Follow TV Tropes


YMMV / Shin Megami Tensei: Persona

Go To

For the other Persona related YMMV subpages:

  • Acceptable Targets: Considering how the games want to focus on The Power of Friendship, loners in general are a major target, especially as the series went on.
  • Complete Monster: See here for a page of the most despicable villains in this sub-series.
  • Fandom-Enraging Misconception: Referring to Persona 3, 4, and 5 as "the Persona series" is sure to hit a sore spot among more hardcore fans, given how Persona 1 and both Persona 2 games tend to be forgotten while the more recent titles get tons of attention and spin-offs.
  • Fandom Rivalry:
    • With JoJo's Bizarre Adventure, due to both having a spirit like entity each character can summon that represents their "true selves", and in Stardust Crusaders, having an Arcana theme. The biggest example is the rivalry between Diamond Is Unbreakable and Persona 4, due to them having similar premises (high-school-aged protagonists trying to solve a murder in a small town, and at least one of the murder victims was hung from a telephone wire).
    • With the main series, due to its popularity overshadowing it and everything else Atlus makes. There are those who actively dislike the spin-off and its fanbase, viewing them as Johnny-come-latelies who can only enjoy watered-down gameplay and thematic compromise. Simultaneously, some fans are only fans of the spin-off and dislike the main series for its stagnant, recycled "order vs. chaos and both are jerks" plots, flatter characters that contrast heavily with the spin-off's heavily character-focused narratives, and its archaic difficulty and gameplay. There are those who enjoy both, but the two series are different enough from one another that there's less overlap than one would think.
    • Advertisement:
    • And with the fandom itself, there's a split of Persona 1/2 Fans vs. 3 and beyond. Katsura Hashino took over as the Series Director starting with the third game, retooling the series both gameplay and tone-wise in the process. While Persona 3 contained a few easter eggs to the early games, it was essentially a Soft Reboot of the franchise. The side effect of this is all the spin-offs moving forward draw from the Persona 3 and beyond games leading to a rivalry of the fanbase.
  • Fanon: People arguing that the canon love interest for every "Fool" bearing protagonist is whoever happens to be represented by the Lovers Arcana in their respective game.
  • Fridge Horror: The Social Link system introduced in Persona 3 can easily be read as you deliberately cultivating "friendships" solely for the purpose of amassing more power for yourself. This is toned down in Persona 5; most of your Confidants befriend you with the explicit understanding that you're getting some material benefit out of the relationship, and a throwaway line by Morgana indicates that he is aware of Social Links and has no issue with it.
  • Friendly Fandoms:
    • Though there have been spats of a Fandom Rivalry as noted above, the fandoms of the Persona series have started to grow tight with JoJo's Bizarre Adventure due to several similarities, especially with involving Fighting Spirits.
    • The Persona and Super Smash Bros. fanbases got along following Joker's addition to Super Smash Bros. Ultimate; the Persona fanbase was excited to see representation in a major fighting game series, and the Smash side have gotten interested into the Persona games.
  • Hilarious in Hindsight: Persona 3 introduces the series's take on The Grim Reaper, who dual-wields guns. Guess what later property features a dreaded-in-universe character with "Reaper" in his name that dual-wields guns?
  • More Popular Spinoff: The Persona games are the most popular commercially and critically acclaimed about of the whole Shin Megami Tensei franchise, specifically the games from Persona 3 onward, with each new main installment surpassing the previous one in both sales and critical acclaim. Persona 5 in particular has become Atlus's best-selling game ever, and it's main character Joker is a DLC fighter in Super Smash Bros. Ultimate.
  • Never Live It Down:
    • The 10 month delay of Persona 4: Arena in Europe gets brought up every time the series is discussed. Regardless of the change in circumstances for the franchise since thennote , the EU fanbase still holds a grudge. Other titles also coming out late didn't help.
    • The number of Persona 4 spinoffs have also been a source of mockery. While well received, it led to a Broken Base of fans upset that Atlus didn't release a proper new entry instead. Persona 4: Dancing All Night in particular garnered much of the scorn, which led to a case of Hilarious in Hindsight since it is now getting both a P3 and a P5-themed sequel.
  • Sequel Displacement: How many people knew of Persona before the third or fourth games? For that matter, it's rare to meet a Western Shin Megami Tensei fan that wasn't introduced to the series by those two games.


How well does it match the trope?

Example of:


Media sources: