Follow TV Tropes


YMMV / One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest

Go To

The novel

  • Alternative Character Interpretation:
    • Ratched is just a nurse trying to do her job as well as she knows how; McMurphy, a racist and statutory rapist, insists on causing mayhem on her ward.
    • McMurphy himself, who is diagnosed in the play with a pathological need to flout authority and be the center of attention... Which seems about right.
  • Complete Monster: Ratched, the "Big Nurse", is the cruel head of the state hospital the story takes place in, using her connections to her superiors to allow herself free reign over the hospital. Ratched subjects her dozens of patients to horrific conditions and abuse, employing brutal lackeys and methods to keep patients in line and under her thumb, uncaring of the countless patients who commit suicide or self-mutilation due to her rule. Believing that her patients have to be perfectly-functioning before allowing them to leave, Ratched often resorts to electroshock treatments and even lobotomies to destroy her patients' minds. When her rule is challenged over and over again by Randle McMurphy, Ratched increases her abuse of the patients to the point that one of McMurphy's friends kills himself. Though Ratched's control over the patients is broken, she spitefully has McMurphy lobotomized in a last-ditch effort to terrorize the patients into falling back in line.
  • Advertisement:
  • Genius Bonus: Harding is hinted to be gay and doesn't seem to have any apparent mental illness. However, back at the time the book was written and published, homosexuality was in the DSM as a mental illness and was not removed from the DSM until the 1970s. Therefore, Harding could have been hospitalized to try to "cure" his homosexuality, but this was not stated outright, to keep the novel from being labelled as "obscene".
  • Hilarious in Hindsight: Big Nurse Ratched's name has taken on a funny quality now that "ratchet" has become teen slang used to describe anything with the quality of the ghetto about it.
  • Ho Yay: Plenty in the novel, but not between any specific characters and used more to build up the discomforting, emasculating atmosphere of the hospital than to establish the sweetly ambiguous kinds of relationships that the trope is associated with.
    • There's some between Chief and McMurphy
      Chief: That's a lie. I know he’s still alive. That ain’t the reason I want to touch him.I want to touch him because he’s a man.That’s a lie too. There’s other men around. I could touch them. I want to touch him because I’m one of these queers! But that’s a lie too. That’s one fear hiding behind another. If I was one of these queers I’d want to do other things with him. I just want to touch him because he’s who he is.
    • Advertisement:
    • And then there are the orderlies. According to Bromden, they love to give patients showers. They always check the patient's temperature at the same time they shower the patient, and they go down to Miss Ratched beforehand to get a rectal thermometer and a bottle of Vaseline. She admonishes them to use the minimum amount of Vaseline necessary, but they take the whole bottle inside with them, and they turn up the water pressure till the noise makes it impossible to hear anything that's going on inside...
  • Moral Event Horizon: Nurse Ratched has been on the wrong end of the moral event horizon for many years, as she is seen to submit her charges to torture for crossing her (the scene with the germophobe after the fishing trip, the forced anal administration of medication to a patient merely because he questioned what the pills were for), the electroshock 'therapy', and she has also lobotomized patients as punishment for behavior she dislikes. Nurse Ratched is utterly monstrous in the book.
    • Of course, given the book's expert use of Unreliable Narrator, it's hard to tell if she really is that bad or if it's the Chief projecting onto her. Remember, he also thinks that the orderlies are evil robots.
  • Some Anvils Need to Be Dropped: The whole reason this book exists.
  • This Is Your Premise on Drugs: '1984 in rehab'.
  • Values Dissonance:
    • The African-American orderlies are treated a bit indelicately, and McMurphy even drops an N-Bomb. In the book, the orderlies are overtly thugs and rapists.
    • Many people find the book to be misogynist, what with and the idea that matriarchy is akin to castration, and the implication that no woman could/should dominate a "real man." Prostitution and McMurphy's statutory rape charge are treated pretty casually. Ratched's violent comeuppance is, in the book, very sexualized and supposed to be seen as a moment of dishing out truly justified retribution.
    • McMurphy's charge of statutory rape—in the time the book was written, it wasn't as serious a crime. McMurphy also alleges she told him she was eighteen, and he wasn't found guilty of it, but he does brag about it. The book and movie asks you to see him as an admirable anti-authority figure.
  • The Woobie: Every character that's not Nurse Ratched or McMurphy at least until the end. Charlie Cheswick and Billy Bibbit come to mind especially, however.

The movie

  • Alternative Character Interpretation:
  • Award Category Fraud: Louise Fletcher won an Oscar for her work in the leading category when many believe Nurse Ratched, while by far the largest female role, is more of a supporting character, as McMurphy is clearly the much bigger part.
  • Award Snub: While the film swept the major Oscar categories, many still believe Brad Dourif was robbed for not winning Best Supporting Actor for his role as Billy Bibbit.
  • Ensemble Dark Horse: Billy is the most popular of the inmates thanks to being a cute, Adorkable Nice Guy who is also the film’s biggest Woobie
  • Estrogen Brigade: Billy Bibbit has quite the female fandom, probably due to his Moe status, though being played by a young, cute Brad Dourif doesn't hurt.
  • Germans Love David Hasselhoff: The film was very popular in Sweden when it came out.
  • Harsher in Hindsight: McMurphy's original crime was statutory rape. A few years later, Jack Nicholson's house was where the whole Roman Polański fiasco started.
  • Hilarious in Hindsight:
  • Ho Yay: In the film, there's Billy/McMurphy. McMurphy even says to Candy something like, "I just want you to do this one thing for me. He's cute, isn't he?"
    • In the film, much of Sefelt and Fredrickson's interactions-such as their inseparability, how Fredrickson is always touching the older man, them dancing together at the party, and them passing out with their beds pushed together afterwards- can be seen as this
  • Moe: Billy
  • Moral Event Horizon: Nurse Ratched might just be a mean and misguided nurse trying to do her job, right up until the point where she threatens to tell Billy's mother about his "bad behaviour", knowing full well the trauma that would cause him, which leads to his suicide.
  • Retroactive Recognition: Brad Dourif, Christopher Lloyd and Danny DeVito make early appearances.
  • Signature Scene: Chief throwing the sink through the windows and escaping at the end.
  • Unintentionally Unsympathetic:
    • McMurphy. We're supposed to see him as an admirable anti-authority figure even though he's loud, obnoxious, casually racist, and sexist and he had no qualms about conning his fellow patients (who he also mocks and berates) out of their money. Not only that but the entire reason he's at the asylum in the first place is so that he can avoid going to prison on statutory rape charges.


How well does it match the trope?

Example of:


Media sources: