The original run launched as an ongoing series in the New 52, with the initial cast featuring Zatanna, Deadman, Madame Xanadu, John Constantinenote , Shade, the Changing Man and a new character called Mindwarp, who was introduced in Flashpoint. The team's roster fluctuated regularly over the course of the series, drawing on DCU characters with a connection to the supernatural.
It came to an end in 2015 after 44 issues and two annuals... but as the team's members would be the first to tell you, some things don't stay dead for good.
In 2018, a new series was announced as part of the "New Justice" DCU imprint spinning out of Justice League: No Justice, with Wonder Woman heading a team including Zatanna, Swamp Thing, Detective Chimp. and Man-Bat, their first storyline involving the group dealing with the aftermath of the Dark Multiverse Invasion and them trying to stave off the Death of Magic. The very, very, very bloody Death of Magic.
An animated film, Justice League Dark, was released in 2017, with Constantine actor Matt Ryan reprising his role as John Constantine. For this outing, Constantine's team-mates included Deadman, Zatanna, Swamp Thing, Black Orchid and Jason Blood.
In addition to the animated film, there have been numerous attempts at adapting Justice League Dark to live-action, most notably by Guillermo del Toro. His version, titled Dark Universe, was confirmed to exist as a screenplay in late 2014, and reportedly featured a lineup consisting of Constantine, Swamp Thing, Etrigan the Demon, Deadman, Spectre, and Zatanna. Del Toro's film wouldn't have connected to the DC Extended Universe (nor the 2014 NBC series Constantine) though he expressed interest in modifying his script to accomodate them and even having Constantine's Matt Ryan reprise his title role. By June 2015, it was reported that del Toro had left the project, which would still be developed without him as director. In August 2016, Doug Liman was then attached to direct, with del Toro producing, but in May 2017 it was reported that he stepped down to focus on his adaptation of the novel Chaos Walking. In January 2020, it was reported that J. J. Abrams was developing Justice League Dark projects as part of his new production deal with WarnerMedia, which would possibly involve films and television series focusing on various characters.
Tropes featured in Justice League Dark include:
- Always Someone Better: Mordru reveals that his brothers and sisters, the Lords of Order have a glaring limitation. They're so besotted with Order that they limit what they can do with rituals and spells whereas the Lords of Chaos simply channel magic and will it to what they want. So when he turns the Justice League into Lords of Chaos, they easily wipe out the Lords of Order and imprison Nabu.
- Curb-Stomp Battle: Hecate and the Otherkind do this to anyone who goes up against them. Dr Fate and the other Lords of Order continue this tradition of steamrolling everyone, before Justice League Dark are transformed into Lords of Chaos and kill almost every Lord of Order in a single hit.
- Dark Is Not Evil: Pretty much every member of the team would on first glance appear to be more at home causing terror wherever they went, but they only save that for the real bad guys. Hell, it's in the name.
- Deconstruction: The Will They or Won't They?, Opposites Attract, and Working with the Ex dynamics between John and Zatanna are brutally slaughtered. John's attachment is a borderline obsession that no one really approves of. Zatanna is upset and angry whenever John shows up, and never starts to like or even respect him again no matter how many times he saves her life. In issue #30, Zatanna kicks John out of the House of Mysteries and the JLD. John has matured enough to realize that she, and everyone else, would be better off without him.
- Enemy Mine: A Godzilla Threshold moment happens for Wonder Woman's team when they witness Dr. Fate and his fellow Lords of Order slaughtering entire dimensions. They know there's nobody on their side even close to being able to take on them. So they approach the evil Lord of Chaos, Mordru, for help.
- Fantastic Aesop: Magic is sometimes used as an analog to drug abuse, in that most of the magic users are unstable. But the line is blurred with Xanadu, who is dependent on normal drugs in order to cope with her visions of the future.
- FaceHeel Turn: Dr. Fate turns on everyone and sides with his fellow Lords of Order, they end up dismantling entire magical dimensions while their inhabitants were still in them.
- Fire-Forged Friends: The team appears to have softened into this. In the Horror City Arc, John doesn't even need Zatanna to get everyone else to find the stolen House of Mystery, though he does need Frankenstein to talk Swamp Thing around.
- Five-Man Band: The 2018 version of the team.
- Intimate Healing: Averted. While much has been made of tantra as sex magic, the only instance of it being used has John and Zatanna sit across from each other in bathrobes, with only their hands touching. Which is not far off from actual tantra meditation, except for how it heals injuries.
- "I Know You're in There Somewhere" Fight: Subverted. Zatanna tries this on Diana who has been brainwashed by Hecate as a distraction so Constantine can exorcise Hecate's influence from Diana's body.Zatanna: Even a cheap stage magician knows that sleight of hand isn't about what you're looking at. It's about what you missed.
- The Lost Lenore: Kathy George, whom Shade keeps trying to recreate.
- Magic Versus Science: Averted with Dr Kirk Langstrom. Despite being a man of science he accepts magic as real very quickly and is interested in studying it.
- Must Be Invited: Exaggerated. When John invites people — including Andrew Bennett from I, Vampire — into the House of Mystery, he can call them back later whether they want to or not. They usually don't.
- Nice Job Breaking It, Hero!: Enchantress's madness? Madame Xanadu's fault.
- Diana lets the Upside-Down Man into the human world so he can kill Hecate who is trying to bring about the end of the world. Unfortunately, this allows the Otherkind access into the human world and they begin killing people.
- Detective Chimp attempts to resurrect Nightmaster who perished in the events of Dark Nights: Metal. However, because Myrra operates on different set of rules for life and death for Earth, he instead raises an army of zombies that terrorizes the populace. Fortunately, he is able to undo his mistakes.
- Power Perversion Potential: The relationship between Deadman and Dove (of Hawk and Dove) was established when Deadman attempted to possess a human body in order to have physical intimacy with Dove. She was noticeably perturbed.
- Put on a Bus: Shade and Mindwarp in Peter Milligan's final issue.
- Zatanna is conspicuously not called to the team in the Horror City arc.
- Psycho for Hire: When Mindwarp is being recruited, it is established that even the other morally gray characters consider him a psychotic madman.
- Ragtag Bunch of Misfits: Emphasized and acknowledged by Xanadu. She states that all the others are dangerous to themselves and others, but are the only people around to save the world from mystic threats.
- Shoot the Dog: John sacrifices the innocent June Moone in order to stop Enchantress. Deadman calls him out on this.
- Shout-Out: Dove encounters John Constantine eating beans out of a can at her kitchen table. Much like how another bird-themed hero encounters a trenchcoated antihero.
- Star-Crossed Lovers: John fell in love with Zatanna when she was with Nick (and though they were all a happy threesome for a while, they eventually shut Nick out). Then, John's actions led to Giovanni Zatara's death, and Zatanna left John, wanting nothing more to do with him. Shortly after Zatanna finally deals with that and becomes more civil, Xanadu prophesies that John will kill Zatanna. John doesn't take it well.
- Supernatural Team: Every member of Justice League Dark is in some way supernatural, either being magic users, involved with the magical community or some other part of the DC Universe divorced from scientific explanation.
- Teeth-Clenched Teamwork: In the beginning, none of the group really likes or trusts any of the other members, except for Zatanna. Even John looked out for Zatanna.
- The Friend Nobody Likes: On Wonder Woman's team, it's Man-Bat and Detective Chimp. Detective Chimp has become a self-pitying drunk after the death of his best pal, Night Master and shows little desire to get out of his current state. Man-Bat isn't trusted as he's shown to be dangerously unstable in the past with his Mad Science and outside of beating up mook-level threats, he's largely out of his depth as someone with no magical background.
- Will They or Won't They?: John has an obsessive emotional attachment to Zatanna throughout the series, which is not returned. At all. As of Issue #30, John decides that the best thing for him to do is leave Zatanna to move on with her life.
- Working with the Ex: John and Zatanna. Belligerent Sexual Tension abounds as they didn't break up due to internal problems or (entirely) because John was an asshole, but because John's actions led to her father's death.
- You Won't Feel a Thing: Deadman uses the "This won't hurt me" variant on June Moone when entering her body.