"Oh, for crying out loud, no! I had no intention of committing any crimes!
In a series with a recurring Big Bad
, it is sometimes the case that a side-villain or Monster of the Week
is introduced to cause havoc and shake things up.
Of course, since this is a series with a recurring Big Bad
, our heroes may feel perfectly justified in going after the usual suspects. This trope refers to such scenes, in which our regular villain is forced to inform the protagonists that this installment's plot is not his or her doing. This may or may not be believed at first, but after the villain's innocence is established, expect him to curtly dismiss the heroes.
Traditional Truce Zone
requirements mandate that regardless of all the crimes they committed yesterday
, if caught for the wrong thing today; the heroes have to let them go. Either that or the Big Bad
got Off on a Technicality
This trope can be chalked up to The Law of Conservation of Detail
: if you're going to have your villain appear, it might as well be relevant to the plot at hand.
This trope may also occur with any character who has a recurring habit. May or may not lead to Evil Versus Evil
or Enemy Mine
, depending on the story. (A villain might be upset that he was blamed for something he didn't do, or even worse, upset that while he'd have liked
to do it, he'd prefer actually doing it before the hero pounds on him for it. Either reason is enough for him to be pissed at the guy who really
Also see Villains Out Shopping
, which might explain the villain's innocence. Compare Motive Misidentification
, where the Big Bad
is responsible, but for different reasons than the heroes initially suspect. Contrast Hijacked by Ganon
, where it seems like a new villain is at fault but the Big Bad
is revealed to be pulling the strings.
open/close all folders
- A heroic example in Calvin & Hobbes: The Series - Calvin is framed for a water balloon attack he didn't do, and thus ends up having to clear his name.
- Happens to Don Paolo in the Professor Layton fanfic Knights and Knaves. Inspector Chelmey hauls him in for questioning about a series of mysterious clues that have been cropping up across London - simply because he doesn't have any better ideas about who might be responsible. Don Paolo protests his innocence, and is in fact telling the truth.
- In Phantom of Beika Street (a Detective Conan/Danny Phantom crossover), an bright explosion somehow causes a large amount of green goo to splatter everywhere. Yamamoto accused Kaito since he was right next to it when it happened and he's known for such stunts, but Kaito nearly quotes this trope. His answer actually satisfies everyone since they're aware that if he was responsible, he would be taking credit for it.
- In the A Date With Destiny section of the Code Mars Trilogy, Mars seeks to rescue the hostages from the JLF during the hotel jacking. She finds Zero and accuses him being behind it. Unaware of Zero's sudden entrance, he clearly tells her he wasn't behind it, showing the real mastermind's dead body.
- Zig-zagged in the Attack on Titan fanfic, My Child, when Levi and Mikasa's child is about to die, Levi asks Xaphan, the demon who's trying to take his soul, if he knows anything, but Xaphan responds, "Oh, because I'm a demon, everything's my fault? I see how it is. Well, it doesn't matter." and says that if Levi doesn't give him his soul, his child will die. Once Levi signs the contract, Xaphan admits that he was lying all along, so it is possible that he was responsible.
- In The Fairly Oddparents fanfic, Never Had A Friend Like Me, there's a rare hero to hero version of this trope. Jorgen thinks Timmy caused the magical chaos that led to disappearance of the anti-fairies and pixies.
- In WWE Smackdown:
- A storyline in 2010 involved Kane looking for the one who put The Undertaker in a coma. When he accused CM Punk of doing the deed, Punk replied that while he wanted to do it, it wasn't him this time. Kane proceeds to identify Rey Mysterio as the attacker. Subverted; it was Kane himself who was responsible for it all.
- An early storyline in 2011 had Smackdown General Manager Teddy Long getting taken out. Since Wade Barrett had just formed The Corre on that episode, had done something similar to the previous Raw GM during his time as The Nexus leader, and Teddy had just tempted fate by telling them that he would not allow himself to be cowed by their beatdown antics like the current Raw GM was, they were naturally the first suspects. However, they denied having anything to do with it. It eventually turns out that they were telling the truth. It was Vickie Guerrerro and Dolph Ziggler that did it.
- In the Mid Ship Detective Agency attraction for Disney Cruise Line, one of the cases the guests have to solve is who kidnapped the Dalmatian Puppies from 101 Dalmations on the ship. One of the suspects is Cruella De Vil, who despite her threats against the dogs in continuity, she has an alibi, as she wasn't even on the ship at the time they were kidnapped. The Queen was later revealed to be the culprit.note
- You yourself may or have already said this once in your life if you've been blamed for something you didn't do, especially if you're known for making trouble on occasions.
- 2011, the infamous PlayStation Network hack. Anonymous, known for their acts of internet activism/vandalism, came out with a statement titled "For Once We Didn't Do It".
- During World War II, an infamous event called the Katyn Massacre occurred. The Soviets and the Allies claimed that Nazi Germany committed the Massacre, while Germany said that the Soviet Union was responsible for the atrocity. Soviet Union event tried to condemn Germany for the Katyn Massacre during the Nuremberg Trials in 1945 (it didn't work). Records released after the Soviet Union collapsed eventually revealed that, for once, Germany was innocent of that war crime, and it was in fact the Soviets who did it.