- Alas, Poor Scrappy: Even among Yukine's haters (and there were a lot of them), many found his "purification" to be excessively cruel. He gained a lot of fans for simply accepting it rather than turning into an ayakashi. Subverted; although he didn't die, he came quite close to it.
- Alternative Character Interpretation:
- Yato. Due to the ambiguous nature of his backstory and the fact that he considers himself Above Good and Evil, there's plenty of theories to go around. Is he really a Nice Guy who you don't want to push too far? Are his actions because he's atoning for his Dark and Troubled Past, much like Himura Kenshin? Is he really a Blood Knight or Ax-Crazy who is only kept in check by Hiyori?
- Just how much of a positive influence is Hiyori on Yato and Yukine? The most well-accepted theory is that she's just a friend they've come to care a great deal for, but some take it to an extreme and say that she's the only thing keeping Yato from going full God of Calamity. On the other hand, some say that she is actually a negative influence, considering that Yato has shown his Superpowered Evil Side more and more the longer they've known her. This trope also applies In-Universe, as Tenjin notes that even though Yato and Yukine care for Hiyori a lot, when gods get close to one human and neglect others, chaos follows.
- Is Kugaha an irredeemable villain who's only in it for himself, or did he truly believe he was doing what was right for Bishamon? The series suggests the first heavily, but the final confrontation, in which he delivers his Motive Rant, brings up some moral ambiguity to his character. Also In-Universe; Bishamon is willing to forgive him and feels sorry for him, while Yato hates him and considers him pure evil. Tenjin is also not too fond of him, but is willing to recognize his usefulness to Yato's father's plans and takes him prisoner rather than killing him outright. Unfortunately for Kugaha, his "usefulness" involves Mind Rape.
- Also, that he never once blighted Bishamon suggests that at least he believed that everything he was doing was for her benefit.
- Ass Pull: The Underworld Arc has the misfortune of ending with both a Deus ex Machina and a Diabolus ex Machina. On the one hand, Yato can be magically transported out of the Underworld by a spell that's never been mentioned before, the only catch being that it has to be performed by a human; lucky that there just happens to be a human present... On the other hand, Ebisu has finally braved everything the Underworld had to throw at him and came out on top, complete with Yato seemingly and awesomely making a Heroic Sacrifice for him, only to be unceremoniously Impaled with Extreme Prejudice by the other gods who have judged him guilty of being the Sorceror.
- Broken Base: Hiyori's increasing uselessness with every arc is...divisive to say the least. While no one really is in favor of it, a lot of fans are okay with it, saying that it's a logical consequence of an ordinary human getting involved with gods in an increasingly fighting-oriented series and that Hiyori fills her role as The Heart and the Team Mom quite well. Others are not, believing she has been reduced to nothing but a plot device who can only stand on the sidelines, cheer Yato on, and occasionally get captured; these fans would prefer she take a level in badass and tend to like Bishamon more than Hiyori. Interestingly, Kaoru Kamiya, the character who filled the same role to Kenshin, the character Yato is an Expy of, as Hiyori does to Yato, also got this exact same treatment back in The '90s. The divisive reaction is somewhat mitigated during Chapter 62, in which Hiyori BEATS the shit out of Father. Sure he was holding back and warns Hiyori about her parents, but Hiyori doesn't care about his cruel jokes anymore.
- Die for Our Ship: Hiyori is shipped quite a few different ways, including with Yato, Yukine, Kazuma, and even Kofuku, but all the ships are fairly civil with each other. So when Hiyori's Sacred First Kiss was taken, you'd think the losing ships would gracefully concede, right? Wrong. The problem was that out of all the candidates, the one who ended up kissing her was Ordinary High-School Student Kouta Fujisaki. As soon as the chapter in which it happened was published, nearly all other Hiyori ships started calling for his head. Fujisaki being revealed to be Yato's Father and doing it all to mess with Yato has made it worse; now he's even more hated.
- Fan-Preferred Couple:
- Yato X Hiyori is the most popular ship.
- Bishamon X Kazuma also serves as a close runner up.
- If you're talking slash, Yato/Yukine is really popular as well.
- Fridge Brilliance: Hiyori regaining her memories of Yato and Yukine by smelling Yato in the anime holds some credibility since familiar scents are often used to help people who are recovering from amnesia.
- Growing the Beard: For the anime, the general consensus among critics and fans is that Season 2 has done this for Noragami through introducing more complex plots, characterization and adapting one of the major manga story arcs.
- Ho Yay: There's definitely some between Yato and Yukine, and almost always instigated by Yato.
Yato: That's why I fell for him at first sight! (proceeds to glomp Yukine and rub up against him, cat-style)
- In Episode 5, Yato's comments about Yukine are really suggestive even in the context of the scene.
Kazuma: Your father...just who is he?Yato: ...What would you do if I told you? Go introduce yourself? If it's to ask for his blessing in marriage, I'm already gonna be Hiyori's husband!
- Later in the manga, Hiyori refers to Yukine as Yato's "one and only", multiple times.
- Yato evades a serious question from Kazuma by acting like a fool.
- On the girls' side of things, Kofuku is veeeery interested in her "Hiyorin", even groping her several times.
- Harsher in Hindsight: According to this post on tumblr, a lot of Yato's more goofy characterization and the treatment he's received by those around him veers darkly into this territory as it realistically reflects the impact abuse can have on an individual.
- Hype Backlash: As Noragami's fandom have continually grown, it is becoming more common to find Fan Haters who think it's overrated and don't want anything to do with the series. While it's not as big as the cases of Naruto, Sword Art Online, and Axis Powers Hetalia, there is still quite a bit of this.
- Magnificent Bastard: Yato's father is a human who's been manipulating and outwitting gods for many years. He created Yaboku, a god that only he knew, to do his own dirty work in order to ensure that he couldn't turn against his master without dying himself. In the present time, he first used his shinki Kugaha to sow discord in Bishamon's clan in order to hopefully kill her and gain control over her reincarnation, with the added bonus of possibly turning gods against each other. Afterwards, he orders Yato to help Ebisu descend into the Underworld to steal Izanami's ayakashi-controlling brush so that he can get Ebisu framed as the Sorcerer in order to mask his own control of ayakashi, AND obtain the brush for himself. When Yato cuts off ties with him, he responds by Body Surfing into the body of Hiyori's schoolmate Kouta Fujisaki and immediately goes after the weakest member of Yato's group, nearly driving her over the Despair Event Horizon and ruining her family's reputation in a move straight out of The Thirty Six Stratagems. Father is not just an Arc Villain; he's The Man Behind the Man to EVERYTHING that has happened in the manga so far.
- Memetic Mutation: It's a running gag within the fandom to use 5 yen in any sentence when talking about the series.
- Moral Event Horizon: Yato's dad takes a swan dive off it in Chapter 50 through causing the patients of the hospital Hiyori's dad works in to go into a homicidal rage. Hiyori's mother gets bludgeoned by one of the patients and to top things off, "Father" does everything in his power to try make Yato kill Hiyori in a nightmarish Sadistic Choice.
- The Gratuitous English-filled song in Episode 2 of the anime reeks of this.
- Episode 8, Yukine has finally reached the Despair Event Horizon when he realizes he can never have friends in the real world. The animation has him screaming his lungs out, but there's no actual sound, leading to the scene looking more comical than depressing.
- The frequent use of comic relief in the Father arc, even immediately following such serious moments as Hiyori nearly crossing the Despair Event Horizon, turning into an ayakashi, and forcing Yato to kill her, has many fans laughing for the wrong reasons.
- Rescued from the Scrappy Heap: Yukine. He was a total jerk that was killing Yato. After his punishment he improved, so did the fandom reaction to him. When he had a Disney Death that lead to his evolution into a Blessed Vessel in Chapter 19, the fandom was horrified.
- The Scrappy: While Kugaha was introduced as a Manipulative Bastard, he got a hold of the Villain Ball in record time, resulting in the fandom unilaterally hating him for being Too Dumb to Live, although messing with sympathetic characters like Bishamon and Yukine didn't help. It's very telling that when he made a surprise return in the Underworld arc, the fan reaction was a near-consensus "oh my god, why hasn't someone killed him yet?!"
- Signature Scene: The scene where Yato and the gang are falling off a skyscraper while Yato's client tells his overly long backstory tends to be the most remembered.
YMMV / Noragami