...because you just might get it.
A character makes a wish and actually gets what they wished for, only to find that the reality does not live up to their fantasy.
This trope is all about how a character who makes a wish comes to regret it; the actual circumstances vary. The wisher may or may not have known that his/her wish was actually going to be heard. The one which grants it may be anything from a wish-granting Genie who wants to show the character the error of their ways to a Jackass Genie who just wants them to suffer. A sudden appearance by Louis Cypher, ready to offer a Deal with the Devil, is not out of the question either. Sometimes the character gets a tour through an Alternate Timeline. Other times the mechanism of the granted wish is not even explained — the wisher gets what s/he wants through nothing more than an ironic and coincidental twist of circumstances.
The "deal breaker" that makes the wish not worth it also comes in a lot of possible flavors. Perhaps the character finds out that what they wanted comes at the cost of something they wanted even more. Maybe the element of their life they wanted gone is really essential to who they are; maybe their wish isn't all they thought it was cracked up to be; or maybe it just comes true in an unanticipated manner.
In many cases the character repents of his/her ill-considered wish and things revert to normal — though in some stories the character is stuck in the new situation and forced to deal with the consequences of his/her thoughtless wish.
This is an elementary form of deconstruction - The character wants X, and then they find out that X has unforeseen consequences or is less satisfying than expected. Nine times of ten this is an outright Aesop, though strictly speaking it doesn't have to be. A crucial element of playing that angle well is making the "deal breaker" a meaningful, inherent flaw to the original wish rather than something tacked on or that could have easily turned out differently if the character had more common sense. Otherwise, a Broken Aesop is almost guaranteed.
Often a cause of Blessed with Suck, though not the only one; wont to count as an Opinion Changing Dream; Contains the same type of irony as Ironic Hell. In some cases the experience may lead the wisher to discover an Awful Truth.
Sub-Trope of Be Careful What You Say. Super Trope of It's a Wonderful Plot, I Wish It Were Real, I Wished You Were Dead, Please Dump Me, and Rhetorical Request Blunder.
Compare Gone Horribly Right, when science or logic is involved rather than wishes, and Wanting Is Better Than Having, when getting your wish ends with more disappointment than satisfaction.
Contrast the Literal Genie, which ignores the intent of the wish in favor of the exact words; this trope is about the complications that arise when you get exactly what you wanted, rather than exactly what you said. A Jackass Genie is likely to cause this to happen, if he doesn't just twist your words entirely.
open/close all folders
A variation on this is the theme of one commercial for Wilkins Coffee:
Wilkins the frog: Boy, I'd give a million bucks for a cup of Wilkins coffee. (a cup of coffee appears in his lap) Wontkins the blob:(appearing beside him) Okay, buster, pay up!
Anime and Manga
Inverted in Attack on Titan, Eren's titan form seems to respond to what he wants when he transforms. However, he gets the best results when he isn't careful. for example, when he wished for the power to kill a lot of titans and save his squadmates he gets it. When he wants specifically the strength to lift a boulder, he loses control.
Arisa takes this trope and tweaks it. Rather than the wishes themselves that are messed up, it's the desire to have one's wishes granted. Most of the people are overlooking the obvious with rationalizations of "it could never happen to me" until it actually does, making selfish and arbitrary wishes without considering the side-effects. That is, rather than being about wish corruption, it's about the corruption by wishes (having your desires constantly fulfilled). Understandably, the entire class as a result is just a few shades short of psychopathy.
Van Hohenheim of Fullmetal Alchemist spends his entire long life (over 400 years) wishing his life would end. When the end finally comes, however, he wishes he would not die yet.
Father heartily lauds how Truth gives humans despair when they get conceited, to keep them in line. Then, following a long, action-packed sequence of events, he winds up in front of Truth himself, who reminds Father of his exact words, and points out how conceited Father was to think he could absorb a god. He gets plenty of despair.
Human transmutation is wrought with this. By the laws of alchemy, it is forbidden, since the value of human life is immeasurable, so attempting it will cause those involved to lose that which was most precious to them. When Izumi attempted it to revive her stillborn child, she lost her reproductive organs. When Ed and Al tried it to revive their mother, Ed lost An Arm and a Leg, and Al was lucky for Ed's quick thinking that he only lost his entire body.
In Bleach, Aizen tries to help Ichigo get stronger because he wants a Worthy Opponent. Well, he got what he asked for... right through his stupid face.
Ichigo tells Keigo after he loses his powers that he always wanted a normal life...then sees the folly of that when Ginjo and Xcution start messing up his life.
The series Asatte no Houkou begins with a single (well, double) instance of this, with a dash of Swapped Roles. The rest of the series consists of the characters dealing with the results.
Making wishes under the old sakura tree in Da Capo can have major consequences. For some it's even worse though when those wishes get reverted.
The 'Suruga Monkey' arc of Bakemonogatari initially appears to be a minor twist on the traditional story of the Monkey's Paw (the twist being that the paw has grafted itself to its owner's arm) but turns out to be rather more of a twist than usual. The owner's first wish was to run faster than her classmates to stop them from laughing at her; everyone in the class faster than her was mysteriously beaten up the day before the athletics carnival. The real twist is that the paw isn't a Monkey's Paw, it belongs to a malevolent spirit called a Rainy Devil that grants your true subconscious wish- even though Kanbaru wished to run faster than her classmates she really wanted revenge on them, so the Rainy Devil possessed her and beat them up. Things get worse when the sempai she had a long-term crush on gets a boyfriend. The final twist is that after granting her third wish, the Rainy Devil will take her soul.
The Rayearth OVA starts this way - the heroines fear their graduation, as they will be separated. So they wish something prevents this... then all the mayhem starts.
In D.Gray-Man, the unlucky Miranda Lotto loses her one hundredth job. She says: "Day after day, things always go wrong for me. I wish tomorrow would never come." What's the problem? Her Innocence-superpowered clock hears it, and it grants her wish. The whole town where she lives gets stuck in October 9th for more than a month.
Quite a few Franken Fran stories end this way. One, for example, has a modern Elizabeth Bathory asking for eternal youth and eternal life. Fran gave her what she wants by turning all of her cells into the one type of cell that isn't programmed to die: Cancer Cells.
Actually Fran just gave her what she wanted. The woman went way overboard with the treatment and Fran was trying to warn her when it was too late. Still an example but not Fran's fault.
×××HOLiC features a chapter and episode involving a monkey's paw, which, as in the original W. W. Jacobs short story, grants wishes for its holder - five wishes in this case, one for each finger of the mummified paw, which break one at a time as wishes are granted. Also as in the original story, the young woman who gets hold of the paw finds her wishes backfiring on her, particularly when she thoughtlessly wishes that there would be a railway accident so that her lateness would be excused, causing a bystander to be suddenly pushed in front of the train. The paw and her own careless wishes end up killing her.
Definitely the instance that most people think of in Dragon Ball Z is when Perfect Cell, wanting to get a good fight before he destroys the Earth, hears from Gohan who, not wanting to fight, will let loose and kill him if Cell pushes him too hard. Cell, being Cell, goes ahead with that anyways, pulling some heavy Kick the Dog moments by nearly killing the rest of the cast and killing Android 16, and which pushes Gohan to go Super Saiyan 2 and beat Cell half to death and drive him to Villainous Breakdown. Gohan even invokes the whole trope by pointing to Cell that him letting loose is what Cell wanted in the first place.
Gohan: I warned you! I warned you what would happen if you made me unleash my power! But you had to see it! And now that you have seen it, you're afraid!
Garlic Jr. is the perfect example of this trope. Enjoy being trapped in a void forever unable to die.
Another key example is in Dragon Ball GT, when Pilaf, having summoned the Black Star Dragon, gets distracted by Goku. Pilaf, frustrated at Goku's supposed thwarting of his plan, absentmindedly wishes that Goku was a child again. The Dragon grants his wish.
In general though, the Dragon Ball series is actually a massive subversion. Since fairly specific wishes are made and the dragons aren't assholes, every wish they make ends up doing exactly what they want. Example: King Piccolo wishes for youth. He doesn't turn into a fetus or baby, but instead turns to his prime. And to take it even farther, the dragons will even double check with you. When they try to wish Goku back to life, the dragon mentions that he'd be brought back at the same location he died at and since the planet he was on exploded, he'd be revived in space and then die again, giving them a chance to wish for something else instead.
General Wolf of Monster comes to regret asking Johan how he's feeling. Johan can't put it into words, so he demonstrates it by killing everyone close to the general. This lets the General feel Johan's own isolation.
This trope happens to be the one that catalyzes the real story for Tenma, and thus the entire series. Tenma, after being demoted by the corrupt hospital director for saving a patient and dumped by the director's daughter, states that his superiors "would be better off dead" to that same supposedly comatose patient. Should've thought that one out better; turns out his patient, Johan, is a sociopathic mass murderer who would gladly oblige such a request.
Mostly subverted in Ah! My Goddess. Goddesses grant wishes to humans, and they don't try and cheat them out of anything. It does, however, apply when a demon is granting a wish, since A; they might cheat you on it, and B; they will ask for something in return proportionate to the wish, though according to Hild at least, that means a demon won't ever grant a wish to destroy the world, since no mortal could possibly have anything to offer of equal value to that wish.
Gets played straight with revelations in the manga Chapter 285. While a lighter example in things, it begins to explain some things.
One other danger in wishes with demons is that even if they don't cheat you on the wish, you still can't back out of it if it being granted is something they want.
The entire story of the manga is this: Keiichi thought Belldandy was a prank pulled by his flatmates and jokingly wished that she would stay by his side. To Belldandy's utter shock, it went through.
Zelgadis of Slayers wishes to be strong and he gets his wish when he turns into a golem/mazoku chimera . It's a funny case because he mentions that he could've lived with the effects if he wasn't being used as a guinea pig by his grandfather Rezo.
In Nightmare Inspector, Hiruko often lets the dreamer's wishes be fulfilled. Whether they were actually beneficial to the dreamer is a different question ...
Yu-Gi-Oh! GX: Professor Cobra wanted to be reunited with his dead son. Yubel promised to do so. He thought that meant she would bring him back to life. She/He had other ideas, consisting of erasing the memory that his son died in the first place and dropping Cobra to his death. But, hey, if you believe in the afterlife... Yubel was like that about a lot of things.
This is a very important theme in Tenshi Ni Narumon where the strength of one of the main characters' wish almost erases him and two other individuals from existence.
Kyubey grants wishes in exchange for the wisher becoming a Magical Girl and fighting monsters for him. The problems that arise from the granting of the wish aren't exactly because of the wish itself, or from Kyubey - while he's not exactly trustworthy, he has no incentive to screw with peoples' wishes: when he says he can grant any wish, he means it, and he has no reason to influence what a Magical Girl wishes for, or to decide for her what she thinks fighting Witches for the rest of her life is worth. The problem is the person making the wish is almost never honest about what they really wanted. Those whose wishes are fully selfish end up regretting foregoing an unique opportunity to help others, while those who chose to help others forget that every selfless wish has a selfish motive behind it, which is by no means guaranteed to be fulfilled. In either case, the resultant regret sends a Magical Girl deeper into despair... which is what Kyubey wants. The fact that the Incubators only contract with willing girls and offer no-strings-attached wishes is their idea of equal payment for what the Magical Girls inevitably have to suffer in the end. If there is an aesop in all of this, it is perhaps simply being honest with your desires and aware of sacrifices you're willing to make to see them fulfilled.
The ending turns the situation on its head. Madoka makes a wish that balances both selfishness and selflessness and thus manages to lessen the tragedies of everyone else's wishes but avoids the despair that would have resulted if her wish did not specify a clause for herself that would guarantee her survival and happiness. It still manages to backfire a fair bit as while she becomes a godlike figure spread across time and space, everyone save for one person forgets that she ever existed, but it certainly beats the alternatives.
A straight version of the trope applies for Kyubey, who tried to prod Madoka towards making a contract by telling her she has the power to become a god who could save magical girls from their tragic fates. By stating a wish that could save everyone and herself, this is precisely what she does. Thus Kyubey's race gets the short end of the Miracle Contract stick for a change.
Puella Magi Madoka Magica The Movie: Rebellion is less explicit about it, but the story is still based around this trope. Because of one character's desire for everyone to be together, they all get trapped in her giant witch labyrinth. The other characters inadvertently imply that they wanted this, too, so she decides to give them what they want... by becoming a demon and brainwashing everyone, especially Madoka. The instigator herself isn't happy with this, because she can't even be Madoka's friend anymore; but she feels it's necessary for everyone else to be happy, even though they probably wouldn't be if they remembered everything.
In Himitsu no Akko-chan, (the original version from 1969), the titular heroine, Akko-chan, upon meeting a deaf-mute kid, asks her magic mirror to turn her into a deaf-mute version of herself, reasoning that, after her brush with disability, she'll be able to restore herself with a second wish. However, since the mirror works only by clearly enunciated utterances, and since it was literal enough to strip Akko-chan of the ability to speak at all, the unfortunate wishee finds herself deaf, voiceless and cut off of her power source. She gets better later, though, as the Reset Button simply presses itself after imparting a much needed Aesop.
Tokyo Magnitude 8 begins with the narrator saying she hates Tokyo and wishes it would just break, the whole city. Cue the titular earthquake.
Goku from Saiyuki thinks it would be okay if he died. WAIT HE DIDN'T MEAN THIS SECOND!
Up against Olegmon, one of the Death Generals in Digimon Xros Wars, when Sutyr, one of his shoulder devils, taunts the team by suggesting he'll grant a wish, Kiriha defiantly shouts that the only wish he has is to defeat Olegmon, who interprets that as a world without Olegmon. Sutyr grants this wish by ejecting Kiriha and his Digimon clear across the world.
In Arata Kangatari, Arata wishes that he would go to a faraway world in the manga's opening chapter. Likewise, Hinohara wishes that he would disappear in his introductory chapter. The moment that latter makes his wish, both of them are fulfilled by their switch.
In Fate/Zero Kiritsugu wants the Holy Grail to grant world peace, but when he finally has the chance to make his wish the corrupted Grail explains how it intends to grant it: by killing off all of mankind but Kiritsugu and his daughter, because Humans would always fight. Then it's subverted when Kiritsugu destroys the Grail.
In Kami-sama no Inai Nichiyoubi, when God left the world, He granted people the ability to make wishes come true, but said wishes often backfire. Hampnie wished for Resurrective Immortality, which he later realized meant he could be left as the last living human in the world. Alice wished for Improbable Aiming Skillsso he could be better at basketball, but then he realized such an ability would be cheating and thus quit his favorite sport. All of Class 3-4 wished to reset time to prevent Alice's death, trapping themselves in a "Groundhog Day" Loop. Other characters raise the possibility that the reason death doesn't exist anymore is because people wished for immortality, and that gravekeepers came into being for the few that did still wish for death.
Haiyore! Nyarko-san has Mahiro saying he just wants a quiet normal life in the first season finale. What he gets is that everyone around him disappeared and he was left alone just like he wanted. He then realises just how important his alien friends are to him, despite their quirks and how much they annoy him.
A funny example in Maji De Watashi Ni Koi Shinasai when Kokoro tries seducing Yamato by wearing skimpy bikini to turn him on. At first Yamato brushes off her charm and so she demands that he "show her that he's a man" for not being enticed by her seduction. How does Yamato respond? By unzipping his fly and showing Kokoro what TRULY makes him a man.
In the "Id" story line of JLA, a group of 6th-dimensional beings release an entity capable of granting wishes... unfortunately, it's a Literal Genie. It affects the league, splitting them into their superheroic and secret identities, and wreaks havoc (most hilariously when some guy wishes his boss would go to hell). In the end, Plastic Man's alter-ego pulls the league back together, comes up with a plan to defeat Id, and saves Earth.
In Avril Lavigne's Make 5 Wishes since there is no Reset Button at the end. Protagonist Hana, having used up all five wishes and finding herself no better off, maybe even worse, than at the beginning of the story, decides to jump off a bridge so as to get rid of the demon Romeo and prevent his magic from harming anyone ever again. Romeo somehow escapes from the box before they reach the riverbed, claiming that he "can't die." The last page shows a news report saying that Hana's body has still not been found.
"Wish You Were Here", a 1953 story from the EC Comics horror title The Haunt of Fear, uses a variation of "The Monkeys Paw" story: A businessman's wife discovers an enchanted Chinese figurine and wishes for a fortune. Learning that her husband was killed while driving to his lawyer's office (after naming her the beneficiary of a generous life insurance policy) and remembering what happened in "The Monkey's Paw", she wishes for him to be brought back to the way he was "just before the accident"; unfortunately, he's still a corpse since his actual death was due to a heart attack. She uses the third and final wish to make him "alive now, alive forever!"...which condemns him to eternal pain and agony, since his dead body had been embalmed. Even her hacking him to tiny bits can't put him out of his misery. (The comic was later adapted for the 1972 movie anthology: Tales from the Crypt.)
Ultimately, B.A. is able to invoke this trope. While the wish was airtight the immortality granted to Brian leaves a vengeful deity he previously pissed off free to attack him with full force. Fortunately for Brian, a clause of the wish stated that if he died as a direct consequence of the wish, all effects of the wish would be undone and Brian would get a 25,000 gp consolation prize.
The 2011 "Heart of the Monster" arc in The Incredible Hulks is built around this trope - Hulk and his team encounter a Wishing Well. Everyone involved is Genre Savvy enough to know what it will twist every wish it grants. What they don't know is the intentions of the Red She-Hulk, who used it to wish doom on her ex-husband.... if she meant it, his circumstances are going to improve, but if she liked him... As it turns out, she hated him at the time, meaning all of his dreams briefly came true.
In a Transformers: More than Meets the Eye sidestory, Trailcutter briefly wishes that he no longer had his signature forcefield before going to sleep as he feels that is the only thing people remember about him. When he awakens, an malfunctioning pulse weapon has frozen everyone else on the ship and taken away his ability to project forcefields. He later learns that his forcefields are what protected him from the inventions effects.
Recent events in Archie Comics' Sonic the Hedgehog have displayed this: Mina Mongoose, after being traumatized by the Iron Dominion's occupation of New Mobotropolis and of NICOLE's brief Magitek-inducedFace-Heel Turn, uses her status as a music icon to send a message across the city to inspire them and raise awareness concerning possible problems should NICOLE become compromised again. In comes Ixis Naugus, who uses his magic to augment all existing feelings of anger and fear in the public to turn NICOLE into a Hero with Bad Publicity and eventually get her exiled from the city altogether, which, combined with the revelation that NICOLE was acting as The Mole proceeding Sonic and Sally's departure from the city, leaves Mina guilt-ridden. When Mina goes to Freedom HQ, the place of NICOLE's exile, to speak with her and apologize, NICOLE explicitly informs her that with her exile, she got what she wanted.
A laser guided version occurs in The Sandman. Richard Madoc participates in the sex-trafficking of a muse because, as a writer, he needs ideas. It all works pretty well for him until Morpheus gives him more ideas than his brain can handle.
The My Little Pony fanfiction The Curse of Beauty involves a story within a story about six pony princesses, each named for a fairy tale heroine, who each recklessly used a spell from a magic tome called "The Excess Magic of Wishes", with disastrous and ironic results: Princess Snow White wishes she weren't so tall, and shrinks to a tiny size; Princess Goldilocks wishes to be more "sensitive", and suddenly everything feels too hard or too soft, too cold or too hot, etc.; Princess Rapunzel wishes for a longer mane, and ends up with enough hair to swamp a tower; and so on. Princess Cinderella "merely" gets trapped in a giant pumpkin after losing her concentration while casting a powerful spell.
In The Second Try, Shinji and Asuka were sent back in time because of an offhanded wish they made one night. They got their wish, but it came with a heavy cost. They wished that they could do something to allow their 3-year old daughter a normal life; a life where she could have friends. By going back in time they got their chance to make such a world, but it also erased their daughter from existence. Shinji doesn't take this very well when he learns of it.
Ultimately averted when it turns out she was sent back as well, but to a later date than her parents.
A Future Of Friendship A History Of Hate: Episode 5 is built on this trope — Scootaloo, tired of the downsides of being a kid, accepts Miserain's aid in becoming an adult... only to figure out pretty fast that she has no idea how to be one, getting her into all kinds of trouble, eventually leaving her completely depressed. Which is what Miserain wanted, as Scootaloo's despair fed the woebeghoul sealed in the Tear of Covet. Once everything is over and done with, Scootaloo learns the episode's Aesop about waiting to grow up.
The Pony POV Series has this as the origin story of General-Admiral Makarov. The Hooviet Empire was struggling to stay afloat after the Dragon-Hooviet War (which ended with the Dragon's leader QueenTiamatCurbstomping their entire military and leaving half the empire blazing ruin) and sought to create the Ultimate Lifeform to enable them to lead them back to greatness. The resulting Super Soldier experiment created Makarov. The good news? He's doing exactly what they wanted him to do. The bad news? He's playing his leaders for pawns and has his own goals of world domination. Made more literal by the fact he's actually a Equineoid Abomination called the Shadow of Chernobull created by Pandora and imprisoned in her box. A Hooviet experiment with an imagination engine ended up releasing him from his prison, after which he fed off their desires and wishes to become Makarov, in the process eating the existences of countless deer and threatening the entire world.
The Reading Rainbowverse has Bonbon being a bit annoyed that Lyra isn't taking their relationship seriously... and then Lyra finds out how Bonbon feels and breaks up with her, thinking that she can't return the affections.
Transformers Mosaic: The Final Lesson a continuation from the Marvel story Aspects of evil. The Autobot student wanted to know what true evil was, and sought out Unicron. He demands the Fallen to take him to Unicron, and the Fallen does so, teleporting him to a seemingly endless glassy wasteland. The Student is trapped there for months, until he finally realizes his mistake.
"In the eyes of Gods we are all just motes of dust."
In a "what if?" Yu-Gi-Oh fanfic called Isn't It Grand What I've Managed to Do?, Pegasus beats Yugi during their duel, claims Yugi's Millenium Puzzle, and then uses the Millenium Items to bring Cyndia back to life, just as he wanted. However, before he brings her back, he is warned both by Shadi and by the pharaoh's spirit that while he will find what he seeks, it will end badly for him. He doesn't care, and resurrects Cyndia anyway. No, it's not a monkey's paw twist; she doesn't come back as a zombie or anything. In fact, at first, everything goes smoothly. Pegasus has Cyndia back the way she was before, and they make the most of their happy reunion. So why does "be careful what you wish for" come into play? Because as we know, Pegasus had to steal people's souls in order to pull off the resurrection...which Cyndia discovers. She then becomes absolutely furious that Pegasus would murder people to bring her back to life, and tells Pegasus to his face that she barely recognizes him, that she hates him, and she doubts he really loves her at all if he would treat her like a lost possession to be brought back at any price. This causes Pegasus to wish he had never brought Cyndia back to life; he would rather have her dead and loving him than alive and hating him, and he has a humongous My God, What Have I Done? moment. They do eventually reconcile when Cyndia, recalling Pegasus' childhood refusals to follow the rules, manages to forgive Pegasus...but Pegasus has to fake his own death in order for him and Cyndia to be able to live happily together.
In Love Hina: Like It Could Have Been, Naru and Makoto successfully drive Keitaro away from the Hinata Inn, meaning they don't have to deal with a male manager. Instead, they have to cope with the fallout, as a coldly furious Haruka promptly declares the girls will have to split all the chores he would have taken over.
Based off To Love-Ru, this darker fan fic, "To-Love-DEATH" has an element of this. When the alien Gruello kills Princess Lala, Rito freaks out and immediately regrets wishing his life away. Although his panic attack is cut off short when Gruello enters his chest cavity.
Harry Potter fanfic "Wish Carefully" is pretty much this. Thanks to a deal made with Harry Potter, the Death Eaters get what they want (no Muggle-born wizards, no contact with the Muggles, full control over Magical England, all of their enemies out of the way), but instead of being able to reveling in what they have done, Lucius Malfoy eventually realizes that their wishes have actually condemned them. He actually mentions the trope, and calls it trite.
Similar stories went around in seventeenth century England. In some cases a Catholic or Anglican parent would rather their unborn child to have no head than be a Roundhead, in others, a Puritan would wish for their child have no head than have a priest make the Sign of the Cross on it. Either way, they ended up with a headless baby.
There is a fairy tale about a poor couple that rescues an elf and is granted three wishes in return. The wife, being hungry, wishes she had a nice, tasty sausage. Her husband scolds her for wasting a wish on such a mundane thing and blurts out in anger: "I wish that stupid sausage was stuck on your nose!" which is exactly what happens next. In the end, they have to use the third wish to get the sausage off the poor woman's face and have thus wasted all three of them.
There's a story from somewhere in Africa about a tribe that doesn't exist any more, because when seeking a reward from some supernatural being, the men said that the best thing that could happen to them was for their wife to give them a son, and for their cattle to give them female calves. — So be it, all your children shall be sons and all your calves shall be heifers. — They rejoiced, until...
In the Looney Tunes compilation movie Daffy Duck's Fantastic Island, Daffy, Speedy Gonzales, Yosemite Sam and the Tasmanian Devil are stuck on an deserted island with only three wishes after the map that works a wishing well is destroyed. Speedy and Daffy play this trope straight when Speedy wishes for a burrito and Daffy, annoyed over the wish, wishes it was on his nose. When Daffy suggests using the last wish to get it off, he finds out that Sam and Taz has averted the trope by wishing for a new ship, leaving the other two behind.
Aladdin wishes to become a prince, but he only wants for Jasmine to love him. He certainly gets to be a magnificent prince, but Jasmine is put off. Once he starts acting like a street rat, Jasmine is once again attracted to him.
Jafar caught this too - he wants power, and eventually to get the level of power he wants, he becomes a genie and is bound to a lamp. So he had vast power but at the same time, no power at all.
In the sequel Aladdin: The Return of Jafar, Jafar becomes a Literal Genie and tricks Abis Mal into wasting two wishes by making him wish for a sunken treasure... and teleporting him to the bottom of the sea, making him use his second wish to go back to Agrabah.
Lady and the Tramp 2: Scamp's Adventure: Scamp desires to be "wild and free" and not be restricted by rules. However, when he gets his chance and discovers the harsh realities of that kind of life, he changes his tone:
Scamp: "I got all I ever wanted... and it stinks."
In Bolt, the director pulls one of these when Mindy-from-the-Network asks for a less than happy ending. He ends it abruptly and says to Mindy "How does your audience feel about... cliffhangers? You wanted unhappy 18-35 year olds, I'll give you unhappy 18-35 year olds. Small example but it works."
A cover for the film version of Coraline features the trope name, word for word, written on a wall.
In this case, Facilier uses Exact Words and double-meanings to convince the pair to accept his deal; Facilier identifies Naveen as "Wanting to be free" and offers "Green" to get that (The card for future shows Naveen on a lily pad). Lawrence is recognized as always being a servant, but is offered a chance to improve his station (Lawrence's future card shows him and Naveen in switched positions). When they accept, Naveen is turned into a frog and Lawrence is given Naveen's appearence.
This drives the movie Shrek Forever After. When Shrek wants "one day where I can be an ogre like I used to be," he gets it. Too bad the deal he made with the Big Bad has rather unpleasant consequences.
This happens to Merida in Brave when she wished that her mother would "change" without saying specifics and to the prince of the legend who wishes for "the strength of ten men", was turned into a bear and caused him to kill everyone in the throne room and his brothers were among the victims.
In Wreck-It Ralph, the Nicelanders challenge Ralph that if he can get a medal, he can get the keys to the penthouse. Ralph does manage to get a medal, but because of his and Fix-It Felix's (who went to find Ralph) absence, Fix-it Felix Jr. has already been declared out of order and will be unplugged soon. As promised, Ralph gets the key to the penthouse but it is now abandoned.
Toy Story 3 has the main characters wishing early on that they would get played with again. When they do, it's at a day care where they happen to be assigned to toddlers who handle them too roughly. (All the main characters are toys meant for older kids than toddlers.) (And when Buzz Lightyear tries to negotiate with Lotso, the toy in charge of all the other toys, to get himself and the rest of the main characters put into the room with the older kids, Buzz and eventually the other toys find out that Lotso runs the place like a prison.)note (On a sidenote, Toy Story 3 might actually double as a meta-example on top of that; all series have some fans who wish the series would explore Darker and Edgier themes, but before the third installment came out, discussions of this idea had more of a "wouldn't this be interesting" prevailing tone, while after it came out discussions of the dark themes that actually were involved ranged from Running Gags about how dark the movie was to serious concerns about whether or not the movie was too dark for children.)
Film - Live Action
In the Robert Zemeckis war film Forrest Gump, Jenny tells Forrest that her dream is to "be up on a stage with just my guitar and my voice…" She gets that dream, all right, but she neglected to mention whether she'd be wearing anything, and when the time comes she isn't.
In the Frank Capra classic It's a Wonderful Life, protagonist George Bailey's life falls apart so dramatically that he wishes he was never born. His guardian angel, Clarence, decides to show him exactly how much of a suckfest his home town of Bedford Falls would have become without his influence. This in turn was parodied relentlessly.
In the "Fiction" section of Storytelling, white girl Vi wants to have sex with her black literature professor Mr. Scott. The actual experience turns out to be traumatic; she realises she is the latest young, impressionable white girl in a series of sexual conquests, and Mr. Scott has a proclivity for racial epithets that makes the scene memorably disturbing.
This is how Labyrinth starts. Frustrated at her baby half-brother, Sarah carelessly wishes that the villain from her favorite book would take the brat away and is more than a bit shocked when he actually does. Whoopsie.
In the Disney Movie Blank Check the protagonist feels left out because he has no money while everyone else in his family does. While blowing out the candles on his birthday cake, he wishes to be rich. Shortly afterwards , his bike gets run over and he is handed a blank check to cover for his bike, he cashes it for 1 million dollars. After buying a house and loads of fancy toys, he realizes that he is just as friendless as before. The final scene has him considering his wish for his next birthday while admiring the attractive female FBI agent that saved him from the villains.
What happens to her in the novelization of the movie is even worse. She feels her skull start to crystalize and sees the true forms of the aliens right before she explodes.
Played for laughs in Temple of Doom, where Indy, after having stopped a mining cart with his foot and resulting in his boot smoking, cries out "Water! Water!". Mere seconds later...
Also applies to the villains of The Last Crusade, though subverted. Donovan wished for eternal life as he drank from what he thought was the holy grail; ironically, he disintegrated after rapidly aging to death. Moments later, Dr. Elsa Schneider attempts to leave with the true holy grail that she would have "done anything" to get. Her wish is granted - or so she thinks - until she crosses the seal and creates an earthquake inside the temple. She nearly falls into a crevasse chasing after the grail, but Indiana catches her. Instead, she chooses to reach the grail using his grip. Just before she can get it, her hand slips from its glove and she loses her life.
The Russian film Adventures of Petrov and Vasechkin (two children) has a subplot about wishes. For example, Vasechkin states how great it would be to be invisible, only to collide with other person and shout: "What are you thinking, didn't you see me?!" When they really get wishes granted, things get even uglier.
In Leatherheads, "Dodge" Connelly (played by George Clooney) wants professional football to become a legitimate, respectable way to make a living. A variant in that there's nothing supernatural to grant his wish. The government steps in and appoints a Commissioner to clean things up. Once this happens, he discovers there's no longer a place for him or his style of play.
A Day Without a Mexican. The film starts with several Californians expressing their contempt and animosity for Mexican immigrants (mostly the illegal ones), then suddenly all Mexican immigrants start vanishing all over the state forcing them to see how much they relied on them and then making them long for their return.
In the Olsen twins movie Double, Double, Toil and Trouble, Agatha wishes that she and her identical twin Sophia were "completely different". Agatha grows up to be an evil witch who relatives avoid unless they need money, and Sophia grows up to be a kindly woman who everyone loves.
In Freaky Friday, the heroine and her mother both wish to be each other "just for one day". Since they make the wish at the same time, this being Hollywood, it happens. Hilarity Ensues.
In Bernard and the Genie, the Genie warns Bernard "Use the words 'I wish' with the caution you used to reserve for the words 'Please castrate me.'"
In Star Trek III: The Search for Spock, the Lieutenant working with Uhura at the Transporter station asks for "a little excitement"...and he gets it, but not what he had in mind.
It's somewhat overshadowed by the main "foiling the burglars" plot, but Home Alone plays this straight with the protagonist wishing his family didn't exist, and ultimately coming to regret their being gone.
"I made my family disappear!"
The horror movie Open Graves (as reviewed by Phelous) ends with the character being granted a wish, and using it to rewind time to before the tragic events of the film occurred. Since he neglected to mention that he wanted some kind of foreknowledge of what was going to happen it proceeded to just happen over again. To make it worse, the witch who created the cursed game that set this in motion showed up to tell him his wish was stupid and maybe he should make a different one, and he just insisted that was what he wanted.
The Banker. The titular character invokes this trope on a fellow who is blackmailing him. Let's just say that things don't go too well for the blackmailer after that.
In Dead Friend (aka The Ghost) Su-in, completely by accident, got what she wished for - She becomes Ji-won. Unfortunately for her, there were some nasty consequences.
Lenina Huxley, a huge fan of the pre-Utopia history, wished for some real action in Demolition Man and then Simon Phoenix broke out of the cryo prison.
The Movie of Wizards of Waverly Place had it too. Alex yells at her mother when the latter grounds the former, ultimately wishing that her parents never met. At all. And because she is holding the wand, the wish that Alex unintentionally makes comes true. Ironic that she'd wish that on vacation in the one place where her parents first met.
Essentially the plot of most Hellraiser films, especially the firsttwo and the ninth where the cenobites are simply Sense Freaks. Hedonists who open the box looking for sensation the normal, dull, unfulfilling world can't provide learn this lesson very quickly, but far too late. In Hellraiser: Deader, Pinhead delivers the trope name to Winter for trying to cheat death but messing up and delivering himself right into Pinhead's waiting chains.
Interstate 60: O.W. Grant often grants wishes this way if he thinks the wish is boring or doesn't like the person making the wish. As he explains: "Now one young couple wished to be married and live happily ever after. So I blew up their car at the church on the way to the honeymoon. Another guy he wanted great, perfect sex every day with his choice of gorgeous women - no pregnancies. So everyday he gets a Fed Ex delivery of a skin magazine and a box of tissues."
In In Time, Sylvia was bored of her sterile, rich life and wanted a life of adventure. Then, Will kidnaps her and she nearly dies a few times. After getting over the initial shock, she falls for him and joins him in his quest.
In the movie Battleship, Earth people want to contact another planet, known to be circling a similar star in a similar Goldilock's zone (not too hot, not too cold). What they don't realize is, if the civilization has the technology to actually send their people here, while all we can do is send a radio signal there, they might be a little more advanced technologically. And they might want to use that same technology (ours) to call for reinforcements.
The Sex Monster is about a man who wants his wife to agree to a threesome with them and another woman. She eventually does agree, and has such a good time that she ends up going on what can only be termed a lesbian rampage. He ends up being very unhappy about this; this trope, then is effectively the plot of the whole movie.
In The Dark Knight Rises, Selina Kyle wishes for the rich to "wonder how you ever thought you could live so large and leave so little for the rest of us." Her opinion changes after seeing just how destructive Bane's "liberation" of Gotham is.
Also, twice, this happens with Daggett. First time is when he's going to his office:
John Daggett: And can we get some girls in here?
Selina Kyle: Careful what you wish for. [immediately pounces on Daggett, throws him across the room, and pins him against the wall with her left boot and right hand] Cat got your tongue?
John Daggett: You dumb bitch!
Selina Kyle: Nobody ever accused me of being dumb!
There's also Daggett's confrontation with Bane:
John Daggett: How the hell did Miranda Tate get the inside track on the Wayne board?! I mean, has she been meeting with him?! Has she been sleeping with him?!
Philip Stryver: Not that we know of.
John Daggett: Ah, clearly you don't know much of anything, do you?! Where is Bane?!
This second time does not go so well for Daggett's neck.
The old pilgrim in the beginning of The Sword Of Doomwas praying for death, but he probably wasn't asking for it in the form of Ryūnosuke cutting him down right then & there.
In Breaking the Waves every time any character prays, this happens, along with lots of it got worse
Newton in Pacific Rim desired to see a Kaiju up close, being a huge "Kaiju groupie", as his co-worker called him. He got his wish when Otachi specifically came to Hong Kong to kill him and he nearly got eaten by Otachi Jr. Raleigh even lampshaded this and warns Newton he wouldn't want to see a Kaiju up close.
In Bride of Chucky, Tiffany proposes to Chucky after he returns to life and kills her ex-boyfriend, but Chucky only remarks that the only reason he gave her the ring was due to its value of the last victim he killed before becoming a doll. Tiffany does not take the fact kindly and locks up Chucky to force him into changing him mind. Chucky however doesn't like that and kills Tiffany to get back at her, then proceeds to resurrect her into a nearby wedding doll, making them inseparable.
Tiffany: YOU SON OF A BITCH!! WHAT HAVE YOU DONE TO ME?!! [punches Chucky in the face, Chucky then gets up and holds the Ring that Tiffany proposed to him earlier with.]
The titular character in Eve's Bayou finds this out the hard way when she wishes her father would die and enlists a voodoo practitioner to make it happen. Eve then realizes that she didn't actually want her dad to die and blames herself when he does (though it's left ambiguous whether or not her curse killed him.)
Wishmaster goes way beyond even what you'd expect from a Jerk Ass Genie. Be Careful What You Say At All might be a better advise, because the evil Djinn will interpret it as a wish and then twist it to murder you in the most horrific way possible.
In the medieval Chivalric Romance of Robert the Devil and all its variants, the parents wish for a child — whether from God or the Devil. The son is therefore born possessed by evil. (Fortunately for him, in due time, he repents and does penitence for his evil. This results in either marryingthe princess or becoming a saint.)
In Hans Christian Andersen's "The Galoshes of Fortune", the titular shoes grant the wishes of whoever is wearing them. This usually ends badly, as the characters are unaware of their power. For example, the Councilor of Justice held the view that in the time of King Hans, around 1500, everything was better; when the galoshes transport him to that age, he finds out that it was actually much worse.
The Edgar Allan Poe story "Never Bet the Devil Your Head" is an odd case of this. A man tells a story of a friend who says he'd "bet the devil his head" that he could perform a particular trick; out of nowhere, a mystery man shows up eager to take him up on his bet, and sure enough, he manages to decapitate himself and the man runs off with his prize.
In "Wedding Shirts" from A Bouquet of Czech Folktales, a ballad by Karel Jaromír Erben, a woman makes the following wish in a prayer: "O Mary, full of power / Oh, help me at this hour / Bring my beloved home / Lord knows where he does roam / Bring him, I reck not how / Or finish my life now." You know what followed... Her beloved returned to her from the grave, almost leading to the second part of the wish coming true as well.
Both subverted and not in the short story "The Wish Ring". A farmer is kind to an old woman, and gets a wish ring in return. He shows it to a jeweler to see how much it's worth, and the jeweler steals it from him and replaces it with an identical copy. The jeweler then wishes for a million gold pieces, which promptly begin raining from the sky and crush him to death. In the meantime, the farmer goes home still thinking he has the real ring. Every time his wife suggests something they could wish for, he says no, they can work for that and earn it instead. Eventually they become happy and rich because of their hard work, and die with the wish still unasked.
In The Picture of Dorian Gray, the titular character makes a Deal with the Devil to stay young and good looking forever; instead, a life sized portrait of him will age in his place. While he enjoys his life of consequence-free debauchery at first, eventually the picture begins to serve as his conscience, reminding him of things to prefer to forget. Comes complete with a heavy dose of symbolism, as after he commits murder blood appears on his portrait's hands. Eventually, trying to eliminate the portrait and the evidence of his sins causes his own death.
Forms most of the plot of the Edwardian children's novel Five Children and It by E Nesbit — the "it" of the title is a cantankerous sand-fairy, whose granted wishes always backfire on the children.
W.W. Jacobs's classic short story "The Monkey's Paw" concerns a married couple who receive the title item as a gift from a friend who served in the British Army in India. The paw grants its owner Three Wishes, and the husband uses the first of these to wish for 200 pounds; the couple subsequently learns that their grown son was killed after falling into the machinery at the factory where he worked, and they are offered as compensation from the employers. The wife then begs the husband to wish for the son to be brought back to life; after he does so (with great reluctance), they hear a steady knocking on their door. As the overjoyed wife runs to unlock and open the door, the husband realizes to his horror that the son will have come back in his mutilated state, and quickly uses the third wish; when the wife finally gets the door open, there's nobody there, implying that the third wish was for the son to be returned to the grave.
Gelsomino, whose voice could shatter even stone, wished to come into a land "where everything is inversed, and people don't worry about my voice". He then arrives into Land of Liars, where everybody is obliged by law to lie, naming night day, black white etc. Naturally, they don't care about his voice - they have other problems!
Also part of the backstory of the Nazgűl: they were once mighty, arrogant Kings of Men who desired power and long life. So Sauron gave them magic rings. Now they are immortal...undead slaves to Sauron's will.
In The Chronicles of Thomas Covenant: The Land, drinking the Blood of the Earth gives the power to command absolutely anything to happen, but limited human minds simply cannot know all consequences of a sudden change to reality. So it's usually safest not to use it.
In Ursula K. Le Guin's The Lathe of Heaven, the protagonist is repeatedly asked to dream of a solution to a pressing problem, and the solution turns out to be worse than the original. For example, asked to make sure that there is enough food for everyone, he dreams of a plague that has killed most people in the past, and the survivors have enough to eat. Then, he's asked to find a way to avert a threatened global war, so dreams that the nations of the Earth united... against the threat of an alien species that has taken up residence on the Moon. Then, when he is asked to dream that the aliens are no longer on the moon, so he makes them leave the Moon for...Earth.
The basic premise of John Brunner's novel The Traveller in Black is that of a man who grants wishes in ways that are almost never to the wishers' liking; the ultimate goal of which is to replace Chaos with Order. At least, those who are selfish get their comeuppance, but the few who are unselfish (e.g. someone who wishes the Traveller success in his present quest, a little girl who wants to make the fire burn brighter so the family hut will be warm) are rewarded. Moreover, the Traveller often simply accelerates a comeuppance that the character was bound to suffer anyway, as when he splashes Lorega with the transformative water she'd intended to jump into already.
Another work by Brunner, Galactic Consumer Reports 2: Automatic twin-tube wishing machine, states that the machines are "twintube" because the inventor of the machine got killed by a creature it created, so they had to develop a second tube that would moderate the wishes. The story contains many examples of the second tube not quite working as needed, but it's still better than the sometimes sold cheaper one tube machines... apparently, one world is quarantined because a five year old child who wasn't given ice cream got angry, so he used such a machine to create an army of Killer Robots and take over the planet.
There's a short story about a world where wishes came true automatically. In this setting, people lived idyllic lives as their every needs were met. Unfortunately, there was a fool, whose wishes were so poorly conceived that they always backfired on him. After making a number of increasingly short-sighted wishes, he finally thought of one that would put an end to this chain of misfortune: he wished "that wishes would no longer automatically come true." The next and final line of the story reads, "Things were tough all over."
In Edward Everett Hale's short story "The Man Without a Country", Philip Nolan, as a young man enamored with Aaron Burr, cries out at his court-martial, "Damn the United States! I wish I may never hear of the United States again!" The court grants him his wish by sentencing him to forever live on ships sailing away from the United States and be forbidden from ever hearing or reading anything about the United States ever again. He comes to really and truly regret his wish, and makes sure to tell the narrator not to make the same mistake he did.
Witch Week by Diana Wynne Jones has Charles use his new-found powers to torment Simon, the classroom bully. How does he do this? With a literal game of Simon says; anything Simon says comes true. After a few mishaps (with Simon saying everything from 'You girls stink' to 'I'm not clever at all!'), Chrestomanci comes in, gets Simon to shut up and tells Charles how horribly everything could've gone if Simon had said something like 'Two plus two equals three' or the like.
Bill Brittain's The Wish Giver is all about this. Three children in a small American town (along with the narrator, a man from the general store who answers to the nickname "Stew Meat") get cards that supposedly grant wishes from a mysterious vendor at the county fair, and the three stories in the book deal with the consequences of the kids' ill-thought-out wishes: A sharp-tongued tomboy named Polly wishes people would start being glad to see her, and much to the amusement of her peers she starts to croak like a bullfrog whenever she starts insulting people; a sentimental girl named Rowena wishes the handsome young traveling salesman she has a crush on would "put down roots in Coven Tree and never leave", and he starts turning into a tree; a farm boy named Adam wishes his family's farm had more than enough water, and it ends up flooded. In the epilogue, the trio have learned their lessons, and beg Stew Meat to undo their wishes with his own wish card.
Another Bill Brittain book, All the Money in the World, has a kid asking a leprechaun for just that. He gets his wish...only to learn that he's unable to spend it, give it away, or otherwise make use of it, because when he tries to do so it boomerangs right back to him. (Also that he's inadvertently bankrupted every nation on Earth.)
Non-supernatural example: In Margaret Atwood's The Handmaid's Tale, the character of Serena Joy is a former conservative televangelist who preached that women belonged in the home and helped to support the overthrow of the United States by the theocratic Republic of Gilead; by the time of the novel, she has been stripped of her public role, reduced to the role of subjugated housewife, and forced to be present while another woman - the Handmaid of the title - has sex with her husband every month. As Atwood wryly notes, "How furious she must be, now that she's been taken at her word."
Along the same lines as The Handmaid's Tale, Sinclair Lewis's It Can't Happen Here details the takeover of the U.S. government by a fascistic regime led by a demagogue named Buzz Windrip. Some characters who initially support Windrip's regime wind up becoming imprisoned or executed by it.
Truth in Television: among the many, many victims of the Nazis were some of the senior members of the Nationalist and Center Parties, which had originally supported Hitler (under the impression that it was him or the Communists, and the Communists were worse.) Windrip isn't quite a Hitler Expy, but Lewis was writing in the 1930s and almost certainly expected his readers to spot the parallels.
In C. J. Cherryh's Russian trilogy (Rusalka, Chernevog, and Yvgenie), wizards work magic by wanting something. Since the form of the wish takes the easiest path, a wish, for example, for the five-year-old wizard's father to not hit him again could and did result in the house burning down and both his parents dying in the fire. Every wish is fraught with the potential for disaster, and not wanting things is like not thinking of elephants, so wizards, by and large, end up insane hermits.
In the first book of Animorphs, Tobias states he's all right with his red-tailed hawk morph and doesn't want to be anything else. Consequently, the end of that episode (and the whole rest of the series) sees him trapped in that shape.
It doesn't quite come true, but there is a scene where Arya (disguised as a servant-girl) is talking to an annoying Frey squire who keeps jabbering about how he's going to marry a princess. At some point Arya just snaps at him, yelling "I wish your princess was dead!" not knowing she just wished her own demise. Averted in some ways in that she's still alive, although whether she's still Arya Stark is questionable.
And also when at the beginning of "A Game of Thrones" Catelyn prayed to the Seven Gods that they let Bran stay in Winterfell. He ended up falling from a tower and not being able to walk ever again.
And at one point, Jeyne Poole remarks about how when she was little, she often dreamed how it would be like to be a Stark. Now she does know for sure - and this involves massive Break the Cutie.
A principal point in the novel Coraline by Neil Gaiman — even used as a tagline in the film. Coraline wants her life to be more interesting, exciting, and engaging... she gets it, but not the way she wants.
One of the characters in Singularity Sky by Charles Stross receives three wishes. His first wish is to be young again; he becomes eight years old. Not quite what he had in mind, but as certain people sought to kill him, he was not going to complain. His second wish is for some "real friends"; he gets some talking animals. His third wish is for adventure. Bad idea.
A running theme in the Tiffany Aching series (the young adult Discworld books):
In The Wee Free Men, Tiffany's baby brother is stolen by the Queen of the Fairies, who will give him whatever he wants - and since he wants sweets, he'll get sweets, and nothing else, for the rest of his life.
That's not even the main problem. He can get as many sweets as he wants and his imagination is a limit... but since he is a little boy, every sweet he is going to eat now means that there is a better sweet in the future he can imagine that he is NOT eating right now. The end result is a crying boy sitting surrounded by ever growing pile of sweets that is unable to choose a single one, because there is always a better one just beyond his reach.
In the third book in the series, Wintersmith, Tiffany doesn't want the titular Anthropomorphic Personification of Winter to continue making her name in frost, or icebergs that look like her, but feels sorry and lets him make all the snowflake portraits of her that he wishes. As the story opens with a Flash Forward of the entire Chalk covered in tens of feet of snow, you can see where this is going.
In A Hat Full of Sky, this trope is explicitly dissected, with Granny Weatherwax pointing out that if someone in a story gets three wishes, the third will always be "undo the harm caused by the first two wishes". And in the beginning of the book it's noted that had Tiffany said aloud that she'd like to marry a prince, the Feegles might well show up at her door with an (unconscious) prince and a (tied up) priest ready to perform the ceremony.
There's an example in the main series as well: in Eric, the titular character demands three wishes from Rincewind the wizzard [sic]: mastery over the kingdoms of the world; to meet the most beautiful woman who ever lived; and to live forever. Oh, and a chest of gold. The first wish (granted by Vassenegothrough Rincewind) sends them in orbit above the Disc, and then to one of Eric's new dominions for tribute (the Tezuman empire, the inhabitants of which want to sacrifice them for being a bad landlord, metaphorically speaking). The second wish takes them to the Tsortean Wars, where they meet Elenor of Tsort (an Expy of Helen of Troy), the most beautiful woman who ever lived- ten years and seven children too late. As for the third wish, well, if you want to live for ever, you have to go back to the start of "ever", right?
Also Played for Laughs when it's noted that "yes, but not this bit!" has not been recognised as a valid clause in magic spells ever since the late Funnit the Forgetful's arguably successful spell to destroy the entire tree he was sitting in.
Common in Jonathan Strange & Mr Norrell, especially when fairies are involved. The Gentleman with the Thistledown Hair even invokes this, as one of his plans for defeating Jonathan Strange is to appear to him and offer him whatever he wants, on the basis that it's bound to cause him trouble. That plan rather backfired when Strange doesn't ask for infinite gold, the most beautiful woman in the world or something distracting and troublesome like that, but instead asks for various lost pieces of information about magic The Gentleman doesn't want him to know, leaving him flustered and trying to convince him to pick something else.
Serwe's backstory in Second Apocalypse has a lot to do with this trope. Her prayers to gods come true several times but not in a way she wants.
Fairy Haven and the Quest for the Wand by Gail Carson Levine. The Neverland fairies get a wand to repay a mermaid, but, unaware that all wands have a mind of their own, accidentally pick one of the meanest wands.
In Death Star, Imperial gunner Tenn Graneet, after Alderaan, remembers his grandfather's saying about being careful what you wish for.
Now he understood exactly what that meant. He had wanted to fire the big gun, and he had gotten to do just that. The only man in the galaxy who had shot it for real, at real targets, and look what it had brought him: misery beyondhisugliest dreams.
Unstated, but in Galaxy of Fear: The Doomsday Ship Zak Arranda, tired from ten books of constant adventure and hazard, just wants to stop and have nothing to do for a while. In the next book, Clones, the family has been on Dantooine for two weeks traveling with a local tribe with anything dangerous being quickly and easily resolved by the adults, and the tech-minded Zak is bored out of his mind.
In Franny Billingsley's Well Wished this trope is the main basis of the plot. The antagonist sets up the protagonist to fall for this trap. She tricks the protagonist into a making wish that she knows will exchange her crippled body for the protagonist's healthy one.
In Melissa Marr's Ink Exchange Leslie wishes for 'no more fear and pain' when she gets her tattoo...she ends up being used as a conduit by some very darkfaeries with a Horror Hunger for negative emotions, unable to feel anything for more than a few seconds and barely lucid.
Mat from The Wheel of Time books is granted three wishes, but doesn't realise it and goes on a rant. Luckily, he manages to get some useful stuff from it.
In The Voyage of the Dawn Treader, one of the seven lords is stranded on an island where all of your dreams come true. When the Dawn Treader arrives there in search of him, they initially think that this sounds pretty good, until poor Lord Rhoop corrects their misconception: not daydreams, dreams. Including nightmares. Once the sailors take a moment to think about some of the dreams they've had, they quickly throw their full efforts into getting the hell out of there.
Also, in The Magician's Nephew, the fruit that Digory picks for Aslan grants wishes. But as the writing on the garden wall warns...
Come in through the gold gates or not at all.
Take of my fruit for others or forbear.
For those who steal or those who climb the wall
Shall find their heart's desire and find despair.
In The Emperor's Winding Sheet by Jill Paton Walsh, the last Emperor of Constantinople said that in his youth he plotted and schemed to become Emperor, and God punished him-by making him Emperor.
At the end of L. Jagi Lamplighter's Prospero in Hell, Miranda reflects on how she had wished to have a common enemy for her family to unite against. She got one. (It's the second in a trilogy.)
Elfsong by Elaine Cunningham includes a stanza from Danilo Thann which says this in the chorus. It's a Bawdy Song. "Your wish bespoke how long it WAS, and not how long 'twould LAST!". And yes, it's about a knight's lance.
One implication of a Cautionary Tale - "A tomboy who became a real boy". A girl wants to do boyish things, and now she has to do boyish things, since she just became a boy.
A short story "The Dumpster". Sick of your asocial family?, The dumpster will replace it with copies that behave perfectly, but: 1) They will be creepy in their own way, and, most important 2)YOU are now held to the same high standards - slack off and the dumpster will replace you with a perfect copy as well.
In Peter Freund's Mysteria series, there is a teenage girl Jessie who, when her father starts a book about the titular land, is excited of it and wants to go there; and then she accidently gets stuck in Mysteria, which is very bad because she requires insulin injections and Mysteria doesn't offer this, even with the magic, so she must find a way back before her supply runs out.
The In Death series: Eve is doing paperwork, which she hates, at the beginning of New York to Dallas. She wishes that there was some murderer out there for her to go get. She gets it in the form of Isaac McQueen, a rapist and pedophile, who was the first murderer she took down while she was in uniform, and is out for Revenge against Eve. It goes From Bad to Worse when Isaac goes to Dallas, the place where she killed her father in self-defense at 8 years old. Paperwork suddenly looks very good right about now.
In The Obsidian Trilogy and The Enduring Flame Trilogy Wildmages can make wishes to the Wildmagic which will grant it for a price which varies depending on the difficulty of the wish. Since the magic will grant you what you ask for, not what you want, Wildmages are warned to think carefully what they really want/desire in order to not waste time and energy paying off a wasted wish, and to minimize the cost of any necessary wishes.
Septimus Heap: Lampshaded with Marcia becoming ExtraOrdinary Wizard, since she wished it all the time and it eventually became true... by Alther being shot on the day she became EOW: "Beware what you wish for, lest it come true"
Jack: I should be able to just stick out my arms, and have a princess fall right into them!
Enchantress from the Stars: Young, overenthusiastic Elana wants to be a part of expedition on Andrecia. She gets her wish when Ilura, another agent, is killed and from then on is on for a very harsh mission from which she now can't back down.
Charlie and the Chocolate Factory: Seemingly every child on planet wants to get one of the five Golden Tickets, which will enable him or her to visit Willy Wonka's factory. For four out of five children who find it (and of these four, at least three actively seek the ticket) the visit turns into a horrible experience. This is subverted with The Hero, who becomes the heir to the factory.
Ista: The gods' most savage curses come to us as answers to our own prayers. Prayer is a dangerous business.
This echoes a remark by the Roman writer Juvenal about "monstrous prayers that Heaven in anger grants."
In a 1941 Theodore Sturgeon short story "Shottle Bop", a seer-of-ghosts sees a ghostly couple in an endless feedback loop, repeating a conversation, summed up as follows: "If we kill ourselves, we're sure to be together.... forever.... just like this." "Will we, Tommy?" "I promise.... just like this."
In The ABC Murders, Hercule Poirot says his ideal mystery would be murder at a bridge game, where everyone was so intent upon the game that noone noticed when one of them, the dummy that round, got up and killed the host. A few books later, he faces exactly that.
In E. D. Baker's The Wide-Awake Princess, Sleeping Beauty's parents want to protect their second daughter and assure the Fairy Godmother they would do anything to prevent such a curse on her. The fairy godmother makes her immune to magic. Which means she doesn't get the standard gifts that make her beautiful, talented, charming, etc.
In Airframe, after a strange incident involving a plane, the manufacturer takes it up to recreate it, and a reporter that's been following them demands to go along. She winds up regretting it.
Household Gods by Judith Tarr and Harry Turtledove begins when Nicole, fed up with life in modern-day LA, tells what she believes to be perfectly ordinary statues of the Roman gods Liber and Libera that she wished she could live in ancient Rome. Liber and Libera deem it an excellent request, and are all too happy to grant it.
As John Galt explains towards the end of Atlas Shrugged, society has claimed for decades that wealthy businessmen, executives, and entrepreneurs are evil villains who harm, exploit, and enslave others. Well, he has made them all vanish, liberating society of their evil... so what does anyone have to complain about?
"Be Careful What You Wish For" by Stef already states it in the title. Young girl Gwen is bored and wishes for something to do. She is sent on a quest to save Idlebury kingdom... from itself.
John Collier's short story "The Chaser" applies the principle to a Love Potion. The customer buys it in order to secure the absolute and undying love of the woman he desires, but it's implied that this will eventually grate on him. In fact the chaser of the title is the untraceable poison the shopkeeper is sure he'll be back to purchase. The story was adapted as an episode of The Twilight Zone.
A very sad example happens in Bridge to Terabithia. In the beginning, Jess want to become the fastest runner in his grade, but he is beaten by Leslie. Near the end, he contemplates that now he probably is the fastest runner - because Leslie, who became his best friend during the year, has just died in a tragic accident Needlessly to say, this wish fulfillment doesn't make him happy.
In The Book of Lost Things a greedy and gluttonous man requests that the Crooked Man pay him in gold the weight of everything that he has eaten at a buffet. The Crooked Man complies...by pouring molten gold down his throat.
For most of his career, Horatio Hornblower really wants financial security (he's terribly unlucky with prize money, which is the real source of a captain's living), recognition of his good work by the Service, and (after The Happy Return) a way to marry Lady Barbara and a title to impress her. He gets all of it at the end of Flying Colours—but because his hero's welcome and title are calculated propaganda, he and Barbara are freed by the death of their spouses, and his constant self-loathing makes him feel like he deserves none of it anyway, Hornblower starts hating it before the last page.
One of the obvious aspects in The Wishing Maiden, as the titular Maiden has no control over how the wishes are granted; it's all in the phrasing, and the phrasing tends to be taken very literally.
In Red Mars, one of the First Hundred colonists on Mars is Arkady Bogdanov, a visionary who dreams of remaking humanity on a new world and craves revolution to escape from the old-fashioned and oppressive political structures on Earth. When the revolution comes in 2061 he's as happy as a clam in his free city. Until, that is, it's sabotaged and immolated by U.N. forces, killing him and hundreds of others. The Revolution of 2061 turns into a total bloodbath as the U.N., now a puppet of "metanational" corporations, hunts down and slaughters as many revolutionaries as it can, locks down control of Mars, and forces the survivors deep into hiding for decades.
Early in season 8 Chloe notes that Tess certainly seems like a Luthor-wannabe, and while Tess isn't the one saying it, it's pretty obvious that it's true. In season 10, Tess finds out that she is a Luthor, Lionel's bastard daughter, and let's just say that she is not happy about it.
Sesame Street: The Amazing Mumford and Abby Cadabby lack both the skill to control their magic and the ability to undo their mistakes. A number of episodes are based on this.
In an episode of Top Gear devoted to Lamborghini, James May learns this the hard way when he finally gets to drive the car of his dreams, the Countach. He lampshades this without mentioning the trope by name.
James: And [the Countach] looked so good on the poster. In fact, I wish it had stayed there. I'm absolutely gutted. But you know it's not the car's fault; it's mine. I've broken the Golden Rule: You never, ever meet your childhood heroes. ...Stick with the memories. They're just better.
The plot of Beetleborgs centers around three kids who wish to be their favorite comic book superheroes. Consequently, the villains also appear, handing out several Curb Stomp Battles over the course of the series. The first episode of the second season, "Metallix", also showed that the wish had a second part - you get the powers, you get the bad guys. No more bad guys? No more powers. Thankfully, new bad guys showed up and the kids were back in action.
The Cosby Show did this plot, with Theo as the teenager who wanted to be treated like an adult, in its first season, but it has appeared in other series as well.
iCarly: The Christmas Episode "iChristmas". Carly wishes for Spencer to be normal, and an It's a Wonderful Life style homage ensues, ending with Carly more appreciative than ever of her life.
Ensnaring wronged people with Be Careful What You Wish For is the whole modus operandi of vengeance demons in Buffy. They find somebody who's been wronged, get them to make a wish, and then make the wish come true in a gruesome manner that the wisher never intended.
In the episode entitled "The Wish", Cordelia wished that "Buffy Summers had never come to Sunnydale." In the Bizarro World which resulted, without Buffy to stop him, the Master and his vampires succeeded in taking over Sunnydale completely, turning Willow and Xander into vampires with Cordelia herself getting killed.
Which means that Cordelia never actually learns anything after the snapback at the end of the episode.
In "Older and Far Away," Dawn makes a wish to Halfrek that everybody would spend more time with her. Halfrek makes the dream come true by magically making it impossible for any of the guests at Buffy's party to leave the house. And then promptly picks up the Idiot Ball by entering the house herself, causing the curse to affect her.
Later in "Selfless," Anya makes a wish to D'Hoffryn that her vengeance curse be undone. D'Hoffryn answers that undoing the curses requires the death of a vengeance demon. Anya agrees to the price, assuming that she's the one who will die, but then D'Hoffryn summons Anya's friend Halfrek and kills her to undo Anya's curses.
In another example from the series, Buffy wishes that her parental figures, Joyce (her actual mother) and Giles (her Watcher) would stop forcing her to be responsible. Later in the episode, entitled "Band Candy," when the adults lose their ability to act responsibly, Buffy sees the disasters that can result when no one does what they are supposed to do, e.g. vampires can steal babies to feed to giant demon snakes if no one cares to watch out for such things. The Reset is rarely complete though - quite a few memories and changes were kept until the end of the show.
A more terrifying example occurs in the episode wherein Dawn uses a spell to bring Joyce Summers back to life. It's the classic Monkey's Paw, and the horror is only increased by the fact that except for her feet walking through the cemetery, we never see what Joyce looked like. She had been dead for some time, so...
Xander stepping up to the plate and taking his best shot with Buffy. "I want to dance with you". He gets his wish in the very next episode, when a shell-shocked Buffy bumps and grinds against him to enrage Willow and Angel.
Quoted by Halloween costume fashionista Ethan Rayne. "Don't wish to blow my own trumpet, but it's genius. The very embodiment of 'be careful what you wish for'."
Buffy has a love-hate relationship with her job. She complains about being a Slayer, but is reluctant to give up her duties when Kendra and Faith threaten to edge her out of the gang.
"Helpless" depicts what would happen if Buffy were truly a normal girl stuck in a house with vampires.
A scorned Xander performing a love spell on Cordelia. Needless to say, it backfires.
Giles: I cannot believe that you are fool enough to do something like this!
Xander: Oh, no, I'm twice the fool it takes to do something like this.
Ken's "The Reason You Suck" Speech in "Anne". He ridiculing her for running away from Sunnydale and her old identity trying to disappear. "Congratulations. You got your wish."
The Trio in Season 6 wanted to be taken seriously as super villains. Willow completely flayed Warren, leading Jonathan and Andrew to flee the country to escape her wrath.
Eventually, they knew better than to say they wished for things aloud, given every time they do, something perverts the wish. This is much to the chagrin of Anya, who was trying to get them to wish for something so she could pervert it.
Liam always wanted to get out of Galway and see the world. So naturally, he jumped at Darla's offer to see it together. He didn't regret it for a moment (until...) but he probably didn't expect it to happen in quite that way.
Cordelia actually has this happen to her twice—given the opportunity in Angel to wish she had never reunited with Angel and gotten the visions which were killing her, she found herself in a world where Angel was insane, Wesley was missing an arm, and Fred was nowhere to be found.
Newsradio did a hilarious variation on this where Dave and Lisa put Bill in charge of the station for a day in order to show him how hard their jobs were; the twist was that Bill knew what they were doing from the start (going so far as to ask if they were doing it), but he still played along until they admitted to what they were doing.
Subverted in Dad's Army, when Captain Mainwaring decides to give persistent grumbler Private Frazer a week's experience in commanding the unit in order to see that it is not as easy as he thinks, only for Frazer to grow increasingly tyrannical and arrogant with power; the catch is that Frazer, although unpopular with the rest of the men, actually proves himself a competent commanding officer whose skills are even recognized and rewarded by a superior officer.
In the The X-Files episode "Je Souhaite", Mulder meets a female genie who can grant anyone three wishes... but she is forced to interpret the wishes rather literally, causing her much frustration at the stupidity of people who don't think things through. It is revealed that she used to be a poor peasant woman in the Middle Ages, who found the original genie and squandered her first two wishes asking for a mule and a magic sack of turnips that never ran out. For her third wish, she asked for great power and eternal life: the other genie promptly turned her into a genie, too. The downside: She is now bound to act on the decisions of whichever idiot unrolls her from the carpet she is mystically connected to, and she cannot grant wishes to herself. When Mulder wishes for "peace on Earth", his wish is granted... by making every other person in the world disappear except him. The genie tells him it is impossible for her to change the minds of 6 billion people, but making them disappear was within the rules. Mulder uses his final wish by giving it to her, granting her the ability to make her own decisions and become a mortal woman again.
Charmed has several genies corrupting the wishes of the characters that made them.
In the pilot episode of The Sentinel, Blair wants to learn about Jim and write about him for his dissertation. When Jim offers to let Blair follow him at work, Blair excitedly declares that his book might be a best seller. In the final episode, when Blair's dissertation gets leaked to a publisher, he gets everything he wished for. He gets offered fame and money for his work... but Jim's life becomes a living hell now that the media knows about his abilities.
One episode has a boy running into a genie who grants him several wishes, but they all end up backfiring on him. For example, when he wishes for a brand new car, the boy gets it, but is later arrested when the police discover that the car is stolen. In order to end his torment, the boy finally wishes that he had never met the genie, effectively pressing the Reset Button.
Another episode uses a thinly-veiled version of The Monkey's Paw: One of the kids wishes to win a race, so a wild dog shows up and breaks his rival's leg, etc. The wishes escalate until one of them wishes his grandfather (who's dead) were there, at which point Zombie Gramps starts knocking on the door (you don't get to see it, though) until one of the kids wishes they'd never made the wishes.
In another one, a girl wishes to live in a fairy tale world, and her wish is granted by the Jackass Genie Sandman.
In response to being asked what he wanted, by Mr Morden.
Londo: ...All right. Fine. You really want to know what I want?! You really want to know the truth?! I want my people to reclaim their rightful place in the galaxy. I want to see the Centauri stretch forth their hand again, and command the stars. I want a rebirth of glory, a renaissance of power. I want to stop running through my life like a man late for an appointment, afraid to... To look back, or to look forward. I want us to be what we used to be. I want... I want it all back, the way that it was! Does that answer your question? Morden: ...Yes. Yes it does.
Another thing Londo desires, is to get a better position at court rather than the ambassador to Babylon 5. He eventually gets everything he asked for, and ends up Emperor of the Republic for good measure. The process takes the next three seasons to fulfill and leads to several major galactic wars and millions of casualties. And he has no freedom at all.
Supernatural had an episode with a whole town full of this trope because of a wishing well that worked, involving most notably (and hilariously, in that depressing ''Supernatural'' way) a little girl wishing for a giant talking Teddy Bear. Who spent most of the subsequent episode drinking, watching porn and trying to commit suicide. Life as a giant talking Teddy Bear, apparently, makes Marvin the Paranoid Android's life seem full of cheer and meaning. In a possible aversion though, the brothers stop the wishing well before things go catastrophically bad. The original wisher was a man with a magic coin who wished for his high school crush to fall in love with him, which didn't quite turn out how he hoped either.
The third season finale of Heroes seems to drop a load of this in Sylar's lap if one looks back at his words from season 1:
Gabriel Gray/Sylar: [to Chandra] When I was a kid I used to wish some stranger would come and tell me my family wasn't really my family. Oh, they weren't bad people, they were just...insignificant. And I wanted to be different. Special. I wanted to change. A new name, a new life.
Eden McCain (aka Sarah Ellis) has an extremely potent power of verbal suggestion. During an argument with her (horrible) stepmother, she unwittingly shouts at her: "I wish you'd just die!". Her heart immediately stops.
The Imagin of Kamen Rider Den-O operate on this trope. They seek out people and grant their wishes, but only in letter. In one episode, when a park groundskeeper wished to make his park a safe haven for strays, the Imajin granting the wish responded by attacking any human who set foot in the park and barricading the entrances.
Disney Channel had a weekend special where they did this with 3 of their shows:
Hannah Montana - Miley wishes she was just Hannah Montana all the time. It is granted and her dad married a Gold Digger, her best friend became Alpha Bitch, and her brother became a hobo.
Cory in the House - Corey Baxter wishes that he was president of the U.S.A. After it's granted, Corey uses his authority to get rich, and slacks off on his presidential duties. This leads to being completely unprepared for an alien invasion, and a literal Reset Button is pressed at the end.
The Suite Life of Zack and Cody- Zack and Cody wish that they were superheroes. After having to defeat now-supervillian Mr. Moseby, the twins learn they'll have to fight evil 24/7 and give up all their free time. This prompts them to try and fix things by running fast enough to travel through time, to before they made the wish.
Though not an actual wish, also in The Suite Life of Zack and Cody, the episode "The Suite Smell of Excess", Zack and Cody get a chance to go to an alternate world where everything is reversed and they can play around as much as they like and do whatever they want when they want. However after a few days of excess, they realize that the "preferred" alternate universe Tipton is NOT the perfect place they thought it would be.
As does an episode of Tales from the Crypt, "Last Respects", which features three sisters. After one sister wishes for a million pounds, another sister dies in a car crash with the third sister (who survives). Guess what the insurance payoff was? When she wishes that the sister hadn't died in the accident, she gets a call from the morgue, and finds out that she was murdered before the accident. When the third sister admits to the murder and comes after her, she deliberately invokes the "Comes back as a Zombie" part to let her slain sister avenge herself.
There's an episode of Tales from the Crypt about a scriptwriter who continuously fantasizes about his hot neighbour being sexually obsessed with him. His creepy landlady gives him a bottle of something to slip into her drink, which he does, and it works too well: she's now continuously badgering him for sex at every moment of the day, until he commits suicide to get away from her. Even that doesn't work because she throws herself out the window to be with him, and her (now horrifically disfigured ghost)continues to nag him for sex .
Many Twilight Zone episodes used this trope. One notable one being "Time Enough at Last" starring Burgess Meredith. He wanted to be left alone so he could read and wound up the lone survivor of a nuclear war...with broken glasses.
From the same series, "Of Late I Think of Cliffordville": A ruthless, aging businessman desires to return to his hometown in the time when he was a young adult, so he could make a business deal for land that he knew was valuable in the present. He's sent back, but forgot a couple of details: (1)he didn't ask for his money to be converted to older currency, so when he tries to make the deal, it's dismissed as counterfeit; and (2) although he wished to look like his younger past self, his physical body is still that of an old man (which he learns the hard way after getting into a fight.) Well, what did you expect from a Deal with the Devil, even one played by Julie Newmar? (Although this devil is more sympathetic, and lets him return to the present at the cost of his fortune.)
Monty Python's Flying Circus used this in a sketch parodying a fairy tale; a witch invokes a curse upon the attendants of a wedding, turning everyone present into chickens. After a brief second, her eyes widen and she adds "EXCEPT ME!" It's too late, though.
Witch Chicken: Oh, bugger.
Perhaps unsurprisingly, Fantasy Island employed this trope quite often.
Doctor Who had the Family of Blood, who wanted immortality so badly that they hunted the Doctor for months, then on finding him proceeded to slaughter their way through a village in order to draw him out of hiding. When he does, there's hell to pay.
The genie from the episode "Fruit of a Poisoned Tree" in Once Upon a Time says that he has granted 1001 wishes and 1001 times seen things end badly. We see three wishes granted during the episode, the King's wish for the genie's freedom, which results in the genie falling in love with the Queen and murdering the King, the second wish was for the genie to have the third allowing the genie's own wish to be able to stay with his true love forever and always be able to gaze on her face, resulting in him turning into the Queen's Magic Mirror, and they would seem to confirm the genie's statement.
One Episode of The Adventures Of Shirley Holmes has a teenage girl who was constaltnly harassing the male child star for some unknown series, with the intent to get him out of the show, so that she could the star instead. The boy actually did want to quit, but the Corrupt Corporate Executive wouldn't let him. Shirley exposes the executive and helps the boy to nullify his contract, but didn't find any evidence against the girl. The narration then states: "But she did got what she deserved: her own studio contract, with lots of fine print..." Cue the sight of the girl, forced to do a "take 12" of some stupid episode, exhausted, angry, and clearly miserable after just a few days - and earlier it was established that the contracts with this studio have a minimum term of two years. For the girl, those years will be very long.
The plot of "Amok Time" is driven by a Vulcan love triangle involving Spock. The other man ends up with Spock's ex-fiancee, which actually comes as a relief to Spock. (The woman in question is a Manipulative Bitch who is perfectly willing to force two close friends to fight to the death if it will get her out of an inconvenient Arranged Marriage.) Spock wishes the other man well and invokes this trope, saying "You may find that having is not so pleasing a thing after all as wanting. It is not logical, but it is often true." This is probably as close as a Vulcan can come to saying, "Dude, you have no idea what you are getting into."
"Shore Leave" has the story conclude with the Caretaker of the strange planet the landing party is on explain that it's a essentially a giant recreation area where anything they think of will be created. He invites the crew to live it up for a while, as long as they follow this trope.
In "Tapestry", Picard dies from his artificial heart failing him, and he encounters Q in what seems to be the afterlife. After much prodding by Q, Picard reveals he regrets getting into a fight with Nausicaans (mentioned in an earlier episode), in which he suffered a near-fatal wound to his heart, necessitating his artificial heart. So Q takes Picard back to that time so he can avoid the brawl. He does, but this new, "play-it-safe" Picard doesn't have the same drive that made him captain of the Enterprise, instead being stuck as a lowly science officer with no career prospects. Picard regrets this, so with some pleading, Q takes Picard back to that time again to let him get into that fight once more, believing that if he has to die, he wants to die as someone who did something with his life. He does, but in the present, he ends up recovering from his artificial heart's problems, perhaps a token of appreciation by Q.
Starfleet security officer turned Maquis rebel Eddington framed his conflict with Sisko as Valjean vs. Javert. Once he went too far by using a bioweapon to drive Cardassians from one of the contested worlds, Sisko got tired of the song and dance and rendered an entire Maquis world uninhabitable for human life, and was going to keep going if not for Eddington's surrender.
Odo desperately wanted to find his people and learn where he had come from. When he finally does, he discovers his people are a ruthless, xenophobic, egomaniacal race that has already conquered the Gamma Quadrant and is now bent on conquering the Alpha Quadrant. He is, suffice it to say, devastated.
Garak desperately wanted to return home from exile. He eventually gets his wish at the very end of the show after Cardassia has been ravaged by an Occupation that caused war with the entire Alpha Quadrant, the loss of over eight hundred million lives and the complete devastation of its government, security forces, military forces, culture and infrastructure. It goes without saying that this is not the homecoming he dreamed of.
Martok, holding a grudge against aging Klingon warrior Kor for trying to ruin his career before it began, would like nothing better than to see the living legend slip up. When a bout of senility finally gets to the old man mid-battle, though, Martok can't take any pleasure in it. All he sees is a man losing a battle to the one enemy no Klingon can beat: time.
In the tie-in novel "Behind Enemy Lines" Ro Laren, after seeing her home devastated by the Dominion, swears to fight until Cardassia is equally devastated. In the later book, she reflects on her previous wish and how horrified she is now of Cardassia's fate.
In "Blood Fever", it ends with Paris telling Torres he didn't really mind her "scary" Klingon side, and said he might like to see it again someday. She warns him this. It's what launched their relationship.
In one Muppets Disney Xtreme Digital skit, the Newsman reports that a government aircraft carrying fresh mint money is experiencing some technical difficulties and it is causing the aircraft to dump untraceable cash from the sky. Suddenly a sack falls down on to the Newsman's desk and it is followed by bills of money floating down. The Newsman wishes it had been huge sacks of priceless diamonds and then, to his surprise, another sack falls down as diamonds rain down on him. Getting excited, the Newsman wishes for a 32oz T-Bone (medium well done) and a steak falls down on his desk. Getting even more excited, the Newsman also asks for a beautiful brown-eye blonde... But then a cow with blonde hair crashes onto his desk from above. He painfully crawls up and mutters that he should have been specific on that last one.
Detective Beckett spends most of the first season and the beginning of the second mortified and annoyed that Castle's following her around for inspiration and research for his novel, and not-so-subtly wishing he'd just go away, stop writing about her and leave her alone. Then, in "When the Bough Breaks", not only is Castle's novel about to be finished, but he's been offered a very lucrative job writing a series of thrillers starring "a certainBritish secret agent", meaning everything that Beckett's been counting the days down about is about to come to pass. Only now that it's happening, Beckett is clearly a bit upset both about him leaving and the fact that he's apparently not interested in writing about her any more. When the contract for his series about her is unexpectedly renewed, she's clearly annoyed but, it's strongly hinted, a bit relieved as well.
In "Knockout", after an argument with Castle about her mother's case (and the unspoken feelings between them) has gotten out of hand and become very vicious, Beckett angrily goes to her boss demanding that Castle be kicked out of the precinct. His nonchalant agreement with her request completely throws her off-balance. Subverted, since her boss clearly could tell that she was just venting and her flustered back-tracking only confirmed that she wasn't serious.
The crew parodied Coily in episode 317 (the famous "waffle episode"), with Willy the Waffle, the Wonderful Whimsical Wisecracking Waffle granting Tom's wish for a world without waffles ("Noooooooooo Waffles! *coil spring noise* "). Willy appeared again in 423 to show Tom a world without advertising ("It was all I had, I had to work fast"). After Willy's spiel, Joel and Tom agree that they prefer the world without advertising.
They also parodied Coily in the host segments for the episode in which they watched "A Case of Spring Fever". While discussing the skit, Tom wishes never to see Mike again, which prompts a visit by Mikey the Mike Sprite, who makes Nelson disappear. The Bots aren't too bothered, but Mikey eventually badgers them into at least pretending they've learned their lesson, and brings Mike back. Then Crow says he doesn't want to see Mike's socks again; cue Mikesocksy...
After winning a game of Three-Card Monty against Pearl, Mike wins the right to watch any movie he wants. He decides he wants to watch Hamlet, and Pearl responds by giving him an incredibly dull, black-and-white German rendition of Hamlet.
In Game of Thrones, Sansa Stark, begs her mother to give her permission to leave Winterfell and marry Prince Joffrey Baratheon, because she wanted to live the privilege life of a Queen and give birth to the future King's children. Sansa quickly regrets this, after she realized what a monster his is at the end of season 1 and during season 2. He has her father beheaded, despite promising her, he'd show mercy if he admitted to treason. Then during season 2, he mentally and physically tortures her.
Then there's Arya, the tomboy of the Stark family. She never wanted to be a lady. She said it herself. By the end of Season 1, her hair is cut and she is forced to disguise herself as a boy to escape Joffrey and the Lannisters.
LOST Jack wants nothing more than to get off the Island. Ben himself calls Jack out on having nothing to go back to off of the Island. Once Jack makes it off of the Island, instead of the heroic leader he was on the Island, he becomes an alcoholic suicidal delusional man who heavily regrets leaving the Island, and reluctantly knows that the man who told him not to leave was right all along.
The Tales from the Darkside episode "The Milkman Cometh" featured a milkman that granted wishes that his customers wrote down and left in their discarded milk bottles. One guy gets addicted to having his wishes granted, and the family soon becomes rich, but his Genre Savvy son begs him to stop before they get screwed over. He refuses, and wishes that they had a second child, only for the milkman to grant it by breaking into the house and raping his wife.
Less squicky and more And I Must Scream is "Lifebomb"; a workaholic executive is offered, free of charge, the titular device - an implant on his back that instantly wraps him in a lifesaving cocoon should he have a heart attack. Turns out that the reason it's provided free of charge is that he's worth millions in life insurance - the insurance companies won't let him die, no matter how much his quality of life decays, until he cancels his insurance policies, which would bankrupt his family. The doctor who gave him the lifebomb says that though he developed the device for sick and elderly patients, the only people who would fund his research were insurance companies. Also a case of Laser-Guided Karma - he denied the families of workers who died in a mine collapse a settlement because they already received company insurance payoffs. "They got what they've been promised." Guess what that doctor says to him at the end of the episode?
Julian Priest (David Bowie), the Mad ArtistHorror Host of the second season of the anthology The Hunger, cites this trope by name as a way of summing up the events of his debut episode "Sanctuary", though the desire and its granting are unusual. Julian hated death and desired artistic immortality; he realized he could achieve it by making his suicide a piece of performance art. Now he's a lonely ghost, haunting the abandoned prison that was his home — perhaps Death's punishment for his defiance.
In one episode of The Monkees, one of them finds a Monkey's Paw. They don't realize how dangerous it is until the owner says "I wish I could stop talking about it", only to have the wish granted before he can say the last two words of that sentence.
In one episode of Wizards of Waverly Place, when Alex asks a genie to stop people from comparing her to Justin, no one remembers who he is.
This happens to Robbie Rotten in "The First Day of Summer" on LazyTown. He wishes that everyone else in LazyTown would just disappear and seemingly gets his wish when they all head off to play at the beach. He quickly realizes, however, that all of the things that he enjoys about being a villain— the setting of traps, hatching evil schemes, etc., just aren't much fun without anyone there to actually scheme against. He ends up falling into one of his own traps, and when Sportacus comes to rescue him, everyone else follows. He's so happy to see them that he even joins them for the singing and dancing of the episode-ending "Bing Bang Song."
When Father Mukada is falsely accused of molestation by inmate Timmy Kirk, he prays for Kirk's death. The next day Kirk is murdered by a crazed inmate who believes he's carrying out God's will, whereupon Mukada tries to convince himself that God doesn't carry out that kind of request.
Rome. After discovering his wife's infidelity, and realising his children conspired to keep the secret from him, Vorenus curses them all to damnation. This is Serious Business for a Roman so Vorenus is aghast when he returns to his house and finds them missing. Pullo assures him he can just lift the curse when his children return. They don't, having been abducted and sold into slavery by an enemy of Vorenus while he was absent from his house.
One instance where the genie is as much a victim as the wisher is in Once Upon a Time in Wonderland, where the Lizard wishes that Will, now a genie, could feel something and the magic complies, killing her dead and getting Will to feel something - grief and guilt.
On Salem, Mary says this exactly to Mercy after recounting how she came to be George Sibley's wife. Namely, "the problem with becoming the Queen is that you have to marry the King."
In Farscape the Skarran Empire and Peacekeepers spent a great deal of effort trying to create wormhole weapons, with Crichton being their focus due to the knowledge imbedded in his mind. In The Peacekeeper Wars Crichton finally gives them a wormhole weapon, namely a self-propagating black hole capable of consuming the entire universe. At this point both factions agreed to stop fighting.
The titular character of Marilyn Manson's concept album Antichrist Superstar rises to become the Physical God he always dreamed of being, but crosses the Despair Event Horizon in the process and destroys the earth in a nihilistic rage. The last words of the album are actually "when all of your wishes are granted, many of your dreams will be destroyed" - repeated over and over amidst a wall of static.
The titular King in Metallica's "King Nothing" did get the title he worked for, but alienated his would-be subjects in the process, leaving him alone to attend to a crumbling kingdom.
The Talking Heads song, "Burning Down The House" opens up with "Watch out, you might get what you're after"
Eurydice in "Hadestown" wants to "lie down forever," so she's taken to the underworld.
The narrator of Rush's song "Xanadu" wishes he could visit the stately pleasure dome of Coleridge's poem and gain immortality by drinking honeydew and the milk of paradise. He succeeds, but finds himself eternally trapped within the dome.
The song "Carnies" from Clockwork Angels has the protagonist realizing that wishing to get away from his ordinary life wasn't going to go the way he meant it to.
Mentioned in the Art of Dying song "Completely"; the lead-in line to the chorus in (both versions) is "watch what you wish for, you know you just might get it..." In the original, there is a line in the chorus about how "everything you want/ain't always what you need..."
The song "Black Fox" by Heather Dale. Whilst out on a unsuccessful fox-hunt, the master huntsman proclaims "If only the Devil himself come by, we'd run him such a race!". A little black fox then appears, and the huntsmen chase it until it crosses a river... and promptly turns into the devil, whereupon the huntsmen have a collective Oh Crap moment and flee, pursued by the (now-laughing) little black fox.
Her other song "Changeling Child" is about a woman who longed for a "babe" of her own so she ask the Fairies to give her one. They give her exactly what she asked for: a child that forever stays as a babe.
"Cat's in the Cradle" by Harry Chapin (and covered in the 1990s by Ugly Kid Joe). "I'm gonna be like you, Dad!" The boy's ambition will come true in a most depressing way.
As per the page quote, this is a recurring theme in Eminem's raps, especially after his best friend and fellow rapper, Deshaun "Proof" Holton died. The track "My Darling" also covers this trope extensively.
Kanye West professes to having a love/hate relationship with fame, especially after his mother died from complications from extensive surgery after they were enveloped in Hollywood.
Explicitly quoted by the protaganist of WASP's concept album The Crimson Idol Jonathan Aaron Steel just before his onstage suicide. He got fame, money and glory but at the expense of his family, his sanity and health and never knowing if anyone saying they loved him actually meant it or were just saying it because of who he was.
The trope image comes from Calvin and Hobbes, during a storyline where Calvin gets sick.
Two arcs of FoxTrot relating to one of Jason's money making schemes are a direct result of this trope: The first one related to Jason making his own website, and the second dealt with a greeting card, both times were the result of Roger, his father, ranting about how he would make a lot of money creating a site and at the cost of buying Christmas cards, respectively. The second time, Jason wasn't even in the same room as Roger, implying that Roger was talking about to Andy loud enough for Jason to hear it from another room.
Garfield: Reruns! Yesterday's news... Leftovers! There's never anything new around here! Jon: Run for your life! The plumbing backed up, and thousands of piranha are spawning in the toilet!! Garfield: Again?!
In another strip, Garfield wished for a fifty-pound pan of lasagna. It fell on him. (At which point he mused, "Now wouldn't you think I'd know better than to make a wish like that on a Monday?")
In a ''very'' early strip, Garfield is shown hanging onto the screen door simply because he's bored complaining of his boredom. He wishes for something to happen. A very mundane yet apparently painful aftermath occurs when Jon announces lunchtime.
One strip has Garfield stranded up a tree. Garfield says to it "Stupid tree...May all your stupid branches fall off!" Needless to say, all the trees branches broke off and fell to the ground. Including the one he was on.
Liō went to a wishing well and evidently wished that his crush Eva would love him back. He turned into a sword, which she loved.
SCP-738 ("The Devil's Deal"). The entity connected to SCP-738 grants wishes as part of a bargain, but it will only give exactly what it has agreed to and no more. For example, one subject who asked for "freedom" disappeared from custody, but was captured again a few hours later.
Not Always Learning has this tale, in which a class-cutting student tells the professor that all they want from the class they skipped so much is a passing grade. At the end of the semester, the student gets a C... even though they completed enough coursework to earn an A.
Even God could be harsh in granting wishes when the wishers were being too whiny. In response to the Israelites complaining about all manna and no meat, he gave them meat for a month "until it come out at your nostrils, and it be loathsome unto you" (KJV).
Ten of the twelve Israelites sent to spy out the Promised Land insisted that its people were too strong to conquer, even though they had God on their side. The people declared that it would be better to die in the desert than try to conquer the Land. God, furious, declared that they wouldn't enter the Land until every man who complained had, in fact, died in the desert. Cue 39 more years of wandering.
Jephthah in the book of Judges gets a lesson in Be Careful What You Pray For, when he prays to God, "If thou shalt without fail deliver the children of Ammon into mine hands, Then it shall be, that whatsoever cometh forth of the doors of my house to meet me, when I return in peace from the children of Ammon, shall surely be the LORD's, and I will offer it up for a burnt offering." (Judges 11:30,31) God gives him the victory, but when Jephthah comes home, the first thing that greets him at the doors was his only daughter! The jury is undecided over how Jephthah actually goes through with the sacrifice, whether he does make her a burnt offering or, as some believe, keeps her a virgin for the rest of her life, which in that culture at the time was considered a sacrifice.
And him making the oath was pretty pointless, since God had already promised him that he would win.
Continuing the story: During the time of the Judges, Israel had no king (except for God himself). The Israelites decided they didn't like this situation and wanted a human king like all the surrounding nations. So God tells them, "Alright, I'll give you your king, but you won't like him very much". What followed was a whole succession of mostly bad kings, which led to the split of Israel into two nations, followed eventually by a long period of captivity in Babylon.
One particular instance is Draupadi, the Pandavas's wife, in the Mahabharata yearning for a husband in her previous life. She wanted her husband to be as strong as Vayu, as talented as Indra, as moral as Dharma and as beautiful as the Ashwini twins. She forgot to specify that she wanted one husband. As a result, in her next incarnation, she married five men and was the wife of five husbands simultaneously.
The legend of King Midas (the first part, at least) is a good example. Upon finding the drunken satyr Silenus, a follower of Dionysus, trespassing on his property, Midas treated him hospitably for ten days rather than punishing him. Dionysus offered Midas a reward for his charity, offering him anything he wanted; Midas asked that anything he touched be turned to gold. Although the god warned him that he had made a foolish wish, he still granted it. Though Midas was happy at first, it soon became obvious that he had indeed been foolish. His daughter was quickly turned into a statue by this power, and Midas couldn't even touch food without it turning to gold. When faced with starvation, he begged Dionysus to take the gift back...
In Igor Stravinsky's The Rake's Progress, the hapless (and gormless) Tom Rakewell's troubles start with him wishing he had money, upon which a mysterious manservant appears to inform him that an estranged uncle has left him a fortune. Once Tom realises that urban decadence and high living are no substitute for the love he left behind in the countryside, he wishes he were happy, and his servant convinces him to marry a genderbending circus artist. Once the marriage falls apart, he dreams of a machine that turns stone into bread and, upon waking, wishes it were true; the servant wheels in a prototype. The machine is a complete fraud, and Tom is bankrupted. You'd think the fact that the servant gives his name as "Nick Shadow" would have rung a bell at some point...
Stephen Sondheim's Into the Woods: Everyone wishes for something at one point - in fact, the beginning prologue song comprised of mostly the lyrics "I wish, more than anything, more than life" - but it typically backfires. Cinderella wishes to go to the Festival but doesn't count on a prince chasing her around the woods. The Baker and his wife wish to have a child but don't intend to also run around the woods trying to get stuff for the Witch. This theme carries through the whole thing. Just when you think everything is resolved, someone whispers "I wish...", which kicks off the whole second half of the play.
In Shakespeare's Henry V, Henry asks three traitorous nobles what he should do with a drunk who called him a nasty name. The nobles, unaware that Henry knows of their treachery, tell him emphatically that he should show no mercy for this (minor) infraction and punish the drunk harshly. In doing so, they leave themselves no room to ask for mercy when Henry reveals his knowledge of their betrayal. He has them executed.
During "The Wizard and I" in Wicked, Elphaba sings of one day being known by everyone in Oz. Since it's a Foregone Conclusion that she's going to become the Wicked Witch, she gets exactly what she wanted.
Salem: Mary says this exactly to Mercy after recounting how she came to be George Sibley's wife.
Notorious warning given by almost all GMs in fantasy roleplaying when a player acquires a magical artifact or spell that grants them wishes. Often leads to almost comic wordings of wishes to avoid the GM taking it too literally and punishing the player. Apparently the fact that wish is 9th level (requiring the character to be at 17th level with genius-level Intelligence to be able to cast it at all) and ages the caster five years (In pre-3rd edition Dungeons & Dragons) isn't bad enough.
notably the description for the Wish spell (in 3rd ed at least) contains a standard list of things it can do and then says it may be able to do other things, but if a player makes a wish not on the standard list the DM should feel free to be a Jackass Genie and screw over the player.
You can ask an higher power to directly intervene in battle in Fate of the Norns: Ragnarok, but if the runes are not with you, they might very well appear on the battlefield and kick the crap out of your party instead of helping you.
The game has a cycle of Wish cards, the flavour text of each of which is a variant on the following: "He wished for X, but not for the Y to [Verb that means use effectively] it."
Braid of Fire is based around this. It gives you increasing amounts of mana at the start of your upkeep, and by its mana given/casting cost ratio is one of the best mana accelerants ever made. But unlike most it happened uncontrollably, and it was also made in the days of mana burn; if you couldn't find something to spend all that mana on before your mana pool emptied you'd take increasing amounts of damage, giving you a choice between hoping something turned up before it killed you and giving up so much lovely extra mana.
Warhammer 40,000: In the background fluff of the Changeling, the Dark Angels besieging the fortress of a rogue planetary Governor who'd turned to Chaos. The governor asks the daemon of Tzeentch for a way to break the siege, the daemon asks for the Governor's daughter in exchange for the favour. The Governor grimly complies and the Changeling hands him something and disappears. The governor just has time to wonder what it is before he is surrounded by the hulking blue force fields heralding teleporting Space Marine Terminators; the Changeling had stolen a teleporter homer from a nearby Ravenwing biker, which was keyed to that of the attached Deathwing Terminator Squads. The siege was indeed swiftly ended.
Chuubo's Marvelous Wish-Granting Engine has a special chart for Reality Syndrome characters, used to determine which foundations of a wish are likely to go well and which are more likely to end up failing horribly instead of entertainingly. A character who wishes for a friend because they are lonely and who has "a little lonely" on their sheet is likely to get it or something like it quite easily; wishing for your own pet shoggoth because you are lonely is...less likely to work out well, put it that way. (Incentive for the archetypal Reality Syndrome character, Chuubo, to fail horribly anyway is provided by a system wherein he gets bonus XP for making the other players Face Palm in an amused fashion.)
This is one of the main subtexts of Metal Gear Solid 2: Sons of Liberty, as the game shows exactly what the players who wanted to be Solid Snake would have to go through with Raiden.
Calypso, from the Twisted Metal games. He grants the winners of his competitions their wishes in a manner that either kills them or results in an outcome different from what they had envisioned.
A case of the former in Twisted Metal: Head-On is when the driver of Spectre, Chuckie Floop, wished for a lot of money and was then buried alive underneath a massive pile of cash. In Warthog's ending for Twisted Metal 2, Calypso delivers a sickeningly brilliant example of the latter when he grants the 105-year-old Captain Rogers's wish for a youthful body ... sans the head to match.
Occasionally, Calypso will grant a wish straight, only for the winner to experience the inevitable or natural consequences of their wish.
And for all his trickery, Calypso has indeed suffered a reversal of this (Sweet Tooth in Twisted Metal: Black).
Most of the "bad" endings in S.T.A.L.K.E.R.: Shadow of Chernobyl consist of this, with the player character succumbing to the temptation to make a wish to the mysterious artifact in the middle of Chernobyl (the wish chosen depending on certain conditions). All of these wishes end up backfiring on him:
"I want the Zone to disappear": the PC goes blind
"Mankind is corrupt, it must be controllednote In the original Russian he says destroyed": Images of war and death start flashing followed by the PC standing in a black void
"I want to be rich": the PC sees gold coins falling from the sky...which turn out to be an hallucination: the "coins" are actually bolts falling from the ceiling which collapses on the PC, killing him.
"I want to be immortal": the PC is turned into a metal statue.
In Baldur's Gate II: Throne of Bhaal you get the wish spell. It's a lot more powerful than the limited wish spell and also level 9. It's also extremely tricky to cast, as the Djinn that you summon is a grumpy so-and-so who's out to get you and as such you will need a very good Wisdom score to be able to handle him okay. A WIS of 18 is nigh-on essential to get the most out of this spell, and anything under 9 WIS is catastrophic. When you cast the spell, time is stopped and the casting character negotiates with the Djinn for some hours - finally he presents you with "a list of 5 ways I can interpret your wish - choose one".
A major concept behind the Game of Afterlife by LucasArts. This is even billed as rule #1 of the afterlife. Specifically, it's stated that souls are treated differently after death based on what they believed in while living.
Planescape: Torment utilizes a classic and particularly chilling incarnation of the trope. An NPC named Yves Tale-Chaser will trade stories with the Nameless One and his companions. One of them begins with a man who comes to in an alley, remembering nothing. An old woman is in front of him, and she asks, "And your third wish?" He says he doesn't understand, and she explains she had offered him three wishes, and he'd already used two - and the second wish was to undo and forget his first wish. So, for the third, he asks to know who he is. She cackles softly as she prepares to grant his wish, and he asks what's so funny. "That was your first wish." It's heavily implied in another part of the game that this actually occurred between the Nameless One and the Night Hag Ravel Puzzlewell.
Eternal Darkness has this happen once. Bored Cambodian temple dancer Ellia finds herself all alone with nothing but what she thinks is an innocuous book of legends to entertain herself, wishes that something exciting would happen to her, and ends up immediately getting locked inside the temple, finding herself entangled and directly involved in the book's "legends," and killed as a result of all this. Now, was that exciting enough for you, Ellia?
There's a wish-granting Mana (the main character) in Mana Khemia Alchemists Of Alrevis. The first wish it ever granted was death, although, in a subversion, that wish was exactly what the person who wished it was asking for.
The Precursors offer to turn Jak into one of them as thanks for his services. All of a sudden Count Veger arrives with a gun demanding that HE be turned into one instead. The Precursor says "Be Careful What You Wish For" and does something to Veger. Shortly afterwards it's revealed that the Energy Being they were talking to was just a hologram and that the Precursors... are ottsels. Cue Karmic Transformation when Veger realizes the implications of this.
Later, Daxter, finally in peace with his ottsel appearance, asks for a set of pants. His girlfriend then says that those pants are so cute, she wished she had a pair of them herself. Cue the precursors' "Be Careful What You Wish For" a second time, and the girl getting a pair of pants just like that... and turned into an ottsel so she could fit into them.
In NetHack, it is possible to be granted a wish. A common choice is to wish for a blessed Archon figurine, which when used has an 80% chance of netting you an extremely powerful pet. There is, however a 10% chance that it will instead be generated hostile. Have a Nice Death!
Final Fantasy Tactics Advance has a group of kids who wish they can live in the fantasy world that their video game (which is also called F Inal Fantasy) presents. Their wish is granted, though Marche isn't keen on the idea of staying in a fantasy world forever.
Persona 2: Innocent Sin puts a spin on this. You don't so much have to be careful what you wish for, as be careful about wishing at all. Having your wildest dreams handed to you without struggle or effort will eventually rob you of your ideal energy, causing you to fade away to nonexistence.
This was the case on the production level for Left 4 Dead 2. Valve is notoriously known for their Valve Time due to how long they take to produce games in order to perfect them and/or delaying games after they get close to a release date. People got sick of Valve taking too long to produce anything, so Valve made Left 4 Dead 2 nearly one year after the first game was released in order to prove to people that they CAN release on time and on a fixed schedule. While Left 4 Dead 2 was generally well received, the more dedicated fans complain to this day about random bugs and balance issues with some people stating Valve Time is actually a good thing and Valve should not be rushed.
Similarly, corner camping became a huge issue in Left 4 Dead 1; it was a technique used by survivor players where they huddle in a corner or in a closet and mow down all infected that came their way. People complained about the exploit and started to make suggestions to counter corner camping, which Valve implemented for Left 4 Dead 2 with new infected that dealt with survivors that holed up in a spot (Spitter, Charger, and Jockey), allowing common infected to rush in from more places, and included gauntlet crescendos where survivors have to keep moving through a never ending horde and stop the source (such an an alarm). This worked too well since now most survivor players will always rush the maps and hardly stop, making it difficult for zombie players to be able to spawn in time or attack effectively. Naturally, people are complaining about the changes and want even more special infected that has the ability to stop a survivor from running.
In The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim, the Daedric Prince Clavicus Vile is essentially this trope given corporeal form. The cave in which you find his shrine is populated with vampires that wished for an end to their suffering, which they presumably thought meant a cure for vampirism. He gave them a heavily armed adventurer. Vile sends you after the Rueful Axe, which he granted to a wizard who wished to end his daughter's lycanthropy.
Ragnarok allows you to make wishes if you can find the wand of wishing. However, if you don't have sufficient luck, or you wish for certain unique items you will get an evil item instead.
PAYDAY: The Heist has the Cloaker, a special SWAT unit who can instantly down players by kicking them. The sequel was supposed to have Cloakers, but they were Dummied Out due to them causing the game to crash if they kicked a player. The Cloaker was MIA for several months and everyone kept demanding for the Cloaker to return. The Cloaker eventually was brought back, still doing his instant takedown kicks. Most of the people that wanted the Cloaker now don't want him anymore.
Discussed in detail in Fate/stay night, but for the most part averted. Except for Archer. I want to save everyone! I know, how about I make a contract with the world? Guardian Spirits gets to save people all the time! Oh wait, they actually kill people en masse indiscriminately to prevent them from killing even more people. Woops. Other than that little mistake, it seems the idea is 'do what you can with your own ability, and accept your own failures if it doesn't work.
Also played straight in "Unlimited Blade Works" when Shinji obtains the Holy Grail... by having it implanted in his body, transforming him into its vessel. He recovers and is noted to have reverted to a more pleasant personality after overcoming his obsession.
One of the side stories in Kagetsu Tohya has Shiki living in a world based on Twin Threesome Fantasy fantasy scenario he had. The problem is, he realized such a thing could never happen unless they were in a world all by themselves plus he's currently already trapped inside a "Groundhog Day" Loop. So the Dream Within a Dream he has just traps him a world where he's living forever inside the mansion grounds with only Kohaku and Hisui, doing whatever he likes with them while slowly going insane.
A character playing a D&D game gets a ring of three wishes, much to the chagrin of the DM. The character immediately wishes for more gold than he knows what to do with, and his player is instantly crushed by a giant gold boulder. When the previous wish is reversed while still losing the wish, he then wishes for a million gold pieces, and receives gold pieces so small that he "might be able to afford an ale with them". When he finally gets a wish written up by a lawyer in order to avoid any exploitable loopholes, the DM relents and has no choice but to grant the wish. And then the player's character gets eaten by a dragon.
Another DM had a player who wished for an infinite gold mine. His wish was granted, and the player's character was instantly teleported into a mine of solid gold, stretching forever in all directions...
Death of Insanely Overpowered Fireballs from Irregular Webcomic! wished to get his job back after getting demoted. He got his job back, to process all the people who have died when the Irregular Universe was torn apart from Time Paradox.
when you ask to be sent back in time, specify when first.
From the very end: "Who do you want brought back?" Think carefully. "Everyone" is a lot of people... and animals...
Girl Genius has a variation: Castle Heterodyne seems to delight in creativeinterpretation of Agatha's orders. Not so much because of malice as much as because it's too Axe Crazy to imagine she might NOT want to kill everyone.
ThisSubnormality strip shows how to have everything you could ever need in life.
Parson: "I mean, then... what's the lesson supposed to be here, Wanda? 'Be careful what you wish for?' This isn't what I wished for!"
Wanda: "Hah! You didn't wish for this world, Parson Gotti. It wished for you.
Also, the "Ultimate Warlord" spell. Why did Stanley get Parson? Well, this is how he described what he wanted:
"I want him to be obsessed with war! Somebody who plans wars and kills his enemies for fun!note Parson enjoys playing table top wargames, a lot I want somebody who snacks on Gwiffonsnote Gwiffons look exactly like marshmallow Peeps. and eats Marbits for breakfast!note Parson calls marshmallow bits (like the kind you find in Lucky Charms) "Marbits= Marshmallow bits".
Roadkill: Wish One: I want all my wishes loopholed out of any negative or ironic consequences. Wish Two: Apply wish number one to itself ex post facto. Wish Three: Make me the effin' master of the Universe NOW.
Any plot in The Wotch involving Djinn will feature at least one of these types of wishes. It is explained that some Djinn do it out of spite for the human race, others do it because they've been summoned through a curse bottle that mandates their wishes backfire.
He still gets bitten a little. He wished that everything the enemy had stolen be returned to Fenwick. Not just things that had been stolen from Fenwick. And the enemy had a very long career of stealing things. There are now entire store-rooms of 'returned' loot, much of which is unidentifiable and now worthless.
Also played straight with Rahan, when he wishes he could see Quentyn's face after a prank involving pillows and tar goes off. He does—after Squidge sends the prank completely sideways.
Very old Vera Salt of Magellan found a genie and wished herself to be younger. She started to age backwards until she was a child. Then, she wished for a way to age herself and had to siphon age from others over several centuries in order to maintain a stable age. Finally, when she was in custody, she used her last wish to wish herself free and ended up dying of old age.
In Homestuck, the pre-Scratch troll players are hinted (and stated outright in one case) to have gotten exactly what they wanted for their lives in the retconned universe they created... at a tremendous cost.
Aranea wished she could be outgoing and adventurous without caring about what other people think of her. Then she helped perform the Scratch and got her wish, at least vicariously... but at the cost of her people being enslaved by a devil-figure and being driven to near-extinction; because she didn't really care about other people, she did nothing to prevent any of the suffering.
Kankri wanted to fight for social justice, and his Scratched counterpart was a Messianic Archetype... who ended up with an even more painful end than Jesus, for significantly less accomplishment.
Meenah wanted to be a horrific absolute monarch without personal responsibility regarding her society's rigid White Man's Burden (which fell on her the heaviest), and her counterpart was just such a tyrant... who was secretly forced to obey the Bigger Bad and who was so cruel a tyrant that she tortured the counterpart of one of Meenah's friends, who Meenah never wanted to harm.
Same for Kurloz, who became head of his church and likewise killed those his counterpart cared about
Porrim wanted to take care of Kankri; she did so, then watched him killed and was made a slave
Meulin wanted true love, got it, and then saw it killed in front of her
Latula wanted to bring justice and protect the innocent, and was lynched for it
Cronus wanted to be part of an interesting story and have a dramatic rival; he was killed by that rival
Mituna wanted to help his friends and was made into a living battery/engine part by one of them
Rufioh wanted to be a hero, and led a great rebellion... which failed and made things worse
In Doc Rat, Wilbur Fuzz is shaken when after all his jokes about heart attacks, he actually has one. He thinks of Crying Wolf. The paramedics — wolves — tell him that they came, and he should be careful what he wishes for.
In Ménage ŕ 3, central character Gary implicitly wishes, in the second panel of the very first strip, for a more interesting life. He gets ... to be the central character of this comic. Actually, it's not entirely a bad life, but he gets things like lots of women wanting him without ever getting a clue how to handle the consequences. Other characters in the same comic also tend to get things that they think they want, while lacking the emotional maturity to deal with them.
In The Order of the Stick Nale demands independence from his father, saying that he wants NOTHING from him, and specifically including nepotism, charity, and pity. Nale tried to overthrow his father, constantly insults him and tries to undermine his authority, and killed his best friend and valuable ally Malack. So when Tarquin stops treating him like his son, and treats him like he would anyone else who's done those things, he immediately kills him. He points out as Nale dies that he'd have been dead years ago if Tarquin hadn't been protecting him.
Invoked in an intentionally nonsensical manner in the Something Awful parody "horror film" Doom House. "My name is Reginald P. Linux, and ever since my wife died, I've been very depressed. This is why I've been searching for the house of my dreams. But as a philosopher once said, be careful what you dream for, because you just... might... get it." Since he wasn't "dreaming for" a house haunted by an odd-looking figurine and built over a terrorist burial camp, this makes no sense, and it's only put there as a parody of bad writing.
Doctor Horrible's Sing-Along Blog is this trope played deadly straight. Billy/Dr. Horrible wants to be a supervillain and join the Evil League of Evil. He also wants to get a girlfriend. Well, he gets one of his wishes when the Evil League demands that he commit a heinous crime ("a murder would be nice of course") as a membership test. This turns out to be Foreshadowing, as the final confrontation with his Arch-Enemy, Captain Hammer, ends with the latter's humiliating defeat and the world bowing to him in fear due to the murder of... his girlfriend, Penny. Cue his entry into the Evil League, having both gained and lost everything he wanted.
Krillin wished for the perfect Christmas tree. Shenron delivered. Thanks for the special, you two!
Reject Mall Santa: Turles, sir! Our ship has mysteriously changed course for a new planet: Earth! Turles: Does it contain the sufficient amount of joy? Reject Mall Santa: According to our sensors... yes! Turles: Well, then... merry Christmas!
In Lucky Day Forever, 514 finally wins the lottery in this film, but he gets locked into the Lotus-Eater Machine and gets used as resources for the Whites.
In Doom House, when Reginald informs the audience of his ambition to move into the house of his dreams in his Opening Narration, he is still quick to remember the words of a philosopher, "Be careful what you dream for because you just might get it."
In the Tales of the Folly series in the Chakona Space setting, you really should be careful what you wish for on the Folly, as there are a number of fairly mischievous, and meddlesome Rakshani Deities hanging around. The trope is lampshaded word-for-word on a couple of occasions.
This trope is the entire premise of The Fairly OddParents, and played various ways in different episodes.
A specific example: In the episode "Most Wanted Wish", Timmy wishes that he was the most wanted kid in the world. He does indeed become the most wanted kid on Earth.
The Samurai Jack universe has a well that grants any wish. Once, three men wished that they would become the ultimate warriors. And they did! By becoming the well's eternal guardians, robbed of both their sight and minds until Jack came along.
In the Reboot episode "Enzo the Smart", Enzo fiddles with the system clock in order to make himself smarter than everyone else, and instead makes everyone else half as smart as he is. Since he's Just a Kid, this ends up making everyone else in the city of Mainframe really dumb.
The wishing character was not aware that their wish would be granted, but still wound up regretting voicing the wish. Notable for the fact that at the end of the episode the Reset Button remained largely untouched. All the characters retained full memories of everything that had transpired, and a permanent change to Danny's ghost costume was made.
There was another, earlier episode with the same villain with the same premise where Tucker wished he had ghost powers. The Reset Button was pressed because Tucker did not handle them all that well...
The pilot of Transformers Animated had Optimus Prime nostalgically wishing that he'd been around to fight Decepticons in the Great War. Ten minutes later the biggest, baddest Decepticon of all time shows up with his warship. It's not pretty.
Parodied in the episode "A Dumb Wish". Grim's mom gives Billy, Mandy, and Grim three wishes. Billy squanders his wish, and his arguing with Grim bugs Mandy enough that she wishes they would shut up, causing Billy and Grim's mouths to become sealed shut. Since Grim can't talk, Mandy gets his wish, and Grim and Billy compete to see who gets their mouth fixed by buttering up to Mandy. They only succeed in driving Mandy to the point that she shouts "I wish everyone in the entire world would just go away!" After everyone else on the planet disappears, Mandy seems to regret what she did, only to instead smile for one of the only times ever and say "Perfect".
Another episode, "Wishbones," also played with this trope. A Literal Genie trapped in the form of a talking, rhyming skull named Thromnambular spends most of the episode granting various characters wishes, which inevitably backfire. (It's explicitly said that it doesn't matter what they're wishing for, it'll screw them over regardless.) Thronambular is condemned to grant nine wishes before it can be freed from its skull form, more on that later. One example of a wish (and its reworking) is General Skarr wishing to be ruler of the world. A giant statue of himself rises from the ground beneath him and grows so large, he ends up in the upper atmosphere and suffocates. When it's Mandy's turn to make a wish, she realizes that any wish she makes will only turn out badly, so instead she decides to sell her wish to the highest bidder. A frustrated Grim pushes the Reset Button when he declares "I wish you two had never found that skull!" This wish does not backfire, instead returning everything to the way it was before Billy and Mandy found the skull. Grim then wishes that he was free of his promise to be Billy and Mandy's best friend, and that Thronambular was free of his imprisonment, hoping that Thronambular would be grateful enough not to stab him in the back. To Grim's horror, Thronambular grants the wish by trading their dilemmas: Thronambular had to keep Grim's promise, but gained a body. Grim found himself trapped as a skull, and bound to carry out the eight remaining wishes.
There was one Halloween episode based on The Monkeys Paw. Homer buys the magic paw at a Bazaar of the Bizarre and he and his family try wishing for fame and wealth (which backfires when everyone gets sick of hearing about the Simpsons) world peace (which backfires when aliens attack the now defenseless Earth) and a turkey sandwich (which backfires because the turkey's a little dry; at least Homer was Genre Savvy enough by this point to specify, "I don't want any zombie turkey, I don't want to turn into a turkey when I eat it...".) Homer gives the monkey paw to Flanders in the hope that it backfires on him too, but the Rule of Funny ensures that no such thing happens.
One episode parodies "A Case of Spring Fever", a 1950s educational film which has a young man foolishly wish that zinc didn't exist (?!), which proceeded to ruin his life because he couldn't (a) drive his zinc-less car to pick up his girlfriend for a date; (b) call his girlfriend to postpone their date with his zinc-less telephone; and (c) shoot himself in despair (as even the hammer in the gun was made of zinc). The young man is quick to regret his desire for a world without zinc ("Zinc! Come back!"); fortunately, it turns out to be All Just a Dream.
"Wish World" from the Mighty Orbots series. Oh-No wishes to be human—and thanks to one of the Big Bad goons, she becomes human—but discover that Oh-No can't power up the Mighty Orbots in this form.
The episode "The Magic Coins" features this trope.
Also, in "The Prince and the Ponies", the First-Tooth Baby Ponies were jealous of the extra attention the newborns were receiving and wished them ill only to be sorry when they saw it had actually happened. An important and applicable lesson for the target audience.
The entire premise of the Celebrity ToonWish Kid. Nick gets a magical baseball glove that lets him have one wish a week - and that's it. And they're all temporary and can end at any time, meaning that every single wish he makes disappears at the worst possible time. All so he can learn this trope as a moral every single episode.
When we first meet Puck, he plays Literal Genie to Demona. Later, it's revealed that when Puck revealed himself to Xanatos for the first time, he offered him either a single wish or a lifetime of loyal service as Owen Burnett. Proving himself to be the smartest person in the entire series, Xanatos chooses the latter.
Puck ended up on the receiving end of this too. One of his major motivations throughout the series is delaying his return to Avalon because he finds the mortal world too fun. At the end of "The Gathering", Oberon decides to give Puck what he wants...by trapping him in human form (except for the purposes of training a changeling in magic or defending his ward) and banishing him from Avalon forever.
A similar thing happens in an episode of DuckTales: both Scrooge McDuck and Flintheart Glomgold find a magical lamp. To decide who gets it, the genie tells them to race each other back home. Glomgold wins, and his first wish is for Scrooge to be stranded on a desert island. However, his second wish is that he could see the look on Scrooge's face, and he's sent to the same island to do so. Then he wishes that he "had never found this blasted lamp". Cue the Reset Button, and Scrooge this time wildly chases Glomgold out of the cave without finding the lamp, just before a cave-in traps it forever.
Extreme Ghostbusters: The team fought a wish-making ghost who functioned as a Literal Genie. It turned Eduardo into Kylie's cat (because he "wanted her to treat him with the same respect she does her cat"). The episode was actually titled "Be Careful What You Wish For".
A preview episode has Ben 10 easily dispatching criminals, and, in the end, he was wondering if there was any challenge left for him. The episode in question is the Series Finale, which introduced the Negative 10.
One episode of Wunschpunsch revolved around it - Wizards created a spell that granted one wish for every person in the city, but always in the way to backfire. The wizards used it later for themselves, sure they'd found a wish that would let them get rid of their boss and not backfire at them in any way. They were wrong.
One of the lines the wizards recite while casting Wunschpunsch spells is "hear our wish and grant us a notion". See Hoist by His Own Petard for details.
Jacob and Maurizio aren't immune to the trope. In "Nice Wizards", they tampered with a spell and wished Bubonic and Tyrannia became good people. Even well-intended, the wizards' spells cause disaster.
In "Mayor for a Day", Bubonic switched bodies with the Mayor, who said he'd rather be struck by lightning. After it happened, Tyrannia quoted the trope.
The Spectacular Spider-Man: In Group Therapy, just before going to sleep, Peter remarks, "I wish I could just wake up tomorrow, with Doc and his merry morons back in jail." Oh, he gets his wish alright. But at the cost of losing himself to the symbiote, waking up exhausted, and being out of the loop for a whole day that his aunt has had a heart attack.
SpongeBob SquarePants had an episode that featured Mr. Krabs wishing for the power to be able to talk to money. It turns out that his money always wants to be spent.
In "Wishing You Well", the people who wished for stuff at the wishing well get their wish, and Mr Krabs chalks it all off as coincidence. To prove it, he wishes he was steamed with a side of butter. You can guess what happens next.
Cow and Chicken: In the episode of the same name, Chicken, fed up with Cow's motor-mouth, wishes that Cow would just shut up. Cow decides to grant his wish by never talking again. Though Chicken enjoys it at first, it ultimately backfires when Cow, due to the wish, is unable to warn him of an incoming truck, resulting in Chicken being run over by said truck. Subsequently, when Chicken is put on trial for jaywalking, Cow is unable to speak in his defense either, and the Red Guy, serving as the bailiff, misinterprets her attempts at signing that Chicken is innocent as declaring him guilty, resulting in Chicken getting fifty years in prison.
Used to a lesser extent in the episode "Chachi, the Chewing Gum Seal". Cow wishes that Chachi, a seal she made out of chewing gum, was alive so he could be her friend. When Chachi comes alive, he's always complaining. When Cow tells Chachi to stand up for himself, he brutally attacks Chicken in revenge for Chicken chewing on him. But after Cow congratulates him, Chachi yells at Cow, calling her a freak and a waste of bones and organs.
The Human CentiPad episode of South Park has Cartman demanding God to "give me a courtesy lick before I get fucked!" after Cartman loses his Human Centipede/iPad hybrid. God complies by smiting Cartman with a bolt of lightning, landing Cartman in the hospital.
The Marvelous Misadventures of Flapjack: In "Wishing Not so Well", K'nuckles wishes to be left alone and is immediately finds himself in a Stormalong that contains no other people. It doesn't work out so well for him.
In "Phineas and Ferb Get Busted", Candace busts Phineas and Ferb on building an unsafe airlift, and their mother sends them away to a reformatory school; at first, Candace is glad they are away, but it is not too long before she begins to miss them. Then when she finds out how the reformatory school is run. Candace's friend Stacy even calls her out on this:
Stacy: You finally have everything you ever wanted. Call me when you get over it!
The first two episodes of the first season seem to have a hint of this, with Twilight Sparkle at first not wanting to make new friends, only to find out later that "just when I learn how wonderful it is to have friends, I have to leave them." That is a milder case, though, as it turns out Celestia lets Twilight stay in Ponyville with her new friends anyway.
Princess Luna is this, too; she wished to exceed her sister, to be appreciated like her, and then she became Nightmare Moon as a consequence.
In "Green Isn't Your Color" the theme has been doubled! Rarity getting what she thought she wanted earlier on left her making the same mistake in the opposite direction later on.
Earlier, Rarity insists that she wants Fluttershy to become a model. As a result, Fluttershy becomes so famous that Rarity gets very jealous.
Rarity: I'M the one who should be mobbed by strangers wherever I go!
Later, Rarity explains this was her reason for standing up for Fluttershy; in her jealousy, she thought she wanted something embarrassing to happen to Fluttershy on-stage, but she felt extremely guilty when it actually did.
"Sisterhooves Social" has Rarity wanting to get away from Sweetie Belle earlier on but missing her later on.
In "The Cutie Pox", Apple Bloom uses a magical flower called "Heart's Desire" to finally get her Cutie Mark. Unfortunately, over the course of the day she gets several more cutie marks, each of which brings both a new talent and a compulsion to practice that talent endlessly, whether it's window-washing, tap-dancing, speaking French, or lion-taming.
A hint of this also shows up in "May The Best Pet Win", with Rainbow Dash insisting earlier on that she wanted a fast, agile, flying animal for a pet... and after putting the animals through competitions testing these (among other) traits she found out that the falcon met her standards the most... but by the time she found this out, she had evidently changed her mind about what she wanted in a pet after all, as she clearly wasn't happy about being told that the falcon won. Of course, she found out a loophole in her rules that allowed her to adopt a tortoise instead, in a clear contrast to what she at first wanted.
Pinkie Pie runs into this trope head-on in "Baby Cakes". She begs the Cakes for a chance to babysit their newborn twins, but ends up running herself ragged after they let her do it.
Pinkie Pie wishes in "Too Many Pinkie Pies" to have a clone to be able to have fun in two places, but then she makes more clones to have more fun, and then the clones clone themselves further, which ultimately obscures who the real Pinkie Pie is. Now the real Pinkie can't have any fun at all.
In Inspiration Manifestation, wishing for a spell that will make one's imagination come to life might cause them to want to inflict it upon the town.
In the Young Justice episode "Misplaced", Zatanna tells Artemis how she wished her Overprotective Dad would give her some space. The very next second, her father (and the rest of the adults) disappear before them. At the end of the episode, Zatara sacrifices himself so that Nabu wouldn't possess Zatanna. She may never get her father back.
Cut to Season 2; we get a confirmation...She didn't.
Garfield and Friends: In one episode, Garfield found a wishing well and wished there were no more mondays. At first, when he learned the wish became true, he was happy. A few weeks later, Garfield felt the drawbacks of a world without Mondays: the streets were full of garbage because garbagemen only came at Mondays; gyms that used to be open for all days of the week were closed; movie theaters never showed new movies because they only changed their movies at Mondays; Jon couldn't buy more food because he always received his paychecks at Mondays; and he always made lasagna at Mondays. Being a Big Eater, the two last bits were what horrified Garfield the most. He then returned to the wishing well, desperately asking for the Mondays to be back. The well refused and threatened to remove other stuff, until the well's mother, who revealed they were actually aliens who look like wells, forced him to restore everything back to normal. Garfield then started loving Mondays. At least until he was reminded of why he hated them in the first place.
In another episode Garfield gets a fairy godfather who grants him three wishes. The first wish is for lasagna, which the godfather steals from a nearby chef. The chef immediately suspects Garfield and takes it back. Then Garfield wishes for money to buy lasagna with. The godfather zaps in money from a bank and Garfield is promptly thrown in jail.
In the season 5 premiere of Adventure Time, Finn and Jake chase the Lich into a mysterious room in an alternate dimension where a creature named Prismo offers to grant each of them a wish. Finn tries to wish that the Lich never existed, and ends up in an Alternate Universe where Simon Petrokov/The Ice King sacrificed himself to prevent the Mushroom War, but wound up freezing the world for 400 years after getting slowly crushed to death by a frozen bomb. Finn ends up putting on the Ice Crown himself in an effort to save his family from a gang, and proceeds to go mad with power and accidentally set off the bomb. When Jake tries to make a wish to fix things, Prismo even gives him a brief speech warning him about this trope, as Prismo can't control the outcome of the wishes and the vaguer they are the more likely it is the wish will go wrong.
An earlier episode had them find a being in the center of a maze who granted wishes, but had this trope in mind in granting them. Finn ultimately outwits it by actually being careful about what he wished for and wishing for an Ancient Psychic Tandem War Elephant and then having it wish for everyone to be healed.
In contrast, in "Wishful Thinking" the big desaster for the penguins is caused by the fact that any idiot (read: Zookeeper Alice) gets his wishes granted. (Still counts because a few of the wishes in the episode backfire or don't come out as expected.)
In the Family Guy Episode "Family Guy Viewer Mail No. 1", Peter finds a genie, who will grant him three wishes. His first two wishes (to see what Kelly Ripa was like off the set, and that he had his own theme music) go fine. But when he's on a bus, a man threatens to break every bone in his body. Peter hastily wishes that he had no bones. The wish is granted, but the trope kicks in when he realizes how hard it is on his family with him as a boneless blob.
Sofia the First: King Roland's wish for a baker's life in "The Baker King". To a lesser extent in that same episode, Amber wanting the cake to have one hundred layers.
The American Dad! episode "One Little Word" has Francine vehement Stan say "no" to his boss, Director Bullock's increasingly ludicrous demands so they can have a couples vacation. After Stan takes increasingly elaborate methods to please both parties, the convoluted outcome leaves Bullock dying from a gunshot wound. This is the point Stan finally has enough and says no, and walks off to spend time with Francine, much to her horror.
An episode of Rick And Morty featured a mysterious store owned by a strange man that gave away magical items that seemed to solve the user's problems, with the "price" being that they always featured an ironic twist (for example, a cologne that makes you irresistible to women while also making you impotent). Rick not only guesses that the owner is the Devil mere seconds after meeting him, but manages to create a device that instantly detects the curses of the items and later starts a neighboring business that removes the curses solely to spite the Devil.
In one episode of the ongoing Aladdin series, Jasmine tried to prove to Aladdin that she could survive the way he did originally by dressing up as a "street rat" (much the way she did at the beginning of the first movie) and going to the bad part of town. (Dragging Iago with her this time.) She managed to steal something - a mirror, which she had no idea was able to grant wishes. After getting away with it, she looked at it and declared herself a "street rat", while Iago sarcastically said, "If you're a street rat, I'm a frilled lizard!" at which point the mirror's magic turned them into arealrat and frilled lizard. (Worse, the mirror itself shattered because she dropped it when it happened, making it unusable as a solution to the problem, and worse yet, humans couldn't understand what they were saying anymore, making them entirely on their own.) The whole rest of the episode consisted of the two of them trying to make it back to the palace without getting stepped on or otherwise killed so they could get Genie to break the spell, which was not easy.
In "Terry's Friend Dates a Robot", Terry's friend Howard asks for a sythoid girlfriend who is "totally devoted" to him. She turns out to be dangerouslypossessive, and uses her enhanced strength to attack people she perceives as threatening him or getting between him and her.
Everyone has had experiences like this in his life. Usually your expectations have been too high, idealized, romanticized or unrealistic in general. This can be disappointing, but the important thing is that you have learned something about it.
You desperately want to visit or move to a certain place and when you finally arrive there you start to feel homesick.
You crave a certain toy, gadget or product and after you bought it you grow tired of it in five minutes. Or it turns out to have too many functions you don't need or is less durable than you thought it would be.
You are in love with somebody and want him/her to be your partner. Then, when you finally get to know each other better or are in a relationship it turns out you're no match for each other.
You work hard to accomplish something, but when you achieve it you feel as if you have nothing else to achieve anymore.
You want a job with more responsibility, power or a higher paycheck, but it creates more stress than you can handle.
You want to be more famous and succesful so that people will like you. When this happens you wonder whether people actually like you for who you are, or just because you're a succesful celebrity?
You want something, but only fixate yourself on the plus sides. When you finally achieve your goal it turns out there are several downsides you didn't foresee.
You want to build a complete collection, but after you have completed it you finally wonder what on Earth you are going to do with all these things, many of which you've only used once, cost you a lot of money and now simply take up space in your house?
You always wanted to rewatch, relisten or reread a TV show, film, radio show or book you remember from your childhood and haven't checked out ever since. When you finally have to the chance to check it out again you quickly notice that your nostalgia and memories have made it far more memorable than it actually is. And now all your fond memories are a bit destroyed because you realize the story hasn't aged well or was never that great to begin with.
The Open-Source Wish Project tries to find perfect, loophole-less wordings for wishes to avert this trope. While it might work against the Jackass Genie, it doesn't really strike at the heart of the lesson of this trope; if you get exactly the thing you wanted, there's still the possibility you'll find you don't like it.
In 2001, the city of Buffalo, NY had no snow in November and most of December, and it was possible that the city would have no snow on Christmas. So on Christmas Eve, everyone in Buffalo wished for a white Christmas. The next day, they awoke to the beginning of a 5-day blizzard that killed 4 people and dropped seven feet of snow onto the city. Whoops.
During the years 2005-2006 many people in USA and UK desperately wished for real estate prices to fall. They did fall in 2007 - resulting the current (2008 - onwards) financial crisis.
To be fair, the actual cause of this was the inflation of the real estate market - the economy was already bad, but the housing boom made it seem otherwise. When it was realized that the emperor had no clothes, it was over.
Richard Heene's attempt to become a reality star with his Balloon Boy stunt on October 15, 2009. Looks like he succeeded, just not in the way he had hoped for.
After viewing his teammate going past him for the win as an act of betrayal, Gilles Villeneuve vowed never to speak to Didier Pironi ever again. He got it: Villeneuve was killed in qualifying the very next race.
As it was entering its third season, the producers of Moral Orel asked the creators to give them the darkest season they could. And boy did they get it. One episode in particular, the infamous "Alone" was so dark, the producers sliced season three's original episode count in half, and axed the show.
Chicago Bears fans wished to be rid of Rex Grossman for throwing too many interceptions (despite leading them to the Super Bowl in his first season as a starter). Then came along Jay Cutler, who led the NFL in interceptions.
Fanboys of Nintendo wanted the company to reign supreme in the Console Wars after taking a beating from Sony for two generations in a row. The Wii comes along and puts Nintendo back on top, but at the expense of the hardcore fans as Nintendo marketed the majority of its gaming to the casuals. Cue nerd rage.
Then along comes the Wii U, essentially a high-powered Wii with state-of-the-art HD graphics and an innovative tablet controller with its own touchscreen. Did "hardcore" gamers sing Nintendo's praises and come flocking back toward the company? Of course not, despite how much said hardcore gamers demanded to have an HD version of the Wii.
There is the most common consequence of a phenomenon known as "Punishment voting", when people vote in masse for the ideological opposite of whoever is in power now, just to get that person out of office and have a different face and political party, only for the candidate to become the opposite of what the voters (and, sometimes, the candiate sponsors) wanted. If you combine that with Nostalgia Filter, the results can be awful...
When Lena, a young German girl, moved out from her parents' house at 18 (this was in 2007), they were not happy about it and had repeatedly tried to convince her to come back. Then Lena got caught in the 2010 Love Parade Disaster. Since then, she returned to her parent's house - and she refuses to leave and constantly clings to her parents.
Many lottery winners encounter this, due to not being used to handling such large amounts of money. It's estimated 60% of them wind up bankrupt within a year. See A Fool and His New Money Are Soon Parted.
The temperance movement in America got its wish with the Prohibition in the early 1920s. But while it did significantly reduce the rate of alcohol-related diseases and injuries, it also forced an industry into the hands of the Black Market, encouraged illicit alcohol production and drinking in speakeasy parlours, and led to a difficult-to-enforce ban that underpaid and corrupt police officers struggled to uphold. Prohibition was repealed in 1933, but the problems never quite disappeared: Prohibition transformed the American alcoholic beverages industry from one that made traditional drinks from across Europe and a number of homegrown ones as well to purveyors of swill only good for getting drunk, and it would be decades before American beer and winenote Spirits weren't affected quite as badly, as the primary liquor—American whiskey—has a very slow production process, so there was more continuity. would reach a reasonable level of quality.
Related: Almost anything to do with the Jedi in Star Wars: Galaxies. Sure people would have been fine if they didn't exist... but they were proven to be true, and sure enough everyone wanted to be a Jedi. The process was verylabyrinthine, and the players whined non-stop about how it was too cryptic and nobody would ever be a jedi apart from maybe .001% of the playerbase (Who complained about it every step of the way.) When things became much easier (ie, they actually told you what profession(s) to go for), what did everyone complain about now? That everyone was a jedi.
Lyndon Johnson was actually rather peeved when he got the Democratic nomination for vice president in 1960—you see, he wanted the top job, not the post that his predecessor and fellow Texan John Nance Garner had described as "not worth a pitcher of warm piss." Then John F. Kennedy got shot, and LBJ became one of the most unpopular presidents in US history.
That's a little harsh on LBJ. He was a very effective leader, though his legacy is mixed. He was re-elected in one of the biggest landslides in history, but chose not to run in 1968 because the election looked unwinnable. Current historians generally give him better than average rankings.
"If the Germans want a war of extermination, then they will get one." - Josef Stalin, in a speech in November 1941.
"Better Hitler than Blum!" - Slogan of the French ultra-conservatives. Sometimes fate can be a Literal Genie.
"It is humiliating to remain with our hands folded while others write history. It matters little who wins. To make a people great it is necessary to send them to battle even if you have to kick them in the pants. That is what I shall do." - Benito Mussolini, April 11 1940, before having Italy enter World War II without being anywhere near ready for it.
Italy was a repeated offender. Before World War I, the government wished for a number of Austro-Hungarian territories mostly populated by Italians and a war to close their cold war with Austria-Hungary once for all, so at the start of the war they remained neutral for a year and then entered the war on the other side... Without being ready for it and ignoring the army's commander-in-chief pointing this out.
Another World War I example: before the war started, a) nationalism was becoming a rising thing, and b) people were getting bored with the peace, leading to c) young men wishing a war would start to give them a chance to "participate in its glories", "prove their patriotism", and "be heroes". When the war started, people actually started celebrating. In a few months, those naďve young men had turned into Shell-Shocked Veterans after learning that War Is Hell, and civilians in every country were praying that the war would end. But hey, at least it wasn't boring, right?
For that matter, we can add It's Popular, Now It Sucks to this - a lot of people wish for certain franchises and the like to be more popular. Then all of a sudden, half their fans turn their backs on it when it does become popular.
Particularly common after the end of longstanding governments, as the people who know how to run the country after the revolution will still be those who learned it under the previous regime, so specific measures have to be taken to prevent this (often at the expense of experience and ability).
Specific for Live-Action Television, many shows that were Un-Cancelled or with a Post Script Season suffer from this. By the time the continuation is greenlit, many actors and authors have moved on, and the remaining cast often cannot compensate, meaning that the show now sucks. Cue disappointment from all those who fought so hard for continuation.
Wall Street got its wish when Elizabeth Warren was blocked from taking the top spot at her brainchild the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau. After the notoriously outspoken consumer advocate wasn't even nominated - because the President knew he could never get her confirmed in the Senate - Warren went back to Massachusetts and launched her campaign against incumbent Senator Scott Brown. She won the election by an eight-point landslide, Wall Street lost its favorite Senator, and Senator Elizabeth Warren, who has no intention of stopping her crusade any time soon, is now not only part of the very body that wanted to send her back to her ivory tower, but (thanks to John Kerry's promotion) Massachussetts's senior Senator and a member of the Senate Banking Committee — which is where Wall Street absolutely did not want her. Oooops! And then the awesome continued to just keep coming; most notably, the presiding officer of the Senate holding the gavel when Richard Cordray was finally confirmed as head of the CFPB was none other than Senator Elizabeth Warren. Holy cow.
Scott Brown's own election was an example of this. In 2004, the heavily Democratic state legislature was concerned that if then-Senator John Kerry became President, then-Governor Mitt Romney, a Republican, would choose his successor and Massachusetts would have a Republican senator until at least the next regular election. So, they passed a law requiring a special election in case of a Senate vacancy. Kerry lost the election and remained in the Senate, and the next vacancy was when Ted Kennedy passed away in 2009. By then, Massachusetts had a Democratic governor who appointed a Democrat to succeed him- until the special election the Democrats had put in place back in 2004, which Scott Brown won.
Chrysler wanted to discontinue the minivans (Dodge Caravan, Chrysler Grand Voyager, Chrysler Town & Country). They almost did...
This could apply to any kids who wish to get out of school by being sick. Most don't get their wish, but the ones who do, realize that getting out of school by being sick requires that you, well, be sick, as in "feeling horrible enough that you spend your days off in bed and it becomes utterly boring." Not to mention all the schoolwork you have to make up.
Same thing for going to work. Some people make up any excuse they can to skip work, only to suffer from the excuse they used to get out of it (getting sick, family member fell down the stairs, etc.).
Engineer Henry Winstanley achieved what was thought to be the impossible when he successfully built a lighthouse on the the notorious Eddystone rocks. He was so pleased with it that he often expressed a wish to be inside it during "the greatest storm there ever was". On 27 November 1703, his wish came true, as he was overseeing repairs when the Great Storm of 1703 struck the south coast of England. The lighthouse was completely destroyed and Winstanley was never seen again.
In March of 2014, Steve Colbert did a segment on his show making an Asian joke. Many Asians and other people found the joke offensive and racist. This resulted in a twitter campaign called #CancelColbert, run by a well known Asian American activist named Suey Parks. After three weeks of the boycott, it was revealed in early April 2014 that Colbert is leaving Comedy Central, to be the replacement host for The Late Show, taking over for the retiring David Letterman. In short, Steve Colbert's career actually improved not worsened after the controversy, but the Colbert show on the Comedy Central cable channel will end after Letterman makes his final appearance.