Every time I look at you I don't understand Why you let the things you did get so out of hand. You'd have managed better if you'd had it planned; Why'd you choose such a backward time in such a strange land? If you'd come today you could have reached a whole nation— Israel in 4 B.C. had no mass communication! ... Jesus Christ, Jesus Christ! Who are You? What have You sacrificed? Jesus Christ, Superstar, do You think You're what they say You are?
A Rock Opera and (subverted?) Passion Play by Andrew Lloyd Webber and Tim Rice. Originally released as a Concept Album in 1970, it made its way to the Broadway and London stage in 1971 and was filmed as a major movie in 1973. An updated version was recorded sometime around 2000 by Webber's Really Useful Group for PBS, and the show lives on in stage production and tours to this day. Inspired By certain sections of The Bible, it chronicles the last seven days of Jesus' life, focusing mainly on the characters of Jesus, Judas and Mary Magdalene. It's regarded among Andrew Lloyd Webber's best works. It's sort of a sequel to Joseph and the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat, though this took a bit more liberty with the source material.Depending on the production, the actors and settings in the show are portrayed with blends of modern and biblical-era clothing and motifs, running with the idea of Jesus being a rockstar-like figure (something not always appreciated by the Moral Guardians), the Apostles being counter-cultural radicals, and the Romans dressing in black leather and taking a Big Brother approach to running The Empire. The 2000 filmed version updates the visual metaphors. Specifically, setting it in a modern-day dystopic version of the Roman Empire with Nazi-esque guards, and Jesus' followers appear to be a street gang, seen toting submachine guns and assault rifles at times. The plot is pretty much the same, but with different things emphasized; Annas, for instance, appears in many more scenes than in the '73 version and in a very different light, the Ho Yay between Judas and Jesus is played up to the point of a Love Triangle with Mary Magdalene, and some other things.
Ambiguous Ending: The film ends shortly after the death of Jesus with the rest of the cast simply boarding the bus; Pilate, Mary Magdalene and Judas (last of all) look back wistfully. The matter of the resurrection is left unclear.
Might count as Fridge Brilliance, as the historical Herod was a thoroughly Romanized client king with connections to the imperial family.
Anachronism Stew: Some characters in the original film, like Mary Magdalene and Jesus, have decent costumes. Then you see the Roman guards, whose armor consists of purple tank tops, cargo pants, combat boots, AK 47s, and sticks. Other people for crowd scenes seemingly just walk onto the camera with whatever they're wearing.
Even more justified than the anachronisms in the 2000 version are those in the 2012 arena tour, as it appears to have been transplanted to some kind of Occupy camp (Occupy Jerusalem, perhaps...?), but the Temple in that version has been turned into a nightclub, complete with drag queens dressed as angels and devils, and topless dancers.
Angrish: "Don’t believe — our good — save Him — if I could!"
Biting-the-Hand Humor: The 2012 British Arena tour version has Herod's song, performed by Chris Moyles, be a Take That at ITV1 style Talent Shows replete with showing Herod's judgement of Jesus as a false god being based on TV viewer's votes. Guess how Ben Forster this version's Jesus was selected?
Used again in the Australian Arena Tour, with Herod now played by Andrew O'Keefe, host of the long running series Deal or No Deal, who essentially spends every minute on stage making fun of himself.
Buffy Speak: "...than John was when John did his baptism thing?
Also subverted in some of these; it's a façade that he keeps to hide his actual accent.
In Real Life, Herod was a notorious womanizer, and the whole Camp Gay thing was something his detractors made up to discredit him. Thus, some productions (including the 2000 film) now portray Herod as a Seedy Hollywood Agent/1980s yuppie-type who seems to be tolerating Jesus' presence as a favor to a friend.
The 1996 London Cast Recording got Alice Cooper to sing the Herod song. Make of that what you will.
Justified in that this is a rock opera. Both Rock and Opera are known for not exactly being realist drama.
Comically Missing the Point: Simon gets an entire song dedicated to how he and the other hangers-on think Jesus is there to violently overthrow the Romans. When the play caused controversy, a British clergyman attempted to defend it by urging people to overlook the long hair and beards (which were most likely historically correct) and instead listen to the lyrics (which, apparently unbeknownst to him, are often subversive to Christian beliefs).
Composite Character: Mary Magdalene in the musical's story combines elements of herself with that of Mary, the sister of Martha, whose "waste" of costly perfume on Jesus was derided by Judas.
Darker and Edgier: In 1998, Webber said that he wanted to give a new design for the musical, saying that the funky disco and sequined leisure suits were fresh for its time, but he wanted to make it into something the younger people could relate to. When making the 2000 version he wanted it to be grittier and darker than the earlier versions.
Dark Reprise: Several. Both I Don't Know How to Love Him and Hosanna have dark reprises. When Jesus accuses his followers of not caring about him at the end of What's the Buzz, they answer with "No, you're wrong, how can you say that?" which is set to the same music used later for "Now we've got him, take him to Pilate." And meanwhile Damned For All Time/Blood Money, which wasn't pleasant to begin with, gets even worse the second time around.
Epic Rocking: "The Last Supper." Also, "Overture", "Heaven on Their Minds", "What's the Buzz/Strange Thing Mystifying", and "Everything's Alright" are all performed as one extremely long song, clocking in at about 17 minutes (!)
Ghost Song: Judas comes back to sing the title song as Jesus is marched up to the crucifixion site. (See page quote).
God Test: Quoth Herod to Jesus, "Prove to me that you're no fool/Walk upon my swimming pool."
Good Colors, Evil Colors: The show's not quite subtle about its color palette. Jesus is always in white and khaki. Judas is in red and, especially after his betrayal, black. Mary Magdalene is usually in red, but changes to white for "Could We Start Again, Please?" The High Priests wear black. Pilate wears purple (which denotes royalty). The apostles are usually in greens and blues.
Oddly done in different ways in the movies. In the '70s, Judas returns as an angel, dressed all in white with a wing-like fringe on his arms. In the 2000 version, Judas and his backup are clad all in red leather, thus implying that he's a demon.
Especially, of course, in the 1973 version. At one point, after Judas riles Jesus by suggesting he not spend time with ex-prostitutes, one of the followers says "Hey, cool it, man!"
Historical Villain Upgrade: Inverted. The key individuals responsible for Jesus's death (Judas, Caiaphas, Pilate) are given much more sympathetic depictions than almost anywhere else. Herod's still a jerk, though.
Incredibly Long Note: The climactic Metal Scream ("See... how... I... DIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIEEEEE") in "Gethsemane" can fall under this. The champion is probably Steve Balsamo, from the 1996 London cast; on the soundtrack album, he holds the note a full twenty seconds.
Jesus: For all you care / This bread could be my body / For all you care / This wine could be my blood.
Jesus sees his Father as this as well, demanding to know during the "Gethsemane" song what justice there could be in his having to die and receiving no answer. By the end of the song he is quite bitter, and sulkily tells the Father to send the mob to arrest him "before I change my mind."
Note that the "cool vs crazy" debate is not about being for or against Jesus. Pilate is trying to save him, while Caiaphas, who is trying to get him crucified, subscribes to the "Jesus is cool" camp. In the initial scene, Judas is still loyal to Jesus, and yet complains about how Jesus is turning increasingly mentally unstable under the pressure from his believers.
Caiaphas: One thing I'll say for him, Jesus is cool.
The 2000 version instead has this line by a nameless priest as part of it's...significantly lessened ambiguity:
Priest: Infantile sermons, the multitude drools!
Kangaroo Court: All three of Jesus's trials; at the hands of Caiaphas, Herod and Pontius.
Karma Houdini: Extreme, when you consider the fates of Judas and Peter - betray Jesus once, suicide and eternal damnation. Deny him three times, become the first pope.
Zig-zagged to some extent: Judas' acts lead to the death of Jesus, Peter's were arguably harmless. Many believe Judas was forgiven and allowed into heaven, while Peter was forced to watch the gates for all eternity. Then again Jesus was supposed to die because God said so, so Judas was actually instrumental in God's plan. Then again again suicide is supposed to be a one way ticket to hell. It's all quite confusing.
Some have argued that the main difference between what Judas did and what Peter did, is that Peter didn't kill himself and stayed around long enough for Jesus to forgive him. Maybe Judas would've been forgiven if he'd stuck around.
Judas: (in his death song) Does he— does he love me, too? Does he care for me?!
Meaningful Background Event: During "Simon Zealotes" in the 1973 film version, Roman soldiers can be seen gathering to observe the commotion. Judas is also in the background, visibly disturbed by the events before storming off during the next song, "Poor Jerusalem".
Metal Scream: Inspired by Ian Gillan of Deep Purple (as Jesus) and Murray Head (as Judas) on the original Concept Album. Ted Neely (as Jesus) and Carl Anderson, an understudy for Ben Vereen (as Judas) became famous for the roles on stage and film, since Gillan and Head had become too successful as musicians to perform, and duplicating their vocal range can be quite difficult for other actors. Interestingly, Murray Head is not black; Ben Vereen and subsequently Carl Anderson pioneered that idea, in no small part because Anderson simply had the voice for the notes.
Mood Whiplash: A disturbing amount for a religion-based story. The juxtaposition of Mary Magdalene's sweet Crapsaccharine World anthem "Everything's Alright" with Judas's angry accusations against her probably qualifies. An even better example is the jarring shift (at least on the concept album) from King Herod's comical music-hall number to Judas's histrionic reaction to seeing the scourging of Jesus.
Movie Bonus Song: An unusual example. While many film versions of stage musicals include an original Award Bait Song, the only new song featured is the short Villain Song between Annas and Caiaphas, "Then We Are Decided."
"Could We Start Again, Please?" is often mistaken for one of these by fans of the original album. However, it was actually added for the original Broadway production a few years before the movie.
New-Age Retro Hippie: Extremely pronounced. This and Hair are probably the most New-Age Retro Hippie plays that exist. Not really "retro" when the film / play / soundtrack was first produced, but Jesus' followers are portrayed as counter-cultural hippies and Judas and the Zealots are portrayed as members of the New Left. This is especially pronounced in the film.
Rule of Cool: The new stage adaptation runs on this. For example, during the performance of Pilate's Dream, Pilate is surrounded by government officials who move in slow motion, then speed up, Zack Snyder-style. On stage.
Scenery Porn: Norman Jewison really took advantage of filming in Israel for the first film.
Judas: You want me to do it! What if I just stayed here and ruined your ambition? Christ, you deserve it!
Shaming the Mob: Pilate lambasts the mob screaming for Jesus to be crucified, since he sees Jesus as a harmless crazy man being used as a scapegoat by the mob for the revolutionary rumblings his presence set off. Nearly half of Pilate's final song is calling the crowd hypocrites and pointing out the Disproportionate Retribution they're forcing him to deal to Jesus.
Pilate: I see no reason! I find no evil! This man is harmless, so why does he upset you?! He's just misguided! Thinks he's important! But to keep you vultures happy I will flog him!
Shout-Out: In the 1973 film, when Jesus and the twelve apostles sit down for The Last Supper, they all freeze for a moment in the exact poses depicted in Leonardo da Vinci's famous painting of The Last Supper. Movie fans have used this scene to identify exactly which actors are playing which apostles, since not all of them are identified by name in the film.
Sliding Scale of Idealism Versus Cynicism: Depending on the production, the entire message of the play can be changed. The songs and script themselves are just general enough to paint Jesus or Judas as the protagonist to root for. Jesus can vary between being well, a pretty nice guy, to a snob who's all talk, or whether or not he is even actually the son of God. To this day people still aren't sure whether the play was intended to give a family friendly
Christian story, or whether it was made to cast a more jaded light on it.
Slut Shaming: Judas doesn't believe that Mary Magdalene (or "women of her kind") is an appropriate companion for Jesus.
Villainous Breakdown: Judas' Death. This is what all other breakdown tropes want to be when they grow up. It is the God of character meltdowns.
Villain Song: "This Jesus Must Die" and "King Herod's Song."
Also "We Are Decided" in the movie. Also virtually every song sung by Judas (with a few exceptions) are Villain Songs, even if he is an Anti-Villain.
Voice Types: Jesus, Judas, Simon Zealotes and King Herod are tenors. Mary Magdalene is an alto. Pilate and Peter are baritones. Caiaphas is a bass. Annas is a countertenor, unless you cross-cast, in which case s/he is usually a mezzo-soprano. Other productions, such as the 1996 London cast, simply drop his lines down an octave, making him a baritone.
Arguably, Caiaphas, who thinks that Jesus is a pretty cool guy, but feels that he has to have him killed to prevent him from stirring up revolution and provoking retaliation from Rome. When Judas is having his BSOD, Caiaphas comforts him, saying that his actions have saved Israel.
You Can't Fight Fate: One of the main themes (along with all the Ho Yay). Jesus, Judas, Pilate and even Peter struggle to escape the roles that have been written for them, or at least to pass/pin the blame for their part on someone else, but to no avail. God will have His martyr, His betrayer(s), and His bloody, horrible ending.