Follow TV Tropes


Film / I Could Never Be Your Woman

Go To

I Could Never Be Your Woman is a 2007 romantic comedy film written and directed by Amy Heckerling, starring Michelle Pfeiffer, Paul Rudd, and Saoirse Ronan.

Rosie Hanson is a divorced woman in her 40s who writes and produces a teen sitcom. She becomes involved with a 29-year-old man named Adam Pearl, who is cast in a guest role on her show. While she worries about their age difference, as well as Executive Meddling and possible cancellation, her daughter Izzie stresses over her first crush, on a boy named Dylan. Meanwhile, Rosie's secretary, Jeannie, tries to break up Rosie and Adam, by manufacturing evidence to suggest Adam is secretly seeing Brianna Minx, the star of Rosie's show.

This film provides examples of the following tropes:

  • Actor Allusion: A subtle one: Stacey Dash and Paul Rudd playing twenty-something actors playing teenagers - which is exactly what they did in Clueless, also directed by Amy Heckerling.
  • Amicably Divorced: Rosie and Nathan, more or less.
  • As Himself: Henry Winkler, who Izzy prank calls.
  • Berserk Button: Jeannie gets Rosie really mad when she breaks the necklace Izzy made for her.
  • Betty and Veronica: Jeannie fancies herself as the Veronica to Rosie's Betty, with Adam as Archie. But Adam has no interest in Jeannie, going after Rosie from the start.
  • Bitch Alert: Jeannie establishes herself as the below trope in her first scene by being a Graceful Loser when Rosie gives her bad news, but then immediately saying nasty things about her once she's gone.
  • Bitch in Sheep's Clothing: Jeannie (or as Izzie called her, "past aggressive").
  • But Not Too White: Taylor is incredibly over-tanned.
  • Cat Fight: Rosie and Jeannie.
  • Character Tics: Rosie's voice going all high and squeaky when she's really mad.
  • Coolest Club Ever: Where Adam and Rosie go on their first date.
  • Costume-Test Montage: Rosie does this for her first date with Adam.
  • Deadpan Snarker: Rosie and Adam.
  • Disproportionate Retribution: Jeannie tries to sabotage Rosie's relationship with Adam just because her scene was cut from an episode of Rosie's sitcom.
  • Double Entendre: Nathan claims his ass is his best feature.
    Rosie: You know what, you're right. That's what everyone says: 'there goes Nathan. What an ass.'
  • "Eureka!" Moment: Rosie has one where she finally realises that Jeannie has been manipulating her.
  • Funny Background Event: Mother Nature's reactions to what Rosie is doing in a lot of her scenes.
  • Green Aesop: Downplayed for laughs. Mother Nature rants about the Baby Boomer generation disrupting the natural order of things (though some of what she says comes off as a bit sexist). But her main concern in this movie is not the environment, but people's refusal to accept their own aging.
  • Hollywood Old: Subverted. Rosie is forty but believably passes herself off as thirty seven to Adam. And in real life, Michelle Pfeiffer was seven years older than her character.
  • I Am Not Pretty: Izzie thinks this in one scene. It seems to run in the family, judging by how hard Rosie is on her own appearance.
    "Things are falling down, everything is drying out. I am hurdling towards Cloris Leachman..."'
  • Inner Monologue: Rosie occasionally argues with her own subconscious, which takes the form of Mother Nature (though Mother Nature also appears to serve a bit of a Narrator role for the film, independent of Rosie).
  • I Resemble That Remark!: Adam's indignant response when told by Jeannie that his acting is too broad:
    Adam: [does exaggerated Spit Take] Me?!!
  • Little Miss Snarker: Izzie
  • Makeover Montage: A slight example is done for Adam's character on the show.
  • May–December Romance: Parodied. Rosie treats her relationship with Adam like it's this but it's shown how silly she's being. The age difference is his 29 to her 40.
  • No Periods, Period: Averted where Izzie gets hers early on and excitedly shops for tampons with Rosie.
  • Older Than They Look: Nathan believes this, and Rosie advises everyone to say he looks 32 to spare his feelings. Rosie is a straight example - being 40 and passing for 37 initially. Her actress was 47 at the time. The movie parodies this with Stacey Dash and Paul Rudd playing 20-somethings who play teenagers on a sitcom.
  • Parent with New Paramour: Type 1.
  • Pet Homosexual: Taylor, the TV show's stylist.
  • Plot Parallel: Rosie & Adam and Izzie & Dylan
  • Public Service Announcement: Brianna does an anti-smoking PSA, then immediately starts smoking.
  • Relationship Sabotage: Jeannie tries to do this to Adam and Rosie.
  • Sadist Teacher: Appears to be the case with Izzy's math teacher, who fails her for not showing her work in the same way as everyone else - despite getting the questions right.
  • Shout-Out: The Graduate; Adam jokingly calls Rosie "Mrs. Robinson" in one scene (he and Rosie quote lines from the movie as foreplay). In a later scene, Rosie and Mother Nature watch a scene from the movie.
  • Sidetracked by the Analogy: Nathan tells Rosie to stay with Adam, saying he's trying to be Bruce Willis to Adam's Ashton Kutcher. They get sidetracked wondering how Demi Moore's name is meant to be pronounced.
  • Song Parody: Izzie does this to songs by Britney Spears and Alanis Morissette.
  • Spit Take: Played straight by Mother Nature in one scene. Played for Laughs (if that's not too redundant) by Adam in a later scene.
  • Terrible Interviewees Montage: Adam is the only good actor to audition for a role on the show; his audition might be considered a Meet Cute for him and Rosie.
  • The Talk: Initiated by Izzy.
    Izzy: When can I have sex?
    Rosie: When you get your Masters Degree.
    They haggle over the number. Izzy wants fifteen and Rosie insists seventeen.
    Izzy: But mom, fifteen is the new seventeen.
  • Totally Radical: Parodied by Rosie's attempts to write teenage slang for her show. One of her Establishing Character Moments is asking her daughter if people still say "gee" anymore.
  • Ugly Guy, Hot Wife: Well they're divorced now but it was still Jon Lovitz married to Michelle Pfeiffer.
  • Wise Beyond Their Years: Izzie, to an extent; though in many ways she's quite typical of her age.