Bait the Dog
"I wanted to lull the audience into a false sense of security with who this character was. We had seen him in the films and the literature post-incarceration where the world knows exactly who he is and what he is and what he's capable of. He had no motivation to hide any of it, so I wanted to really get the audience into Hannibal's corner as a likeable character. Then when he does terrible things, you've already fallen in love with him and like him as a character. So you have to then juxtapose what you've just seen against what you've experienced in the previous episodes. But the first time he smashed Alana Bloom's head against the wall, it's startling. It's like, 'Oh, yeah. We're watching Hannibal. He's that guy.'"You're watching a movie or something, and there's some character named Bob who may or may not be rumoured to be kind of evil, but you don't know for sure. All you know is what he's doing right this minute is kind of endearing from an audience perspective. He's fun, he's cool. Quirky, maybe, but in a good way. At this rate, he'll be a runaway favourite with the fans. Yeah, he's okay. We like him. He's... Wait, what is he doing now? Why has he cornered Tropey in the old mill? What's with the bicycle pump, oven mitts and three pounds of feathers? ...oh. Oh, no. Oh God, not the dog! Not the dog!! Nooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo! Bob, you horrible bastard! How could you do such a thing?! I can't believe I used to think you were cool! Did the cunning writers set you up to sort of like the villain just so it would be even more jarring when you realized he was, well, evil? That's this trope. Kind of a cross between Pet the Dog and Kick the Dog, but the Pet the Dog action needn't be nice — any combination of cool, badass and funny works just as well, as long as it's all calculated by the writer to get you on this character's side. Kind of a bait-and-switch technique for viewer sympathy. Distinct from Face-Heel Turn because the character was always this much of a psycho, but the audience just hadn't seen it yet, though they may have heard that they did something bad offscreen. It's generally always done purely to accentuate a Kick the Dog moment—you see a bit of personal quirkiness or interesting backstory that has you liking this character, that has you 'on their side', and then they do something really really nasty, and as a viewer you feel worse because you're guilty by association. This is anything that makes you squeal, 'But we liked him!' Compare/contrast the other Tropey the Wonder Dog tropes, especially Pet the Dog and Kick the Dog. If it's the series itself that seems relatively harmless until it happens, there may be a Dead Star Walking indicating that Anyone Can Die. Can induce Mood Whiplash. Also compare and contrast with Villainy Discretion Shot; oftentimes the only line separating this trope from that one is that we see the dog kicking moment in gory detail. A Bait the Dog moment can subvert an Establishing Character Moment, or it might show that the character is more complex than first apparent. Often a Bitch in Sheep's Clothing, ironically, or perhaps fittingly enough. Also see Evil All Along and Faux Affably Evil. Compare Devil in Plain Sight, where the character is blatantly evil but nonetheless fools most of the other characters. This is ultimately a Betrayal Trope (of audience expectations if not other characters in-universe), so there will be spoilers. Sensitive details are spoiler-tagged, but many names are not.
open/close all folders
Anime and Manga
- Nena Trinity from Mobile Suit Gundam 00. She was introduced as cute, quirky (she kissed the protagonist upon first meeting him) and seemed like a Genki Girl caught in a bad situation but trying to smile to her two older brothers and herself (and further supported that she has the voice of Rie Kugimiya, a popular voice actress known for heroic Tsundere loli roles, which also makes people think she's going to be great). Then, in the very next episode when flying over a civilian wedding, says, "How dare you have fun while I'm working! You should just die." and then promptly sends a missile their way. Twice. All the attendants but a young girl are killed, and even that poor kid loses one of her hands and her mind. And then, when asked by her teammates (and brothers) why she did it, laughs and says, "Oops! I guess I pushed the wrong button!". She's a Cute and Psycho Tyke Bomb, if you don't get what this scene totally says.
- Johan Liebert of Monster indulges in this trope on more than one occasion. He's hardly ever shown as anything other than an awful psychopath who enjoys murdering people for little more than shits and giggles. However, during the university arc, we see him lovingly playing with children, and helping an old man and his illegitimate son reunite for the first time. However, this is quickly subverted when we see that he manipulated said children into playing a game by which they would attempt to balance themselves on the sides of rooftops, whereby many children fell to their deaths, and that he merely brought the father and son together so that it would be easier to kill them both (he fails on the second part, but still). He also gives money to a sickly homeless woman... because he can tell she's a heroin addict, and would almost certainly spend the money to buy more.
- Occurs at least twice in the Elfen Lied manga.
- The first one involves a man who is first introduced as a Chivalrous Pervert with an odd sense of humor, then turns out to be a rapist assassin with a gun that fires spiked balls dosed in extremely painful toxins.
- A chapter ending introduces a few techs at the Diclonius research facility, along with their boss, a quirky, joking bishonen with a fondness for candy sticks. All is well and good... until a Reveal Shot reveals that they're working, joking and laughing in an office with a window showing an endless train of mutilated and uncensored Diclonii torsos for that radar system rattling past.
- In the first episode of Code Geass, Prince Clovis is introduced giving a powerful speech condemning an act of terrorism by the Japanese resistance which seems pretty conciliatory, as he underscores how loyal Japanese are equal citizens of Britannia. Then a moment later, he is shown going back to socialize at a party, demonstrating that all of that pathos was a put-on. By the end of the episode, he shows his True Colors as a neurotic nutjob, by despairing due to C.C's escape to the point of ordering a murderous pogrom on the Japanese ghetto to cover it up. Unlike many of these examples though, Karma catches up with him quickly so he doesn't make it very long in the series.
- Clovis's older brother, Prince Schneizel, was kind of the same. He was introduced as a seemingly nice guy who many fans speculated was a heroic Anti-Villain in contrast to Lelouch, a ruthless Anti-Hero. Then, he starts manipulating the mentally unbalanced TV Genius Nina into building a nuclear weapon, uses a critical momentary absence of Lelouch to turn the Black Knights against said leader, and eventually reveals his plan to nuke millions of people and declare himself God. And using his half-sister Nunnally, also very unstable at the moment, to such an end. Of course, there was at least one sign prior to this: his smile as the Avalon prepared to nuke both Suzaku and a pinned-down Zero in the first season.
- In Fullmetal Alchemist; While we see fairly early on that the Amestrian military is a fairly ruthless and potentially dodgy organization, its leader, Fuhrer President Bradley, presents himself (despite his title and kickass fighting skills) as a more-or-less benign individual who does what he thinks is best for his country and his beloved family. He even offers to help our heroes fight the conspiracy inside the military. Then it's revealed that he's a homunculus and part of the aforementioned conspiracy, not to mention the one who ordered the Ishval civil war and subsequent genocide campaign. Despite this, he's among the most human (not necessarily sympathetic) of the homunculi and it seems that his love for his wife, in the manga at any rate, is genuine.
- To add to that, Bradley is shown to be shaking during Hughes' funeral, one of the major Tear Jerkers of the series. When Mustang brings this event up, it is revealed that he was in fact shaking with anger at the noise that Hughes' daughter Elicia was causing, as she cried over her father being buried.
- Amazingly, the series manages to one-up this. Selim Bradley is a cute little kid who looks up to his father, studies hard so he help the country when he grows up and fanboys other characters with big sparkly eyes. Which makes it all the more horrifying when the reader learns that not only is he a homunculus, but the oldest of the second-generation homunculi and arguably the most powerful and evil. His actual body is a living shadow that tore a group of Briggs soldiers to pieces and left the survivors so traumatized that they were almost insane! That cute little boy form is more like a shell that he moves within, animating with his shadows. . Worst of all, his poor mother has no idea that [[spoiler:her family are evil homonculi (although they both seem to care about her in their own ways).
- Shou Tucker initially appears to be a kindly state alchemist with a loving daughter Nina and her equally adorable dog Alexander, who the Elric Brothers eventually end up meeting. Even when it turns out that his wife left him, it could be argued that he had learned from his mistakes since then and that he was still a good father even if he wasn't a good husband. Then it turns out that his wife hadn't actually left him. Shou Tucker had condemned the rest of her life to one of pain and suffering after he transformed her into a Half-Human Hybrid. And as if that wasn't enough, he later does the same thing to Nina and Alexander. Notably, he is the only character in the franchise that doesn't go to Heaven...instead, he goes to Hell.
- In One Piece, Marshall D. Teach aka Blackbeard, our story's likely true Big Bad first started out as a rather jolly Boisterous Bruiser and at least Affably Evil type, always encouraging Luffy to get stronger, caring for his crewmates, etc. Then fast-forward to the Maineford Arc, where he mocks Whitebeard, feigns sympathy with him, then gleefully and brutally murders the old man who he once called father for well over 20 years plus with his crewmates, then steals his Devil's Fruit, revealing himself to be always just a power-hungry megalomaniac. And it's likely this won't be the first thing he does like this, before and after either.
- See also, Eustace Kid, at first presented as being disgusted with the World Government Slave Auctions and setting himself up as a worthy opponent to Luffy and Trafalgar Law. Roughly a hundred chapters later he's seen crucifying pirates attempting to flee the ludicrously dangerous sea of the New World.
- Word of God is that the only reason Kid's bounty was higher than Luffy's is that Kid leaves a trail of corpses wherever he goes. When he said that he kills anybody who laughs at his dreams, he's not joking.
- While his most acts of horrific violence have been off screen, it was soon obvious that Trafalgar Law himself isn't the mellow pretty boy he acts. He sent the hearts of 100 pirates to the world government to become a Warlord of the Sea.It was later revealed that by his power, these hearts are possibly still beating and the people who lose them are still alive but now at the mercy of the one who holds their heart, who can crush it to kill them. No word on how many of the hundred victims are still alive. It's also worth noting that in his first appearance, the other Supernovas were as wary of him as they were of Kidd.
- The trope seems to have been ultimately subverted with Law, as while he can be terrifying to deal with, he turned out to be a Well-Intentioned Extremist who was simply doing all he could to take down Donflamingo, who killed Law's savior and father figure Corazon and instead became an Honorary True Companion of the Straw Hats. Unlike Kid, his Hidden Depths showed a softer side.
- Completely inverted with Jinbe. When we first heard of Jinbe, being Arlong's former captain and the one who let Arlong run wild in East Blue, it seems like Oda was setting Jinbe up to be a major villain. Who would have thought that he would actually be a honorable and a decent person, become one of the Straw Hats' biggest allies but also be invited by Luffy to join the crew?
- Vice-Admiral Vergo did this to G-5. Pretended to be a kind, virtuous marine who was A Father to His Men, it turns out that he was none of those things, and was instead a mole for Dolfamingo. He mercilessly slaughtered most of his subordinates and had no qualms of sending children to be experimented on. Let's just say Smoker didn't take this betrayal very well and leave at that.
- See also, Eustace Kid, at first presented as being disgusted with the World Government Slave Auctions and setting himself up as a worthy opponent to Luffy and Trafalgar Law. Roughly a hundred chapters later he's seen crucifying pirates attempting to flee the ludicrously dangerous sea of the New World.
- Darker Than Black does this in the new season with the team of Japanese agents. While immediately established as antagonist's to Hei, this isn't really a strike against them for sympathy points, given the Grey and Gray Morality of the series. Mina is a Bad Ass fighter and provides lesbianism and Genma is highly affable and funny and seems to be a Lovable Sex Maniac. Then, in the third episode, you have them ambushing a squad of Russian soldiers. Genma hijacks a train and as he uses it to kill, you see the mangled body of the conductor next to him. Then, after Mina shows up and slaughters several more soldiers, Gemna creates a gas explosion to kill the remainder and during this whole time, finds this carnage absolutely hilarious. This is shockingly violent, even for Contractors and conveys total lack of empathy for human life. Finally, while Genma initially seems to be a Lovable Sex Maniac, he's really more like a pedophile.
- There's also the token human, Yoko. "Look at me, I'm all shy and glasses-y and Moe! A girl kissed me and I liked it!" Then boom. She DePowers Hei PAINFULLY and seems absolutely thrilled by it, like he's a guinea pig as opposed to a person. Not to mention Episode 6, when she starts pulling Scary Shiny Glasses and generally looking like Gendo Ikari was reincarnated as an early twenty-something year old girl.
- Izaya Orihara in Durarara!! is introduced acting like a nice guy and seems to be comforting a troubled girl named Rio Kamichika. Then, it turns out that he had persuaded Rio into a Suicide Pact, and he tells her that all the nice things he said was just him screwing with her, which pushes poor Rio to really attempt suicide (she survives unharmed, but no thanks to him) after he announces that he really doesn't care what she does with herself. After this scene, he is generally more comically evil, but the show has moments once in a while to remind you what a creepy, sociopathic person Izaya is.
- In Bleach, Aizen's a pretty nice guy right up until he stabs Hinamori.
- Puella Magi Madoka Magica has Kyubey. He looked innocent and overall the typical mascot pet, though with something sinister about him, until Episode 6 reveals really nasty things about him.
- Yukiteru's dad from Mirai Nikki. At first, he looked like a genuinely nice person who was just trying to help his son. Then it is revealed that he is trying to find and destroy Yukiteru's cellphone- Therefore killing him- To erase his debt.
- Though in his defense, he was not aware that destroying his son's phone would kill him.
- Sabertooth as a whole gets this in Fairy Tail. Initially just the strongest guild that Fairy Tail must compete with, full of members who have all sorts of cool powers. Then we see exactly how they deal with failure. Special mention goes to Sting, who was introduced as a new dragon slayer who was once a fan of the main character, and is far more interactive than his companion Rogue. After Sabertooth's collective bait the dog moment Sting is seen laughing at the misfortune of the girl they booted out (this despite his having failed worse than her and gotten off with a warning) and claiming she deserved it for being weak while Rogue insists that as a guild they ought to look out for their members.
- In the Ace Attorney manga, Robin Wolfe is polite and friendly toward Phoenix when Phoenix comes to defend him when he is about to be accused of killing his employee Eddie Johnson, but increasingly suspicious hints pop up about him. His wife is cold and distant toward him, his daughter pokes holes in his claims about Eddie, and Eddie's brother confronts him about his role in Eddie's death. While Robin denies his brother Bobby's existence, the "Den of Spiders" built and maintained at considerable expense, seems to be a Pet the Dog moment as does his having him run an errand near the time of Eddie's death, but then Phoenix sees that the Den of Spiders has a chair with restraints that is used on Bobby to keep him out of sight of guests. By the end of the night, Phoenix and Maya are essentially convinced Robin drove Eddie to his suicide... and around this, time Robin gets killed.
- In the Investigations manga, Chase Clink seems like a friendly and reasonable police chief, until Emi St. Cloud is murdered and he suspects Shawn Southern. When Edgeworth protests his haste in declaring Shawn the suspect, Chase derides him for spending so much time around Gumshoe. Chase is also the actual murderer, who killed Emi St. Cloud and had Shawn framed in order to cover up a secret that he thought would sully the police department's name.
- Mizuki's first line is suggesting that Iruka let Naruto pass despite not being able to make clones, a suggestion Iruka shoots down. Soon afterward, he has a talk with the depressed Naruto, trying to get him to understand why Iruka is as strict as he is. He then offers an alternative way for Naruto to graduate- all part of his plan to steal the scroll of forbidden jutsus.
- At first, Tobi seems to be a silly, likeable, eager-to-please Butt Monkey with a 'lollipop mask' who clearly doesn't quite fit in with the rest of the Akatsuki. It doesn't last.
- Every time it seems like Sasuke is becoming a better and less self-centered person. Even Sakura and Naruto have caught on to this and don't seem too surprised by his betrayal in chapter 692.
- In Mai-Otome, Tomoe initially seems fairly humble about being the second ranked student in Garderobe and welcoming toward Arika, in contrast to the top-ranked Nina, who says she only sees her classmates as rivals. When Arika's uniform goes missing and she's suspected of selling it, Tomoe seems unwilling to believe that it's the case. Then comes the scene when Tomoe berates the girl she bullied into stealing the uniform for deviating from the plan and slaps her, and Tomoe goes downhill from there.
- In the manga for A Certain Scientific Railgun we're introduced to the scientists in charge of the Sisters/Level 6 development project. They're friendly, affable, serve one of the Misaka clones an expensive tea and chat with her... and then without missing a beat they ask her to clean up the corpses of half a dozen of her brutally killed sisters. Those who have read or watched Index before Railgun will probably see it coming, but for first time readers it's quite the shock.
- The Joker does this a lot. As one comic writer said, "The Joker's job is to make the audience laugh, then feel ashamed about it afterwards."
- In a 2006 Captain America What If? story, Steve Rogers is a soldier during the Civil War era, part of a group ordered to attack some American Indians. When he expresses doubt about this, his superior officer Colonel "Bucky" Barnes appears to understand. Later, it's shown that the Colonel not only allows the attack to happen, but in fact has his men surrender the loot to him as well.
- The Transformers: Robots in Disguise Zig-zags this with Starscream. First and foremost, he's Starscream, Jerkass, backstabber, and only in it for himself. However, in this series the war is at it's tentative end, and he goes into politics, juggling his ambition with what's best for the people, being a cocky arrogant prick, but also trying to befriend fellow candidate Metalhawk and raise the people of Cybertron out of the crappy shambles of a city they've made. In Issue 16, allies with the Autobots against the Decepticons who are attempting an uprising, and he saves Metalhawk before coldly murdering him and blaming it on the Decepticon/Autobot war, and rallying the people against his former comrades and enemies and sealing power for himself. In spite of that, when we next see him, he admits that he feels guilty for what he's done, and his new position puts him under massive amounts of scrutiny from former soldiers who've stayed in the city, the press and the encroaching Dark Cybertron Prophecy.
- One of the longest-term and most emotionally powerful examples was Cassidy in Preacher: he was a Lovable Rogue for practically the whole first half of the story, but the second half was devoted to a very unpleasant Face-Heel Turn coupled with increasingly grotesque and horrific revelations about his past actions.
- Judge Dredd: In Boyhood of a Superfiend, Judge Death had an impressively cruel one of these during his day as a trainee Judge in court, where he executed every single one of the 27 defendants who were brought before him. The last case was couple who filed for divorce, but tried to save themselves by getting back together and canceling the motion. Death smiles and wishes them a long and happy life together... then blows out their brains anyway because they wasted his time.
- Downplayed in The CATverse- while he is clearly a villain from the start, most of the Scarecrow's worst actions take place offstage or are implied, the stories are mostly Black Comedy, and he has sympathetic moments with his henchgirls. His actions in Small World - strangling his mother to death and torturing her child, all with no remorse whatsoever and with no happy ending to mitigate them - are downright brutal, are played dead seriously, and are a reminder to the reader that Jonathan Crane is still a very bad man.
- Daemon Bridges in It's not the Raptor DNA is introduced as a Corrupt Corporate Executive who, while bordering on Ax-Crazy, has some sympathetic and humanizing characteristics - namely, his genuine concern for Sobek, an aging Spinosaurus, and his desire to see him well cared for. Then he and a henchman murder Blake, an ACU officer who was in the wrong place at the wrong time, and he feels no remorse for the crime.
Film - Animated
- Frozen. Prince Hans of the Southern Isles is a Nice Guy who bonds with Anna over being shut out by their older siblings and ends up asking her to marry him—which is the catalyst for Elsa accidentally losing control and freezing the entire kingdom. Anna leaves him in charge while she goes to search for Elsa, and he's shown helping the common folk and standing up to the Duke when the old man tries to accuse Anna. He later goes after the sisters himself when Anna's horse comes back without her, stops Elsa from killing the Duke's men who had attacked her, stops one of the men from shooting her, and then later when Elsa is imprisoned pleads with her to stop the eternal winter and seems nothing but sympathetic. Soon after Anna returns, near death since her sister accidentally froze her heart, and begs Hans for a kiss since only "an act of true love" can save her. Hans smiles, leans in... and reveals he never really loved her, he just wanted to take over her kingdom since he would never be able to inherit the throne of the Southern Isles with 12 older brothers in the way. He planned to have Elsa killed after they were married, but now he can blame Elsa for Anna's death and do it openly while looking like a hero. He then locks Anna in and leaves her to die. Hans gets a lot more hate than other Disney villains who actually succeeded in killing people, and it's probably because of this trope; there is almost no indication before The Reveal that he is anything other than an Adorkable heroic standard Disney prince, so his betrayal hits the audience as hard as it hits Anna. The fact that Disney is usually pretty clear about who their villains are didn't help.
- Toy Story 3. After saving Lotso from being torn apart by shredders, he immediately shows them gratitude and later asks them to push him up a ladder so that he can save them all from an incinerator...only to leave them to die by not pressing the emergency stop button and mockingly salute Woody as he makes his way out of the garbage dump.
Film - Live Action
- Quentin Tarantino admits to doing this with Mr Blond in Reservoir Dogs, whose Moral Event Horizon moment involved cutting off a cop's ear and slicing his face while he was gagged and duct-taped to a chair, then dousing him with gasoline and preparing to set him on fire before he was stopped. All of this is done after we get introduced via a little How We Got Here flashback and get to see him do the twist to some funky 70's music on the radio.
- And again in Jackie Brown, we assume we're on Samuel L. Jackson's side, because he seems like his character in Pulp Fiction, with some funny lines about AK-47's and a stoner girlfriend, etc. He goes on to shoot or threaten to shoot most of the characters in the movie. Robert De Niro's character is the same, except we don't find out until much later on when he shoots his/Ardell's girlfriend dead because she wouldn't stop talking.
- Nightcrawler has Lou Bloom—a socially awkward, but nice, kid of recent generations, forced into thievery and petty crime by the horrible economy, something that everyone, from Millennials to Boomers, have felt. He's good with tech, and tries to make an effort to be nice, and social, and is eager to learn, right? Even though his job, and focus of the film, capitalizes on sensationalism and suffering, well, that's just something everyone in this economy's had to swallow, right? Surely, that doesn't include stuff like sexual extortion, evidence rigging, eliminating the competition, and outright murder, right...? He's not someone like Sheldon Cooper or Steve Urkel—he's really Patrick Bateman.
- Maman in Slumdog Millionaire. A viewer might be slightly suspicious when this man is offering homeless children soda and giving them a home in an orphanage. You may think he's a little shady, but not too terrible when he has the children panhandle in exchange for food and board. Then when he really likes you, you get to sing for him. However, he has a way to make every singing orphan worth double.
- Barton Fink. Charlie seems like a lovable oaf and becomes Barton's only real friend. Then it turns out he's a homicidal maniac who probably killed his girlfriend and gave her head to him in box.
- The 1945 American Propaganda film My Japan, whose message is "Holy shit Japan is Badass" bookends scenes of Japanese brutality with tranquil koi ponds. http://www.archive.org/details/MyJapan1945
- The Imaginarium of Doctor Parnassus brings us Tony. He's introduced as a likeable chap who has a gift for bringing people in to be enlightened in the titular imaginarium. It's shown that he was involved in some sort of scandal about a children's charity, but he still comes off as a Loveable Rogue. Then it's revealed that he was selling the children's organs on the black market. The man triggers an Even Evil Has Standards reaction in the Devil himself.
- Done deliberately with the film version of 'Secret Window''—according to the director, by the time our protagonist finally snaps completely and kills his ex-wife and her boyfriend, we were meant to be too involved with him to stop cheering him on.
- Any horror film where they don't show who the killer is before the big reveal. Especially in the Scream film series where Ghostface turns out to be someone you wouldn't expect to be a homicidal mass murderer.
- A subtle example in Watchmen. There's a Male Gaze shot of Silk Spectre in her form-fitting costume, then a cut to the Comedian leering at her. He's a cool superhero type, and he's also just a guy like us! Then, moments later, he tries to rape her.
- In X2: X-Men United, Magneto and the Brotherhood team up with the X-Men in an Enemy Mine battle against a racist, genocidal military colonel. Magneto's more or less leading a rescue mission to save Professor Xavier, and the two teams fight together so well (the movie's even subtitled "X-Men United") that you can't help but cheer him on and start to wonder if, all things considered, he's really such a bad guy. And then he proceeds to remind the audience that yes, he really is a villain, when instead of rescuing him, he tries to use the captive, brainwashed Xavier to kill every non-mutant on Earth.
- In Dragonheart we first see Einon as though he is like any other fantasy hero, who was given Draco's heart and the audience assumes it would be about A Boy and His X. But in a few minutes, we see that he is a spoiled prince who is even more oppressive and cruel than his father. When he forces the rebels to help build his new castle, he has their leader blinded for good measure.
- Though the signs were present long before that. It was in fact the moment he came upon his dying father, and tried to steal his crown that got him injured badly enough to need a dragon heart transplant in the first place.
- The robber in The Amazing Spider-Man is introduced to us this way. He's behind Peter in line at a convenience store, who is trying to buy a chocolate milk and is two cents short. The jerkass clerk won't even let him make up the difference from the "take a penny/leave a penny" jar because he hasn't paid enough. As Peter leaves, the robber tosses his money on the floor, making the clerk bend down to get it, empties the register while he is distracted, and tosses Peter the milk. Since the robbery was non-violent, the robber was nice to Peter, and the clerk was a jerk, you are tempted to like the guy and understand why Peter doesn't stop him. Moments later he has murdered Uncle Ben for getting in his way.
- G Force, Speckles.
- The Japanese horror classic Audition perfectly fits this trope.
- The film Side Effects proves to be this with the main female protagonist Emily. The film seems like it's a cautionary tale about the dangers of prescription medicine with Emily being the tragic victim. Only to reveal that she used prescription drugs as cover to kill her husband, set up her psychiatrist to take the blame, and get rich off the stock market.
- Annie Wilkes in Misery. She saves the author Paul Sheldon from a deadly car crash in the middle of a blizzard. She makes it clear to be a huge fan of his books. She seems dedicated and delighted to nurse his wounds until he makes a full recovery. Though she almost violently disagrees with Sheldon's new book, it's just the actions of a passionate fan. Nothing wrong with that, right? Too bad she's revealed to be a psychopath that has no intention of letting Sheldon go or let anyone know he's still alive. Then it's revealed that she had a dark past where she poisoned her husband and was a nurse who poisoned many of her patients.
- Pan's Labyrinth: Captain Vidal is introduced as a stern militant, with a dash of My Country, Right or Wrong to go along with his fascism. He's polite to Carmen and stern to Ofelia. When he finds a couple of hunters who his men have captured, he searches their bags, finding some tobacco and a beer bottle. He shushes them whenever they talk, and when the younger hunter insists that the other, his father is telling the truth, Vidal calmly walks up to him and beats his face in with the beer bottle. Then he shoots the man's father (not even bothering to warn the soldier who was standing right behind the man, who could have been killed by the exit wound if he hadn't moved away), and calmly shoots the first hunter. He later finds that they were only hunters, and tells his men to do a better job of searching before they bring people to him.
- In Hellraiser: Bloodline, Pinhead appears to be petting a little white dove in one scene. He promptly feeds it to his hellhound the Chatterbeast.
- In The Man with the Iron Fists, Brass Body is introduced playing with some orphans and cheering them up. He is later shown to be a ruthless murderer and rapist.
- Pitch Black: So it seems like Riddick, after all this talk about how bad he is, might be an alright guy after all when he prevents Jack from getting killed and used as bait by Johns. Then Riddick leaving the others to die as soon as it becomes a viable option really drives home the point of what a scumbag he can be.
- The Radix: The Knight offers a street bum meal, shower, new clothing... Just to cut him up and use as a model for his painting of a Christian martyr. Later The Dog Bites Back as one of the bum's pals recognizes him and reports to authorities.
- Mr. Teatime in Hogfather is introduced with a Badass sequence in which he sneaks into the head assassin's office, then turns out to be a total psycho.
- Of course, we only get a couple paragraphs of "what a badass" before "Oh my Om, what a psycho" sets in, because we first see him playing with some dogs; the character speaking to him expresses surprise, because on his last job he nailed one to the ceiling.
- "He lost both parents at an early age. I think, on reflection, that we should have wondered a bit more about that."
- Of course, we only get a couple paragraphs of "what a badass" before "Oh my Om, what a psycho" sets in, because we first see him playing with some dogs; the character speaking to him expresses surprise, because on his last job he nailed one to the ceiling.
- Zakalwe from Use of Weapons by Iain M. Banks. Initially he comes off being a cool, badass secret agent with a rather dark sense of humour, and though his handlers seem to think he's a dangerous psycho, they seem totally off base. It's not until the very end of the story that we find out that he's an ex Evil Overlord, with a penchant for flaying who was involved in a civil war with his brother. He ended that civil war by murdering their sister and his ex-girlfriend, making a chair out of her corpse, and then having it sent to his brother, who kills himself. He then steals his brother's identity, and uses it to escape his past.
- Wilkie Collins did this in his novel The Woman in White with Enigmatic Minion Count Fosco. Fosco is so friendly and charming that the heroines turn to him for help against the seemingly main villain, Sir Percival Glyde, who is a Dastardly Whiplash type. Turns out that Fosco is actually a master villain who is aiding Glyde. It's also shown that Fosco has cowed and abused his wife into becoming a Stepford Smiler and it has been argued by British critic John Sutherland that the discrepancies in time between what Fosco says it took for Anne Catherick's death and what another character reports is meant to suggest that Fosco killed her after a prolonged period of torture and rape.
- In the Warhammer novel Inheritance, the character of Vlad von Carstein is introduced like a non-annoying version of an Anne Rice vampire, who practically sweats pure liquid awesome. He's philosophically inclined, a good fighter, looks cool, enters like a true badass, and ohmigod did he just slaughter hundreds of people in extremely sadistic manners and resurrect them as zombies?
- In George P. Pelecanos' novel King Suckerman, ex-con Wilton Cooper appears to be a cool Badass but is gradually revealed to be a rather frightening sociopath.
- When introduced in the first Gormenghast novel, Titus Groan, Steerpike is not only the most dynamic character in the entire cast, with a clear and sympathetic goal (escape), but is the viewpoint character for most of the book, not to mention showing extreme skill at what he does. By the time he reveals himself to be a deceitful serial killer, the reader has been well and truly disposed to view him as the hero.
- In R.L. Stein's Fear Games trilogy (Part of The Nightmare Room), the sorceress who is the trilogy's Big Bad lures a seagull to her hand, pets it while she tells it her evil plot, then snaps the seagull's neck and throws it to the ground.
- In the Dale Brown book Air Battle Force, General Gryzlov first appears as A Father to His Men, chatting with the aircrew of the bomber he's on. Then it turns out that he's there to oversee firebombing the shit out of Chechens.
- Ventrue can only drink from a certain type of person. Jan Pieterzoon is a decent guy who happens to be a vampire, thrust into a bad position and doing the best he can. We even see him mourn for his aides when they die, which lasts until he decides that he needs a new source of blood: Jan can only feed on rape victims, so he Dominates the night manager into raping the check-in girl so Jan can feed. But Jan feels bad about it, so it's okay... ?
- Not that it excuses it at all, but Jan was so badly damaged, he needed to feed right off or he wouldn't have lasted the night.
- A Song of Ice and Fire has Littlefinger. He's a schemer and whoremonger, but he's also a childhood friend of Catelyn, so he helps her out and gives Ned some brutally honest advice. He might be a weasel, but he's their weasel. But he was all part of his scheme to completely betray the Starks and improve his own position.
- In The Dagger and the Coin, Geder initially appears to be a highly sympathetic character and obvious Audience Surrogate- its a fantasy novel, and he's a young soldier who is overweight and nerdy and would rather read than fight, and is the target of cruel bullying by his fellow officers, all aristocratic jocks. Soon afterward, Geder shows a clever schemer side that gives him Badass Bookworm cred, and is at the lead in taking an enemy city. Then, some people in the City protest against the occupation and burn Geder in effigy. His response- order his troops to cover the streets with flammable material and close off all escape roots before burning the city to the ground. He listens calmly over the next couple of days as upwards of ten thousand people burn alive. After this, he just keeps going, and his moments of being friendly and mild-mannered make his monstrous sociopathy all the more frightening. Essentially, it takes what looks to be the origin story of an underdog hero, then turns it on its head by revealing it to be the origin story of the Dark Lord instead.
- Denth and Tonk Fah from Warbreaker.
Live Action TV
- 24: Since revealed to be alive, Tony Almeida's been acting a little shady, but also has been doing everything in his power to aid Jack and the FBI stop the Starkwood conspiracy and destroy their bioweapon which has already infected Jack, personally taking out the main facility. Then someone escapes with a sample of the weapon and Tony teams up with FBI head agent Larry Moss to take him down. But when they corner the guy and Larry is shot, Tony then proceeds to suffocate him to death and reveal he's working with the man who has the sample.
- Battlestar Galactica (2003): Happens a few times on the new show. First there's Cavil/#1, who's introduced as a Deadpan Snarker type and even seems to be one of the more sympathetic Cylons. As the story develops, we get to know Cavil for what he really is. Then there's Tory, who learns she's a Cylon, but manages to keep it together at first. When Cally has a breakdown upon realizing her husband Tyrol is a Cylon, she takes her infant son and prepares to toss herself and him out of an airlock. Tory shows up, talks Cally down-and then takes Cally's son before ejecting her into space anyway.
- Blackadder: General Melchett in the fourth series initially seems like a comically eccentric Pointy-Haired Boss, but his behavior in the second episode, in which Blackadder is court marshaled suggests that he is seriously mentally unstable. Although Melchett is at first a comic parody of the We Have Reserves habit of World War One generals, it's ultimately pretty clear that Melchett's not just incompetent—he's The Sociopath who couldn't give a damn about his troops.
- Breaking Bad: When we first see Todd, he's a criminal but he is still unfailingly polite and genuinely nice to everyone he interacts with. Then he casually executes a child as if it were no big deal.
- Fargo: This is essentially Lester's character arc. He's a put upon Henpecked Husband who's constantly abused by those around him and he maintains the Sympathetic P.O.V. as he kills his wife and desperately tries to fix his life as it crumbles around him. As the episodes go on he just get's darker and darker culminating in him framing his brother and sending him to jail. Then the Time Skip occurs and he's successful happy and has put his life back together again until a chance encounter with Lorne makes him a target again. Lester tricks his current wife into a fatal situation which ends with Lorne shooting her in the head.
- Firefly: Had a good example with Bounty Hunter Jubal Early. It's clear that Whedon assumed that viewers would react to him with similar good will as was shown towards Boba Fett in Star Wars, and when he first appears, he is an erudite and funny Bad Ass. Then he starts threatening to rape Kaylee and admitting to his love of torturing animals as a child, making the audience remember that, yes, someone like him probably would be a vicious psychopath.
- Game of Thrones: Joffery Baratheon proves to be this. He starts off as a bratty, spoiled, prince that gets humbled and learned his lesson. He seems to get better and make an effort to be the kind of prince that would make a good king. Only to reveal his true colors after he becomes king. He has Ned Stark beheaded for treason, despite seemingly promising Sansa Stark, his fiancee and Ned's daughter, as well as his own mother, that he would spare him. He then goes on to mentally and physically torment Sansa and others at court. And once he gets his crossbow....
- When Theon Greyjoy is captured by men who tortured, he is helped by a boy who saves him from the dungeons. The boy is later revealed to be Ramsay Snow the bastard of Roose Bolton, and he inflicts even more torture on Theon, and is an even bigger sadist than Joffery.
- Hannibal: The title character is a ruthless, cannibalistic serial killer, but in every other capacity he's thoroughly helpful, polite and very entertaining, not to mention an excellent chef and a great host. Then he discovers that Will has severe encephalitis, and starts slowly Gaslighting him so he has a front-row seat to a mental collapse, and eventually frames Will as a serial killer. The only thing more dramatic than how quickly Will went from sane to insane is how quickly the fandom's opinion of Hannibal went from Draco in Leather Pants to evil.
- In the iZombie pilot, Blaine is portrayed as a sinister drug dealer who then turns Liv into a zombie after she rejects him (he himself becomes a zombie a few seconds before that thanks to his own product). At the end of the episode, Liv gets a vision of Blaine viciously attacking a guy in "full-on zombie mode". And yet, when he shows up in the second episode, he appears as this friendly and disarming guy who is just as confused about his new condition as Liv and is glad to have another zombie to talk to and compare notes with. He seems genuinely surprised that he is the one who turned her and seems to feel remorse. He also looks hurt that Liv doesn't trust him enough to leave him alone with her friend Ravi. It's not long that it's shown that, yes, Blaine really is a bad guy who uses his new strength and invulnerability to hunt his competition. He also sleeps with a woman, turning her into a zombie through fluid contact intentionally to turn her, extorting her to pay exorbitant amounts of money for brains so she can remain sane and present as human. Brains that he gets from murdering people in a butcher shop. It's been heavily implied that many of the people he's been butchering are at-risk teens that he has a fellow zombie/drug dealer kidnap.
- Lost has Locke's long-lost father, Anthony Cooper. At first, he seems happy to finally meet Locke and starts giving him the family life he never had. Then it turns out all that was a con to steal Locke's kidney, after which he wants nothing more to do with his son. Later, he tries to kill Locke by pushing him out a window, which led to Locke ending up paralyzed and wheelchair-bound.
- Merlin: Morgause at first simply seems to be a Well-Intentioned Extremist who wants Uther off the throne for the good of the people. Her first two attempts involve telling Arthur the truth about his parentage and putting all the residents of Camelot to sleep without hurting them and she removes the spell to save her sister's life. But in season 3 we see how much of a villain she really is as she tries to drive Uther mad and get armies to invade Camelot. We also see her sadistic side through her treatment of Gwen and Cenred. And to boot she corrupts Morgana and turns her into the series' Big Bad.
- Once Upon a Time: Greg Mendell, who appeared to be an innocent, likeable Muggle. Then it was revealed he actually had a tragic history with Storybrooke which led to him losing his father, and he became very sympathetic to fans. But then he was revealed as a Knight Templar who seems more interested in eradicating magic than finding/avenging his father, and is willing to resort to Cold-Blooded Torture and even mass murder to accomplish this.
- Person of Interest: Elias helps Reese save an infant, only to lock Reese and the child in a refrigerated truck to force Reese's assistance.
- Revolution: Throughout the first season, Tom Neville has been that sort of villain who just follows orders and doesn't seem to have anything personal with the protagonists. Then he defects from the Monroe Republic to the Georgia Federation. Then he's working with the protagonists to stop his former boss, Sebastian Monroe. Then he exploits the fact that Monroe is terrible at being a leader to get himself put in charge of the Monroe Republic. Now, you might think that the situation will improve. However, first he tells Monroe loyalist Captain Mark Franklin that he'll be let go...and then murders him in cold blood and makes it look like self-defense. Then he promises his son Jason that he'll keep Charlie and Rachel alive...but then decides to have the protagonists all killed off anyway. A lot of sympathy for the character is gone by the first season finale.
- Samurai Sentai Shinkenger: There's Fuwa Juzou, who is a half-Gedoushuu and sets himself up as Takeru's Worthy Opponent, constantly seeking to fight him. With him not really getting along with the head honcho of Gedoushuu, Chimatsuri Doukokuu, plus building up some 'friendship' with Usukawa Dayuu and the fact that he's half-human makes people think that since this is Super Sentai, he'd at least be shown as either a Noble Demon, or pull a Heel-Face Turn later. Then, he foils Akumaro's plan...by revealing that he revels on his Gedoushuu lineage, preferring to be a full-blooded Gedoushuu (which he did), and his sword Uramasa turned out to be his parents begging him to stop killing, but he doesn't care one bit, liking his profession as a Blood Knight to the max and wants nothing more than kill and more killing. At that point, any hopes of him as mentioned above are dashed forever and he places himself as one of Super Sentai's monsters.
- Star Trek: Deep Space Nine: Actually an Invoked Trope when the writers thought that the recurring villain Dukat was getting too popular with the audience as a perceived Noble Demon. Despite his charming demeanor and the fact that he truly cared for his illegitimate daughter, he was a hypocritical, crazed, sexually voracious dictator who had thousands of people butchered directly and sent millions more to die in labor camps and didn't hesitate to sell his own people to the Dominion which directly led to his home planet winding up thoroughly demolished (perhaps even worse than they had done to Bajor, certainly faster) by the end of the show. The episode "Waltz" exists for the sake of showing the audience that, charm or no charm, this man is a monster, whose biggest regret in life is that he didn't wipe out the entire population of Bajor when he might have had the chance.
- Torchwood: Captain John, who is So. Cool...and kills people for no particular reason. This is done on his first appearance in the show.
- Spartacus: Blood and Sand:
- Batiatus from initially looks like an Ineffectual Sympathetic Villain or a Jerkass Woobie. Then he crosses the Moral Event Horizon. With a smile.
- Despite having started out as simply a spoiled Bratty Half-Pint, Tiberius Crassus in the third season, War Of The Damned, gained a measure of sympathy when he was forced to kill his best friend in Decimation, on the orders of his own father. He proceeded to toss that away by raping the slave who was his father's lover and had shown him kindness as a way at getting back at his father.
- In season 5 of Supernatural, Bobby makes a deal with the demon Crowley for his soul so they can find the location of Death, the last of Lucifer's Horsemen. Then Crowley goes out of his way to give Bobby back the use of his legs even though Bobby never bothered to include it in their contract and even promises to give back his soul when everything's done. Except the next season Crowley fully intends to hang on to it and send Bobby to Hell in 10 years and Bobby has to spend the entire episode getting it back.
- Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D.:
- Grant Ward is set up to be an honorable, loyal agent. Then, he is revealed to be HYDRA in episode 17.
- Ward gets an even more extreme one in "Ragtag". Garrett orders him to kill Fitz and Simmons, who end up locking themselves on the other side of a transparent door. Fitz insists that they are friends and Ward still must care about them. After a Pet the Dog flashback, Ward acknowledges that yes, he does care about them...it's a weakness. He then flips the switch to dump them out of the plane and into the ocean.
- On Salem, Increase Mather declares that Gloriana is not a witch and so she will not be tried; but since she is a prostitute she's hereby banished.
- Utopia: Milner, the only trustworthy authority figure, who turns out to be Mr Rabbit, the series Big Bad. Also a Double Subversion in that The Assistant has been set up and revealed to play that exact role minutes before.
- This was probably the intention of the famous Israeli song The Snakeís Sough: the narrator is described initially as a young man who just canít get the hang of staying in the rat race, wishing he could re-invent himself away from his current life... then near the end, he turns out to be a fugitive, avoiding arrest after having severely injured his then-girlfriend, who was Ďa little wild, a little unclearí, with his car. However, some see this song as seriously downplaying the effect of the manís actions and trying to pass him as a sympathetic character.
- William Shakespeare likes these:
- Chiron and Demetrius in Titus Andronicus. They're introduced as a couple of thick comedic teenagers fighting over some girl; ten minutes with The Chessmaster Aaron and they go on to rape and mutilate her.
- Edmund in King Lear. He starts off as somewhere between a Loveable Rogue and a Magnificent Bastard (literally), then, just as the audience is rooting for him and his Evil Plan and wondering if he's shaping up to be an Anti-Hero, they're hit with a real Kick the Dog moment, and confronted with their Misaimed Fandom, when his scheming leads to the Duke of Cornwall gouging out the eyes of Edmund's own aged father, on-stage.
- Though this was far from M. Hugo's original intent, the musical of Les Misťrables gives its most upbeat, funniest, and catchiest musical number to Monsieur Thenardier and his wife, as they swindle, cheat, and serve questionable food to the patrons at their inn, and abuse and starve the little girl they're supposed to be taking care of. Watch and see if you can keep your feet from tapping.
- Not even the rest of the cast is able to sit still!
- Caesar's Legion in Fallout: New Vegas initally seem like a subversion. Their atrocties and reputation as powerful but mindless savages trying to topple civilisation seems to be their one defining attribute—until you meet Caesar himself and find out that he's a well spoken philosopher who wants to create a civilisation that won't implode on itself. But just annoy him a little and it turns out the Legion are every bit as self interested and nightmarish as their reputation suggested, endorsing everything from cannibalism, human sacrifice to rape. And just to kill any doubt that Caesar only sees this as a harsh necessity, he orders the peaceful town of New Canaan to be wiped out purely to torment his former Legate.
- Between his intelligence, respectful disposition and warrior's honour, many players would be fooled into thinking that Legate Lanius would be a great leader of the Legion, even greater than Caesar himself. Should for some reason Caesar die and the Legion win, it turns out that Lanius' rule of Vegas is even more brutal than Caesar's.
- Kazuya Mishima of the Tekken franchise (and his evil 'alter ego' Devil) qualifies. Starting out the series with white clothing and somehow 'stoic' attitude, you'd think he's like The Hero, trying to topple his evil father Heihachi's company. Upon victorious, it is widely thought that he'd strive to steer his father's company to the righteous way. Cue the sequel, it turns out he does things far worse than Heihachi ever did, turning into a full-blown villain (with some minor things like being attracted to Jun Kazama, and having Angel), and has remained that way until now. You could actually get a hint of Kazuya's evil side since Tekken 1 if you buy the Playstation port, whereas he got Devil as his alternate costume.
- Arthas Menethil in Warcraft. While he's first seen, he may seem to be a genuinely good person put through horrible circumstances to the point his desire to save his country makes him do a Face-Heel Turn and eventually gets promoted into the Big Bad. It wasn't later that supplemental materials reveal that he's not as goody-goody as his debut game pre-insanity showed him to be, and it's heavily hinted that Arthas!Lich King's over-inflated sense of pride and ego comes from Arthas' own.
- In the opening cinema of The Burning Crusade expansion for World of Warcraft, you see a rather beautiful Blood Elf woman playing with a creature made primarily of mana in a graceful, Disney-Princess kind of way... and after about 8 seconds of this she forcibly drains the things essence out, killing it. This establishes the blood elves' sinister, mana-addicted nature hiding underneath their extravagant High People aesthetic.
- In Wrath of the Lich King, Drakuru starts of as a morally dubious but generally affable troll who aids the player in taking down the forces of the Drakkari Trolls, who are large and dangerous enough to put up a fight even against the Scourge. After helping cleanse their forces, you find out Drakuru is actually in league with Arthas to eliminate the Drakkari threat and turn them over to the Scourge. You get the chance to repay him for his betrayal during a quest line in Zul'Drak.
- (Aside from his flashback appearance) Kefka from Final Fantasy VI is introduced in the story as a quirky and colorful Villainous Harlequin like character, humorously demanding that his shoes be emptied of sand in the middle of a desert and generally acting like a goofy manchild. He later reveals himself as a sociopath whose idea of fun generally revolves around mass genocide.
- Yunalesca of Final Fantasy X is known as the first summoner to defeat Sin and save the world (albeit temporarily). She waits in Zanarkand as a ghost to greet summoners at the end of their pilgrimage. Until we discover she turns one of the summoner's guardians into a living statue forever and that she knows it's impossible to truly defeat Sin this way. When the protagonists refuse to go along with her, she does NOT take it well. And shockingly, she actually remains an Anti-Villain the whole time.
- Subverted with Slayer in Guilty Gear XX. One of his intro sequences features him with an attractive woman clinging to him... who he then drains of blood until she's nothing but an empty husk. This seems like a straight application of the trope... until you get into the series story. The woman in question is his wife, who has the special ability that she simply can't die, period. She kills parasites and disease-causing organisms just by being near them—to the point Eddie (a body-stealing bioweapon) tries to possess her in one of his endings and melts—and being drained like this is, at worst, a minor inconvenience for her. Slayer is a villain by some readings (he's not just an assassin, he's the founder and former head of the guild), but his relationship with his wife is one of his better aspects.
- Carl Clover in BlazBlue is a cheerful, polite and idealistic child as long as one nods politely when he mentions his sister. Running is advised if she starts to make suggestions to him.
- However, he aspires to become like Litchi in his story mode ending in Continuum Shift.
- Which is, kind of subverted later, when people are introduced to Litchi, she displayed herself as a kind hearted woman who cared about everyone and would even sacrifice herself to save someone unknown as Carl at that time. Time by time, we are also told that she was trying to save her lover. Come Continuum Shift, however, said emotion became a catalyst for her to do a Face-Heel Turn, joining in Carl's father for a chance to save her lover, maybe to establish that she is not meant to be the sensible Love You and Everybody Messianic Archetype, but a desperate lover to the level of near-obsession. Somehow she still retained her kind self, but it was probably a type of baiting provided by Arc System Works.
- In the first game, there's that mild-mannered informant Hazama who merrily helped Noel... until suddenly in the True End, he reveals his true card, that being Troll extraordinary Terumi Yuuki, who's responsible for nearly every single depravity done to the world.
- GlaDOS in Portal. At first, you don't think much of the A.I. telling you how to use that handy little portal gun, outside of her advice and sense of humor. Then, she sends you into a testchamber full of murderous turrets and you notice the Room Full of Crazy. Then she makes you murder your (non-sentient) friend. Then you reach the end of Test Chamber 19...
- Dimitri Rascalov in Grand Theft Auto IV. At first, he seems like a decent guy, especially when compared to his boss, Mikhail Faustin. When he orders Niko to kill Mikhail, most players would think he's doing it for the right reasons. However, he then betrays Niko to Ray Bulgarin, a human trafficker he ows money to, and becomes one half of the game's Big Bad Duumvirate. And he later tries to make Niko's life hell with a series of progressively escalating Kick the Dog moments.
- Eva Beatrice in Umineko no Naku Koro ni is introduced with a happy, innocent sounding tune and just seems so thrilled about her recent 'promotion' that even Battler applauds her. However, she turns out to be far worse than even Beatrice and disgusts an actual demon with her antics.
- Inverted and played straight for different characters in Muramasa: The Demon Blade. In Momohime's storyline, we're soon introduced to a seemingly utterly vile Villain Protagonist by the name of Jinkuro, and a seemingly noble monk who helped save Momohime and seems committed to making Jinkuro pay for his crimes... but it quickly turns out that things aren't quite so black and white. Rankai, the monk, is actually just motivated by vengeance and will do anything to see Jinkuro die, including selling Momohime's soul to a demon, while Jinkuro, although still very much a villain, isn't quite as callous and devoid of redeeming features as he first appears.
- In Penumbra: Black Plague Clarence initially seems to be a harmless and funny, if somewhat crazy character (a bit like Overture's Red). However, when he finds out he can make Philip hallucinate and uses that power to play "hilarious japes", which begin with causing Philip to see enemies from overture and culminate in tricking him into killing the Amabel Swanson, the one person who has been really nice to him in the whole game, he suddenly becomes a lot more sinister.
- Brothers: A Tale of Two Sons: The girl the brothers rescue from the cult helps them get to the Water of Life, only to reveal herself as a giant spider creature and mortally wound the older brother.
- The Walking Dead:
- In season one, the survivors meet up St. John family, who are a nice group who offered to invite the survivors to dinner. But they are really a Cannibal Clan and plan to slaughter the group like livestock.
- A literal example in season two, Clementine finds a stray dog in the woods after being washed downstream. She quickly makes friends with him and it seems like he's going to become an Animal Companion of sorts. Then she finds some food and the very hungry dog quickly turns feral the moment she tries to take the food off him; she's forced to fend him off and severely injure him to escape, with the option to even kill him to put him out of his misery.
- The intro of the Resident Evil Remake has Wesker stop while being chased by zombie dogs to shoot one that was about to kill Chris. Of course we find out much later the only reason he did this was to get Chris to the mansion to serve as a guinea pig to test the B.O.W's combat effectiveness.
- The Jagermonsters in Girl Genius often come across as goofy eccentrics who like drinking and fighting a bit more than normal guys...so sometimes it's easy to forget that they're hyperefficient killing machines who are only as moral as their master (so it's okay to root for them now, but you'd better hope Agatha's kids are more like their grandparents than their great grandparents).
- Homestuck pulls one with Jack Noir, who we are first introduced to as a Comedic Sociopath Ineffectual Sympathetic Villain. Hah, it looks like we're going to have a lot of laughs watching him freak out about his paperwork, right? ...wait, did he just kill the Black Queen? Looks like he's going to be the Big Bad, but at least he's pretty cool...what did he just do to Prospit!?!?
- Hussie pulls an interesting case with Vriska. She's introduced as a evil bitch right off the bat—the first thing she does (crippling Tavros) is her Moral Event Horizon and it turns out she murders other troll kids. But post-Time Skip, she seems to be nicer, even helpful in some cases, in her own strange Vriska-ish way, and gains some sympathy in that her murders were committed to feed her spider-lusus, who would otherwise have eaten her instead. Not to mention falling in love with Nicholas Cage. All of this makes her seem like The Atoner and that she was really a Jerk with a Heart of Gold all along, right? Wrong. She finally offs Tavros for good. However, she later says that she feels guilty about that in a conversation where she pours her heart out to John. Conclusion? With Vriska, it's always hard to tell where you stand.
- And again with Eridan. The entire comic builds him up as a worthless Butt Monkey whose attempts at world domination are overly ambitious and doomed to failure, leading everyone to believe that he's an Ineffectual Sympathetic Villain (even having a quote from his introductory exposition on that trope page). Then he announces he plans to betray his friends and join Jack Noir, we learn that he committed genocide on the inhabitants of his planet after he murdered a few for no reason, and he proceeds to beat up Sollux for being in his way and murder both his love interest and the one person whom he referred to as a friend.
- Doc Scratch is presented as a fairly polite villian who wants to help the protagonists (to further his own ambitions), and is even kind to Spades Slick, who spent his time at Scratch's pad trying to light it on fire and attack the host. Towards the end of his narrative, we discover an Awful Truth: he's kidnapped and abused Aradia's ancestor to the point where she becomes a Brainwashed Death Seeker. This is best exemplified when he temporarily takes away her ability to breathe. Damn.
- Not to mention Caliborn. Not long after his introduction, he aggressively solicits Dirk to draw him some "pornography"—mundane depictions of human courtship, with no nudity or anything. His odd personality and over-the-top crudeness lead you to believe he's going to be a Cloudcuckoolander Jerkass... then he reveals that he killed his sister by proxy. Laughing maniacally all the while. After that, it's not much of a surprise when it turns out he's Lord English as a child.
- At the start of The Order of the Stick, Xykon seems like a crazy but slightly loveable and harmless Evil Overlord whose plans were invariably doomed. But if you thought that you were oh so wrong.
- And Redcloak at first appears to merely be Xykon's Deadpan Snarker Beleaguered Assistant. Turns out he and his god are actually behind everything, and even using Xykon to their ends.
- An even further baiting: The Order of the Stick author Rich Burlew has occasionally written little essays on how D&D is played and storylines are formed on his website. In particular he talks about things like how evil people can have friends, Even Evil Has Loved Ones, and two villains working together aren't always just looking to turn on each other at the first opportunity. Combine that with scenes of Xykon and Redcloak joking together, snarking each other, and commiserating when their cause seemed to be lost, and it seemed like might be such friends. Then Start of Darkness came out and kicked that theory right in the nuts. Well played, Mr. Burlew, well played.
- When General Tarquin was introduced he got a lot of fans for affability, savvy, and style. And of course he's Elan's father. It's since become apparent that he uses his position as de facto ruler of the Empire of Blood to force any woman he takes a fancy to to marry him, then kills them when he gets tired of them. Which makes him rather less likable. Not to mention burning 30 slaves (possibly alive) to spell Elan's name out in lights—even Elan finally realizes it at that point.
- The same goes for his partner Minister Malack. He's polite, efficient, eschews Tarquin's theatrics, and one of the first things we learn about him is that he hates Nale for murdering his children. Then we learn those weren't his biological children. He's a vampire. One who's planning to outlive the rest of Team Tarquin, inherit a unified continent and offer his god a thousand sacrifices a day. "I'm thinking of developing some sort of special chamber by then to make the process more efficient..."
- Skippy the Demon from Sluggy Freelance was originally introduced as just a kind of dopey guy for the real Big Bad, K'Z'K, to explain his plan to. But when he shows up again later, he's scarily devoted to reviving K'Z'K, bringing about the end of the world, and seeing that Zoe burns.
- Gunnerkrigg Court has a somewhat literal example with Coyote. At first he comes across as a friendly, Crazy Awesome, and hilarious trickster, especially when compared to his lieutenant, Ysengrin, who seems Ax-Crazy. However, as time goes on, more and more hints are dropped that Coyote is really a wild, unpredictable entity that only does things for his own enjoyment, regardless of who might get hurt in the process. His dog kicking has included treating the loyal Ysengrin like garbage, threatening to blow Annieís hand off if she tells anyone about the sword he gave her, and knowingly allowing Reynardine to walk into a trap set by the Court because he thought itíd be amusing. He finally seems to have crossed the Moral Event Horizon after The Reveal that heís been forcibly removing Ysengrinís memories and eating them. This is complete with a visibly horrified Ysengrin begging Coyote to stop as the god reaches into his head while sporting a Slasher Smile. This has been lampshaded by Word of God.
Tom: Reminder: Coyote ainít your bro.
- In Nebula, Black Hole, despite her Evil Laugh and general creepiness, at first does nothing harmful onscreen. Given that Pluto was already shown to shunned and feared as a when he's just a Misunderstood Loner with a Heart of Gold, it's easy for the reader to think that she's like him- strange, but not evil, and that the fear the planets have for her isn't based on truth. And then she lies to Pluto, nearly kills all the planets, and actually does get Ceres killed in a way that cements her as a Humanoid Abomination Manipulative Bastard.
- In The Salvation War, Michael-Lan is set up as a Magnificent Bastard power behind the throne in heaven; he likes human music and culture, he is manipulating Yahweh and generally being cool. Then he gets a naive young angel hooked on heroin so he can force her into prostitution to support her habit. That was also part of his plan too .
- In Red vs. Blue's 11th season we meet Felix who at first starts out as a well meaning rouge who works for the New Republic, and is a mercenary counterpart of Locus. But in the next season he finally shows his true colors he was really in league with Locus, and is an even worse psycho than him. He has no problems with killing people and would have nuked the entire planet for the lulz.
- In RWBY Volume 3, Emerald picks up Ruby's dropped purse and has a friendly chat with Team RWBY, praising how they fought in their previous match against Team ABRN. Just when they part ways and you start thinking Emerald might actually be sort of sympathetic, Emerald bluntly states to Mercury that she really actually hates them, dismissing Weiss and Yang as "the heiress and the bimbo" - she only pretended to be nice to them to find out which of the four girls they'd be facing in the doubles' rounds.
- In The Movie of Ed Edd N Eddy this is mildly applied. Eddy's Brother is initially portrayed upon his introduction as cool older brother willing to help out Eddy and his friends. It almost seems heartwarming the way Eddy hugs his brother for promising to help them out. One minute later he's beating the hell out of his little brother, his brother's best friend, and has the rest of the cast watching in horror.
- In Gargoyles, Xanatos seems honestly remorseful for what happened to Derek, and is trying to make a cure. Then comes the ending, and it's revealed that he has no cure, he just wants to keep Derek close by for further testing and doesn't care at all what he did to him. If there was ever a moment you truly hated Xanatos on the cartoon, chances are this was it.
- Directly inverted by Razer in the third episode of Green Lantern: The Animated Series. When Aya frees him from the prison and tells him Hal and Kilowog came to rescue him and need his help, he runs off to their abandoned ship, supposedly leaving them to die. He was going back for his ring, and saves them.
- In Ultimate Spider-Man, the Green Goblin finally tells his son the words that his son always wanted to hear: he's proud of him. Then he drops his son to his possible death right after.
- TRON: Uprising: Tessler, Dyson and Clu establish themselves as evil as early as possible, but then there's Pavel. Pavel's initially a Dirty Coward, Large Ham, and most ineffectual of the Occupation officers. He's a borderline Butt Monkey who's efficiency sees a temporary boost before he's knocked back down to Ineffectual Sympathetic Villain. As the show goes on he get's gradually worse, from his reveal as the Torture Technician, to his actions in Rendezvous, which start with him walking into a prison cell and murdering the occupants just to test a weapon and go downhill from there.