Please don't list this on a work's page as a trope. Examples can go on the work's YMMV tab.
"If film critics could destroy a movie, Michael Bay and Adam Sandler would be working at Starbucks. If film critics could make a movie a hit, the Dardenne brothers would be courted by every studio in town."
Sometimes, a movie, book, game, or song is released and the critics hate it. They just hate it. Entire forests are destroyed printing scathing reviews that dissect such media down to the bone, showing in every possible way that the general public should stay away in droves. But, no matter how bad they are... no matter how many bad reviews they receive, the public loves it. The movie becomes a blockbuster. The book sits atop the New York Times best-seller list. The game flies off the shelves and becomes a must-have. The song is on everyone's iPod...
The reasons for this phenomenon are myriad and diverse. Critics are often not fans of the source material being adapted, so they look upon things from a layman perspective. Some dislike the style and humor, preferring more "sophisticated" works. Sometimes the fans are so hardcore that they'd accept anything from the source, and sometimes, it's made to be fun. In fact, many who see/buy the work may not even think the best of it either, but it's familiar enough that it manages to stand out and market itself. Sometimes it's simply become popular through being So Bad, It's Good.
When no critic in the world can affect a work's popularity, it is Critic Proof.
Compare Love It or Hate It, Critical Backlash, It's Not Supposed to Win Oscars, Critical Dissonance, and He Panned It, Now He Sucks. Contrast with Acclaimed Flop, Confirmation Bias, Reviews Are The Gospel and Guilty Pleasure. Not to be confused with Protection from Editors.
open/close all folders
Anime and Manga
The much reviled Endless Eight episodes of the Haruhi Suzumiya second season were released across 4 DVDs in Japan. Given that said arc basically consisted of the same episode eight times in a row, it's surprising that the first DVDs sold (relatively) well.
Though the later ones to a lesser extent; the second and third sold only half the amount the first one did.
On the other hand, the North American licensors of Season 2 knew very well that they would not be Critic Proof (plenty of fans had already vowed a boycott due to the extreme unpopularity of Endless Eight), and simply released all 14 episodes in a single set.
SHUFFLE! got panned by review sites as just another annoying harem show, and even when it was first licensed, overwhelming opinion was that FUNimation must like losing money, because nobody would buy it. The DVD sales in North America were a surprising success, to the point that Funi produced a collector's box with the final volume.
Pokémon. Despite not having any international theatrical releases since the Johto era, in Japan the twelfth film, Arceus and the Jewel of Life has become the highest grossing anime film of 2009. People complain about the anime itself. Although it has lost some popularity, it's still extremely popular.
Mobile Suit Gundam SEED Destiny is very popular among the Japanese audiences, despite the mixed reviews the series received, and even won the Anime Grand Prix award for Most Popular Anime in 2004 and 2005.
Sword Art Online. Bloggers generally agree that it is mediocre at best. It was the most popular anime of 2012. AMVs for the series on Youtube regularly reach into the hundreds of thousands of views. Most other AMVs are lucky if they get to the tens of thousands.
Transformers: Revenge Of The Fallen is currently the worst reviewed movie ever to earn $400+ million dollars at the domestic box office.
And it actually made 800 million plus worldwide, the first movie of 2009 to do so (even beating at least one of The Dark Knight's records) so it will take some beating.
Tranformers: Dark of the Moon (which got better reviews than Revenge of the Fallen, but still quite negative none the less) grossed over a billion dollars worldwide and is currently the 5th highest grossing movie. Ever.
Bad Boys 2, a movie Bay directed a full 4 years before Transformers, actually used all the same conventions. Critics hated it while the audience ate it up.
The only entry in the Scary Movie series to get overall positive reviews was the first one. This didn't keep the others from making money, albeit not as much as the first.
Rambo: First Blood Part II was savaged by critics, but made triple its budget domestically and triple that internationally; Rambo III was only slightly better reviewed and didn't do so well domestically, but still did pretty well internationally. Both are now considered cult classics.
One might as well say "NOOOOO BAD REVIEWS EVEEER!!" when talking about Mommie Dearest.
Wild Wild West. Not just critic proof, but star proof as well. Even the film's star Will Smith and director Barry Sonnenfeld said they realized the movie was crap. It didn't stop it from making a ton of money.
Many of Tyler Perry's movies, though not considered awful, are usually not liked by critics. However, his movies do extremely well with the African-American community.
Kevin Smith tried to invoke this with Jersey Girl by saying it "wasn't for critics". It didn't work so well. Then Penny Arcade tried to parody it by coming up with absurdist nonsense perpetrators Twisp and Catsby, and taunting all the critics who couldn't criticize them because it wasn't for them. This backfired on Penny Arcade as well, when Twisp and Catsby instead became insanely popular.
The mostly negative critical reviews for The Hangover: Part II haven't stopped it from being hugely successful at the box office.
All of Seltzer and Friedberg's movies have had overwhelmingly negative reviews, yet they still manage to more than make back their budget (except Disaster Movie). Epic Movie and Meet the Spartans both debuted at #1 at the box office on their opening weekends, and Vampires Suck debuted at #2.
All of their movies also have fairly low budgets, so really, no matter how bad their movies get, there will be enough people going to see them to make back their budgets several times over.
Batman & Robin. Immensely panned by critics and fans alike, but made over $100 million at the box office.
Street Fighter: The Movie. The scathing reviews it got from critics didn't stop it from becoming one of the highest-grossing movies of 1994.
Surprisingly subverted with The Lone Ranger. For a Johnny Depp film you'd expect it to earn big bucks. It was savaged by critics, but the audiences didn't eat it up like they did for the Pirates movies. Jerry Bruckheimer and Johnny Depp blamed critics for "conspiring" against the film to make it bomb, which in turn led Duralde's response in the page quote.
Cars 2 is Pixar's worst reviewed animated film (currently in the below 40% range at Rotten Tomatoes), but that hasn't stopped the film from making huge bucks at the box office.
The Left Behind series. The books are rather poorly written, and there have been many articles written that give specific examples of just how stupid the characters act. Even from the perspective of Evangelical Protestant Christianity, the theology behind it is suspect. But the target audience strongly believes in the books' message and likes them anyway.
Breaking Dawn (the last book) probably qualifies the most. Despite the frequent hate you see, the earlier books got some decent reviews when they were released, it was later that the hatedom grew as large as it did. Breaking Dawn, however, was actively disliked by many fans of the series, and still sold incredibly well.
A fictional version, from Ben Bova's Cyberbooks: at a meeting in a publishing house, the staff discuss the latest "SheldonStoker" manuscript and judge it to be complete rubbish, but a guaranteed best-seller. They recommend "Hold our noses and buy it."
In music, just about any re-united band. A band that broke up 20 years ago and are now making a new album? It'll sell huge. Reunion tour? Sold out. No matter how poorly the members have aged, no matter how different their new music is, it'll all make a ton of money.
Case in point: the Spice Girls' brief reunion. Even if it was only for a couple of months, it made seventy million dollars.
Rascal Flatts from the mid-2000s onward. Ever since Dann Huff became their producer, they've been widely criticized for many reasons: Huff's bombastic production; Gary LeVox's over-the-top, whiny, nasal singing voice; and unimpressive song choices. Such derision didn't stop them from continuing to land in the Top 10, sell lots of albums, win lots of awards, and overall be the top band in country music for several years running.
It would seem that the band eventually learned their lesson in 2010, when their label (Disney-owned Lyric Street) closed, and they moved over to the indie label Big Machine Records. In an odd inversion, their two albums for Big Machine have garnered more favorable reviews, although sales have slumped, and their singles have had to fight much harder for their Top 10 positioning — except for 2013's "Changed", which, despite a minor crossover to the Christian charts, accounted for their lowest chart peaks to date. Also, Lady Antebellum and Zac Brown Band moved on to trump them commercially.
And Grand Funk wasn't an act of the cute, well-groomed, sugary variety (like their contemporaries the Osmonds or the Bay City Rollers, or later entries such as the Spice Girls or the Backstreet Boys) who garnered huge followings by appealing to prepubescent girls or drooling adolescent males — their records were bought by, and their concerts attended by, "real" rock fans.
Nickelback can be seen as the modern-day version of Grand Funk Railroad in this respect. They have been widely panned by critics and were once voted the worst band of all time; there exist countless YouTube videos devoted to picking apart how all their songs sound the same. It didn't stop them from selling 30 million albums worldwide.
A lot of late-1970s/early-1980s AOR bands were despised by critics while still selling multi-platinum albums. None got it worse than Toto, who were accused of using their industry connections (they'd all been prolific session musicians before they formed the band) to rig the Grammy Awards in 1983.
In the 1980's, Stevie Nicks was commonly dismissed by "highbrow" rock critics (Rolling Stone was particularly egregious in this regard) who fawned on her former lover and current bandmate Lindsey Buckingham, notwithstanding that his albums were only a fraction as popular as hers. Many of those same critics did a perfect about-face and hailed her as an elder stateswoman of rock and roll in the late 1990's and 2000's.
Music critics hated the entire Hair Metal genre during the 1980s, but that didn't stop it from becoming the biggest music genre in the world during that decade. When Grunge became popular in the early 1990s and pushed hair metal out of the spotlight those critics breathed a sigh of relief and embraced the "earthy, genuine, and intelligent" new rock genre. In the last few years, how ever, Hair Metal has experienced a resurgence in popularity with bands like Mötley Crüe and Poison having highly successful tours, with some of these bands even releasing new albums.
Britney Spears has one of the biggest hatedoms in all of pop land, but somehow manages to get those #1 singles and albums, sell out tours, get hired for big bucks for tv shows and generally remain relevant and popular in the public eye.
One word: Dubstep. It is the current whipping boy of every major music critic, lambasted as a tuneless disgrace to all music. Now watch any video game trailer in the last year or two. That stuff is popular.
When she first appeared, most critics said, and not without some justification, that Lady Gaga would still be a C-List Girl Singer with no record contract were it not for her outlandish behavior, and that her "true talent" wasn't music, but rather PR management. Millions of her fans surprisingly failed to care and buy her albums in droves.
Classical music is often thought of as being above such battles, but Giacomo Puccini is an example of a composer who's effectively Critic Proof. There is a large body of informed opinion in the classical world which argues that Puccini may have had a knack for catchy tunes, but compared to his compatriot Giuseppe Verdi he had very little talent for constructing musical drama, and most of his stories, however promising, are effectively ruined by the steaming ladles-ful of musical Narm that he poured over them. However, none of this seems to affect Puccini's box office, and he remains one of the most popular opera composers ever.
Billy Joel has been known to have been savaged critically, at least at the height of his success, but according to The Other Wiki has sold 150 million albums worldwide as of 2013. His 1978 album 52nd Street (which bears the distinction of being the first album mass-manufactured for Compact Disc in 1982) won the Album Of The Year Grammy, he's a member of the Rock And Roll Hall Of Fame, and many of hs hits have become standards.
The Jewish/Irish ethnic comedy play Abie's Irish Rose opened on Broadway in 1922, and quickly became a laughingstock of theatre critics. It closed five years later, having run longer than any previous Broadway show.
Les Misérables was panned by critics after the first performance in the 1980s. The cast expected empty seats at the next performance, yet Word Of Mouth by theatregoers who absolutely loved it ensured that now, even 25 years later, it's a box office hit.
In-story example: In Dream Girl, Jim is fired by a publishing house after he turns down Always Opal (an obvious Fictional Counterpart of Forever Amber), which proceeds to sell out at bookstores everywhere. "If I had it to do over again, I'd still turn that book down," he tells his sister-in-law Georgina, who completely agrees with him on the book's trashiness: "It's nothing but a lot of dressed-up smut, atrociously written, and all in very bad taste, if you ask me."
Backyard Sports. There are new editions every year and the games keep selling. IGN and G4 continue to hate the series, though (they both thought it was average at the beginning, then they considered it one of the worst game series of all time).
Most EA Sports franchises, though FIFA and NHL have been acclaimed in later years. Part of FIFA's success should be credited to the poor job Konami did with Pro Evolution Soccer on the last couple years.
Enter the Matrix sold 5 million copies despite being panned by critics (and many gamers, after they bought it).
The Simpsons. While many fans feel that the show has gotten stale and repetitive over the years, that certainly hasn't stopped it from getting high ratings every week.
Family Guy. Despite getting a considerable amount of Hate since its resurrection in 2005 and being considered one of the most controversial things man ever wrought, it's still one of FOX's highest rated shows.