"He's willing to be second best, the perfect lodger, the perfect guest..."
Some people always win
, some people always lose
, and these people... end up second place.
They're usually competent, skilled, or (if it is romance
we are talking about) relatively inoffensive at least. But they never quite
succeed. There's usually some character (usually, but not always, the protagonist) who beats them. If it wasn't for That One Person they'd be number one, but they aren't.
So they're number two, making them prime material for Rival Turned Evil
. If a Sibling Rivalry
is involved being always second best often comes part and parcel with being the Unfavorite
Compare Can't Catch Up
. The Worf Barrage
. Romantic Runner-Up
is a version of this character specific to romance stories. Poor Man's Substitute
is the version where a character acts as a poor replacement. When it's more perceived than actual, it's Always Someone Better
. Often related to Second Place Is for Losers
and The B Grade
open/close all folders
- Flintheart Glomgold's main grievance with Scrooge McDuck is that Scrooge is the Richest Duck in the World, Flintheart the Second Richest Duck— a designation that he feels to be humiliating. Much of the humor in his first two appearances is that the characters have similar skill-sets and about equal fortunes. Scrooge gains the victory in their first story by having some more string than Flintheart, and wins the rematch by a rather small sum of coins. The problem is that they are both too competitive to accept anyone as an equal.
- Batgirl 2009 is Stephanie Brown, aka Spoiler, aka girl Robin, aka girl who screws up every major plan. Her predecessor, Cassandra Cain, was a much better fighter, with a far better track record and a cooler tragic backstory note . Key to this relationship, however, was that Stephanie showed no bitterness towards Cassandra for all of this — they were, in fact, good friends —and accepting it in good humour, attempting now and then to do the best with what she had rather than seethe about being in second place. This was also partly because there was one key area that Stephanie could trump Cassandra — social skills (Cassandra having such a maladjusted upbringing that she could barely read, write or speak coherently until her teenage years).
- Jason Todd, the second Robin feels this way towards Dick Grayson, the first Robin and current Nightwing. It really doesn't help that Bruce expected him to be exactly like Dick, and that, as a family, Dick is by far Bruce's preferred son. Arguably second most preferred son after Damian's introduction, although it's debatable, and either way, Dick is the one who will inherit the title of Batman.
- Doctor Doom's boiling hatred of Reed Richards stems from the fact that Reed is the smartest man in the world — just the tiniest bit smarter than Doom is. He also came up second to Doctor Strange in a contest between the world's mages; though Doom being Doom, he managed to suppress his pride long enough to work the situation to his advantage.
Live Action TV
- In Star Trek: Deep Space Nine, Dr. Julian Bashir graduated second in his class from Star Fleet Medical. For a while he seemed to have a bit of a complex about this, until it was decided that he did it on purpose so as not to draw too much attention to himself.
- Amanda Kimmel and Russell Hantz both made it to the final Tribal Council on Survivor twice in a row. And both lost twice. In a row.
- The Brady Bunch: Marcia Marcia Marcia!!!
- The writers of Merlin have set up an interesting dynamic between Arthur and Lancelot that seems to be based on this trope in which both of them are always second best to the other. Where Arthur is arrogant, Lancelot is humble, yet he has been the only male character thus far that has ever been able to best Arthur in combat. However, he declines membership into Arthur's knights as he considers himself unworthy. Later, on noticing that Arthur clearly has feelings for Guinevere, Lancelot bows out of the Love Triangle without a fight so as not to get in the way of Arthur's intentions - even though he obviously had the more advantageous suit. Lancelot is only second best to Arthur because he chooses to be - and Arthur knows it.
- Conversely, Lancelot adores Merlin and Guinevere to the point of worship. He has stepped into the void for their sakes. However, their lives revolve completely around Arthur, and he's all they ever seem to talk about in Lancelot's presence.
- Part of the Sibling Rivalry between Niles and Frasier Crane stems from the fact that they both consider themselves this trope. Whether it be the success of their personal lives (for much of the show's run, Frasier was twice-divorced and once left at the altar, while Niles was mired in a miserable, abusive marriage), the prestige of their professions (Frasier had fame from his radio show, while Niles's private practice was more dignified and lucrative), their parents' love (they both took after their dead mother, and barely resemble their father at all), or anything else under the sun, a staple of their dynamic was to declare they were better than the other, rub the other's face in it, and then privately worry that the other was better than them.
- Friends: Played with between Chandler and Richard. Chandler feels like he's second best to Richard, who is the mature, sophisticated man he always wanted to be and the love of Monica's life. In fact Richard is second best to Chandler, as when faced with a choice between the two, Monica picks Chandler (with all his immaturity and quirks) over the seemingly perfect Richard and repeatedly reassures him he is the love of her life.
- Prior to this Chandler was also second best to Joey whenever they tried to pick up girls. Though again subverted when Joey's serious girlfriend falls for Chandler instead. (Though he still worries he's second best in bed, so much of his belief he's second best comes from his own rampant insecurities).
- There was a commercial in which the main character was a man who had a history of being second-best at everything he'd ever done, and had developed something of a complex about that fact. However, the fact that he has managed to get second place at everything should mean he's still ridiculously talented in a wide range of skills.
- Allison Harvard reached the final Runway of America's Next Top Model in Cycle 12 and 17. She finished 2nd both times.
- Saturday Night Live once did a commercial parody for "The People's Second Choice Awards". Hosted by Ed McMahon, celebrity presenters included Oates, Tom Wopat (referred to as "the dark haired guy from The Dukes of Hazzard"), etc.
- The Vampire Diaries: Damon Salvatore fits this trope.
- After the events of 4x20, Katherine Pierce may qualify in regards to Elijah. She finally admits she loves him and wants to be with him, and he chooses his brother over her. For the third or fourth time. This has also happened to her various times throughout her life.
- In Noob, this is explictly the situation of Amaras in regards to Fantöm until it turns out that Fantöm had been unknowingly getting an illegal boost from the game creators and the creators delete Fantöm's avatar in an attmept to cover their tracks and make Fantöm's player the scapegoat. This automatically made Amaras number one.
- "Beautiful Loser" by Bob Seger (see the page quote) sums up someone who fits this trope nicely.
- Small Faces were considered this to The Who, who were themselves considered this to The Beatles.
- Any musical act that has had several songs go to #2 but has never had a #1. In the United States, Creedence Clearwater Revival are the kings of this trope, reaching #2 five times without ever hitting the top spot
- Dave Mustaine's band Megadeth have always been behind his former band Metallica in terms of popularity. He has long been frustrated about this situation (as heard in the documentary Some Kind Of Monster), despite being extremely successful himself, just out of sheer rivalry.
- In their documentary, Fearless Vampire Killer's Laurence Beveridge admits to feeling this about Kier Kemp. Both sing and play rhythm guitar for the band and were best friends since they were 9. Laurence feels that Kier is a better singer than himself and that people notice Kier more than himself.
- Conversely, Kier Kemp also feels this to a lesser extent about Laurence. He says that he feels inferior to Laurence based on his ability to perform and get a crowd going.
- Boy bands One Direction and The Wanted were considered equals...until the former soared to international superstardom while the latter got completely flattened by their rivals.
- Paul Simon has complained from time to time about people viewing him as this in comparison to Bob Dylan.
- In Tales of Legendia, Shirley is always getting overlooked by her big sister Stella, as well as both sisters' mutual love interest, Senel. Senel continues to choose Stella over Shirley even after Stella dies partway through the game.
- Juan Corrida to Matt Engarde in Phoenix Wright: Ace Attorney: Justice for All. Even in Jerkassery.
- Yellow, the professional StarCraft gamer, was titled king of second place for always getting oh so close to the gold, but never EVER winning a major title. Another gamer, Stork, had inherited his title until finally getting a gold in a relatively recent finals.
- Further, in Starcraft 2, Marine King Prime has been in more GSL finals than anyone else (3 out of 5 so far) and has come in 2nd every time.
- Dex from Mega Man Battle Network, he even has to lie to his little brother Chisao to hide this fact.
- The Rivals from the Pokémon games, especially Blue and Silver. They're all highly skilled trainers who manage to beat all eight Gym Leaders (and, in Blue's case, the Elite Four) yet always manage to lose to the player. The first two generations tied this into An Aesop about The Power of Love, but in the third and fourth generations, you're just better than them.
- Aperture Science to Black Mesa. In Portal 2, you come across several second-place trophies in the 1950s Aperture Science area; it is implied they lost every time to Black Mesa. This is after they've been shown to go out of their way to engage in everything they do in the most ridiculous, inefficient, dangerous, and/or pointless manner possible, so what they succeed at must be rather phenomenal. On the other hand, there is a branch in which Aperture managed to trump Black Mesa: Potato Sciences.
- Luigi in the Super Mario series, every version, has had to feel this his entire life. Every time he wants to do something, Mario beats him to it or outperforms him when the brothers are both present. This has since become a defining character trait for Luigi from Luigi's Mansion and onward, with him nearly snapping in Mario & Luigi: Partners in Time.
- Subverted in Touhou: Marisa's pretty proud of being second only to Reimu, since it means she's still skilled enough to take on everybody else, even without any special powers of her own.
- Riki from Little Busters! sees himself as this - not as strong as Masato, as strong-willed as Kengo, or as generally perfect as Kyousuke, or anything really all that special in general. It actually doesn't bother him, though, and he's content to just follow after his friends for his whole life.
- Also, Haruka is this for her twin sister, Kanata. Their parents enforced a heavy competition between them as to which would be the heir and which the unnecessary child, and in almost everything Kanata would win. She takes it much worse than Riki, though.
- In Class Trip Crush, twins Taketo and Yasuto Kanzaki manage to be mutually Always Second Best to one another. Taketo is good at everything he puts his hand to, where Yasuto is rather clumsy outside of baseball and quite conscious of that fact; Taketo, however, describes Yasuto as a "genius" and observes that no one can possibly match him at the one thing he's devoted all of his effort to. The feeling that he couldn't measure up to his brother led Taketo to switch from the baseball team to soccer team to avoid competing with Yasuto, and his route shows that he has something of a complex about it.
- In Batman Arkham Series, The Riddler is this to Batman. His attempts to prove himself the intellectual superior through his riddles and deathtraps only serve to disprove this notion when Batman constantly defeats him. In fact during one of his Death Trap scenarios when Edward attempts to cheat, in order to "outwit" the Dark Knight, it fails because Batman is also better at cheating.
- David Robinson was this to Hakeem Olajuwon.
- Kevin Durant to LeBron James.
- The Utah Jazz, Miami Heat, New York Knicks, Orlando Magic, Indiana Pacers, Portland Trail Blazers, Phoenix Suns, Seattle SuperSonics and Los Angeles Lakers all were this to Michael Jordan's Chicago Bulls.
- Jordan, himself, had his own personal Second Best in the form of Clyde Drexler, who was known in his prime as "the best player in the NBA not named 'Jordan.'"
- The Los Angeles Lakers used to be this, losing to the Boston Celtics six times in The Sixties. Los Angeles has won 11 titles since, Boston 6.
- The Dallas Cowboys in the late 1960s fit this trope, believe it or not. They couldn't quite win the NFL championship, resulting in several infamous defeats:
- The 1967 Ice Bowl to Vince Lombardi's Green Bay Packers.
- The 1971 Super Bowl V loss to the then-Baltimore Colts, decided by a controversial call on the "double-touch" rule that has since been changed. It was also the only time the Super Bowl MVP was selected from the losing team.
- There was even a book written at the time, sarcastically titled Next Year's Champions. They finally broke the jinx with a 24-3 victory over Don Shula's Miami Dolphins in Super Bowl VI.
- Susan Lucci, long time Soap Opera actress, was notorious for being nominated, but not winning, the daytime Emmy for "Outstanding Actress in a Daytime Drama Series". It was only after 19 nominations over 21 years that she finally won, in 1999. Perhaps not a perfect fit to the trope, but worth mentioning.
- The ancient Greek philosopher Eratosthenes was nicknamed "Beta" by one of his contemporaries, because he was supposedly "the second-best in the world at everything". This means this trope is one of the oldest ones in the book. Carl Sagan said in Cosmos, however, that Eratosthenes was clearly Alpha at many things, since among other achievements he was the first to scientifically and correctly measure the circumference of the Earth. Using nothing but sticks, shadows, and a bit of mathematics.
- The Buffalo Bills lost 4 Super Bowls in a row, to three different teams, making them by definition the second-best team in the NFL, 1991-1994.
- This trope is Tim Henman to a tee, it is.
- Though as far as tennis is concerned, Rafael Nadal holds the dubious record of "Most Weeks Ranked No. 2" and while it would be immensely unfair to label him as anything less than an amazing player who's rightly known as the "King of Clay", the fact remains that he spent the first three years of his career struggling to get out of Roger Federer's shadow and that when it looked like he had finally succeeded and had a real chance of surpassing Federer's Grand Slam record, some guy named Novak Djokovic who had never given him any trouble before suddenly exploded onto the world stage and defeated him in seven straight finals, three of them Grand Slams. Nadal did finally beat him on clay at the 2012 French Open but still, that's gotta hurt.
- Julien Benneteau, while hardly the second-best player on tour, still qualifies for this trope because in spite of having a career-high ranking of No. 26 and beating Roger Federer twice, he's finished as the runner-up in all of his tournament finals (8 of them) and consequently doesn't have a single individual title to his name.
- There's a reason why figure skater Sasha Cohen is called "The Silver Belle". Very rarely has she won a competition; she almost always makes one mistake and comes in second... usually to Michelle Kwan.
- A dreaded moniker in golf circles is "best player never to win a major." Phil Mickelson was stuck with this moniker until he won the Masters in 2004. The current holder of the moniker is probably Lee Westwood.
- Raymond Poulidor, a French cyclist known for always ranking second (or close to second) in the races he participated in, to the point that his name became a French expression: "X is the Poulidor of this game," meaning X always comes second.
- This has been a commonly zig-zagging trend in Country Music. From 1984 to 1991, The Judds were so commercially successful that no other duo had a chance at getting any of the industry's Duo awards — for most of those years, the closest anyone ever came to their success was the Bellamy Brothers, who had constant showing on the charts but comparatively poor album sales. The Bellamys went indie in 1991, the same year that Brooks & Dunn debuted. From then until the late 2000s, it was a Foregone Conclusion that Brooks & Dunn would get the awards (except for a fluke year in 1999, where it somehow went to Montgomery Gentry although they were brand new at the time); their commercial success was near-untouchable, and many duos got lost in the Follow the Leader stampede of singer-songwriter duos. Come the late 2000s, the tide turned highly in favor of Sugarland; Montgomery Gentry appeared to be warming up considerably in 2008-2009, but only one year later their star power fell considerably. And then Sugarland went on a long hiatus, allowing Thompson Square to sneak in… only for them to get trumped by Florida Georgia Line.
- The Dutch football team is often regarded as the best team to have never won The World Cup, with three lost finals under their belt. Their most recent one defeated was to the other team that was until then regarded as the best to have never won a Cup, Spain.
- Amusingly, the biggest winner of the World Cup, Brazil, is this in the Olympic Games, where their best result were three silver medals. The women's team even more (two silver Olympic medals and one lost final in the Women's World Cup).
- Speaking of Italian football, Naples is an interesting case. While during The Eighties they outright dominated the championship — thanks to one man named Diego Armando Maradona — and had legendary team AC Milan as this to them, in the current decade they always ended up second (well, also third as of the last championship, but it was a quite small gap). The one team who always bested them recently? Juventus FC, from Turin.
- German Football club Bayer Leverkusen deserves special mention as they are not just the only big-name, long-running club in the league never to win the championship, but in the 2002 season actually managed to come second in all three competitions they were in: National Championship, National Cup, AND the Champions League.
- It gets worse; five Bayer players went with the German Football Team to the World Cup in Japan and South Korea and... Germany would lose in the final.
- It gets even worse; the best of them, Michael Ballack, never won any international title despite taking part in another Champions League final with Chelsea and reaching the final with the German team in the 2008 European championship. He won quite a number of national titles (none with Leverkusen) though.
- The England Cricket team has been to three World Cup Finals in 1979, 1987 and 1992 and has lost all three Finals. The 1992 one especially stings because they had the best team by far in that year in the final against a mercurial, injury-plagued and slow-starting Pakistan team that 1) only qualified for the semifinals after a very unlikely series of results from other teams and 2) had been demolished by England in the group match. Guess who was holding up the trophy at the end of the night?
- Goran Ivanisevic was this in Wimbledon until 2001.
- Megadeth at the Grammys. Over a span of 22 years, they have been nominated eleven times... and lost every single time. As if that weren't enough, there is only one category for metal, so they only have one chance per year.
- It only gets worse when Dave Mustaine (guitarist/founder of Megadeth)'s former band Metallica has won seven times, mostly on albums/songs that are subpar in comparison to the bands previous works.
- Andy Schleck seems to become this in Tour de France. Second in 2009, 2010 (to Contador) and 2011 (to Evans). Tour de France 2011 even had a perfect route for Andy Schleck, with four mountain finishes, only one individual time trial, a team time trial. Contador was tired after a hard Giro d'Italia, had a minor injury and a weak team. Andy still couldn't win. Joop Zoetemelk and Jan Ullrich also have quite a lot of second places (6 and 5), but also have one win each (1980 and 1997). Ullrich also lost TDF 2003 on good sportsmanship.
- Then again, Andy Schleck has been named the official winner of TDF 10, after Contador got a doping penalty for clenbuterol use. It only took 18 months to reach a verdict.
- One of the fastest Thoroughbred racehorses ever was Sham, a colt whose three-year-old racing season occurred in 1973. Sham had perhaps the fourth best time ever in the Kentucky Derby, but didn't win the Derby or either of the other two Triple Crown races — because unfortunately, he had the bad luck to be racing in the same year as another, slightly more notable Thoroughbred by the name of Secretariat.
- Affirmed won the Triple Crown in 1978. Alydar finished second in all three races.
- Juan Manuel Marquez had long been this to fellow boxer Manny Pacquiao. After three competitive fights and while both were considered among the top ten best pound-for-pound, Pacquiao went on to be rated #1 pound for pound, dominate multiple higher weight divisions, make considerably more money through endorsements and the like, and become the biggest global boxing star in the world. Not to mention getting two highly disputed wins in the trilogy itself. Even in the pre-fight buildups before later matches Juan was largely talked of as if he were a tuneup to a potential record-shattering superfight between Manny Pacquiao and Floyd Mayweather. Then the fourth fight happened. So... subverted?
- Chilean football team Universidad Católica ranks third in overall championships won (behind Colo-colo and Universidad de Chile), but holds a pretty-much insurmountable record of finishing up in second place, especially in recent years. The team has become the butt of ill-willed jokes for their "lackluster results", even though their campaigns are consistently very good if not outright impressive... only to lose to an even better team. Every time.
- Truth in Television when it comes to tag teams in Professional Wrestling. It's quite rare when a team has both members have equal success.
- Jimmy White was a runner-up in the World Snooker Championship six times; he never won. He also never got better than the second place in the snooker world ranking.
- Mark Messier. Outstanding hockey player and team leader. Played on the same team as Wayne Gretzky in his prime, so you know how that worked out. Then they went their separate ways on other teams and Messier became recognized enough in his own right to have his jersey number retired by both the teams he starred on, one of only six players in NHL history to have their number retired by two teams. Of course, one of the other five was Wayne Greztky who had his number retired by two teams...as well as the entire league.
- After the Battle of Salamis, the Greek commanders voted on who did the most for the victory. Everyone put himself first. The winner, of course, was Themistocles, since everyone put him second.
- In South Korea, professional StarCraft player Hong Jin-Ho earned the nickname "King of Silver" after he managed to come in 2nd place in 6 different major tournaments but never won one.
- Notre Dame has lost 3 of the last 4 NCAA Division I Womens' basketball championship games. They did win one back in 2001, though.