Main Tropes Index

Troperville

Editing Help

Tools

Toys

Narrative

Genre

Media

Topical Tropes

Other Categories

Custom Search

"Why should they save this fish?" he demanded. "This is not a good fish. It's oily and you cannot eat this, and it's a smelly fish." Fixing me with a puzzled look, he concluded: "It's a bad fish."
From The Guardian, about the Coelacanth (this Trope's official mascot. See right.)

"You'd almost feel bad about killing them if they weren't so damn ugly."
Mike Rowe, of Dirty Jobs, on barnacles, of all things

"If God had wanted us to be concerned for the plight of the toads, he would have made them cute and furry."

Humans being the right bastards we are, tend to only like certain animals. Oh, how our dog smiles and plays! Oh, how our cat rolls on the rug asking for a tummy rub! Oh, how pretty the Mute Swan is as he glides across the pond! Oh, how the Coelacanth... um... damn that thing's boring. It's pretty butt-ugly too.

And so, only cute, cuddly, and cool animals are good guys while unpopular or unattractive animals are brought in to be the Designated Villains. This usually plays into the "Carnivores are Mean" subtrope of Carnivore Confusion. Wolves were cast as baddies for centuries. Owls and hawks and corvids basically exist to drop down on our cuter protagonists from the 'bove. Wasps and termites are mini villans and the evil twins of bees and ants. Rats and weasels are the go-to pocket-sized villains. And friendly sharks pretty much exist only as a subversion. The heroes, on the other hand, will be cute or cool animals like doggies and kitties and bunnies and duckies and turtles and froggies and ladybugs and bees and ants and monkeys and dolphins and Reticulated Chipmunks and blah. Wolves and Foxes, and Lions and other big cats can be heroes as well because their babies are cute and thus remind people of puppies and kittens, and the adults look Bad Ass. All butterflies are marked "Cute", even those you won't like to see in your garden. Spiders and bats are marked "Mean" even though they usually don't bother humans at all and even devour lots of annoying and dangerous insects. And if you'll encounter an Antlion in the role of horrible predator, its adult form is not likely to appear in next scenes (it looks like a cute, pretty dragonfly). For any animals not in this short list, it's usually divided into:

  • Ugly - Predatory - Mean
  • Cute - Awesome - Herbivore - Pacifistic - Nice

Sadly, some fiction goes even further, casting only cute, cuddly, and cool animals - ugly and unpopular animals tend to be non anthropomorphic or outright absent.

It should be noted that which animals get to be considered cute/cool or the opposite tends to vary by culture. Just as an example, in general foxes are cute in America, mean in some parts of Europe and Magnificent Bastard types in others, magical tricksters in Japan, and Axe Crazy evil in Korea. Another factor may be the animal's size and/or place in human society. For example, both Mice and Rats can be cute, but they can get a bad rap because they're commonly household pests. Even then, the tiny Mice are likely to be portrayed more positively than the larger Rats. (Possibly justified, as rats are more likely to bite, though they make more trainable pets. Please note that rodents can and do eat meat.) Consequently; if a Cat is chasing Mice, the Cat is often portrayed as the villain, but a Cat chasing rats is usually the hero. Whatever the case may be, if you happen to think any of the animals in the "Designated Villains" list are cute and/or cool, you are a weirdo in the eyes of the Pop Culture Gods.

It is worth noting that there are some exceptions to this rule, because perceived slyness and/or cunning are often important determining factors along with cuteness. Rats and ferrets, for example, are almost always portrayed as mean and/or evil, even though they are small and fuzzy. However, mice, who appear nice or mostly harmless quite a bit, are commonly thought to be unable to think their way out of a wet paper bag. For this reason, though cats are indisputably adorable, they are often seen as mean or a villain's pet.

This trope is pervasive enough that simply associating a human character with a certain animal or, in fantastic fiction, giving him the features of an animal can immediately peg him as good or bad.

In extreme cases, this can start to look like the animal equivalent of Fantastic Racism. And if you know anything about actual animal behavior, it's a lot easier to say They Just Didnt Care most of the time. Where are the wise crows, easygoing iguanas, relentless all-consuming caterpillars, murderous doves, Axe Crazy chimpanzees, bullying swans, suicidal deer, ad infinitum?

Unfortunately, this trope is Truth In Television and a major problem in wildlife preservation, euphemistically termed charismatic megafauna. It doesn't matter if, like the aforementioned Coelocanth, you've survived damn near everything else the world can throw at you; if you aren't generally thought of as cute by most people, you're in serious trouble. Nobody seems to care about ugly or unpopular animals who are just as important to the ecosystem. You don't see the Coelacanth as the World Wildlife Fund mascot, do you?

The Uncanny Valley is somewhat related, as it was born from the scientific study of this trope. It often cross-pollinates with Beauty Equals Goodness, Animal Stereotypes, Carnivore Confusion, and What Measure Is A Non Human. See also Ugly Cute, Bug War, Reptiles Are Abhorrent, and Always Chaotic Evil. Contrast Dark Is Not Evil, Light Is Not Good, Tastes Like Diabetes and Grotesque Cute. This trope also applies to humans and is often the deciding factor of who gets to be the Face Of The Band. This trope is pervasive enough that the Killer Rabbit, Evil Duck, and some of the Bad Kitties exist to subvert it.

Incidentally, we are very happy to report that since this Trope was launched, it turns out that many Tropers have a soft-spot for unpopular creatures. Just, please, if you need to vent, go to our It Just Bugs Me page. We really need to cut down the natter.

Examples:

    open/close all folders 

     Anime and Manga  

     Film  

     Literature  

     Live Action TV  

     New Media  

     Tabletop Games  

     Toys  

     Video Games  

     Web Comics  

     Web Original 

     Western Animation  

     Real Life  


What Measure Is A Non HumanWhat Measure Is An IndexWhat Measure Is A Me
Beauty Equals GoodnessPersonal Appearance TropesBeauty Inversion
What Measure Is A Non HumanAnimal TropesUgly Cute
What Kind Of Lame Power Is Heart AnywayAnimated TropeWhere Did They Get Lasers