You only went a year before you used a gun?
So you've got a hero. He's a really good hero, and he has rules
(heroes often do, after all). Let's say, hypothetically, that one of those rules is that he'll never use a gun
. Maybe his parents were brutally murdered in front of him with one, spurring him into heroism in the first place.
Whatever. The guy doesn't use guns.
Then something bad happens. The stakes go up.
Maybe a villain bent on bringing about universal entropy
arrives. The hero's pushed to his absolute limit. The world, even the universe, is hanging in the balance. There's only one way to put things right. The hero picks up the weapon...
Batman's Got a Gun.
Can, and often does, overlap with Let's Get Dangerous
, Big Damn Heroes
, OOC Is Serious Business
, and/or Despair Event Horizon
. It's a kind of Godzilla Threshold
. Pretty much always results in an Oh, Crap
moment for the villain. Can be a Moment Of Awesome
, but it will always
be Played for Drama
. This trope isn't just a hero doing something they wouldn't normally do. It's a hero doing something they're fundamentally against
(see the examples below). If they've done it before (at least in that continuity), it isn't this trope. It's also not this trope if they almost
break their rule but then don't; Batman
and the Doctor
particularly have a bad habit of almost breaking their rule, or breaking their rule in a hallucination/alternate timeline/dream sequence… none of which is this trope. This is the hero breaking their golden rule
Happens most frequently to the Retired Badass
, Knight in Shining Armor
, or Invincible Hero
, often during a What You Are in the Dark
moment. Contrast the Frequently-Broken Unbreakable Vow
When adding examples, please be sure to mention for the sake of clarity what the rule is that's being broken. Also, please don't bother with examples of almost
breaking their rule; characters who have a prominent rule tend to frequently be pushed/tempted/pressured to break it, but it's only this trope if and when they actually do. Otherwise, every fifth Joker
story would count, as would about fifty Doctor Who
episodes. This trope is about the first
time the rule is broken (though of course with alternate continuities and such a character might have more than one "first" time breaking their vow), not subsequent breaks or near misses.
Named for Batman's use of a gun during Grant Morrison
's Final Crisis
open/close all folders
Anime And Manga
- Rurouni Kenshin uses this trope during the Kyoto arc, when Kenshin tries to rescue a baby named Iori from Chou, the Sword Hunter. Chou kidnapped the baby for forcing his parent to tell him the location of the last sword ever made by the legendary sword-smith Shakku Arai, Iori's grandfather. Kenshin manages to pull a fight even though his reversed-bladed sword is broken, but Chou eventually disarms him. When everything seems lost, Iori's father appears and gives Kenshin Shakku Arai's last sword. However, Kenshin hesitates, since using a normal sword means that he will almost certainly kill Chou, which would break his oath of never killing a man ever again. Only when Chou threatens to kill Iori on the spot, Kenshin snaps out of it and defeats Chou with a single blow. Then everyone realizes that the sword was also reverse-bladed, so Chou naturally has survived.
- Trigun: Vash uses guns all the time. However, as a master of Improbable Aiming Skills, he uses it solely for trick shots, and when in serious trouble, will at most shoot a person somewhere where they'll heal. He doesn't believe in a situation where you can't save everyone. However, at one point, he is given a true no-win scenario, where the villain sets up a situation that will result in the death of his friends, unless the villain is killed (he has... issues). After much hesitation, Vash kills him. He doesn't take it well. Bear in mind that this was merely The Dragon he killed, and getting himself shot was the whole point.
- Oddly enough Vash was almost willing to kill someone much earlier in the series for killing a few dozen people. But that side of him was pretty much never seen again after.
- Miria in Claymore breaks her one rule of never killing fellow Claymores during her battle against Hysteria the Elegant, as that was the only way to end the fight before a recently Awakened Cassandra killed all her allies.
- Monster: One of the major theme of the manga is the mental and physical tribulation of Dr. Tenma as he's forced to pick up a gun to hunt and kill a monster he unknowingly saved. This trope already has a bleak atmosphere hanging around it, but it's pushed to the realm of Deconstruction in his case. In the end, he didn't kill anyone. Not even The Dragon of said monster he thought he killed. Not the monster himself, the final confrontation with whom put the life of a child at stake.
- Fullmetal Alchemist: In his battle with Wrath near the end of the series, Scar breaks his code as an Ishvalan and uses Alchemy to reconstruct matter, thus regaining the upper hand. Up until that point, he only used his abilities to destroy things and so remained technically within the bounds of his code against it.
- In Zatch Bell! The heroes are fighting Zeon's co-dragons in an attempt to stop Faudo, a giant demon who towers over small mountain ranges. Things are not going well they are getting defeated one by one when Umagon desperately starts raising the heat in the area with his flame spells. The villains are confused at first, since there isn't enough heat to burn the Demon's book, which would take him out of the fight, then we get the truth: Umagon isn't trying to burn the demon's book, he is trying to boil the demon's human partner alive.
- Nanashi in Sword of the Stranger has his sword bound with a rope, and he has vowed not to draw it. You know where this is going - as he draws his sword at the climax, shit gets real.
- The Trope Namer: Batman breaking out a gun as his "once in a lifetime exception" to try and kill Darkseid during Final Crisis.
- There are numerous counter-examples (his 1939-1940 version (now out of continuity) used a gun occasionally, and there are isolated stories here and there where he uses one as a threat or a tool), but as far as the spirit of the trope goes, Final Crisis is the only current in-continuity example of Batman using a gun with intent to harm/kill and going through with it, and even the current page image from Batman: Year 2 had him not pull the trigger in the end thanks to circumstances outside of his control.
- This is all of course separate from "out of the field" use of a gun such as for ballistics analysis.
- Daredevil attempted this after Bullseye killed Elektra, but Bullseye survived.
- Dick Grayson broke his no-killing rule after he believed The Joker had murdered Tim Drake.
- Pretty common in general among the Gotham heroes, as it happened with Catwoman against Black Mask.
- Two-Face had a villainous one a long time ago, choosing to ignore his coin to spare Batman's life.
- Superman finds himself forced to execute Kryptonians of a "pocket universe" after they have killed almost everybody in their universe. This experience eventually causes him a breakdown. Superman at Earth's End has Superman use a (very) heavy machine gun to kill twin clones of Hitler and zombie Batman.
- An aversion in the final issue of Richard Dragon's series. He's sworn off killing, and SPECIFICALLY sworn off using the deadly Leopard Blow, but resolves to kill one final time (specifically, to kill his love interest/arch enemy Lady Shiva) to save the life of a young boy. During the climactic battle with Shiva, he has her set up for the blow, and attempts to deliver it, but is tackled away by her ninjas and killed shortly thereafter. It is worth mentioning that large parts of this series have been booted from canon.
- Subverted during an arc of X-Men: Professor X, of all people, is packing heat. But it's only to use as a last resort on himself to prevent any evil force from "hijacking" his brain (arguably one of the greatest weapons in the Marvel Universe). When faced with such a threat... he does not go through with it, giving the entity a chance to leave his mind before he fires. Things go downhill from there...
- Spider-Man in the Back in Black arc nearly fits this trope. After Aunt May is shot by a hit man, Peter flips out and dons his black costume. He goes around the town beating anyone remotely involved with the shooting until he finally meets the main villain, Kingpin. If Kingpin had a fair chance against Spidey during the 1970s and 1980s, we don't see it here: In the end Kingpin is left bleeding and broken with a promise, if/when May dies, Kingpin will follow. There is a What If… story where MJ takes the bullet and dies, and Peter goes on full rampage and in the end punches Kingpin through the heart. Try to remember, this is from the "friendly neighborhood" Spider-Man.
- In Superior Spider-Man, Spidey/Dr. Octopus confronts the murderer Massacre after he escapes and begins to kill again. In his anger, the web-slinger snatches a fallen gun and shoots him in the leg, then puts the gun to his head. At that moment, Massacre, who had no emotions thanks to a horrible accident that damaged his brain, started feeling fear. Despite the pleas from Ghost!Peter, Ock has no remorse for such a callous killer and shoots him dead.
- Rom Spaceknight usually follows Thou Shalt Not Kill, but made an exception for Hybrid when he realized his Neutralizer couldn't banish a human-Wraith hybrid to Limbo and that Hybrid was too evil and dangerous to be allowed to live.
- In Starman, Jack Knight kills exactly twice: the first was Kyle, the son of the Mist, while the second was Medphyll, a Green Lantern-turned-traitor. Both weighed heavily on his mind, especially the first one, and he eventually meets them in the afterlife and makes peace with them thanks to his brother David.
- Adrian Veidt/Ozymandias in Watchmen spent his crimefighting career as a friendly, idealistic and well-liked superhero who refused to kill and cooperated with the authorities. Then he became convinced that only he could save the world, and embarked on a horrific campaign that culminated in the mass murder of three million New Yorkers.
- At the climax of Whatever Happened To The Man Of Tomorrow, Superman is forced to kill Mr. Mxyzptlk (who has decided to try being evil for a few years- definitely not good when you consider his Reality Warper powers) by splitting him between the Phantom Zone and Mxyzptlk's home dimension. He regrets this so much that he uses Gold Kryptonite on himself (robbing him of his powers) and walks out into the frozen wastes to his death... or so the media says.
- In Things to Do in Denver When You're Dead, protagonist Jimmy the Saint spends the last twenty minutes or so of the movie doing all the things he spent the whole movie trying to avoid doing.
- In Wizards, Actual Pacifist wizard Avatar confronts his evil brother Blackwolf, and rather than engage him in a Wizard Duel, simply pulls out a gun and shoots him dead.
- In The Rundown, the Rock's character refuses to pick up a gun the entire movie, maintaining that "bad things happen" when he does. When he gets into a tight spot in the end, he does end up using guns — and it's awesome.
- In Unforgiven, William Munny avoids drinking because his wife "cured" him of such vices before she died. When Little Bill kills Ned, Munny finishes the Kid's bottle of whiskey and goes on a Roaring Rampage of Revenge.
- The Dark Knight Saga:
- In The Dark Knight, The Joker tells Batman that "tonight [he's] going to break [his] one rule". Batman's reply is "I'm considering it." He doesn't. Then, at the end, Batman tackles Harvey Dent, who falls of a ledge and dies. Depending on your interpretation, The Joker was either completely wrong (if it was an accident) or just one day off (if it wasn't), or Batman simply miscalculated the strength that was sufficient to subdue Dent in the heat of the moment (again, if it was an accident).
- During the final confrontation in The Dark Knight Rises, Batman seems completely willing to kill Bane, and isn't simply considering it, as he repeats his opponent's earlier threat to make him suffer a horrible death in a ironic way. Bane himself prefers hand-to-hand neck-snaps over gun executions, but after being beaten to an inch of his life and planning on dying either way, uses a gun to make sure Batman STAYS dead. And ironically, is shot in the face by Catwoman riding the batcycle. Finally, Batman himself personally shoots TWO PEOPLE with explosive rounds, but by then he's only got minutes to prevent an atomic bomb from killing twelve million people.
- The series itself inverts this in his character backstory. His first method of dealing with injustice in this series was going to be to shoot his parents' murderer, Joe Chill (fortunately for Bruce, the mob got to Chill first). It's his shame over this incident in reflection that causes him to adopt his normal rule about not using them.
- In The Omega Man it is actually one of the villains who suddenly picks up a gun he has secretly been carrying in order to use it against the protagonist. This is despite being a member of a cult of mutated technophobes who refuses to use complex devises on ideological grounds and who wants both technology and the protagonist destroyed.
- In Star Wars, Obi-Wan Kenobi hates using blasters, finding them uncivilized and crude. But in Revenge of the Sith, when it's the only weapon available, he grabs one to kill General Grievous. Afterward, he throws it away and remarks "so uncivilized.", as a humorous Call Forward to A New Hope.
- Played for Laughs in Spaceballs: Lone Starr hands Vespa a laser gun, and tells her to hold off the Mooks pursuing them. Vespa refuses, exclaiming that she hates guns. However, after one of the mooks gives her a Close-Call Haircut, she gets so mad, she promptly shoots all of them down.
- In The Dresden Files, Harry has been offered incredible power, often at terrible prices, throughout the series. He's always refused, though at the same time has always been tempted by that power. Offers range from the addictive draw of pure Black Magic, the eternal knowledge and power of a Fallen Angel, the possible godlike power of the Darkhallow, and the standing offer by Mab, Queen of the Winter Court, to become her Knight. Harry steadfastly resists all of these offers, as he knows that succumbing to these temptations will destroy him as a person. Then the bad guys kidnap his daughter, and Harry accepts Mab's offer to become her Knight.
- Earlier on, he threatens to pull everything listed above to his advantage if Mavra the Black Court Vampiress ever does harm to his friends again (especially Murphy). The threat is so effective that Mavra hasn't been seen or heard from since.
- In many Discworld novels, Sam Vimes thinks about how he's afraid of what he might become if he started acting outside the law, and hopes he never finds something awful enough to make him cross the line. In Snuff, he finally finds it.
- Happens in Agatha Christie's Curtain: Although Hercule Poirot has never shot or killed anyone until now, the fact that Stephen Norton can never be tried or connected to the murders that he gets away with puts the lives of the entire UK in danger, leaving it hanging in the balance while Poirot is dying of a heart condition; and he is pushed to the absolute limit so much that he has no other option but to shoot Norton dead in order to stop anymore crimes from happening. He could not say whether it was right to kill, but he is sure that it's for the benefit of everyone.
- In Harry Potter And The Order Of The Phoenix, Harry uses the Cruciatus Curse, one of the three Unforgivable Curses, on Bellatrix Lestrange after she kills Sirius.
- He uses it again, as well as another of the Unforgivable Curses (the Imperious Curse), during the course of Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows. It's telling of just how dark and desperate things have gotten.
- Famously done in Magnum, P.I. with Magnum shooting an unarmed man.
- Leverage: Elliot Spencer does not like guns. He never said he couldn't use them.
- White Collar's Neal snaps in this manner in the second season episode Point Blank, when he has a chance to encounter and kill the man who he believes killed Kate. All of his friends are so worried about him being in this state that when Mozzie finds out he's got a gun, he immediately calls Peter, an FBI agent, which is his equivalent of this trope.
- Interestingly, that episode actually makes a couple of Batman references early on, so it's entirely possible that Jeff Eastin is One of Us and decided to give us tropers a Shout-Out.
- Person of Interest: When Carter's son is kidnapped, the very anti-gun/anti-weapon Finch is so desperate to help save him that he picks up a gun and asks Reese to teach him how to use it, though he's quite realistic on what sort of assistance he'd be able to give even with a gun. Reese, however, refuses to teach Finch and instead suggests that Finch perform the very valuable assistance of being ready with the get-away car.
- The title character of Chuck hates firearms, preferring tranquilizer guns. The only time he uses one is when his girlfriend and partner Sarah is being threatened.
- John Drake in Danger Man rarely uses a gun, to the point where when he does it's actually a shock. In the entire run of the series, Drake shoots only one person (not counting a later episode with gunplay that ends up being All Just a Dream).
- The main character in The Prisoner never uses a gun, until the events of the final episode push him too far. (Some believe the character is the aforementioned John Drake.)
- In the Star Trek: The Next Generation episode "The Most Toys", Data witnesses Fajo murder one of his employees with a weapon that was banned because of the slow, excruciating manner in which it kills. Her death is so brutal, in fact, that it even Fajo is clearly disturbed by it—so much so that he throws the weapon aside in disgust. Data, an android who's actions are strictly governed by ethics software, picks up the disruptor, aims it at Fajo, and talks himself into pulling the trigger. Fortuitous timing on Chief O'Brien's part saved Fajo, but tellingly, Data lies to Riker in his report of the incidentnote Riker doesn't buy it, but lets it slide.
- In Doctor Who the Doctor is a Technical Pacifist that has replaced someone's gun with a banana on at least one occasion. Even if he does resort to using weapons in dire situations, he'll try to avoid a gun and go for something explosives-related. This is especially prominent in the new series, for where 'never carries a weapon' went from a small exchange between the Fourth Doctor (who actually Does Like Guns, but doesn't carry one unless he knows he's going to need one) and Leela to a key part of the Doctor's characterisation:
- In "The End of Time" he pointedly refuses Wilf's old war pistol to use against the Master... but the moment he hears that the Time Lords are about to return, he grabs it with zero hesitation. And subverted, oddly enough, with the Doctors most violent and least hopeful incarnation, the War Doctor, who picks up a gun only to use it to write "No More" during the Fall of Arcadia.
- The reason for using this only in extremes is unintentionally revealed in "The Seeds of Doom". Yes, it's tons of fun watching the Doctor punch people in the groin, but yes, the bad guys are just humans or a recycled Axon suit spraypainted green, meaning the fact that the Doctor spends the entire story breaking necks, shooting guns and mixing Molotov cocktails comes across as rather unnecessary and out-of-character.
- The first time the Doctor uses a gun, according to a list on the subject in DWM is in "Day of the Daleks", where he disintegrates an Ogron. The first time he holds a gun is in "The Gunfighters", where he observes "People keep handing me guns. I do wish they wouldn't."
- Macgyver is known for never using guns, but he did actually use one in the pilot episode. Probably more Early Installment Weirdness than this trope, though.
- Faith from Mirrors Edge applies to this based on her personal politics and ignoring player cruelty potential; considering her mother was shot for protesting, her sister is a cop and the player is generously awarded for not so much as shooting anyone, you know Faith is pissed when she's pointing a gun at an officer (though she seems to have remarkably few qualms about punting said cops off the roofs of buildings).
- Played with in Metal Gear Solid 4: Guns of the Patriots, with Snake's rule not to use CQC (added to the series in Metal Gear Solid 3: Snake Eater, a prequel, so presumably Snake knew it since before Metal Gear), because of Big Boss' betrayal of FOXHOUND. He uses it because his first response to someone using it on him is to respond in kind. While Liquid, Ocelot, Gray Fox and Solidus might have known it, they all either had their own highly effective fighting styles, or were just never never in a situation where they would use it.
- Done subtly in Revengeance. Raiden says multiple times that he fights for justice, and he sees his sword as a tool to protect people weaker than himself. However, over the course of the game, he slowly starts going back on this, being forced to nearly kill a kid and unleash his psychotic Jack the Ripper persona to defeat his enemies. This comes to a head in the final battle where he has to use Sam's sword against Armstrong, proclaiming "This isn't MY sword!" and going to town on his opponent. Armstrong seems proud of him, using his dying words to congratulate him for shedding his ideals and being willing to kill. This rocks Raiden to his core as he realises everything he's had to give up to win. After all is said and done, it's clear in end that he's starting to feel Not So Different from his foes.
- Played brilliantly straight in Devil May Cry 3. Dante and Vergil are the twin sons of the Legendary Dark Knight Sparda. Dante chose to fight the demons while Vergil joined them. Dante uses his pistols, Ebony and Ivory, and his sword, Rebellion; Vergil believes guns are dishonorable, choosing to use only his katana, Yamato. However, when push comes to shove, Vergil ends up taking one of Dante's guns and the pair shoot Arkham simultaneously, finishing him off.
- In Batman: Vengeance, Batman is forced to use Mr. Freeze's cryo-gun after defeating the madman, whose helmet had started to show cracks. After encasing Freeze in a block of ice, the Dark Knight rather irritably throws the gun to one side.
- Batman: Arkham City doesn't have the Dark Knight use a gun, but he does resort to lethal force against two separate opponents. Fully justified in both cases; the first is Solomon Grundy, who cannot be stopped by anything less, and the other is Clayface, who is effectively immune to all of Batman's conventional tactics.
- Xenogears: For the first half of the game, Citan only fights with his bare hands. During the escape from Solaris, he pulls out a sword. He says that he had sworn to himself he'd never use it again, but with the state of the world being what it is, he can't afford to be self-righteous and try to keep his "innocence."
- South Park: The Stick of Truth has your character, the New Kid (or Douchebag) trained in mystical magical arts (or rather, magical farts) by several different teachers. All of them close their lessons by warning Douchebag to never, ever, fart on a man's balls. However, when Princess Kenny betrays your side and ingests the Nazi Zombie serum, then withstands all of your allies' most powerful attacks in the final battle, Cartman says that their one hope is for Douchebag to break the "Gentleman's Oath", and fart on your enemy's balls. Doing so is the only way to defeat this foe.
- Though Grisaia No Meikyuu established that Yuuji hates guns and get sick if he tries to kill, the final piece of the trilogy Grisaia No Rakuen has him infiltrate a floating fortress and break a guard's neck barehanded. If he's to have any chance of success, he can't hold back.
- In the Web Serial Novel Worm, the main character breaks her code against killing when she uses a gun to execute Diabolical Mastermind Coil, reasoning that though he was temporarily outmaneuvered, his resources and powers meant that no prison would be able to hold him even if they could get the heroes to charge him.
- Afterworld: The main character, inspired by a vagrant with an interest in nonviolent problem solving (negotiation, scavenging, running), chooses to discard his gun in a hostile post-apocalypse so that he's more charismatic and trustworthy to the people that he meets on the way. However, the west side of the united states develops a high-strung police state, forcing him to grab a gun and start shooting, albeit sparingly and tactically.
- Batman Beyond is kicked off when an aged, ailing Batman suffers a heart attack at the worst possible moment — right in the middle of a crime bust — and is forced to grab a gun to defend himself. This Moment of Weakness convinces him that it's time to hang up the cowl, setting the stage for Terry to take it up years later.
- Justice League Unlimited
- Batman: The Brave and the Bold plays with this in the Grand Finale. Bat-Mite, trying to get the show cancelled, alters the show dramatically with many jump the shark mainstays, while Ambush Bug tries desperately to prove to a disbelieving Batman that it's not right for him to have a wife, a sickeningly cute daughter, and obvious toy tie-in gear. He finally gets Batman's attention when Bat-Mite makes him use guns, which Bug points out is completely Out of Character for Batman, and this makes the turning point of the episode where Batman starts fighting back as well.
- In the Adventure Time episode "Simon & Marcy" a young Marceline makes Simon promise to stop using the crown that gives him ice powers but makes him more deformed and insane the longer he wears it. He tries his best to keep his promise, but when they find themselves in a dead end ambushed by mutants, he's forced to use it again to protect her.
- In an early episode of Futurama, Hermes Conrad was revealed to be a former limbo champion who vowed to never limbo again after a young fan broke his back trying to emulate him. He is forced to use his limbo skills to get under a lowering door to save everyone else later in the episode. His vow seemed to be permanently disregarded after that.