YMMV / Amphibia

YMMV tropes for the Amphibia series

Tropes with their own pages:

• Alternative Character Interpretation
• Angst? What Angst?
• Base Breaking Characters and Broken Base
• Draco in Leather Pants
• Fandom-Specific Plot
• Fanon
• Friendly Fandoms
• Harsher in Hindsight
• Memes
• They Wasted a Perfectly Good Plot
• What An Idiot!
• What Could Have Been

---

A-E

• Accidental Aesop:
  • Crying Wolf exists as a trope for a reason. If you lie too many times to people and threaten their lives, they have no reason to trust you. Sasha finds this out the hard way in "True Colors" when Anne refuses to believe her about the truth of King Andrias after she lied to Anne and the Plantars to stage a coup, locked them up, and spitefully attempted to send Anne home without giving the Plantars a proper goodbye.
  • "Lily Pad Thai's" ultimate message seems to boil down to "What professional critics look for is so far removed from what the public wants that appeasing them is pointless." When such a critic seems to be the only person who doesn't enjoy Stumpy and Anne's new cooking, they instead appease him with the novelty of a meal that comes to life and tries to kill him.
• Adorkable:
  • Marcy definitely embraces this. She's smart, a bit clumsy, and also really nerdy when it comes to her passions.
  • In "Anne of the Year", when Ivy Sundew asks Sprig if he'd like to go out with her, she does so while stuttering nervously. She initially takes his elated silence as a "no", and blushes furiously, covering her face with her hat out of embarrassment until Sprig admits he feels the same way.
• Alternative Character Interpretation: See here.
• Aluminum Christmas Trees: Tusked frogs, bizarre as they sound, are real, with two small tusks in their lower jaw. Of course, they don't have Hulking Out powers.
• Americans Hate Tingle: In Japan, Grime is noticeably less cared about, with there being very little fanart of him, if not just little fans in general. In comparison, in Western territories, he is one of the show's most popular characters. This is due to Grime's tough guy nature and less cute appearance contradicting with Japanese pop culture, which values the opposite of those things, hence why fanart commonly depicts the three main girls.
• Arc Fatigue: By far, the biggest criticism with the show is that while the Myth Arc is really good, it takes a while to get there.
  • Season 1 is a major Slow-Paced Beginning, with most of the season doing nothing but teasing the major picture and introducing the character in lighthearted episodes. There's one Villain Episode halfway through the season but otherwise the main storyline actually starts in "Reunion", the last episode of the season.
  • Anne trying to find a way to return to Amphibia takes the first half of the third season which causes the entire Amphibia cast to go Out of Focus, given this portion of the story is notably Lighter and Softer meaning it waits until the return to Amphibia to adress the consequences of "True Colors", these episodes can feel like a chore for those interesed in the main plotline.
  • "Turning Point" sets up Sasha's Redemption Quest only for her to disappear of the series until "Commander Anne" half a season later.
  • Marcy is even worse in this regard in Season 3. Like Sasha she only appears in one episode of Season 3A where she becomes a Mind Hive for the Greater-Scope Villain, while Sasha's story continues through the second half, Marcy doesn't get to confront her own actions until the penultimate episode and Sasha and Anne only acknowledge Marcy's existence one episode before that.
  • Season 3B also suffers of a Four Lines, All Waiting nature, with several episodes focusing solely on recruiting an old character (some of which appeared only in a single episode prior) into the resistance rather that focusing on properly fighting King Andrias's forces which is reserved to the final bunch of episodes.
  • Season 2 teases Anne, Sasha and Marcy to be part of a prophecy but it isn't until "Mother of Olms" that is finally revealed what that prophecy actually is. The problem is that by the time it was finally revealed most of it was inferred already, many fans felt it would have being more impactful if the content of the prophecy was revealed back in Season 2 rather that dragging a major Captain Obvious Reveal for one season.
• Ass Pull:
  • Many fans thought Hop Pop losing the election for mayor in "Hop Popular" because the rest of the valley also had a vote and he didn't campaign outside of Wartwood to be a huge cop out, not only this is a major case of Artistic License in Politics that had no foreshadowing before the fact but the in-universe elections are a series of trials that all happened in Wartwood leading into question what kind of campaigns would Toadstool do that had any relationship with that.
  • Related to that, The Reveal that after Hop Pop ran for mayor against Toadstool he unknowingly inspired other frogs across the valley to stand up and rebel against the toads that had been suppressing them can feel out of nowhere considering the resolution of the previously mentioned episode is all based on no one outside of Wartwood paying attention to his campaign, which leads into question why none of the rebel frogs voted for Hop Pop if the rest of the valley had a vote on the election.
  • After a 3-seasons Myth Arc focused on the Calamity Box, the Grand Finale suddenly reveals that there was a Guardian Deity meant to protect the stones this whole time, one has to wonder why after all the events of the series only now the guardian decided to show up.
• Awesome Art: The fight scene between Anne and King Andrias also doubles as an Animation Bump. In it, her hair becomes blue as she becomes invigorated by the power of the Calamity Box. From there comes a flashy, action-packed sequence where Anne moves at lightspeed when decimating Andrias' robot army.
• Awesomeness Withdrawal: Despite the show's overall message of letting go in the face of change, to say that the fandom hasn't been coping well with the show ending is a major understatement. In the first few months after the finale, the fandom has been so desperate in pining for new related content that Matt Braly had to give his own take on the situation.
• Broken Aesop:
  • "Dating Season" tries to teach viewers that you can't force people who clearly just want to be friends into a romantic relationship based on what you think or for your own desires, and that obsessive shipping can be a problem. Anne, Hop Pop, and Felicia realize this after Polly called Felicia and Hop Pop out for their greed and Anne for her shortsightedness. In the end, they finally decide to let Sprig and Ivy stay as friends, but Sprig ends up falling in love with Ivy anyways, and it was at least partly due to Anne, Hop Pop, and Felicia's meddling.
  • Regarding the series finale "The Hardest Thing" Some viewers believe that the episode's message about accepting change and loss was badly contradicted by things like the Anne being brought back after her Heroic Sacrifice, the trio being able to return to Earth after the gems were destroyed, and the Time Skip showing Marcy reuniting with Anne and Sasha after 10 years despite her own arc being about learning to accept being split from them.
• Bizarro Episode: "The Shut-In!" is very clearly not in continuity even in its framing story, with Polly turning into a monster at the end.
• Catharsis Factor:
  • For those troubled by Sasha's lying, manipulative, and domineering behavior toward Anne, it can be immensely satisfying to see various characters give her a scathing "Reason You Suck" Speech. Particularly, Sprig calls her a "bully" and Anne stands up to her in "Reunion", both Percy and Braddock call her out in "Barrel's Warhammer", and especially Anne absolutely lets her have it in "True Colors".
  • Andrias' breakdown and defeat in "All In" are so brutal to watch (especially due to the previous revelations about his true feelings about what he's doing and how he ultimately saved Marcy's life), there's next to no jubilation to be gained from watching Anne blast him out of his armor. But Darcy? After every vicious and cruel thing they've done to Marcy, Sasha, and Grime (and even Andrias) in the penultimate episode alone and their smug gloating about it, their complete and justified freak-out when they realize Sasha has severed their Achilles' Power Cord is truly something to savor.
    • Tragic as he may be, for those waiting to see Andrias face poetic justice for having run Marcy through with his sword in "True Colors" can take some satisfaction in seeing him willingly allowing Anne to run him through in a similar way, with her superpowered body flying right through him and his Mech Suit, dealing him a blow that does irreversible damage to his mechanical insides.
  • "The Hardest Thing" has Andrias finally standing up to his abusive father Aldrich and refusing his offer to become part of the Core by crushing the crown that Aldrich is speaking to him through in his hands. This is followed by Anne using the power of all three stones to destroy the Core once and for all, just as they were about to destroy Amphibia out of spite.
• Common Knowledge: Many people claim that in the Grand Finale, Anne was Killed Off for Real and replaced by a clone. Never mind the fact that this is only an implication; the Guardian of the Multiverse even noted that Anne could get resurrected into a new body, vague as it was.
• Complete Monster: King Aldrich Leviathan, the previous ruler of Newtopia and the father of the current ruler King Andrias, is a megalomaniacal tyrant desiring to rule Amphibia for eternity. Having implicitly invaded other worlds during his kingship, Aldrich tasks his son with strip-mining a medieval Earth and exterminating mankind, expressing nothing but contempt for the "primitive species". Upon assimilating his consciousness into the Core, Aldrich grooms his son into becoming the ruthless monarch he was. After being defeated and losing his connection to his host Marcy Wu, Aldrich activates his final gambit: sending an artificial moon to crash into Amphibia just to deny the heroes their victory.
• Continuity Lockout: Season 1 is mostly standalone, but season 2 and season 3 both follow a continuous narrative through each episode. However, most fans agree that it is imperative that one watches every episode, as the first season is nonetheless filled with countless Innocuously Important Episodes with characters, moments, and even gags that become plot relevant in the final season.
• Crosses the Line Twice:
  • In "Hop Luck", the baker sells dough to the Plantars in exchange for Sprig marrying his creepy daughter, Maddie — who is introduced by driving a splinter into a Voodoo Doll resembling Sprig. Everyone, from Anne to Hop Pop to Sprig himself, treats this as a minor inconvenience at most. As Anne (who is supposed to be Sprig's best friend) puts it: "Sprig's eternal happiness is a small price to pay for pizza."
  • Later in "Dating Season", both Anne and Hop Pop force Sprig to go on a date with Ivy while he's still being engaged to Maddie. Even though Sprig reminds them of this, Hop Pop tells him to forget about her as Ivy's family has access to exclusive crops that could make them rich. Even though both Sprig and Ivy didn't want to date at the time, Anne and Hop Pop both treat this as a minor inconvenience because of the former's obsessive shipping and the latter's greed.
• Crossover Ship: Many with The Owl House, since both are confirmed to take place in a Shared Universe.
  • Anne and Luz have many similarities, so fans think they would get along quite well.
  • Some think Luz would bond quickly with Marcy, due to being young girls with ambiguous disorders that see being trapped in another world as a dream come true. Marcy would love to go to Hexside, given how excited she is to learn about witchcraft from Maddie.
  • Many have joked about the idea of King Andrias and Emperor Belos either teaming up upon realizing how similar they and their goals are or becoming a couple.
  • Marcy and Hunter already have some fan-art, a fan-vid, and even a fanchild. No one knows how it got so popular, but Hunter already being a Launcher of a Thousand Ships may be the cause.
  • Sasha and Hunter is another popular pair, and it helps how similar both of their personalities, character arcs, and facial scars are. They're also both blondes.
• Cry for the Devil: After turning out to be Evil All Along, King Andrias seems for the first half of season 3 like a fun but irredeemably cruel and evil Chessmaster whose defeat, when it comes, will be extremely satisfying. But as the details of his background, his relationship with the Core, and his true feelings about Marcy and about the planned invasion are fleshed out, he becomes an increasingly tragic, broken man. Despite the terrible things he's done, when Andrias' downfall actually does come amid a full-blown Villainous BSoD in "All In", it's ultimately a brutal thing to watch and it's almost impossible to derive any joy from it.
• Diagnosed by the Audience:
  • Marcy Wu has many traits of autism, including trouble making eye contact and forming connections (which she mentions in season 2), hyperfocusing, highly specific interests, poor social skills, reacts in an overly excited manner towards ‘new’ things, and being too honest for her own good. More or less every fan agrees that she is on the autism spectrum. Incredibly, the creator denies intentionally writing Marcy Wu as a character with autism, although he agreed that she does show signs of it, and accepted it as canon after 3 psychiatrists gave their opinions that she fits the diagnosis.
  • Sprig having ADHD is one headcanon that's somewhat popular. Signs of this include his short-attention span, a compulsion to touch or do certain things at times, and having a Sensory Overload at one point.
• Ensemble Dark Horse:
  • Fanart for Maddie exploded as soon as the character was introduced. Her popularity further increased when "Cursed!" established her as a good person in spite of her looks. Which increased even more when "Maddie and Marcy" shows that she's also a Cool Big Sis to her younger triplet sisters Rosemary, Lavender, and Ginger despite them getting on her nerves at times. As well as forming a heartwarming friendship with fan-favorite Marcy Wu, with fanart featuring the two girls still being quite popular among fans. Many fans also find Maddie a much more interesting character than Ivy Sundew, and some still prefer to ship Maddie with Sprig over Ivy.
  • Wally is also pretty well liked by fans thanks to his silly and eccentric personality, and his presence ultimately leading to Anne meeting Sprig and ends up living with the Plantars. Fans grew to love him even more in his Day in the Limelight episode "Wally and Anne" and "Swamp and Insensitivity" with both episodes showing him form a sweet Intergenerational Friendship with Anne.
  • General Yunan, Scourge of the Sand Wars, Defeater of Ragnar the Wretched, aaaaand the youngest newt to ever achieve the rank of general in the great Newtopian Army, has gotten a huge amount of love thanks to her Large Ham nature, Blood Knight tendencies, and hamtastic portrayal by Zehra Fazal.
  • Maggie only appeared for less than a minute in the episode "Reunion" with only a handful of lines, but has received quite a bit of attention from fans. Fanart often portrays her as a sort of Sixth Ranger to the trio, or have her be stuck in Amphibia instead of Sasha or Marcy. She's also quite popular in memes, with Kao New Bing being memed to be her Trademark Favorite Food.
  • Mr. X acquired a great following after his debut episode. His eccentric yet menacing personality combined with his use of heelie shoes that contrast his sharp-dressed look made him a well-received and unique antagonist that fans wanted to see more of, despite him being only a secondary villain.
  • Both of Andrias's former friends Leif and Barrel quickly gained popularity among fans shortly after "The Core and the King". Part of the is because of their friendship dynamic being similar to the present Calamity Trio, and Leif and Barrel sharing many similarities with Marcy, which is very likely why the present Andrias wanted to befriend her.
    • Barrel is well liked because of his goofy Nice Guy personality; despite his tough guy appearance. It helps that he's voiced by none other than Jason Ritter, the voice actor of Dipper Pines from Gravity Falls. He ultimately becomes The Woobie of the group after he gets banished by his friend Andrias after his decent into darkness. So who doesn't want to give the poor guy a hug?!
    • Leif is loved by fans because she's a Nice Girl who loves all living things, and loves discovering new ways to interact with animals. Her selfless act to steal the Calamity Box to save Amphibia from destruction ultimately kick starts the events of the series. Even though it meant ending her friendship with Andrias and Barrel and getting exiled from Newtopia forever. After she Starting a New Life, it's revealed that she's also the founding member of the Plantar family home, and is Sprig, Polly, and Hop Pop's distant ancestor who help grant Leif's final wish to help Andrias redeem himself.
• Epileptic Trees:
  • A fairly popular theory goes that the magic from each of the three gems on the music box went into one of the girls, and they'll have to all put it back to go home, and that in the meantime, it'll give them each a superpower. This turns out to be true, for Anne at least, but the other two are left in the air for now since their gems are currently fully charged.
  • After the season 2 finale aired, two theories involving the girls losing limbs began popping up:
    • Anne losing her arm.
    • Sasha losing her eye.
    • Both theories are ultimately jossed. Both Anne and Sasha kept their limbs intact by the end of the show. Grime on the other hand loses an arm protecting Sasha from Darcy.
  • To a lesser extent, there are theories running around that someone (Hop Pop or one of the girls) is going to die in the series finale. Considering how Marcy actually got stabbed on screen for real, this might as well be plausible.
    • Ultimately, Anne was the one to die as a result of using the Calamity Stones to destroy the Core once and for all, only for cosmic intervention to rescue her and clone her, meaning she's Only Mostly Dead.
  • Rumors and theories about the series' ending being controversial began making rounds when an alleged tweet from Matt Braly implied it to be as such. The fact that Anne basically dies and gets "resurrected" as a clone in the series finale is probably what made it controversial in some way.
• Escapist Character: Marcy Wu is an awkward, clumsy nerd who, upon being sent to another world, becomes a respected hero in its most prosperous city and close friends with its king because of her knowledge of RPGs. It becomes something of an In-Universe example when it's revealed that she willingly got herself, Anne, and Sasha stuck in Amphibia in order to escape from her own problems on Earth, as well as a deconstruction, as her desire to live in a fantasy world causes her to be easily manipulated and winds up getting her almost killed.
• Evil Is Cool:
  • Captain Grime comes across as a total badass with his competency as a fighter and lack of cowardice demonstrated when he decides to take on a flock of herons attacking Toad Tower himself.
  • Sasha Waybright is a skilled manipulator to the point she becomes the right-hand of Captain Grime. She is also a very skilled swordfighter, giving Anne a tough fight in the season 1 finale "Reunion".
  • Tritonio Espada, a Dashing Hispanic salamander who is a skilled swordsmen running a defunct Train Job organization. He also grows to eventually respect Anne, taking his defeat like a champ.
  • Curator Ponds, who's a Corrupted Character Copy of Stan Pines from Gravity Falls. As a result, he's quite entertaining to watch, jumpscaring visitors of his wax exhibit purely to troll them, and shows that he can be surprisingly menacing by manipulating Anne into becoming part of his museum permanently.
  • King Andrias shows himself as being a master manipulator and commands an entire army of robo-frog minions. Despite his large frame, he is actually an agile combatant who even wields a flaming sword.
  • The Core, a Mind Hive of Amphibia's past rulers and greatest minds placed into a Mechanical Abomination, as well as the true Big Bad of the entire series. Furthered when it transfers its consciousness into Marcy to become Darcy, a Laughably Evil Psychopathic Womanchild with a Sinister Scythe and a Cool Helmet.
  • While he's an Anti-Villain at worst, Mr. X can qualify thanks to his goofy mannerisms and being rather competent in his attempts to capture the Plantars.

F-O

• Fanfic Fuel: The Calamity Box set each girl on a destined path, but some fans like to take the opportunity to see what may have happened if the roles were swapped. The fanfic Sasha and the Frogs brings up switching Anne and Sasha's places, and some stories like A Theory of Butterflies and Other Insects, Trade Us for the World, and A Witch in Wartwood take it a step further by adding Marcy to the mix.
• Fan Nickname:
  • Due to the similar visual style to Gravity Falls, some people started to refer to the show as "Gravity Frogs".
  • Before its official name was revealed, fans took to calling the Core, the Mechanical Abomination that Andrias serves, "the Night" in reference to the translated prophecy.
  • Anne, Sasha and Marcy are often referred to as "frog girls" or "Calamity Trio" after their connection to the stones in the Calamity Box was confirmed.
    • The other former group of friends depicted in the series, aka Andrias, Barrel and Leif, are called the "divorced trio".
  • Anne's Super Mode is called Super Saiyanne or Super Cyanne.
  • Similarly to the Core, prior to her official name being revealed, fans took to calling Leif, the pink frog Andrias was friends with until she stole the Calamity Box, Froog.
• Fandom Rivalry: A fairly mild, very friendly one popped up with The Owl House during Amphibia's second season, with the two shows premiering episodes back-to-back. At the time you would get fans debating who had the better episode that week, though these still had a tendency to sometimes escalate into more traditional, heated arguments over which show is better overall. Dana Terrace and Matt Braly have fostered a strong sense of camaraderie that has extended to the fandom, keeping everything friendly for the most part.
• Foe Yay Shipping: Sashanne (Sasha/Anne) is a fairly popular pairing that's slowly grew ever since the events of the season 1 finale. The short scene of the two battling each other in the season 2 opening added some fuel to shippers.
• Genius Bonus:
  • Amphibia bears a strong resemblance to Earth during the Carboniferous Period, a world of perpetual swamp where giant amphibians and insects were the dominant species. It also contains several species similar to those of the Late Cretaceous, including toothed birds and primitive, opossum-like mammals.
  • The beetles that Hop Pop befriends at the cemetery in "Sprig vs. Hop Pop" may be based on carrion beetles, which feed on dead bodies and are indeed one of the more social types of beetles.
  • The mind-controlling mushroom from "Children of the Spore" resembles the Ophiocordyceps unilateralis, a fungus that infects ants and manipulates their behavior.
  • Valeriana from the Bizarre Bazaar, who is possibly a salamander, makes sense to be associated with magic and mysteries, as salamanders were considered elementals of fire in alchemy.
  • The giant robot that Andrias sends after Grime and Sasha in "Turning Point" is modeled after the Suriname toad, known for giving birth through its back.
  • The Olm town is called "Proteus", which is the genus name for olms.
• Growing the Beard: Season 1 was pretty well-regarded in its own right, but its pacing made a segment of the community impatient, as the plot seemed to progress in extremely scattershot fits and most episodes played out as low-key sitcom hijinks rather than thrilling adventures. Season 2 managed a much more equal balance between standalone stories and progressing the Myth Arc, and the show itself even seems to acknowledge this shift in priorities with Anne's first line in the season.
  Anne: All right, Sprig. New season, new possibilities. I'm ready to blossom into my best self.
• Heartwarming in Hindsight:
  • "Spranne against the world!" is meant to be a declaration of Anne and Sprig's that nearly goes awry when they decide to be roommates. It becomes far more meaningful in the Season 1 finale when Sprig defends Anne against Sasha and even more so during "The Hardest Thing", as these are their last words before they part ways permanently.
  • Hop Pop running for mayor against Toadstool, despite him losing, becomes this when we learn that this single action inspired frogs across Amphibia to stand up to toad overlords and run for office as well.
  • "The Domino Effect" is dedicated to Anne missing her cat Domino, who was left behind when she got transported to Amphibia. The season 3 opening confirms that Anne has returned home, reuniting with her parents and her cat, who adjusts well to having three frogs in the house.
  • It's a Running Gag that Anne tries to pull the leaves and twigs out of her hair, but no matter what she does, they keep reappearing. What is the first thing her mother does after reuniting with her daughter? Give her a big hug, and pull the twigs out. Anne later wakes up because her mother is combing out her hair.
• He Really Can Act:
  • While already proving how emotional his performances can be through A Goofy Movie, Bill Farmer really expresses his acting chops as Hop Pop in "After the Rain" where sells how emotional he can be regarding the scene where Hop Pop explains the demise of Sprig and Polly's mom and dad and Bill expressing just how regretful and heartbroken he is about it.
  • While in this case it's already well documented that he's a skilled actor and voice actor, many fans have praised Keith David’s layered performance as King Andrias; from his jovial persona pre-reveal, to his Faux Affably Evil demeanor thereafter, to his bitterly remorseful side come the Series Finale.
  • Haley Tju's performance as Marcy has been praised especially in the scene in "True Colors" where she manages to capture Marcy's desperate attempts to justify her actions, only to somberly admit that what she did was all in a vain and desperate attempt to not be alone. Another example of Haley's impressive voice acting as Marcy comes in "Olivia & Yunan" where she manages to make Marcy's Painful Transformation into Darcy sound so chilling. Her performance as Darcy has also been praised for being able to sound genuinely chilling while maintaining Marcy's innocent sounding voice.
• Hilarious in Hindsight:
  • The Les Yay between Sasha and her friends as well as the "In Commander Anne, Sasha is revealed to be attracted to women" meme becomes validated once it's revealed in "The Hardest Thing" that Sasha is attracted to women, bisexual to be exact, via a bi flag heart sticker in the rearview mirror of her car.
  • In a similar sense to the above, the show's LGBT Fanbase and Ho Yay and Les Yay moments gets even more support and validation as Season 3 reveals the show to have a handful of LGBT characters all along, with Sasha, Toadstool, and Toadie's identities marking this as far back as Season 1, even if most of it was limited to just subtext back then. There's also the Friendly Fandoms with The Owl House and it's multiple queer representations, alongside the two's implied Shared Universe.
  • During Anne's drugged trip in "Adventures of Catsitting", she applauds her cat Domino as the "Alpha and Omega, an interdimensional being beyond all time and space". She later comes to be technically right, given her replacement pet and briefly-turned-enemy, Domino 2, becomes the alpha of her species in "Fight or Flight", and on top of that the Cosmic Guardian takes the form of the first Domino in "The Hardest Thing".
  • In the episode "Civil Wart," one of the potential love interests of the heroine is an anthropomorphic deer boy named Alistair. Later the same year that this episode was released, the pilot for Hazbin Hotel introduced ANOTHER character with the same name (if spelled differently - Alastor as opposed to Alistair) who has a deer theme; though the Hazbin Hotel Alastor is not nearly as peaceful as Amphibia's Alistair.
• I Knew It!:
  • In the first season, it was near universally agreed upon by fans that the three gem stones on the music box represent Anne, Sasha, and Marcy, with the stones possibly enhancing their physical abilities, based on the Freeze-Frame Bonus in the first episode where Anne's eyes turn blue. This was more-or-less confirmed in season 2's premiere, when Anne's eyes once again glow in this manner during a fight. Fans also speculated that Sasha's color is pink, while Marcy's would be green; Sasha's eyes were indeed seen glowing pink in "Barrel's Warhammer", while Marcy's eyes glow green in her debut episode, confirming Sasha to be the pink gem by proxy.
  • One of the most popular and prolific theories to come out of the season 2 finale was that Marcy was going to end up being brainwashed or possessed by the Core (Andrias’ multi-eyed master). The season 3 trailer proves this theory correct. The best part is that many assumed the Core's eyes would be an indicator, and in the Sneak Peek, Marcy indeed has a helmet that is covered in the Core's eyes.
  • In a rather interesting example, twitter user Arsonist Frogg got a bunch of Amphibia fans to tweet about how Sasha's middle name was Elizabeth, causing it to become Common Knowledge in the fandom. Fastforward exactly one month, and Matt Braly reveals in an interview that Sasha's middle name is Elizabeth.
• The Inverse Law of Fandom Levity: While Amphibia did eventually have an overarching story with some Cerebus Syndrome mixed in, the series is still largely comedic and lighthearted and, as Season 3A shows, still retained it's Slice of Life aspect and slapstick to it. The fandom however, tends to focus on the more gritty parts of the show, expanding on the conflicts of Newtopia, Toad Tower, and Wartwood, as well as exploring the abusive dynamics and toxic relationships between the characters even more so than what was shown. Some fans even come up with more dire situations and backstories to the Calamity Trio. Also, interestingly enough, with how much they show up in fanworks, you'd mistake the main cast to consist of Anne, Sasha, and Marcy, instead of Anne, Sprig, Hop Pop, and Polly, due to the Planter family being Out of Focus in them.
• It's the Same, Now It Sucks!: After his first appearence painted him as a very disturbing Knight of Cerebus, The Core becomes a much more comedical (but still dangerous) antagonist in his following appearences, this dissapointed a good number of fans who felt that every single villain until now had it's quips and comical aspects and that a completely serious villain would have make him stand up among the villain gallery.
• Jerkass Woobie:
  • Anne Boonchuy. She can be quite self-centered and controlling at times, thinking that her ideals and methods are beneficial to everyone, and has a habit of jumping into situations without thinking about the consequences. On the other hand, it's not hard to feel sorry for her, considering that she's Trapped in Another World with no idea how to go back home, completely lost in a Death World and forced to fend for herself for days before meeting the Plantars. Most of her flaws come from a very screwed-up view about how friendships should work because of Sasha and Marcy's Toxic Friend Influence. It becomes more prominent in "True Colors" when she finds out both of her friends betrayed her — Sasha by staging a coup against King Andrias and Marcy by deliberately stranding the girls in Amphibia and not planning for them to return home. While Anne is shocked and downright furious at her friends, this doesn't make Sasha and Marcy excuses for Anne's bad deeds during the course of the show as Anne herself acknowledges her faults and vowed to do the right thing and learn from them at the end when Valeriana gave her "The Reason You Suck" Speech as A Secret Test Of Character at "The Second Temple".
  • Sasha Waybright is initially presented as manipulative and bossy even towards her friends, and doesn’t accept any insubordination. However, throughout the series it turns out that her Control Freak tendencies are born out of a misguided yet genuine desire to make sure that her loved ones will succeed, and she sincerely considers that her ways are the best ways (the fact that her parents are divorced may have something to do with it). Indeed, when Anne calls her "a horrible friend" in a fit of rage, Sasha is shaken by her words and takes them to heart, resolving to become a better person and friend as atonement. In Season 3B, she’s even shown to have serious self-doubt about whether she’s really changed.
  • Hop Pop can be overly stern towards his grandchildren and occasionally calls Anne, Sprig, and Polly out for things he sometimes does, and can even be greedy at times. The reason for his overprotectiveness stems from losing his own child who was either Sprig and Polly's mom or dad in a Heron attack. Causing Hop Pop to deal with survivors guilt for years, and leaving him to raise Sprig and Polly on his own. Making it impossible to not feel sorry for him.
  • While Polly can be highly aggressive and violent, she's shown to have been as deeply affected by the loss of her parents in "After the Rain" and "All In" as Sprig and Hop Pop. It's even sadder when you realize that while Sprig is the older of the two, he was still too young to remember much about them aside from them giving him iconic hat on his birthday. Meaning that Polly very likely doesn't remember a single thing about them.
  • Tritonio Espada was introduced as a backstabbing crook who would use children to get what he wants. "Newts in Tights" makes him this after the reveal that he was orphaned and forced to live on the streets of Newtopia and would betray or be betrayed by whatever street gang he finds himself in just to survive. Something that he clearly doesn't like doing, even when it's clear that his current merry band adores him. Prompting Anne to give him a lesson about loyalty. He eventually changes his ways and becomes an ally to the heroes.
• Just Here for Godzilla:
  • There are lots of older, nostalgic viewers watching for Brenda Song who are glad to have her back for her first major role in a Disney property since the end of The Suite Life on Deck eight years prior. ^note Though she did have a brief voice role in Miles from Tomorrowland as Miles' aunt in 2015.
  • A fair amount of Gravity Falls fans probably tuned in just for the crossover episode "Wax Museum" wherein Alex Hirsch himself played expies of Grunkle Stan and Soos.
  • Likewise, Kermit providing a guest voice here following Fozzie Bear doing so on an episode of Big City Greens piqued the curiosity of The Muppets fans.
  • Some fans expressed being more invested in the backstory of Anne's toxic and complicated relationships with Sasha and Marcy than her interactions with the Plantar family. Especially for those who ship her with either, or both girls.
  • Alternatively, a fair amount of fans watch simply, and even solely, for both Sasha and Marcy (especially the latter) and their storylines, regardless whether or not Anne is involved. ^note Though she is usually involved most of the time due to shippers.
• LGBT Fanbase:
  • The show has quite a following amongst the LGBT community due to all of the chemistry and subtext Anne, Sasha, and Marcy have with each other, leading to various headcanons for the three. Other ships include Hop Pop/Grime and Yunan/Olivia, the latter of which grew after the season 2 finale. Being Friendly Fandoms with The Owl House, which has very open queer rep, probably helps too.
  • Season 3 actually features a few supporting and minor characters being confirmed to be in gay relationships, such as Ally and Jess, and the two nameless guys shown in "Sprig's Birthday". Additionally, a Freeze-Frame Bonus in "All In" has a pride flag placed on a building behind Domino 2. The same episode also implies that Mr. X might have a husband based on the people listed in his contacts. In the series finale, Sasha is even confirmed on-screen to be bi thanks to a bi flag sticker on her car.
• Love to Hate:
  • Once he was revealed to be Evil All Along, King Andrias was praised by fans for his status as the ultimate villain of the show and taking it into Darker and Edgier territory. He maintains a cheerful, eccentric, and somewhat silly personality, even after his true colors are revealed and he commits some seriously evil actions, making him quite an entertaining and watchable villain. His implicitly tragic backstory with his two friends and the signs that he's genuinely capable of making emotional connections yet will sacrifice them like chess-pieces with sheer ruthlessness that would make Tywin Lannister proud make the character all the more dynamic. At the same time, all of the sheer needless, petty Kick the Dog that Andrias conducts left and right on everyone who ever comes within ten feet of him, never mind him aiding the Core in turning Amphibia into a Polluted Wasteland and his active efforts to kill Anne and conquer Earth, very much make the audience root against him. The increasing Cry for the Devil he racks up as his true feelings on his evil plans and actions are further fleshed out, culminating in a surprisingly tear-jerking end to his menace, only makes the character's appeal even more universal.
  • Darcy. They combine Faux Affably Evil and a ruthless ambition with the personality quirks of a thirteen-year-old to form an overall Psychopathic Womanchild personality which is amusing, terrifying, and all-round entertaining to watch. At the same time, the sheer savage bloodlust with which they conduct themselves in "All In" (putting even Andrias' cruelty to shame) makes the audience cheer the heroes on when they start handing Darcy their own ass, never mind the Core's violent possession of Marcy beforehand to achieve this form.
• Magnificent Bastard:
  • Sasha Waybright is a talented, scheming teenager and friend of Anne Boonchuy and Marcy Wu. After being pulled into Amphibia and imprisoned by Grime, she is able to charm his guards and gets many of his goons to leave his army; when Grime offers to recruit her, she teaches him to become a pragmatic warlord. Sasha strikes a deal with Grime agreeing to assist him in quashing the rebellion by executing Hop-Pop in return for a chance of returning home with her friends. After this fails she works to help Grime regain his will to fight, succeeding after skillfully defeating the warrior Yunan. When she and Grime decide to take over all of Amphibia, they recruit the entirety of the Toad Army to their cause by acquiring the legendary "Barrel's Warhammer." Nearly succeeding at conquering Newtopia, Sasha and Grime try to warn Anne when Andrias's true colors are exposed. After betraying her friends, Sasha realizes she was a horrible person and works to finally improve herself. She becomes a valued ally to the rebellion, helping Anne break into the castle, and later fights Darcy before defeating her by severing the Core's connection.
  • "Combat Camp": Tritonio Espada is a notorious train robber using a bogus daycare center as a front to run his operation. When Hop Pop places the kids into his care, Tritonio teaches Sprig and Polly how to use weapons and gradually earns Anne's trust by appealing to her hidden potential. He sets Sprig up to play an injured orphan so that Anne and Polly can infiltrate the train. Retrieving the gem, Tritonio swipes it with the full intention of leaving the kids to the mercy of the guards. When defeated, he expresses little anger towards them, instead using the opportunity to compliment Anne for besting him.
  • "A Caravan Named Desire": Renée Frodgers is the director of a theater caravan who uses her shows as a distraction to rob banks, as they don't make much money anymore. Saving the Plantars' lives and recognizing Hop Pop's passion for acting, Renée invites him into the troupe, even casting him as the lead. Even when Hop Pop realizes Renée's true intentions, she plays on his pride and lifelong dreams to convince him to keep supporting the art. When this stops working and Hop Pop exposes Renée in public, she makes a swift getaway on her caravan and is only defeated by an intercepting sandworm, reacting with delight at finally being involved in some real drama.
• Memetic Loser: Sasha, despite being a capable leader and skilled fighter in canon, is often portrayed in fanart and fan works as an awkward, insecure, unstable mess who regularly gets flustered around Anne and/or Marcy. Her occasional Not So Above It All moments such as her Inelligant Blubbering when saying goodbye to Grime in the finale only added fuel to her memetic loser status.
• Moe:
  • Anne, Sasha, and Marcy were all adorable when they were young.
  • Marcy is still this in her teen and adult years, thanks to her cute design and Adorkable personality. Not even King Andrias is immune to her cuteness.
  • Sprig is this due to his adorable appearance and likeable characteristics. His tadpole appearance in "Family Fishing Trip" will just melt your heart.
  • Ivy is just as cute as buttons, especially regarding her Puppy Love relationship with Sprig when they're together, as well as being a good fighter.
  • Rosemary, Lavender, and Ginger are adorable and cheerful pollywog's who just love their big sister Maddie, and want nothing nothing more than to play with her.
  • And of course, there's the Badass Adorable Polly; who just gets even more adorable and capable after she finally gets her leg.
• Moral Event Horizon:
  • The innkeepers in "Night at the Inn" cross this when it's revealed that they set up bear traps to snag unsuspecting frogs' snail mounts so as to lure them to the lobby and persuade them to spend the night, drugging them with cookies. Then they eat the guests and lock up the snails indefinitely. One of their previous meals was a married couple. It's implied they don't survive the baking soda and vinegar explosion that Anne sets in an attempt to not get followed, and no one mourns for them.
  • If the Core doesn't cross the MEH by ordering Andrias to strip-mine Amphibia of all its resources to fuel their war-machine (turning their ancestral homeworld into an apocalyptic Polluted Wasteland), then it certainly crosses it when it forcefully possesses Marcy, a process which causes the girl excruciating pain and which even Andrias of all people was hesitant to do, showing that Andrias' master is in fact even worse than him, due to being a Mind Hive of psychopathic Evil Geniuses.
• Most Wonderful Sound:
  • Marcy's adorable and innocent giggling.
  • Hop Pop gasping in shock.
• Obvious Crossover Method: In the final episode, Anne is offered the position as Guardian of the Multiverse. While she turns it down, the door is left open for her to accept once she reaches the end of her life, and popular Fanon is that she'll invite Sasha and Marcy to join her, leading to the Fanfic Fuel of the Calamity Trio traversing different universes.
• One True Pairing:
  • While technically a throuple and not a pairing, you'd be hard pressed to find an Amphibia fan that does not ship Sasha/Anne/Marcy in some way. While ships between any two of them are also immensely popular, nearly everyone acknowledge that the three have an immense amount of chemistry and romantic subtext.
  • Pretty much the entire fandom took it for granted by the end of season 2 that Lady Olivia and General Yunan were in a relationship or at least had some attraction. According to Matt Braly, it was even the crew's favorite ship, and they ultimately had no issues with unambiguously pairing the two while deliberately leaving the human girls' relationships open for interpretation.
• One True Threesome:
  • Starting in the second season Anne/Sasha/Marcy slowly rose to be one of the most popular ships in the fandom. The ship itself even made it onto one of Tumblr's shipping lists for a brief time. That said there is a lot of options for how this relationship presents itself, there is a perfect triangle where everyone loves each other equally, then there is the pyramid where two are in love with one, usually Anne, but just friends with each other, and for the drama lovers there is the circle where one is in love with another who is inlove with another who is in love with the original, as an example; Anne is in love with Marcy who is in love with Sasha who is in love with Anne.
  • Shipping Sprig in a poly relationship with Maddie and Ivy is quite popular thanks to his past Arranged Marriage to and bonds with Maddie, as well as his canon relationship with Ivy.
  • After "The Core and the King" aired, fans began shipping Andrias in a poly relationship with his old friends Leif and Barrel. Some crew members have even liked art relating to this ship on Twitter. The fact that the three are shown to have some comparisons and a lot of parallels to the Sashannarcy ship above helps to fuel it even more.
  • To a lesser extent, Hop Pop, Grime, and Sylivia being together is another popular polyship in the series due to the increasing popularity of GrimePop and because of Hop Pop's short romance arc with Sylvia back in season 1.

P-Z

• Popular with Furries: Seeing as how half the cast consists of anthropomorphic amphibians, it's no surprise the series became bit of a hit with scalies.
• Portmanteau Couple Name:
  • Sashanarcy = Sasha/Anne/Marcy
    • Sashanne = Sasha/Anne (Funnily enough, Marcy indirectly ends up saying this when talking to the both of them in a flashback sequence.)
    • Marcanne = Anne/Marcy (could be called Annarcy as well, or Marbanana from their Affectionate Nicknames "Marbles" and "Anna Banana")
    • Sasharcy = Sasha/Marcy
  • Sprivy = Sprig/Ivy (the ship name has been used in-universe and is even the title of a season 3 episode)
  • Yulivia = Yunan/Olivia
  • Grimepop = Grime/Hop Pop
  • Spradivy - Sprig/Maddie/Ivy
  • Spranne = Sprig/Anne and P'anne = Polly/Anne are used In-Universe to refer to the platonic relationship between Anne and her adopted siblings.
• Realism-Induced Horror: For many people, especially those in relationships, Anne, Marcy, and Sasha's intially toxic relationship is the most disturbing part of a show that involves giant monsters and mind control among other things.
• Recurring Fanon Character: Marky Wu, a slightly goofy-looking version of Marcy with a wide smile and half-closed eyes. Originally created by fanartist Jopajopovna in response to the debate about wether Marcanne is pronounced Mars-anne or Mark-anne. Marky became so popular in memes and fanworks that Matt Braly himself asked what the heck was going on. In fanworks, Marky is usually depicted either as a shapeshifter or clone or, in more serious stories, as Marcy's sibling.
• Ron the Death Eater:
  • In general, despite only being heard and mentioned a few times, both the Wu and Waybright parents (especially the latter) are often portrayed as emotionally absent or outright abusive in a multitude of ways. This is used in fanworks as a way to give angst potential to Marcy and Sasha, especially in shipping fics, as well as a way to make them feel more sympathetic and to give them a Freudian Excuse to explain many of their more hurtful actions towards Anne in the series. In the actual series, there's no explicit confirmation that Sasha and Marcy's issues stem from their parents, and Sasha's parents' possible divorce isn't solidly confirmed as affecting her behavior in any way, albeit with the caveat there was an episode planned to address this but was cut due to potential message muddying (I.E 'blaming Sasha's parents for Sasha's problems, the very same thing that this trope does). For what it's worth, the only abusive parent that's ever actually depicted onscreen in the series is Andrias's father, the former King Aldrich. And even then, many fics have both girls' parents be portrayed to be as villainous as the above character, in a sense. Interestingly, these portrayals of the two's parents slowed down a bit, but hardly went away, as season 3 approaches, at at least one parent from both pairs, as the general trend has changed from both parents of each sucking to one of them, usually Mr. Wu and Mrs. Waybright, being bad, and the other parent being better, though takes where both parents of one or both girls are equally sucky are still findable. This newer portrayal is most likely because of how many mean girls' moms are portrayed in most media as emotionally abusive and/or overbearing in Sasha's case, with the fathers sometimes being a bit more reasonable than their wives. In Marcy's case, when she runs away from her parents' announcement, both call out to her, and the tones they use is what most fans based their portrayals on: her father sounds harsh and somewhat demanding when calling out to her (he was also the one that texted her), while her mother's voice, on the other hand, sounds rather worried and possibly a bit more understanding.
  • While she was shown bullying Anne in the flashback in "Reunion", Maggie's second and last appearance shows her briefly rooting for Anne while the latter was defeating Andrias implying that she does have some respect for Anne to some degree. However, many fanfics ramp up her jerky tendencies and bullying by having Maggie be homophobic, transphobic, and to a lesser extent, racist towards Anne, to the point where she's just as demonized as Sasha and Marcy's parents. In the series itself, being a minor character, there's really nothing to suggest that she's that much of a horrible jerk. Granted, she's usually portrayed as such to be a classmate conflict and a regular bully to the trio in said fanworks.
  • Unfortunately, despite her vast popularity among the fandom as well as being a Nice Girl who is firmly on the side of good, Marcy herself has gotten this ever since The Reveal that she knew what The Calamity Box would do and got herself along with Anne and Sasha trapped in Amphibia on purpose in "True Colors". While many fans sympathize and felt bad for Marcy over the unfortunate circumstances that have befallen on her, others have demonized her here and there by saying that "she can just as bad or even worse than Sasha in selfishness, her faith in True Colors was deserved, and she should've acted logically in talked to Anne and Sasha about her problems like a normal person". This makes it even worse as Marcy was considered autistic coded long before being Diagnosis of God. Which makes it even more demonizing to say that a girl with ADHD and Autism to act logically, and should've sat down and talked to her friends like a normal person in her situation.
  • Despite being already a villain, Andrias Leviathan has been hit with this. In the show, he's a Tragic Villain who appears to take some sadistic pleasure in his actions but is really controlled and manipulated by his cruel ancestors and who's only real joy comes from his friendship with Marcy. In fanworks, however, even those released after the end of the show, he's often shown as a sadistic sociopath who's happily carrying out every cruel and tyrannical action, which tend to never factor in his past and the fact that so long as he wears the crown, he can hear the Core in his head always ordering him around and influencing his course of action rather than him always deciding to do wrong because he enjoys it.
• Rooting for the Empire: Sasha, Grime, and the toads are shown not to be very good people, but the fandom loves them anyway, due to how cool they are and the True Companions bond they share. It doesn't help that in season 2, they're going up against the ruling class of Newtopia, which is strongly hinted to be an even greater evil behind its veneer of pleasantry.
• Salvaged Story: Marcy's Journal seemingly offer many characters inside and how they truly felt during the event of the series.
  • Many fans didn't take kindly to Anne not reacting much to Marcy's supposed death and seemingly having fun on Earth. When it's her turn to write the journal, it reveals that Anne has been angsty not only for returning the Plantars home (feeling like she's the only one to take it seriously) but legit guilt and fear her friends, Sasha and Marcy, may not be alive. Anne even reveals she hopes Marcy is okay because if she, for a moment, believes she's dead, she would break down and be unable to help her family.
  • The journal reveals more details about Sasha and Marcy's family. Sasha's father remarried with a new wife who already has kids, and her mother has a steady boyfriend. And Marcy's parents, mostly her dad, were strict with her, leading to a heavily strained relationship and the decision to move out to be the last straw for her.
  • While the ending was well-received, some fans thought that Anne and everyone being separated was too much sadness for a found family story. By the end of the journal, Terri called them with big news. It wasn't revealed what the news was, but the last time they spoke, Terri and X planned to get the portal working, and this could be that news.
• Seasonal Rot: While “rot” is too much to say, but many fans still regard the third season as the weakest one since it doesn't discuss the angst that Anne and the Plantars endured was brushed off easily. What's more is that an analysis by The Roundtable criticized how Anne is basically having the time of her life while her best friends are literally suffering in Amphibia. While things started to get back on track once Anne and the Plantars eventually made their way back to Amphibia and joined the resistance, the second half also received criticism for its Four Lines, All Waiting nature, with several episodes focusing solely on recruiting an old character (some of which appeared only in a single episode prior) for the upcoming battle against Darcy and King Andrias, while still neglecting to address any of Anne's trauma and angst. Season 3 also contains what fans consider to be the only real duds of the show; "Mother of Olms" and "Sprivy"^note The former is disliked by many for being an out of place grossout episode that wasted months of build-up and a talented guest star (Whoopi Goldberg); the latter is often disliked because of Sprig and Ivy spending the entire episode as Sickeningly Sweethearts while in the middle of a war, despite the two never acting this way in previous episodes, with fans finding the episode jarring and cringey.. That said, the three-part Grand Finale is widely regarded as an immensely satisfying sendoff, which helps it in retrospect.
• Self-Fanservice:
  • Mrs. Boonchoy is frequently drawn as a rather curvy 'M.I.L.F' type woman in fan art, where she's not really shown to be attractive or anything specific in the show itself even with the show's art style in mind.
  • After the finale, all three of the Calamity Girls as adults tend to be drawn in outfits that play up their features, and with more curves as opposed to the Noodle People that the show is characterized by.
• Shocking Moments:
  • The ending to "Anne of the Year": Anne and Sasha reunite. Sasha genuinely greets her... only to reveal that she brought Grime and his army. Then it turns out Grime has an unknown interest in Anne.
  • The following episode and season 1 finale, "Reunion", only increased the HSQ and bolstered the show's reputation even further. The town of Wartwood is suspicious that the Toad Army would only come to extend them a banquet invitation, but Anne, against her better judgment, trusts Sasha. Sprig finds out the banquet is a trap so that Grime can execute Hop Pop, who's inspired frog rebellions unknowingly, and break everyone's spirits. Anne tries to sneak everyone out to save Hop Pop's life, only to fail miserably. Cue Anne standing up to Sasha when Sprig calls out the latter for being a bully, and Wally blowing up Toad Tower with boom shrooms. The toad regime is over... for now.
  • "Marcy at the Gates": Marcy, who is alive and an Action Girl, and Anne happily reunite, while Sprig is suspicious that she's another Sasha. He changes his mind when she saves his life. Though Marcy only gets the bare bones of details about what happened with Sasha, she insists that she and Anne need to find her before they go home.
  • The ending of "The First Temple": King Andrias is subordinate to a 13-eyed Mechanical Abomination, and the two are planning some sort of revenge scheme. According to Andrias, the first gem of the Calamity Box getting recharged is the first step to a prophecy becoming undone.
  • The season 2 finale "True Colors" is just an utter parade of these, but special mention goes to the ending wherein Marcy is run through with King Andrias' fire sword (bloodlessly, but still on-screen) and apparently dies. It's only mitigated a little by how we see her being kept on life-support by Andrias in the teaser for season 3 that follows.
• Slow-Paced Beginning: While the format is that of a Quarter Hour Short series, the series' pacing is fairly slow, with season 1 spending a lot of time focusing on establishing the character dynamics between Anne and the Plantars, hinting at the cracks in Anne's friendship with Sasha and Marcy, and building the world of Amphibia itself. These aspects, along with the almost Sitcom-esque structure of some of the episodes, may tempt viewers to drop out early on, but fans who stuck around believe the payoff in "Reunion" (where Anne and Sasha meet again and end up coming to blows) is worth it.
• So Okay, It's Average:
  • This is the overwhelming consensus for Season 3b. Apart from the critically acclaimed three-part-finale, the final stretch of episodes are considered to be unremarkable at best, with many finding the stories to be inconsequential and the largely lighthearted tone to be at odds with the dire state Amphibia is in.
• Spiritual Successor:
  • Due to succeeding Star vs. the Forces of Evil on the Disney Channel cartoon lineup, saying that the former passed off the torch to Amphibia is common, especially as both are quirky and magical stories about a girl from another world befriending a local boy^note although Star goes from a fantastical world to a mundane one, whereas Anne goes from a mundane world to a fantastical one and fighting all the evil that ensues because of her arrival.
  • The show can also be considered a less wacky version of Billy Dilley's Super Duper Subterranean Summer, due to both shows focusing on impulsive, main characters getting trapped in some secret society of strange creatures.
  • Season 2's subplot of the Plantars and Marcy traveling to temples to recharge the Calamity Box's gems has been compared to Sonic Unleashed, which has a similar plot. Considering how Matt Braly is a self-proclaimed Sonic fan, this is unsurprising.
• Spoiled by the Format: Disney released the revamped opening credits for season 3 at the same time the season 2 finale aired, which gives away that Marcy is still alive. This may have been deliberately invoked, considering the last-minute difficulties in getting the episode to air — the only way a series aimed at children could get away with the horrific, near-fatal injury she suffers is to reassure them that she managed to survive it.
• They Wasted a Perfectly Good Character:
  • Sasha and Marcy's parents are never physically shown in the entire series save for Marcy's parents' voices being heard when telling her their decision to move kicking off the entire series as shown in "True Colors", Anne giving their families letters in "Froggy Little Christmas," and Marcy telling Anne's parents to inform her and Sasha's parents on their whereabouts for the past few months in "All In". It would've been interesting to see how they reacted to their daughters' disappearances not to mention how they affected their personalities pre-Amphibia (especially considering Sasha's parents are divorced). There was an episode planned where Sasha has a flashback to her parents, but the crew had trouble writing it in a way that didn't contradict Sasha's arc so it was scrapped.
  • Of Andrias's past friend trio, Barrel The Brave barely gets any development and screentime before getting casted away in his debut episode. Whatever happened to him and how he coped with the downfall after Leif steals the Calamity Box is left untold. This is opposed to Leif, who has more arcs given to her. Further development on the relationship between him and Andrias, and Leif would've been compelling to see as well.
  • While most of the citzens of Wartwood were givin an short arc, there's quite some Earth characters introduced during Season 3A that don't have much screentime and are mostly used as minor characters with some of their backgrounds not getting explored. Dr. Jan, Terri, and the IT Gals come to mind.
  • Out of all the citizens in Wartwood, Ivy barely interacts with any of the other characters other than Sprig, and doesn't get much development besides her and Sprig's Relationship Upgrade in "Anne of the Year". While the episode "Ivy on the Run" gives her break from being a Satellite Love Interest for Sprig, and builds on her relationship with her Mother. Some fans have wished that there were more episodes like this for Ivy to give her more character outside of being Sprig's girlfriend, and even wanted to see her and Maddie interact with each other and become friends.
  • Marcy herself, compared to Anne and some of Sasha's arcs. She never gets a speaking role in Season 1 and barely appears in Season 3, with half of her appearances in the latter comprised of the Core possessing her. This culminates in most of her Character Development all happening in "All In". Furthermore, most of her potentially angsty storylines, such as her dealing with her family moving for her dad's job, her guilt of sending her friends to Amphibia, and the aftereffects of Andrias stabbing her and the Core's possession and all the emotions she would've felt were left either not fully developed, rushed, or ignored in favor of mostly showing her happy-go-lucky side. Some fans even expressed wanting to see her go fully angry like Anne and Sasha did at various points.
• Trans Audience Interpretation:
  • It's not uncommon for fans to view one or all of the girls as trans in one way or another. Some take it to the logical conclusion of them being a three-gender-ensemble, with Anne as a trans girl, Marcy as nonbinary, and Sasha as either transmasculine or genderfluid.
  • Anne gets this in particular due to two scenes, one in "Bessie and Microangelo" where she talks about finally being happy about who she sees in the mirror after months in Amphibia, and one in "All In" where she tells the Plantars that she was Brilliant, but Lazy before meeting them because she didn't really love herself, both of which are sentiments commonly expressed by trans people.
• Unexpected Character: While she just makes a quick cameo as an Easter Egg, nobody expected to see Pepper Ann of all characters appear in "All In", given how obscure she and her cartoon is even by Disney show standards... unless you remember that Matt Braly is a Pepper Ann fan (and the show itself is the result of him watching Pepper Ann and Dragon Ball Z back to back, as he's admitted).
• Unintentionally Sympathetic:
  • Sasha Waybright is this in the episode "The Dinner". Given that the audience already knows that the Plantars were Right for the Wrong Reasons to be skeptical about Sasha and Grime's Heel–Face Turn. We're supposed to side against Sasha when Anne defends her frog family from Sasha's temper. But the Plantars spend the entire episode ganging up on Sasha, and they take things too far when they remind Sasha of her near suicide attempt after her falling out with Anne. Sprig especially goes out of his way to antagonize Sasha whenever given the opportunity to the point of callously pointing out how she nearly fell to her death. They were bullying someone who lost her friend then attempted suicide, so it's no wonder why Sasha lost her cool and lashed out at them.
  • The reveal of Marcy stranding the trio in Amphibia on purpose was supposed to be seen as something that was just as bad as, if not worse than, Sasha and Grime's earlier betrayal. But unlike Sasha, Marcy did not do this out of spite towards them. She was just terrified of losing the two most important people to her. As she tries to justify her actions to both of them, Sasha is the first to single her out, but Marcy was just as much a victim of Sasha's latest betrayal as Anne was.
• Ugly Cute:
  • The giant alligator in "Scavenger Hunt" would be hideous if not for the perpetual derpy smile it has on its face, which makes it oddly adorable.
  • Many of the toad characters also qualify (particularly Percy, Braddock, Barrel and, at times, even Grime), essentially being larger, buffer, scarier versions of the frogs.
• Viewer Gender Confusion: Due to how quick season 3's trailer scenes were shown, it's quite understandable that viewers would mistake Terri as a guy.
• Viewer Species Confusion: Lysil and Angwin have been mistaken for axolotls by viewers, which is understandable, as olms are quite obscure.
• What Do You Mean, It's for Kids?: The series tends to have a plethora of darker scenes and themes, which become more prominent as the series progresses.
  • Season 1 is fairly tame, with just a few things such as cannibalistic frogs, near-death experiences the main cast gets into, and more seriously, Sasha implying suicide when letting go of Anne's hand.
  • Seasons 2 and 3 are where things really get kicked up a notch. The blood and death imagery is more apparent, there's parental death and conflicts, themes of war, assassination attempts, and many more. What gets really worse is Andrias sending deadly weapons to Earth and the fact Anne, the Plantars, and her family nearly die.
  • Then there's the events of both "True Colors" and "Olivia & Yunan". The former features Andrias attempting child murder by throwing Sprig out a window, trying to kill Polly for getting in the way, and the cherry on top: impaling Marcy. The latter is even worse somehow, as there's the nightmare projection the characters suffer through, and the literal entire ending to the episode.
  • The finale has Anne dying in the process of destroying the Core, fading into ash as her loved ones cry over her. She also appears to be Killed Off for Real, with the Anne seen afterwards presumably being a clone with her memories.
• The Woobie:
  • Marcy is constantly getting hurt, has trouble communicating with other people, and Hates Being Alone so much that the idea of being separated from her only friends caused her to send them to another world just so that they wouldn't have to be apart, only for them all to be separated upon arrival and her being seemingly killed shortly after she's finally reunited with Anne and Sasha. Things only get worse for her in season 3 when she gets possessed and controlled by Andrias' master, the evil hive mind of the Core. And to top it off, in "The Beginning of the End", a flashback shows that her only friends mostly ignored her and cared little for her interests, which is implied to be part of what drove her to bring them to Amphibia.
    • Marcy's Journal also shows us how strained the relationship between Marcy and her parents was, with her dad already having put a lot of pressure on her and accepting a job out of state without considering her feelings. Something that Marcy would resent him for even after being in Amphibia for the first few months. Other journal entries have also confirmed Marcy to be a social pariah on Earth as she struggled to make friends even when she was very young, likely due to her hyperactive and energetic personality. She was also looked down upon and even laughed at by her fellow peers. Which gives Marcy a low opinion on humans save for Anne and Sasha, and why she liked being in Amphibia so much.
  • Barrel The Brave was just a loveable toad who enjoyed hanging out and having fun with his friends Andrias and Leif who then suddenly found himself caught in between their conflict after Leif steals the music box, and even when Barrel had Leif cornered, he couldn't bring himself to hurt his friend which allowed her to escape. Because of this, Andrias deems Barrel as a failure to him and coldly banishes him to the outskirts to defend villages. Barrel tearfully complies to his former friends reassignment, and later sacrificed his life following through on that order.
  • Sprig; due to him having trouble making friends other than Ivy because of his eccentric personality before Anne showed up, and having lost his parents in a heron attack at a very young age to the point where he can barely remember anything about them, save for a time where they gave him his iconic hat for his birthday.

---