Sole Survivor
Second The X-Files fan character, and Ethan's past self.
- Hidden Depths: He taught himself how to cook.
- Innocently Insensitive: He does a lot of poking and prodding around Yessi's alien-ness. He gets better after a talking-to from Nolaa, though. The discovery that he's an alien too helps more.
- Sole Survivor: The eighteenth in series history, saved in the end by apparently having a stronger social game than Sagitarria's.
- Tomato in the Mirror: His parents are aliens!
Runner-Ups
Second Fur Fighters fan character, and Ria's past self.
- Good Is Not Nice: Is Sagittaria brave and heroic? Definitely. Is she a pleasant person to be around? Not so much, and throughout the season the others frequently comment on how poor her social game is and how easily she alienates people. This is why she loses to E.T. in the end; while the jurors agreed that Sagi's game was much more honorable and proactive than his, E.T. bonded with all the jurors while Sagi never socialized with anyone but Ria.
- Large Ham: Between her naturally loud and peppy personality and actions like imitating a shark and comically using army lingo this trope comes naturally.
Second Yakuza fan character, and Kasai's past self.
- Cheaters Never Prosper: He admitted to cheating at the Final Tribal Council, because otherwise he would win with all but one vote and become Kasai.
- The Perfectionist: Tries to play the game without pissing off any people. It doesn't work.
- Screw Destiny: He's willing to do anything to avoid becoming Kasai. This includes throwing away a sure shot at winning.
The Jury
Second Star Wars fan character, and Nolaa's past self.
Came back for Season 20: Generations as Nolaa.
- Sex Slave: Strongly hinted she is this.
- Shrinking Violet: Yessi's a sweet girl, but shy and unsure of herself.
- Surpassed the Teacher: Votes Clarissa off after a heated debate over Frysk's loyalty. Clarissa, for one, is quite impressed.
- Took a Level in Badass: Thanks to the mentorship of Clarissa and her future self.
Fifth Star Fox fan character, and Kitsunie's future self.
- The Comically Serious: Occasionally.
- The Ditherer: The Insecure/Submissive type. Due to making some horrible decisions as Kitsunie, he prefers to let his superiors make decisions for him.Ria: Frysk... How the heck am I supposed to know what kind of hobbies you'd enjoy?
- Giver of Lame Names: Post-game, he's taken up weapon development, with lovely titles such as the "Cheese Grater Circular Saw" and the "Barbell and Machete Club".
- I Hate Past Me. The feeling is mutual.
- Last of His Kind: The last member of the original Future tribe to be voted out.
- No Poker Face: In a similar manner as the page image - going by his face, he's The Stoic, but his tail will give away everything.
- Squat's in a Name: Despite being a Cornerian fox named McCloud, was a complete washout in flight training.
- The Stoic: Doesn't show a lot of emotion.
- Super-Soldier
Second Mean Girls fan character, and Claire's future self.
- The Fashionista: CEO of a fashion company.
- Heel–Face Turn: Attempts this after meeting her past self. Ultimately downplayed.
- Hypocrite: Her reason to go off on Lady Bit is that she hates pretentious upper class women that achieved success just because of their looks, while she herself is very close to one.
- Jerk with a Heart of Gold: Although she has a tough demeanor, the side of her that is Claire is still there.
- Karma Houdini: Sabotages the tribe during the second immunity challenge and gets away with it.
- The Speechless: Is unable to speak during most of the second round, as she was muted by Lady Bit.
- Surpassed the Teacher: The teacher to Yessi's student. She's quite proud of the results.
- Took a Level in Jerkass: Between the iterations of her characters shown, she certainly did.
- Villainous BSoD: When her past self gives her "The Reason You Suck" Speech behind her back, and she happens to be listening.
First Fur Fighters fan character, and Sagittaria's future self.
- Shell-Shocked Veteran: A former soldier suffering from trauma, she came into the game hoping to see if her issues were improving.
- Younger Than They Look: Is 24 (only four years older than Sagittaria) but has apparently been through enough to appear middle-aged.
Fifth Second Life fan character, and Deimos's future self.
- Formerly Fit: Even ignoring the lost height, he's notably pudgier than his past self.
- Keet: Turns out that for how much mystery surrounds him, he's actually very cheery and outgoing.
- Laser-Guided Amnesia: He is suffering from short-term memory loss. It's revealed during his family visit that it's because the headphones that he wears erase his memory when he goes to sleep.
- Line-of-Sight Name: He got his name from the tribe he started on. Unusually for this trope, there's thoughtful reasoning behind it in-universe.Nolaa: I wasn't going to wait for him to get stuck with a name like "Mr. Fluffles" or "Chubbs". Besides, when you're dealing with cargo and someone living is actually a part of it, if they're messed up and don't remember things, giving them the name of where you found them usually ends up as a good lead for the authorities later on. If Atlas is a good enough name for a tribe, it's good enough for him.
- My Name Is ???: The other characters later name him Atlas.
- Physical God: As Deimos' future self, he is likely this.
First Yakuza fan character, and Shin's future self.
Came back for Season 20: Generations.
- Evil Mentor: To his past self.
- Failure Gambit: Masterminded his own elimination as part of his plan to get Shin a perfect win.
- Faux Affably Evil: He may seem kooky and playful, but when Deimos' slip at the challenge gives him an excuse to show his true self, he's nothing short of terrifying. Subverted, according to Word of God
- Last-Name Basis: His full name is Shin Kasai.
- Loveable Rogue: Comes off this way at first.
- Mask of Sanity: It's been heavily implied that his Loveable Rogue persona is a mask for deep mental instability. Not actually true, though.
- Master Forger: Created numerous fake idols and other game items to keep everyone guessing.
- The Man Behind the Man: To Shin, having masterminded and mapped out every single move Shin made in the game, including his own elimination to throw off suspicion.
- Took a Level in Jerkass: Much more abrasive and conniving than his past self.
Second Jojos Bizarre Adventure fan character, and Nayla's future self.
- Counterspell: It turns out his "House of Light" ability can disable Deimos' dark influence.
- The Leader: Type II.
- Large and in Charge: He's almost a head taller than Kasai and Ethan, with the strength to back it up.
- Old Friend, New Gender: His past self is female, making him the first transmasculine contestant on SFC.
First Mean Girls fan character, and Clarissa's past self.
Came back for Season 20: Generations as Clara, a midpoint between herself and Clarissa.
- Future Me Scares Me: Though she attempts to reason with herself.
- Innocently Insensitive: Tries to talk with Nayla about her future self being a male, and triggers her Berserk Button.
Eliminated
First Star Wars fan character, and Yessi's future self.
- The Mentor: Takes on this role with her past self.
- Straight Man and Wise Guy: She is the Straight Man to Clarissa's Wise Guy.
- Took a Level in Badass: She's a lot more calm, collected and capable than her past self.
Fourth Second Life fan character, and ???'s past self.
- The Atoner: He feels horrible about his past actions, and although he feels he can't be forgiven, he wishes to do no more harm for the rest of his existence.
- The Big Guy: He dwarfs the rest of the cast with his massive muscles.
- Cain and Abel: The Cain to his brother's Abel.
- History Repeats: A Second Life lion character who quits.
- Non-Gameplay Elimination: Quits at the sixth tribal council after his powers flare up and cause members of his tribe to become exceptionally aggressive during a challenge.
- Physical God: Literally, he's a demigod.
- Retired Monster: He was once a vicious demigod of war, but his brother performed a Heroic Sacrifice that removed all trace of evil from his heart.
- Sacrificial Lion: Literally.
First The X-Files fan character, and E.T.'s future self.
- I Say What I Say: With his younger self
- Not So Above It All: Although he is in sync with his past self.
- Only Sane Man: The voice of reason on the future tribe.
- Taking the Bullet: For ET. Why he did that is unexplained, though it's likely so he can ensure that he still wins at the end.
- Unfazed Everyman: Due to his experience with stories.Ethan: I'm also the only person here over 25, discounting Deimos. I have no idea how old he is.Deimos: If you're curious, I'm over 2000 years old.Ethan: So you see, Deimos and I are the designated old men of the tribe.
First Jojos Bizarre Adventure fan character, and Ernest's past self.
- Cool People Rebel Against Authority: Joins Kitsunie's alliance against Sagittaria, just because.
- Old Friend, New Gender: Her future self is male. She does not like to talk about it. Although more due to how she didn’t expect herself to be an authority figure.
- Suicide by Cop: Eventually decides this game isn’t going to solve her problems.
Fourth Star Fox fan character, and Frysk's past self.
- Aura Vision: Frequently discusses being able to sense positive and negative energies.
- The Friend Nobody Likes: Quickly alienates everyone aside from E.T. and Nayla, and even Nayla doesn't actually like him and only sees him as a number.
- Future Me Scares Me: Does not like his future self one bit.
- Jerkass: Though he doesn't seem to realize it.
- Only Known by Their Nickname: His real name is Frysk McCloud, but he insists on being called "Kitsunie."
- Revenge Before Reason/Leeroy Jenkins: Goes after his most competent tribesmates for petty reasons.
Third Hyperdimension Neptunia fan character, and Sprinkles's future self.
- Cassandra Truth: She correctly states that Clarissa sabotaged the tribe during the second immunity challenge. However, Ethan is able to create a plausible scenario for Lady Bit to be guilty, and everyone believes Ethan's scenario.
- Game-Breaker: Her ability to play God includes: muting other contestants, banning all strategy discussions that she is not personally involved in, and making everyone unable to say or write her name.
- Large Ham
- Punny Name: Her name can also be read as "Lady Bitcoin EA". She also mentions "Master Pei Tuwehn".
- The Tribemate Nobody Likes: Thanks to her Game-Breaker powers and unsociable attitude, her entire tribe wants her gone as soon as possible.
Second Hyperdimension Neptunia fan character, and Lady Bit's past self.
- Children Are Innocent: Sprinkles genuinely doesn't understand that playing with dangerous objects and nearly maiming a tribemate is a bad idea.
- Deliberately Cute Child/Kawaiiko: Sprinkles dresses and acts deliberately for maximum cuteness, and speaks in an adowable Third-Person Person style. To some other characters' surprise this wasn't to hide an evil side or negative personality traits; she's really just that obsessed with being the cutest thing around.
- Elmuh Fudd Syndwome: The cutest woice awound.
- The Load: She's completely useless both at camp and in challenges, and she doesn't care about anything besides acting cute. This is why she leaves first.