Nevermind, I actually found the time both for that trope and for Me Too!. If someone wants to use the former wicks ... I have saved it in the history of Me Too!.
Going back to the Sandbox.Orwellian Rewrite, if it's already covered by Internal Retcon and Cosmic Retcon perhaps we ought to simply move examples to these tropes?
Also still wondering whether to launch Sandbox.Internet Jerk (optionally, we can merge GIFT later into the trope) and whether anyone wants to make a Mediator trope.
Edited by SeptimusHeap on Apr 2nd 2021 at 1:56:51 PM
"For a successful technology, reality must take precedence over public relations, for Nature cannot be fooled." - Richard FeynmanHmm... Actually, reading through Internal Retcon, I'm inclined to agree that it seems to be pretty much the same as Orwellian Rewrite.
Cosmic Retcon, I think, is a different thing: it seems to be describing an actual change to the canon of the work, just implemented internally, where Internal Retcon is about changing internal records of what happened. In the former, in-universe records might still reflect the original canon, theoretically, while in the latter, canon and the narrative might belie the new records.
My Games & WritingHm. The 1984 example is even the page quote for Internal Retcon. Maybe expand the "authority figure" paragraph to cover examples in the sandbox not about authority figures.
One could make the argument that there's a different narrative impact to a ruler exerting their power to explicitly rewrite history than to a scholar doing the same in secret.
But is that enough of a difference that it justifies separate tropes? I'm not sure.
Come to that, it might not even be important: the two different cases might be modelled as a single "rewriting history" trope combined with two separate tropes covering the positions and authority of the characters.
My Games & WritingCombining would solve the issue of examples of either trope being vague about whether it was authority who performed the purge/rewrite, or if the scholars who did it were actually under orders from authority, or if those responsible were the winners who wanted to glorify themselves... (or even if they were writing wishful alternate history fiction and theirs was the only record that survived?)
Well, I am seeing some support for using Internal Retcon here. I agree that "authority figure or not" isn't a trope distinction; the scholar has to have the credibility to successfully pull it off - otherwise they'll just be dismissed as a crank - and that's as good as power.
So I am thinking we might be ready to go with Internal Retcon and Cosmic Retcon as items on an Orwellian Editor disambiguation (plus Forum Speak).
That only leaves Mediator and Sandbox.Internet Jerk. I am inclined to put the former in the TLP Salvage Yard and launch the latter, followed by a TRS to merge GIFT into it as Sandbox.GIFT Wicks says that many links are just "jerk on the Internet".
"For a successful technology, reality must take precedence over public relations, for Nature cannot be fooled." - Richard FeynmanAll of that sounds good to me! ^_^
My Games & WritingSounds good.
she/her | TRS needs your help! | Contributor of Trope ReportOrwellian Retcon is done, but it's late evening here so punting the other tropes to tomorrow.
"For a successful technology, reality must take precedence over public relations, for Nature cannot be fooled." - Richard FeynmanPatiently awaiting the release of Paper Luigi and the Marvelous Compass.
Internet Tough Guy and Mediator are also done. Writing up new TRS for GIFT and Wiki Tropes as we speak, but I'll close this as "done" after I am finished typing this.
For posterity, the examples of Mediator are here:
Crown Description:
What would be the best way to fix the page?
OK, these Retcon tropes are being a little too many. Perhaps we only need Internal Retcon which already involves the Orwellian aspect.
Also, I see that I won't have much time for wick-moving so someone will have to do the Forum Pecking Order move to Useful Notes.
"For a successful technology, reality must take precedence over public relations, for Nature cannot be fooled." - Richard Feynman