Big things are happening on TV Tropes! New admins, new designs, fewer ads, mobile versions, beta testing opportunities, thematic discovery engine, fun trope tools and toys, and much more - Learn how to help here and discuss here.
Expect him to have at least one bizarre traitor ability that should not be overlooked, as well as a completely unhealthy attitude about love, life, and humanity in general. He most likely doesn't have anyone that loves or respects him for what he really is. This may be justified.
In the most cynical works on the sliding scale, he'll be a Serial Killer, or at least a future one.
This character is usually male, but not always. Also, he's not always evil - maybe just a well-hidden Jerkass. The chief difference between the Broken Ace and the usually female Stepford Smiler is that the Stepford Smiler wants to appear normal at all costs, often to the point of hurting herself emotionally (or because she's sociopathic). This guy has the same setup, but is more talented and wants to be the best, loved by all, and accepted. The debilitating personal issues which he's hiding are only getting worse because of being repressed and the stress of his efforts to excel, and these sorts of characters are prime Jerkass Woobie material.
See also The Ace, who's still better than you at everything but isn't so prone to mental disorders or emotional problems, and the Byronic Hero, who's just as awe-inspiring and brooding but lacks the charming, polished façade and is rarely presented as pathetic. For a plot wherein The Ace is revealed to have deep personal problems, see Broken Pedestal. In case you haven't noticed, this has nothing to do with Asexuality.
In Real Life, this is rather common. Real people have flaws no matter how perfect they seem to be at first glance.
open/close all folders
Anime & Manga
One Piece's Portgas D. Ace. One of the most powerful pirates under Whitebeard's command, owning nearly everyone he comes across... until he meets Blackbeard. After being imprisoned in Impel Down, he is revealed to have a lot of angst about his father (none other than Gold Roger) and barely even wanting to live. And once his little brother Luffy frees him and gives him a second chance? He takes a lava punch from a General Ripper to protect the poor kid, then dies in his arms.
To explain how badly broken Ace was, one must know the Driving Question of his life. The question which he spent his entire life searching for, that he continued to live to find the answer to... was whether or not he deserved to be born. He was that broken.
Monster's Johann Liebert. Everyone loves him... Until he kills them.
Johan is something of a subversion, in that he has virtually no actual personality or drive of his own, to the point of being almost more of a force of nature read as The Ace than even a broken one. His sister Nina, on the other hand, is brilliant, driven, and a genuinely good person, but plagued by first her lack of memories and then the horrors of the ones she recovers.
Neon Genesis Evangelion: Asuka Langley Sohryu. At the beginning of the show, Asuka has the highest sync ratio, is the most superlatively trained pilot, and has a college degree at age 13. While Shinji cowers and struggles to overcome his fear of giant horrible aliens trying to kill him, Asuka readily jumps into the fray to kick ass and take names... only to be revealed to be crippled by parental issues, combat stress and adolescent angst. Oh, and a bit after Shinji passes her in synch tests (essentially taking away her "best pilot" status), she is hit with a Mind Rape.
Soichiro Arima from Kare Kano. Handsome, popular, smart, kind... and full of self-hatred and parental issues that pushed him to become the "perfect" son, even after he and his girlfriend Yukino (who's also a Broken Ace, but a far milder one) agree to drop their Stepford Smiler facades.
Yukino became jealous of Soichiro's success but we find out he modeled himself after her. She later has to face her own Broken Ace phase after Maho temporarily gets the others against her, and when she realizes that thanks to her sheer efforts to act like the Perfect Girl, she cannot interact with others normally.
Yu-Gi-Oh!'s Seto Kaiba mixes this with Villain with Good Publicity on one hand and Noble Demon on the other. He's a world-famous duelist, a child genius, and the billionaire head of a hugely successful multi-national gaming company. He's also completely uncaring of anyone outside his Morality Pet Mokuba, is filled with hatred for Yugi for being a better duelist, is haunted by the memory of his abusive stepfather, and is completely absorbed in his work and his dueling, showing little, if any, interest in anything else.
Judai Yuki becomes a deconstruction of The Ace in season 3 of Sequel SeriesYu-Gi-Oh! GX. Success has always come so easily for him that he puts too much pressure on himself to be a perfect, invincible hero who can never let anyone down until he finally snaps under it and falls over the Despair Event Horizon. In this series, when it comes to the psyches of teenagers burdened with saving the world, Reality Ensues.
Hell Kaiser Ryo suffered a similar breakdown — one major loss for the undefeated champion made him lose all sense of self-worth until a Freak Out transformed him into a Combat Sadomasochist.
Andrea Cavalcanti/Benedetto in Gankutsuou, an effortlessly charming fop who happens to also be a wild-eyed rapist with daddy issues.
Light from Death Note is an incredibly handsome, straight-laced, straight-A, genius student who happens to believe that murdering masses of criminals (and anyone else who stands in his way) will create a perfect utopia with himself as its all-powerful omnipotent God.
Mu La Flaga in Mobile Suit Gundam SEED is the second type: he's an expert pilot and war hero and comes across as a friendly and easygoing person - which he is, but a lot of his affable behavior serves to cover for the fact that he drove himself to become an ace pilot as a means of finding some sense of self-worth (he was such an unfavorite in the eyes of his father that he was disinherited and locked away in a Big Fancy House for years, while his dad went and cloned himself), and he's overachieved as a soldier to the point that he's not capable of thinking like a civilian any more.
Athrun Zala becomes this in the sequel. ZAFT, and in particular the Minerva crew treat him like The Ace, but he can't live up to his own standards, is obviously struggling with PTSD, and is more than a little self-destructive. Throw in a nice big batch of Heroic Self-Deprecation, and the inability to see anything but shades of grey and away we go.
Heck, Char Aznable from the original series is pretty broken. So much so that he becomes an Omnicidal Maniac and a borderline Lolicon during the events of Char's Counterattack. Even before then, he suffered from a near total Lack of Empathy, and a vastly overblown sense of his own self-importance.
This just happens to geniuses a lot in the Naruto world, as you would expect from anyone who's ranked especially high within a society of superpowered killers.
Uchiha Itachi- he was torn between village and clan and full of emotional turmoil while going about being a thirteen-year-old The Stoic, and then Danzou pushed it to the crisis point and made him choose. A well-adjusted person, let alone a well-adjusted genius, could probably have taken a third option. Itachi's training and issues combined to make him manipulable. He's yet another iteration of the old Naruto koan, 'a ninja is a weapon.
He does touch upon this when he's resurrected though. Itachi's biggest problem was that because of how he was, he couldn't relate well to people and so did things on his own. He didn't have a team to really bond with and admitted that he trusted others or had Sasuke help him with his family, things may have turned out different.
This trope definitely runs in the family. Itachi's brother, Uchiha Sasuke- A genius prodigy, handsome, extremely skilled ninja, wanted by a lot of girls, and pretty damn screwed up in the head as a result of his past and present. When the main character, his rival, starts to surpass him, Sasuke snaps and pulls a Face-Heel Turn.
And the legendary Uchiha clan head, Madara Uchiha. Having been raised in war and combat, he made a name for himself as one of the world's strongest, always fighting to protect the Uchiha. When his clan turned their backs on him in order to honor a peace pact that was "practically binding them into submission," making all that his clan had sacrificed meaningless, he abandoned them and took it all out on the new village of Konoha which he helped build, dying in the process.
Before being outed as a villain, Orochimaru was a tremendously skilled young man, ranked as one of the powerful ninjas in the world, and on track to become the head of his village. Until all the horrendous things he'd done as a Mad Scientist came to light.
Pain's smooth confidence and A God Am I mentality eventually give way. Beneath them, Pain is a shattered husk of a man who lost everything to war convinced that sharing this suffering with everyone in the world is the only way to achieve (even temporary) world peace
Yuki Sohma of Fruits Basket. He gets better by the end of the series, though.
His underclassman and future girlfriend Machi Kuragi can be seen as a failed attempt at this since by the time we see her, her neurosis has taken over.
Prince Schneizel of Code Geass. The most brilliant and talented out of The Emperor's children pretty much the perfect heir. But also cynical, unhumanly cold, and willing to commit horrible deeds to get his goals done.
And his brother Prince Clovis. To most of his subjects he appears to be the perfect prince. In reality, he is an insecure wreck who commits mass slaughter to cover his screw ups.
Souma Saiki of Sakura Gari. A man with a borderline unearthly beauty, extremely cultures and a genius-like businessman... but also a cynical Depraved Bisexual who has been through severe abuse of all kinds.
Griffith from Berserk. An excellent commander, a masterful swordsman, graceful, elegant, and charismatic. He's also got serious problems, mostly involving his greatest warrior Guts. When Guts leaves the Hawks, it starts a downward spiral for Griffith that would culminate in the betrayal of all the Hawks in order to become Femto during the Eclipse.
Guts is gaining this status with his new companions. They all look up to him as an awesome force of nature against impossibly strong foes more or less, but it's obvious or at least suspected by them all that Guts is hiding some serious issues about his past (which, funnily enough, none of actually inquired about).
The titular Haruhi Suzumiya. Talented in pretty much everything she does (especially music and studies), bright, cheerful, charismatic—and dangerously out of reality, as well as so spoiled and pushy that she treats other people like toys. (Poor Mikuru). And then we have her massive Reality Warper powers. The series is about Kyon and the SOS Brigade attempting to keep her worst traits at bay.
Another example is Shizuo Heiwajima's younger brother, Kasuka. Rich, talented, brilliant, beautiful and... off. The fact that he hooked up with a serial killer should tell you just how off. Even said Serial Killer, Ruri, described him as being out of his mind.
Izaya Orihara. Smart, rich, connected, Bishōnen, good at fighting, and an incredibly awful sociopath underneath, who will go as far as tricking girls into making Suicide Pacts with him For the Lulz and manipualte other people for the same reason. If not for Shinra, he'd be a downright monster.
Oboro Mochizuki of Psyren. He's a Long-Haired Pretty Boy, is a movie star and idol, has the ability to master PSI abilities with almost no effort, has healing ability and excels in Rise type of PSI. However, he also has a hidden screwed up and sadistic side. He shows it when he uses his "First aid heal" at full power against a Tavoo.
Ciel Phantomhive of Black Butler. He's a very cute young male, the head of the Phantomhive noble family, and runs the Phantomhive Company, which manufactures toys, sweets, and food. He is shown to be extremely competent and intelligent, both at running his company and at learning new tasks. He learns to dance in a short period of time, just through Sebastian's teaching, and it is stated that he takes a variety of lessons from tutors. He also comes across as being a mostly emotionless, cold, intelligent child; he is capable of portraying himself as an engaging, happy, easygoing individual, typically when undercover, but is quick to revert to being callous when he no longer has to hide his True Self. Before the loss of his parents, his life as a slave and role as a human sacrifice, however, he seemed to be a happy and energetic child. He also seems to have no qualms with lying to, stealing from, or killing others, so long as it benefits him in some way.
Akio Ohtori of Revolutionary Girl Utena. He once was the most generous and sweet person as Prince Dios, but his terrible experiences left him completely disenchanted and embittered. Now he's a Magnificent Bastard who manipulates everyone and everything, including Anthy, his little sister, who is pretty much trapped in a Fate Worse Than Death after trying to help him.
In ef - a fairy tale of the two., Miyako Miyamura seems to be a walking Purity Sue: cheery, athletic, funny, with top grades, a superb cook and housekeeper. She's actually unable to socialize with people since she was practically abandoned by her parents after their VERY bitter divorce, so she became The Ace to try regaining their affections - and failed badly. So she's also out-of-reality, selfish, clingy, childish, love-starved... and in dire need of both a swift slap to the head and a tight, warm hug.
Carlos Santana and Roberto Hongo from Captain Tsubasa. Both are handsome and skilled sports idols, but to reach the places they are now, they went through lots of heartbreak and suffer. Santana became a heartless machine after his doubleParental Abandonment and the abuse dealed by his coach, and for several years he was unable to connect to anyone emotionally; Roberto was almost Driven to Suicide when he lost everything after being diagnosed with eyesight problems and having to forcibly retire and had to rebuild himself from zero. They both get better.
And then we have Stefan Levin, who had a borderline perfect life until his girlfriend was hit by a truck in the same day he became the Swedish champion and was about to propose to her. The results were horrifying on his psyche, and drove him to straightforwardly brutalize his rivals as much as he could within the rules to win and dull the pain. He also gets better in the end.
Mikael from Tenshi Ni Narumon calm, polite and sweet to those who don't know him and stubborn, obsessive and totally insecure boy to those who are close to him (mainly, one person). In reality, a boy who cannot accept who he really is and constantly desires perfection. His self-hatred leads to an epic Face Heel Turn and even more epic breakdown. He gets better, though.
Vash of Trigun is quite possibly the best gun-fighter on Gunsmoke, effectively immortal, and has saved countless lives. However, he has also suffered immense tragedies, his body is littered with the scars and wounds of his battles, and for every life he fails to save he falls into a depression. He tries to hide the bleaker side of his existence by constantly smiling, goofing off, and partying whenever possible.
Vash approaches this trope extremely sideways, given that the classic Broken Ace is preoccupied with appearances and Vash has three distinct reputations: the way people think about his name, the way people who meet him casually view him, and the way people think of him after he saves the day. The three interact in strange ways. Vash wants to be seen as harmless, except when he's using his scary rep to intimidate opponents or clear innocents out of ricochet range, but his actual excellence and kindness draw a lot of admiration when observed. On the other hand, his emotional issues combined with his evil reputation can attract a lot of serious hate.
That is to say, he tries to be a loveable fool except when it's necessary to be otherwise, but is often believed to be the Big Bad or The Ace depending on what data observers have.
Suguru Teshigawara from Great Teacher Onizuka is the most well known teacher in school. He is handsome, smart and comes from an influential family. He also harbors an unhealthy attraction towards Azusa. After Onizuka one-ups him again, Suguru beats up a student while in class.
Barnaby's situation turns out to be worse than he himself believed when it's revealed that his parents' murderer is the man who eventually became his trusted mentor and guardian of 20 years; a man who's in the habit of doctoring people's (including Barnaby's, obviously) memories whenever he wants them to do his bidding. Is it any wonder the poor guy's so messed up?
In a milder version, Keith "Sky High" Goodman temporarily went through this after the Time Skip when he loses his title as King of the Heroes, slips further down the ranks, and has to come to terms with his defeat at the hands of Jake Martinez. After falling in love with a strange and quietgirl in the park, he regains his confidence in himself and his abilities.
Aoyama Masaya from Tokyo Mew Mew tries hard to be a perfect son and student in order to hide his rather misanthropic personality and the conflicts that come with it. He also admits that the facade is largely out of practicality, since seeming like an ideal kid was the surest way to get adopted.
Rurouni Kenshin has a whole Crouching Moron, Hidden Badass thing going, like Vash above, but with those who know the truth about him cultivates a type of guardian dragon image and attempts to show no genuine weaknesses because they're under his protection and look up to him, and is almost universally admired and feared under his Nom de Guerre. He is, however, crawling with issues, mostly self-doubt and self-loathing but also some serious unresolved conflicts in his personal philosophy.
Understandable in someone traumatically orphaned and enslaved around eight, raised by a tsundere drunkard genius with a very cynical view of the world, and became a terrifyingly effective assassin at fourteen. Who is now a Technical Pacifist. In a nation that has just pulled itself out of war and is in its way to become Imperial Japan. His story is a Take That to the whole Jidai Geki fiction genre, and it shows.
Agon Kongo of Eyeshield 21. He's a once-a-century prodigy, who doesn't even need to practise to be a brilliant athlete, has a reaction time that's nearly superhuman, gets good grades with his eyes closed, and has fantastic social skills when he cares to. One the field he's a One Man Football Team; off the field, he's incredibly successful with girls, and is more or less allowed to do whatever he wants to at the school. It's made him an incredibly entitled, borderline sociopath, with no empathy, a total inability to connect to others, and a very short fuse. He's feared instead of liked, and almost everyone who spends more than a few minutes with him (deservedly) wishes he was dead.
In Arisa, Arisa, who was thought of as the beautiful charismatic class rep by her twin sister Tsubasa is gradually revealed as one of these having a part in creating the King, culminating in her attempted suicide which starts the plot off.
Tetsuya Tsurugi from Great Mazinger. Yes, all those ten years of training under his adoptive father's wing have made him into a combat pro that is respected by everyone, including the Mykene... but nothing can cure his lack of self worth, his inferiority complex, and his pathological fear of being left alone and replaced. And that bites EVERYONE in the ass later. To the point that in one continuity, he practically commits suicideto take downthe Mykenes.
Hikaru Himuro of Dragon Drive. At the start of the series, he's undefeated and has curb stomped everyone he's ever played against - until Reiji catches him off-guard and nearly defeats him. It later becomes evident that he has a serious inferiority complex and literally does not understand the concept of friends.
Claudine de Montesse becomes this when he goes to university. While he's genuinely booksmart, kindhearted, world-weary and all, his Break the Cutie past as well as his identity issues coming from being a female-to-male transsexual in early XX century France cause the poor dude lots of emotional trouble.
Haru's friend Taku from Accel World is a friendly, smart, athletic...pretty much everything Haru wishes he was. All of this masks Taku's extreme resentment and jealousy of Haru. Taku is horribly insecure about his relationship with his girlfriend Chiyu because he believes that Chiyu secretly loves Haru instead of him. In his eyes, Chiyu always looks happier hanging out with Haru than she does when she is with him. All of Taku's achievements — athletics, academics — were done for the sole purpose of making himself better boyfriend material than Haru. Taku even went so far as to use Acceleration to improve his performance — he didn't actually achieve anything through effort alone. He also installed a virus in Chiyu's neurolink so he can spy on her at any time, making him borderline Bastard Boyfriend material. Thankfully Taku gets better after a confrontation with Haru.
Keiichi Maebara of Higurashi no Naku Koro ni worked extremely hard for his top grades and the praise of his parents and teachers, as elaborated upon in the Tsumihoroboshi-hen manga. However, what followed was more pressure from said parties and jealousy of his classmates resulted in being the target of bullies and attacks (such as the dead rat in his desk). With no motivation, Keiichi grew bored of working so hard with no reward and was drawn to a model gun that he used to shoot young girls with for laughs. He broke more after accidentally shooting a girl in the eye, causing her to lose it and turning himself into the police, leading to his move to Hinamizawa.
Atsumu Matsuyuki aka Yukiatsu from Ano Hana. On one hand he's gorgeous, booksmart enough to go to an elite highschool, popular among girls, and looks pretty well-adjusted. On the other he blames himself for his first love Menma's death, deeply resents Jintan and his closeness to her, is unable to interact well with Tsuruko (the only person from the True Companions still close to him), considered Anaru as his "backup" love interest, and took to crossdressing as Menma to alleviate his own pain.
Kouji Nanjo from Zetsuai 1989. He's handsome, smart, good at kendo, excellent in singing and songwriting, and from a powerful and rich family. And he's also a BUNDLE of issues.
Sun Ce from Ravages Of Time — a warrior with few peers who can and has single-handedly torn his way through armies, a Magnificent Bastard even to the point of outdoing his oath-brother Zhou Yu (one of the Eight Geniuses), leader of an army at age twenty and military hegemon of southeastern China under his family banner by his mid-20s... but underneath it all, a boy still lashing out at a cruel world that got his beloved father Sun Jian killed right after finally showing his son some affection. Moreover, it's a father whose public reputation for loyalty to the Han Dynasty and righteousness is at odds with Sun Ce's own beliefs and public personanote and both Gan Ning and Cao Cao use this against Sun Ce in decrying him to his face. It doesn't help that in the side-novel Bofu, he's got a case of the Green-Eyed Monster regarding his younger brother Sun Quan.
Comes with the territory in Attack on Titan, due to the nature of the world. Anyone that survives long enough ends up with MASSIVE issues of one nature or another.
Levi is considered the World's Strongest Man. He's also an obsessive neat freak, incredibly snarky, and abrasive to the extreme. One could only assume that this is his way of coping with the countless deaths he has faced.
Mikasa ranked in the top of her class, and is considered a prodigy of historical significance. She's also a Broken BirdEmotionless Girl desperate not to lose her family for a third time, and it's heavily implied that the reason she is so powerful is because of the horrific trauma she experienced as a child.
Reiner ranked just below Mikasa, being both an incredibly skilled soldier and an all-around solid, reliable guy that others deeply admire. He's actually a Titan spy, and slowly suffers a complete emotional breakdown as a result of Becoming the Mask.
Phoenix Ikki is LEAGUES over the other Bronze Saints in fighting ability, and his Phoenix Cloth guarantees that, even if defeated, he comes back stronger and more dangerous every time. However, getting that Cloth was an ordeal that scarred him for life, and even having his friends as support he still has trouble coping with friendship and companionship.
In Kannazuki no Miko, Chikane is a female example of this. Intelligent, wealthy and beautiful, she's basically adored by everyone around her, and doesn't show any real flaws...until Cerebus Syndrome kicks in. Then we learn that she's destined to kill the only girl she's ever loved... and she becomes a Yandere to cope with this... and she secretly fears that her feelings for Himeko make her 'unclean'. For someone so gifted, she's remarkably quick to fall to the dark side.
In Tengen Toppa Gurren Lagann, Kamina. He was an insecure young man painfully aware of his own shortcomings who always relied on others. The only thing he could do was inspire other people, most notably Simon (considering how valuable this was, this was quite useful.) Word of God is that he had the lowest potential for Spiral Power among the main cast because of this (excluding Viral, being a Beastman who cannot naturally produce Spiral energy to begin with). Spiral power depends on a person believing in himself/herself, which Kamina could never do.
Ozymandias from Watchmen AKA Adrian Veidt, a seemingly forever young (he's 46 and looks about 25), blond supergenius who is insanely rich, pretty much has America in his hands and defeats Rorshach, Silk Spectre, and Nite Owl at the end ... he's also persuasive enough to talk Dr Manhattan around at least to the point of not turning him into a rapidly expanding cloud of superheated plasma. He is also the antagonist, and portrayed as deludedly idealistic to believe that his plan will work. He even has a slight Villainous BSOD after enacting his plan, although the film version ramps his emotional broken-ness up several levels. He shows approximately three times the guilt, self-loathing and painful isolation of his comic book counterpart, even saying he "often [feels] stupid at being unable to relate to anybody". He spends his last few minutes of screentime in a Villainous BSOD, staring into space and looking about ready to fall over as the camera zooms out on him.
The new Phantom Lady is a PHD Multimillionare who has been trained since birth to be a super spy superhero. Also canonically one of the most beautiful women in the DC universe. Yet she's constantly worried that people don't take her seriously and that being a superhero is eating her soul.
The Plutonian of Irredeemable is slowly revealed by flashbacks to have formerly been this. Underneath his standard smiling, selfless persona he was actually resentful of his life as a superhero, stuck saving people he felt were ungrateful, being totally unable to cope with any critics, and needing to be compulsively loved and adored by everyone in the world. When he realized that wasn't going to happen he wound up even more broken.
Batman. Wealthy enough to do whatever he wants to do, can have beautiful ladies by the score, highly educated, is as strong and smart as a non-meta human can get, can outthink pretty much every other superhero (including Mr. Terrific and J'onn J'onzz), and can flatten Lex Luthor at his own games. Permanently scarred by the blood and death of his parents, driven to protect as many as possible to keep others from feeling that horror, finds it incredibly difficult to completely trust and give of his self, and has had terrible romantic relationships due to the second identity, which eventually became his first.
Cyclops. He's the leader of the X-Men and the leader of the mutant race, but oh boy, has Scott ever endured so much pain, chaos and tragedy throughout the course of his life. Underneath that stoic facade is most definitely an emotionally broken and fragile man.
Even before Cerebus Syndrome hit, Cyclops was this. A strong, versatile power came with a crippling inability to control it, and fear that someday he would hurt those he loved with it. Good strategizing skills coupled with terrible social skills isolated him from his teammates and made him a repressed, disliked, Kuudere who had barely any close relationships.
Scott's fellow X-man Wolverine is also one of these. He's got over a century's worth of accumulated skills, accomplishments, bedmates, friends, and is the poster-boy of "mutant cool". He's also got over a century's worth of painful memories, dirty business, lost loves, enemies, and is full of self-loathing.
And Logan's own daughter/Opposite-Sex Clone, Laura Kinney aka X-23, who may pack even more angst into her seventeen short years than Logan has his entire 150 or more. She's without question one of the best fighters and most experienced members of whatever team she's assigned to thanks to being raised as a Living Weapon by the ones who created her. She was also horrifically physically and emotionally abused by her creators, forced to kill her own mother via a chemically-induced berserker rage which will make her turn on anyone no matter how much she cares for them, had to give up the relatively normal and happy life she was creating with her only other family when the ones who made her came looking for her in order to protect them, and spent an unknown period of time as a prostitute under a violently possessive and abusive pimp. Laura has been left a mess of confused emotions and finds establishing true friendships incredibly difficult as a result, and it's been very strongly implied she's prone to bouts of severe, if not outright suicidal, depression. And her solo series reveals she was left with so little sense of self during her captivity and days as a prostitute she never realized the horrible things done to her were even wrong!
Evangelion 303: Asuka was the best pilot in the entire base. However, her war plane crashed during a test and Asuka spent several months in a coma. When she woke up she considered herself responsible of the failure of the test and of Jessika’s death. She spent several weeks in a permanent state of rage, hating herself, hating everybody, lashing out for anything and being on the brink of committing suicide several times. She even ran away at one point because she could not stand being reminded of her failures, mistakes and wrongdoings or being reminded of her abusive behaviour every time that she saw Shinji.
In Reconciliation, Hanako is a best-selling author, but has no real friends, apart from her publicist Sho; as a result of her Bad Ending, she cut ties with Hisao and Lilly because she was too ashamed and afraid to face them. By the end of the fic, the "broken" part seems to have faded; while Hisao is dead, Hanako is once again friends with Lilly, and is in a relationship with Sho.
Kali of the Death Note fanfic Zenith, Darkness, Reverie. The tale commences with with a brilliant (but exceptionally verbose) freshman accepted into one of the best high schools in the country. It's mentioned rather nonchalantly that she's a competent violist, boulders competitively, writes novels (possibly), and possesses an extensive knowledge base about string theory. By the eleventh chapter or so, she spends several paragraphs begging the voices in her head to "Shut up." And this is Kali, who peruses the dictionary when bored.Kira is purportedly the manifestation of this "Broken Ace" state. Kira's not particularly broken.
The Immortal Game: Twilight Sparkle is an example of an Ace who gets broken over the course of the story. At the beginning, it's established that in addition to being Celestia's prized student, she's also officially the most powerful Unicorn alive. However, this just makes her a target for the villains, who infect her with an Artifact of Doom (by pushing it through her eye), which takes control of her body and forces her to watch as it tries to kill her friends. She's eventually freed, but soon after finds herself forced into the role of Rebel Leader, the stress of which — combined with the psychological trauma from the possession — drives her to the brink of insanity. On top of that is the reveal that Celestia was subtly manipulating and training her for this role all along, which shatters Twilight's image of her beloved mentor and leads to her hating her. Even after her mind recovers, she's left a lot more cynical and bitter.
Gilda in Ace Combat The Equestrian War. Even though she became one of the best griffin fighters, she turned away from everyone and remained a solo player. Rainbow Dash makes her realize that during their second confrontation.
“You are very hopeful that this will turn out in such a way... But I gave up on hope a long time ago.”
In Kitsune no Ken: Fist of the Fox, Naruto himself is this. He isn't as Book Dumb as his canon-series counterpart, and he's a terrifyingly skilled fighter capable of taking down gangs all by himself. At the same time, he's got some serious loathing for his time as a Kyuushingai in the back-story, and the trauma of having to partake of city-wide massacres day after day for a whole year has taken a toll on him by the time the story's main plot has begun.
Robin in Pretender is this. Robin is a genius tactician gifted with both tomes and swords, lead his army to many countless victories without the loss of a single life. On the other hand, he is filled with great guilt over Emmeryn's death and his jealousy of Sumia for having Chrom's love and has poor self-esteem for having no identity outside of being a tactician and no past to speak off.
Films — Animated
Big Z in Surf's Up, who threw a race and pretended to be dead when he found he was getting too competitive (and someone was actually capable of beating him.)
Prince Charming in the Shrek movies is a parody of this type that acts like and actually thinks he is a standard heroic Ace, but really is a vain, juvenile Mama's boy once you scratch the surface.
Elsa from Frozen. As shown in supplementary material, her little sister Anna views her as The Ace, and with good reason. Elsa is intelligent, elegant, graceful, beautiful... and constantly living in fear of hurting people with her ice powers, having to keep up a facade of perfection and stoicism to protect people, only to have it all completely backfire, meaning her life spent in silent misery was for nothing. Needless to say, Elsa finally gets pushed over the edge, though her intentions are always good.
Word of God confirms that she has depression and anxiety issues.
Films — Live-Action
John Nash in A Beautiful Mind is a brilliant and successful graduate student and later mathematics professor but is a socially clumsy loner with schizophrenia.
Tyler Durden from Fight Club, being The narrator's subconscious conception of his ideal self, which he manifests as an alternate personality.
Apt Pupil has an A student get fascinated with the local hidden Nazi's old war stories. This eventually causes him (and the Nazi) to snap.
Die Another Day villain Gustav Graves is charming, talented, and insanely rich (from blood diamonds). However, he is really a North Korean with plastic surgery building a Kill Sat to help his faction finally win the war. He has daddy issues too, and really really hates anything Western.
Kathryn from Cruel Intentions falls between this and Stepford Smiler. She must be considered a lady (smiler) and that requires being a role model who's the best at everything (this).
Chuck Hansen in Pacific Rim. He's one of the youngest Jaeger pilots and has the highest Kaiju kill count in history. However, he's also a Child Soldier who has a Hair-Trigger Temper, terrible communication skills, and a double dose of Daddy Issues and Survivors Guilt with regards to his father choosing to save him over his mother. It's also heavily implied that he believes his only purpose in life is to live and die fighting the Kaiju, which comes true by the end of the film.
Chuck: After Mum died, I spent more time with these machines than I ever did with you.
(The real) Jerome Morrow in Gattaca. Once a champion swimmer on top of the world, he lost the use of his legs in an accident and was confined to a wheel chair for the rest of his life. He's still a brilliant and remarkably gifted individual (with an ego to match), but he's also internalized a lot of their culture's demands for absolute perfection. As a result, he's got a lot of anger with himself and everyone else.
Anton Jr. (Vincent's younger brother) turns out to be something like this as well. The audience doesn't get to know him very well, but he's definitely the Ace in their father's eyes, and seems at least a little Broken considering his issues with the fact that his non-engineered brother beat him in a swimming race once after years and years of beating him every time since they were little kids.
The title character from The Stepfather film franchise. He's very good with this hands, able to create works of art with just a couple pieces of wood and an hour's worth of time. He's also very intelligent and charismatic. Unfortunately, he's also an ax crazy, sociopath, and psychopath, that's obsessed with creating the perfect family seen in the television sitcoms of the 50s and 60s.
Ginger from Casino is Vegas' top casino hustler. She's beautiful and smart. She marries Ace and becomes respected among Vegas' elite. But she also has a troubled relationship with her pimp Lester and as the years pass she succumbs to substance abuse.
High School Musical: Gabriella. She's portrayed a very attractive Teen Genius, but underneath is extremely lonely from constantly moving schools, insecure about everything outside of studying and hides her intelligence to avoid being labelled the 'freaky math girl'. She does become more comfortable with herself after the first film.
Troy has it even worse. Big Man on Campus and super-talented basket ball captain, but also increasingly uncomfortable with the expectations of his parents, friends and the rest of the school. In the third film, after a song which screams self-loathing (to the point of him ripping down posters of himself), he decides to go to a different college than expected, thousands of miles away from his hometown, partly to get away from the spotlight and pressure. In fact a huge part of his and Gabriella's initial attraction, is that they accept each other as themselves and not the hyped up perfect people everyone see's.
Parodied in Tropic Thunder with Kirk Lazarus, who is a talented actor because he doesn't know who he is.
Detective Loki from Prisoners has solved every case assigned to him. In reality, he is a man without a perfect life.
Eddie Felton is this at the start of The Color of Money, after the events of The Hustler. He ekes out a living selling liquor, and no longer plays pool or hustles people for money.
Nina from Black Swan. She's a young ballet prodigy who is a natural for the lead role of Swan Lake, is very sweet and incredibly beautiful... who's also incredibly socially awkward, emotionally stunted, self-loathing, is implied to have an eating disorder, and is completely batshit insane.
Interstellar brings us Dr. Mann. Everyone speaks of him as if he was a hero, the best scientist and most driven member of the Lazarus Project. Unfortunately, by the time the main characters reach him, the isolation, fear and frustration over the planet he was assigned to survey being completely uninhabitable has driven him mad.
Lance from the Gone series. He is smart, athletic, handsome, and was popular before the poof. He also suffers from Fantastic Racism.
Maxim from the first Night Watch novel is good-looking, fairly intelligent, and a very successful businessman, and he looks down at the less successful. While some of his murdering of Dark Others isn't his fault (he had Detect Evil ability and wasn't in on The Masquerade), it's noted that he has no real comprehension of love- pretty much, when given a choice between punishing evil and doing good, he chose the former.
Melkor. The name means "He Who Arises in Might," and he is explicitly called the greatest of the Ainur. This goes to his head, and he eventually winds up getting a new name ... Morgoth, the Dark Enemy.
Also Boromir from The Lord of the Rings. He's a proud and gallant warrior, greatly admired for this by his people (and his younger brother) but the pressure put on him by his position as heir to Gondor's ruler and his belief that Sauron could never be beaten fed his obsession with the Ring and made it easy for him to fall for the temptation.
Crowley from Good Omens. He's a Noble Demon, with a confident, attractive facade (implied to even have an aggressively cool haircut that only looks good on someone like him) and a quick wit. He has a relentlessly stylish apartment full of fancy gadgets, he always seems to have the best of everything, and drives the coolest of Cool Cars. However, in spite of the book's ensemble cast, he stands out as pretty much the main viewpoint character, whose thoughts we hear the most, and behind the painfully cool exterior he's frightened, weary, and eventually very angry, which causes him to rebel against both Heaven and Hell. He's definitely not the slick bastard he appears to be on the outside, but unlike a lot of these characters it ends up making him stronger and extremely sympathetic.
Carl Hamilton from the Hamilton series is a famous, highly decorated SEAL-trained intelligence operative, independently wealthy, a gourmet chef and wine connoisseur and fluent in four languages. He is also crippled by a complete inability to handle romantic relationships, not being able to confide in anyone concerning his work, and increasingly guilty conscience about killing people for what later may turn out to be no good reason.
Harry himself excels in Defense Against the Dart Arts and Quidditch, and, to a lesser extent, other fields in magic. However, Harry develops major insecurities as a result of his abusive childhood and the pressures the wizarding world dumps on him.
Albus Dumbledore is talented, powerful, and famous bordering on revered for defeating Grindlewald and leading the fight against Voldemort, both of whom are said to have only feared him out of all wizards. As the books go on, it becomes clear that he's also a deeply lonely man whose intelligence does not prevent him from making emotional mistakes. The "broken" part really kicks when his Dark and Troubled Past is revealed in book seven.
Tom Riddle was an example during his schooldays - a prodigy, incredibly popular, disguising his true nature. In this case, he's an out-and-out murderous lunatic instead of just "messed up" or "morally ambiguous".
Severus Snape. Brilliant student who improved his potion textbook. But he was also a non-socialized Creepy Child, allegedly created many Curses (actually he only created ONE curse and many spells) alongside his potions, destroyed his one chance of a happy life upon using a massive slur against his Only Friend, and is so bitter over his bullying at the hands of the hero's father and the abuse he suffered at the hands of his parents and everyone around him... that he takes up to use his position as a Hogwarts teacher to torment not only The Hero, but his friends, and especially an innocent boy named Neville Longbottom.
Percy Jackson and the Olympians: Luke Castellan is this trope all over. He's handsome, popular, talented, and a trusted authority figure. He's also a huge traitor who wants to overthrow the gods. This is later revealed to be because his mother was cursed and went completely insane when he was a baby and his father, Hermes, left him with her.
Of The Three Musketeers: Athos is outstanding for his looks, thorough education, martial prowess, and social graces. Unfortunately, he is also a somewhat misogynistic alcoholic with truly terrible luck. He is less misogynistic then horribly distrustful of women, because he married the patron saint of Bitch in Sheep's Clothing, Milady de Winter. Athos really achieves Broken Ace in the later books, when his faith in Royalty is shattered when the king takes his son's fiancee as his mistress.
Ciaphas Cain. Capable, intelligent, handsome - and a compulsive liar desperately trying to hide what he sees as his own fundamental lack of courage and decency in a culture obsessed with martyrdom. It's fairly obvious in his memoirs that Ciaphas is incapable of giving himself credit for any achievement, because he has to justify any noble act with ignoble intentions.
Horatio Hornblower is a brilliant sea warrior whose men are devoted to him, who managed to make several women fall in love with him and who managed to manipulate the French into two of their greatest military disasters in history(Trafalgar and Russia). He also absolutely hates himself.
Ender Wiggin from Enders Game may be only 10, but he is one of these. Everyone in Battle School (with some exceptions) loves him. He is the best in the standings, his free-time practice sessions are attended by many people throughout the school, he has the best army in the school and is one of the best tacticians ever. But he feels isolated from his friends and unloved. This becomes very apparent in Ender's Shadow, as Bean is really Ender's only confidant. He is a poor, lonely boy with the weight of the world on him.
Kvothe from The Kingkiller Chronicles is the perfect type 2 example. Pretty, Magically gifted, Superlative at everthing he does, but poor, arrogant and a wreck in the present day.
Sisterhood Series by Fern Michaels: Henry "Hank" Jellicoe is firmly revealed to be Type 1 in the books Cross Roads and Deja Vu. He is at least a He-Man Woman Hater and at most a Straw Misogynist. He tried using President Martine Connor to save his funding from the Pentagon from being cut off. He had several contracts murdered as part of his plan, and when the CIA had to cut ties with him, he went and murdered a number of CIA agents. Cross Roads makes it sound like he was a good man who went bad. Deja Vu, however, reveals that he was always bad and that the disguise had finally worn thin. He tried splitting up the Vigilantes for a few years, so he could keep an eye on them and prevent them from interfering with his plans - namely his plan to make it sound like someone was going to assassinate the president (there isn't, because he made it up), and he would step in to save the day. He had a wife named Louise, who kept a diary of his illegal dealings with terrorist groups and other things (like creating bad situations and riding in to the rescue, probably to improve his image), and she was put under Witness Protection, and he was never able to find her. He considers that My Greatest Failure, and that there were failures, but he corrected them. When a man writing a book about Jellicoe called Jellicoe a monster in the title, Henry blew a gasket, had his goons beat the guy up to the point of leaving him wheelchair-bound and then put him in a luxurious mansion and spent a few minutes with him, talking like they were best friends. He did this to prove that he wasn't a monster, and to set up a safe house in the future.
Lecter was already a Broken Ace, just a Type 1, at least before the events of Red Dragon: he was a charming, cultured, and highly respected medical doctor and later psychiatrist who was secretly a serial killer/cannibal. Hannibal Rising simply revealed him to be a Type 2 as well.
Mason Verger, the primary antagonist of the sequel novel Hannibal probably also counts(as a Type 1) before his disfigurement at Lecter's hands. Up to that point, Mason was the charming and handsome heir to his father's meatpacking fortune but secretly molested children at the summer camp his father ran and also sexually assaulted his sister. There also subtle clues that he was himself molested as a child by his father, which would make him a Type 2 as well.
Denth from Warbreaker is friendly, charming and good with words, despite being a mercenary. He also happens to be obsessed with revenge, and will do anything to get it, including torturing and killing innocent people. He can't move past the issue that broke him in the first place, even when given the opportunity to heal.
Kaladin from The Stormlight Archive is an interesting version of this trope. He starts out as an Ace, charismatic leader, excellent spearman, trained in medicine, pays bribes to protect his men and get new untrained boys into his squad where he can watch over them. But after he's betrayed he's definitely broken. The skills are all still there, but he has trouble finding the will to use them anymore.
Lancelot in The Once and Future King, who falls in love with Arthur and becomes so obsessed with becoming the greatest knight in the world (so that Arthur will love him back) that he gives his entire childhood in the pursuit of this dream. Throughout the book, he is shown to be extremely uncomfortable in his own mind, and is quite self-loathing. Guenever mellows him out a bit, eventually.
"Three years is a long time for a boy to spend in one room [the armoury], if he only goes out of it to eat and sleep and to practice tilting in the field. It is even difficult to imagine a boy who would do it, unless you realize from the start that Lancelot was not romantic and debonair. Tennyson and the Pre-Raphaelites would have found it difficult to recognize this rather sullen and unsatisfactory child with the ugly face, who did not disclose to anybody that he was living on dreams and prayers. They might have wondered what store of ferocity he had against himself, that could set him to break his own body so young. They might have wondered why he was so strange."
Song at Dawn: Dragonetz appears to be the perfect knight: strong, gallant, handsome, but he's also bitter, disillusioned and afraid of marriage because he thinks he'll screw it up.
A Song of Ice and Fire. Robert Baratheon is remembered as a handsome, virile warrior but he degenerated physically and morally after becoming king. He understands how out of depth he is with running a kingdom and would have preferred a life of wandering.
Deverry: Rhodry ap Maelwaedd. A brilliant fighter and battle leader, he is very intelligent, willing to work past cultural and societal constraints and bias, successfully ruled a rhyn for many years, and can be very quick to notice small things and take advantage. Also severely prone to terrible bouts of depression called hiraedd, often takes on far more responsibility then is remotely necessary, blames himself for things that are in no way his fault, is often subject to severe honor before reason and becomes a Death Seeker, with only his honor keeping him from suicide.
Skulduggery Pleasant is the best Detective the Irish Sanctuary (or possibly any sanctuary) has, is skilled with both magic and hand to hand combat and was one of the best soldiers during the war, being part of a 7 man cell called the Dead Men who went on suicide missions but always survived. He's also a living skeleton. His friends and allies all warn his new protege that he is horribly damaged by his family's murder and is renowned for his Unstoppable Rage when people he cares about are in danger. This doesn't worry Valkyrie at all until she learns that Skulduggery is so broken his darker thoughts and desire for revenge turned him into Lord Vile, the most infamous general of Menevolent's armies, and hell bent on the annihilation of all life
Made worse because the Faceless Ones spent a year torturing Skulduggery making him a little bit more unhinged than normal (including threatening someone sent to keep an eye on him with a gun) and separating The Lord Vile part of Skulduggery's psyche into a separate Ax-Crazy entity
Live Action Television
Jeff Winger from Community is good looking, has a gift of gab, and liked by everyone but his masculinity hides his issues with his estranged father and his fear that no one will like his vulnerable side. He calls himself "broken" in season 4.
Dr.Gregory House from House. Not only is he the greatest diagnostician, he has also mastered all the manipulative aspects of human sociology and psychology. In addition, he speaks several language, plays a mean guitar, and has the expertise needed to turn his own apartment into an ICU. Despite all this, he still manages to have no social skills, has no friends, and is an unapologetic, drug-addicted criminal.
Kara "Starbuck" Thrace from the Battlestar Galactica remake. Top notch pilot, expert markswoman, fine brawler-but suffering from memories of an abusive childhood, a morass of self-esteem and self-loathing issues, and unsure of how to have a life beyond being The Ace. And of course it just gets worse halfway through the fourth season when she finds out she's been Dead All Along.
Jack Shephard of LOST- brilliant, handsome, athletic, charismatic doctor on the outside. Angry, emotionally abused, masochistic, repeatedly relapsing addict with a messiah complex on the inside.
The Tenth Doctor is confident and cavalier on the outside, but he suffers from survivor's guilt and verges on self-loathing on the inside.
The Eleventh Doctor is a charming, charismatic, moral, slightly eccentric, Chaste Hero on the outside. At first, his confidence seems genuine, but as time passes it quickly becomes apparent that Eleven is just as riddled with grief, rage and self-loathing as Ten.
"The Daleks' Master Plan": Sara Kingdom is Mavic Chen's best agent, a hero in her organisation, said in awed tones to have 'the strength of ten men'. She shoots Bret Vyon (a 'traitor' allied to the Doctor) and was sent to murder the Doctor and his companion too, and would have done it if they hadn't been accidentally teleported to the planet Mira. While on Mira, the Doctor confronts her, clearly in a disturbed psychological state, and she eventually admits Bret was her brother. She joins the Doctor's side soon afterwards.
Captain Jack Harkness, later of Torchwood. Dashingly handsome, brave, cocky and nigh-immortal...but after being abandoned by the Doctor for being"wrong", suffering trauma after his repeated deaths, seeing everyone he loves die in battle or of old age, and now having being forced to allow his own grandson to be killed he's definitely a Broken Ace. He also has a Dark and Troubled Past. He still feels guilt over getting his brother captured by a vicious alien race. Even during his time as a temporal agent, it wasn't all gallivanting through history and screwing Anything That Moves (although there was a fair bit of that too). He has a chunk of memory the size of 2 years missing, although he completely forgets about it after meeting the Doctor.
Red Dwarf's Arnold J. Rimmer is a literal example of the trope. Sucked dry of his negativity and neuroses (themselves powerful enough to destroy a Lotus-Eater Machine) by an Emotion Eater, he immediately turns into Ace Rimmer (what a guy!). Eventually, he becomes the next Ace Rimmer - as each one dies, he recruits the next, and so on, until it finally reaches Arnie himself. It is mostly his neuroses that hold him back - but luckily for him, the Red Dwarf universe has it set that pretty much every Rimmer gets redeemed. Before then, he makes an awesome Last Stand at the end of Series 6.
Lionel Luthor: Of the Villain with Good Publicity variety, Lionel is the Big Bad of Season's 1-3. He's a Magnificent Bastard, Corrupt Corporate Executive and Cultured Badass with more money than God, and the ears of kings, sultans, and presidents. He's respected by those who don't know how evil he is, feared by those who do, and has the entire world at his beck and call. He's also a damaged, empty man who has immense difficulty identifying with other people, and is trapped in a mutually self-destructive relationship with his son, a relationship he is unable to salvage even after a Heel-Face Turn. He's burned every bridge he's got to get where he is, and is revealed to be a Self-Made Orphan who's still running away from his abusive, drunken parents.
Lex Luthor: Lionel's son. On the surface he's got it all: wealth, power, women, immunity from prosecution. Underneath, he's self-loathing, caught up in a desire for parental approval that he'll never get, before or post-Face-Heel Turn, haunted by the deaths of his mother and brother, and consumed by his need to control the people around him. He blows up every friendship he ever has in his drive for success and his eventual slide into cackling supervillainy is as tragic as it is inevitable.
Jason Teague: He's a good-looking football coach, secretly dating one of the hottest girls in the school. His family is rich, he's a former star player himself, and he's able to lie and cheat at Lex's level. Unfortunately, he's pretty eaten up by his Mommy Issues, has no self-esteem, and is nearly incapable of taking any action his mother (Season 4 Big Bad Genevieve Teague) doesn't approve.
Green Arrow/Oliver Queen: A heroic example. In one life Oliver is the heir to an immense fortune, a billionaire playboy with more women than he can handle and a life most people only dream of. In his other life, he moonlights as a Badass NormalSuperhero saving more lives before nine A.M. than most people do before lunch. And yet neither of these is the real Oliver Queen. Inside he's hollow, convinced that his life is a sham, and manifests numerous self-destructive tendencies including alcoholism, the inability to commit to anything, and a total disregard for his own safety that's both impressive and frightening. His committment to saving the world overshadows everything else he does, leading to bouts of drinking, a temporary drug addiction, and culminating in his Interrupted Suicide in Season 9.
TessMercer: A female variant. Much like Lionel and Lex, whom she succeeds as leader of LuthorCorp, Tess is an incredibly rich young woman, who has successfully escaped an abusive home life. She speaks two or three different languages, is extremely attractive, and has the money and power to do whatever she wants. She also has horribly low self-esteem, no faith in humanity, and a fatalistic need for a Messiah, all stemming from having given up on her former idealism and desire to change the world in favour of moving up in the world. As the show progresses, her ace facade disintegrates more and more, and the Broken Bird underneath is increasingly exposed. Alliances with Checkmate and Major Zod, and an eventual Heel-Face Turn have all failed to give her the sense of self-worth she's seeking.
His marriage to Betty showed the consequences of a Broken Ace marrying a Stepford Smiler. A major part of season 4 was about surveying the wreckage of that union.
John Connor is the Messianic Archetype of the Terminator franchise who will eventually lead the human race to victory against the machines but The Sarah Connor Chronicles shows the hell he went through to become what he is. He's also made rather questionable decisions like trying to strike an alliance with a renegade faction of machines.
In The Sopranos, Tony Soprano is the mob boss of all New Jersey; charismatic, powerful, ruthless, and has a keen business acumen. Underneath it all, he suffers from some seriousParental Issues and other mental problems, which cause him to have panic attacks.
Dean Winchester from Supernatural. Handsome, charming ladies' man and badass hunter on the outside, self-loathing bundle of PTSD and daddy issues on the inside. His brother Sam is the brains of the operation (but no less badass) and tends to be much more empathetic towards people in need, but is a nest of hatred, anger, and self-loathing and is driven primarily by revenge for much of the show.
Every hunter is this in spades, to the point of only being good at what they do by being so horribly broken. Capable of fighting monsters, demons and undead nightmares, hiding from (or staying on the run from) the police and FBI for the crimes they commit doing their jobs, and all of them make the hardiest survivalist look like a pansy. The only reason any of them live the life they do is that either they were raised into it, which is a whole mess of issues right there, or they experienced firsthand losing someone close to them because of the things that go bump in the night and became obsessed with revenge. John Winchester was arguably the worst we've seen, often being remarked on as a hunter of unparalleled skill but uncaring of anything that wouldn't lead him to the Yellow-Eyed Demon, to the point of being abusive and neglectful towards his sons and raising them as soldiers to fight an unending daily war (which Sam and later Dean resent him for).
Possibly Charlie Harper from Two and a Half Men. Despite being a rich, handsome womanizer, many episodes indicate or imply that he is riddled with mommy issues. There is the possibility that his womanizing is a means of acting out said mommy issues or is even a means of overcompensating for repressed homosexuality/bisexuality or having been more abused or neglected than Alan when they were kids.
Rich Stephenson, a recurring character on Community is a cool example. For the entirety of his first episode, Jeff is convinced that Rich is a Broken Ace—that he was not the pottery prodigy that he appeared to be, but that he had taken lessons before and was faking natural talent due to deep-seated insecurities. Jeff ends the episode having learned the lesson that some people are going to be better than you, and there's nothing wrong with that. Then we find out that he was right all along. Rich had been doing pottery all his life, and hated himself deeply. Further appearances confirm that though Rich is handsome, rich, charitable, good at everything he does, and well-liked by others, he is also incredibly screwed up.
An early episode had JD competing (purely in his own mind) with another intern (named Nick) to see who was the best between them and who should be the unofficial leader of that group of interns. Eventually JD has to concede defeat, as his rival can match JD's medical knowledge while also being more handsome, less socially awkward, more charismatic, less of a suck-up and even has the girl JD likes interested in him. Hints are dropped throughout the episode however, that Nick is a Stepford Smiler who is repressing all his doubts and feelings. At the end of the episode Nick fails to save the life a 7 year old kid and completely breaks down and quits working at Sacred Heart.
A little later in the series, they brought in Doctor Kevin Casey. He was played by Michael J. Fox, and they gave the character severe OCD to help explain the tics caused by Fox's Parkinson's Disease. His OCD made him an incredible doctor and surgeon, as his compulsive need to study meant that he had read every book he could get his hands on multiple times and perfected his physical dexterity, performing complex operations in a fraction of the time a normal surgeon would require. He's also incredibly nice and wise, giving helpful advice to everyone in the hospital, helping them fix their lives. So, having humiliated Turk in the OR, Cox in front of his interns, and JD by destroying his ego with an off-hand comment, all three seek him out to confront him. And they find him trapped in the scrub room outside the OR, unable to leave because he's been compulsively washing his hands for hours. He's on the verge of tears but he just can't leave.
Dr. Cox himself could be seen as this. He's intelligent, witty, well respected, perhaps the best Doctor at Sacred Heart and keeps in fantastic shape for a man his age. However, he's also bitterly lonely, broken shell of a man who hasn't had a meaningful relationship in years.
Hawkeye has signs of this through the mid and late seasons from the stress of saving the lives of soldiers that are just going to get killed later anyway. But the final episode is when he really is broken because he inadvertently caused a mother to kill her own child.
Barney Stinson of How I Met Your Mother tries very hard not to be this trope, but he isn't nearly as good as hiding this fact as he thinks he is. His over-the-top, self-aggrandizing "awesomeness" is his way of overshadowing all his emotional issues.
This seemed to be a central theme in the NBC series Heroes. Having superpowers didn't cure the characters of their painful pasts, past mental issues, or dark secrets.
The Crane brothers in Frasier. For all their success as psychiatrists, it doesn't spare them from the fact that both of them suffer from deep-seated parental issues and are both hapless with women, even though, oddly, they never seem for want of one.
John Sheppard on Stargate Atlantis is undeniably a Colonel Badass and Ace Pilot who's not afraid to kick some ass in order to defend the city of Atlantis. He also has severe self-loathing, intimacy, trust, and abandonment issues which come into play when people under his command or close to him die because of the inherent danger of his job.
Dr. Bashir, CMO of Deep Space Nine: brilliant, charming, funny, athletic, genuinely caring enough to make ex-torturers Heel-Face Turn out of love....and needy as hell, ignorant of his own privilege, and convinced that he's a fraud and that everything he's achieved is fake due to his extremely illegal genetic enhancements, which were given to him by his parents without his consent and if discovered will lead to him losing everything.
Nikita is the best covert operative Division created but she hates them for turning her into a killer who is unable to live a normal life.
The abovementioned "Richard Cory" example was expanded on in a song of the same title by Simon & Garfunkel, contrasting Cory's facade of happiness with the poverty of one of his envious employees. The song ends the same as the poem. The narrator still envies him.
Is the chorus repeated (even after The Reveal) merely to be consistent with standard song structure? Seems unlikely, as Simon—self-described in "Homeward Bound" as "a poet and a one-man band"—was a careful wordsmith. And because a final chorus would be anti-climactic, its inclusion requires an important reason. Even so, it's not clear whether this was simply for the sake of Irony, or if the narrator's envy was allowed to persist so his crushing poverty would be underscored.
Ziltoid of Devin Townsend's Ziltoid The Omnicient seems like your ordinary fourth dimensional evil overlord, spreading terror and destruction across the known universes, fraternising with the fifth dimensional planet smasher and the omnidimensional creator, and of course raiding the earth for our finest coffee to use for time-bending. But in the end, Captain Spectacular of Earth has seen Ziltoid's true self; a nerd.
The list of "troubled musicians" in Real Life and fiction is probably plentiful enough for it to be its own trope.
"We" by Christian singer-songwriter Joy Williams describes two people wanting to really be known as they truly are.
"She's independent and beautiful Wish I could be like her She's got the girls and the boys so wrapped around her finger Rumor is, she's some kind of dream Nobody knows, she cries herself to sleep." ... "He's on the top of the social scene He's stylish, cool, and clever He's got a cool attitude that screams 'He's got it all together' You'd think he's addicted to himself But he wishes he could be someone else."
Sadly this trope is very common for professional wrestlers. Many great talents have been plagued with severe personal issues that have ruined their careers.
Scott Hall has been wrestling with alcoholism for quite some times, yo-yoing back and forth for almost two decades. WCW even made his drunken behavior into a character trait.
Jake Roberts has struggled with alcoholism as well. Several times during his career he's shown up to an arena fully drunk. He was one of the first wrestlers to take advantage of the WWE's drug rehab program for current and former wrestlers in the wake of the Chris Benoit situation.
Jeff Hardy and his battles with drug addictions will very likely land him in jail in the near future. Not to mention, his already terrible reign as TNA World Champion was capped off with one of the worst title matches in history (see the So Bad It's Horrible TNA page for more details).
"Mr. Perfect" Kurt Hennig could do just about anything, except put down the bottle which led to his death.
If there ever needs to be a crowning example for Type 1, then it's Desus of Exalted. A hero of the First Age, renowned throughout all the land for his great feats of prowess and courage... well, actually, he had a Charm that allowed him to Mind Rape everyone into thinking he was a grand hero. Behind the scenes, he was a cheater and a maniac with little regard for the lives and well-beings of other sentients. He was yandere towards his wife Lilith, in love with her even as he abused her horribly. He was also firmly in denial about the true nature of his cruelty, typically managing to convince himself that his deeds were justified.
The truly sad thing is, he started off as type two, otherwise Sol never would have chosen him. And a combination of having absolute power, no accountability towards what he did with it, and the Great Curse led him to be the prime example of how bad the First Age Solars got on a personal scale.
The Primarchs of Warhammer 40,000 are gods among men and strong charismatic leaders of their adopted planets but each harbor serious issues like insecurity (Fulgrim), inferiority complex (Perturabo) or a need for revenge (Angron) which led half of them to commit rebellion. The loyalists aren't any better.
Their father/creator the Emperor of Mankind. The most powerful psyker to ever live, a brilliant scientist, a ruler who united humanity in a golden age, practically a living god...but his inability to be the father his sons needed dooms himself and the Imperium to a slow wasting death. All that is left of the once-mighty Emperor is a decaying husk trapped between life and death that can only watch as the Imperium falls apart over ten thousand years.
Tybalt in Gerard Presgurvic's musical version of Romeo and Juliet, especially in the Hungarian production, where he's an epileptic pyromaniac on top of being obsessed by family honor and in love with Juliet.
Graf von Krolock from Tanz Der Vampire. Suave, unflappable vampire, seducer of the young and beautiful, dominating and powerful... and then, come The Eleven O'Clock Number, we see him practically writhing in the dirt of the castle graveyard as he castigates himself for being driven to destroy what he loves and never rising to the true pinnacle he always wanted to achieve.
Freddie Trumper in Chess, though his ace reputation is also notoriously short-tempered and cocky. Still, he drove himself to be a chess champion due to his rather hellish childhood, and doesn't want anyone seeing his weakness. The audience only finds out during "Pity the Child".
Anatoly Sergeievski counts too, if the lyrics of "Where I Want To Be" are any indication. Figures that in a show where the two female leads are broken birds, the men would be broken aces.
Ultimate heroic example, without even a trace of Jerkass: Jesus Christ himself in Jesus Christ Superstar is deeply conflicted by his own messiah role and increasingly uncomfortable with his followers and fanbase, particularly because he doubts that anything he's done will even make an impact.
Kyras in Dawn of War 2. He is the single best psyker and soldier in the entire Blood Ravens chapter and behind it all he has fallen over to chaos not out of self interest, but simply for fear of being forced to lose his men to it again.
Deugan from MARDEK. In Chapter 3, he actually becomes the next Grand Adventurer as "Lone Wolf", just like he always wanted to, and is already almost as famous and popular as his childhood hero Social Fox was. But due to his incredibly poor self esteem, he still doesn't think this is enough, and also seems to think he doesn't deserve anything good that happens to him.
Zack from Crisis Core is a Type 2 Broken Ace. He had to pick up the slack when many of the other SOLDIERs either quit, went crazy, or died, then ends up having to kill his rogue mentor. He is eventually utterly betrayed by the megacorporation that he worked for and used as a test subject by a sadistic Mad Scientist which he himself ironically saved earlier on. After escaping from four years of experimentation and imprisonment, he takes care of his helplessly comatose fellow escapee and friend Cloud for nearly a year while running from relentless pursuers, even though it would have been much easier for Zack if he had just dumped Cloud somewhere. Ultimately, Zack confronts a massive Shinra military force in a Bolivian Army Ending because he chooses to protect Cloud instead of escaping by himself.
Zack's fellow 1st Class Soldiers Sephiroth, Genesis, and Angeal who played a big role in breaking him also count. Their issues drive the first two to villainy and the third to perform Suicide by Cop.
Kaori Yae of Tokimeki Memorial 2: she's pretty, has the overall best academic grades among the whole cast, is even better at sports than sporty heroine Hikari, and has such a natural talent at rythmic games such as Dance Dance Revolution she can play them flawlessly even on her first try; yet, due to a traumatic event in her past, she has zero social skills, as she can't trust anyone anymore, and people in return can't trust her. Her Ace skills even out if the Main Protagonist manages to help her get out of her Heroic BSOD, as she'll enter again the Volley-Ball Club and fully involves herself in, meaning her grades take a toll and become only average; and while she becomes more cheerful and open to others, she still has difficulties making friends.
The main guys of the Tokimeki Memorial Girl's Side games lean towards being Broken Aces as well. They're always smart, athletic, good-looking, and admired by their classmates, but Kei Hazuki in GS1 is deeply apathetic about most things and finds it hard to relate to others; he's often tired to the point of falling asleep in class because of his modeling jobs, which he does not because he's particularly interested in it but because he has difficulty saying no. Teru Saeki in GS2 is a worse case: he pushes himself hard to live up to other people's expectations to the point that his entire speech pattern changes depending on who he's talking to, and like Kei, he's often tired from the combined burdens of keeping up his grades, working his part-time job, and pacifying his league of fangirls.
Harken from Fire Emblem 7 is a handsome, skilled, loyal, popular knight and about to marry the local Lady of War, Isadora. He is then utterly broken by the deaths of his lord in liege and his companions at the hands of the Black Fang, and becomes a Death SeekerBlood Knight who has to be talked out from pretty much throwing himself into battle to just die and dull the pain, and is also plagued by the guilt of having almost forgotten the girl he loved in between all the angst. He gets better, thank God.
Not only that, but his supports with Marcus reveal that before he was subjected to all of that trauma, poor Harken already had serious self-worth issues coming from how his former lord of liege used and abused him and then threw him out of his household. What happened with the Black Fang was the corollary to a breaking process that lasted several years.
Fire Emblem Awakening gives us Cordelia. She's a beautiful redhead with outstanding fighting skills, a self-assured atittude and a kind heart, as well as very popular in Ylisse. However, we then find out that she loves a man she believes herself to be unworthy of, that she's thought of to be arrogant and spoiled when she's actually not, and that pretty much eaten on the inside by Survivor Guiltafter her whole squad is massacred. Not to mention, her Kid from the Future Severa has a HUGE inferiority complex due to her mother's fame, and when Cordelia died after they had a huge fight over a misunderstanding, she's totally broken.
Cherche's son Gerome is pretty much good at everything, from fighting to handling hisdragon mountto sewing. His Ace-like traits (strength, aloofness, seriousness) are because of his major trauma from losing everyone (including his parents) in the Bad Future; he might not have become so good at everything if it weren't for that, but he'd be far better off as a person.
Miranda from Mass Effect 2. Beautiful, intelligent, confident, skilled, a decent fighter and "absolutely perfect" in every aspect. And then it is revealed why she is perfect: "daddy issues" does not begin to cover it. She was genetically engineered to be absolutely perfect and capable of accomplishing anything. This causes her to view anything she accomplishes to be a result of her father's money and planning, and believes that only her mistakes are truly hers. This means that when everything goes right she has no sense of accomplishment, and when everything goes wrong or she is surpassed somehow (such as through most of the plot of the game) she feels like a complete failure, because she was given everything she needed and still managed to screw it up. Thankfully, Shepard can fix that if he/she so chooses.
Depending on how s/he's played, Shepard can be a pretty good example. During character creation, Shepard can be given a Dark and Troubled Past that would leave anyone with some serious psychological traumas; by the end of Mass Effect 3 it's possible to lose a lot of crew members and friends (and be forced to kill a few of them), commit genocide (including destroying an entire inhabited solar system to slow down the Reapers, which is not optional) and see some of the most seriously messed up sights the galaxy has to offer. Shepard may be the baddest warrior to ever live, but it's no picnic to be her/him.
Garrus Vakarian is basically Shepard's understudy and becomes a Memetic Badass between the first and second games by fighting evil mercenary groups on Omega. A deadly shot, a skilled hand-to-hand combatant, and a talented leader...who spends about half the second game obsessed with revenge against the traitor who got his squad wiped out, blaming himself for trusting said traitor, and depending on Shepard to be his rock, the person he can rely on to never betray him. In his romance with a female Shepard, he eventually admits that he's seen so much of what he's been involved with fall apart messily that he desperately wants that romance to be the one thing that goes right. He mostly grows out of it by the third game, and even switches roles so that he is the one keeping Shepard standing when everything goes to hell, even if not romanced.
Kasumi Goto is the galaxy's best master thief, a sophisticated, quick-witted, technologically adept cat-burglar who is equally at home robbing a casino and strolling around a party, but is so obsessed with her dead boyfriend that if you let her keep the graybox at the end of her loyalty mission, she begins to withdraw into those memories rather than move on with her life. Unlike many options, you don't get a chance to help her truly overcome it; Shepard's recommendations to that effect are treated to a flip dismissal, and even when you send her to help on the Crucible (assuming she was loyal; if not, she'll die/disappear), that seeming functionality is just a patch and the underlying issues are still there. Then, in the Extended Cut, you'll get a shot of her hooked up to the graybox if you pick the Destroy or Control endings, implying that she's pretty much descended into addiction; even Synthesis only keeps her functional by recreating Keiji from those memories.
Carth Onasi: Ace Pilot, decorated war veteran, and can be a genuine Nice Guy...but his mentor's betrayal, destruction of his homeworld, and loss of his family have left him with raging trust issues.
Bastila Shan: Whooooo Boy. Talented and beautiful young woman, star Padawan of the Jedi Order, mastered a rare Force ability that makes her essential to the war effort (and the only thing stopping Malak from steamrolling the galaxy), and is given most of the credit for taking down Darth Revan...but is wound up so tightly from all the pressure that she's become dogmatic, thoroughly lacks a sense of humor, and is terrified of anything that might go against the Order's dogma.
Juhani: Survived an attempted genocide by the Mandalorians, Upto Eleven levels of Fantastic Racism, crawled her way out of one of the worst slums in the galaxy and fought hard to be accepted into the Jedi, even though she was older than most trainees. Probably the best lightsaber fighter in the galaxy besides the Player Character, and holds herself to extremely high standards. Too bad she's wound up tighter than Bastila, and is a psychological mess from all the pressure she puts on herself and the unresolved childhood issues that Jedi training has done absolutely nothing to help and everything to try and repress.
Canderous Ordo: One of Mandalore's generals, commander and veteran of battles all over the galaxy for forty years. Lost it all at Malachor Five, was cracking heads for a petty crime boss, and after unraveling his Proud Warrior Race Guy persona and laundry list of battles fought? He admits he's Desperately Looking for a Purpose in Life. Even when he finds one? His gruff pride and steady persona are used as target practice when Kreia delivers a Breaking Speech about how he's really little more than Revan's "loyal beast."
Jolee Bindo: Lived in the dangerous woods of Kashyyyk, and puts on a face that's a cross of "Grumpy Old Man," and "Old Master." Fought in Exar Kun's War, was a smuggler and adventurer even when he was with the Order, and never stopped with the thrill seeking...but was really self-exiling himself over his perceived failures as a Jedi, including his failure in training his wife, who turned to the Dark Side.
The Jedi Exile in the second game? A highly charismatic Magnetic Hero, one of Revan's top generals in the Mandalorian Wars and the "Hero" of Malachor V. A grossly dysfuntional mess who can't even talk about their previous battles and so traumatised by ordering the destruction of Malachor V, that it severed their entire connection to the Force.
And then revealed to have become a Humanoid Abomination, who's Magnetic Hero qualites are the result of unknowingly creating Force-bonds which sway people to their point of view, as well as having regained the Force by pulling it out of the Force-Sensitive people around them and people they've slain in battle.
Atton? Ace Pilot, excellent smuggler, rarely loses at Pazaak, decorated vet of the Mandalorian Wars, utter Determinator when he fights... former Sith Assassin that used to get off on torturing Jedi until one showed him he was Force Sensitive and persuaded him to run away.
Bao-Dur? Gadgeteer Genius whose talents with shield technology surpasses even the Echani (who invented them). Built his own mechanical arm after losing his in battle... and made the weapon of mass destruction that won the battle at Malachor V.
Handmaiden? Daughter of an Echani general turned Senator, one of six elite guards to a Jedi Master, excellent fighter, impeccable protocol and manners... Is hated by her half-sisters just for existing (she was the product of daddy's affair with a Jedi), has such little self-esteem she doesn't feel worthy of a name, and reading her thoughts produces an endless loop of how she must learn to fight harder.
Mical: Officer and a Gentleman, Gentleman and a Scholar, spy that ostensibly works for the Republic, but might be working just for Cede or Carth, he is doing some "light" reading in a monster-infested ruins of a Jedi archive, and greets you in a formal (if a bit archaic) manner. "Broken" because being a Republic officer was merely a fallback after he spent his childhood and youth training for the Jedi, but the Wars left no one left to train him, leaving him to pick through ashes for what was left of his dream.
None of them hold a candle to Revan, in terms of Ace-ness and Broken-ness. A near perfect blend of charisma and power...which made his fall to the Dark Side all the more disastrous. There's a reason he's known as one of the galaxy's greatest heroes and as one of its worst villains.
Kyo Kusanagi's cousin and Big Brother Mentor, Souji, in The King of Fighters: KYO. He was supposed to be the true sucessor to the Kusanagi family instead of Kyo or Saisyu, and Kyo respects him to the point of calling him "Souji-san" (which considering Kyo's very rough and informal speech patterns, is very meaningful)... but he pushed himself so insanely hard that he ended up giving into his dark side and had to relay the leadership on his uncle and cousin, or he'd be consumed by his own darkness.
Samus Aran of Metroid. Beautiful, one of the greatest fighters in the galaxy, a legend in her own lifetime. Also one big bundle of neuroses, dependency issues, and survivor's guilt held together almost entirely by thoughts of vengeance most of the time.
Jin Kisaragi from BlazBlue. Handsome, smart, strong, rich, highly ranked, popular with girls despite his cold attitude, a hero for ending a long civil war, and so on. As he put it himself, he was showered with everything men would kill for. His only problem was his inability to care about all of those. However, when he found out that his brother was still alive, he snapped hard and being nihilistic turned out to be the leastdisturbingthing about him.
Makoto Nanaya shows some of this as well, though not to the same extent. She's an outstanding fighter, a massive determinator, and surprisingly smart and perceptive, with a compassionate and energetic personality to go with it, on top of being smoking hot. She also has a bit of a childish disposition, but your mileage may vary on that one. Unlike Jin, however, she was the least popular girl at school not because of any of that, but due to intense Fantastic Racism, forcing her to take on a Jerkass Façade to keep the assholes away. Her bad ending makes it worse by implying (with some undeniable evidence) that she's essentially a Pandora's Box of racism issues that she's tried to keep shut her entire life, and that the Academy bullying is the tip of the iceberg...
Hibiki from Lux-Pain is this. He's considered one of the top students of Kisaragi High school that got accepted on board to study to America, beats the Insufferable GeniusShinji at math and computers and is deemed very attractive by his peers. However, that's only on the surface reputation. To begin with his trauma, his parents died in a car accident when he was very young and it left him relatively unstable, he was taken care of by the Kisaragi nurse Honokawho later adopted him. However, he was labeled as a strange boy shortly after being released from the hospital after the accident and was isolated from his peers. Then his best friend who later because his crushRyo befriended him and he was fine...until those feelings got in the way and he got jealous of Ryo's co-worker Ai. This promotes him to leave to America but then comes back a year later thinking that his feelings were gone. They didn't go away... and he goes crazy because of his powers that were caused by his phycological pain. Whether or not he survives depends on if the player gets the normal ending or the good ending. Regardless, he lead a pretty bad life and the player can decide how it can change.
Cole Phelps in L.A. Noire is unique; Starts as a type 1, then ascends to type 2. He initially spent most of his time in the army screwing his friends over for fame and medals, then is overwhelmed by guilt shortly after attaining said fame and joins the police after the war to atone for his mistakes.
Shinjiro Aragaki of Persona 3 may qualify. When he rejoins SEES, he likely has the single greatest damage output of the group and is implied to have been the best fighter before he left in the first place. Thing is, he's being eaten away at from the inside by guilt from having accidentally killed Ken's mother two years prior.
Lots of characters in the Tales Series.Nobody in the franchise gets away with just being The Ace. You've got to get broken somehow. A few examples:
Guy and Jade both nearly fit this archetype in Tales of the Abyss. They are both extremely talented fighters. Guy is set up to be a quintessential hero, reminiscent of the protagonists of previous games - his optimistic attitude, as well as his fighting style, are very similar to Lloyd's - while Jade has the reputation and intelligence of an ace. Both of them, however, are more broken than they initially seem:
Jade, for starters, is a sociopath, whose disregard for human life and Pride pushed him to invent fomicry. After realizing the many, many horrors that his technology brought to the world, he feels so guilty that he wishes he could go back in time to kill himself as a newborn. If you think hard enough about fomicry, especially how the Big Bad plans to use it, Jade's ace tendencies basically caused every problem in the game.
Guy pretends to be confident and optimistic, and his Dynamic Entry in the first few hours of the game is so cool that when he says "enter the amazing Guy!" you're more inclined to applaud than disagree. While he's also charming enough to be a womanizer of Zelos's caliber, his gynophobia means that he's more likely to lead girls on. There's also the fact that Duke Fabre slaughtered his entire family and left him buried under a pile of corpses for several days when he was five years old. His initial goal was to kill Luke in front of his father for revenge, and thanks to the curse slot, it's confirmed that this desire is still present throughout the game despite his Undying Loyalty. Guy is much creepier than that winking face would lead you to believe.
Solid Snake is a type 2, especially in the original Metal Gear Solid. Even though he's become a legendary hero that's prevented global war, he's haunted by the things he's done and seen and often downplays his achievements.
Solid Snake: There are no heroes in war. The only heroes I know are either dead or in prison. One or the other. I'm just a man who's good at what he does: killing.
Riku- Sora's best friend from Kingdom Hearts- to an extent, at least in the very first game. Better than The Protagonist Sora and the other island kids at pretty much everything; older, stronger, cooler, more attractive, and (most importantly) seemingly "closer" to Kairi, whom he and Sora- quite awkwardly for them- both have feelings for. Riku, as a result, takes position as the leader of the group. While Sora is jealous of these aspects about Riku, it turns out later in the game that Riku is the one with a massive inferiority complex to Sora, becoming very jealous when Sora finds new friends in Donald and Goofy and Sora turns out to be the Chosen One for the Keyblade; and last but not least, it gets even worse when it turns out that Riku feels as though Kairi likes Sora more despite the fact that he (Riku) has "done more for her". The villains, naturally, exploit Riku's issues with Sora soon enough and draws him into the Darkness and have the two fighting against each other.
Eventually, Riku goes through extensive Character Development in Chain of Memories (the mid-sequel between Kingdom Hearts and Kingdom Hearts 2) when he confronts his insecurities head on. However, the sequel mostly abandons his Ace traits altogether; the plot no longer concentrates on that aspect of Riku as Sora finally takes over the leadership role permanently.
And THAT gets turned on its head in Kingdom Hearts 3D: Dream Drop Distance though in a positive way. Sora and Riku end up taking the Mark of Mastery Exam in order to deal with issues in the Worlds in the Realm of Sleep. While Riku still harbored some feelings of self-doubt (which lead to Sora agreeing to take the exam in the first place), things play out interestingly enough. Throughout the game, it's Sora who ends up going through Mind Rape via the New Organization XIII. Riku, due to said Character Development and past experiences, actually got his body immune to any Darkness based issues caused by Xehanort. In the end, after all hell breaks loose, it's Riku who ends up being named Keyblade Master over Sora. Good thing Sora is an all around Nice Guy and is genuinely happy for Riku so no jealousy issues crop up again.
Keiichi Maebara in Higurashi no Naku Koro ni. He's a perfectly kind fellow in Hinamizawa, bright in comparison to some of his peers, well known and respected by many in the village, and has a few females who have a crush on him. Oh, and in the past, he went on a (non-lethal) shooting rampage because all his peers had grown jealous of his talent and bullied him. Let's not even get started on other situations in the present times...
Amusingly, Ace from Nine Hours, Nine Persons, Nine Doors is this. He's smart, noble, self-sacrificing, and the sole culprit of the deaths that take place, as well as the ruthless and antisocial owner of the evil pharmaceutical company.
Saber in Fate/stay night, toward the end of her life. She suffered in her Masquerade out of duty, and became broken when it seemed to her that her country would've been better off if she hadn't tried, and someone else taken the role.
Gilgamesh. The greatest of all Heroic Spirits, the "King of Heroes", and wielder of some of the most powerful Noble Phantasms in existence...whose ego was left unchecked after the loss of his Only Friend Enkidu.
Souji in Suika is good at essentially everything: handsome, popular and a complete chick magnet, but has been using these as part of a fake persona out of trauma for eight years.
Phoenix Wright: Ace Attorney has a few. Adrian Andrews is cool and professional to hide the fact that she's got a severe codependency problem and is still aching from the trauma of her mentor Celeste Inpax's suicide, a fact that Franziska takes full advantage of. When she shows up again her demeanor is far changed. She's flightier and less professional, but also seems happier.
Manfred von Karma is like a Broken Ace factory. His daughter Franziska is a prosecuting prodigy who won her first case at thirteen, but she's got a mad obsession with perfection and one-upping her adopted brother Miles Edgeworth. Edgeworth himself has a lessened obsession with winning, but is haunted by suspicions that he killed his father.
Edgeworth's worse than that — he is undoubtedly an excellent prosecutor, known both as "The Demon Prosecutor" and "King of Prosecutors" in-universe and is apparently so handsome that almost every woman (and possibly some of the men) develop crushes on him on sight, but not only is he so haunted by his father's murder that he has screaming nightmares every night until Phoenix Wright solves the case, he's also terrified of small spaces, heights, and earthquakes because it took place in an elevator to the point where he passes out on turbulent airplanes and is so socially inept that he has no friends, doesn't understand basic social protocol, and doesn't notice when or understand why people would flirt with him.
Lucan from (P)lanets. He's as handsome as a prince, just as kind as one, and is so popular and loved by everyone that he has an Instant Fanclub of two hundred girls. Except that he really doesn't want the attention and the main reason he's so popular in the first place is that he brainwashed them with his Mind Control psych into loving him due to his loneliness and belief that he's so pathetic that they couldn't possibly love his true self. The brainwashing was largely unintentional on his part and he's meant to be a sympathetic version of this trope, but that's still one hell of a warped facade to live with. Lucan is so Broken that he is the only choice that can lead to a Bad Ending. If Marin rejects him after learning his dark secret, he takes it so badly that he intentionally brainwashes Marin into loving him.
In Nameless - The One Thing You Must Recall - Tei. He's the most handsome, most popular, and most mature of the dolls, but it's a a front he's viciously maintaining to mask the fact that his self loathing has reached the level of dangerous unbalance.
Yuuji in Grisaia No Kajitsu is very intelligent and experienced with a wide range of skills, but beneath the surface are many hints of deep depression and self loathing. Grisaia No Meikyuu explains how those parts of himself got there. Grisaia No Rakuen shows that his shattered psychological state was in fact much worse than it seemed at the end of the preceding story though he finally does find true peace at the end when he, the Mihama girls, Chizuru, JB and Kazuki all set up a new Mihama on a southern island granted to him by Asako.
Homestuck's Dirk is a perfect example. At first glance, he appears to be completely flawless - he is a Badass of the highest caliber, is an incredibly skilled engineer capable of creating fully-sentient virtual clones of himself, and has his group's session of Sburball planned out. The reality, though, is quite different: he suffers from severe psychological trauma from being born in a Bad Future, and is one of only two humans left alive on Earth. His Bro, his one guardian figure who he clearly adored, was murdered prior to his birth, leaving him forced not only to raise himself with nothing but a Demonic Dummy for company, but to live up to the legacy of his heroic and Shrouded in Myth ancestor. Due to the pain this famous ancestor inflicted upon the ruling empress, Dirk is top on her hit list. On top of all this, he has developed a crush on Jake, who was born 400 years in the past and who he may not even meet, yet alone get to confess his feelings to. As The Stoic, he's unable to confide in anyone, leaving him the heroic equivalent of a ticking time bomb - though from what we've seen so far, he'll probably be okay.
Vriska could also count. From the outside, she's a wild, powerful, and intensely confident Pirate Girl who has her friends wrapped around her little finger. As time goes on, though, it becomes more and more clear that her desire to live up to what she believes her ancestor is has turned her insensitive to the point of a Jerkass Sue, which has driven away all of her friends, including her crush and her moirail, something she claims to not care about but which she really does. Despite acting confident, she lapses into worrying Self-Deprecation at times. Also, as Terezi points out, she can only manipulate people through mind control since she's too impatient and reckless to actually play people properly. Basically all of her plans fail, and the one thing that actually does go right for her - becoming God Tier - only happened when Aradia beat her up in revenge and left her to bleed to death slowly...and then it all ended up being pointless anyway, since the one time it would have actually helped, she is killed beforehand since even if she won, Karkat and Terezi would still have died. In the end, the one person who had ever believed in her, John, later admits that she was just some weird psychotic girl who kind of had a crush on him one day a long time ago.Ouch.
Artie of Narbonic has undertones of this. He is 6+ ft tall with a perfect body, has an IQ that is literally beyond human possibility, has won several genius grants, is quite successful as a novelist, and as of Skin-Horse, is seen to have an endless stream of one night stands with other gorgeous men. Hell, as of Skin-Horse he is described exactly by the trope description if you add Civil Rights Leader to the list. But on the inside, he is nearly continually disappointed with himself, and struggles to deal with his dual nature as a human and a gerbil and his place in the transgenic community. He isn't quite completely broken, but he is as close as you can get without becoming so.
Atop the Fourth Wall: Linkara has more than a few elements of this. He's a nice-looking hero with wonderful toys and True Companions around him — but he wants so badly to be a good guy and to think that he's much more than his Channel Awesome co-workers. He has a Small Name, Big Ego: his number one priority seems to be whether the fans watch him or not and his Comedic Sociopathynote Wanting to rule the nation on his own turns into "I am the liberator of Kickassia" is far creepier than the others because whereas they embrace it, he denies it. The post-Entity storyline has people calling him out on how broken he is, and tell him that he's close to becoming an outright villain.
Phase (Ayla Goodkind) of the Whateley Universe. He's Exemplar hot, he has a gorgeous girlfriend, he's made himself a fortune in the past year, he speaks multiple languages, he has superpowers that make him a threat against most mutants, he's a gourmet... and he is tortured by the fact that his family hates him because he turned into a mutant.
Pyrrha Nikos, of RWBY, is a Type 1. She's wise, unfailingly kind, and an epic warrior even by Remnant's standards, which led the fanbase to consider her a Purity Sue...before Volume 2, which revealed that she is incredibly lonely because no-one ever sees her as an equal, or even a normal person. It wasn't until she entered Beacon Academy that she found true friends who didn't exploit her fame or put her on a pedestal. (One of the reasons she sticks by Jaune so adamantly is that he's the first person she met who was like that.)
Princess Azula from Avatar: The Last Airbender, though she doesn't really bother with the good publicity part of Villain with Good Publicity, still fits. She's a beautiful, extraordinarily talented young woman, even if she isDaddy's Little Villain, but most of her exterior aloofness and obsession with power stems from being desperate to ignore how utterly psychotic she is thanks to her thinking that her mother hated her. Same inside, same overcompensation, different shell.
In the Search, she starts hallucinating visions of her mother regularly, and her only goal at this point (and the reason she went along with Zuko in the first place) is to find and kill Ursa. By the end of Part 3 she might potentially be on the road to recovery. She had an easy chance to kill Ursa (who didn't know she was Ursa at the time...It Makes Sense in Context) but Zuko was able to talk her down and she left on her own accord. Now if she finds out what Ursa actually did to lead them to that point...she might snap again, potentially justified in doing so.
The second flavor fits as well. She has some serious issues with perfectionism, thanks to her desperation to win her father's favor and not turn out like her brother.
Harvey Dent is often portrayed this way before he becomes Two-Face, particularly in Batman: The Animated Series. Fantastically successful District Attorney, beautiful fiancee, best friends with Bruce Wayne, one of Gotham's wealthiest citizens from one of its older families -but Dent's long-term mental issues of anger repression and dividing his vicious side from his lawful side catch up with him -with terrible results. Bruce never gives up on him, though.
Vlad Masters in Danny Phantom. Despite being the Big Bad, to the public's eye, he is a well-known and well-respected billionaire celebrity and later mayor. He's handsome, debonair, intelligent, and in his ghost form, clearly a better fighter then the hero is. And yet, his big ego prevents him from gaining the love of his life and Danny as a surrogate son because he is too deep in denial to realize he's getting love in all the wrong ways. This bites him in the ass hard in the Grand Finale.
Olga Pataki of Hey Arnold!. She looks perfect on first glance, being very good at academics, music, has a personality many consider pleasant, and is considered very beautiful. However, with enough pressure this facade of perfection can crack... revealing a young woman who's horribly neurotic, unstable and melodramatic due to having to live up to her parents' constant attention and enormously high standards, as well as dangerously out of reality. In Olga's own words to her little sister Helga: "You're lucky[our parents] don't even notice you."
Billy in Adventure Time. He is ahem "~THE GREATEST WARRIOR EVER / A HERO OF RENOWN! / WHO SLAYED AN EVIL OCEAN / WHO CAST THE LICH KING DOWN! / [...] / ALSO, HE FOUGHT A BEEEEEAAAAAR!~". However, since doing all sorts of similar heroic deeds in the past, and becoming a role model for Finn and Jake, he's holed up in his secret crack and stopped fighting evil with violence, because he's seen that doing so in the Land Of Ooo is useless. He tries to convince Finn and Jake that fighting evil in that way is "as pointless as a dog chasing his own tail."
In Recess a one-shot character arrives at the school who is better than everyone in everything ever. He is the very image of a Marty Stu...who is desperately lonely because his talent makes everyone he meets resent him. As long as he remains true to himself, he can't make friends.
Eddie Brock, as seen in The Spectacular Spider Man. He is introduced as Peter Parker's Big Brother Mentor who playfully teases him, puts his life on the line often in supervillain attacks, has a great job with the Connors, and is overall a nice, friendly guy. When things start to not go his way, however, his true colors are revealed: He truly hates Peter and is jealous of him because when their parents died, Pete was raised by his aunt and uncle, he was orphaned, his "teasing" of him is actually belittling him, his "self-less" flirtations with life are his Death Seeker tendencies, and considers the Connors to be his only "family", so his resentment of Peter grows when he accidentally causes him to be fired from his job.
Chalky Studebaker from Doug is a mild example. Exposed in an episode where Doug is accused of cheating off of Chalky. Doug and Chalky's papers for a test are near identical, and since Chalky is The Ace, everyone assumes Doug was the one who cheated. (Despite the test being a mere "B"). Doug has to chase down Chalky to confront him about it, and ends up being exposed to Chalky's trophy case, which is not as big or filled as his older brother's. Chalky's dad gives obvious encouragement towards getting all the trophies, showing the "Well Done, Son!" Guy side of Chalky. After Doug flat tells Chalky's father that he cheated, Chalky proceeds to break down and say that he just wasn't able to keep up with all of the different trophy earning activities AND keep up his grades and finally admitted to cheating.
An episode of Beetlejuice had the Ghost with the Most going into a funk after being constantly upstaged by his insufferably cheerful, goody two-shoes brother Donnie. When BJ goes on a "mope-about" in the Down-and-Outback, Donnie and Lydia go to rescue him. But after getting hit by a "gloom-a-rang", Donnie goes into a funk too and admits that he knows full well how much his perpetually cheery attitude annoys people. Donnie doesn't cheer up again until Beetlejuice admits that he doesn't really hate his brother.
In the Grand Finale of Spider-Man: The Animated Series, Spider-man teams up with a bunch of Spider-mans from alternate realities. One of them has a suit of armor similar to Iron Man. He is rich, the head of his own corporation, loved by everyone in his city, engaged to Gwen Stacy, J. Jonah Jameson is his godfather, Wilson Fisk is his lawyer, and Uncle Ben is still alive. He is in short, everything that Spider-man isn't. He's also a cocky, egotistical, Jerkass, and his Leeroy Jenkins tendencies result in both him and another member of the team being injured.
The Outrider from The Venture Bros. is like this, though what exactly is broken is not immediately obvious. He's a powerful mage and superhero who is handsome, charismatic, and manages to balance his work with his personal life in a way that his rival Dr. Orpheus (and, indeed, most of the other characters on the show) just can't. However, it's revealed that he was only able to do this by taking risky shortcuts to power that, though they paid off, left him vulnerable in ways Dr. Orpheus isn't. Also, he's a bit of a jerk.
An episode of Alvin and the Chipmunks has a one-episode character who is good at everything, which pushes all of Alvin's competitive buttons. But the episode also shows that the case full of trophies and his working spaceship built as a science project don't keep his parents from leaving him with the butler and travelling around the world, sometimes remembering to drop him a postcard, maybe. The boy deeply envies Alvin and his brothers for their loving father. Admitting this and his loneliness enable him and Alvin to become friends.
In The Powerpuff Girls, Blossom seems to feel that if she isn't perfect, her life is worthless, as shown in "Power-Noia". She also runs away from home after making a few simple mistakes, such as spilling tea and knocking over a toy tower, in "Not-So Awesome Blossom".
Rick Sanchez of Rick and Morty is a genius scientist and inventor who builds robots for fun and invented inter-dimensional travel. He's also a raging alcoholic (being drunk almost all of the time) and snorts crystals (in a thinly veiled reference to crystal meth and cocaine) while being neglectful (if not abusive) to his family. His catchphrase "Wubba Lubba Dub Dub" translates to "I am in great pain, please help me" which is why he tries to numb his emotions with substances. Nevertheless he almost always is able to save the day (even if it was mostly his fault to begin with)
Often, people with Narcissistic Personality Disorder or sociopathy can become type 1 if they reach a position of high power.
Similar can be said of those with an Inferiority Complex, except they tend to be a type 2 - regardless of what they've achieved, it will never be good enough.
People tend to perceive actors and people in Hollywood as this (although sometimes it's more a case of a masquerade finally breaking.) If a mostly level-headed actor (not a typical Hollywood train wreck such as Charlie Sheen or Lindsay Lohan) does something like check into rehab, file for divorce, or declare bankruptcy, it tends to shock people on the gossip circuits. If (and inevitably, when) they do a special on the person, expect the very beginning of it to say something to the effect of "they're rich, beautiful, talented, successful... what went wrong?"
American Founding Father Alexander Hamilton—whose face is on the ten-dollar bill—was the ultimate Broken Ace: he was one of the few famous Founders not to come from a land-wealthy family. Hamilton went from a poor orphan boy in the West Indies to Revolutionary War hero and father of American finance out of his sheer force of will. Meanwhile, his father left the family when Alexander was ten, his mother died of yellow fever two years later, his cousin who was supposed to take care of him and his brother committed suicide, one of his best friends died in battle, his eldest son died in a duel, causing his eldest daughter to become mentally unstable. Contemporaries routinely described him as cocky, strident, fiercely opinionated, and hot-tempered yet there is much evidence to suggest that for most of his adult life he was chonically insecure about his humble origins and being a bastard child and that he was constantly haunted by fears of not amounting to much as a statesman.
General George S. Patton was one of the most famous figures of World War II, both for his brash, domineering attitude and the fact that he was a brilliant General. However, he also struggled a great deal with his self-esteem and believed he would never live up to his father's reputation.
Others view him as a type 1, such as the film Patton, which portrays him as a General Ripper tolerated only because his results were good.
Tyra Banks, a beautiful girl who is one of the most successful supermodels and also intelligent and attending Harvard on top of it. Also happens to meet all the criteria for being a narcissist.
Some of this has slowly been creeping through during her time on America's Next Top Model. The fact that the judges have constantly rotated in and out for starters, but the most telling was her meltdown on Tiffany in Cycle 4. Tiffany's crime? She took her elimination in stride. It was explained as Tyra being angry with her for wasting such a great opportunity, but a lot of people saw it as Tyra being outraged that she wasn't crushed by her rejection.
Michael Jackson was the King of Pop and had a star-studded life. Deep down, though, he didn't want to be a star; he wanted to have a real childhood.
Ernest Hemingway was a renowned writer but had a miserable life. Traumatized by war, unable to stay in a romantic relationship, he eventually killed himself.
Doug Walker. Attractive, popular, funny, eloquent and surrounded by people who love him, but has a Guilt Complex the size of Texas. You can pop on any of his anniversary commentaries to find that out.
Pete Wentz. Member of one of the most popular bands of the 2000s, crush for thousands of teenage girls from 2005-2007 - Rolling Stone called him "the RPatz of his time" - excellent lyricist, suffers from Bipolar Disorder and nearly took his own life in 2005 just before his band got huge.
Professional golfer Tiger Woods: During the Turn of the Millennium, he experienced a meteoric rise to the top spot in golf, not just among his contemporaries but of all time. He won an unprecedented number of major and minor tournaments, coming one win away from achieving a Grand Slam (winning all four major golf tournaments in one year), which no one has completed under the current requirements. Then his infamous sex scandal broke in 2009, where he was revealed to have at least a double-digit number of mistresses, leading to a divorce from his wife, a shift in public perception from awe and admiration to ridicule and suspicion, and a career slump that he has yet to recover from.