Follow TV Tropes

Following

Downer Ending

Go To

https://static.tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pub/images/hamlet_gnsp.png
"The rest is silence."
"Oh, somewhere in this favored land the sun is shining bright;
The band is playing somewhere, and somewhere hearts are light,
And somewhere men are laughing, and somewhere children shout;
But there is no joy in Mudville — mighty Casey has struck out."
— The final lines of Ernest Thayer's Casey at the Bat

Many stories have a Happy Ending. Sometimes, the characters have to earn it. Sometimes, a random last-minute swerve saves the day. And sometimes, things are kind of dark, but ultimately look like they'll work out.

But sometimes, there is no happiness in the ending. Sometimes, there's a Downer Ending; an ending where the curtain falls on an upsetting, depressing, or bleak scene. While there might be a small bit of light in the darkness, the story has still come to a close with everything in a worse place than where it started. Simply put, it's where a work has an ending that's designed to make the audience sad.

Downer Endings typically come in two flavors:

  1. A finale to a movie, a TV series or an episode of that TV series, a video game, or some other form of media that ends things in a way that varies from sad to tragic. These tend to be rare, as there is overwhelming pressure to tie loose ends up in a "happy" way. Sometimes done as a way to assure that the show, once canceled, cannot be revived later (similar to the Grand Finale), but sometimes leaves the show on a cliffhanger.

  2. A similarly low-key or unhappy ending to an episode of a normally "happy" series. Also rare, due to the same reasons as above. Sometimes used in an attempt to get Emmy nominations, or to at least surprise the viewer. When the series finale of an otherwise "happy" series is one of these, it's a Sudden Downer Ending.

Downer endings have effectively been used to drive home an episode's Aesop. For some issues, it's the only effective way to deliver the message.

Sometimes, a downer ending can conclude the character arcs in a very satisfying way, despite (or because of) being dark, if the characters are Villain Protagonists and people feel that they got what was coming to them (unless the ending is a downer because the villain protagonists win). This is not an absolute rule, however, and there are cases where the audience can have enough sympathy and pity for the characters in question, especially if they sympathetic qualities and poignant moments that can lead more into an Alas, Poor Villain perspective, especially when the character in question was once a hero. Other times, it can be overused to the point it feels like a Mandatory Twist Ending. If it comes out of nowhere or is the result of an Ass Pull, then it may be the result of the writers summoning Diabolus ex Machina. If enough people consider it fundamentally unjust, it may acquire the Fanon Discontinuity and Snicket Warning Labels.

"Everybody Dies" Ending, Shoot the Shaggy Dog, and The Bad Guy Wins are particularly cruel variations of this. A Prequel may require one, or both; the Happy Ending was Doomed by Canon. It can be resulted into this if the protagonist is doomed since the beginning and dies at the end, except when they get a cure or miracle for this.

If the ending mixes elements of happiness and Downer Ending, then it's a Bittersweet Ending. If the whole adventure leading up to it turned out to be meaningless, then it's Shoot the Shaggy Dog. The Cliffhanger is often a Downer Ending, but one that's implicitly not final; tune in next time to see how they retrieve this one. If it's only the main characters who get this, see Only the Leads Get a Downer Ending.

See also Gainax Ending, Bolivian Army Ending, Last Breath Bullet, Crapsack World, Yank the Dog's Chain, and It's a Wonderful Failure. Occasionally, part of a Tragedy or an Utsuge. Sometimes a Foregone Conclusion, either because of a historical setting or if the work is a Prequel. The hero may or may not die. Some video games feature this as a Non-Standard Game Over, and in games with Multiple Endings, it's not uncommon for at least one of them to be a total bummer- though it’s very uncommon (and downright spiteful) for all of them to be downers. Realization of an Inferred Holocaust may turn even the happiest of "happy endings" into one. When it’s caused by the work being unfinished, it’s a Accidental Downer Ending. Compare Downer Beginning. Contrast Happy Ending.

Note: This is a Spoilered Rotten trope, that means that EVERY SINGLE EXAMPLE listed in the subpages below is a spoiler by default and most of them will be unmarked. This is your last warning, only proceed if you really believe you can handle the subpages.


Example subpages:

Other examples:

    open/close all folders 

    Art 
  • As of the last painting of Marriage A-la-Mode, the Earl has been killed in a duel, Silvertongue has been hanged for his murder, and the Countess has committed suicide. The title cannot pass to their now orphaned daughter, and the circumstances of her parents' deaths also mean she cannot inherit what remains of their money; she has, however, inherited her father's case of syphilis (the braces on her legs also indicate a case of rickets), so she'll be lucky if she lives long enough to have children of her own (who will also have syphilis).

    Animation (non-Western) 
Asian Animation:
  • The Chinese short film Miss Daizi ends with the main character surviving suicide attempts in the state of depression in a future, landfilled Earth.
  • Qin's Moon ends nearly all of their seasons with one.
    • The OVA, Birdsong in Hollow Valley ends with Ink Crow dying from his wounds protecting White Phoenix and Nong Yu from Ji Wuye and helping them escape from his palace. However, Nong Yu, who poisoned herself, reveals to White Phoenix that there was never an antidote, causing her to die as well. White Phoenix, all alone, gets approached by Crimson Snake and Wei Zhuang, only to be told that he can only blame himself for being unable to do anything to prevent his friends's deaths.

Eastern European Animation:

    Audio Drama 
  • At the end of the Big Finish Doctor Who story Pretty Lies, the Doctor and Cardinal Ollistra leave the planet Beltox, assured that they saved as many people from the Dalek destruction of the city of Fergill as they could and that, now they're no longer harbouring Time Lords, the Daleks have no reason to continue threatening the Beltoxians. The last scene is the Daleks, being Daleks, blowing up the entire planet out of sheer spite.
  • Stan Freberg's musical Audio Play "Green Christmas" is a protest against Commercialized Christmas starring updated versions of characters from A Christmas Carol. Bob Cratchet is an Honest Corporate Executive who tries to convince his greedy boss Scrooge that Christmas is more than just another opportunity to make money. But this time, Scrooge does not do a Heel–Face Turn, and the story ends with Cratchet sadly accepting that Scrooge will never change.
    Cratchet: But don't you realize Christmas has a significance, a meaning?!
    Scrooge: A sales curve! Wake up, Cratchet, it's later than you think.
    Cratchet: I know, Mr. Scrooge, I know.

    Comic Strips 
  • Japanese Slice-of-Life comic strip This Croc Will Die In 100 Days, as you see in the title, in the last episode, after having a springtime picnic event with The Crocodile and his friends, The Mouse went home using his motorbike. He stopped when the traffic light went red, taking a picture of beautiful cherry blossom trees using his smartphone and send it to The Crocodile. Then a chick crossed the road, but then the traffic light went green while the chick was on the middle of the zebra-cross road, so The Crocodile bursts in and saved the chick from getting hit by a car, but instead, it was vaguely implied he got killed off-screen after his Heroic Sacrifice.
  • Dick Tracy: The Model Jones story in the 1950s. It is a story of Junior Tracy's first love, a lovely girl whose homelife is a total wreck with drunken parents and a bullying small time hood brother named Larry. As Junior and Model's relationship grows, Larry murders a police officer while robbing parking meters. Model learns of this crime and tries to keep Junior out of her life by pretending to reject him with a sneering façade. However, Junior learns the truth, is profoundly touched by her concern and seeks her out to try to resolve the situation by bringing Larry to justice. Unfortunately, Model impulsively tries to confront Larry herself to convince him to give himself up, but Dick Tracy and troopers arrive before the argument could be resolved. The siblings struggle, Larry's gun goes off and Model is mortally wounded. While Larry is chased and caught by Tracy while Sam Catchem quickly radios medics, her condition is hopeless. Eventually, Model dies in Junior's arms and the only tarnished silver lining is Model's family, the ones who responsible for this tragedy, are utterly destroyed by the consequences of their actions with Larry facing murder and resisting arrest charges.
  • Garfield: The April 17, 2022 strip gives a bad ending to Garfield.note 

    Fairy Tales 
  • The Yellow Dwarf. The titular villain ends up murdering the hero, and the bereaved heroine dies of grief not long after.
  • The Ram (also known as The Wonderful Sheep), by Madame d'Aulnoy (who also wrote The Yellow Dwarf). The titular ram, who has previously declared that losing his beloved princess, Merveilleuse, would cost him his life, waits for her in town, but is forbidden from entering the palace. Merveilleuse told her father that the ram was actually a prince, but she was so excited in telling him that she lost track of time. The ram waits such a long time that by the time Merveilleuse sees him, he has died, leaving Merveilleuse with a broken heart.
    • Some retellings have Merveilleuse die as well.
  • Babes in the Wood is usually known as a pantomime in which the two titular children, having been abandoned in the woods by their wicked uncle, are rescued by either fairies or by friends of Robin Hood. The original ballad has a far less pleasant scenario: after being abandoned in the wild wood, the two children starve to death.
  • Frau Trude by the Brothers Grimm. The titular witch turns the protagonist into a block of wood and throws her into the fire.
  • The Poor Boy in the Grave. The protagonist is killed, and his abusive master and his wife lose their home.
  • The Maiden and the Beast, a Portuguese version of Beauty and the Beast. It ends with the beast dying, the heroine dying soon afterwards, and her sisters being reduced to poverty.
  • Although it's gone through Disneyfication over the years, the original Little Red Riding Hood definitely falls under this: the little girl is devoured, rather messily, by the wolf, who gets off scot-free and wanders away. No brave hunter in this version, nope!
  • The original version of Hans Christian Andersen's The Little Mermaid. No happy ending for you.
    • Many other of Andersen's works do not end well. The Little Match Girl ends with a girl freezing to death, and the princess in The Swineherd does not learn her lesson and is rejected by the prince.
  • The Slavic fairy tale The Three Treasures of the Giants sets up a happy ending where Jack, the hero, receives a magic table, cornet, and bag from giants, marries a princess, and becomes a wise king. However, the story continues, and Jack's descendants grow proud and neglect the king's treasures. One king thrusts the treasures into a cellar. Years later, the king's grandson searches for the treasures to defend himself from an invading army. He finds the treasures, but all the magic has faded from them due to neglect.
  • The Romanian fairy tale The Death of the Sun-Hero ends with its protagonist having his tongue ripped out by a crab and dying soon afterwards. For no good reason as well! He was supposed to protect a tree for nine days and nine nights from wolves and actually managed to stay awake for eight days, before succumbing to slumber and falling asleep. A lady in black appears and condemns him, ignoring that humans have to sleep!
  • Many fairy tales from sub-Saharan Africa feature sad endings. A prime example is The Rover of the Plain, where a husband loses his wife and fortune due to her laziness and neglect of her buffalo, and the husband feeling humiliated for not obeying his parents.
  • Anguillette by Henriette-Julie de Murat. Hebe, the heroine, is warned by the fairy Anguillette that her love life may be fatal. She falls in love with a prince named Atimir, who later falls in love with her sister Ilerie. Hebe marries another prince, while Atimir marries Ilerie, but Hebe and Atimir still pine for each other, despite Anguillette's warnings that Hebe must never see Atimir again. Eventually, Atimir duels with Hebe's husband. Atimir dies, and when Hebe sees the lifeless bodies, she commits suicide. Hebe's husband turns out to have survived the duel.
  • The Palace of Revenge, also by Murat. The protagonist, Imis, and her lover Philax are shut up in the Palace of Revenge by the evil spirit Pagan because Imis had rejected him in favor of Philax. Imis and Philax eventually find a way out, but have grown so sick of each other that they do not marry. (A rare fairy tale example of a sad ending where the protagonists do not die.)
  • Joliette by Jeanne-Marie Leprince de Beaumont. The protagonist, Joliette, has a penchant for gossiping and tattling. Eventually, her gossiping gets her in serious trouble when a gentleman overhears her gossiping to his wife that her husband told her that the man was dishonorable. The man later proceeds to kill Joliette's husband. Upon seeing her husband's dead body and realizing what a horrible mistake she made, Joliette impales herself on the sword that killed him. Joliette's mother dies right afterwards.
  • Judar and His Brethren, a story from the Arabian Nights. Judar is poisoned by his brothers after he becomes sultan.
  • In the anthology book Ask the Bones: Scary Stories from Around the World, there's a story titled Nowhere to Hide about a princess who refuses to marry anyone who doesn't beat her at a three-day game of hide-and-seek. Anyone who challenges her but loses gets his head cut off. The protagonist wants to marry her, but isn't good at hiding. So he asks for the help of a djinn... then when he challenges the princess, on the first day the djinn turns into a fish and hides the man in his mouth. The princess doesn't find him. The second day, the djinn becomes a bird and hides the man under his wing; once again, the princess doesn't find him. On the third day, the djinn digs a hole under the princess's floorboards and hides the man there. The man listens to the princess magically search for him until the third day is nearly up, and is relieved that he won't get beheaded... then the princess stomps her foot in tantrum and the floor breaks under her feet. She looks down the hole...
  • The Blueberry ends with the heroine crying her heart out, forever away from home, and eventually turning into a blueberry.
  • Hans Christian Andersen's "The Little Match Girl" is about a poor girl trying to sell matches on a freezing New Year's Eve. After failing to sell any matches and desperate to stay warm, the girl begins to light them to use them herself, all while hallucinating better times she's had with her late grandmother. In the end, she's used up all her matches and frozen to death, with her body being found by passers-by the next morning on New Year's Day. Ameliorated by the epilogue showing she has gone to Heaven, where she becomes reunited with her grandmother and nothing can hurt her again]].
  • Alexander Afanasyev's "Kolobok": The main character -a sentient little bun- is eaten by a cunning fox. Meanwhile, the poor old couple who baked it is left with nothing to eat.

    Podcasts 

    Professional Wrestling 
  • Triple H's feud with Cactus Jack ends with him retiring Mick Foley at No Way Out 2000. Mick Foley kinda gets a Hope Spot by being reinstated for one night to compete in the title match main event at WrestleMania 16 (or 2000 as it was also title in honor of the new millennium) but he just ends up getting eliminated in the middle of the match by Triple H.
    • Speaking of which up to this point all WrestleMania's ended with the babyface winning in the main event. However WrestleMania 16 ended with Triple H beating The Rock thanks to Vince McMahon turning on The Rock. Even though The Rock kinda got revenge by giving Stephanie McMahon the Rock Bottom and the People's Elbow at the end, Rock still lost the match. At least The Rock overall won the feud.
  • WrestleMania 17 ended with "Stone Cold" Steve Austin turning heel and teaming up with Vince McMahon.note 
  • Triple H's feud with Booker T in which he went on about how people like Booker T don't get to become champion and after all the build up to WrestleMania 19 with this story line-Triple H wins. This was hugely criticized by fans for a varied of reasons ranging from how Triple H came off as a huge racist in the feud and by beating Booker T essentially proved the racist was right, to how it took at least a minute for Triple H to pin Booker T after hitting the pedigree on him which in turn made Booker look really weak.note 
  • The Undertaker's legendary winning streak at WrestleMania tragically coming to a end when Brock Lesnar beat him at WrestleMania 30.
  • Survivor Series 1997, depending on whose side you are on could count for this. The Montreal Screwjob where Bret Hart legitimately got double crossed and screwed out of his belt and also humiliated in his home country.
  • At Ultima Lucha in season 1 of Lucha Underground, pretty much every heel won their match, with maybe only one or two exceptions.
    • A year later at Ultima Lucha 2, Pentagón Jr. had a big rematch against Matanza Cueto for the title where he trained intensely to beat him, yet Matanza still wound up winning against Pentagon Jr.
  • Dusty Rhodes never got any revenge against Ted DiBiase who pretty much beat Dusty in every match they had.
  • Kofi Kingston's WWE Title reign came to an end when Brock Lesnar beat him on the first episode of SmackDown on FOX in less than ten seconds. Afterwards, Kofi never even tried to reclaim the belt, or showed any sign that the loss of what's supposedly the top championship in wrestling bothered him at all and was promptly shuffled back into the midcard tag team scene, which, if anything, attracted even more criticism than the squash loss itself.
  • Every major main event of WrestleMania since 2021 has seen the company's top heel Roman Reigns defeat the all-conquering white-hot babyface challengers.

    Radio 
  • Big Finish Doctor Who:
    • "Lucie Miller/To the Death" has one of the biggest Downer Endings in Doctor Who, surpassing all the New Who endings. Tamsin is killed senselessly by the Daleks, upsetting the Monk. Alex and Lucy die defeating the Daleks, and by the end the Doctor is left broken.
    • To make matters worse, and crossing into Live-Action TV, "The Night of the Doctor" short that serves as the sendoff for the Eighth Doctor confirms that the audios are canon in the context of the TV show. As it turns out, the Eighth Doctor hit the Despair Event Horizon afterward when his choice not to fight in the Time War and instead try to save lives didn't do much good. When he was fatally wounded and urged by the Sisterhood of Karn not to give up on his own life for the sake of the universe, he chose to give up his ideals instead, regenerating into the warrior responsible for the genocide of both the Daleks and his own people that brought the war to an end. The subsequent Doctors refuse to acknowledge this incarnation for centuries afterward, until the events of "The Day of the Doctor" allow for a happier outcome to the Time War — which still doesn't make up for the Eighth Doctor's miserable descent into despair.
    • Another spectacular example from Big Finish, "The Holy Terror," concludes with the Doctor and Frobisher unable to save anyone. Frobisher's attempts to teach free will to the people of the Castle end with The Child massacring them - the entire population of the world dying horrible while begging Frobisher for a miracle he can't provide. Though the Doctor manages to discover the truth behind the Castle and stop Eugene from carrying on the same cycle of murder and forgetting he's been stuck in for the last few thousand years, he can't free him from his Self-Inflicted Hell: unwilling to spend another cycle in the prison dimension but unable to forgive himself, Eugene allows the Child to kill him. In the end, the Doctor and Frobisher are the only survivors of the entire story, and both of them are horribly traumatized by what they've encountered.
    • "Project Lazarus" has the rare distinction of having two downer endings: the Sixth Doctor's part in the story ends with the Doctor barely escaping the Forge alive, his attempts to cure Cassie having been All for Nothing; Cassie herself has been murdered by Nimrod, leaving her son an orphan; finally, Evelyn is deeply shaken and not at all happy at the Doctor's attempts to bounce back from the disaster. Worse still, it's also revealed that Evelyn is actually suffering from a serious heart condition - one of the reasons why she decided to go travelling with the Doctor in the first place - and might not be around much longer. Meanwhile, the Seventh Doctor's story ends with the Forge's base in ruins and the Huldran able to escape without being dissected... but Nimrod is still alive and setting up a new base in London, the clone of Six died in despair with the rest of his brothers, and the few sympathetic base personnel were either murdered by Nimrod or died saving the Doctor. Seven, needless to say, is left shell-shocked by this incident and decides that it's time to return home...
    • The Unbound story "He Jests At Scars" ends with the Valeyard's efforts to alter history in his favour blowing up in his face, resulting in a cascade of temporal paradoxes that force him to retreat to his TARDIS full time in order to escape the collapse of the universe. In order to prevent him from doing even potential damage to history while the universe recovers, the TARDIS effectively paralyzes him, leaving him trapped in the console room with only a virtual reality scenario to keep him occupied... until power drain forces the TARDIS to shut down that, too. Worse still, Mel - having been sent to stop the Valeyard - ends up trapped along with him, leaving her mission to bring back the Doctor's personality a failure. In a final jab to the heart, it's revealed that the TARDIS will soon have to mute the two of them so their speech can't cause any potential damage either, leaving the Valeyard and Mel paralyzed and speechless for all eternity. The story ends with Mel using her last few seconds of speech to whisper that she just wants to go home, and the Valeyard futilely apologizing for everything before he too falls silent forever.
  • Dimension X's "Pebble in the Sky": Because Joseph Schwarz and the Synapsifier are removed from this adaptation of Pebble in the Sky, the happy ending of the original cannot occur and Dr Arvardan predicts that all humanity will die, except for those native to Earth, and the science needed for interstellar travel will be lost.

    Sports 
  • The Holocaust is the setting of Canadian figure skater Roman Sadovsky's long program from the 2018-2019 and 2019-2020 competitive seasons, which features music from Schindler's List. His costume evokes the filth and blood of a concentration camp prisoner, and the jumps represent hard labour. It's the darkest program in the sport to date because Sadovsky maintains a haunting, grim tone throughout his performance. It ends on a hopeless note, as his character doesn't get rescued. His final pose consists of looking up to the sky (or the ceiling of his cell) with his arms outstretched as if pleading for help from the heavens, but the only response he receives is an ominous-sounding wind gust. It's Truth in Television because for nearly all victims of genocide, there is no happy ending.

    Tabletop Games 
  • Though Vampire: The Masquerade ends with Gehenna, a vampire apocalypse, most of the potential Gehenna scenarios end on a surprisingly hopeful note. However, "The Crucible of God" scenario has three alternative endings, one of which is specifically intended for players who enjoy downers: "The Rest Is Silence" features the Antediluvians draining all life from the face of the planet in their respective quests for godhood; every single species on the planet is driven into extinction, leaving Earth completely barren and lifeless. The only survivors are the players, and now that humanity is dead as the rest of the world, they have nothing left to feed on except each other; from there, they either commit suicide via sunlight, or sink into Torpor for all eternity. For added misery points, the instructions suggest that this final decision should be made in the decaying remains of the Garden of Eden, the only safe haven from the Antediluvians' death-throes.
  • Warhammer 40,000: No matter how you look at it, the human race is screwed: The God-Emperor's life support is failing, the Necrons are waking up, the Orks are everywhere, the Eldar are dying/being eaten by a God of Evil, Chaos can't be beaten as long as emotion still exists, and of course, the Tyranids will eat everything.
  • Warhammer has the aptly named "The End Times" series, which each book the heroes take a progressive beating, and it starts out with Chaos forces overrunning almost everyone and the Lizardmen pulling a "Screw this we're outta here". The final book in the series, Archaon, apparently pulls an Apocalypse How on the setting, destroying the very universe itself at the behest of the Chaos Gods.
  • The storylines of some Magic: The Gathering sets and blocks have particularly nasty Downer Endings, since the next one will typically take place in an entirely different world anyway. In particular, "Scars of Mirrodin" ends with Mirrodin losing and Phyrexia's rebirth, "Khans of Tarkir" actually ends up with Tarkir a worse place after Sarkhan's temporal meddling leads to the clans being conquered by dragons instead of exterminating them, and "Theros" ends with Elspeth's needless death at the hands of Heliod.
  • The board game Defictionalization of Jumanji can have this happen in some playings. Each time a player lands on a space, the rest of the players have a limited amount of time to use their "rescue die" to save the player from the game's hazard they drew, otherwise said hazard manages to escape into the real world. Failure to do this ten times results in an automatic loss for all players.
  • The Purist play mode of Trail of Cthulhu is meant to emulate your average Cosmic Horror Story in its most austere and bleak mood. The Purist scenario The Final Revelation ends with the PCs discovering that horrible alien gods have ALREADY devoured their reality before the scenario even began. The PCs immediately go insane as their world dissolves into surreal nightmares.

Top

Mr Bean's car gets destroyed

Mr. Bean is too busy eating chocolate to realise his car has been crushed by a tank.

How well does it match the trope?

5 (4 votes)

Example of:

Main / DownerEnding

Media sources:

Report