Troperville
Editing Help
Tools
Toys
|
Evil sows the seeds of its own destruction. At least that's what every Aesop and fortune cookie says, anyway. There seems to be some truth to it, though, at least in fiction, because regardless of Genre Savvy, villains tend to inherently draw the kind of heroic attention to themselves that leads to their demise, or at least the demise of their plans. Basically, they're saddled with carrying their own version of the Idiot Ball: the Villain Ball.
Maybe their attempt at averting attention has the opposite effect, or they insist on taking a friend of the heroes hostage in exchange for the MacGuffin and busting the deal, and make it personal for the hero, or maybe they just can't help threatening the innocent puppy to show that they really are the Villains, no really!
Inevitably, it's their own inherent Fatal Flaws that lead to their downfall, possibly even an apropos Karmic Death or Cool And Unusual Punishment.
Villains who are likely to carry the Villain Ball:
Related Plots:
Can lead to:
See also Contractual Genre Blindness, often a choice when Evil Is Stylish. For villains who pass the Villain Ball, see Dangerously Genre Savvy. For those who pick it up and run with it, see Stupid Evil. Contrast Flaw Exploitation.
Also see and contrast The Law Of Bruce.
open/close all folders
Examples
Anime and Manga
- Yu-Gi-Oh: Giving Yugi's Duel Monsters track record, just shooting him sure would be an easier way of killing him than challenging him to a duel every time! They would also accomplish any other goals like destroying/ taking over the world much faster if they didn't let it all rest on a one-on-one duel with him, a tradition Saiou finally breaks in GX.
- The series do what they can in terms of justifying it; most of the MacGuffin collections can only change hands in a duel and so forth. Then there was that time one of the "Player Killers" in the Duelist Kingdom arc decided to protest his defeat by Yugi... using a pair of flamethrowers. It didn't work. Yami's Mind Crush on the other hand worked just fine.
- Indeed. Duel Monsters has deep and complex links with Ancient Egyptian (and older) magic, and many of the items being fought over are magical. It's not that surprising that exchange of said objects is covered by binding magical contracts. It's likely that Millenium Objects will simply refuse to work for anyone who attempts to use them without having won them fairly.
- This is how Saiou breaks the tradition. He pretends to be playing along with this, and then while the hero is bound in the fight, he sets off his plan. Because all he needs to do is press a button, he can do it during the match. Judai/Jaden and his duel spirits can't leave the match.
- Yu Gi Oh The Abridged Series has a field day with this issue.
- In One Piece, the World Government has pretty much been the poster organization for the Moral Event Horizon. That said, they usually have some kind of interest in preserving a tenuous peace and covering up their own horrible actions. Then it turns out that they hunted down and killed every child, born and unborn, that could have been conceived during a certain timeframe and location - all just to eliminate any descendant of the infamous Pirate King. Later, they finally find the Pirate King's own son and decide to publicly execute him, knowing full well that this will ignite a war with the strongest and most dangerous pirates in the world. This situation has the government acting like irredeemable, self-destructive bastards entirely on the assumption that being a world-class criminal is genetic.
Films
- The sheriff in First Blood could have avoided a lot of death and bloodshed had he simply let the wandering Vietnam veteran get something to eat, but instead chose to throw his weight around and treat the guy like a criminal. Not a smart thing to do to John Rambo...
- Willy Bank and Terry Benedict in Ocean's Thirteen. The former's outright betrayal of Reuben leading to Ocean and co. seeking justice is the impetus for the plot; knowing full well their reputation as capable of beating the odds. The latter in his insistence to betray them and get several diamonds.
- It does not always happen to the Big Bad: In the James Bond film Thunderball (1965), Count Lippe alias "sub-operator G", was handed the ball and attacked an unsuspecting off-duty Bond, tipping him off about what was happening in the fitness center. As a result, he was properly dealt with by his boss.
- The novel version, at least, has Count Lippe trying to kill Bond because he (mistakenly) believed that Bond had penetrated his cover and was there to take him out. However, like the movie version, he fails and is "properly dealt with" for his failure. Ironically, Bond never figures out that Lippe was working for SPECTRE at all, although Felix Leiter eventually puts the pieces together.
- The only reason Han Solo could shoot first in Star Wars was because Greedo was an idiot who couldn't tell when someone was very obviously reaching for his gun.
- In Demolition Man, Jean Cocteau cannot be killed by revived murderer Simon Phoenix: he took the precaution of inserting a mental block to that effect. He did not plan on Phoenix ordering one of of his revived goons to shoot him, though.
- In a similar vein, the Corrupt Corporate Executive BigBad of RoboCop didn't take into account the fact that while the titular cyborg was unable to act against an OCP employee, he might get fired on the spot for holding his boss hostage.
- The plot of each of the Transporter films basically doesn't kick-off until someone higher in the criminal food-chain than the Protagonist grabs the Villain Ball and doesn't let go until they've done something horribly cliche'd.
Literature
- The leader of the Psychlos from the Battlefield Earth novel and film does a lot of things that make the viewer/reader shout, "What an idiot!" In an especially stupid move, the leader teaches the hero, Jonny "Goodboy" Tyler, everything about Psychlos in a matter of seconds, in an attempt to get him to assist their enslavement of Earth. Naturally, it comes back to bite him in the ass at the end in a big way.
- Villain Ball moments have consistently been the cause of Lord Voldemort's defeats. Nearly every significant failure he experiences (up to and including his Karmic Death) result from some detail or circumstance he completely failed to consider at the time. This frequently resulted from a combination of Voldemort's arrogance and the fact that Evil Cannot Comprehend Good.
- There's also the fact that he's totally nuts, as a side-effect of making so many Horcruxes. Taking for example his scheme in Goblet of Fire - it's the sort of thing that's too complex for a stupid person to have come up with, but too convoluted and just plain bizarre to have been the product of a stable mind.
- Lestat passes off the Villain Ball between books in The Vampire Chronicles; he retcons into Yet Another Good Vampire when he takes on the mantle of narrator.
- In Jonathan Strange And Mr Norrell Jonathan's father Lawrence strange was a sure-handed holder. The narration mentions that he let petty maliciousness overcome his long term benefit, and suffered a Karmic Death when he opened a window on a cold night to further torment a fevered servant who had annoyed him - forgetting that he was much less healthy than the other man. He was found to have frozen to death during the night.
Live Action TV
- Baal, from Stargate SG-1 should get a mention here. He can't seem to make up his mind if he wants to have the Villain Ball or not. Half the time he's charging around like an idiot coming up with ridiculously complex and stupid plans to DESTROY THE UNIVERSE or somesuch nonsense, and then the other half of the time he's acting as the CEO for a major company and fully intends to just live on earth peacefully. It then gets even more ridiculous when SG-1 force him to take action and the entire thing dissolves into a massive i-don't-know-what-the-fuck-is-happening with the end result revealing Baal actually really likes the Tau'ri and would probably quite happily be a fairly good ally, if we'd just stop shooting him. Then when the SGC realises this and attempts to join forces with Baal, he backstabs them. I've never seen a villain juggle the Villain Ball quite so obsessively as Baal does. Half the time I was thinking he was one of the best genre savvy villains I've ever seen, the other half of the time I was wondering who'd been hitting him with the idiot stick lately.
Musicals
- The Wicked Witch of the West passes off the Villain Ball in Wicked to The Wizard. Of course he's always been a Nazi! And Dorothy was his unwitting dupe! At least until HE gets to narrate and pass the Ball...
Print Media
Sports
Video Games
- In Eternal Sonata, your party is forced by Count Waltz to surrender a party member named Polka. Despite having what he needs to conquer the world, instead of leaving, Waltz attempts to kill you, without his army (the reason you surrendered in the first place), and gets killed himself.
- Arthas in Wrath of the Lich King. So hard. Any dumb thing that the evil guy can do just to prove his credentials, he does. Like telling the most important part of his army (who, by a strange coincidence, are one of about three parts of his army who have free will) that they were BAIT for a guy who was supposed to mow them down in seconds, but didn't even show up for said fight until they already lost. Did we mention he laughed at them, too? Oh, and he delivered the weapon that can beat him to said guy in this ploy. OH, and it turns out that after betraying and alienating his officer core, he's having a tough time finding commanders. Whoops! And that's just one example.
- There's also his tendency of finding his few surviving commanders in mortal danger and deciding that if they can't survive the battle then too bad. You'd think after losing every single known lieutenant he has he'd stop throwing their lives away.
- Well, he is the Lich King. It's not like when they die he can't just bring them back anyway. But really, why waste the time? Kill the snots that are screwing with you and just be done with it already.
- Face it, with the kind of power Arthas can throw around, if he hadn't swallowed the Villain Ball there's no way in hell anyone would ever be able to even slow him down.
- Blizzard even all but admitted this when his resources and capabilities simply didn't match up at all from what we last knew and threw in justification for the idleness and poor judgment in the form of essentially being catatonic for several of the last couple years while the two ids making up the Lich King proper fought for control. Which contradicts entirely what they said before in that there were no separate personalities to him anymore and there was only the Lich King, no Nerzhul or Arthas.
- I'm sorry, but nearly EVERY end raid boss that was based in some sort of lore apparently selected the ball crafting profession and specced "villain ball". Only a few bosses don't seem that out of place.
- The artifact Illidan stole in Frozen Throne although named "The Eye of Sargares" was in fact a Villain Ball of titanic proportions. See for yourself: he wants to use the said ball to destroy the Frozen Throne - the seat of the Lich King and thus eliminate the Undead army that threatens the world. Unfortunately, the side effects of the ball's operation include severe earth tremors hence Illidan's brother Malfurion jumps to conclusion that Illidan is up to destroying the world and sets forth to stop him. Does Illidan bother to clarify the situation and explain his plan which would without doubt be backed by Malfurion? He does, but only AFTER Malfurion destroyes the Eye. That is a prime example of what happens when a Villain Ball collides with a Hero Ball.
Web Comics
- In Sluggy Freelance, Hereti Corp should have realized that, when they turned Aylee into a man-eating monster bent on world domination, it was probably a bad idea to leave Riff, one of her friends with a penchant for Saving The World, not only alive, but on their payroll. That's got conflict of interests written all over it.
- Hereti Corps carries the Villain Ball less idiotically now that Dr. Schlock has taken over. But in that instance at least, Riff was 'one of her friends' who wanted kill her, so if anything, they should've been alert to the possibility of attacks from him.
- In Bob And George, Bob seemed like your perfectly reasonable villain, driven to extremes by the world he was forced into. Then he decided to go kidnap the world's creator... who let himself be captured for the sake of a minor bet with the REAL Big Bad. Bob never did get beat down, though... or so it seems.
- Order of the Dragon first appear as a group of near omnipotent individuals with supernatural powers and represent the greatest threat AEGIS has encountered so far. Members include Robert, a cunning illusionist and conman, or Keith, Rikk's former nemesis. Then there's this guy.
 And you can rest assured that the others are no better. The fact that their plan involved literally KILLING the aphabet and eliminating all written forms of comunication doesn't help.
Western Animation
- The Evil Chancellor Long Feng in Avatar The Last Airbender. Had he simply directed them to the nearest general outside the city after explaining the whole "No talking about the war here" thing and sent them on their way, they would have been out of his hair right there and he'd still be The Man Behind The Man. But instead, he tried to play Big Brother and threaten them about Appa, and thus made an enemy out of Aang, eventually leading to his arrest, then losing even the Dai Li to Azula in an attempt to break out and take over.
- Fire Lord Sozin, while an Omnicidal Maniac, was depicted as being coldbloodedly rational in how he went about it. Except he also began the tradition of hunting dragons, up til then the Fire Nation's animal totem, which led to their near-extinction. It's hard to see why, since dragons were incredibly useful flying transportation for the Fire Nation, and their extinction led to the loss of any air capability for the better part of a century. The equivalent would be Genghis Khan ordering the Mongols to stop taming and raising horses and start killing them instead.
- Why would the Dragons help versus the other nations, against the Avatar?
- In the Grand Finale of Transformers: Beast Wars, Megatron decides to use the Fusion Cannon on the entirely helpless proto-humans when he should have attacked the Maximals first, who could actually do something to stop him.. To make it even worse all of the proto-humans survived somehow and he only succeeded in killing Quickstrike and Inferno.
- Who, if you're not familiar with the series, are his own minions.
- iirc, he even lampshades this as he's doing it...
- By being the Genre Blind Harmless Villain he is, Dr. Drakken from Kim Possible is by no means immune to this trope. In one episode he created the awesome plan of disrupting the Kimmunicator so that he could pretend to be the Techno Wizard Wade in order for Kim to steal the Phlebotinum from Professor Dementor. Twice. Which got Kim's suspicions up and let to his defeat. When he has Shego, who is more than capable of stealing the Phlebotinum by herself....
- Then there is Senor Senior Senior, who literally read the book on how to carry the Villain Ball...
- In Venture Brothers the supervillains, (or "antagonists" as they prefer,) that work for the Guild of Calamitous Intent carry the ball as part of the Guild's strict regulations for "Controlled Costumed Aggression". Low level troublemakers use tranq guns, whereas hand guns and the like are reserved for more threatening opponents. Likewise, "protagonists" need to carry the Idiot Ball because, to borrow a quote:
Brock Samson: Hey, no disrespect Jonas, but it isn't so easy. These guys like their system; it's what they do. You take that away, and you are dealing with a bunch of pissed off nutbags with rayguns and giant, I don't know, a giant octopus/tank with laser eyes.
- Slade in Teen Titans would be a full-time Magnificent Bastard if he'd just learn not to give in to his sadistic impulses unnecessarily. As it is, this has gotten in the way of his plans by providing an out for one minion and turning another against him (which got him lava fried). Of course, this does mean that for a Smug Snake, he's still very effective and creepy, but he could be so much more...
- The Archmage of Gargoyles grasps the Villain Ball hard due to his hatred of Goliath. He makes two big mistakes: he doesn't wait until sunrise when the gargoyles are all helpless before starting the attack, and he opts to torture Goliath for amusement rather than simply killing him instantly with his incredible power. This leads directly to his defeat and rather nasty death.
- In fact, Word Of God explicitly notes this as his undoing- for all his power, at heart he's a walking (though effective) cliche and cannot escape genre conventions.
- Winx Club: The 4K dub provides an example of a Dub-Induced Villain Ball in the S1 finale, which has Icy telling the other Trix, "Give me your share of the Dragonfire, I need it to take care of this uppity pixie (Bloom). Don't worry, you won't need more than your regular powers to take on those four poseurs (the other Winx)." She doesn't tell them this in the original, but the result is the same anyway. Video.
- The Trix's other two seasons each have a major non-Dub-Induced Villain Ball: S2 sees them burying the Winx and the Specialists' plane under snow and an icy deathtrap... and then simply leaving, so they're not there to shoot them down again when they escape. S3 has Icy de-powering Bloom in a one-on-one (the other fairies are away in a crystal labyrinth, while the other Trix are taking on the Specialists) and not making her history immediately, allowing the other Winx to return in time to take the Trix out.
Real Life
- Adolf Hitler. Starting a war with the USSR while still engaged with the British Commonwealth and her allies? Dumb. Thinking that said war with the largest country on the Earth would be all over quickly — and not equipping his troops with winter clothing? Quite Stupid. Casually declaring war on the US after the Japanese attacked Pearl Harbor, providing justification for the largest economy on the entire planet to go full-bore against him? So unbelievably idiotic, it's off the chart.
- Oh, it's even better than that. He didn't bother to tell his Japanese allies that he was planning to invade the Soviet Union, so they signed a five year non-aggression treaty with the Soviets a few months before Hitler attacked, thus making them entirely useless as allies in the one theater of war where they might actually have done him some good. The human race is extremely lucky that Hitler was Too Dumb To Live. (Then again, the Japanese weren't all that smarter: one of the best jokes in The Onion's Our Dumb Century is the one about "Japan Allies With White Supremacists In Well-Thought-Out Scheme.")
- Not to mention Hitler's tendency to favor the development of huge, useless moving (well, sort of) fortresses and ridiculous crazy plane designs over the construction of more plausible military vehicles, like the Panzer III (which was arguably the best tank design of the time — as opposed to the lumbering "Maus" or "Ratte" designs Hitler was in love with).
- I believe you might be thinking of the Pz IV. The III couldn't mount a gun large enough to effectively threaten a T-34 and was discontinued.
- He also pissed away whatever public sympathy he still retained in those countries he wasn't invading — and parts of some of those he was — by murdering POWs (to say nothing of his own war wounded) en masse instead of treating them humanely, and not only those he deemed racially inferior (not that it would have been any better if it were). This was arguably even more true of the Japanese in Southeast Asia.
- Hitler managed to get the populace of the Soviet Union (including the Ukraine, where famine was used as a weapon against class enemies not long before) and Eastern Europe to consider Stalin the lesser of two evils if not an outright liberator.
- Well, Hitler was a great political figure that knew how to pull the right strings on the population, and considering what he was aiming for, the concentration camps were more of a pragmatic solution than outright evilness. Not that it excuses him for not leaving the military thinking to his generals or not having a little patience with his expansion plans... Not that the US was much better on the matter, in any given conflict.
- This troper is deeply suspicious of the notion that the sort of pragmatism that involves death camps isn't necessarily the sort that is "outright evil".
- Nothing is pragmatic if the end goal is utterly insane, evil, inefficient, and useless (from a military and propaganda perspective): you're wasting perfectly good soldiers and perfectly good slave labor, and making your side come across as monstrous.
- Don't argue with it, you might offend the people who are trying to uphold the Rule Of Cautious Editing Judgement. Especially someone equating the United States military with Nazi Germany, that's really classy and obviously not someone trying to push an agenda.
- Also also, near the end of the war, Hitler tried to hurry the death camps to get as many undesirables murdered as possible before the Allies came and liberated them. He was so anxious to do this that concentration camp trains tended to get higher priority on the rail lines than troop trains did.
- By that point, he at least had some justification... er... well, a good reason... an excuse for bad thinking! It has been proposed based on his actions later in the war, how little video is available of that time, what that video shows (muscular twitches, awkward movement) and some of the doctors he had that he was suffering from Parkinson's disease and the Nazi higher ups hid the knowledge from the public. It's suspected that this drastically affected his judgment.
- Alternate hypotheses include insanity induced by syphilis.
- And doing too much speed.
|
|
