The beautiful only child of a widowed queen is sent off to marry the prince to whom she is betrothed. Before she leaves, her mother presents her with a small token; some versions say it is a lock of the mother's hair, others have it as a handkerchief with drops of the mother's blood. In any case, this token provides her with magical protection. She is also presented with Falada, a magical horse with the ability to speak.
However, the maidservant who accompanies the princess treats her very brutishly, and when circumstances cause the princess to lose her token, the maid seizes the opportunity to force the princess into trading places. She makes the princess switch clothes with her, and tries to ride Falada, though in most versions he refuses and the maid has no choice but to continue riding her ordinary horse. The maid further extorts a vow from the real princess that she will never tell a living soul what has happened, on threat of death.
Once they arrive in the prince's kingdom, the false princess says that Falada was a very ill-tempered mount and demands that he be executed (so he can't speak up and reveal the truth). She also wants the true princess nowhere near her, and says that the king can make her whatever sort of servant he pleases. The true princess, grieving for Falada's death, manages to persuade the groom to have the horse's head mounted above one of the palace gates where she can still see it every day.
The true princess is so lovely and delicate that no one can bear to give her hard work, so they send her out with the goose boy. In the morning and in the evening, she sighs over her horse's head and it responds. During the day, she tries to comb her hair, but it looks so much like real gold that the goose boy is convinced that it is, and tries to steal some; she uses a little rhyme to summon the wind to blow the goose boy's cap away, making him chase it and letting her comb her hair in peace.
After three days of this, the goose boy complains that he won't work with her any more, and his report catches the ear of the king (who is not at all impressed with the false princess). He approaches the goose girl, but she is bound by her promise not to speak of her misfortunes to any living creature - so he kindly suggests that she unburden herself to the iron stove in the palace kitchen. While she does that, the king sneaks up to the roof and listens at the chimney in order to hear the truth. Now aware of the deception, the king sends the true princess to the royal household to be dressed properly, and then he brings her to a great banquet. She makes so fine an appearance that even the false princess does not recognize her.
The king asks the guests what sort of punishment would be fitting for someone who has deceived everyone around them, and proceeds to describe the situation in a way that does not reveal anyone's identity. He turns to the false princess for her opinion, and she recommends an exceptionally cruel and gruesome style of execution. He then condemns her to the very death she has suggested, introduces his son to the true princess, and the young couple are delighted with each other and marry the next day.
In some versions, the princess is the daughter of a fairy or other magical being, who restores all her fortunes once she is married, including bringing the dead horse back to life.
A Gender Flip is found in both the Chivalric Romance Roswall And Lillian and the Child Ballad "The Lord of Lorn and the False Steward". The Romanian fairy tale "Harap Alb" ("White Slave") by Ion Creanga also has the prince/evil servant switch as its main plot.
In 2003, Shannon Hale wrote a young adult novel retelling of the story, which was so successful that she ultimately wrote three sequels, creating the Books of Bayern series.
Tropes found in this story include:
- Amateur Sleuth: The king, who personally finds out what the deal is with the new goose girl.
- Barefoot Poverty: The real princess and Conrad the goose boy.
- Beauty Equals Goodness: The princess.
- Bride and Switch: The central plot.
- Cruel and Unusual Death: What the chambermaid brings upon herself: dragged to death in a barrel studded with nails.
- Damsel in Distress: The real princess.
- Exact Words: She promised not to tell a single living creature. The stove didn't count.
- Dead Guy on Display: Falada.
- Entitled Bitch: The maid, who is all too happy to push the princess around and make them swap places (threatening to murder the poor girl if she doesn't).
- Exact Eavesdropping: The king deliberately engineered a situation in which he could do this.
- Extreme Doormat: The princess is too humble to reprimand her maidservant for disobeying her, even when she has her mother's protective charm still in her hand.
- Fallen-on-Hard-Times Job: The title job.
- Family-Unfriendly Death: The maid's specifically, she is put, stark naked, into a barrel lined with nails, which is then dragged about the streets by two white horses until she is dead.
- The Good King: The prince's father seems to be this.
- Hair of Gold, Heart of Gold: It's not literally gold, but the goose boy isn't exactly the brightest either.
- Happily Ever After: Implied by the ending.
- The High Queen: The princess's mother seems to be this.
- Hoist by His Own Petard: The chambermaid. After the king asks what punishment she thinks would be most fitting for someone who has committed the crime she (doesn't realize he already knows she) has committed, it's carried out forthwith. See Family-Unfriendly Death.
- Honor Before Reason: The princess still honors the oath she made under duress, even if speaking up would solve all of her problems.
- I Gave My Word: The princess.
- Interspecies Friendship: The princess and Falada.
- Iron Maiden: A variant provides the Family-Unfriendly Death of the false princess.
- Kick the Dog: The none-too-bright goose boy not only thinks it's a great idea to try and rip out some of his coworker's hair, but he gets terribly offended when she casts a magic spell to stop him.
- Leonine Contract: The princess agrees to switch places with the maid in order to keep the maid from killing her.
- Nice Job Fixing It, Villain: Downplayed in the case of the goose boy. While he's not an out-and-out villain, he's still a moronic Jerkass who complains to the king that the titular goose girl won't let him tear out her hair. This causes the king to question her, which ultimately leads to her happy ending.
- Original Position Fallacy: The false princess fails to realize that the horrible death she orders will happen to her.
- Perfectly Arranged Marriage: They never set eyes on each other until the king explains everything to his son, but once they meet, the prince and princess are very satisfied by the setup.
- Royals Who Actually Do Something: The king alone notices something off about his son's supposed bride and the goose boy's story about the insubordinate goose girl, so he takes it upon himself to find out what happened (rather than sending a servant to it for him) and resolves the whole story's conflict single-handedly.
- Rags to Royalty: Inverted with the true princess, then played straight when her status is restored in the ending.
- Rule of Three: The mother gives the princess a handkerchief with three drops of blood as magical protection, and the princess is forced to be a goose girl for presumably three days; or at least Falada's decapitated head informs her that her mother's heart would break if she knew followed closely by the goose girl asking the wind to chase Conrad's hat three times before the king saves her from her situation.
- Rule of Two: The evil chambermaid pounces on her chance to switch places with the princess the second time she dips down to the stream to get some water.
- Spared by the Adaptation:
- Most modern retellings skip the part where Falada is decapitated and mounted in the archway. Instead, the princess pays off the executioner and she keeps the horse in a little-used field.
- Several retellings also provide the maid with a less gruesome fate, as the princess intervenes to have her exiled instead.
- Surrogate Soliloquy: Talk to the stove.
- Talking Animal: Falada. Even after getting beheaded!
- Too Dumb to Live: The maid. How often do servants impersonate their employers, that she didn't get suspicious when the king asked her to name the punishment for her exact case?
- Unusually Uninteresting Sight: If Falada being a talking animal wasn't this already, then his severed head somehow talking while nailed to a public gateway seems to be this for the townsfolk and the goose boy.
- Victoria's Secret Compartment: The aforementioned handkerchief is kept in the princess' bosom.