry and the importance given in the plot to learning Occlumency is casually handwaved at the start of Book 6 with Dumbledore noting that Voldemort wouldn't try planting fake visions again. Many felt that this was a cheap resolution to a huge dramatic can of worms, made a whole newly introduced section of magic (Occlumency) a giant "Shaggy Dog" Story that had no bearing on the series' end (since Harry doesn't use it to defeat Voldemort) and likewise removed any tension, ambiguity, and risk on the question of whether Harry could decipher true and false memories, where Book 7 once again has Harry stumbling around camping in the forest until Voldemort's visions show him where the Plot Coupon is and likewise updates the hero of his activities and movements which allows the hero to keep his Advantage Ball rather than work for his victory.
Trailer Joke Decay: The "who are you and what have you done with Hermione Granger?" exchange played in most trailers.
Everyone plays Marietta's betrayal of the DA as a Moral Event Horizon, but according to Cho, she did it out of fear that her mother would lose her job. Of course, her mother's job is being a stooge for Umbridge in installing surveillance over the Floo Network which more or less leads Harry and others in the fandom to string the World's Smallest Violin (especially since Umbridge has made it harder for genuinely struggling and upstanding folks like Lupin to get legal work). Harry brings up how the Weasley's father Arthur works at the ministry, yet none of them ratted out the DA. However, given that Arthur is a member of the Order, disagrees with what the Ministry is doing, and deliberately refused to get a higher paying position (thus keeping his family poor), it's suggested that he wouldn't care much about his job and would encourage what his children were doing. Given that Harry has shown to be subject to Protagonist-Centered Morality in this book (he and Ron refusing to help Graham Montague after what the Weasley twins' prank nearly killed him), he most likely didn't consider the very real possibility that there are people in the Ministry whose jobs are even less secure than Arthur Weasley's. Especially since Marietta's mother values her job more to want to be more successful and supports Umbribge, and wouldn't want to jeopardize her career. There's also the matter of it being heavily implied that Marietta didn't even want to join the DA in the first place and was pressured into going to support Cho.
While Sirius' treatment of Kreacher is painted in a poor light, it should be noted that while he was mostly just grumpy and uncaring towards him and never abused his authority or fired the house elf, Kreacher was the antagonist in their relationship, unceasingly insulting him and his friends, including calling Hermione a mudblood, and plots his murder at the first opportunity. It's little wonder Sirius doesn't treat him with love and respect. Part of the problem is a House Elf's Blue and Orange Morality — only loyal to those who are kind to them. Sirius hated his house and his family, and that included Kreacher.
Unintentionally Unsympathetic: Combining Cho and Marietta for the film and then having it turn out that Cho was under influence of Veritaserum thanks to Umbridge really makes Harry look bad — he ignores Cho entirely when she attempts to talk to him after the Room of Requirement is broken into, and by extension so do the rest of the DA. Then after Snape reveals Mariette was essentially drugged by Umbridge, Harry still never speaks to the girl, making him come off as callous and petty for holding a grudge over something that clearly wasn't in her control to begin with.
Harry is specifically told that the increasingly paranoid Fudge is convinced that Dumbledore is raising an army to depose the Ministry. Harry has already been on the unkind end of Fudge's unhinged ire and knows he's walking on thin ice. He still goes along with Ginny's idea to codename the group attending his forbidden extracurricular classes "Dumbledore's Army" instead of Cho's much more sensible suggestion "Defense Association". When he's eventually found out, this title is reasonably cited by Umbridge as proof that Dumbledore was up to something sinister.
Marietta ratting out the D.A., which Cho was attending, instead of asking for Cho to leave her out of a group that conflicts with what her mother wants. Even without the jinx, it meant she sold out a good portion of the student body, including her best friend, to be expelled, just to "save her mother's job". Not to mention it's partially her fault that Dumbledore decides to Take The Heat for Harry and has to abandon the school to Umbridge's mercy.
The climax is one big idiot moment for Harry. After a good portion of the book has spent its time informing Harry that he should learn Occlumency because he shares a mind-link with Voldemort, who himself has learned this and could use it to his advantage, Harry still believes that Sirius has been kidnapped and was being tortured to be real. His hotheaded nature leads to him ignoring the more rationally-thinking Hermione, insists on getting to the Ministry of Magic right away, and this results in Sirius dying, as well as other people being heavily injured.
In the movie, Lucius Malfoy intentionally taking off his Death Eater's mask in front of witnesses who can very well inform Dumbledore and others that he is still on Voldemort's side. Granted he thought they'd all be killed anyway, but you'd think he'd be a bit more cautious.
What Do You Mean, It's Not Political?: A major incident occurs where the Government decides to butt in and turn Hogwarts into a police state, and one of the people in charge has a firm believe that torture gets results. Considering this was released in 2003, you won't be faulted for thinking this book was an allegory for the post-9/11 measures, particularly the Patriot Act and the torture that goes on at Guantanamo Bay.
Invoked by Harry in a friendship example; he calls out Cho for trying to justify what Marietta did and still being friends with her: "She sold everyone out, including you!" It'd have been one thing if Marietta had told on them when they first met in the Hog's Head, since she wasn't fully invested and the group wasn't officially formed yet, but she saw how the group was helping Cho deal with her grief for Cedric over months. Umbridge said anyone breaking the team decree would be expelldd, and she's only shown favoring the Slyherins. You can't blame Harry for asking Cho why she'd defend someone that would stab her in the back, and stay friends.
More realistically, Harry tries to pursue Cho, who is still grieving Cedric. Harry is also grieving him and feeling guilty about Cedric's death. While they have chemistry, they have a nasty fight over a misunderstanding on Valentine's Day, and Harry never gets the chance to explain himself. While they make up and Harry thinks they have a chance, Hermione tells Harry bluntly that Cho sees Harry as someone to help her cope with losing her boyfriend. Then Marietta rats out the D.A., and Harry no longer is attracted to Cho after she tries to explain Marietta's actions.