The TV World, Tartarus and other bizarre worlds the franchise explores are all small parts or remnants of the Realm of Souls, what the Warp used to be before it was fully corrupted by the Ruinous Forces. The Realm of Souls was shaped by sentient life's collective thoughts and experiences, but, similar to the gods, these worlds are far smaller and only focused on humanity. This extends to the Shadows, which are shaped by humanity's feelings, but since they are not connected to the more monstrous chaos gods, they are more benign and, to a degree, less evil. Humanity, at this point, cannot comprehend or access the full immeasurable power of the Warp, thus it's scope can only be glimpsed in these limited worlds.
- So this means that the Persona protagonists are reincarnations of the following: Minato/Makoto is the Emperor, Yu/Souji is Sanguinius while Joker/Akira/Ren is a more benevolent Horus.
- Each of the Persona protagonists past Persona 3 are probably based on some real person.
- The Persona 3 protagonists would be based on two terminal illness patients who only had 1 year to live their fullest. One fell into depression after being told about it but nevertheless made it through with several acquaintances, the other managed to live to their fullest and content while still realizing that they have to pass away. The former is actually the male protagonist, the latter is the female protagonist.
- The Persona 4 protagonist might be a city boy who got thrown into a rural town with virtually no urban support other than a mega department store that currently invaded into the local economy while their parents went overseas to work. He got used to the rural life after a year and got back home.
- The Persona 5 protagonist might be based on a kid who got bullied and got arrested because he retaliated the bully by punching his face and the bully's family decided to sue him and he lucked out and the Japanese government gave him a one year probation order. He would be often assigned to clean the streets and pick up trash as "rehabilitation." He managed to end a year of probation and went back home.
- It should also be noted that the school bully might be the motif for Shido, as he doesn't act any different from a real school bully, and "Changing Hearts" might be a metaphor for a street cleaner job because all of the people that the Phantom Thieves changed hearts are actually "becoming one with the distorted masses."
- In Persona 5, there are characters that are named after infamous fraudsters, sex maniac athletes or even activists.
- However, the most realistic people in the Persona world are probably Adachi from Persona 4 and Hikari from Persona Q2. It's hard to even believe that they aren't modeled after real people. Adachi is probably based on an angsty kid that had life go perfectly against them and grew to hate the world, while Hikari is likely based on someone who had gone through a lifetime of emotional traumas and became a self-withdrawing Hikkikomori as a result.
- The MC could be a student on a year long study trip around the world.
- You could meet the party members at different points of the world.
- The player could stay at a certain location for a month, and the player will have until the day they depart to defeat the Shadow Boss.
- The Velvet Room would be a flight cabin, with Igor as "the Captain" and his assistant as a flight attendant.
- The Personas you collect vary on what part of the world you're at, being based on the mythologies or prominent religions of that country.
- Your party's main Personas are based on mythical/legendary travelers, while the antagonists' Personas are based on enemies/obstacles faced by those travelers and/or mythical/legendary conquerors (since conquest can be seen as sort of the dark side of travel).
- The Big Bad could use Mordred as his Persona.
- For Arcanas, King Arthur could be the Fool or Emperor, Queen Guinevere as either the Empress or the Lovers, Lancelot as the Chariot, Merlin as the Magician, and Mordred as the Devil.
- One of the party members could be an intelligent horse as the Team Pet, similar to Koromaru in Persona 3. Its persona would be Cavall, Arthur's dog.
- The Fool: Frankenstein's Monster / Adam Frankenstein. Alternatively, he'll be the Persona of the Velvet Room assistant.
- The Lovers: The Bride Of Frankenstein / Elizabeth.
- The Emperor: Dracula.
- The Empress: Medusa.
- The Magician: The Wicked Witch of the West.
- The Hermit: Quasimodo.
- The Sun: The Invisible Man / Dr. Griffin.
- The Moon: The Wolf Man (1941).
- The Heirophant and the Devil: Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde respectively. The user will have a split personality. Jekyll will be his basic Persona, but Mr. Hyde comes out when he's low on HP.
For a change, given that Shadows born from the collective unconscious manifest as all sorts of demons, deities, angels, etc. from all across the globe, and America is all but the smelting pot of all cultures and all ideas (despite some purists claiming the contrary), perhaps that would be an interesting change.
- It will take place in a prison reform school as its main setting, to connect to part 6.
- The main theme of the game will center around fantasy and escapism, with a focus on Arthurian legend and other escapist mythologies or fantasies)
- As a way to differentiate itself from 5, the group this time will be full of anti-heroes who, while having sympathetic reasons for the crimes they were incarcerated for, are still guilty of the crimes and the reasons really serves as excuses.
- To go even further, when they join the party they're full-on villain protagonists, but as you rank their social links up they become Type 1 anti-heroes.
- The cognitive universe this time around will be differing adventure and fantasy versions of different locations.
- The soundtrack will be electronic for the versatility of sound, to express the isolation and imprisonment of the incarcerated setting and a type of music to deliver exciting but not full on escapist sound for the cognitive universe setting.
- The Velvet Room does not appear because it has been destroyed and Igor has been killed. The attendant for this game has amnesia like the protagonist, and asks the cast for help discovering who did it.
- It then turns out Igor was just hiding and the Velvet Room comes back at the end.
- The protagonist is a amnesiac prisoner who woke up in the prison without knowing their true crimes, if they committed any at all and is infact Goro Akechi, who kept his Wild Card and somehow survived Shido's ship.
- Or it could just be another blank slate, because it being Goro would be stupid.
- The main antagonist, or at least The Dragon is Goro shadow which goes by Loki which was separated from the protagonist BY Nyarlathotep to mess up Philemon's plan.
- There will be a green color motif this time. P3 used a blue motif, P4 a yellow one and P5 was red. It would be fitting if the next one rounds out the primary color spectrum with green.
- A revelation from this game is the fact that the world was in fact, not reset from P2 but the one now inhabited is a cognitive versse forged by Philemon for humanity to inhabit. Nyarlathotep is trying to destroy the barrier between the dream world and hellishbdestroyed world he created in Innocent Sin.
- Matthew Mercer will voice one of the main party again. Just for added flavor, he'd be the Star Arcana.
- On the Japanese side, Tomokazu Sugita would also be in the same game, but now he'd be the Hermit Arcana.
- The premise will be the unused travel theme for this game. The party stays in a certain location for a month, and they have until the day they leave for their next destination to kill the Shadow of the Month. The Personas you find vary on the country's religion and mythology.
- It'll be a horror themed. The party's Personas will be famous fictional horror figures such as the Frankenstein Monster, Dracula, the Wolf Man, etc. The primary story theme will be facing your fears.
- And the Ultimate Personas will be from the Cthulhu Mythos like Hastur, Yog-Sothoth, Shub-Niggurath, even Cthulhu himself. (Due to the Cosmic Horror Genre being unofficially the Spiritual Successor to Gothic Horror, which the original personas originate from.) With the Protagonist's being none other than Azathoth
- If the Big Bad is Nyarlathotep, it would definitely be cathartic if he got defeated by his own pantheon.
- And the Ultimate Personas will be from the Cthulhu Mythos like Hastur, Yog-Sothoth, Shub-Niggurath, even Cthulhu himself. (Due to the Cosmic Horror Genre being unofficially the Spiritual Successor to Gothic Horror, which the original personas originate from.) With the Protagonist's being none other than Azathoth
- A major theme of the next game will be how far you are willing to go for friendship and at what point you need to cut toxic people out of your lives. The betrayal will be your entire party, who turn out to have been villains all along and have been trying to corrupt you. At several points during their Social Links, you will be given the option to betray your morals in order to help them out; refusing to compromise breaks the Social Link, but puts you on the path to the good ending. For bonus points, you will recruit an investigator character named Something A—chi who appears suspicious; in reality, he is the only party member who is genuinely loyal to you.
- That honestly sounds pretty antithetical to the theme of bonds in Persona. Especially since you would have to get the bad ending in order to max all your social links. That and being down to two party members would make the endgame section a lot harder than it needs to be.
The final boss of this game is the mind of the Holy Grail, after all. The idea is that pieces of Yaldabaoth will fall to Earth and find homes in the hearts of people driven to control others by any means necessary, awakening their Personas as various figures in Arthurian myth. They will be drawn to each other, publicly decide to share power with each other, and become their own, demented version of the Phantom Thieves, the samurai to their ninjas. They start attacking corrupt Palaces too, but rather than sneak in and burgle, they lay siege and plunder, with the ultimate goal being to turn their targets into their agents rather than reforming them. And as the trope suggests, each will be a dark mirror of one of the Thieves (their Ryuji counterpart will be a remorseless berserker Badass Biker, their Futaba equivalent blames her problems on the world, their Haru version is Daddy's Little Villain..)
- Continuing Off of this, the antagonists' arcanas will be the reverse of the Phantom Thieves, and if any of their Personas progress from Initial to Ultimate, they will transform into representations of the agents of higher powers.
- Reverse Fool:King Arthur> Metatron
- Reverse Chariot: Lancelot> Erlang Sheng
- Reverse Lovers: Morgana> Artemis
- Reverse Magician: Merlin> Mars
- Reverse Emperor: Percival> Kamu Tsukuyomi
- Reverse Priestess: Caelia> Nanshe
- Reverse Hermit: Nimue> Hephaestus
- Reverse Empress: Guinevere> Marduk
- Reverse Justice: Mordred> Freyr
- Jossed, no Psycho Rangers.
- Um, no it hasn't? I (the original theorist) specified the direct sequel to this game, which has not even been announced yet.
- Oh whoops...read it wrong, my bad, this is my fault, sorry everyone, y'all have a good time now.
- Shit this idea is so good it should be used as the primary antagonist for Persona 6.
- One can imagine that it doesn't take much of a stretch for someone to widen what they consider to be "evil" to be more willing to use that power on others. Look as Shadow Mishima, he arose from such thoughts.
- The Cognitive Universe has the odd ability of generating money when Shadows are defeated. Imagine then, wouldn't someone rather kill Shadows all day rather than work a boring 9-5 job somewhere? It can provide a source of income, and one that an antagonist might be willing to preserve so long as they can make money for it. Financial security is in high regard after all.
- There's also the idea that Heel–Face Brainwashing has one major flaw: you're essentially taking the choice of free will out of another's hands, and forcing them to change. While the Phantom Thieves do it to people who are so atrocious they need to have it done, it would be interesting to see how an antagonist who decides The Evils of Free Will is too much for humanity to handle decides to take things into their own hands.
As for why Morgan Le Fey? Let's make some analogies to why she's fitting as a Persona for this antagonist.
- Morgan Le Fey translates to "Morgan the Fairy". Back in arturian times, the fae meant The Fair Folk, beings of inhuman beauty and yet inhuman standards. They went underneath full Blue-and-Orange Morality, deviating from what humans saw as normal. And there have been more than a few antagonists in Persona that fall under the trope.
- Morgan Le Fey is also known as the Evil Sorceress codifier in Arthurian Mythos, causing the most problems for him such as taking away Excalibur's Scabbard which let him heal indefinitely, exposing Lancelot and Guinivere's affair, and mothering Mordred, her and Arthur's bastard child to take the throne from Arthur.
- Morgan Le Fey has multiple characterizations, from sympathetic healer of Avalon to the Lady of Black Magic Femme Fatal, which befits how Persona seems to explore how some of the antagonists can have some good in them (Adachi being willing to atone, Akechi sacrificing himself so the PT can leave).
- Finally, it gives a funny reference to the Phantom Thieves of Hearts. Morgan Le Fey has been subject to many different respellings, one of them being "Morrigan". This gives a connection to The Morrigan of Ulster of Celtic Mythology, who had one of her titles being "Queen of Phantoms".
- The original idea of backpacking around the world and its theme of self discovery can be revisited.
It'd be a nice change of pace, and the series that Persona is strongly influenced by, JoJo's Bizarre Adventure, coincidentally has a female protagonist in the Sixth Part.
I know they did it for Persona 5 Scramble, but Persona 6 could allow more exploration for each of these cities, much like what they did for Tokyo in Persona 5.
- This◊ official art was released as part of the 25th anniversary celebrations. It shows the protagonists of previous games splattered with paint in the colors of those games, with some green paint sitting conspicuously in the corner.
Asians (Specifically the Japanese in World War 2) or African-Americans and both's relationships with white Americans might be the focus. The Japanese would be more familiar to injustices done to their own for one. And blacks having more tangible current history in the US fit for an Urban Fantasy as well (As opposed to Native Americans who are unfortunately nearly extinct by comparison, and Mexicans who have their own neighboring countries albeit also facing racial injustices. Though they would undoubtedly be included if Atlus is already going this route). Bunch of research would be required and might alienate their JP playerbase tho so it might be a no go. If done right and we'll it could be among the best narrative games of the 2020's.
- Doubtful on the latter. I know they did it with Captain Kidd and Goemon, but I highly doubt they would go THAT far.
- A Monkey
- A Bird
- A Hamster
- A Dog (albeit an anthropomorphic dog along the lines of Teddie and Morgana rather than an actual dog like Koromaru.)
- A Weasel/Ferret.
- Because Horny Vikings in general are strongly associated with exploration, and if courage is involved as a theme, all the more pertinent to such a warrior-focused mythology. This also allows the boss characters to be themed after the crazier monsters (like matching wits with a Master of Illusion modeled after Glamr, or a Colossus Climb on Mokkafir), with the "foil to courage" being that, being largely themed after jotnar, they are the ultimate bullies, relying on physical strength and raw power to terrorize everyone near them.
This is just one possible way that the protagonist could be different from Joker. While Joker was falsely accused of assault by a corrupt politician, the protagonist will have actually committed a crime in the past and was punished for it. By the time the story starts, he’ll have come to regret it and try to be a better person, moving to the game’s main location for a fresh start.
- A Childhood Friend of the protagonist: They’ve first met each other when they were kids (at least 10 years prior to the story), but the friend ended up moving away. They never saw each other again until the protagonist happened to move to the same place as his old friend. Perhaps the friend could even be a romance option for the protagonist.
- A Token Adult: While the main characters are just about always teenagers, the Persona series is not averse to showing adults with Personas, even having a mostly adult cast in Eternal Punishment and having Zenkichi join the Phantom Thieves in Strikers. So maybe they could have an adult party member in P6? They could be anything from a college student (so that they could be a few years older than the protagonist while still being considered young) to the protagonist’s homeroom teacher or even their caretaker.
- A Team Pet: Persona 3 has shown that animals can use Personas, yet so far we’ve only had Koromaru. Maybe the developers can revisit the concept, as unlikely as it seems.
Inspired by this video.
- Vlad the Impaler
- Frankenstein (both the monster and the doctor himself)
- Johnny Appleseed - Earth-elemental and healing-based
- Paul Bunyan - Physical-oriented
- Babe the Blue Ox
- Br'er Rabbit
- Anansi
- Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde
- Beowulf
- Ned Kelly - In my opinion
- Gatsby- Hanged Man Arcana
- Jack the Ripper - Likely of the Moon Arcana, representing the mystery surrounding the serial killer’s identity. Specializes in physical and/or curse skills. Would look like a tall man in a black trenchcoat and top hat wearing a mask and holding a large knife. Bonus points if the mask in some way resembled Jack Frost’s face.