Dawson Casting: Ted Neeley, now in his seventies, continues to make appearances as Jesus.
Fake Shemp: During the recording of the original album, part of a single line in “Pilate and Christ” (“Who is this unfortunate?”) was accidentally taped over. Barry Dennen (Pilate) was unable to re-record, so Murray Head (Judas) filled in doing a hilariously nasal impression of Dennen on only the last two words.
Averted during “The 39 Lashes”- that’s Tim Rice, not Barry Dennen, counting thr lashes, but the decision to have Pilate counting came later, and Rice is simply providing a narrative function.
Meaningful Release Date: The 2018 NBC live production aired on Easter Sunday (which was coincidentally also April Fools' Day that year), the celebration of Christ's resurrection in Christian tradition.
Old Shame: Not the work itself, which is one of Lloyd Webber’s proudest achievements, but the 1971 Broadway production, an intensely abstract mess that reportedly brought him to tears with fear that it would be the last anyone cared to hear of the score. Enter Australian director Jim Sharman and designer Brian Thompson, whose reinvention for a Down Under staging set a show-saving standard they exported to London.
Production Posse: Was in fact the origin of much of the gang behind The Rocky Horror Picture Show and Shock Treatment. Richard O Brien met director Jim Sharman while starring as an apostle (and for one disastrous night, Herod) in the London production and eventually pitched his own idea for a rock musical B-movie satire. Sharman enthusiastically accepted the project and brought Thompson along to design the sets, while also suggesting a tap-dancer named Laura Campbell- eventually known to pop culture history as Little Nell- whom he’d seen busking outside the theater where Superstar was playing, for the role of Columbia. With a few more additions, all of them would stick together through Rocky’s original stage production, the film, and the pseudo-sequel Shock Treatment.
Romance on the Set: Ted Neeley met his future wife during the production (she's one of the background dancers in the "Simon Zealotes" segment). They've been married for nearly 40 years. Lyricist Tim Rice fell in love with Elaine Paige after the two met when she was a chorus member in an early production; they had a 12-year affair, but never married as Rice was (and still is) married to his estranged wife.
The last shot of the original film is a zoom out of the cross which is left behind. In the foreground, a shepherd can be seen walking by. It was not planned that way, but the filmmakers felt that it fit the scene so well, they kept it in the film.
Judas being surprised by fighter jets screaming by was completely unexpected (they were genuine Israeli fighters on patrol) and was kept in the final cut.
One of those up for the role of Jesus was a nineteen-year old actor from New Jersey named John Travolta. Not saying it would've been good, but it certainly would've been interesting.
Ted Neeley auditioned for Judas. No, seriously.
The 2014 revived touring production was going to have John Lydon as Herod, Brandon Boyd as Judas, Michelle Williams as Mary Magadalene, and JC Chasez as Pontius Pilate, before being abruptly cancelled by the promoter. Oddly enough (or not) the promoter also happens to be the one behind Spider-Man: Turn Off the Dark. The promoter is currently being sued for breach of contract by Andrew Lloyd-Webber.