The Spear Counterpart of the Psycho Lesbian, and the monosexual counterpart to the Depraved Bisexual. Usually a villainous take on the Camp Gay or, on the other end of the spectrum, a Manly Gay sexual predator whose preferred "quarry" are straight men. His motive is usually either his depraved sexuality, or an unrequited love, like his Psycho Lesbian sister. If he's not explicitly gay, but it wouldn't be surprising, he's a Sissy Villain.
Please note that a villain simply being gay is not enough for this trope to be in effect. His brand of evil must involve a sexual nature and/or some uncomfortable flirting with the hero. Or even better, outright threats of rape/molestation. Before adding an example, think of whether he'd be any different if he wasn't gay.
On the other hand, for some people it is enough. For decades, this was the only role gays could play in mainstream media, and it still crops up uncomfortably often. Frequently the villain will be the only homosexual in the story. Now there will be a Freudian Excuse or they be played sympathetically - a kind of Author's Saving Throw against criticism.
But at the end of the day the question for most of us who keep track of these portrayals isn't "Why isn't that Ax Crazy gay man more sympathetic?" but "Why are there so many Ax Crazy gays and lesbians out there?"
These days, it's far more common that a gay character is not evil. However, another character might then be cast in the role of Heteronormative Crusader and mistake the gay character for being evil.
While the characters mentioned certainly fit the trope, other, much more sympathetic characters are pretty strongly implied to be gay or bisexual, rather averting the implication that they're ALL depraved. Off the top of my head—Heisuke makes more than a few references to men and boys he finds attractive or may or may not have slept with, and he's shown as a good, fun sort of guy, if not one who has some trouble making good life choices. Saitou, while he may or may not actually be interested in men (who knows with him?), is willing enough to pretend to be for information. And general dynamics of Ho Yay between various cast members aside, there are always Hijikata and Okita, who always seem just one step shy of being an Official Couple (with Hijikata's voice actor going so far as to respond to a remark about his character having given up romantic pursuits for his mission with, essentially, "Uh...no"). In fact, given that the whole thing is set in the more-or-less privileged classes of late-Edo period Japan, one could make the argument that historical context rather suggests an Everyone Is Bi situation.
In YuYu Hakusho. Sensui averts. He is gay, and he is more than a little crazy, but his insanity and his villainy have nothing to do with his homosexuality, which is more or less second-hand Informed Attribute in any case.
Team Toguro's Karasu from the Dark Tournament practically embodies this trope. He wants to own Kurama, and considers killing him slowly and painfully to be the very best and most intimate way to do so. His depravity and overall creepiness is given more focus than the fact that he's homosexual, though.
However upon his reintroduction a whole community of homosexuals is introduced along with a "queen" of gays with the power to change the gender of himself and others. He could be considered pretty bad on his own but later back on the island he used to rule Sanji crash lands and the residents continually try to chase him and force him into homosexuality, almost succeeding a few times.
Inuyasha is the poster show for this, as every openly homosexual character who has appeared been a depraved sociopath. The only exception is Jakotsu, who started out as a Depraved Homosexual, but became quite more sympathetic as the show went on and we saw his fierce loyalty to his best friend and leader Bankotsu... only to have him end up dying, his Shikon shard stolen by one of his own comrades. To be fair, though, both he and his friend were in a Psycho for Hire group that was wiped out, so Jakotsu's death is NOT linked to his sexuality.
Jakotsu is shown to be intensely loyal to and get on fairly well with Bankotsu, but until his death he remains a steadfast misogynist and a vicious sadist whose idea of "romancing" Inuyasha is synonymous with "beat him until he can't fight back, and then torture & rape him to death".
Another Depraved Homosexual villain threatened to cut off Hojo's face, make it into a wall hanging, and kiss it every day, right before licking said face (anime only).
A popular fan theory speculates that Rolo Haliburton/Lamperouge, Lelouch's "fake brother" in Code Geass, is a Depraved Homosexual who killed Lelouch's prospect girlfriend, Shirley Fenettesolely out of pure jealousy.
A similar and perhaps stronger case could be made concerning V.V., who very canonically and unambiguously killed Marianne entirely out of jealousy and resentment concerning all the attention she was getting from his brother Charles. Making this a case of Twincest as well as Depraved Homosexual.
Creed from Black Cat, though not stated explicitly, exhibits many overt signs of being an example of this trope. With the way he dresses, the way he obviously has perverted fantasies about Train, and his unreasonable jealousy towards anyone remotely close to Train makes him a very likely example of a Depraved Homosexual.
MW looks like it's setting up for this early on with the relationship and backstory between the two lead characters, Michio and Garai. But it's later subverted when the better part of a chapter is used to deliver an aesop about how the world is becoming more accepting of homosexuality and there's nothing wrong with it, and the Villain Protagonist's gay relationship comes off as one of his few humanizing characteristics by the end. This is particularly notable as the series was written in 1976 AND its author is none other than Osamu Tezuka.
Gauron from Full Metal Panic, depending on whether one chooses to follow the novels (where he managed to successfully execute his Wife Husbandry plan with male twins) or the anime (where the twins were female, making him a Depraved Bisexual). But no matter which version, one thing is for sure: he is acompleteandtotalpervert for Sousuke. Seriously? Getting stiffies over fantasizing that he would rape the poor 16-year-old's dead body after he slowly kills him? The poor boy was completely horrified and traumatized when Gauron took the opportunity to let him know what his plans for him were.
In the manga, the gay substitute teacher for Sousuke's high school's men's swim team had some hints of this as shown in the above picture. The guy keeps a whip in his swim trunks and drools and blushes while thinking about Sousuke.
Genkaku from Deadman Wonderland, after getting repeatedly raped and beaten by a group of bullies (who were monk trainees like him) at the temple during his childhood, "became" gay and insane. He seems to express disgust and contempt towards women, and is shown to have a strong attraction to Nagi. In fact, he confesses to Nagi that he "loved him".
Alois Trancy in season 2 of Black Butler. He alternates between being Ax Crazy and sweet and cheerful, flirts with Sebastian via leaning into him and pronouncing that he "smells good", is very attached to his butler Claude, treats his one female maidservant like absolute crap (he stabs out her eye with his fingers just for looking at him and later mocks her for it), dresses and acts very effeminately and flamboyantly and has a girlish face, cross-dresses and flirts with Ciel in the fifth episode and outright tells Ciel that he "wants" him and that he'll kill all his loved ones unless Ciel becomes "his". Also, in episode 8 Alois practically confesses to Claude and in episode 11, Alois tells Claude "Claude, you ensnared my heart in a spider web, my eternal Highness. I wanted your love". In episode 8 Alois also seduces the old man Lord Trancy.
The old man Lord Trancy from episode 8 is one too. He was looking for young boys to be his sex slaves and raped Alois.
Also, Sakurako Saiki who is actually Souma's younger brother, named Youya. He stole his mother's name and dressed in her clothing after she died and he witnessed her murder (at the hands of Katsuragi and a reluctant Souma), which made him lose his mind completely. Soon after his gender was discovered by Masataka, he tried to kill both him and Masataka, and later committed suicide. He also was very much a Yandere towards Souma, and playfully flirted with Masataka on occasion, though he might've done so because he was jealous of Masataka because Souma was in love with him, and wanted to get him away from Souma - this is confirmed when he cooks for Masataka and sneaks glass pieces into said food, and later ties him up and force feeds him.
Paprika: Possibly the Chairman, though his attachment to Osanai seems more a master/slave thing than a sexual or romantic relationship. Also possibly Himuro, who seems to have fetishized Osanai, since we briefly see dirty magazines in his apartment with a younger Osanai on the cover, and his dreamscape features a towering statue of Osanai as a Greek god. It's the Depraved part that's up for debate with Himuro; the gay Porn Stash, cross-dressing and "idolization" of Osanai are more than enough evidence of his sexuality. It's possible Osanai tricked Himuro, or that Himuro was just thinking with his other head when Osanai offered himself.
In Karate Shoukoushi Kohinata Minoru, there's Pedro, the Brazilian martial artist and transfer student. It turns out that he was the masked rapist that went around raping a bunch of male martial arts students, and he ends up setting his sights on Minoru, the pretty boy protagonist. His depraved, rapist tendencies are played as comedy, and eventually the main characters forgive him and have him join their karate club. Even make Minoru room with him. Which results in him trying several times to rape Minoru (including an instance where Pedro went pantless with his junk out, in the middle of the night, to rape Minoru while Minoru was unconscious and drunk). Aside from the aforementioned insanity, Unfortunate Implications abound in this example, seeing how he's the only homosexual character in the series.
Trigun: The manga contains a few creepy examples among secondary characters; Legato is implied to fit into this role too, but the guy who raped him was even creepier (at least as a depraved gay guy). Manga Knives might fit too depending on what subtext you follow and what level of Fan Wank you adhere to. The anime also has Sodom, a Camp Gay secondary character.
Lord Gennon from Berserk. He is a homosexual and a notorious pedophile, and he developed an attraction for Griffith, which culminated when Griffith agreed to sleep with him in exchange for funds to support the growing Band of the Hawks. He is often seen to be attended by many very young male servants, no older than being in their teens.
Also, Donovan. He's a notorious pederast who raped Guts when he was still a vulnerable child. Donovan bought Guts for a night from Gambino, Guts adoptive father.
Government official Hidehiko Otoya from Akikan. He's a self-proclaimed gay who loves pretty boys and he goes undercover at the school as the school doctor. He's often having contact with Kakeru harassing him sexually, only to be hurt severely by Kakeru every time.
Sho Tsukioka from Battle Royale is effeminate in manner but humorously masculine in appearance and uses his skills as a Stalker with a Crush to tail Kiriyama. He's also a borderline alcoholic drag queen with an irrational crush on Kiriyama and overall thinks like a total lunatic.
Both Arthur and Shalott of Air Gear. Arthur is a masochist who pelvic thrusts against his male opponent Agito and nibbles on his ear while fighting him. He also has flamboyant mannerisms, speaks in a polite manner, and frequently releases heart marks whenever he's reveling in the feeling of pain. Shalott is a loli who wears a frilly looking dress and reveals to Agito that he's actually a girly-looking guy who is in a BDSM type relationship with Arthur. The end of chapter 279 has him pin Agito to the ground and straddle him, saying after he tortures him then Agito can "lick it" if he wants.
In Rurouni Kenshin, we have a subverted example: Kanryu Takeda. The historical, Real LifeKanryusai Takeda (on whom he is heavily based) was a well-known homosexual (and all-around bad guy), but Nobuhiro Watsuki didn't see how that fit into his fictional story, and so it is not mentioned in-story. Though he did wonder how it would have been different if he had managed to work it in. (Which he mentions inhis notes.)
A half human half spider hybrid who appears in the first OVA of Angel's Feather. When he appears he wraps Shou up in his web, caresses him, gets close to his face, sticks his finger in his mouth, and licks him before trying to murder him.
Naoe of Mirage Of Blaze. He's a Straight Gay but he's also quite the Yandere in regards to Kagetora whom he nearly rapes and was tempted to kill himself and Kagetora so that Kagetora will never belong to anyone else. He also tries to Murder the Hypotenuse and says he wants to keep Kagetora for himself, and tries to plant Forceful Kisses on Kagetora. In the novels it's hinted that he's a rapist.
Krad of D.N.Angel. He's a homicidal Bishōnen and has tons of obsessive Ho Yay towards his host Satoshi (though he doesn't mind it if he hurts Satoshi) and Foe Yay towards Dark (whom he tries to kill numerous times).
In chapter 6 of No6 a greasy old corpse collector hits on Shion and promises him food and drink, and clearly has bad intentions. Shion initiates the Groin Attack on him to escape from him.
Tomoe's boyfriend (and later husband) Kurokawa from Challengers and The Tyrant Falls in Love is really a perfectly nice guy. However, his homophobic Knight Templar Big Brother, Souichi, doesn't see it that way and a lot of the comedy of the series is derived from him trying to murder Kurokawa at every opportunity for "corrupting" his brother.
MurakuMatsumoto from Gamaran. His routine is the following: falling in love with a very powerful opponent, maim him to death to "show him his love" and then scalp him and add his hair to his special hair-woven chainmail.
Angelo Sauper from Gundam Unicorn, one of the few canonically gay characters in the Gundam series, isn't especially perverted but he is very, very angry and won't hesitate to slaughter anybody who stands in the way of his commander and love interest Full Frontal in the most vicious ways available to him.
Subverted by the Pied Piper in The Flash. His orientation isn't revealed until he's been established as an Anti-Villain who helps the homeless and has become on fairly good terms with Wally West. Further defied when Wally speculates that the Joker is one of these; Piper is highly skeptical.
"The pope" from Give Me Liberty, a gang boss inside the Cabrini-Green ghetto/prison. His henchmen originally kidnapped Martha Washington for rape because she was disguised as a boy.
The Sandman: The Corinthian likes guys. Also, he likes guys' eyes. Whether these two are connected, I am unsure. Either way. He's not particularly camp and the only suggestion (outside of the continuation of stories in The Dreaming) that he's homosexual usually center around his choice of victims (it helps that he takes a distinct relish in despoiling innocence that implies eye-taking is at least as good as sex for him).
Sasuke of Naruto sometimes gets this characterization in Slash Fic with Naruto which is best expressed with him sometimes attempting to rape or harassing Naruto. In the Slash Fic "Purple" by kodak-85 for example he attacks and rapes Naruto.
The Nostalgia Chick: "He has this bizarre co-dependent crush on the Beast and just loves him getting emo."
Film - Live-Action
Skyfall features an oddly lisping and bleach blonde Silva menacingly rubbing Bond's thighs.
Well, to be fair, he's not really oddly lisping: his face is quite severely deformed from a failed cyanide suicide attempt, thus spurring his desire for revenge against M., and he wears a prosthetic device to keep a semi-normal shape. The hair, however, is inexplicable.
The most spectacular part of this scene, however, is Bond's reaction. With typical unruffled Bond demeanour, he says, "What makes you think this is my first time?"
Cruising, starring Al Pacino, is about a cop chasing a gay serial killer through the New York CityLeatherman community, circa 1980. It's implied that being around S&M turns Pacino's character gay, and possibly murderous as well.
The film did have a disclaimer at the start that the movie was not in any way representative of all gay men, to try to calm the protests that arose after its premiere.
Andy Warhol was portrayed in this manner (by Guy Pierce!) in Factory Girl (2006). So much so that one reviewer referred to the character as "Andy Warhol, or, as this film wants you to know him, Darth Warhol."
The 1961 short film Boys Beware, produced by Sid Davis. It was intended to be shown in high schools to warn teenage boys about the dangers of gay men. This film has become famous on the internet for lines such as "What Jimmy didn't know was that Ralph was sick. A sickness that was not visible like smallpox, but no less dangerous and contagious — a sickness of the mind. You see, Ralph was a homosexual." Another fun element: the violent contrast between the hysterical condemnation of homosexuality and the unconditional endorsement it gives the practice of hitchhiking.
Even more dissonant is that the way Ralph acts (very touchy) is not the problem even though today someone who gave young boys a ride and pats on the back would certainly be assumed to be a pedophile or at least creepy instantly.
The X-Files: I Want to Believe is guilty of this, with Callum Keith Rennie's serial killer kidnapping young women to build his boyfriend a girl-body. One has to hope that said boyfriend is actually a Transsexual and that said serial killer is actually bisexual because otherwise... well... slight problems might arise in the relationship. Add that to the plot of the evil psychic gay pedophile priest in the movie and it probably should have been called "The X-Files: I Want to Believe Gay People Are Evil". At least the pedophile priest seems to be genuinely repentant of his crimes. He did admit to cutting his own balls off after all.
The Flanderization of the eponymous character of Brüno. He's ostensibly not a villain, but Bruno became so horny to all other men that it would make ANYONE want to get away from him. So the "undercurrent of homophobia" in American society that Sacha Baron Cohen was trying to expose mostly comes off as sane people reacting normally to an unbelievably offensive living stereotype. The film really did more harm than good for the gay community.
Parodied and subverted in Cecil B. Demented, where sadistic hairdresser Rodney takes his frustration over being heterosexual out on other people by abusing them physically.
As a matter of fact, all records that mention his sexuality present Herod as a raging heterosexual hedonist with several wives and concubines, with the idea of him being gay a slander started by his enemies.
Irreversible has a whole club full of these, one of which is a nasty piece of work called le Tenia, 'the Tapeworm'. Despite his orientation, he's the one who rapes and beats Monica Bellucci's character, Alex.
The case of real life thrill-killers and literal Nietzsche Wannabes Nathan Leopold, Jr. and Richard Loeb has been depicted a couple of times on film. Hitchcock'sRope is a fictionalized version, with most of the homosexual overtones subtextual; Tom Kalin's Swoon is more explicit and adheres more literally to the real-life case.
The villain of the Walter Matthau film The Laughing Policeman, who is revealed to have committed a series of murders, including spraying dozens of innocent people on a bus with machine gun fire, in order to keep from being outed.
Sebastian in Meet the Feebles isn't exactly a villain and is definitely more sympathetic than a lot of the other characters, but he bullies the cast members, forces Robert to replace the assistant the drugged-up knife-thrower accidentally killed, and thinks nothing of singing an elaborate ode to sodomy, complete with appropriate props and ostentatious pelvic thrusts, on a family-oriented variety show.
In Jeepers Creepers, the Creeper is popularly described as this, since it really only seems interested in male victims, which it has a penchant for acting lewd towards (gestures, winking, licking windows, etc.) At least one review of the second film described it as "a demonic Jeffrey Dahmer".
Stu from Scream (1996) seems to be labeled this a lot.
Crazy Larry from Layer Cake, with his penchant for raping and murdering other men.
Crazy Larry: "Fucking females is for poofs."
Charles Laughton (who was gay) as Emperor Nero in The Sign of the Cross. Subverted in that he liked to play the role, and stated that it was better for him than a month of therapy.
The 1976 pirate movie Swashbuckler has Peter Boyle playing the evil homosexual governor who is tyrannizing Jamaica. His effeminate boy lover dies by falling into his ridiculously impractical weapon during the finale, when he tries to attack the hero from behind.
In the 1987 thriller No Way Out, Scott Pritchard, Defense Secretary David Brice's aide, helps him cover up his involvement in the death of his mistress. As the situation devolves, Pritchard becomes increasingly psychopathic until, at the end, it is revealed that he's been harboring an Unrequited Love for Brice. He commits suicide upon being rejected.
In Deathtrap, the Michael Caine and Christopher Reeve characters turn out to be lovers who conspire to murder Caine's wife.
Coach Schneider in A Nightmare on Elm Street Part 2: Freddy's Revenge is a sexually predatory gay man working as a gym coach at a high school. He abducts Jesse when he sees him in a gay bar, and it is implied that he was about to rape him before Freddy intervened and killed Schneider.
This trope probably has its origins in The Green Carnation, a truly libelous roman a clef written in the 1890s and featuring villains based on Oscar Wilde and his lover Alfred "Bosie" Douglas who plot to defraud a young widow of her fortune. They are assisted by a kind of Yaoi Fangirl based on Wilde's real-life Fag Hag Ada "Sphinx" Leverson.
Another early example was E. W. Hornung's Raffles stories. Hornung intended the stories to subvert the glamor of the Gentleman Thief; Raffles was no Robin Hood in the original stories, just a criminal. Although expressed very discreetly between the lines, the relationship between Raffles and his pathetically submissive sidekick/victim Bunny Manders was definitely homosexual (see discussion under Ho Yay/Literature). The way Raffles is shown relating to Bunny is definitely exploitative and abusive. Hornung was frustrated that his readers insisted on seeing Raffles as glamorous anyhow; his later stories, where he portrayed Raffles more brutally, were less popular. More recent takes on Raffles invariably go the Robin Hood, detective, or other hero route.
Bernard Cornwell portrays precisely three gay characters in the Sharpe series. One, Lord Pumphrey, is a ruthless, Camp Gay secret agent who has Sharpe's ex-lover and unborn child murdered to protect "information that might...embarass His Majesty's Government. A favourite habit of his is to draw his finger across his throat slowly when giving instructions. The other two are a pair Spanish officers in Chile - the cowardly and deceitful Captain Martinez and the psychotic Captain-General Baptista. Their relationship (and Baptista) does not survive Richard Sharpe.
Dyan Ardais in Marion Zimmer Bradley's Darkover series, although he eventually redeems himself somewhat.
There's only one character in the Elenium trilogy by David Eddings who is confirmed to be homosexual, and that's Baron Harparin. He's a noted pederast. When he gets beheaded toward the end of the series, one character comments that a whole generation of little boys will probably remember the knight who killed him in their prayers every night.
Subverted though in the fact it's made clear that it's Harparin's pederasty the characters have a problem with, rather than his homosexuality.
Although sympathetic homosexual characters appear later on in The Tamuli. Granted, they largely fall under Bury Your Gays.
James Ellroy's The Big Nowhere is chock-full of these. One uses the gay escort service he runs to out and blackmail his clients; another, a closeted actor, sexually abuses his own son; and the son himself goes on to become a Serial Killer. The only sympathetic gay man in the entire book, Danny Upshaw, kills himself to avoid being outed.
The killer in the Ellery Queen novel The Last Woman in His Life.
a monk named Ambrose, in Candace Robb's medieval mystery The Apothecary Rose (the next book, however, contains a sympathetic character (Martin Werther) who is gay. Secretly).
Leslie Marmon Silko's Almanac of the Dead received some criticism for this as several of the main villains are gay.
Anno Dracula has Vardalek, a diseased, murderously sadistic member of the Carpathian Guard.
Miles Mellough, a Psycho for Hire and the main character's longtime nemesis in the satiric The Eiger Sanction. He comes complete with a home base in San Francisco and a poodle named "Faggot." Apparently, quite a few people have assumed he was just as soft as he acted, to their peril.
Averted in Outlander by Diana Gabaldon: there is seemingly a textbook example of this in the form of moustache-twirling villain Captain "Black Jack" Randall, who lusts after, pursues, and then tortures and repeatedly rapes the novel's hero, Jamie Frasier. However, there is also a heroic character who is gay in subsequent novels. In any case, Randall isn't evil because he's gay (bisexual, to be more precise), he's evil because he's a sadistic rapist. Gabaldon has plenty of sleazy gay characters, but they're no worse and no better than the straight ones.
The fact that some readers read this trope (amongst others) into Katherine Kerr's Deverry series is one of the reasons that she released a revised edition of the second book Darkspell. In the original version, the evil mage Alastyr rapes his apprentice Sarcyn and his younger brother. When Sarcyn has grown to adulthood, the two are shown abducting a man and raping him repeatedly. (They draw magical powers from this act.) This led some readers to conclude that Alastyr was intended to be an evil gay pedophile rapistwizard. One of the revisions Kerr made was to change Sarcyn's brother into a sister, to drive home the point that no, Alastyr's crime is not homosexuality, it's that he's a child molester. Likewise, Sarcyn is shown to be sexually interested in both men and women - it's not that he's straight or gay or even bisexual but that his sexuality is, in Kerr's own words, "a mess". Growing up in a brothel and then getting molested as a child has left him unable to develop a healthy attitude towards sex.
The boy killer in "Apt Pupil" from Stephen King's Different Seasons anthology is implied to have latent homosexual feelings. The 1998 movie adaptation hints at the possibility but makes it more ambiguous. (Additionally, the movie presents the boy as a much more sympathetic character than in the book, more a confused kid who's sucked into a situation he can't handle than an unrepentant sociopath.)
All homosexuals in Marquis de Sade's books fit the trope, although this is probably meant to be ironic nod at the values of his time, as good Marquis was himself bisexual, and all characters who aren't innocent victims are depraved monsters regardless of their sexual preference anyway in his stories. There is a social message in there if you squint hard enough.
Bone and Chair, the stand-ins for The Mad Hatter and the March Hare in Patrick Senecal's take on Alice in Wonderland,Aliss. At one point, Aliss watches the two of them having passionate sex in the midst of the blood and guts of the man they've just horrifically tortured not-quite-to-death.
Live Action TV
Averted in 'Allo 'Allo!, where the gay and bisexual German officers tend to be the most genial and harmless of the lot.
Criminal Minds had an... interesting variant on the "evil because they're gay" thing. The UnSub in "In Heat" was filled with so muchGayngst that it drove him insane and made him kill other gay men, so he could steal their identities and live their lives to escape his own. His anger was mainly due to his father's behavious, beating him and berating him because he was gay, rather than him being gay.
The UnSub in "Identity" had a meek, gay accomplice who helped the killer because he was obsessively in love with him (the team note that, in the videos the accomplice made of the killer torturing his victims, he seemed more focused on the killer's chest and abs than the victims). When the killer commits suicide, the accomplice goes insane and tries to become him.
Live Documentary: The whelk is nothing but a homosexual of the worst kind. This gay boy of the gastropods, this queer crustacean, this mincing mollusk, this screaming, prancing, limp-wristed queen of the deep MAKES ME SICK!!!
Generally screwed around with - arguably averted or played straight, though the conditions of neither are met entirely - in Sherlock with Jim, introduced as a camp gay with a high-pitched voice whose underwear sticks out of his trousers and who gives Sherlock his phone number. Later, Jim is revealed to be James Moriarty. He claims that he has been playing gay for Sherlock, but since he continues to act in much the same fashion as he did before and continues to flirt with Sherlock, it's difficult to say whether or not he qualifies as a Depraved Homosexual.
Picket Fences - In the episode Be My Valentine, it turns out that The serial killer known as "Cupid" turns out to be both Barry and Ben. In the version that I saw, they were raping their female victims with a dildo because they would never use their own penises (though it's not in the Hulu version, so they're not Depraved Bisexuals). Bonus points for when Max says "What the hell? That's sick!" When she sees the two men kiss
Crowley from Supernatural reads as this.note Which is amusing because Crowley's whole character is a reference to Good Omens, where it's Aziraphale people think is gayer than a treeful of monkeys on nitrous oxide. The rules of the Supernatural universe require a kiss to seal a deal with a demon, and Crowley seems to delight in making deals with men and watching them squirm uncomfortably about it. His relationship with Bobby in particular is incredibly subtext laden. He subverts this for about half a season by helping the boys try and stop Lucifer from unleashing the apocalypse, and then turns out to be one of season six's Big Bads.
Crowley's extreme amusement at kissing said men might derive partly from the fact that they are far more hesitant to kiss him than they are to sell their souls to hell for eternity, which indicates a seriously demented set of priorities.
Karofsky from Glee. A somewhat unusual example, though, since his target is also gay.
Sandy Ryerson, of the second (at the moment) page quote, is a much less unusual example.
Sebastian Smythe, despite his target also being another gay, is another straighter-playing of the trope, with his stalkerish behavior toward Blaine and aggressive hatred of Kurt.
Kurt was this in the first season to Finn and Finn being disturbed by it.
Subverted with Barca, from Spartacus: Blood and Sand. Although he is a villain, in a sense, he's just a Punch Clock Villain who wants to buy freedom for himself and his boyfriend. Gnaeus, on the other hand, is a straight example whose primary role in the series is to rape and beat Pietros until he commits suicide.
Subverted in a Las Vegas episode by a gay couple when they have Danny and Mike over for some food. They say that the four of them can have each other for lunch and then dinner, weirding out Danny and Mike, but then admit that they were just messing with them.
Banshee has a flashback to Lucas' time in prison where he was abused by an Evil Albino inmate. The albino is described by another inmate as "as queer as they come" to indicate that he is not just 'prison gay'. The albino then offers to go easy on Lucas if Lucas willingly has sex with the him. Otherwise the albino will beat up and torture Lucas for the entirety of Lucas' 15 year sentence. Lucas chooses to Take a Third Option and brutally kills the albino in front of the other prisoners.
The title character of Nick Cave's "Stagger Lee" (although not in the traditional version).
Timo Maas's "Pictures" is about a homosexual child pornographer.
Slaanesh worshippers in the Warhammer 40000/Warhammer universes are often depicted this way. They have moved beyond homosexuality and will hump Anything That Moves once just to see what it is like. However, in what may or may not be an example of Unfortunate Implications, Slaanesh worshipers are the only characters in the Warhammer continuities who ever even hint at being gay. Creating an impression that ALL homosexuals end up as drug-addled false-idol-fondling heathen devil-pagans having wild drug-fueled orgies with men, women, beasts, aliens, mutants, demons and whatever else has a conveniently sized hole in it.
Given the Empire's large and powerful Church Militant and the Imperium's attitude to, well, everything, it can probably be assumed that anyone even suspected of being gay is burned. Possibly on the grounds of "we need you to breed more troops so don't be gay".
The Ravenor books depict gay people as citizens in Imperial society. The best explanation seems to be that some worlds may have laws or social conventions against homosexuality, and others don't. The Imperium is a big place after all.
That's why we have Ciaphas Cain, which has a number of gay characters. None are evil.
However, Ciaphas Cain is a work of parody so it is questionable if the books can be considered hard Canon.
Technically, none of the novelizations are hard canon, and the sourcebooks don't really go into the Depraved Homosexual Slaaneshi cultist thing to any noticible extent.
Everything 40k related that has the Gamesworkshop logo or the logo of one of their subsidiaries is canon. Even the things that contradict each other. And the Cain books aren't really a parody so much as Flash ManIN SPAAAAAAAAAAAAACE!
Given that the whole deal with Slaanesh is the pursuit of perfection and beauty to the point of cosmic horrorterror parody, slaaneshi cultists are less depraved homosexuals and more depraved bisexuals, or omnisexuals rather (they really will do anything that moves) The likelihood of negative portrayal of homosexuals in the Imperium is still high but also depends on the planet's culture and the local ecclesiarchy, needless to say however it would be not be unreasonable to assume the Inquisition and the church would keep a close eye on sexual morality because, well, Slaanesh is kind of really insidious that way. The Eldar however would likely persecute it very hard with their very low population growth rate (what with their fertility goddess being captured by Nurgle and all) they'd likely try to encourage population growth very heavily.
Roy Cohn from Angels in America. Probably falls more under Truth in Television though, since he's one of two characters based off of real people, and also a Straw Hypocrite who believes his "clout" puts him above oppression and social stigma most gay men in the play have to deal with. Joe is also painted as a "bad guy" of sorts because he agreed to work for Cohn, but he really is more insecure than depraved.
Some critics believe that Iago is one of these in the Shakespeare play Othello, driven to destroy Othello because of his unrequited homosexual love for the Moorish general.
A similar interpretation has been applied to Hermia's father in A Midsummer Night's Dream, who is unusually...determined to see her married off to the guy he wants. A lot of people believe that he was actually in love with Lysander himself and forcing Hermia to marry him (with threats of imprisonment in a convent and death) was as close as he could get.
Well, Shakespeare opened that door himself. You have her father's love, Demetrius; let me have Hermia's; do you marry him. Especially the way Dick Powell delivers that line.
Lieutenant Yaha, the guardian of the District of Precious Light in Drakengard 2. He made a pact with the gnomes, giving him the ability to beguile and charm anyone who looked him in the eyes, but the price he paid was that he lost the ability to feel pleasure. He makes very "interesting" comments during his boss battle, and it's heavily implied that he had a romantic relationship with one of your allies, Urick.
Quite possibly Sander Cohen in BioShock, if the sneering remarks in some of the audio diaries are to be believed.
It's more than the allegations in the audio diaries: it's pretty strongly implied that the targets Cohen has you to track down to complete his Quadtych were his former lovers. However, Cohen is really more of a Mad Artist than a Depraved Homosexual.
He's implied to be both homosexual and depraved prior to arriving in Rapture, with rumors of young men disappearing around him and his 'project' of undressed proteges 'performing' scenes from Caligula's life. He's definitely depraved (and still homosexual) once Rapture starts falling apart, since the 2K Games-approved novel mentions him forcing a teenage boy to fuck an octopus at a 'wild party.'
Done tragically with Abul Nuquod in Assassin's Creed. His sexuality does drive him to mass-murder and joining conspiracy to take over the Holy Land, but specifically because the culture he lives in and Islam in general call him an "abomination" and cause him to be the object of shame and scorn despite his generosity and lavish parties.
What little we learn about Major Raikov in Metal Gear Solid 3: Snake Eater is that he's gay and beats up his men for fun, and will molest Big Boss if you stand him in front of him. He gets a little more characterisation in Portable Ops, but not much (Oddly, he's become a kind of Ensemble Dark Horse, and his relationship with Colonel Volgin is kind of sweet).
Somewhat implied in Fire Emblem: The Sword of Seals, with a highly effeminate duo of bandits (with equally effeminate names—Maggie and Rose) that attacks the party in the desert in one chapter. Completely irrelevant to the plot, however, so it's just for uncomfortable humor.
Thomas in Deadly Premonition seems like a nice guy at first, but turns out to be in league with the killer, and ends up trying to kill Emily because he believes her to be a romantic rival. Adding to the Unfortunate Implications is the fact that his effeminacy seems to increase in direct proportion to his craziness.
In The Witcher 2, one of the main characters during the chapter 2 is sorcerer Dethmold. During most of his arc, he's rather Bad Ass, dabbling in necromancy and showing ability to one-shot wraiths by shooting lightning out of his staff, which ends in a cockerel, and generally proves to be a formidable opponent, even if he's somewhat prejudiced against women. In the chapter 3, we learn why. He's gay. When he becomes a villain, all of a sudden, he turns out to be gay, with a sex slave, and terribly incompetent. Upon getting his arm broken, instead of releasing a barrage of magic, he just cries out how precious his arm is. In the end, it looks like game developers decided that making him gay would somehow make him more creepy.
Captain Vicente De Santa in Red Dead Redemption is a yellow-eyed bastard in the Mexican Army under the command of Col. Augustin Allende, who regularly shoots unarmed civilians, declares the oppressed peasantry to be stupid and backwards, back-stabs his allies in the name of his own ambition and eventually betrays and tries to kill John Marston. He is also heavily hinted to be a homosexual, in an implied affair with his boss' butler. His fanatical devotion to Col. Allende could also be seen as a form of unrequited love. He gets executed either by Mexican Rebels or John himself .
The main character's evil gay twinNaitsirhc from Sonichu. He seems to be evil precisely because he is gay (when he's injected with a homosexuality cure, he instantly becomes a good guy) and the hero is repulsed and unnerved by his very presence. To say that the creator has issues is a massive understatement.
Averted in Our Little Adventure. The main villains Angelo and Brian are a homosexual married couple. They are both gay and evil, but they are not Depraved Homosexuals. Their relationship is actually far more caring then one would expect from any evil relationship, and does not have any overtly sexual tones to it. In fact Angelo could be made female without any other change to the comic and the comic would work perfectly well. This is one of the rare examples where the character's being evil appears to be completely independent of the fact that they are homosexual.
The Onion had a (satirical, obviously) story about how some people, who were initially tolerant of homosexuals, started to believe this trope after seeing a gay pride parade (link).
Internet Story, a short suspense film on youtube by Adam Butcher possibly has this as its conclusion, but it's deliberately left ambiguous as to whether between a gay guy and a possibly homophobic guy which one was the murderer and which was the victim.
The Booty Warrior from The Boondocks. While it's made clear that most of the prisoners present rape each other out of sheer loneliness, The Booty Warrior was already raping men and was happy to go to prison where he could rape inmates.
Herbert from Family Guy is a creepy elderly ephebophile who resides just down the street from the Griffin Family and lusts after Chris (to the point of being a Stalker with a Crush). Other episodes show him lusting after other adolescent male characters, and in one episode, the one year old Stewie.
Stewie can be considered one of these as well.
Though his most depraved moment (burning alive two toddlers) was when he was heterosexual, and in fact was his reaction to discovering unfaithfulness in his heterosexual relationship. So his depravity seems to be independent of his sexuality.
The character mentioned in the trope's quote, Mr. Garrison from South Park. Who goes through a lot of different sexualities/identities/gross cynical criminal schemes, always being some depraved version of that. And then back again.
Mr. Slave is a subversion, at least when it comes to humans. He looks the part as he dresses in buttless leather biker wear and has extremely messed up sexual fetishes, but he's actually a nice guy who understands that his twisted perversions (namely his extreme BDSM and jamming living things up his ass) are not things to be emulated.
Played straight with Saddam Hussien. Satan while gay, is not depraved and was actually on the receiving end of domestic abuse when dating Saddam.