Accidental Aesop: Going through the book's history, it seems that many of the problems could've been avoided had certain people learned to live and work better with others, understood that their value systems need to change overtime, or just let go of their grudges with certain characters. Sally follows this when she talks to the Prowers and forms the council, but many of the councilors didn't let go of their grudges with the royal family or Freedom Fighters. Similarly many arcs involve the heroes making Fire-Forged Friends with previous adversaries or being forced to let go of previous grudges, a lot of which were formed by hubris and poor communication (eg. Sonic with Knuckles, Monkey Khan and Silver).
Accidental Innuendo: Almost certainly unintentional, but still: Lupe comes from the word Lupa, which is Latin and means either she-wolf, or, well...
It's generally agreed that "Iron Dominion" overstayed its welcome. Some are willing to forgive for setting up the epic "Genesis" story arc, but this is far from universal.
Some also blame the unfinished Mecha Sally arc as much on it's lagging pace as the copyright enforced retcon. Had it been padded less excessively, the original continuity could have possibly gotten a more proper ending.
The "Shattered World" arc is starting to lean into this since it's been going on for nearly three years now. The "Worlds Unite" crossover (Which is generally considered a major step down from the first crossover) popping up in the the middle of the story and delaying things only compounded this.
Ironically, after "Worlds Unite", the general consensus in the later issues was that the arc was rushed due the Strictly Formula format in Key Guardians part of the story, the Master Emerald subplot taking up around half of each issue and the lack of development of the Sonic Unleashed characters, especially Chip. Be Careful What You Wish For indeed...
Archive Panic: It can be hard to get into the comic at first because of its vast, complex backstory developed over 200 issues, any one of which can be referenced at random in a newer issue. Though thanks to the retcon, it provides a good jumping on point without having to worry too much about history.
Author's Saving Throw: Ian Flynn's fans believe he has managed to pull off a lot of these, especially regarding plots left dangling or satisfied unsatisfactorily by the previous author.
A few also see the post-Sonic the Hedgehog/Mega Man: Worlds Collide issues this as well. They essentially save a comic that had many of its characters and lore ripped out due a lawsuit from an embittered ex-writer, by flip-flopping the focus from SatAM material to Sega material.
When it comes to individual characters, "Sonic Universe 50" and "Sonic the Hedgehog 256" are deliberate saving throws in regards to MetalSonic since they both address the character’s Adaptational Wimp status in the comic (which was becoming a very loud criticism up to that point), with SU 50 giving Metal a rematch against Shard (who effortlessly destroyed Metal previously) and effectively winning, albeit by self-destructing, and 256 had Metal Sonic fighting against Amy, Cream, and Sally (all three being formidable Action Girls in their own ways) at once without damage and was only defeated after Tails dropped a missile on him, which even then only destroyed his legs- the rest of Metal was perfectly intact.
“Sonic the Hedgehog 267” and “Sonic the Hedgehog 283” seemed to be attempted saving throws for CreamtheRabbit, who has been woefully underutilized throughout the comic and rarely shown taking action or overall contributing (even after the Reboot has her become a Freedom Fighter, although that’s “justified” by Sally constantly commanding Cream to stay out of missions and battles), with 267 having Cream leading the rescue for the rest of the Freedom Fighters from a death trap and 283’s solicitations labeling Cream as the “central hero” for the story. But whether either or both issues actually succeeded is debated since Cream didn’t receive any acknowledgement for her effort in 267, and continued being sidelined by Sally afterwards, and while 283 gave Cream a bit more focus, her actual role was to merely deliver the McGuffins to a vault. Or rather accompany Big the Cat, who has been rather heavily utilized thus far, as he makes the delivery. However, “Sonic the Hedgehog 285” can be considered a big step in the right direction if not an Author's Saving Throw as that issue has Cream finally demonstrate her Badass Adorable side by stomping on the head of BarkthePolarBear and forcing the enemy team to retreat, and then after attempting to give chase Cream goes on to personally take care of the Badniks attacking the city.
Shadow the Hedgehog gets this amongst the main cast, he goes from one of the most unstoppable opponents and formidable major players in the real Sonic cannon to a peer of not only Sonic, but Amy (it was a curbstomp but Shadow had to rely on teleportation to dodge Amy's attacks which is overkill since he already incapacitated her with a kick in the first exchange) and Knuckles in combat. He can barely defeat big bads on his own, puts more effort in defeating weak characters like Amy and is overshadowed against even Robot Masters his rival can defeat in seconds in other continuities, as well gets teased and annoyed easily by other characters to the point it's casual contrary to the original games where his presence meant serious business and a grave immense tension.
Princess Sally Acorn. Oh, Princess Sally Acorn. Depending on who you ask, she’s either the absolute best female Sonic character, if not the best overall character in the franchise, who is the perfect foil and love interest for Sonic, a proactive Action Girl, has a loving personality, and a positive influence on all the characters. Or a very boring and unlovable character whose influence has a very negative impact on the other characters (especially Sonic and, as of recently, Cream), reeks of Positive Discrimination, and a Faux Action Girl. Not helping matters at all is Sally’s prominent usage, which has increased even further ever since Ian Flynn took over as head writer of the comics, causing detractors to label her as a blatant Creator's Pet. And that's without getting into the shipping side of things...
Geoffrey St. John. Some people see him as a sympathetic guy who was fed a bunch of lies as a child which lead him to making the biggest mistake of his life which he regrets wholeheartedly. Other see him as a boy who was fed a lot of lies as a child but should have know better than to trust Naugus a known Villain and a jerkass who crosses several moral lines by betraying and/or manipulating his friends who are citizens in the country his is trying to protect. Added points for the latter seeing how he knew his wife would be against any of this from the start.
"Sonic Live" (in which Sonic and pals travel to the real world and interact with real kids) and Super Special #17 (a crossover with characters from Image Comics of all places). So much so that neither is considered canon by fans or the creators.
Seasonal Rot is largely the cause of this. Where did the Dork Age start? Where did it end? Did it end? Was Sally's Chickification justified, or was it a hideously huge breach of established character just to sink the fanbase's largest ship? The typical benchmarks are that the series started to decline after Endgame, took a full-on nosedive during the Bem/Xorda arc, and has only started recovering since issue #160 with Ian Flynn being head writer.
The reboot's set off a whole new schism among fans between those who like it and those who don't.
The original Dr. Ivo Robotnik, during the Great War, intended to test weapons he'd developed for the government on his own people and fled to the Mobians' side when he was to be punished for his actions. While acting as warlord for King Acorn, he secretly captured a peaceful village of Mobian monkeys and utilized them in an early attempt to create mechanical slaves by surgically implanting cybernetics, and of that entire village only one survived the process. Afterwards, he sabotaged the roboticizer developed by Charles Hedgehog just as it was to be used on his wounded brother Jules, making him think he'd turned his own brother into a mindless drone. When Jules's wife discovered the truth, Robotnik had Jules toss her into the Roboticizer and transformed into a robian as well, orphaning Sonic and crushing Charles's spirit to the point of retiring from being a Science Minister to running a chili dog stand. He then did similarly to Tails's father Amadeus on the day of his birth, making it seem as though Amadeus could care less for his newborn son and subsequently shattering his wife's heart, throughout which Robotnik maintained a straight face. Afterwards followed his betrayal of King Acorn and the takeover of Mobius, during which countless families were broken and millions enslaved, and over the course of a decade, he'd wreak havoc upon planet Mobius, destroying the ecology and pushing more than a few mobian breeds to the brink of extinction. And just prior to his death, he displayed a deeply disturbing relish at the thought of murdering one of his own kind and was positively gleeful when he got the chance to use his latest and greatest weapon on a fellow overlander.
General Kage Von Stryker is the leader of the Eggman-backed Dingo Regime. After ousting his father from power, Kage led his people in conquering Angel Island, imprisoning the Echidnas in what were clearly concentration camps, which led to countless deaths. He personally tortured Knuckles's father for the location of the Master Emerald, tried to wipe out the last echidna village on two occasions, and during the second attack boasted that he had crushed more Echidnas under his boot than he could remember. While like Helmut, Kage also hated the echidnas, unlike his father, Kage just wanted to Kill 'em All.
Dr.Finitevus was once a fellow scientist of a race of prosperous echidnas, until a freak accident changed his looks and intelligence. Despite his new-found genius, he was declared mentally unstable and was to be put down. He escaped and later sold out his home to Dr. Robotnik, resulting in everyone who had once lived there dying later. In addition, Finitevus manipulated four whole sides in a war—Dingoes, Echidnas, and two Dark Legion factions—into providing the fuel for the fire of his master plan, which is him deciding the world is hopelessly corrupt and wanting to purify it...in fire. He, to this end, manipulated Dimitri, a head in a jar, into providing secrets and information, and then manipulated Knux into becoming Knuxerjak and starting a battle with his former friends after the whole corruption from power thing. Finitevus's expression at the scene where Knux becomes Enerjak shows he is not only mad, but completely delighted, even as his betrayed allies watch on and denounce him.
Hunter is a sociopathic Overlander known as a poacher of the Mobian kind. Hunter first debuts forcing Knuckles and his partner Monk into a hunt for their lives by threatening to murder Julie-Su, forcing the two to fight for their lives which ultimately leads to Monk's death. Though seemingly killed afterwards, Hunter is saved by Dr. Eggman and allows Hunter further work in his service, giving Hunter the chance to gleefully participate in Eggman's genocidal hunts and capture scores of innocent Mobians to have the life tortuously drained out of them in Eggman's Egg Grape Chambers, leading to the deaths of dozens. Proudly boasting of the various heads he keeps on his own wall of previous victims, Hunter's supposed sense of honor in his first appearance falls to reveal a sadistic mass murderer who hunts purely for the thrill of it.
Dark Enerjak, the tyrannical ruler of another dimension, is actually a version of Knuckles the Echidna fueled by a desire to make the world a better place, whose Chaos Powers went out of control. While he started out noble, he gradually went more and more insane as time went on, before he considered everyone an enemy. Among his atrocities are the sinking of a continent; the destruction of several enemy cities, such as Station Square, as punishment for their defiance; and the capture of his strongest opponents and ripping their souls out—victims include Sonic, Shadow, Tails, Amy, Sally, and all the villains. He turns the souls into robotic slaves known as "Prelates". His soulmate was one of his victims, and he made sure not to use her soul to form a Prelate until the final battle, when he summoned her to fight their daughter, much to said daughter's disbelief. Dark Enerjak's mainly motivated by his own amusement, despite saying how much of a hero he is at other times. He allowed the Freedom Fighters to exist to give him something to do, sent soldiers to other dimensions to try and find new worlds to conquer, and continued to indulge Silver because of his power to actually give the living God a challenge. He derives joy from people's suffering, as seen with how he forces his own daughter to fight her mother and his former mate and how, upon seeing how upset Silver is at Enerjak using the souls to make his Prelate Army, he summons them all at once.
The first couple of issues of Sonic Universe have this problem. #1 gave such a quick summary of Sonic Rush Adventure that only people who played the game knew what was going on. Also, #1 continued from Sonic X #40 (a whole different series), which continued from Sonic the Hedgehog #196, which was part of a large story arc from the main series. #2 was an adaptation of Sonic Adventure 2 (probably an attempt to explain how it did fit into the continuity, as the original adaptation didn't really tell the reader much of anything about the game's story or how it fit into continuity), but would probably be pretty confusing to anyone who didn't play the original game. It should be noted that they can't get too into the Sonic Rush side of things, as they're apparently forbidden from using Eggman Nega beyond a few ominous references. ...And one "Off Panel" strip.
This is the fate of the pre-Nu252 comics because it relies so much on characters and concepts created by people not named Ian Flynn.
There's also Bean The Duck, an insane Cloud Cuckoolander duck who throws bombs at everything and loves shiny things, and Captain Metal, a crazed version of Metal Sonic who has become a stereotypical pirate that makes hilariously bad jokes and puns (such as saying that Blaze and her allies that their acting crabby right before revealing that he's given himself a ridiculous crab body) and plans to take over the world using the dimensionally displaced Wily Egg (renamed the Egg'O'War).
Dr. Robotnik seems to be developing into this under Ian Flynn's pen, similar to his game counterpart.
Creator's Pet: A character was introduced named Tommy Turtle, a childhood friend of Sonic that had never been mentioned before, but had once taught him a valuable life lesson. He died in his first appearance while performing a Heroic Sacrifice to save Sonic, but about a year later was revealed to not have actually been killed and was brought back. Unfortunately, after bringing him back, the writers didn't seem to have any real idea what to do with him, and attempts to make him more relevant (such as having him become infested with nanobots, causing him to develop Transformers-esque abilities) ended up just appearing ridiculous and making fans hate him. In Sonic Grams while Archie staff admitted that they knew a lot of their fans hadn't liked the character, they'd hoped they could change their tune, showing the clear divide between the staff at Archie at the time and the people actually reading the book. In the end writer Ian Flynn said when compiling a list of the comic's most unpopular characters, Tommy still ranked very high among the fanbase despite efforts to make him popular by previous writers. Tommy was therefore killed off (performing anotherHeroic Sacrifice) and hasn't been seen since.
Different writers have met criticism over over usage of certain cast members. Ken Penders was noted for his expansion of the Echidna brotherhood, which by the end of his run had its population and story background bloated to a convoluted rate. This treatment did not seem mutual with later writers, who decided to limit their numbers and had numerous Echidna characters Killed Off for Real. Ian Flynn however has been noted for his recent usage of Sally Acorn, reestablishing her as an active Freedom Fighter and love interest for Sonic and giving her a fairly notable role in nearly every arc (ranging from main character to prominent supporting character). Granted in both cases there are still a fair amount of supporters, though it's obvious the fanbase is very polarized by their heavy usage in the comics.
Die for Our Ship: Relic the Pika got hit with this the moment she was introduced, both by Knuckles/Rouge shippers and fans of Julie-Su, who felt that introducing another potential love interest for Knuckles so soon after Julie-Su was purged from the comic was hitting a nerve. Notably, she and Knuckles aren't actually romantically involved, and despite some noticeable Ship Tease, Ian Flynn has said he has no plans to make them a couple.
Ensemble Darkhorse: Among the comic-only characters, Scourge has a large following (his girlfriend Fiona Fox and the rest of the Suppression Squad are a semi-case too through association), as do Mina Mongoose and Dr. Finitevus. The fandom rejoiced when Scratch, Grounder and Coconuts were revealed to be returning after more than 100 issues of absence.
One of the few major Brotherhood member to get any big artwork was Spectre, who has one of the most imposing appearances of anyone in the comic.
Nicole, Sally's handheld A.I., had been an ancillary character since almost the beginning of the comic. Then along came Tania Del Rio's "Stargazing", which gave her a Mobian form and sent her popularity right through the roof — and Nicole subsequently catapulted to Major Character status, overtaking even longstanding characters in the fanart department since her debut and never halting since.
Shard the Metal has become pretty popular as well.
From the new reality, Eclipse the Darkling has become rather popular as well. Also, when Breezie the Hedgehog made a triumphant return after near 20 years of absence, the fandom's reception has been overwhelmingly positive.
Metal Sonic is a massive Ensemble Darkhorse in the rest of the franchise, but his portrayal here as a Redshirt Army of drones with no personality was widely seen as Villain Decay. The new Metal Sonic introduced in issue 50 of Sonic Universe was thus massively popular for a) actually having a personality, b) bringing Metal closer to his canon portrayal, and c) being a One-Man Army that made the character scary and badass again.
All of the Egg Bosses in general ever since the reboot. It helps they're written as being far from one-dimensional villains, being morally complex and having their own reasons for joining the Eggman Empire.
Epileptic Trees: There are many fans who believe that Lien-Da and Finitevus were involved at some point during the X Years Later timeline, and that he's the father of her son Rutan (this being mostly due to the fact that the tips of Rutan's dreadlocks are white, like Finitevus' fur.)
Evil is Cool: Pretty much any villain that isn't a Butt Monkey. Notable stand-outs are Dr. Robotnik, Scourge, Mammoth Mogul, the Dark Legion, and Dr. Finitevus.
Lien-Da. A sexy as hell Echidna girl in skintight leather and a habit of whip wielding? What's not to like here?
The Iron Queen has more than a few fans too. As does Finitevus, Scourge, Fiona, and (disturbingly) Snively and Eggman.
Nicole's lynx avatar doesn't look half bad. Iron Nicole looks even better.
Fanon Discontinuity: There are a good number of people that refuse to read the comic after the reboot for three main reasons:
The first reason is for removing every character not owned by Flynn or created by Sega from the comic.
The second reason is for how it was executed. The final storyline before the comics' reboot was not given a proper ending and so many questions and problems were left unanswered (We'd list them, but there are so many, it would likely result in a Wall of Text.) Things would have been fine if the final storyline had a proper ending instead of giving it a combination of No Ending and Cliffhanger, but because it didn't many people wish that they would have finished the old storyline instead of ending it the way it ended.
Finally, for all of the Executive Meddling SEGA has done with the comic ever since its reboot. To name a few examples, the characters cannot have any Character Development unless its approved, Sonic always has to win no matter what and the characters can have no parents or relatives. Before the reboot was forced, the comic was able to have all of that and even more creative liberty but now SEGA is practically breathing down the comics' throat and they are barely giving it any freedom whatsoever. (see the trivia tab for more Executive Meddling SEGA has in place). For these reasons, to many fans, they see it as a shadow of its former self compared to what it used to be.
Clashes also tend to erupt with dedicated fans of the games continuity, with many arguments over which incarnation of the franchise is better and more definitive.
Franchise Original Sin: A lot of the problems with Ken Penders and Karl Bollers's run (too many plot points, too much focus on people other than Sonic, inconsistent art, etc.) later down the line can be traced back to their critically acclaimed earlier days (storylines like "Endgame" and "Metal Madness" are considered excellent to this day). The difference is that back then, the two weren't engaged in constant petty fights with each other over the comic's story direction and the Echidnas weren't Ken's pets. That coupled with the lack of a solid threat or plot now that Robotnik was dealt with, caused the comic to slip into its infamous Dork Age.
It's generally agreed that the comic became genuinely good around the issue 25 mark (which introduced Metal Sonic into the comic and was where the comic developed an actual plot). It lost its beard during the comic's Dork Age and there's debate as to where or if it regrew; some feel that Ian Flynn taking over restored the comic's respectability, others see the reboot as the comic finally doing away with the massive Continuity Snarl and unmanageably large cast (not to mention Sega personally intervening to end Metal Sonic's Badass Decay and get rid of the Romantic Plot Tumor), and of course there are those who feel that it never regrew.
This definitely seems to apply to the 4-issue "Champions" Arc. The reception has generally been positive as most readers note that its probably the best the comic has been in a while. Highlights include, a revamped Ensemble Darkhorse in Breezie, amazingly expressive and vibrant art, and a more character driven plot than what the series usually tries.
From his first introduction Silver mistakenly thought the Freedom Fighter Traitor was Sonic to counter his first Sega in game appearance. His second guess was really made in Sonic Universe 6 where upon realizing the Freedom Fighters disbanded because Queen Sally thought they were no longer needed. Silver guess this but for the first and only time he thought he was wrong. Fast forward a couple hundred comics later and it turns out he was somewhat right.
Issue 3 had everyone think Robotnik got hold of atomic bombs and went over the destruction the weapons could cause. While it turned out he had only gotten a bomb to be used against bugs, later on Robotnik did get atomic bombs. Robo-Robotnik wiped out Future Mobius with them, and Robotropolis got nuked by missiles.
Some fans have noticed that this panel from the old Knuckles comic is a pretty accurate depiction of Penders and what he caused with the lawsuit.
Its either this and/or Harsher in Hindsight, but in October 2013 we saw the release of The Complete Sonic Comic Encyclopedia, which pretty much tells us everything that has happened in the comics since it's release and information on the characters. Unfortunately, this was released five months before the comic's reboot due to the Ken Penders lawsuit. So the encyclopedia covers almost everything that happened in the comic before its reboot making it a good way to remember the old comics' story.
In issue 19, Sonic teams up with several of his alternate counterparts from other worlds to stop Robo-Robotnik; one of the counterparts is a Batman version. Nearly 20 years later, Sonic's current voice actor becomes Batman.
Megabeatman, a Youtube reviewer who reviews the Sonic and Mega Man comics, jokingly called King Acorn of the new universe "Nigel" based off his speech in Sonic Universe #87. Come Sonic #284, we find out that really is his name in this universe.
One early issue featured Tails temporarily becoming a genius. Most later depictions of him (as well as the original) show him as a Child Prodigy, capable of building planes and even a translator for a language he doesn't understand.
"Holy Shit!" Quotient: High during the wham episodes and milestone issues, but the "Endgame" and "Countdown to Chaos" story arcs stand out in terms of sheer HOLY SHIT inducing moments.
Idiot Plot: Done at times, most frequently (but more intentionally) in the earlier comical issues. The Iron Dominion arc in particular dangles a long time for the same of climax build up, relying too much on the entire Freedom Fighter squad being blindly overconfident enough to give the villains blatant advantages (eg. letting Snively go free and ignoring his activity after Eggman's defeat (despite his usual track record), oblivious to the harm a super powered techno mage may have on a city completely composed of artificial life). Sally at least has the decency to Lampshade these were exceptionally stupid moves afterwards, but all the same, surely someone else had enough brain cells to see it coming.
An example is the Endgame arc. Dulcy explains that dragons are able to sense truth, something treated as common enough that Geoffrey St. John, Knuckles, and Espio believe that Sonic's been framed for killing Sally. No one questioned why she wasn't called in before, especially since this story was about the third time Sonic's been framed for treason. Also, it was revealed earlier in Sally's mini-series that Robotnik could make robots that flawlessly imitate real people, so there was no real reason for everyone to take this at face value.
Informed Wrongness: Issue #134, where Princess Sally slapped Sonic across the face out of rage after the latter decided to fight in the battlefield to defeat Eggman over ruling by the former's side. While it was indeed wrong for Sally to slap Sonic like that, nobody ever considered the fact that Sonic was about to risk his life another time after he had nearly died twice prior to the issue, and that really put a lot of massive stress on Sally since she had to live with Sonic being gone for a full year, thinking he was dead, not to mention that before that, Sonic became her official consort. While Sonic is the main hero who would risk his life to save those he loves, nothing indicates that he's the most important hero of Mobius that would render any of the other fighters that are more than capable of taking on Eggman just as well useless or otherwise less significant. Plus Sonic's arm was in a cast due to getting burned by a laser gun, meaning that he was not in any condition to fight in the battlefield, and doing so would possibly constitute his demise. However, he doesn't even seem to contemplate this and instead decides to fight Eggman while he's handicap anyway, not to mention that by doing this, he had broke his commitment to Sally after he had promised her to be there for her when she needed his help. So in reality, he's just as much in the wrong as Sally, yet Sally is the one seen as the bitch who fans claim tried to force Sonic to marry her and/or make him give up being a hero, and none of them who love to use this as an excuse to hate Sally actually bother to at least look at her side of the story while Sonic gets treated as the victim all because he's the main hero.
Iron Woobie: Sonic himself. He never lets any of the crap that he gets put through keep him down for long. Even the absolutely brutal Darkest Hour in issue 175 doesn't stop him and he manages to flip it back onto Robotnik 25 issues later.
Sally is also this to a certain extent. Yes, she can get pretty bitchy and has the tendency to overreact at times. But keep in mind that her position as a princess and leader of the Freedom Fighter is very stressful since she has many responsibilities to take care of at such a young age. Let's also not forget that at a tender age of five, she has dealt with loss and death as the world collapsed. Her father was trapped in a void while her mother was presumed dead. Also, she actually witnessed many of her loved ones getting robotocized and/or killed. So to be fair, she's really bossy to those she loves because she cares about them, not to mention that a lot of her jerky moments stems from the intense pressure her father puts her through. It doesn't make some of her bitchy moments right, but it does show that the massive stress she goes through causes her to act emotionally unstable.
It Was His Sled: At this point, if you don't know that Sally was roboticized in issue 230 then you have been living under a rock. Not that it matters, since in the Retcon she isn't roboticized anymore.
Jerkass Woobie: Strangeasitsounds, you could actually make the case for Fiona. She really does have serious abandonment issues and her self-esteem is such that she'd sooner stick by a womanizing creep like Scourge over Sonic when the latter started to question her loyalty to him. Even Word of God has hinted that she's still not all bad.
Scourge himself gets this treatment toward the end of the "King Scourge" arc, even to the point of shedding tears.
Snively is also a classic example. Nothing goes right for the poor guy in his life, so you pity him...but he brings so much of these problems upon himself due to his treacherous nature, so you also think he's an asshole.
Dr. Robotnik during the "Darkest Storm" arc where he's tricked into murdering his own surrogate daughter Mecha Robotnik, the only person he ever truly cared about. At the end of the story he actually lets Sonic walk away sadly commenting that "I've lost a lot today".
Even if your not a fan of him, Geoffrey St. John is definitely one. He felt that working with Naugus would help the Acorn Kingdom in the long run. Remember, when he first met him, he had no idea that Naugus was evil because he was a kid when he first met him and his father had just died so he wasn't emotionally stable. When he does learn that Naugus was Evil All Along and that he wanted to control the council, he hated that idea and he wanted to back out, but Naugus reminded him that there was no way he could stop him. When Silver sits to talk with him later on about how working with Naugus is bad, Geoffrey agrees with him but he says that it's too late for him to change. Geoffrey had good intentions and he believed working with Naugus would have good outcomes. It's too bad things didn't work in his favor. Even worse, because of the comics' reboot in 2013, which removed all characters not written by Ian Flynn or SEGA characters, he will never get a chance to redeem himself.
Les Yay: Arguably, between Sally and Nicole in the Spark of Life storyline. Sally seems to be closer to Nicole than to anybody else, and gets extremely pissed off at Nicole's creator for considering her a failure. Nicole, meanwhile, constantly makes glasses at Sally, teases her, and specifically wanted to see the stars the way Sally did in a flashback.
Magnificent Bastard: Mammoth Mogul most certainly didn't fit the bill for this early on, even though he was clearly meant to be one. An immortal cavemammoth from earth's second Ice Age (it's complicated), Mogul was always plotting and scheming, with the writers trying their darndest to build him up with unlikely Evil Plans for the stories. Nothing worked, and his world domination plans failed again and again and again. He spent more time being imprisoned than anything else. Then one day Mogul wised up and essentially said to the heroes "I just remembered that I'm immortal. So here's my new plan: I'll live in this sweet casino I just had built, amuse myself by taking pot shots at you whenever I can, and wait for you all to die of old age. I can beat you by outliving you."
Dr. Robotnik has taken a majorstep up into this after reasoning himself out of insanity. Probably the most notable example of this is "Genesis" where he successfully manages to manipulate everything so that he can rewrite reality itself. And than after Sonic reverses his rewrite what does he do? Rather than take a total loss he roboticizes the injured Sally while Sonic is distracted, thus giving himself a deadly new weapon that Sonic is terrified of injuring. And he does all of this while casually drinking a glass of wine.
Hope Kintobor to a lesser extent, along with Young Regina Ferrum.
Misblamed: Somewhat. While indeed Ken Penders was a major factor in contributing to the Cosmic Retcon, Archie was likewise to blame for not checking over the polices concerning ownership of characters (which indeed while creators can be credited for their creations, they're, by all rights, the property of the company they make it for to use as they see fit) which in turn lead Penders to find the loophole and lead to the whole legal mess in the first place. Some likewise blame Bioware for apparently sparking this for making characters based on some of Penders characters for their Sonic Chronicles which likewise got him riled, though most will argue that they weren't outright copying his characters and could be seen as a tribute to the characters from the comics (considering the how loose the canon is with this series, Sonic Chronicles could've very well been deemed an Alternate Universe). With Penders just being a jerk about the whole thing because hedidn't write said characters. note Considering he was trying enforce his future on the comic and has been on record stating he wasn't a fan of Ian's style. Even outright admitting if he was ever put back in charge that he would undo Ian's changes, leads some credence to this. Sega doesn't get off scot-free either as they were the ones to enforce the new rules once they settled with Penders, forcing the retcon and in turn losing a good chuck of the cast (most of whom were made by other people), neutering most of the character development, and limited what could be done with characters created by them.
ADAM tricking Robotnik into killing Mecha Robotnik. Even with how evil Eggman is that was just pointlessly cruel.
Thrash has definitely crossed this when he literally made Knuckles the last of the echidnas.
Metal Sonic finally crosses it for good when he seemingly murders Shard.
My Real Daddy: Ian Flynn is considered this for Scourge for giving him a cool and distinctive new look and making him into a more intimidating and complex villain instead of the stereotypical Evil Twin he was before.
Some fans go further with this and consider Flynn the real daddy for the comic in general, though this view is veryfar from universal.
Never Live It Down: Many fans aren't willing to let Sally live down the time she slapped Sonic in anger. Even after repeated displays of remorse from the character, and even a Cosmic Retcon rendering it Canon Discontinuity, there are still fans who will hold it against her.
Out of universe, Ken Penders will forever be known as the guy who took away various characters and made a Continuity Reboot necessary just because he was wanted royalties to characters he created and pretty much tried to enforce his version of the universe on the comic without letting other writers have their turn.
Rescued from the Scrappy Heap: Silver of the much maligned Sonic the Hedgehog 2006. His comic version is liked a lot more because his personality has been changed to a guy who is not very confident in his abilities as a "Set Right What Once Went Wrong" guy. Silver was like that though, but his comic counterpart is much less annoying about it, and is (slightly) more easy to reason with.
Shadow and Rouge. For the longest time, the comic had no idea what to do with either of them after the Sonic Adventure 2 adaptation (which was only one issue long). As Sonic Heroes was rendered moot due to comic events, using them for that was out of the question and the two would make sporadic appearances afterwards, Shadow working with Eggman and Rouge with Evil Sonic. It wouldn't be until Ian Flynn took over that both performed a Heel–Face Turn and lead into the creation of the much beloved Team Dark.
Flynn has also with repeated vigour tried to rescue Princess Sally, mostly concerning her past Sue accusations and trying to present her as a more flawed character. While it's not a universal case by a long shot (some still debate whether he's made her worse), most fans at the very least have let go of her infamous outburst in the Home arc following some displays of remorse from her, not to mention that a lot of her diehard fans have even made comprehensive articles and Youtube videos on debunking the major (and, at the same time, absurd) reasons why many people hate her.
Notably, a number of her former detractors have reacted much more positively to the post-reboot version of Sally, for having a new design more in line with Sega's characters, being much more of an Action Girl (she was arguably a Faux Action Girl until then), and Archie quietly dropping her relationship with Sonic, allowing her (and Sonic) to develop as characters on their own. The Spark of Life miniseries was particularly good to her image, as it was the first time in a while that a story centered around her without relegating her to the role of a bit player (something even her own miniseries couldn't do).
Romantic Plot Tumor: Plagued the comic for quite a long time. Luckily the comic has since moved on.
Ron the Death Eater: Thanks to the writers of the earlier arc, Princess Sally has fallen victim to this a lot. Yes, she did have her moments where she was kind of bitchy and a little bratty at times, but many fans often exaggerate how much of a bitch she really was. They claim that she's spoiled and thinks everyone love her, claim that she treats Sonic worse than she actually has treated him (and, to a slightly lesser extent, Amy, despite the fact that the two are actually close friends), call her selfish even though she's mostly selfless and her only act of selfishness was in issue #134 (which, by the way, people keep endlessly using as evidence that she has always been a bitch, ignoring the fact that it was an Out-of-Character Moment), and even go as far to call her a "slut" for many ridiculous reasons (such as not wearing any clothes despite the fact that she's an anthropomorphic animal covered in fur, or cheating on Sonic despite the fact that the times she dated two of each of the other guys were when she wasn't even in a relationship with Sonic). In reality, Sally, in spite of her occasional outbursts whenever she deals with massive stress, is mostly kind, caring, selfless, and is always there for loved ones. Even after the reboot, however, where she is written much more in-character, there are still fans who demonize her and make these ridiculous claims as of today. It also doesn't help that many of the people who make such hateful and exaggerated claims are fans of Amy Rose, most of whom even make fanfics portraying Sally as the villain who either mistreats Sonic or constantly cheats on him.
Rooting for the Empire: It's easy to root for the Dark Egg Legion. They do take orders from Eggman, but they aren't completely evil, and most of their members seem to be regular Mobians, bar the cybernetics. Given that the heroes are headed by Sonic, who can be a bit of a jerkass, and the Kingdom of Acorn, an incredibly ineffectual monarchy that can barely function, it's no wonder. And they're the only group in the world who don't actively despise technology. A great example is the Great Desert DEL. They were turned into mindless Robian mooks thanks to Unwilling Roboticisation and forced to fight the Sand Blasters, an extremist group of Freedom Fighters. After being turned back into Mobians, they tried to make peace with the Sand Blasters, but where instead hit with Fantastic Racism for being former Robians. In order to survive, they went to Eggman for help, who legionized them. When The Baron, leader of the Great Desert DEL, was confronted about this by his niece, hero Bunnie Rabbot D'Coolette, he responded that being in the DEL isn't so bad. Being legionized means cybernetic upgrades, which in turn make for an awesome health plan, as The Baron pointed out, when he thanked legionization for fixing his "bum knee". He also mentioned something about D'Coolette's being oppressors, which insinuates Fantastic Racism within the Kingdom, making them look even worse.
The DEL's post-reboot counterpart, the Egg Army, also falls into this. While many Egg Bosses, such as Thunderbolt, are pure evil, others, like Clove and Nepthys, are treated sympathetically. Both only joined the Eggman Empire out of desperation rather than loyalty to Eggman. Clove joined so that Eggman could save her sister from a debilitating disease, while Nepthys joined to keep the Eggman Empire from completely taking control of Shamar by locking her division of the Egg Army into a stalemate with her longtime friends, the Shamar Freedom Fighters. Even Conquering Storm, who falls very much into evil on the alignment scale, is shown to be somewhat reasonable compared to the people she's fighting; whereas the different clans of Yurashia are highly antagonistic of one another and refuse to work together, she welcomes anyone and everyone into the Egg Clan, provided they pull their weight.
The Scrappy: Tommy Turtle probably got it the worst, but Dulcy and pre-Character Development Antoine had no few detractors.
Post-Character Development Antoine gets it bad too. The fanbase seems divided whether he was originally an annoying one-note Jerkass, or if maturing his character robbed him of his defining characteristics and made him bland. The poor guy just can't win.
There's also Drago Wolf, a traitor to the Freedom Fighters who was also an abusive dick to his girlfriend and soared over the Moral Event Horizon in "Endgame". He's a massive douchebag and later on joined the comic's resident Psycho Rangers which he promptly contributed absolutely nothing too (in fact he was The Millstone to them). No one likes him in-universe or out and Ian Flynn had gleefully admitted that he only brought the guy around when he wanted someone to be beaten up.
It's commonly pointed out that the post-Endgame stories were this due to the fact that they had intended issue 50 to be the end and when it turned out to still be popular, they were forced into a Post-Script Season, but without their main villain.
Many people now consider the reboot to be this as well. Without the original character that existed for many years, including relatives, being removed from the comic, plus the rules SEGA has enforced on the comic, it is seen as a shadow of it's former self. There's even word that the comic might even be cancelled soon due to poor sales.
So Bad, It's Good: The early comics were pretty much this, being funny due to how lame the jokes were at best. Once it started developing an actual plot, the comic became (arguably) just straight up good.
Signature Scene: The "Endgame" story arc, though this has waned over time. It's also famous for cementing the transition to plot-driven stories and killing off the original Robotnik.
Strangled by the Red String: Antoine and Bunnie Rabbot were thrown together in Endgame with almost no build-up beyond the same issue they got together revealing that Antoine had once saved Bunnie's life. Thankfully, the relationship was well handled after that point, and it was easier to accept than most examples because neither of them had any romantic chemistry with other characters.
To their credit, though, Antoine and Bunnie did show a subtle interest on each other when they first saw the other way back in issue #3 (with a few panels of difference, mind you, but the fact remains). There was also the backup story in issue #23 which included Bunnie saving Antoine's life on a mission, and Antoine kissing her in gratitude. When reprinted in Sonic Archives Volume 4, the creators acknowledge that story as the beginning of their impending romance.
Worse off is the Echidna race - according to Word of God, echidnas have what is called "the Soultouch" - a Sixth Sense that also acts as a literal Red String for them and that once they've found their soul mate, they pretty much stay together, although there are some exceptions. This is why Knuckles and Julie-Su hooked up only after 24 issues and why he hasn't been never up with her.
Strawman Has a Point: Thrash admits he doesn't know exactly why the echidnas experimented on his people note it was to fight Mammoth Mogul's Order Of Ixis, viewed as a horrible crime by echidna society, and would've been reversed had one of the Knights of Albion not turned into the second Enerjak and crippled the civilization at the time, thus making his "justice" more like revenge. But between the Brotherhood of Guardians never fighting Robotnik at all, Albion not getting involved either, the Dark Legion, Enerjak incarnations, and a chapter of the Dark Legion willfully joining Eggman for power (they were trying to recruit the rest of their species into Eggman's army when last seen), he's not exactly wrong in his views.
Mina is depicted as being overzealous and callous for making a public statement about how dangerous NICOLE is and indirectly starting a mass paranoia concerning her. However, as sympathetic as she is, NICOLE was shown to be extremely dangerous as a result of the Iron Queen corrupting her programming, leading to a takeover that led to the Mobians being enslaved and many supposedly legionized (IE. mutilated with cyborg implants). The Freedom Fighters are outraged by Mina's actions and labelled the public as being vindictive, but as she angrily pointed out, people had suffered because of NICOLE, and largely because they were cocky enough to make a huge oversight (it was implied they were taking precautions by that point, though had neglected to console the public about it, and even then it was too little too late for some).
Similarly Hamlin is conveyed as smug weasel who uses a long lived grudge against Sally to try and get the council to persecute her for disobeying orders. However, Sally was the one who created the Council in the first place, and then nonchalantly ignored them when they attempted to make a democratic tactic. When Hamlin pointed out she was undermining their entire purpose (with some other members even agreeing there was substance in this), she gave up her refute and outright blackmailed the Council that she would refuse to help at all. The fact that she so quickly assumed Hamlin only accused out of spite (he had, but he had yet to admit it, and his argument had some ground regardless) and moaned how he could have the heart to call her out only further emphasized her self righteousness on the matter (especially keeping in mind she did the exact same thing to Sonic in the Mecha Madness arc and expected Nothing Personal from it).
While we're supposed to side with Hamlin over his team's being mistreated and forgotten by the Freedom Fighters, despite being an actual team that Sally personally trained, it falls apart because that team was called the Substitute Freedom Fighters. By definition, they go into action when the regular line up can't. Also, his team was led by Larry Lynx, who did volunteer to help Rotor in the past so Hamlin and his teammates could've just asked to help out.
Straw Utopia: It isn't hard to see Mobotropolis (under Ken's penmanship) and Echidnaopolis and Albion as beautiful utopias that only had a few blights to them. Mobotropolis is even more telling as the back stories for the setting tend to paint the kingdom as a peaceful place in stark contrast to the Overlander's Megaopolis, which is shown to be incredibly destructive and polluting. However, under Karl Bollers' penmanship, Echidnaopolis and Albion was ravaged to the ground and, under Ian's penmanship, the rulers of Mobotropolis were seen as idiots who were lead by a mystical force that led them to make incredibly bad decisions. In fact, even after the monarchy turned into a republic, it was shown that most (four out of seven) of the councilors had some grudges with the royalty. To say nothing that those same four councilors just aren't the kind of people you'd want to have a position of government, having very little leadership experience and possibly questionable mental health.
A rather Fridge horrific example as Mobotropolis, Echidnaopolis, and Albion seem almost afraid of change. Mobotropolis and its people rarely developed anything new outside of what the Freedom Fighters use and even the citizens want to bring the old Mobotropolis back and never want to develop anything more or integrate more people into it. Echidnaopolis is worse as it never helps anyone but Echidnas grow but it bans the use of technology as they see it as evil, ignoring the fact that they not only still use it, but could still advance if they were more careful with how they used technologynote For instance, don't make a device designed to siphon huge amounts of Chaos Energy something that the user wears on their body.. Albion is the worst as it's an echidna only society and believes all echidnas should live their cut out from the rest of the world. They even go so far as to not correct the mistakes they made in the past.
Suetiful All Along: Many are accusing Sally of leaning into this. Attempts have been made to place Sally in a flawed light due to her emotional outbursts, with later strips lampshading her treatment towards Sonic. However, it is only Sally herself that comes to this conclusion, which generally only leads others to sympathize with her Heroic BSODs and comfort and justify her actions. The fact that the current writer released a blog on how wonderful Sally is (notably consisting solely of less than discript positive traits) doesn't help this at all.
They Wasted a Perfectly Good Character: A major problem with the comic, especially during the Penders/Bollers era. Because of how these two men operate, established Sega-based characters and characters created by other writers tend to get knocked to the wayside or not even introduced. For instance, Ensemble Darkhorse Bean the Dynamite Duck and Bark the Polar Bear were first introduced game-wise in Sonic the Fighters in 1996. It would be 10 years later, in issue #160, that they'd appear in the comics. There's also the Bird Armada for 'Tails Adventure, which didn't show up into the comics for 15 years. Comic wise, for example, the Iron Queen. She first appeared in issue #60. She is not heard from again for 140 issues. With issue #268, it seems that Ian's reaching back further with the first appearance of Breezie the Hedgehog from Adventures of Sonic the Hedgehog.
While most criticisms about Shattered World are arguable at best, many fans agree that Chip was seriously wasted in the comic. Not only was his role in the story not expanded upon or even given much focus at all but Chip’s friendship with Sonic, which was a core element of Unleashed, is completely glossed over until the very end of the saga. Things wouldn’t have been so bad had Chip got to meaningfully interact with the rest of the cast to compensate but he doesn’t get to do much with Knuckles before he’s inevitably given to the Freedom Fighters and Chip’s bonding with them is only shown in a single page flashback. Chip’s whole Identity Amnesia sub-plot is also removed as Tikal informs Chip of his true nature as Light Gaia the instant she sees him, subsequently taking away the impact of the scene where Chip regains his memories which is instead used for more World Building.
Cream the Rabbit is very often considered an example of this. Ignoring how she didn't officially appear in the comic until 7 years after her introduction in Sonic Advance 2 and is the very last Modern game character to be introduced into the comic, which is entirely due to Executive Meddling, Cream is heavily underutilized. When Cream isn’t being a mere background character, the most she gets to actually do is airlift characters around or other actions that are truly insignificant such as finding a missing folder or serving coffee. Whenever Cream gets to take part in a fight, her attempts to attack are negated for the most part and very rarely does she actually get to land a single hit, which is a massive far cry from her gamecounterpart. Things get even worse for Cream after the Reboot, where she joins the Freedom Fighters but spends the next three years since then on the sidelines literally not contributing at all, seemingly only present to balance the roster between the game cast and the comic exclusives and for Sally to mother over in the same vein as Tails from Sonic SatAM. In fact, Archie!Cream feels like an exact repeat of Sat AM!Tails, which is highly questionable considering how controversial Tails' portrayal in that show was.
Issue 172 probably holds one of the most blatant examples, in fact, a double. First, after Fiona tells Tails that he can't count on anybody before slapping him across the face, she sets Sonic as her prime example due to him leaving her imprisoned back in the mining camp (in the 28th issue of the Knuckles The Echidna comic). Sonic attempts to overrule her point by starting off with "That's no excuse to..." before ending up in another physical spat with Scourge, along with Fiona just tell him to "shut up already". Second, when Sonic and Scourge confront each other about why Fiona chose to be with Scourge, Scourge points out that the only way for Sonic to be like him would be "one bad day", which causes Sonic to counterattack by pointing out that Scourge would be just like him if he showed "a little bit of selflessness" and "a little bit of decency". Scourge is completely at a loss for words at this point... until Fiona abruptly intervenes and kicks Sonic aside, claiming that he "had [his] chance". She even goes on to put him down by claiming that he's a weakling by holding back and that "it's all about survival of the best".
Issue #108 would also count, having both the original and the new Dr. Robotnik together in the same reality...only to have them dink around for a third of the issue before the old one disintegrated.
This is a big complaint about Ian's post-"cleaning up" works, up to and including the Iron Dominion saga; many plot points he brought up during this time (such as the revolution of the Kingdom of Acorn into a republic and Eggman going insane) had lots of potential for interesting stories of their own, but were notoriously prone to Snap Back fever. In fact, this became one of the biggest reasons, alongside Pacing Problems, for why even die-hard Ian fans like to hate on the Iron Dominion saga.
The Mecha Sally arc comes off as this to some fans. A lot of it comes from the fact that she never won a fight and some outside circumstance got in the way of her rescue every time. Also not helping is that it only seemed to happen to explain her redesign which could've been easily explained as a result of the first Genesis Wave having residual effects on some people like it did on Naugus.
The introduction of opposing heroic fractions such as members of the Acorn Council. Having characters who call out or cause alternate conflicts for the main Freedom Fighters could have made for an interesting grey dynamic within the team (not to mention serve as potential catharsis by calling out previous shortcomings of characters such as Sonic and Sally). However they are mostly limited to Strawman Political types with Hate Sink personalities, only appearing as a minor frustration in a handful of issues.
The "Freaky Friday" Flip between Sally and Nicole in issue 146 in the story "Circuit Me" is stated as this. A story like this could have explored the birth of Nicole's desire to be more than just an A.I, experiencing real life activities that would eventually give her even more reason for the idea to create her holo-lynx form in Issue 151 "Stargazing" while Sally experiencing(or more precisely)not experiencing what it is like to be a consciousness stuck in a handheld and learning what it is like to be a Freedom Fighter from Nicole's point of view.....only for it to be resolved in a few pages,shafting it as a Noodle Incident.Only at "Stargazing" is this slighty subverted.More details is in here.
The Mecha Sally arc had potential to be better by showcasing the POV of a victim of the Robotizer. Since Uncle Chuck stated that the roboticized are fully aware of their surroundings and what they are doing the whole time as further evidenced by his own robotization, Sally's inner turmoil was never addressed throughout the story. On another note, instead of "Endangered Species" in Issue 243-246, they could have been addressing the fates of the other plot relevant characters instead.More details is in here.
Some considered the whole Sonic Unleashed adaptation to be this. Other then introducing new Egg Commanders and giving some new backstories. Nothing remotely interesting was done with it. It's very by-the-numbers, doesn't expand or focuses on Chip's role at all, and even the whole drama of Werehog Sonic is quickly glossed over (Eggman doesn't even comment on it in the final battle) and is just used as an extended power-up at best. Some speculate that the staff were feeling stymied by all the newfound restrictions SEGA placed on them and were trying to rush through it so they can get back to original stories.
Unintentionally Unsympathetic: According to Ken Penders, readers are supposed to sympathize with Locke as someone who did what he had to do, and a great father at that. However, fan instead saw him as an abusive dad who was willing to put his unborn son's egg through experiments because of a dream, and even fake a suicide right in front of him. Needless to say, not only the fans, but even other writers on the book didn't see Locke the way Penders did.
Values Dissonance: Covering everything from the systems of government on Mobius to the clothes the characters don't wear.
The Felidae in particular have a lot of this, often tying into their Blue and Orange Morality; they have a culture and society that tends to be pretty harsh by the standards of others, but for the Felidae it's the most natural way of doing things. And that's without getting into their views of clothing... to put it mildly, the Felidae are VERY literal-minded when it comes to official costume and dress; from their viewpoint, what you wear literally determines WHO you are. It's rather confusing to outsiders.
The comic utilises not only it's own original cast, but the games and multiple other interpretations. Sonic Universe is devoted largely to giving supporting characters A Day in the Limelight, with the main series itself shifting in and out with Sonic's prominence.
Princess Sally became this in her own mini series. Her role in the main books being largely to play The Straight Man to Sonic, she was left with little chemistry in his absence, leaving her supporting cast to provide most of the conflict and foibles while Sally simply progressed through the mission. Some argue she was still this when she got her own arc in the main comic years later ("Spark of Life"), which similarly relied on several supporting characters and has a somewhat inconsistent mark on her character (eg. being as reckless as she complains Sonic is).
Vindicated by History: Whereas Ken Penders is considered passe, Karl Bollers is the opposite. Back in the day, many hated Bollers' stories, especially issue 134 where Sonic and Sally broke up. While that story is still hated and his reputation still isn't perfect, he's held in much higher regard than he was, with many of his stories like Return to Angel Island getting more respect. It helps that the man himself has shown himself a good sport about later writers' run on their books, unlike his former colleague Penders.
The Woobie: Post Shattered World, it's really hard not to feel for the nobler members of the Egg Bosses, namely Nephthys and Clove, who are just doing their damnedest trying to stake out an existence of some dignity under Eggman. Clove is effectively a case study of a Broken Bird as she breaks.