What Do You Mean, It's Not For Little Girls?
Youtube user: Is this a children's show? If so, why is there a picture of girl mounting another girl lying on the floor?
Uploader: It's NOT a children show.So you find a new show and it has an all female cast, lots of pastel colors, and Tastes Like Diabetes levels of cuteness. And you think "this would be a perfect show for my eight-year-old sister." And then you discover that the show airs at three AM and has a fandom that's mostly 16 to 40 year-old males who consider the girls to be lesbians. After the initial shock is over you start to wonder why any man would even consider watching a show like this. Well, it's because men like cute girls. Though it's not to say that this show would be inappropriate for your little sister, it's just that it's not specifically intended for little girls to watch. In fact these kinds of shows often have a sizeable female fanbase. Of course, it must be noted that entertainment often targeted to young girls, especially in the field of music, has become increasingly sexualized. The classic examples are idol singers and girl groups such as Britney Spears, the Spice Girls, and Destinys Child. The effect has blurred the line in a way many are uncomfortable with: just take a look at any Toddlers & Tiaras type show. A subtrope of What Do You Mean, It's Not for Kids?. Not to be confused with a Subverted Kids Show, which is meant to horrify, or a show that is for little girls but also has an older male fanbase. See also Moe, Girl-Show Ghetto, Testosterone Brigade and Values Dissonance. Can be a problem if a Moral Guardian shows this to a child and it's a Yuri show. Compare with Multiple Demographic Appeal. Do note that not all of these are necessarily family unfriendly at all; all that is actually required for this trope is that it is aimed at an older audience.
— Comments on the opening to Hidamari Sketch
open/close all folders
Anime and Manga
- Lucky Star: A show with lots of pretty colors, cute songs, and a mostly female cast. Except that it's a show about a girl who plays Eroge and sees her life as if she was playing one.
- Azumanga Daioh is about the lives of a bunch of high school girls. The manga is serialized in Dengeki Daioh, a Shōnen magazine.
- K-On! is clearly for a male audience, but appears to have garnered an extensive female fanbase in its wake as well. Point in case: it's airing on the Japanese Disney Channel, but edited of course.
- Scuttlebutt has it that in France, K-On! has been promoted in young girls' publications like Winx Magazine.
- While the manga has its fair share if Les Yay / Ship Teasing, Kyoto Animation toned it down for the anime and added more character focus (Except for Ritsu), presumably in trying to expand the audience. And based on its huge success, it seems to have worked, although it's not that girls dislike yuri per se — especially not in Japan.
- Hanamaru Kindergarten - It aired at Otaku O'Clock.
- Just like K-On, Love Live! is seinen, but became popular enough with young girls that it too ended up airing on the Japanese Disney Channel.
- The Magical Girl Lyrical Nanoha franchise. Its promotional materials and manga adaptations are printed in Seinen magazines and it began its life as a Spin-Off of the Triangle Heart 3: Sweet Songs Forever H-Game. The first season even has some fanservice; the next ones less so.
- In some countries they removed the fanservice and marketed it as a shonen show.
- They still left all the cases of child abuse by the villains though.
- Even though it's a Magical Girl series it's very heavy on the sci-fi and seems more like a Gundam series. Later installments take away the Magical Girl elements making it much more obviously aimed at men.
- Similar to Nanoha, Happy Seven and Rakugo Tennyo Oyui are both Sailor Moon-style Magical Girl Warrior shows that cater to the moe aesthetic and air at Otaku O'Clock.
- Saint October, although the three Magical Girls being named Loli Black, Loli White, and Loli Red was a pretty big hint.
- Moetan is about a Magical Girl who teaches her crush English. Blatant (Older Than She Looks) Lolicon Fanservice and Panty Shots ensue.
- If you just saw the ending theme for CLANNAD then you would think that it's for very young little girls.
- Pretty Face:
- In one of his omake, Kano talks about how a little girl came up to him at Jump Festa with her mother and told him she loved Pretty Face and got his autograph.
- Koi Cupid.
- Strike Witches might seem to be for girls judging from the cast, but any of the promotional art should make it clear, from the skimpy outfits and aerial combat, that it is filled with Fanservice all the way through.
- When you first hear that Kiss Players is about Transformers powering up by getting a kiss from a human girl, you might think that the series is aimed at young girls. But then when you see the blatant, unrelenting sexual imagery, you think different.
- Inverted for Lil Pri, while it is for girls, it is also for a more open market then just young girls due to Telecom's Past Productions.
- Chi's Sweet Home is about a cute little kitty cat and it's in a... Seinen manga magazine.
- Tantei Opera Milky Holmes, while slapsticky, was aiming for the otaku audience from the start. Some of the things Twenty does are a big enough giveaway.
- Amuri in Star Ocean.
- Bamboo Blade - It's about a group of high school girls who are in their school's kendo club. And the manga is serialized in a... Seinen manga magazine.
- A Channel.
- Yuru-Yuri might be about cute middle-school girls, but it has plenty of yuri and it's clearly for a male audience.
- Sasami: Magical Girls Club is a Cute Witch anime that superficially looks a lot like Ojamajo Doremi. It aired at 1:30 am.
- A Little Snow Fairy Sugar is an extremely cutesy show about a young girl who hangs out with cute little fairies who create the weather. It aired at Otaku O'Clock and the manga adaptation was shonen. This is a very odd example, noting that the show itself is very G-rated.
- Hidamari Sketch: See the quote. It is relatively clean, but it's aired in Otaku O'Clock with a seinen demographic, with spots of Les Yay here and there.
- Although Non Non Biyori is relatively clean and can be enjoyed by little girls, this show aired at around 2:00 AM.
- Also from Studio Shaft is Puella Magi Madoka Magica. It has the same character designer from Hidamari Sketch, and the show itself starts off innocently enough; but by the end of Episode 3, it becomes a dark and deconstructive take on the genre more suited to an adult audience. The fact that Gen Urobuchi is heavily involved is also a big tipoff to anyone who knows his Signature Style.
- Either the Australians couldn't care less about this or they believe their youth can handle it, as Madoka has aired on ABC3, The ABC's children channel.
- The third movie invokes this even more; it starts out by thrusting the characters into a stereotypical Magical Girl series setting, and then cranks up the Nightmare Fuel.
- Wandering Son is a Slice of Life centered around kids aging from elementary to high school. The anime has a watercolor style as well. Despite all this it's a Seinen, and its content delves deeply into gender and growing up in a way more common in works for teens and adults. It's less graphic than a lot of the mangaka's other works though.
- Bokura no Hentai has a very cute, almost simplistic art style and the protagonists are mostly middle schoolers. Marika is very much The Cutie with an idealistic viewpoint who basically thinks she's in a 70s shojo manga... But it's a rather dark Seinen series dealing with anything from puberty to sexual abuse.
- Girl Friends focuses a lot on fashion, cosmetics, and other typically girly things, giving people the impression that it's a Shoujo manga. Even the fact that it's a Girls Love series doesn't prevent this, since Girls Love is popular amongst females too so people just assume that it's meant for a LGBT conscious young adult audience considering how realistically it handles the issues of a budding sexuality. Thus, people tend to be surprised when they discover that it ran in Comic High, a Seinen magazine.
- A common stereotype of Axis Powers Hetalia fandom is that it's seemingly made up entirely of yaoi fangirls. On the other hand, it's listed as a Seinen series and has both male and female fans.
- Subverted with the Pretty Cure Franchise. It actually IS a franchise meant for little girls... yet at the same time, official marketing papers have 16-40 year old men as a main demographic at the same time. This explains that compared to most other Magical Girl shows (And even other Magical Girl Warrior shows) why it tends to have physical punching and kicking in its fight scenes on a level that would make most Fighting Series blush with jealousy.
- Yuki Yuna is a Hero is another seinen Magical Girl Warrior series with Slice of Life elements and a cute art style. It has some fanservice that would be unusual in a series for middle school girls, but it's mostly tame. A little over halfway through the series it takes turn for the worst that gives Madoka a run for its money. The girls are less Kid Hero's and more Child Soldier's meant to be sacrifices to the World Tree in a slow, agonizing manner. One of the characters even attempts suicide on-screen.
- Gakkou Gurashi is a cute looking manga about high school girls surviving a zombie apocalypse on their own.
- Barbara Slate's Angel Love comic book series of the 1980s, having rather cute cartoonish artwork, yet dealing with serious topics such as drug abuse, abortion, critical illnesses, and incest.
Live Action TV
- There's a video of a five-year-old girl singing the "Voulez-vous coucher avec moi ce soir?" line from Labelle's "Lady Marmalade." Presumably the train of thought was "It's about dancing, right? Girls love dancing!" Too bad it's not about dancing, it's about a prostitute, and the line translates to "Do you want to sleep with me tonight?"
- The Spice Girls. It's hard to tell exactly how much of their "Girl Power" theme was serious, and how much was self-parody, but their lyrics make it clear that it was at least about sexual liberation... to the dismay of the parents of the 8 year olds who would parrot the lyrics.
- Oingo Boingo's 1981 track "Little Girls" is indeed about them... but from a certain point of view.
- TheIdolmaster. A cute game about pop stars! With catchy songs, cute dresses and tons of accessories to dress up. But the target audience is otaku, with overpriced DLC no young girl (or most adults) can afford. Worth noting though is that Bandai-Namco attempted to get girls into the series with articles about Dearly Stars in girls magazines and the addition of a boy band, but it never really caught on. Once their other idol game series actually intended for young girls, Aikatsu, became popular, they stopped trying to market iM@S to girls. Or at least LITTLE girls.
- The new spinoff game iDOLM@STER SideM is targeted at girls... Teenage girls and young women, though, not little girls. It's an Otome Game.
- Harvest Moon was aimed at a gender-neutral audience originally but you wouldn't know it by its mainly female fandom. The first few games had male-only protagonists but eventually they added females, either in a Game-Favored Gender manner or in their own Distaff Counterparts. Modern games always have an option to chose your gender. Recent incarnations of the game have began to look a lot more Bishoujo than before.
- You'd be surprised at how many clueless parents get Neptunia games for their young daughters. You'd think the Cleavage Windows front and center and the T (M in the case of mk2) rating would be enough... Though it's much more understandable with re;birth 1 and Producting Perfection, which feature modest costumes and very bright colors on the box.
- What makes Producing Perfection all the more troubling is that alphabetically it is placed right next to the still T-rated (3+ in Europe) but more family friendly Hatsune Miku Project Diva games in store displays. Considering Hatsune Miku has a lot of young fans , all it takes is a confused parent who has a child that's into Vocaloid and difficulty remembering long game names seeing two vita games with an anime Pop Idol on it, pick the wrong one and give their ten year old girl a game that gives you points for upskirt shots, has risque dialog that pushes the envelope, and even has scenes of nudity. Not to mention a lot of parents dismiss T ratings in rhythm games due to "family" games like Rock Band having the same rating.
- Arcana Heart features an all-female cast, and some of the cover and promo art◊ would not be out of place for a cheerleading sim. It's a Fighting Game franchise that rivals Guilty Gear and BlazBlue in complexity and SNK in difficulty.
- The Powerpuff Girls was not originally intended for little girls. Craig McCracken created it as a parody of the Magical Girl genre, as he was getting sick of Sailor Moon playing on Cartoon Network's Toonami block every day. As a Take That, he set the girls' ages very low, had them do very inelegant things, and made the villains cheesier than Kraft Macaroni and Cheese Dinners. The intended audience for it was the same as Dexter's Laboratory — animation fans in their teens, 20s, and 30s — but it had to be child-appropriate (This was in the days before [adult swim]). A show like this naturally attracted little girls anyway. One can only imagine how things would have turned out if McCracken was more annoyed by Dragon Ball Z playing on Cartoon Network every day.
- McCracken's college assignment that spawned the series, Whoopass Stew (the title alone should make it clear which demographic he wasn't shooting for), went as follows. Girls beat the crap out of the Gangreen Gang. Amoeba Boys rob a bank. Girls try to stop them but get stuck in their bodies. Girls prevail by flying to the sun, which kills the Amoeba Boys in seconds.
- Making Fiends is actually a relatively dark cartoon about attempting murder with demons, and the colors are anything but bright, pastel or pink. But the two main characters are young girls. The original web animation was for a neutral demographic, but the daughter of a Nickelodeon producer loved it, and so Nick made a deal with Amy Winfrey to turn it into a cartoon. If you look at any of the message boards for Making Fiends, you'll see that male fans are extremely rare, though the show has gotten positive reviews from many male critics.
- Considering Nickelodeon only aired six episodes of the show back in 2008, it could just be that people in general, male and female, haven't had a chance to see it.
- My Little Pony: Friendship Is Magic is similar, but it's more of a Periphery Demographic situation.
What Do You Mean, It Wasn't Made on Drugs? What Do You Mean, It's Not an Index? All Animation Is Disney
What Do You Mean, It's Not for Kids? Unexpected Reactions to This Index What Do You Mean, It's Not Political?