Because of Ashley Tisdale's lovable Large Ham performance, Sharpay comes across as less of an arrogant bitch and more starstruck and neurotic. Her passion for theatre and her determination to be successful also suggests that Sharpay doesn't do the manipulative things she does out of malice - she just truly wants to be the best at everything (star in the musical, dating the most popular boy in school, etc.) She doesn't dislike the Wildcats in the second movie because of any reason other than "they'll steal my talent show!" Selfish, yes, but by the ending of each movie she's realized her mistakes. There's also the fact that Sharpay, who has been performing for far longer than Troy and Gabriella, is right to be suspicious of their skill and commitment to theater.
Quite a few fans assume that Gabriella has trust and Commitment Issues about getting close to people. Despite the fact she and Troy adore each other, she's repeatedly thinks he's going to hurt or leave her, and pushes him away in every film because of it.note In #1 he does genuinely betray her so fair enough, but in #2 she leaves over something that was mostly Sharpay's fault and #3 Troy doesn't do anything at all. Then add in that she has a Disappeared Dad, was ostracized at her previous schools and apparently never had a permanent home (living somewhere longer than a year) and she borders on Broken Bird.
Gabriella: I'm a lot better at saying goodbye than you. I've had a ton of practice.
Likewise, Troy seems less like an uber-popular Big Man on Campus and more of a Broken Ace worn down from years of being East High's golden boy. Every film has him breaking down over disappointing his Dad or friends, often while Chad and the wildcats sit there criticizing him. His delight at Gabriella liking the "real him" makes you wonder when he'd last been allowed to just relax. One tumblr post argues him attending Berkeley was less about Gabriella and more about escaping everyone's expectations.
There is one blogger that claims that Gabriella is an abusive girlfriend to Troy and that he might be an emotionally broken character because of her, as this Tumblr user demonstrates here, here or here (warning:some of the links are broken due to the posts being deleted).
"So the real message of the first movie is: 'If you're popular and you do everything, you're gonna be great at it, but if you dedicate your entire life to something you'll be seen as a villain and now you're the bad person.' "
Film Theoryproposes that the role of the true villain of the series is not Sharpay but... Troy. Though it's not much of a spoiler considering the rant at the beginning...
Anvilicious: Painfully obvious message. Check. Lack of subtlety. Double check.
In the second movie Sharpay tries to get Troy to perform "Humuhumunukunukuapua'a" with her, an extravagant Hawaiian themed number about a pineapple princess and a fish prince falling in love. Characteristic of Sharpay, this is a huge production number with backup dancers and Ryan narrating, providing sound effects/fog, and playing the ocean and fish. It makes just as much sense in context and is never brought up again or acknowledged in the plot. No wonder it's not in the Disney Channel airings, but limited to the home video release. It may be seen as this in universe as well. Throughout the number, we get repeated cuts to Troy, who's facial expressions likely mirror that of the audience. It is brought up one more time when Sharpay demands Troy and Gabriella's duet from Kelsi. Ryan, who was just kicked out of the talent show by his own sister ask what'll happen to Humuhumu and what he's supposed to do with his Tiki warrior outfit.
'All For One' from the end of the second movie has absolutely nothing to do with the rest of the film and comes completely out of nowhere as just an ending song where the cast just sing and dance to the music.
High School Musical 2. Some saw it as a step in the right direction but many people pick up on a lot of issues, in particular the Informed Wrongness of Troy's decisions (how dare you miss a baseball game to work for a scholarship!), the Family-Unfriendly Aesop of the wildcats' reactions (focusing on the future is bad), Sharpay taking a ridiculous level in jerkass, and most of all it's not even set in high school!
Sharpay's Fabulous Adventure. It's not a musical, and even factoring that and its spin-off status in it has a completely different "feel" to the other movies. And those are the minor points - it forgets that Sharpay was supposed to go to the University of Albuquerque after graduation and that Ryan and Kelsi went to New York (they had to rush just to get Lucas Grabeel into the movie at all, so much that his scene is only in the broadcast version).
Draco in Leather Pants: This is combined with Misaimed Fandom. While fans have understandable reasons to sympathize with Sharpay, some of them tend to give her more sympathy than she deserves by saying that she wasnt a villain. This negates the fact that not only was Sharpay a rude Alpha Bitch to almost everyone she came across, but she (with Ryan) went out their way to convince Ms. Darbus to change the time of the audition schedule just to ensure that Troy and Gabriella cannot audition for the lead roles in the play.
The increasingly fabulous Ryan. Since the first movie, he was already considered one of the most talented members of the cast, despite being just the villain's sidekick and a Satellite Character at best. In the second movie, he gets a lot of Character Development, Ship Tease with Chad, a cute Odd Friendship with Gabriella, and is shown to be very likable when not around his sister. In the third movie, he also becomes a Deadpan Snarker which only helped to increase even more his popularity with fans.
Epic Rocking: "Work This Out" in the stage version, and to a lesser extent, "Bet On It". Oddly, "Bet On It" is actually less Narmy onstage, partly to the fact that it becomes more of a Massive Multiplayer Ensemble Number with more emotional weight and less interpretive dancing.
The second film has several, the worst one being that hanging out with your high school friends is more important than your whole future. Troy is portrayed as the bad guy for missing a few ball games because he's trying to get a scholarship and earn money for college. He's redeemed when he throws away chances of impressing the College board so the other wildcats will be friends with him again.
Technically the whole problem was that he was forgetting dates and leaving his friends standing in the dust despite there being enough time to tell them beforehand that something else came up. He never actually did say "Hey guys, I'm sorry but this is important" when there was still time for the others to change their own plans. He didn't acknowledge them in any way to the Red Hawks either even though Chad was right there so if one thinks about it, the aesop isn't all that family unfriendly at all. Thinking about the future is not bad as long as you don't forget about the present.
The musical number "Work This Out" starts off with most of the Wild Cats acting like entitled ungrateful brats, complaining about their "terrible" new jobs (before they have really even started), acting like service jobs are beneath them, and blaming Troy for not getting them better ones, instead of being grateful to him for sticking his neck out to help get them all jobs in the first place; while the song does involve Troy somewhat setting them straight, they others are never really called out for their ungrateful attitude or low opinion of service work.
Even among non-Ryan/Chad shippers, general fanon is that something went down in the locker room after the staff baseball game in HSM2.
In the same vein, Ryan being gay has been pretty much accepted as fact among fans, usually accompanied by a handwave that Kelsi is just a beard. Surprisingly few people consider the option he might be bi.
Gabriella's mom is nameless in the films, but is usually Isabella or Maria in fanfic.
Ryan being dyslexic is brought up in at least 75% of fanfics where he has a lead role, most likely based on him being unable to read Go Drama Club in the first movie despite being portrayed as very intelligent in the later movies.
Harsher in Hindsight: Matt Prokop's scenes in HSM 3, considering the revelation of his abuse towards his girlfriend Sarah Hyland and the fact that they met while auditioning for HSM 3 become much more uncomfortable to watch.
Everything about the "I Don't Dance" sequence in HSM 2. The next time we see Chad and Ryan, they've switched clothes. General consensus among fans is that the entire song is about Chad being in denial about his sexuality and Ryan encouraging him to just let go.
HSM3 has Troy practice a dance move, which he and Sharpay was supposed to perform together, with Ryan. When he was asked to actually do the move with Sharpay, he complains that Ryan was the better partner.
If you go into a group of people that were kids in the mid-to-late 2000s and shout, "WHAT TEAM?!", at least half those kids will, without fail, scream, "WILDCATS!" in response, often without even thinking about it.
Moe: Gabriella is a sweet girl who has a Break the Cutie moment in every movie. The trope is especially evident in the first movie where she was a Shrinking Violet, but is still somewhat present in the sequels.
It's practically impossible to watch "Bet On It" without at least cracking a smile.
"The Boys Are Back" from the third movie.
"Scream", also from the third movie. Basically "Bet On It" with a bigger budget that was not at all. The titular scream that ends the song could not be more wooden.
Even the franchise itself would eventually acknowledge how silly it is to present a guy being interested in both sports and musical theater as any kind of huge shocking thing, with the Disney+ series having a main character whos into both without anyone caring the slightest bit.
Narm Charm: The series in a nutshell. It's ridiculous, corny and twee... but it was insanely popular for a reason.
No Problem with Licensed Games: The games are pretty good, but only because of what gameplay theyre based on. The first two games on DS use the Elite Beat Agents/Osu! Tatakae! Ouendan gameplay, while the third DS game uses Gitaroo Man's gameplay. The console High School Musical 3 Dance! game also uses DDR gameplay on dance pads (On Wii, it's Wii Remote and Nunchuk). While it's somewhat simplistic in terms of difficulty, it does serve as a decent rhythm game. Unfortunately, all the games use covers, which is ironic since Disney develops the games and made the movies. The Game Boy Advance game based on the first movie does have it's own merits too, despite being one half platformer, one half rhythm game.
Older Than the Demographic: Despite being themed around high school, the series was not intended to be aimed at teens. Most of the fans were girls aged 12 - 16, though.
Rooting for the Empire: A lot of people seem to prefer Sharpay and Ryan to the heroes due to their charisma and the fact that they just wanted to have the coveted play roles.
Ron the Death Eater: Many of Sharpay's fans tend to make Gabriella out to be an asshole for "stealing" Troy from Sharpay. This is inaccurate because Troy never liked nor dated Sharpay, and Gabriella was just a sweet, intelligent girl who loved math and musicals and liked Troy for who he was (unlike Sharpay who probably only liked Troy for superficial reasons).
As hard as it is to believe today, High School Musical was very popular and praised by critics when the first movie debut in 2006, getting two sequels (with another in development), a spinoff, foreign remakes in Latin America and China, a concert tour, stage adaptations for the first two movies, tons of merchandise, and four Spiritual Successors in Camp Rock, Teen Beach Movie, Descendants, and Z-O-M-B-I-E-S.
Subsequent Disney Channel Original Movies would try to cash on with its success, through copying the style of the film or overpromoting any shared actor in them (or giving them larger roles in the case of Halloweentown), and even other studios decided to take advantage of its popularity, most noticeably Glee. Even The Suite Life of Zack and Cody did an episode to promote the film. This drove the Periphery Demographic away and caused Disney Channel's Dork Age that lasted until 2017 and give DCOMs the reputation of being forgettable Cliché StormChick Flicks.
Today, while still popular enough to get a new sequel, High School Musical is viewed mostly as a cause of Disney Channel's Network Decay (along with Hannah Montana), is viewed as Narm by people who were not teenage girls in its heyday, and has been pretty much forgotten except for helping to revive musicals and be the Star-Making Role for Zac Efron and Vanessa Hudgens.
Signature Song: "Breaking Free" was supposed to be this, and was for the first movie, but "We're All in This Together" is probably the most remembered song for the whole series.
Surprisingly Improved Sequel: Between a better budget, more production time and the adorable chemistry Troy and Gabriella have developed through Zac and Vanessa's Romance on the Set, Senior Year is probably the best of the three films. Not to mention Troy and Gaby's relationship gets some depth, as per their confiding in each other about their fears for the future.
Each sequel got better in terms of budget and production, with the first one looking much less cinematic than the third.
Special Effect Failure: The second movie, during the song "Bet On It", has Troy looking into the water of a pond, showing his reflection. Ignoring the obvious CGI effect, the reflection itself was not mirrored.
Off-screen, but in the first movie a character says brother and sister Ryan and Sharpay played the title roles of Romeo and Juliet.
The fact that the theater director seem to have no issue with a brother and sister playing romantic interests. Not only that, but the school administrators don't seem to notice this.
Strangled by the Red String: In a badly-made excuse to stop the rumors that the character is gay, Ryan was paired up with Kelsi in the third movie. They are good together, if you ignore the fact Kelsi was paired with Jason in the first two movies and the insane amount of flirting between Ryan and Chad in the second movie (which was intentional).
"Right Here, Right Now" in the third film as Troy and Gabriella consider their future apart from each other. The cut reprise version - set after they've said goodbye - is even worse.
The finale for the third movie has the cast end the song jumping in front of a literal Title Drop. Then we get a close up of each of the character's faces. There's no dancing, no singing, just them standing there smiling, before taking a company bow. It seems awkward at first, but then it hits you: this is their curtain call. These six talented actors are saying goodbye to their characters, and to us. It's a subtle, but effective, instance of Leaning on the Fourth Wall.
The lyrics of the song ("High School Musical") don't help either, especially when you consider that out of the main cast only Zac Efron and Vanessa Hudgens really went on to have successful careers.
Most of the performances performances range from poor to OK, with a few cartoony Ham and Cheese characters. But Zac Efron plays Troy with a real sincerity, ending up being one of the key things that lifts the film above the mediocre direct-to-TV Disney Channel fare it was intended to be.
Ashley Tisdale and Lucas Grabeel qualify too, albeit in a different way, going for strong, entertaining, enjoyable comedic performances instead. Tisdale actually took it so seriously that, when she and fans were unhappy with how High School Musical 3 concluded Sharpay's storyline, she pushed for a spinoff to give her a better wrap-up. Needless to say, these two are overwhelmingly more popular than the lead characters and are often considered the best parts of all three movies.
Vanessa Anne Hudgens seemed to be contractually obligated to sing one overly emotional break-up ballad each movie.
Zac Efron became obligated to supply one token emo, narmy song per movie, famously including "Bet On It" consisting of Zac Efron interpretive-dancing angstily through the golf course in what's supposed to be a serious moment.
"NO, NO, NO, NOOOOOOOOOOOOOO. STICK TO THE STUFF YOU KNOOOOOOOOW." Granted, in this instance, wangst might have been the point.
Gabriella's backstory: It's implied her father has passed away and her mom's constantly-moving job meant she never settled anywhere. Plus she struggles to make friends because of being labelled the 'freaky math girl' wherever she goes.
Troy in the third film. Everyone around him is pressuring him to do different things, he has no idea what to do with his life, and his girlfriend - who he admits was the one person who doesn't see him as the perfect basketball boy - is leaving.