Naturally, fanfic authors have their own ideas about what various characters (both original characters and pre-established ones) should look and/or sound like, specifically for rewrites of films and TV shows:
Fan works with their own page:
- iCarly's Father
and its sequels, a Nick Verse fanfic series which is mainly a crossover between iCarly and Victorious, has the hypothetical casting of Joe Flanigan as the adult Steven Shay, and Ariana Grande with her natural brunette hair colour as Taylor Dorfman in flashbacks set during her and Col Shay's romance during high school. The hypothetical resemblance between Taylor and Cat Valentine (Ariana's redhaired character on Victorious) is brought up when Steven meets Cat for the first time. - The Harmon Verse: Its Original Characters are played by real-life actors and actresses, mostly from either talent shows or from Broadway productions.
- In A Girl and Her Bike, Word of God states that Bumblebee is voiced by Garret Hunter, the same voice actor as Adam Taurus. This was done largely with the intent of playing the two up as foils to each other.
- The Doom Slayer in Remnant Inferis: DOOM is stated by Word of God in the author's notes of Chapter 7 to be voiced by Brian Bloom and his child-self is voiced by Maile Flanagan, as stated in the Chapter 12 author's notes.
- In Child of the Storm has a lot of this, with the author at one point writing down an extensive cast list - though he has admitted that his ideas change from time to time, and it's very hard to pin down someone just right.
- Harry, and by extension Thor's James Potter form, is fancast as Tom Welling. The Casting Gag inherent in this is an early hint at the link between Krypton and Earth, though Word of God has noted that Harry is changing to resemble his mother more as he ages, suggesting that he's growing into something closer to Henry Cavill or Pierce Brosnan.
- Wanda Maximoff - Rachel Weisz
- Doctor Strange - Viggo Mortensen (for lack of better ideas, according to Word of God.)
- Gravemoss - Cillian Murphy
- Warren Worthington III – Orlando Bloom
- Michael Carpenter – Nathan Fillion
- Mister Sinister – Benedict Cumberbatch
- Sean Cassidy - Sam Heughan
- Carol Danvers - Elisha Cuthbert/Katheryn Winnick
- Diana Herculeis - Bridget Regan
- Jean-Paul Beaubier - Gaspard Ulliel
- Uhtred Ullrson - Sean Bean (young)
- Sharon Carter - Rachel Nichols
- Alison Carter/O'Neill - Grace Kelly
- Lily Potter a.k.a. the White Phoenix of the Crown - Bryce Dallas Howard/Hannah Emily Anderson
- Harry Dresden - Clint Eastwood
- Lt. Karrin Murphy - Kristen Bell
- Thomas Raith - Ian Somerhalder
- Bruce Wayne - Christian Bale
- Jean Grey and Maddie Pryor/Rachel Grey - Jaime Ray Newman/Jane Fonda
- Victor Von Doom - Mark Strong (later indicated to be Vincent Cassel)
- Nicodemus Archleone - Jeremy Irons
- Remy LeBeau/ Scott Summers - Ben Barnes
- Death of the Endless - Gemma Arterton
- Dracula - Charles Dance
- In the author's notes of My Immortal, Tara Gilesbie suggested that Gerard Way (!) should play Draco in the next Harry Potter film.
- The Wattpad posting of The First Saniwa boasts a hypothetical live-action cast rather than voice cast, which features most of the characters as played by actors portraying them in the games' official live-action adaptations (except Higekiri who's supposed to be played by Masaki Okada as opposed to the official Hiroki Miura who already plays Hiromasa). The casting for Original Characters and canon characters who haven't appeared in live action is as follows:
- Shun Oguri as Minamoto no Yorimitsu
- Seishirō Katō as Monjumaru/young Yorimitsu
- Shūji Hayashi as Minamoto no Yorichika
- Fuku Suzuki as Fugenmaru/young Yorichika
- Hiroshi Abe as Minamoto no Mitsunaka
- Tatsuya Isaka as Shishiō
- Tsuyoshi Dōmoto as Nansen Ichimonji
- Eisuke Tsuda as Juzumaru Tsunetsugu
- Ryūnosuke Kamiki as Onigiri
- Harumi Inoue as Hōōka
- Nao Nagasawa as Aoandon
- Masataka Kubota as Susabi
- Hiroko Kasahara as Miketsu
- Shima Iwashita as Kuzunoha
- Mitsuru Karahashi as Abe no Yasuna
- Tatsuomi Hamada as Hōchō Tōshirō
- Kōhei Murakami (b. 1986) as Mōri Tōshirō
- Pretty Cure Perfume Preppy has both a Japanese and English language hypothetical voice cast list.
- Japanese:
- Asumi Nakata as Chloe Auriville/Cure Rosa.
- Asami Shimoda as Chiara Auriville/Cure Vanilla.
- Satsuki Yukino as Mayonaka Ayameko/Cure Jasmine.
- Natsuko Kuwatani as Mitsukawa Hanae/Cure Tangerine.
- Rio Natsuki as Torino Ikuko/Cure Cardamomo.
- Tomoko Kaneda as Lavvie.
- Rie Iwatsubo as Lotus.
- Yusuke Tezuka as Pittan/Daidai Pitari.
- Yuriko Yamaguchi as Ashley McFly/Leather Ashes.
- Akio Ōtsuka as Stankou.
- Unshō Ishizuka as Francheese.
- Takeshi Aono as Gaabeiten.
- Bin Shimada as Shashincame.
- Miyoko Aso as Komorah.
- Chiemi Chiba as Nekoshippo Lori/Lapinyuu.
- Toshiko Fujita as Romona McFly/Raflesina.
- English:
- Sherry Lynn as Chloe Auriville/Cure Rosa.
- Luci Christian as Chiara Auriville/Cure Vanilla.
- Sandy Fox as Mayonaka Ayameko/Cure Jasmine.
- Bridget Hoffman as Mitsukawa Hanae/Cure Tangerine.
- Philece Sampler as Torino Ikuko/Cure Cardamomo.
- Tony Oliver as Lavvie.
- Rebecca Forstadt as Lotus.
- Steve Blum as Pittan/Daidai Pitari.
- Jamie Marchi as Ashley McFly/Leather Ashes.
- Lex Lang as Stankou.
- Kirk Thornton as Francheese.
- Richard Epcar as Gaabeiten.
- Mark Hamill as Shashincame.
- Catherine Battistone as Komorah.
- Tress MacNeille as Nekoshippo Lori/Lapinyuu.
- Mary Elizabeth McGlynn as Romona McFly/Raflesina.
- Japanese:
- The Arrow fic Guardians of Star City: Season 1 features a cast list the author is personally picturing, but he encourages readers to stick the show's actors if they so desire. Most of the characters are played by the same actors in they are in the show, the changes (explanations for why such changes were made are provided) are:
- Charlie Hunnam as Oliver Queen/Green Arrow
- Nicole Kidman as Dinah Drake Lance/Black Canary I
- Jim Caviezel as Ted Grant/Wildcat
- Stephen Amell as Tommy Merlyn
- Kyle MacLachlan as Dr. Anthony Ivo
- Michael Chiklis as Daniel Brickwell
- Andrew Scott as Hadrian Walcott/The Huntsman, an Original Character.
- Calvin & Hobbes: The Series did this, playing on its status as a fake Calvin and Hobbes TV show. The central cast includes:
- Pamela Segal as Calvin
- Tom Hanks as Hobbes
- Ryan Stiles as Socrates
- Andrew Lawrence as Andy
- Colin Mochrie as Sherman
- Norman Lovett as the MTM
- letmetellyouaboutmyfeels' MCU Rewrites features this cast list for Marvel characters who have not yet appeared in the Marvel Cinematic Universe:
- Shun Oguri as Gorgon
- Isla Fisher as Sinthea "Sin" Schmidt
- Zach McGowan as Grim Reaper
- Milla Jovovich as Viper/Madame Hydra
- Helen Mirren as Madame B
- Skyhold Academy Yearbook has a full live-action cast, covering many of the characters who have appeared thus far. Unlike in the source material, everyone in the fic universe is human, so finding perfect matches was a challenge. Among others, the cast includes Ewan McGregor as Alistair, Anne Hathaway as Marian Hawke, Michael Hurst as Varric, and Morena Baccarin as Cassandra.
- Tales of the Undiscovered Swords suggests voice actors for every of its Original Characters at the end of each entry.
- Himetsuru Ichimonji – Akira Ishida, Takahiro Sakurai or Koji Yusa
- Nikkō Ichimonji – Yoshimasa Hosoya, Hiroki Takahashi, Takehito Koyasu or Daisuke Hirakawa
- Kitsunegasaki – Yoshitsugu Matsuoka, Masakazu Morita or KENN
- Ishida Sadamune – Mamoru Miyano, Miyu Irino or Takuma Terashima
- Kiriha Sadamune – Shouta Aoi, Yūto Uemura or Marina Inoue
- Sasanoyuki – Nobutoshi Canna, Ryōtarō Okiayu or Masaya Onosaka
- The One With The Angelic Face- a Buffy the Vampire Slayer AU where the curse that restored Angelus's soul also turned him into a woman- the female Angel, now known as 'Angela', has been envisioned by the author as Gina Gershon.
- Infinity Crisis adds the following actors to the Marvel Cinematic Universe and the DC Extended Universe in its subsequent spin-offs;
- Angie Harmon as Jennifer Walters.
- Bryan Cranston as Otto Octavius
- Hugh Laurie as Mr. Sinister
- Mark Strong as The Leader
- John Krasinski as Mr. Fantastic.
- Emilia Clarke as the Invisible Woman
- Armie Hammer as the Thing
- Celestial Navigation has Deadpool noting a "recast" to John Cena.
- Sam Claflin as the Human Torch.
- Donnie Yen as the Mandarin.
- Liam Neeson as the High Evolutionary.
- Charlize Theron as the Enchantress
- Angelina Jolie as Circe
- Liam Hemsworth as Balder
- Jennifer Garner as Earth 51 Catwoman.
- Oded Fehr is the Earth 51 Ra's al Guhl
- Priyanka Chopra is Talia.
- Gamma Relations:
- Angie Harmon as Jennifer Walters.
- Bryan Cranston as Otto Octavius
- Hugh Laurie as Mr. Sinister
- Mark Strong as The Leader
- Taking Flight (And Fights):
- John Krasinski as Mr. Fantastic.
- Emilia Clarke as the Invisible Woman
- Armie Hammer as the Thing
- Sam Claflin as the Human Torch.
- Powers and Marvels:
- Donnie Yen as the Mandarin.
- Liam Neeson as the High Evolutionary.
- Sins, Sirens and Strife:
- Charlize Theron as the Enchantress
- Angelina Jolie as Circe
- Liam Hemsworth as Balder
- Jennifer Garner as Earth-51 Catwoman.
- Counterpart Conferences
- Oded Fehr is the Earth-51 Ra's al Ghul
- Priyanka Chopra is Talia.
- In Hand and Foot
- Eden Sher is Doreen Green/Squirrel Girl.
- Cary-Hiroyuki Tagawa is Fu Manchu.
- Justice Like Lightning
- Matthew McConaughey is Norman Osborn
- Evan Rachel Wood is Moeteorite/Moonstone
- Jharrel Jerome is Goliath
- Josh Hutcherson is MACH-1
- Victoria Justice is Songbird
- Andrew Scott is Techno
- Brothers of Thunder (a gender-inverted version of the Avengers);
- Sandra Bullock is Iron Maiden
- Alison Brie is Captain America
- Katheryn Winnick is Thora
- Jennifer Lawrence is Hawkeye
- Chris Pine is Black Spider
- Rachel Weisz is the Hulk
- Evanna Lynch is Quicksilver
- Daniel Radcliffe is the Scarlet Warlock
- Zac Efron is Captain Marvel
- Kerry Washington is Nicola Fury
- Rooney Mara is Lokia
- Women of Wonder;
- Alexandra Daddario as Zatanna Zatarra
- Glimpses
- John Cho is Black Owl
- Samara Weaving is Doctor Frost
- Scott Evans is Jupiter, Master Magician
- Ian Anthony Dale is Amphibian
- Rosa Salazar is Mickey Martinez/American Crusader II
- Distant Cousins
- Dove Cameron as Gwen Stacy/Ghost Spider
- Celestial Navigation:
- Alan Ritchson is Hercules
- Luke Evans is Namor
- Empath: The Luckiest Smurf lists as its imagined voice actors (on Smurfs Fanon Wiki):
- Robert Duncan McNeill as Empath
- Ethan Phillips as Papa Smurf
- Hynden Walch as Smurfette
- Tim Russ as Polaris Psyche
- Fred Armisen as Brainy
- Jack McBrayer as Clumsy
- Thomas Wilson as Greedy
- Max Cassella as Jokey
- Mark Meer as Vanity
- Steve Blum as Grouchy
- Greg Cipes as Nabby
- Alan Cumming as Duncan McSmurf
- Hank Azaria as Gargamel
- Frank Welker as Azrael
- Starting in Super Sentai vs. Power Rangers II, the writer Arcadiarika would cast various original characters and canon Power Rangers or Super Sentai characters with different actors or other celebrities. Power Rangers Clockwork continues the trend, with a few wrestlers added to the mix. In order of appearance, the characters and their imagined actors (with the canon characters gaining in-universe explanations for the recast) are:
- Tim Phillipps as Tim Langdon/Go-Buster Ranger Red
- John Mark Loudermilk from Power Rangers Megaforce as Will Aston/Black Overdrive Ranger
- Lauren Landa as Neo-Vypra in Super Sentai vs. Power Rangers III and Professor Hannah Harrison starting in Super Sentai vs. Power Rangers 3.5
- Markiplier as Neo-Kiros
- Christopher Randolph as Dezumozorlya in Super Sentai vs. Power Rangers III and Dr. Edward Payne/Black Dino Thunder Ranger starting in Super Sentai vs. Power Rangers 3.5
- Doug Cockle as Gerald Rivera/Red Lightspeed Ranger II
- Sarah Anne Williams as Serena Watson/Blue Mystic Ranger
- Erin Cahill as Jennifer Fleight/Pink Time Force Ranger
- Elias Toufexis as Eli Fleight/Green SPD Ranger
- Kevin T. Collins as Brandon LaChance
- Drew Gulak as Ari!Carter Grayson/Red Lightspeed Ranger
- Heather Masters as Brynja Velothi
- Robin Atkin Downes as Asgaut Velothi
- Buddy Murphy as Aricin Velothi
- Once Upon a Studio: Version 2.0 is as hypothetical extended cut of Disney's centenary short in which several previously absent voice actors return to voice their respective characters, and to fill in for substitutes cast exclusively for the existing cut:
- Most of the 48 voice actors from the existing short would once again return to reprise their characters, including Jodi Benson as Ariel, Paige O'Hara as Belle, Nathan Lane as Timon, Jeremy Irons as Scar, Kristen Bell as Anna, Idina Menzel as Elsa, Dwayne Johnson as Maui and Kelly Marie Tran as Raya. Tom Hulce would also return as Quasimodo. The archival outtakes of Robin Williams as the Genie would also be retained.
- Prince Charming is reprised by Chris Daniel Barnes, who has been his main voice actor since 2001; instead of Keith Ferguson who did Charming's one line in the existing version of the short. This may be a result of Charming's role being increased considerably. Barnes also reprises his role as Prince Eric; a major case of Acting for Two.
- Likewise, Snow White is reprised by Katie Von Till, who has been her main voice actress since 2010, instead of Natalie Babbitt Taylor who did the role in the original short.
- Jiminy Cricket would be voiced by his current voice actor Joe Ochman, instead of an archival recording of Cliff Edwards, due to his solo line occuring earlier on in the rousing rendition of "When You Wish Upon a Star"
- Jennifer Hale remains as Cinderella's voice, and Mandy Moore as Rapunzel's. Their role is expanded considerably as they both start up up the enhanced rendition of "When You Wish Upon a Star", with Raps starting the song off on her guitar, and Cinderella singing the opening lines, before handing over to Belle and the Beast. Hale's singing voice as Cinderella is surprisingly beautiful, which makes her a perfect fit to start; and could make this her finest hour as Cinders if it was ever realized. Moore also gets to start up the final verse as Rapunzel alongside Eugene, Ariel, Eric, Aladdin and Jasmine, while also singing a duet with Eugene near the end.
- Zachary Levi is back as well, due to Eugene's increased role.
- Tony Goldwyn and Minnie Driver also return as the voices of Tarzan and Jane.
- Kate Higgins and Linda Larkin also return as Aurora and Jasmine, respectively, with Brad Kane and Lea Salonga reprising Aladdin and Jasmine's singing voices.
- Ernie Sabella also returns as Pumbaa, whose voice was noticeably absent in the original.
- Temuera Morrison also returns in another rare appearance as Moana's father, Chief Tui; which would be his first time reprising the role since the original Moana in 2016. Morrison would also provide Tui's singing voice, instead of Christopher Jackson.
- Interestingly enough, Morrison would be the third major Star Wars alumni returning; the other two being Jennifer Hale and Kelly Marie Tran.
- Barbara Dirickson is also present as Fairy Godmother's voice.
- In Game of Throne: The Young Stag, the author envisioned live action actors to portray several characters.
- On the FANDOM wiki for Tokimeki PokéLive! and TwinBee, the author has listed some VAs/Seiyuu for characters on their wiki pages. Some examples include:
- Mimori Suzuko as the Japanese voice for Hilda White and Cassandra Lee Morris as her English voice.
- Kate Higgins as the English voice for Original Character Yoko Catherine Osaka White.
- While Kaori Maeda is still Shizuku Kutashimo Osaka's Japanese voice, Stephanie Sheh is her English voice.
- Patrick Seitz as the English voice for Dr. Ivo "Eggman" Robotnik in "The Ideal Hero" story arc, though Mike Pollock still voices him otherwise.
- Pokémon Reset Bloodlines: The writer Crossoverpairinglover and the readers have voiced their opinions on "casting" multiple times, through author's notes and polling, respectively. These include:
- Todd Haberkorn as Ash.
- Michelle Ruff as Misty.
- Crispin Freeman as Red.
- Tara Strong as Yellow.
- Yuri Lowenthal as Gary.
- Stephanie Sheh as the Nurse Joys.
- Julie Ann Taylor as Belladonna.
- Universe Falls:
- MiniJenn has a personal fantasy casting list for the fusions of Steven, Connie, and the Mystery Twins:
- Eden Sher (Star Butterfly from Star vs. the Forces of Evil) or Sarah Stiles (Spinel from Steven Universe: The Movie) as Maven (Mabel+Steven)
- Jeremy Shada (Finn from Adventure Time, Lance from Voltron: Legendary Defender) as Stepper (Dipper+Steven)
- Allyn Rachel (Bee from Bee and Puppycat) as Dipevebel (Steven+Dipper+Mabel).
- Mae Whitman (Katara from Avatar: The Last Airbender, April O'Neil from Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles (2012)) as Mabonnven (Steven+Mabel+Connie).
- Bex Taylor-Klaus (Pidge from Voltron: Legendary Defender) as Convenper (Connie+Steven+Dipper)
- Olivia Olsen (Marceline from Adventure Time) as Stonipbel (Steven+Connie+Dipper+Mabel)
- Other casting suggestions:
- Cree Summer as Zoom, the speed demon from "Gravity Falls Drift".
- Reshma Shetty (Elodie from OK K.O.! Let's Be Heroes, Queen Angella from She-Ra and the Princesses of Power) as Amber, a Gem OC to be introduced in UF2.
- Elizabeth Maxwell (Urbosa from The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild) as Jheselbraum the Unswerving, the oracle from Gravity Falls: Journal 3.
- MiniJenn has a personal fantasy casting list for the fusions of Steven, Connie, and the Mystery Twins:
- In My Ridonculous Race, the OC introduction chapter lists their voice actors as the following:
- Fabian = Demetri Martin
- Jordan = Sarah Natochenny
- Annie = Melissa Fahn
- Leo = Michael Sinterniklaas
- June = Jennifer Hale
- Quince = Michael B. Jordan
- Sam = Samuel Vincent
- May = Janice Kawaye
- Syd = Yuri Lowenthal
- Dani = Maya Rudolph
- Aaron = Ian Sinclair
- Yves = Brenda Song
- Gabriella = Colleen Clinkenbeard
- Nekota = Johnny Yong Bosch
- The Geeky Zoologist's reimagining of Jurassic World features the following casting list for a part of the story's original characters:
- Lionnel Astier as Gilbert Brunet
- Angela Sarafyan as Nataliya Darbinian
- Kristofer Hivju as Leif Drekanson
- Claudia Black as Erin Laurence
- Christine Adams as Patience Bellamy
- Graham McTavish as Duncan Glenmore
- Miguel Izaguirre as Julio Velasquez
- Caity Lotz as Tamara Durant
- George Blagden as Gareth Turner
- Zhu Zhu as Mei Tian
- Erica Cerra as Selma Forrester
- Geoff Gustafson as Niall Forrester
- Iain Glen as Jonas Roth
- Joe Morton as Lambert Ross
- Zach McGowan as Gregor Sherman
- Gerardo Taracena as Paco Cortès
- Terry Chen as Kevin Leng
- Guillaume Delaunay as Nolan Olsen
- Erik Knudsen as Ivan Preston
- Jessica Walter as Susan Lynton
- Orlando Jones as Alistair Iger
- Tom McBeath as Dominick Silverman
- Qianyuan Wang as Zhuge Yu
- Alban Lenoir as Vincent Chapuy
- Robert Picardo as Arthur Butler
- Óscar Jaenada as Jaime Aguilera
- Thomas Kretschmann as Helmut Störmer
- Eivør Pálsdóttir as a singing grey guard
- Some characters that don't appear in the story but who had an important role in the lore of this alternate continuity had benefited of this.
- Mark Addy as Arnold Mountbatten, the first park director of Jurassic World and Claire Dearing's predecessor.
- Luke Evans as Bleidd Pennant, the founder of the Grey Guard.
- Fooly Falls: Ride on Shooting Star: The author's notes at the end of chapter 1 gives this to the nine major original characters, along with some notable roles he had in mind.
- Stephanie Sheh: Gwen (voice of Mamini Samejima and Orihime Inoue)
- Barbara Goodson: Tyrone (voice of Naoto Nandaba and Rita Repulsa)
- Justin Briner: Arnold (voice of Izuku Midoriya and Cloud Strife)
- Doug Erholtz: Ian (voice of Squall Leonhart and Jean Pierre Polnareff)
- Barbara Dunkelman: Leia (voice of Yang Xiao Long)
- Danny Pudi: Juan (voice of Huey Duck and Brainy Smurf)
- Bobby Moynihan: Jorge (voice of Louie Duck and Panda)
- Monica Rial: Imelda (voice of Tsuyu Asui, Bulma Briefs and Tsubaki Nakatsukasa)
- Grey DeLisle: Abby (voice of Lily Loud)
- An update released after chapter 2 revealed Derek Stephen Prince (voice of Uryu Ishida, Impmon, Vexen & Iggy) as Ezra Chiu.
- Little Secrets:
- Jodelle Ferland as young Kala and Rose Byrne as teenage/adult Kala
- Tom Welling as teenage/adult Jason
- Erica Durance as Elise Thorne
- Kristin Kreuk as Giselle Davenport
- Christine Taylor as Lucy Lane
- Boris Kodjoe as Ron Troupe
- Code Prime
- The author has said that he imagines Michael Sinterniklaas as the voice for Rai.
- The author's choices for voice actors for Ironhide, Thundercracker and Skywarp respectively would be Keith Szarabajka, Graham McTavish, and Richard Epcar, who voiced them in Transformers: War for Cybertron.
- Infinity Train: Blossoming Trail: Author notes reveal that she would like Billy Bob Thompson to be the voice actor for Lexi (Because Lexi is an expy of Specter and Billy Bob Thompson voices Specter in the dub.)
- Diary of an Analog has the heavily alluded to Darkdramon as being cast with David Kaye in mind, as mentioned at the end of Chapter 9 when Darkdramon's dialogue is shown for the first time. Special mention going to the voice he uses for Hardshell, and the Actor Allusion present with a drawn out, hammy "Yesss" not being there simply for the sake of a reference to Beast Wars Megatron, but also because Hardshell himself made the exact same Actor Allusion in his debut episode.
- A Boy, a Girl and a Dog: The Leithian Script: At the beginning of the three first acts (and in the course of the fourth one), the author provides a cast list for the main character based on her favorite performances, encouraging readers to supply their own actors:
- Christian Bale as Beren Barahirion (appearing courtesy Treasure Island, Little Women)
- Claudia Black as Lúthien Tinúviel (appearing courtesy Farscape)
- Jeremy Irons as Elu thingol (appearing courtesy Brideshead Revisited)
- Emma Thompson as Melian the Maia (appearing courtesy Sense & Sensibility)
- Ronald Colman as Mablung (appearing courtesy The Prisoner of Zenda)
- David Niven as Belen Cuthalion (appearing courtesy The Prisoner of Zenda)
- Lani John Tupu as Daeron (appearing courtesy Farscape)
- Kenneth Branagh as Finrod Felagund (appearing courtesy Henry V)
- Hugh Jackman as Finrod's Captain (appearing courtesy Kate & Leopold)
- Alan Rickman as Edrahil (appearing courtesy Sense and Sensibility)
- James Marsters as Curufin and Celegorm (courtesy Mutant Enemy)
- Gelsey Kirkland as Finduilas (appearing courtesy the Baryshnikov Nutcracker telecast)
- Hugh Grant as Orodreth (appearing courtesy Sense and Sensibility)
- Celebrimbor played by Alexis Denisof (appearing courtesy Mutant Enemy)
- Ioan Gruffudd as Gwindor (appearing courtesy A&E's Horatio Hornblower series)
