In fiction, the audience (and sometimes the hero) often doesn't just want the villains stopped, they want to see them punished. Often, and especially when the heroes are a little too heroic to get their hands dirty, this comes in the form of a Karmic Death.
But some villains are so villainous, so incredibly evil, that "merely" dying seems like they're getting off just a tad too easy. For these villains, A Fate Worse Than Death is in order. For the very worst of the worst, we have Karmic Rape. Common for those who are rapists themselves, especially child molesters.
A subtrope of Sexual Karma and Laser-Guided Karma. Compare Pay Evil unto Evil. Often implied if the villain is imprisoned. Commonly played for laughs, but can be portrayed seriously. When played for laughs, often overlaps with Disproportionate Retribution. Most examples are male, but the odd Rare Female Example pops up from time to time. Can overlap with Rape Portrayed as Redemption if this starts the villain on the long hard road to a HeelFace Turn. May also overlap with Death by Sex and Redemption Equals Death. See also Victim Blaming. Almost by definition comes with a heaping helping of Unfortunate Implications. It may also overlap with Prison Rape, or an Ironic Hell.
Of course, many people would argue that no one, no matter how evil, deserves rape. Pretty much every civilized nation in the world has laws meant to protect both free citizens and criminals from rape, and international law considers it a crime against humanity to allow or commit rape as part of a punishment for a crime, and there are countless human-rights organizations that work to eliminate rape against prisoners. This trope is when rape is treated by the narrative and/or the characters as a just punishment for the villain's crimes. Since Real Life, as far as we know, lacks a narrative to pass judgment, No Real Life Examples, Please!.
These days, including Karmic Rape in a work of fiction is likely to result in at least some backlash, which indicates that it might be on the way to becoming a Discredited Trope.
- In Karin, Bridget Brownlick is one of the masterminds behind the plan to kidnap Karin, rape, and forcibly impregnate her. When the Maka family find out about this and come to her rescue, Bridget herself ends up getting raped by Karin's brother Ren, and gets pregnant. Of course, it loses some of its meaning when it turns out she's actually thrilled to have the baby; it's Ren who's less amused by this turn of events.
- Kayoko Kasuga from Mofuku Tsuma rapes Honami and orders her Manabu to do it only to end up raped by Manabu and Honami.
- In The Rising of the Shield Hero, Malty, who falsely accused the hero Naofumi of rape, ends up raped to death by the King of Faubley.
- In The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen, the Invisible Man's rape by Mr. Hyde is treated this way. May overlap with Pay Evil unto Evil depending on whether you consider Hyde an Anti-Hero or just another villain.
- In Preacher, the exceptionally vile Herr Starr is raped in an alleyway by a man after a truly disastrous misunderstanding arising from his sheltered underling's incompetent attempt to hire a (female) prostitute for him. This is actually just the beginning of his series-long Humiliation Conga.
- Mirage of the Team Titans once raped Nightwing by using her powers to make him think she was Starfire. When the deception was revealed, she laughed at the idea of his relationship being ruined and Dick was jokingly called a slut. Then a few issues later, Mirage's actual boyfriend (her time's version of Nightwing) was driven insane by Raven and became "Deathwing." Their first night together following his FaceHeel Turn, Deathwing violently assaulted and raped Mirage. Given how incredibly unpopular Mirage was for raping Dick Grayson, it's difficult not to read Mirage being raped as her intended karma.
- In Gold Digger, the evil genie Madrid, trapped in a form resembling Gina Diggers and without any of her powers, was kept as a pet by two dragonesses who once served a villain named Fauntleroy, one of whom 'asserted dominance' over her repeatedly. To make matters worse, Madrid was only in this situation because of a backfired attempt at betrayal. She learns that if she had simply waited, she could have gotten out of the situation without any problems. This brutal treatment plus the knowledge that it was her own scheming ways that got her into this are what catalyzes Madrid's complete HeelFace Turn.
- In The Authority, this is Seth's ultimate fate. He's Too Kinky to Torture, so the Doctor turns him into a flock of chickens outside his uncles' home. We don't see it happen but it's very strongly implied the chickens are then raped/eaten. Seth is a racist, homophobic monstrosity who brags about being a pedophile, gleefully slaughters/tortures on behalf of a cabal of amoral rich people and at various points declared his intention to murder, eat and/or rape a baby, plus made his big entrance by exploding out of an innocent woman's uterus, so no one's shedding any tears over it.
- Soi-Fon's ultimate fate after Aizen becomes Soul Queen in The Defeated is being brought before Barragan to serve as his concubine as punishment for raping and torturing Ichigo, having blamed the Substitute for Yoruichi's death (despite Soi-Fon having killed Yoruichi herself). Notably, while the revived Yoruichi believes it to be a just punishment, she still breaks down crying after leaving Soi-Fon to her fate.
- A brothel owner in A Discordant Note paid some men to kill Harry Potter and kidnap his part-giant wife Ava to be used as an exotic sex slave. Ava uses a wooden strap-on to rape the brothel owner before killing her, claiming she wanted the woman to experience some of what Ava would have.
- Played for Laughs in Little Nicky, where part of Hitler's eternal punishment in Hell is to be periodically anally violated by the Devil with a pineapple. Overlaps with Pay Evil unto Evil considering that the Devil and some of his family are treated sympathetically.
- In Ace Ventura: When Nature Calls, the main bad guy, after his plans to bring the Wachati and Wachootoo tribes into war with each other are brought crashing down around his ears, tries to escape their wrath, but is cornered by a silverback gorilla with... amorous intentions. Cue "The Lion Sleeps Tonight."
- In Trading Places, Clarence Beeks finds himself in a cage with a horny male gorilla, in what is supposed to be karmic justice. They're both last seen being loaded on a freighter bound for Africa, for release into the wild.
- In Reefer Madness: The Musical, this happens in the musical number "Little Mary Sunshine," in which Ralph's marijuana-facilitated attempted seduction of Mary goes horribly, horribly wrong.
Ralph: Help! This crazy tomato's RAPIN' me!
- At the end of The Hot Chick, the villain (now male again, but in a female stripper's outfit and handcuffs) is making his escape from the police and climbs into the back of a car in a back alley, thinking that he will be driven to freedom. Unfortunately for him, the doors immediately lock and the driver turns around with a lecherous smile on his face before driving off as the villain screams in terror. It's insinuated that said driver is going to rape him after the fade-to-black.
- Mallrats has the jerkass love interest of one of the girls who is obsessed with doing it someplace uncomfortable (and no, not the back of a Volkswagen) get sent to prison, where this is strongly implied to happen to him by a larger inmate. Note that although he is unscrupulous and manipulative and intentionally seduces women who are emotionally vulnerable, he is never stated to use force.
- In Tamara, Sean and Patrick frequently Date Rape their female classmates at parties. Tamara, using her newfound mind-control powers, retaliates by forcing them to have sex... with each other.
- In Dangerous Worry Dolls, Eva rapes a prison guard using the same strap-on that the guard had earlier used to rape her.
- At the climax of Showgirls, Molly meets her hero Andrew Carver, but he brutally rapes her, sending her to the hospital. Nomi gets revenge on her behalf by posing as a hooker, and then assaulting him as they are about to get down to business.
- In This Is the End, Jonah Hill's character is at first nothing but nice to Jay in that overly-nice way of someone who knows they aren't liked and is trying really hard to change that opinion. Then he reveals in a monologued prayer to God that he really hates Jay, thinks he's a bad influence on Seth Rogen, and wishes he died. Well, his prayer was heard... by a demon. Who comes at night and forces himself on Jonah Hill's character, leading to him being traumatized and soon after getting Demonically Possessed.
- In the epilogue of Animal House, Greg Marmalard, one of the adversaries of the Delta House, was mentioned to have been raped in prison after taking part in the break-in of the Watergate Hotel in 1974.
- In Kinjite: Forbidden Subjects, Charles Bronson's character decides to let the villain (who rapes and pimps out little girls) live, because that is better for "justice...poetic justice." The catcalls from the prison block and the "new mama" speech from his new cellie leave no doubt as to what that means.
- In My Favorite Martian the evil reporter played by Elizabeth Hurley ends tied to a litter and molested by another villain, Dr. Coleye.
- In Queer Duck: The Movie, the homophobic Reverend Vandergelding attempts to spray every gay man at the theme park with his gay cure to make them straight. He ends up crashing down in a gay rodeo and doused with his own concoction, causing him to be covered in pink fur. This results in a gay bull becoming attracted to him and this is treated as his comeuppance.
- In The Spider novel The Red Death Rain, the villainess is raped to death off-screen by an orangutan. Both a Karmic Rape and a Karmic Death as she had planned to do this to Nita van Sloane, in addition to killing large numbers of people with poisoned tobacco.
- In Myra Breckinridge, the title character anally rapes a man using a strap-on dildo. This act is generally construed as teaching the man a lesson and making a statement for sexual equality. The entire work satirized sex, gender, and sexual practices.
- Zig-Zagged in The Wheel of Time:
- Mat's repeated rape at knife-point by Queen Tylin is generally Played for Laughs, and the other female characters see it as this trope until he, after much pleading for help, finally impresses the severity of the situation on them. Even after they help him, they (and the narrative) treat the situation much less seriously than they would if the genders had been reversed. Word of God is that the reader is not supposed to agree with the ladies' quip that he "had it coming" thanks to his Chivalrous Pervert habits.
- The enslavement, degradation, and sexual abuse of the minor villain Galina Casban by another woman plays this trope straight: she is captured shortly after kidnapping and horribly abusing Rand al'Thor on the Forsaken's orders. She gets this twice over, since her fellow captives' help gets her within a Hope Spot of escaping before she picks up the Villain Ball, betrays them, gets caught by her abuser while trying to escape alone, and is irrevocably broken.
- Myrddraal are Humanoid Abominations known for raping women, which usually either kills them or drives them insane. The Mouth of Sauron, Shaidar Haran, takes the form of a Myrddraal and twice focuses his "attention" on a female Forsaken, first Mesaana and then Graendal, as punishment for failure. In Graendal's case, she actually dies and has to be given a new body.
- In one of the SERRAted Edge novels by Mercedes Lackey, the villain of the book has been sexually molesting his daughter since she was 2 or 3. At the end of the book, he's dumped in an extradimensional prison cell with an entity that will put him through everything he did to the girl.
- In The Dresden Files, Lord Raith raped his daughters into submission. But when it turns out he can't feed after Harry's mother cursed him, his oldest daughter decides to turn the tables. While a horrific scene, he definitely doesn't get any sympathy. Said daughter, Lara, does this again in a later book, against her cousin Madeline, The Heavy for the book. This time, despite her victim generally being unpleasant, it's treated more of a reminder of her own monstrosity than a karmic punishment, in part due to the fact that Lara disembowls (and, it's implied, eats) the victim as well.
- In The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo, anti-heroine Lisbeth Salander gets revenge on her abusive social worker by secretly filming him raping her and then anally raping him with a dildo, tattooing the words "I'm a pig and a rapist" on his torso, and threatening to show the tape recording of his abuses on her if he doesn't comply with her demands.
- Only a few episodes after he raped his ex-wife, Tommy on the dark comedy/drama series Rescue Me is drugged with roofies and raped by his needy, obsessive, psychotic girlfriend Sheila after turning down her offer to retire and run away with her with to live at her beach house.
- The episode "Go Fish" of Buffy the Vampire Slayer. The evil swim coach forces Buffy into the water below his office with the mutant fish-men, but not to feed them: "Boys have other needs." (Buffy herself doesn't like the idea that she'd "made it with the whole swim team"). Xander helps her out, the coach falls through the trap door, and while he yells and splashes below, Buffy quips "Boy, those boys sure like their coach!"
- At one point during his tenure as host of Weekend Update, Norm McDonald joked that Prison Rape, being the worst part of the whole experience, should be formally portioned out during sentencing.
- The Mentalist: Referenced at the denouement of "Red, White and Blue" when Rigsby gets annoyed at a Killer of the Week who's convinced it's Never My Fault.
Rigsby: Oh, well, look on the the bright side. In prison, you won't have to pay for dates.
- In Torchwood, a couple of episodes after he drugs and is strongly implied to rape a man and a woman with Alien Sex Pollen, Owen gets the experience of being raped and murdered implanted into his memory by a time-viewing alien artifact.
- In the first episode of American Horror Story: Coven, Madison gets gang raped by frat boys during a party. They later end up in a bus accident and one of them is brought to the hospital. Zoe then avenges Madison by raping the comatose boy, causing him to bleed from every orifice and die.
- Implied on an episode of My Name Is Earl. Earl punches his Bad Boss in the face, which leads to his wife and his girlfriend finding out about each other, and his (soon-to-be-ex) wife finding the money he stole from the fast-food restaurant he managed, which leads to him being sent to prison. In the end, he is drinking coffee out of a tin mug with the words "World's Best Bottom" scrawled on it, while his cellmate looks on.
- Black Comedy Rape version in one episode of Married... with Children: Seeking revenge on a girl who's been stringing him along and humiliated him years ago, Bud convinces the guy she's really interested in (and who couldn't care less about her) to go along with his plan entice the girl into meeting him under the bleachers for a round of quickie sex. Later, the girl is seen emerging from the bleachers, adjusting her clothes, apparently completely unaware—thanks to the darkness—that she just had sex with Bud, who the audience soon sees coming out a few minutes after she did.
- Subverted in Orange Is the New Black. After Coates rapes Pennsatucky, she and Big Boo plan to drug him and rape him with a broom handle. Subverted when Pennsatucky changes her mind—she's been raped, and she's not going to do that to someone else.
- One Life to Live Roughly a decade after leading the gang-rape of Marty Saybrooke, Todd Manning is kidnapped by an obsessed woman and raped by her (she wants to have his baby). He clearly views his ordeal as this trope, even hallucinating Marty taunting him, "Todd rapes Margaret (her proper name) and Margaret rapes Todd."
- Played straight and for laughs in Sublime's "Date Rape", in which a date rapist is sentenced to prison where he himself is Prison Raped.
Well I can't take pity on a man of his kind,Even though he now takes it in the behind.
- Nirvana's song "Rape Me" from In Utero is, according to one of Kurt Cobain's explanations, about a male rapist of women being raped in jail as some sort of "poetic justice".
- In the Book of Judges, an unnamed Levite man's concubine runs away from him, and allegedly cheats on him with several different men before running home to her father. In turn, he gives her over to a bunch of townsmen that wanted to rape him, and she is raped to death. The narrative is not shy about connecting her alleged cheating with her rape and her most unfortunate demise.
- In another, earlier incident involving Lot and his daughters, after their Doomed Hometown is destroyed and they take shelter in a cave, Lot is raped by his daughters, and has a son/grandson by each of them. Some interpret this as divine punishment for offering the girls to be raped. The reason given in the narrative, however, is that the girls (erroneously) believed themselves and their father to be the last people on Earth alive After the End, their fiances had been killed, and they felt compelled to have children for future security. In other words, they viewed sex with their father as a Necessary Evil, but knew that he'd never go for it sober.
- A Midrash of the Book of Ruth says that the moabite Orpah after abandonning Ruth and Naomi to return to her people was then gang raped by hundred men and a dog. (The text itself says nothing about what might have happened to her. She isn't seen in the text as a "bad person" or deserving of punishment for choosing to go back home, and Naomi actually encouraged it.)
- In William Shakespeare's Measure for Measure, the villain Angelo attempts to use the Scarpia Ultimatum to rape the heroine Isabella by offering to pardon her condemned brother in exchange for sex with her. The Duke foils him by suggesting that Isabella persuade Angelo's rejected ex-fiancée Mariana, who still loves him, to have sex with him in a dark room pretending to be Isabella. So by modern sexual morality, Angelo gets raped by deception while believing that he's raping Isabella by extortion.
- The Korean arcade game Boon-Ga Boon-Ga allows you to select from a number of unpleasant characters, then use the attached stick to anally violate them by shoving the stick through a hole on the front of the cabinet, upon which the character will then make comically exaggerated motions and facial expressions. Well, calling it a "game" is stretching the definition very thin, as there is no story to it or in-game goals (though it does drop prizes). It was marketed as stress relief. Boon-Ga Boon-Ga was never exported to any other region because this premise wouldn't fly anywhere but Korea and its intended audience of Japan.
- Sunless Sea: The Not-So-Delightful Adventuress screws you, the local monkey mayor, and even her Golem bodyguard over with murderous intent. And she would have gotten away with it too - except said bodyguard is Unfinished enough to not be completely loyal to her, allowing him to kick her ass. At this point, you can let the Clay Man or the monkeys do their 'thing' with her, or let her leave unscathed to prevent this trope.
- An article on Cracked mentions a Harry Potter fan theory that Dolores Umbridge — a thoroughly terrible woman who, among other things, tortures children — got gang-raped by centaurs at the end of the fifth book. In the text itself, Umbridge gets dragged deep into the Forbidden Forest by centaurs. After Dumbledore rescues her, she shows little physical damage but remains temporarily catatonic from whatever she endured — until the students start making hoofbeat sounds, at which point Umbridge goes into a panic. As Cracked points out, this has led some fans to conclude exactly what you'd expect. It doesn't help that the original centaurs of Classical Mythology were notorious rapists, and J. K. Rowling likes to show her work regarding myths that she borrows from.
- Whateley Universe: From Jade 4: Bottle a Jinn: Alpha Bitch Solange enters a horrific contract with Thuban: in exchange for keeping her rival Hekate out of her hair for a week, she would allow her body to be possessed for two days and let herself, in effect, be raped by Montana, whom she had previously offered sexual favors with no intention of following through. Having absorbed a powerful spirit (Jinn, who is essentially a part of another student's astral self), she is convinced she can withstand the possession and get around the terms of the contract... but Jinn has been harassing Solange from inside her mind, trying to get Solange to free her, and eventually Solange does - just before the terms of the agreement come due.
- It's hard to tell whether it's this or just the show's usual Black Comedy, but in an early episode of Family Guy, an Alpha Bitch cheerleader is tied up by Stewie and left in a bathroom stall, where Quagmire finds her.
Quagmire: Dear Diary: jackpot!
- In an episode of South Park, a villain who repeatedly tries to get Jimmy killed is raped by a shark. On screen. Twice.
- Archer has the main character find out that his best friend raped him when he was drunk. Given that Archer is a womanizing deviant that even a self-diagnosed sex-addict is disgusted with, his reaction is played for laughs.
- In the Justice League episode "Injustice for All" which features the Injustice Gang, Cheetah appears for the first time and meets Solomon Grundy who clearly shows an unwelcomed attraction to her which she rejects violently. At the end of the two-part episode she's left alone trapped with a smiling Grundy, nothing is shown obviously but the implications are clear.