Viewer Species Confusion

Wait, you mean you're not a badger?

Similar to how Viewer Gender Confusion is the audience thinking the character is of the opposite gender (or isn't sure which gender the character is in general), Viewer Species Confusion is when the audience thinks the character is of a different species. Usually it happens when the character is oddly colored, or if the character barely resembles the species he's supposed to be.

This is an Audience Reaction. Informed Species if intentional, I Am Not Weasel if in-universe.


Examples:

Anime and Manga
  • Io and King from Jewelpet. The first one is a particular species of rabbit characterized by having droopy ears; it's easy to think that he's a dog, especially in Twinkle, where he forms a trio with two dog Jewelpets. As for King, he is supposed to be a French bulldog, but his color scheme makes him look like some sort of creature who decided to wear a pink rabbit outfit... with a pig-like tail. Truly the stuff that Mind Screw is made of.
  • Menchi in Excel Saga is a dog and is constantly referred to as such, but most people would guess "cat" upon seeing her.
  • Sarah in the Sonic the Hedgehog OVA is actually a cat girl, but since the American edit removed all scenes depicting her cat ears, American viewers often mistook her for a monkey. A good majority of the fanbase thinks of her as a human, not a Cat Girl.
  • The Mokonas from Magic Knight Rayearth, XxxHolic and Tsubasa Reservoir Chronicle are usually thought to be a rabbits, when really they're just Mokona.
  • In You Are Umasou, there is a purple horned carnivore whom some viewers think is a Carnotaurus. It is actually supposed to be a Chilantaisaurus like in the book of the same name and this episode from the animated series (and the animal in question does have huge arms and three-fingered hands, in contrast to stubby arms and four-fingered hands like Carnotaurus).

Film
  • Cinderella 3D: Has multiple examples of this trope.
    • It's unclear whether Cinderella is a antelope, deer, cougar, fox, or something else entirely.
    • Cinderella's step mother. Is she supposed to be a dog?
    • One of the characters looks like either a turkey or a vulture. If she is a vulture, this adds a another level of weirdness to a already weird film, because they ride non-anthropomorphic vultures.
  • Rudy from the third Ice Age film is supposed to be a Baryonyx. Some viewers think he is a Suchomimus or even an evolved Spinosaurus. Also the Guanlong, Triceratops, Troodon, Harpactognathus, and Pterodactylus are often thought to be raptors, Chasmosaurus, Compsognathus, Pteranodon, and Quetzalcoatlus respectively (though the latter two weren't specifically identified by Word of God).
  • In "Rite of Spring" segment of Fantasia, the little animal stealing a clam from the Plateosaurus is actually a Kannemeyeria (a dicynodont) according to Word of God, not a Protoceratops like many people assume. Also, the Troodon attacking the Archaeopteryx is often assumed to be an Ornitholestes and the Hallopus climbing the tree above the Stegosaurus are thought to be Compsognathus or Hypsilophodon.
    • Not to mention the Tyrannosaurus rex is often called an Allosaurus due to its three-fingered hands.

Live-Action TV

Mythology
  • Even archeologists are not sure, what the Egyptian god Set is supposed to be. There is an article on The Other Wiki about this.

Newspaper Comics
  • Sheila Roo from Pluggers is, as the name suggests, a kangaroo, but since she's not drawn with kangaroo feet or a kangaroo tail, many readers assume her to be a fox, coyote or some kind of long-nosed rabbit. Interestingly, her species was more obvious back when Jeff MacNelly still drew the strip.

Video Games
  • Chica and Foxy The Pirate from Five Nights at Freddy's. Chica is a chicken, but is frequently referred to as a duck in Let's Play videos, while Foxy is, well, a fox, but LP'ers frequently refer to him as a wolf or coyote. To be fair, though, their names aren't really stated in-game until the seventh night.
  • The seagulls in Metal Gear Solid 2 have been called "pigeons" by some. No, really.
  • One character from the PaRappa the Rapper franchise is Lammy, a lamb who looks more like a deer or a calf, or a human with stubby antlers, pointy ears, and round black nose.
  • Pokémon:
    • Raikou, Suicune, and Entei are often thought of as canines or felines by the fandom, when really they're based on creatures from Chinese/Japanese folklore.
    • Growlithe and Arcanine are striped like tigers, but also resemble and behave like dogs. They're actually based on a variation of the Shisa (A creature that could either be half-dog and half-lion or half-dog and half-tiger) from Okinawa folklore.
    • Mightyena and its pre evo are often thought of as wolves, when they are actually a mix of brown hyenas and wolves.
    • Fans tend to think that Nidoking and Nidoqueen are a strange combonation of a rabbit and a rhino. In reality, they're based off of the kaiju Baragon.
    • Mew is sometimes mistaken for a gerbil by the fandom. It's actually a cat-like fetus creature.
      • Likewise, Mewtwo is sometimes mistaken to be some sort of alien. It doesn't help that he's loosely based off of Giygas from the Mother series of games. like Mew, he's supposed to be some sort of cat.
    • Fans can't seem to determine whether Eevee is supposed to be a fox, cat, or some sort of small dog. It doesn't help that its evolutions can have either canine and/or feline traits.
      • Umbreon resembles some sort of canine. However, it is actually partially based on a black cat, and, oddly enough, a rabbit. This is because Umbreon is supposed to be a Shout-Out to the Moon Rabbit of Asian folklore.
    • Arceus has been called a horse, llama, giraffe, and a goat by the fandom. Its actually a Kirin (A unicorn-like creature from Japanese folklore. Also known as a "Qilin").
    • Lugia is often mistaken for a dragon by the fandom. Although it is partially based on one, Lugia is actually supposed to be a bird.
    • Cranidos and Rampardos are sometimes thought to be tyrannosaurs, when they are clearly pachycephalosaurs (although Pokémon X and Y later introduced proper T. rex Pokemon, Tyrunt and Tyrantrum).
      • Doesn't help that the Pokédex states that Rampardos actively hunts other Pokémon
  • Talon from Primal Rage is really a Deinonychus, but is often called a velociraptor.
  • Chocolat from Solatorobo looks like and is thought to be a cat, but she's really a dog.
  • Several Sonic the Hedgehog characters are often mistaken for other animals, since most of them don't really resemble the animal they're supposed to be.
  • Merasmus the Wizard from Team Fortress 2 has a monkey-like face and appearance, which will make some think he's a monkey for a second.
  • In Adventure, the dragons look more like ducks.
  • The Condor in Ice Climber looks more like a pterodactyl than an actual condor.

Webcomics
  • The cats of Achewood could easily be mistaken for pug dogs, given their round ears and black noses (and in Ray's case — let's face it — his personality).
  • Off-White: In once scene, the wolf Hati looks like a gorilla dispute the artwork being excellent.
  • Penny Arcade:
    • Hardware example: Div. Newcomers who have not yet read the older strips usually think he is a DVD player, when really he is a DIVX player.
    • Also, the wombat symbol is mistaken for a bear by newcomers.

Western Animation
  • Animaniacs: The Warner Brothers don't have a set species, thus no one has any clue as to what they are.
  • Arthur:
    • Arthur looks like a bear or a monkey rather than an aardvark.
    • Ape and bear characters, just as Francine and the Brain, cause problems with fans.
      • A lot of fans just think monkey characters are human.
  • Subverted in CatDog. Eddy the Squirrel looks nothing like a squirrel, but everyone (including the show's viewers) just assumed he is.
  • Danger Mouse:
    • Colonel K is a chinchilla, but due to his mustache and how he appears in scenes where it's hard to judge his size, several people think he's a walrus.
    • Penfold doesn't look much like a hamster, either.
  • Disney:
    • Pete is actually a cat, but practically everyone has thought he was a dog. This even carried into Goof Troop.
    • Goofy himself has confused a number of people.
  • The Raccoons:
    • Cedric and Cyril Sneer are supposed to be aardvarks. They look more like... uhm... naked tapirs?
    • Quick show of hands: How many people knew those guys weren't supposed to be aliens?
  • Regular Show: Eileen is a mole and Pops is a lollipop, but most people assume that the former is a tailed human, and the latter is a big-headed human.
  • Newcomers to Ren and Stimpy sometimes think Ren the Chihuahua is a rabbit.
  • Spongebob Squarepants: According to some sources, Squidward is actually an octopus, but viewers assume he's a squid because he has six tentacles (two for arms, four for legs), and his name, Squidward.
    • On Spongebob Wiki, Sheila was put into the 'Octopi' category when she was clearly a squid.
  • Don Karnage from TaleSpin is clearly a canine, but which kind? Fan consensus is that he's either a fox or wolf.
  • Timothy Goes to School has Fritz. Is he a skunk? A badger? Nobody seems to be sure. Even looking at official reviews for the original Rosemary Wells book that he appears in, Fritz and the Mess Fairy, doesn't shed any light on the subject. Publisher's Weekly calls him a "skunk," Kirkus Reviews describes him as a "badger." Presumably, this applies to Miss Appleberry (the occasionally-seen student teacher) by extension, as she appears to be the exact same species as Fritz.
  • Many eBay listings for Linny the guinea pig on Wonder Pets often describe her variously as a "hamster," "hampster" or "hedgehog." The I Am Not Weasel references worked into the series may have been an intentional reference to this sort of confusion.