In the Trope Pantheons, the following were chosen:
- Samuel William Winchester and Dean Winchester, Co-Gods of Perpetual Angst (Both: The Hardy Boys, Team Free Will (alongside Castiel) Dean: El Deano, Dashing El Deano, Ducky Lips, Li'l Stumpy, Not Moose, Michael Sword, Squirrel, Dean-O, Dee-Dawg, Sam: Sasquatch, Moose, Gigantor, Sam the Ginormotron, Puppy, Darling Sammy, Boy With The Demon Blood), as Lesser Gods in the Hall of Types of Sadness (House of Despondency)
- Castiel, God of Overcoat-Wearing Angels (Cas, Clarence, Asstiel, Feathers, Halo) as an Intermediate God in the Hall of Angels (House of Otherness) and a member of the Clothing Trendsetters in the House of Costumes
- Crowley, God of the Cooperation Gambit (King of Hell, King of the Crossroads, Fergus Rodric McLeod, Dog), as a Greater God in the Hall of Planning (House of Mentalism)
- Lucifer, Unholy Patron of Aggressive Categorism (Luci, Hallucifer, Padre, "Nick", the Devil, Satan, Beelzebub, Serpent, Heaven's Most Wanted, Lightbringer), as an Overdeity in the Hall of Categorism (House of Hatred and Rancor)
- Robert Steven Singer, God of Honorary Uncles (Uncle Bobby), as a Lesser God in the Hall of Surrogate Relationships (House of Family and Relatives)
- Gabriel, God of Ironic Retribution (Archangel Gabriel, the Trickster, Loki, Mr. Trickster, Gabe, the Waiter), as an Overdeity in the Hall of Trickery (House of Mentalism)
- Chuck Shurley, the Missing God (God, The Big G, Carver Edlund, the Lord, the Prophet Chuck, Father, the Big Man), as an Overdeity in the Hall of Holy Authority and Power (House of Religion and Faith)
- Amara, The Anti-Goddess (The Darkness, Aunty Amara, the Nothingness), as an Overdeity in the Hall of Otherness Abominations (House of Otherness)
- The Princes of Hellmembers , Unholy Quartet of Supernatural Gold Eyes (King of Hell (Azazel and Asmodeus), "Yellow Eyes"/Yellow-Eyed Demon (Azazel)), as Overdeities in the Hall of Eye Colors (House of Colours)
- War, Famine, Pestilence, and Death, The Four Horsemen of the Apocalypse (Roger, the Red Horseman (War), the Black Horseman (Famine), Dr. Green, the Green Horseman (Pestilence), The Grim Reaper, Big Daddy Reaper, Angel of Death, the Pale Rider, Angel of Death (Death)), as Greater Gods in the Halls of Religious Figures (House of Religion and Faith) and Ruin and Destruction (House of Slaughter)
- The Shadow, Deity of Slumbering Villains (The Empty, Your Friendly Neighborhood Cosmic Entity) as an Overdeity in the Hall of Slumber And Sleepiness (House of Mentalism)