Rachel Dawes: This is the third of Falcone's thugs you've had declared insane... and moved into your asylum.This is an affirmative defense in which it is claimed that the defendant in a criminal trial is or was unable to understand the nature or unlawfulness of their actions due to a mental defect or disorder, and thus not responsible for the consequences of those actions. "Insanity" here is a legal term, not a medical one, and the court decides whether it applies — though it will take the advice of medical professionals into account. While the use of insanity as a defense has been known since ancient times, it was codified in English law by the ruling in R. v M'Naghten in 1843, which were adopted shortly thereafter in other common-law jurisdictions (including the United States). Most countries in the modern world have some variation of the insanity defense available to criminal defendants. Some jurisdictions instead have "Guilty But Insane," where insanity cannot be a complete defense, but can be a mitigating factor. In Real Life, the insanity plea is rare and difficult to succeed with. It is also a risky gamble, since it is an affirmative defense that requires the defendant to concede culpability in the crime in question and places the burden of proof on the defense to prove beyond a reasonable doubt that their client was insane. Perhaps one percent of criminal cases even attempt an insanity defense, and only about a quarter of those are accepted, primarily if the defendant already has a history of mental illness. Furthermore, it requires expert testimony from a reputable psychiatric authority that the defendant was insane at the time they committed the crime, not just insane in general. Naturally, since the insanity defense is dramatic, it is used much more often in fiction. A variant is "Temporary Insanity," in which the defendant is claimed to have been suffering from an "irresistible impulse" during the crime, but is now sane. Thus, they can be released immediately, rather than being incarcerated for psychiatric treatment. This defense was first used in the United States by U.S. Congressman Daniel Sickles of New York in 1859, after murdering his wife's lover. It was most prevalent as a defense during the 1940s and '50s. Most states do not allow this defense today. Along similar lines, the "Extreme Emotional Disturbance" defense argues mitigating factors compromised the defendant's ability to think rationally. For instance, a man who shot his wife after catching her in bed with her lover could argue his emotional state at the time makes him guilty of the lesser crime of Manslaughter and not 2nd degree Murder. Since someone who has been declared "Not Guilty By Reason of Insanity" is incarcerated for psychiatric treatment until they are deemed to be no longer a threat to themselves or others, this can result in a longer loss of freedom than a normal jail sentence would have caused. Because of this, a defendant has the right to insist that this defense not be used in their case. This has not stopped some defendants — both in fiction and in Real Life — going for this defense under the mistaken belief that a plea of 'insanity' means a cushier time than a regular jail sentence. Also, in some jurisdictions, such as the District of Columbia, a person found not guilty of a sex crime solely by reason of insanity or diminished capacity must register as a sex offender, as though that person had been convicted. A Catch-22 Dilemma takes place with many juries: if the defendant is capable of understanding that an insanity plea would be a good idea, then perhaps they're not legally insane (as insane people typically don't know they're insane — note emphasis on typically, since some actually do know there's something wrong with them). This is in fact closely related to the original Catch-22; the dilemma discussed in that book that a serviceman who requests a discharge for insanity must be sane enough to think to do so, in which case he is refused one. Another use of this trope common in fiction is for a floundering attorney to switch to an insanity defense as a last resort, ignoring the real-life procedural steps needed for this action. It almost never works, just emphasizing how doomed the client is. A related concept is fitness to stand trial. This is often confused with the insanity defense, particularly since they often apply to the same people, but fitness to stand trial says nothing about their mental state when they did the crime. It's about whether their current mental state allows them to understand the charges against them and conduct an appropriate defense. For example, a defendant who was clearly responsible for the crime he committed, but while awaiting trial suffers brain damage from a suicide attempt and becomes unfit to stand trial. Rather than going to jail, he's sent to a care facility. Should he ever recover enough to be declared fit, he will stand trial. Another concept related to insanity, although rarely seen in media, is diminished capacity. Diminished capacity is a claim that the defendant was unable to form the mental state (intent, recklessness, negligence, etc.) required for their action to be a crime. Because diminished capacity is not an affirmative defense, but rather the negation of an element of the crime, the burden of proof remains on the prosecution. Additionally, a successful diminished capacity defense results in a verdict of "not guilty", rather than "not guilty by reason of insanity", so the defendant is not incarcerated for psychiatric treatment (unless the state begins civil commitment proceedings). As a result, diminished capacity tends to be preferred to the insanity defense in jurisdictions in which it is allowed (although the two can be, and often are, combined). In the United States, neither psychopathology or a personality disorder is generally accepted as grounds for an insanity plea, and most states will simply throw the perpetrator in jail like any other criminal if that is their mental illness, since though such persons may have the adequate Lack of Empathy that you can say they don't appreciate the moral reasons for why their crimes were wrong, in general they still understood that they were breaking the law, and having pathological justifications for doing so isn't good enough. However, other countries, such as the United Kingdom, do accept these as valid grounds, and many notorious British serial killers are locked up in mental institutions whereas in America they would be imprisoned for life or sentenced to death. Such British prisoners, however, are usually not expected to ever be released and most of their appeals fail. In fiction, many cases of the insanity defense are often based on personality disorders, even if they are American.
Dr. Jonathan Crane: Well, the work offered by organized crime must hold an attraction to the insane.
Dr. Jonathan Crane: Well, the work offered by organized crime must hold an attraction to the insane.
open/close all folders
Anime and Manga
- In Tokyo Babylon, Subaru encounters a woman who is trying to summon a dog spirit to kill the man who murdered her young daughter, since he had been deemed too insane to stand trial. She plans on using the insanity defense for herself afterwards, figuring that a judge would see the "attempted" ritual as proof that she had lost her mind before killing the man herself.
- The DCU:
- Most of the inhabitants of Arkham Asylum for the Criminally Insane have had a successful Insanity Defense entered on their behalf. Many of them are also, not coincidentally, crazy. However most of them are not legally insane by any reasonable interpretation. A pathological obsession with hats, cats, birds, or riddles does not mean someone isn't aware of what they're doing. The same goes for being an eco-terrorist, wanting to eat people, or most of the various eccentricities Batvillains develop while pursuing a criminal career.
- During the Golden Age and The Interregnum, The Joker was not considered insane enough to qualify for this defense. When he tried it, Batman easily proved that despite Joker's eccentricity, he was fully capable of understanding the illegality and consequences of his actions. It was only when the Joker became a homicidal maniac in the 1970s that Arkham Asylum became a necessity for him.
- In The Joker: Devil's Advocate , a new D.A. decides to go for broke and push for the death penalty after a series of killings with the Joker's MO. After a "Trial of the Century" with accompanying media circus, he is found guilty and sentenced to death. However, he claims to have no knowledge of the murders. Batman, who has never known the Joker to deny any of his crimes, investigates and finds out that this time he really is innocent. Joker is returned to Arkham when this is revealed.
- The nearly abusive use of this defense among Batman villains in particular has caused more than one rant from real legal professionals. It concluded that only Two-Face and sometimes The Joker are "legally" insane, though it's an old and incomplete list. For those who don't feel like reading the linked article in full, what the article concludes is that sometimes the Joker does appear to have a valid insanity defense for his actions (wrongfulness test: sometimes he literally doesn't think what he's doing is wrong; at other times he knows it's wrong but does it anyway For the Lulz, which is not a valid defense), and Two-Face pretty much always appears to have one (irresistible impulse test: he knows it's wrong, but can't stop himself because the coin came up scarred). It specifically lists those two as examples of Arkham inmates who probably do belong there; it then gives a (short) list of others that don't: the Scarecrow, the Mad Hatter, the Penguin, Poison Ivy, Tweedledum and Tweedledee. They don't exhibit any behavior compatible with the legal definition of insanity... mental illness, maybe; they're certainly eccentric... but they fail both prongs of the insanity definition: wrongfulness and irresistible impulse. The author explicitly mentions that he's not trying to give an exhaustive list either way, just examples so that readers can understand what the actual criteria for being judged legally insane are. It also concedes that the audience doesn't know that Gotham uses the same test the real-world US legal system does (which varies from state to state, but they're all more or less based on the Model Penal Code), so maybe under Gotham's definition voluntarily being seen in public in green spandex is all it takes.
- Not all the people listed are sent to Arkham. The Penguin is normally just sent to a normal prison (Blackgate Penitentiary). It was also a plot point that most of the Mooks you fight in Batman: Arkham Asylum had to be sent to the Asylum after a "mysterious" fire.
- The general consensus is that the insanity defense is almost guaranteed to work in the Gotham court system regardless of how much sense it makes legally, but since it means going to Arkham, you'd need to be crazy to try it. In Arkham Asylum: Living Hell, Warren White, an embezzler who stole millions of dollars and unfamiliar with Gotham, made this mistake and found himself in Arkham instead of the cushy rehab center he expected to be sent to. Things didn't go well for him. Killer Croc attacked him, slashing his throat and giving him "gills". Then an encounter with with Jane Doe in Mr. Freeze's specialized cell left him without hair, ears, nose, and lips. Then White filed his teeth to points and took the name "Great White Shark".
- Also, not everyone who gets sent to Arkham is sent there due to being considered insane. Mr. Freeze is (usually) sane, but he's still there because it's the only imprisonment facility with the technology to keep a cell refrigerated enough for him to survive in it. Granted, this probably counts as an abuse of his human rights because it keeps him from interacting with sane people, but he hates everyone anyway, so he won't complain.
- Depending on the Writer, Poison Ivy may be a valid case. Neil Gaiman's origin story strongly implied that Jason Woodrue raped and experimented on her to the point that her original identity is barely a memory, and her current personality is either a trapped plant spirit or so warped that it believes such, making her thought processes so alien that the only one who really "gets" her is Harley Quinn.
- Woodrue himself, as the Floronic Man, eventually gets remanded to Arkham following a psychotic break in the pages of Swamp Thing, where he reaches the plant consciousness of earth and attempts to kill all animal life without realizing doing so would doom the plants he thought he championed. He has since become more a case of Blue and Orange Morality, drifting further away from anything resembling rational thought.
- Harley herself almost qualifies, as she's something of a textbook case of Stockholm Syndrome made worse by being sent back to Arkham right along with the Joker, her abuser. Her New 52 origin story retconned this to some form of permanent psychosis from brain damage or drugging, with Harley eventually rejecting Joker outright. In this version of events, she's not legally insane, and sent to Belle Reve Penitentiary instead of Arkham.
- Firefly would legitimately qualify as a Pyromaniac if he didn't also enjoy killing people. Pyromaniacs can't stop themselves from setting fires, even deadly ones, but Firefly's so openly happy with the consequences even then that the legal system would probably come to the conclusion that he understands morality.
- Clayface III (Preston Payne) was also a legitimate case. Due to his Touch of Death and Power Incontinence, his mind's snapped from the guilt of killing innocent people, to the point where he believed his cell was an apartment he shared with his wife, unbeknownst to him a mannequin.
- Minor villain Humpty-Dumpty is also legitimately insane, and honestly thinks dismembering people and reassembling them (poorly) is best for all involved, with no malice involved. While an extreme case, he's not malevolent in any way... at least not before meeting the general population of Arkham.
- It doesn't help that Gotham's psychiatrists tend to get outed as villains themselves (Scarecrow, Hugo Strange, Dr. Hurt, the various Doctors Arkham) or are shown to be grossly incompetent or negligent. When a steady stream of new inmates ensures new test subjects or funding from bribes, it's easy to see why they'd play fast and loose with the legal definition of insanity.
- It's frequently implied that Gotham's legal system is overloaded at best, openly corrupt at worst. Given that Arkham's infamous for its escapes and the horrific nature of its inmates, part of the high rate of legally sane people incarcerated there is because they fully intend on leaving soon, and partly because many of Gotham's lawyers and judges seem hellbent on keeping all of Gotham's worst right in one place. With Blackgate's introduction, it also helped separate the big-name villains from their Cannon Fodder henchmen.
- When Hal Jordan, Green Lantern, fought an opponent code-named the Aerialist, it became obvious that the Aerialist was under a severe delusion making him believe that his criminal actions were entirely legal and correct. Hal referenced the M'Naghten rules when wrapping up the case, his opinion being that the Aerialist would qualify for an insanity defense.
- Black Hand's current backstory strongly implies he's legitimately insane, compulsively wallowing in death as an erotic experience, often hearing voices compelling him to kill.
- Mind, Black Hand hears voices because someone's legitimately talking to him...
- Black Hand's current backstory strongly implies he's legitimately insane, compulsively wallowing in death as an erotic experience, often hearing voices compelling him to kill.
- Villain Sin Eater (famous for killing Spidey's long-time ally Jean Dewolff) is a notable example of this trope being done correctly; Sin Eater actually was legitimately mentally ill and committed his murders because of this. His insanity defense led to him getting the psychotherapy he needed, and when we next see him, he's slowly recovering and guilt-ridden from the crimes he committed. Either way, he isn't a threat to anyone else now, as his final fight with Spider-Man was so brutal, it left Sin Eater a stuttering wreck who needs help getting around.
- After he was cured Morbius stood trial for his crimes committed during his time as a living vampire. His attorney Jennifer Walters successfully argued that he was not responsible for his actions because his condition literally drove him insane, providing proof in the form of a rabbit that turned violent and killed another rabbit after being injected with the same serum. The jury found him not guilty by reason of insanity, avoiding the death penalty. Nevertheless, Morbius still wallows in guilt for what he has done and tries to attain in several ways.
- Serial killer Cletus Kasady was originally sentenced to Ryker's Island, but after becoming Carnage, he started being shipped to the Ravencroft Institute instead, as acquiring superpowers exacerbated his nihilistic belief system to psychotic levels. He does not believe that the horrible things that he does are wrong, because he sees law and order and existence itself as pointless, and it's everyone else who is crazy and stupid for not seeing the truth; that we should all do whatever we want because nothing matters and there's no such thing as morality, and to think otherwise is unnatural and delusional. As Ravencroft became less and less equipped to handle him, he started being locked away in specialized facilities (like the Raft) with other villains, crazy or not.
- There was a period where War Machine had an advanced interface that displayed how many people his foes had killed, allowing him to decide whether or not it's okay for him to use lethal force against said bad guys. When he faced Norman Osborn, Osborn pointed out that War Machine couldn't kill him since all of the Goblin's murders were committed while either being certifiably insane (such as Gwen Stacy and Terri Kidder) or while in the service of his country (Queen Veranke). War Machine's response was to say "Interesting theory" and then blast him with a rocket.
- In one old The Wizard of Id strip, a lawyer pleads insanity for his client, even though the crime was stealing a pie. The reason? Would a sane man steal a rhubarb pie?
Films — Animated
- In Aladdin, when Princess Jasmine disguised as a commoner accidentally steals an apple, Aladdin saves her from getting her hand chopped off by claiming she's his sister and insane. Jasmine quickly plays along.
Films — Live-Action
- In Anatomy of a Murder, the defense's entire argument rests entirely on the "irresistible impulse" insanity defense.
- In Batman Begins, Dr. Johnathan Crane (aka The Scarecrow) helps mob boss Carmine Falcone by testifying to the insanity of Falcone's thugs and having them put in Arkham Asylum to avoid jail time. But while there, he does twisted experiments on them to drive them to insanity.
- Aversion in Nuts, where Barbra Streisand demands they declare her sane. The film notes (accurately) that if you are declared insane, you can be kept locked up for life, even for a crime that would only entail a few years in prison.
- One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest deconstructs the trope; playing insane got McMurphy transferred into a mental institution, which he knows about and thinks is better than prison. He is sorely mistaken.
- Training Day: Mentioned by one of the three wise men when he recaps to Alonzo how an off-screen criminal recently got off this way by pulling a stunt in court that made him seem mentally unsound.
- Judge Dredd (movie only)
Rico: I remember you. Testified before the Council that I was insane, right?Ilsa: And therefore innocent. I was trying to save your life.Rico: What you did was insult me, 'cause I knew exactly what I was doing. Then and now.
- M is basically a gigantic and brilliantly subtle Author Tract in defense of this. Hitler hated that movie, once someone explained it to him.
- Depending on which version you watch, William Friedkin's Rampage is either the opposite, or agrees.
- Inception inverts this; Mal had herself declared sane by three different psychiatrists, so as to prevent Cobb from being able to explain the nature of her madness, as part of her plan.
- Rowdy Rathore treats this as a "Get Out Of Jail Free" card without any mention of psychiatric treatment; justified in that the Big Bad has clearly bought the judge and no one in the story believes otherwise.
- In Miss Congeniality, Grace sarcastically suggests that Cathy Morningside shoot for an insanity plea after rigging the Miss United States crown to blow up and kill the contest winner, purely out of spite for being fired from running the pageant, and then having the audacity to claim the whole thing was a plan to make the world "a more beautiful place".
- Side Effects has the protagonist take various antidepressants before taking a new experimental drug called Ablixa, which appears to be working until she murders her husband while sleepwalking. At the trial, her current psychiatrist (Jude Law) argues that the drug is to blame, and the defense ends up offering an insanity plea. The trope is slightly subverted in that it's specifically mentioned how low the percentage of success for this type of defense is. The woman is, instead, put into a mental institution until her psychiatrist deems her cured. Subverted in that she knew precisely what she was doing and planned the whole thing with her former psychiatrist in order to kill her husband and cash in on the pharmaceutical company's stock plunge. At the end, Jude Law's character figures it out and puts her back into the mental hospital.
- In the 1962 film version of Chushigura, Lord Asano is allowed the chance to claim that he was mentally deranged when he attacked Lord Kira, and thus not responsible for his actions. Asano refuses to take this easy way out, as it would be dishonorable to lie to save himself.
- In Vera Drake, Susan's doctor coaches her to lie to her psychiatrist and say she has a family history of mental illness and will kill herself if she must take the pregnancy to term. Justified since she was raped and this is the only way she can obtain an abortion legally, and even then, the price is steep.
- Primal Fear:
- After the trial starts, an accused murderer's attorney realizes that his client has Multiple Personality Disorder (i.e. split personality) and that one of the personalities committed the crime. He tries to change his plea from "Not Guilty" to an Insanity Defense. After a dramatic courtroom scene the judge agrees and says she'll send the client to a mental hospital for treatment. At the end, it's revealed that the client was faking insanity to get away with the murder. The killer, for all his cunning, seems not to be aware of the "institutionalization is usually longer than prison" trope.
- In A Time to Kill, the defense lawyer protagonist argued that the rape of his client's daughter combined with the likelihood of the culprits getting off lightly drove the defendant temporarily insane, causing him to kill both rapists with an assault rifle. This plea is somewhat undermined when the prosecution points out that the psychiatrist he brings in to support his argument was convicted of statutory rape and pressures the defendant into angrily declaring that he still thinks the rapists deserved to die, but in the end, he's found not guilty. The defense attorney asked the jury to place themselves in the defendant's place with a thought experiment in his closing argument. The jury realized just how much the rape had to shatter the defendant and voted to acquit. Notably, this is one case where the actual results of an insanity plea would likely match the fictional. As it was a temporary phenomenon brought on by a unique strain, he would probably not be institutionalized.
- They didn't find him "not guilty by reason of insanity", just "not guilty", and thus he couldn't be committed without evidence that he really was mentally ill — which the prosecution had not accepted. The insanity defense is not what gets him off at the end, anyway, but the jury sympathizing with him via his lawyer's speech. This is arguing for jury nullification, though, since he never mentions the insanity defense in his closing argument, and no judge would permit it.
- Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice. Lex Luthor (who certainly is suffering from an Ambiguous Disorder) claims he's too crazy to stand trial after being thrown into prison. His smugness slips a fraction when Batman agrees... and informs Luthor that he's being shipped to Arkham Asylum, where Batman has some friends who'll make Luthor's life unpleasant.
- The misunderstood version appears in 15 Minutes, in which the murderers exploit If It Bleeds, It Leads and plan to plead this, get sent to an asylum, be suddenly "cured", and make a killing by selling the story afterwards.
- However, this falls apart due to his misunderstanding of Double Jeopardy in the US - it only attaches when a verdict is rendered, so if no verdict is rendered (as is the case with this defense)... Also, there are laws on the books specifically to prevent those found Guilty of a crime from profiting off of it.
- Primal Fear, as with the Film of the Book above, has an accused murderer's attorney discover his client has multiple personalities, and that one of them is the actual killer. The judge dismisses the case and orders him committed to a mental institution until he's cured. In the sequels, he manages to fool his doctors into thinking he's cured and get out — where he kills again.
- Deconstructed (at least in the 'Declared insane= gets off basically scott-free' aspect) in One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest. Randle Patrick McMurphy tries to invoke this and pretends to be insane in order to use this defense because he's too lazy to serve out a rather light sentence on a work farm. When he gets to the asylum, he quickly realizes that the asylum is way worse than the prison would be, patients don't have set sentences after which they go free and must stay until declared well- which, considering he's pissed off the evil Nurse Ratched (the reason the place is so awful) is probably not going to happen for him.
- Comes up in The Krytos Trap. Tycho Celchu is accused of murder, and there's a lot of evidence that he did it. A few years ago, he'd been kidnapped by Ysanne Isard, Manchurian Agent maker extraordinaire. People who think he did it are divided between thinking that he'd been brainwashed and thinking that he was a garden-variety traitor; there's evidence for both. His lawyer tells Tycho that if the Tribunal decides he was brainwashed, he'll be declared not guilty by reason of diminished sapience and put into a hospital to be treated, and released when he's cured. That sounds nightmarish to Tycho, but the Tribunal's nightmare is that he'll only be there for a week or two before treatment ends and he'll be released. This would make the justice system seem impotent; the nonhuman public thinks he's a traitor and isn't very sure about their government as it is. The human public is starting to believe that he's actually innocent, since there's proof of that too, and is being offered up to placate the nonhumans. It's sticky. In the end, he's declared completely innocent when the victim turns up alive.
- In Red Dragon and Silence of the Lambs, Dr. Hannibal Lecter was committed to a mental hospital after being convicted of killing and cannibalizing several people and the attempted murder of an FBI agent. The hospital's director Dr. Chilton describes him as a "pure psychopath". Lecter's case wouldn't fit the legal definition of insanity since, based on the discussions he had with Starling and others, it's clear that he was in full possession of his (admittedly impressive) mental faculties and capable of understanding the consequences of what he was doing. In Hannibal, Starling explains that Lecter did not actually plead insanity, but rather that it was the jury that found him insane, the reasoning of the courts being that Lecter was such a respectable, successful, and intelligent individual that the only possible explanation for his crimes was that he was stark raving mad. In the Film of the Book, the headline reads "Lecter Given Nine Life Sentences" or something like that, but he is still put in a mental institution for treatment, which can often occur even when the defendant is found guilty but still has a disorder. Many prisons now have their own psychiatric wards, in fact.
- Older Than Steam: In Don Quixote, Cervantes explains this trope is the reason for why Don Quixote is never killed or sent to jail (though he is often beaten) by the poor Innocent Bystander of the day. Note that it's another character who invokes it, because Don Quixote himself cannot, since he obviously is not mad — those jealous wizards transmuted the giants into windmills! It may be the Ur-Example.
"...The landlord shouted to them to leave him alone, for he had already told them that he was mad, and as a madman he would not be accountable even if he killed them all..."
- Parodied in Soul Music, when a murderer who has already been executed tries to convince Death that "the balance of my mind was disturbed". His logic? "I really wanted to kill him. You can't tell me that's a balanced state of mind."
- What Benjamin and his lawyer try to pull in Hollow Places. While it's obvious that a serial killer who murders women by drying them out in glass boxes and and has a thing for dead bodies isn't entirely sane, it's made clear he knew exactly what he was doing.
- In the third book of The Hunger Games, Katniss is declared insane after she killed President Coin for sending Prim and other children to their deaths.
- In The Adventures of Tom Sawyer, Muff Potter's lawyer said to the jury he wanted to introduce this defense on account of his client's drunkenness before making Tom and Huck testify.
- In After The Golden Age, the supervillain Simon Sito, also known as The Destructor, uses the insanity defense at his trial. The protagonist initially believes it to be a ploy and works with the prosecution to prove that Sito is sane; later in the book, however, she contemplates how Sito has never shown any interest in money, power, or sex, seeming to be solely obsessed with destruction for its own sake, and starts to consider the possibility that he really is insane.
- Jane Boleyn tries this in The Boleyn Inheritance to save her from being executed. It doesn't work because the king just changes the law so anyone can be executed, even if they are mad.
- Death Shall Overcome: After a minor character tries to open fire on a NAACP fundraiser, it's suggested that he should plead insanity to beat the rap. "Loudmouth racist" wouldn't qualify for that defense, but on the other hand, no lawyer was involved in that plan — the character's latest Trophy Wife and his estranged son came up with this on their own, as much to get their hands on his money as to keep him out of jail. note
Live Action TV
- The Made-for-TV Movie The Burning Bed is a good example of a well-supported "temporary insanity" plea. The film is Based on a True Story, and in Real Life, Francine Hughes was acquitted.
- Law & Order:
- The show frequently addresses this, as many defendants plead 'not guilty by reason of mental disease or defect' (which is how they phrase it) and court/prosecution-appointed psychiatrists are often featured for this reason; rarely are the defendants actually found to be legally incompetent to the degree that is required by law for such a plea to be accepted without trial, and even fewer actually have this plea accepted by a jury. The Catch-22 bind is often addressed in episodes where the situation is inverted; the defendant clearly is mentally incompetent, but insists they are sane.
- One episode has the unusual spectacle of a guy using an insanity defense while defending himself. His claim is that he was insane when he committed the crimes, but now is normal thanks to medication, so it's not as ludicrous as it first seems. He is a paranoid schizophrenic, leading to him becoming homeless and murdering people due to his delusions. Before, however, he earned a law degree, and is practicing (while defending himself) for the first time.
- One inversion occurred when an obviously insane defendant who murdered three people refused to allow his attorney to plead insanity, even though he was obviously guilty and eligible for the death penalty if convicted.
- Another subversion was what appeared to be an extremely deranged person pleading it, appearing to be actually insane (voices in his head, erratic behavior, violent reaction to loud noises, etc.) only for the court psychiatrist to see that his symptoms were too good, figuring out that he was only pretending to be insane.
- Then there was an interesting case. The defendant actually was hearing voices in his head. However, it wasn't insanity causing the voices, it was a brain tumor, and the defendant had such a short life expectancy that putting him on trial would be rather pointless. His doctor was charged for criminal incompetence, with the promise that once the defendant died, the doctor would also be charged with homicide (since the tumor was operable when the doctor discovered it).
- A similar case in the below mentioned SVU had a spree killer be sentenced to a psychiatric facility until he is deemed fit to stand trial (which will likely never occur) after it is discovered that his erratic behavior and murders were caused by his mind being destroyed by a now terminal case of Syphilis, which an insurance company had detected during an exam, but failed to inform him of.
- Law & Order: Special Victims Unit: Sexsomnia, watching too much TV (Oz), borderline mental retardation (as noted below), schizophrenia, sexual addiction, even a brain tumor have all been successfully proffered as rape defenses, and in nearly all of these cases, the defense is valid. As with the mothership, defense lawyers still habitually trot out the defense as a last resort when the client is caught red-handed, only to get their asses handed to them when a last-minute fact torpedoes their whole case.
- It's used to chilling effect in an episode where a mentally disabled man rapes an old woman (causing her to have a heart attack) because her position greatly resembles a porn flick he was shown, and he didn't understand the nature or consequences of what he was doing, thus he is acquitted. The prosecutor is infuriated that he 'got off easy' by not being put in prison — but then it cuts to the man being put into a mental institution by one of the detectives, still unsure of what's going on and seeing the various mentally disturbed people talking to themselves or wandering around in an unpleasant gray facility. The final shot is of the horror on the man's face.
- Subverted in episodes of both shows when insane defendants refused to plead insanity for different reasons, forcing the prosecutors to come up with a roundabout way to introduce the evidence of their insanity or compel them to reveal it by goading them into a courtroom outburst of some sort.
- In one episode of Law & Order: Criminal Intent, the user of the insanity defense is a police psychologist. The detectives eventually prove that he'd killed a man in a misguided and misinformed attempt to impress a woman he was in love with, with the Insanity Defense as a contingency plan.
- Parodied in Community. The Insanity Defense is used by Jeff to keep Britta from being expelled from Greendale, arguing that she deliberately sabotaged herself by cheating on a test in order to fail and get kicked out, thus validating her own low sense of self-worth. He then goes on to argue that since everyone at Greendale is crazy in one sense or another, it would be an act of gross hypocrisy to kick her out based on this. It actually works.
- Used in Bones. Zach Addy was deemed insane in an off-screen trial, and went to a mental institution. Eventually, the audience finds out that he didn't actually commit the crime he was accused of, but believes that he may have committed a lesser crime and refuses to confess, because then he could be re-tried and might go to jail.
- One episode of Criminal Minds has Hotch tell the killer himself "You were sick. You didn't know what you were doing", because the man is freaking out while in custody, having just realized that he is actually guilty of the crimes they're accusing him of. The last shot of the episode is the killer in a mental institution. There are a number of other episodes where you don't see the killer in an institution, but it's pretty obvious that the defense applies.
- The Firm on The Practice would cut-and-paste the Insanity Defense around any sympathetic defendant who performed a Vigilante Execution to give the jury an excuse to acquit their client, since arguing an eye for an eye would be considered jury nullification. The chances of a jury buying it were generally low. The episode "Committed" showed the aftermath of one these: a serial killer who used a successful insanity defense some years ago hires Lindsey to help him get declared sane and released from the institution he is now in.
- Attempted by Serial Killer Nate Haskell in CSI, who argues that a combination of childhood abuse and possessing the MAOA gene (which has been linked to an increased propensity for violence) turned him into a sadistic psychopath. His Arch-Enemy Ray Langston shoots him down in court by announcing that he also had an abusive childhood and also possesses the gene, but he became a doctor rather than a murderer, and Haskell later admits in private that he made a conscious decision in his youth to blame everything on the two in the event he was caught. This would be a Crowning Moment of Awesome for Langston, were it not for the sheer amount of Fridge Logic involved in the case — it is strongly implied that if Haskell were found insane, he would actually be let out of custody, despite his entire defense boiling down to "I'm a sadistic, murdering psychopath. And I'll probably do it again." This is a common mistake in the depictions.
- It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia: Mac and Charlie believe that “Psycho Pete,” the former leader of their “Freight Train gang”, killed and ate his parents for dinner and was institutionalized. This turns out to be something they made up entirely. He was actually there for extreme social anxiety, which he still suffers from.
- JAG: In "Act of Terror", a Marine guard is charged for murder after he shot a terrorist suspect during a prisoner transfer, on live TV. Harm, as defense counsel, begins to explore the option of an insanity defense, but he’s taken off the case by the defendant, who’s hired a different attorney.
- Cracked: Given that the show deals exclusively with cases involving The Mentally Ill in some capacity, many of its perpetrators would be judged not fit to stand trial, not guilty by reason of insanity, or to have suffered from diminished capacity. The episode "No Traveller Returns" is dedicated to establishing whether cannibal murderer Mandar Kush, who has spent eleven years in an institution, can be released into society. The answer is yes.
- Used in an episode of Psych. Interestingly, the episode begins after the defense has been used and the sentence passed. Lassiter becomes enraged by the verdict and thinks the defendant was faking it, so he sends Shawn to investigate. The defendant was actually insane, but wasn't actually the murderer.
- Accused: Discussed in "Stephen's Story". Stephen's attorney wants him to get a psychiatric examination so they can prove he was insane at the time of his crime (he's clearly a schizophrenic). Stephen refuses, though, denying he's mentally ill and claiming what happened was justified to defend himself and his family. This doesn't work, and he gets convicted of attempted murder.
- Roy Brown's "Butcher Pete";
Well, they put him in jail again
They tried to give him life
Pete beat the case, he pleaded insane
They gave him back his same ole knife
- "Tabard of Pizarro", an episode of Bold Venture, had the guest star claim that he was framed for murdering his wife, and pled insanity so as to be free to eventually claim his revenge (the villain of the story tries to frame the protagonist for murder during the course of the episode, so it seems likely the guest star is telling the truth). Unfortunately, it was many years before he was considered fit to be released. The eponymous tabard is a fake, created as physical therapy in the asylum, and used as bait to trap the villain. Oh, and the revenge thing didn't turn out so well, not being satisfying at all.
- Addressed in at least two editions of Champions, thanks to Hero author Steven Long also being a practicing attorney. Game-world legal precedents have established that dressing up in a silly costume does not count as insanity, and neither does committing bizarre crimes. The villain Foxbat, who genuinely believes that he is a character in a comic book, is listed as an example of someone who could use the insanity defense.
- Phoenix Wright: Ace Attorney had an Amoral Attorney pressure his client into using an insanity defense. It worked, but the defendant's life was ruined as a result, when he could have been found Not Guilty because he hadn't committed the crime. So he killed the attorney fifteen years later.
- In Knights of the Old Republic, if you let the lawyer appointed to you handle the trial (without telling him that you have evidence of a Sith plot) after you've broken into the Sith embassy in Manaan, then he'll try this as a last defense. It fails, and you're executed in a Non-Standard Game Over.
- In Remember11, Keiko Inubushi avoided going to prison after murdering twelve people due to suffering from Dissociative Identity Disorder. Instead, she was sent to the SPHIA psychiatric hospital.
- In Corpse Party, this is how Yoshikazu Yanagihori avoided going to jail for abducting four children and killing three of him. He actually was pretty insane at that point and he wasn't even the real killer, just an accomplice to the real killer, who was manipulating him, so a mental hospital was probably the best place for him. Unfortunately, security was not very good (it was 1973 Japan) and he ended up breaking out. He then broke into the school where the children were killed and hanged himself.
- Saturday Morning Breakfast Cereal:
- In Freefall, Sam is a larcenous, silver-tongued alien squid. He mentions that spending more than three weeks with him is legally grounds for an individual insanity plea.
- In the Futurama episode "Insane in the Mainframe", Simple Country Lawyer Hyperchicken uses the insanity defense in favor of Fry and Bender, and offers as proof the fact that "they done hired me as their lawyer." What then happens is that they're put in the mental institution, similar to what would have happened now if they weren't found "Guilty but Insane". Note that this in a country where being poor has recently been classified as a mental illness.
- Judy suggests using this excuse when Doug is framed for stealing Mr. Bone's trophy. Doug mentions that someone else actually tried that before but still got in trouble and had to go to the school counselor every day.
- In Archer, Cheryl uses this tactic effectively to avoid jail time, instead being thrown into a mental hospital for ten months. She urges her friends to follow her lead in order to avoid getting arrested for trespassing.
- Harvey Birdman, Attorney at Law:
- Subverted in an episode. Harvey tries to use this defense to acquit his client, and it looked like the jury was going to buy it...and then a talking tapir points out that the defense can only be used in criminal cases. Harvey was defending a man in a lawsuit.
- He used this defense earlier in "The Dabba Don" when he defended Fred Flintstone from charges of violating the RICO Act (in other words, being The Don). He successfully argued that Fred suffered from Identity Amnesia and only thought he was a mafia boss. Then it turns out that despite all clues to the contrary, Fred never was The Don. Barney Rubble was.
Mythology and Religion
- In most Christian Denominations, insanity reduces or outright eliminates someone's responsibility for a sin he commits.
- In Islam, the Prophet Muhammad is recorded as saying the following with regards to this trope.
“The Pen has been lifted from three note : from the sleeper until he awakens, from the child until he reaches puberty and from the insane person until he comes to his senses.”
- Louis Riel's lawyers wanted him to plead insanity to be found not guilty of treason. People will never know if it would have worked, because Riel wanted to use his time in court as a final opportunity to make public the natives' problems. He was found guilty and hanged.
- One of the better known cases in recent American history was the murder of Supervisor Harvey Milk and Mayor George Moscone in San Francisco. Former Supervisor Dan White's defense team was able to convince the jury that he was in such a mental state as to be incapable of premeditation, so he ended up being convicted of voluntary manslaughter (causing riots by San Francisco gay men who saw this as an inadequate outcome motivated by homophobia). Among other things, they cited White's shift from health nut to junk food addict as evidence of his declining mental state. The references to junk food led to the coining of the term "Twinkie Defense". The term "Twinkie Defense" has now entered the language to describe a frivolously thin defence of insanity, with a common belief being that White's lawyers claimed that he should be let off because he did the killings while on a sugar high. Nothing like such an argument was actually used by the defense (and Twinkies were mentioned only in passing), but people think it was.
- A man in Alberta beheaded a fellow passenger on a Greyhound bus. He was found not criminally responsible because he is insane. He was, however, deemed a significant risk — which means he will likely spend the rest of his life in a rubber room. A lot of people misunderstood what the verdict meant for the defendant, and there was some anger that he wasn't found guilty. Others, of course, pointed out that while he might not be in an actual prison, he'd spend a lot longer in a psychiatric institution — essentially, instead of "life with chance of parole in some number of years", he got "life with no real chance of parole".
- A man strangled his wife in his sleep and was released as it was decided that his sleep disorder meant that he wasn't responsible for this act. New Scientist has included a discussion of how you can show whether or not someone has a sleep disorder (after staying awake for 25 hours, a given tone woke up all the sleep-disordered positive people and none of the healthy controls).
- John Hinckley, Jr. attempted to assassinate Ronald Reagan and is one of the few "successful" insanity defense stories. The verdict led to widespread dismay; as a result, the U.S. Congress and a number of states rewrote laws regarding the insanity defense. Idaho, Montana, and Utah have abolished the defense altogether. The dismay is ironic, as he has been in a mental institution for over 30 years, probably more time than he would have spent in prison if convicted, certainly longer than many "sane" murderers spend in prison. Judging by what he did before the attempt and the way he defended himself during trial, he had been everything but sane. Unfortunately, the only way to be sure is to release him now and provide the logistics needed to trace back his obsession — Jodie Foster — if he could cling to it for 35 years and still not give up, he's too insane to count. In August 2016, it was announced that Hinckley would be released, so we'll possibly see now.
- The US Supreme Court ruled that people who are insane cannot be executed, on the grounds that someone who is to be executed must be capable of comprehending the gravity of their own death. Therefore, if medication can make someone sane, they can be forced to take it so they can be executed.
- The lawyers of Serial Killer Herbert Mullin tried this. Somewhat bizarrely, it didn't work, as it was considered that his crimes were too well-planned to be the work of an insane person, even though his motive was that he had a delusion that he had to kill people lest a whole coast of the US be wiped out by natural disasters.
- The Richard Chase trial was similar.
- Jared Loughner is an interesting example of just how hard it is to pull this off in real life. Prior to killing six people, he'd been forced out of college and told he couldn't come back unless he could maintain a mental health clearance proving he wasn't a danger to himself and others. The sheer incoherence of his political and philosophical ramblings got him ejected from abovetopsecret.com, one of the more out-there conspiracy theory sites on the Internet, and countless witnesses on and off-line report him as having done everything from accusing his math teacher of "denying math" to spending thirty minutes in a bathroom and asking afterwards what year it was. He has since been medicated and pleaded guilty.
- An interesting case is an ongoing thread of Jon Ronson's book The Psychopath Test, where he meets a man who pleaded insanity in the expectation that this would be a lighter sentence. Pleading insanity under those circumstances was seen by his doctors as evidence that he actually was insane — but not the kind of insane he claimed to be; it checked the item "Cunning / Manipulative" on the aforementioned Psychopath test, so he was held far longer than he would have been if he had pleaded guilty to the original offense. The book also covers a fairly chilling catch-22; if he expresses no remorse for his crime, he meets one criteria for psychopathy, but if he does express remorse, that could easily be viewed as yet another reason to check "Cunning / Manipulative". Ronson has a TED talk where he discusses this case.
- The lawyers of the British child-killer Ian Brady tried this, basically relying on circular reasoning: "My client has done something so horrible he must be insane, therefore he is insane." It didn't work initially, though he has since been transferred to Broadmoor Psychiatric Hospital — which is specifically for the criminally insane (mostly those who've killed people) and, for someone like him, basically means the most secure detention facility in the UK. "Hospital" is not Broadmoor. He has since survived a murder attempt by another inmate, which left him blind in one eye. It seems safe to say being deemed insane hasn't given him any better treatment than in prison.
- James Holmes, the perpetrator of the 2012 Aurora Colorado shootings, has apparently been called this by his defense attorney. Holmes had also dyed his hair orange and was referring to himself as "the Joker". Then again, he propped open an emergency exit before his rampage so that he could sneak into the theater past the front, and had placed a large number of complicated, connected traps in his apartment that police took several days to disable. In the end, he was found guilty by the jury, but spared the death sentence.
- This was the plea entered in the trial of Winston Moseley, murderer of Kitty Genovese. Although he did show signs of mental illness, the jury decided he did not fit the legal criteria; among other things, he said that he had deliberately counted on no one interfering with his attack, showing that he was aware of the nature of his actions. He remains in prison.
- Jeffrey Dahmer also tried the insanity plea unsuccessfully. He was responsible for at least 17 murders in Milwaukee between 1978 and 1991. He also experimented with cannibalism. Prevailing wisdom indicates that if Dahmer had been insane, he would have been caught much sooner, as his 13-year killing spree took a certain amount of mental faculty to hide, especially given the fact that he was able to talk himself out of trouble on more than one occasion. Ironically, he was then killed in prison by another inmate who claimed that God told him to, but also was not deemed insane.
- In 1970 Twiggs Lyndon, the road manager of The Allman Brothers Band, got in a fight with Buffalo, New York nightclub owner Angelo Aliotta, after Aliotta paid the band just $500 of a $1000 guarantee. In the middle of the fracas, Lyndon stabbed Aliotta, who died a short time later. At the trial, Lyndon's lawyer argued that being the manager of a band that heavily indulged in Sex, Drugs and Rock & Roll had affected his sanity. As proof, they called bassist Berry Oakley to the stand, where he admitted to regularly using drugs, including right before he came to the courtroom. Lyndon was acquitted of first-degree murder, given credit for time served, and sentenced to a few months in a psychiatric hospital. Then he went back to managing the Allmans.
- Not only is it very difficult to successfully argue insanity, in many cases it only makes the situation worse for the defendant. In some US states, being declared unfit only delays the trial, which must resume if the accused is to be released from custody; and since mental health hospitals are rare these days, this time will probably be spent in the prison that the offender would have been sent to anyway. Also, inmates who are "civil commits" have special restrictions that limit contact with properly convicted inmates, which would lead to a lonely (and indefinite) prison term.