"So, are you suggesting that the Alice from Alice in Wonderland this whole time was... Alice from Alice in Wonderland? Whoa, I mean fucking whoa, this movie is pushing the envelope of cinematic twists! I mean, who could have seen that coming? Next you'll be telling me that Clark Kent all this time was... Clark Kent!"A Captain Obvious Reveal occurs when the writer sets up a Reveal for his story... only the audience figured it out already by the time they revealed it. Obviously, this will never apply to 100% of the audience, but when it applies to the majority of an audience, you have this trope on your hands. This can happen for a couple of reasons. The more common one is that the author put in so much Foreshadowing that the reveal becomes clear long before it was intended. Another reason is that there were no other options for the reveal; if we're told that a character has a missing father, and there's only one character we already know who's the right age and position to have a missing child, audiences are likely to figure it out. And finally, it could be that this particular reader/viewer is very Genre Savvy; no matter how well you plan your plot twists, there will always be someone who can figure it out. Note once again that this will never apply to 100% of the audience. Likewise, just because one audience member was Genre Savvy doesn't mean we have this trope - that particular audience member is just very Genre Savvy and good at recognizing foreshadowing. Also worth noting that among the thousands who watch a movie/read a book, someone is bound to simply guess the plot twist ahead of time, no matter how well it is set up - it's practically a statistical certainty. Compare The Untwist; this trope is very similar, but not quite identical to that one. (The difference is that The Untwist can be intentional and always comes from too much foreshadowing. Here, it's never intentional, and it doesn't necessarily have to be foreshadowing.) Also compare It Was His Sled where the twist was a surprise but has become so well known it is no longer a twist. Contrast Tomato Surprise and Deus ex Machina. The in-story version of this is Everybody Knew Already. Supertrope to Obvious Judas, where the most Obviously Evil character is revealed to be the villain. Related to Captain Obvious Aesop, when a moral that everybody in real life believes already ("Murder is bad!") is treated in-story as a profound revelation. Not to be confused with Dramatic Irony; characters may be surprised by information that is new to them, without any expectation that it will be a surprise to the audience. Warning: As this is a plot twist trope, spoilers will be unmarked. Approach with caution.
open/close all folders
Anime & Manga
- Double subverted with the mysterious masked man Tobi being Obito Uchiha. It seemed incredibly obvious right from the get-go, until Tobi pulled a 180 degree on personality, authority, and power level that completely contradicted what Obito would have been capable (eg: the class dunce should not be capable of giving the Fourth Hokage a hard time). This actually led to a number of others characters being considered and causing quite a divide among the fandom. It isn't until 300 chapters later and a confirmation that he wasn't Madara Uchiha that it became somewhat possible, but the vast power level difference allowed this to be subverted up until the chapters leading into The Reveal made it so blatantly obvious it was him that it literally could not have been anyone else.
- Then of course there's the fact that Naruto is the 4th Hokage's son...something most of the audience had already figured out, since they look similar and the guy's face is carved into the side of a freaking mountain. Just one look at his picture, and most of the audience had already figured who Naruto's father was. If you took out the whisker marks on Naruto's cheeks, they could be twins. It really makes you wonder how ignorant the people of Konoha were to not see such an obvious resemblance.
- There's also the reveal that the Six Paths of Pain are just dead bodies being controlled by Nagato. This wasn't revealed until quite a while after Pain (and later Nagato's) introduction into the story, but it was predicted by MANY people in the fandom.
- The reveal that Boruto's teammate is Orochimaru's son hardly came as a surprise given that he both resembles Orochimaru and gave many readers the same creepy vibes.
- The Reveal that Sasuke and Naruto were the reincarnations of the Sage of the Six Paths' elder and younger sons respectively. While many were still shocked, just as many were left unsurprised, and those that were shocked admitted it was obvious in hindsight, especially after it was revealed that their respective previous incarnations were Madara Uchiha and Hashirama Senju, the First Hokage.
- Subverted in Fullmetal Alchemist. Before the main characters encounter Father, we're led to believe that Father is Hohenheim since they both look alike, but we only see the bottom half of Father's face, so one would expect the series to "surprisingly" reveal that Father is Hohenheim. Then it turns out that he's a different person and they just look the same because Father is a homunculus who took on Hohenheim's appearance when they were younger. Arakawa did this on purpose.
- There's a minor reveal in Martian Successor Nadesico that the Jovian Chulips are a kind of warp gate that allow Jovian robots to teleport in directly from Jupiter. Of course, since the audience has already seen the Chulips clearly opening some kind of portal, the biggest surprise is finding out that you weren't supposed to know that already.
- Dangan Ronpa 3, in Side:Despair Episode 10, it's revealed that Juzo is in love with Munakata, not Chisa. Most fans already knew that, but it felt good for it to be confirmed.
- Fairy Tail:
- The siblings of Hoteye/Richard Buchanan and Yukino Agria (Wally and Angel/Sorano, respectively) weren't surprising to the majority of the fanbase who put two and two together. The former pair of brothers have similar appearances with polygonal bodies, while the latter pair of sisters have white hair and are Celestial Spirit Mages. Oddly enough, Lucy, who's fairly intelligent, heard Yukino's story about her sister and knows both Yukino and Sorano, doesn't seem to make the connection.
- It's gloriously subverted with Silver of Tartaros' connection to Gray; readers speculated from the start that he is actually Gray's father before The Reveal that while his body belongs to Gray's father, it's actually possessed by Deliora, the demon that killed Gray's parents and forced Ur to use Iced Shell... only to later be double subverted when Silver reveals he really is Gray's dad brought Back from the Dead, and lied about being Deliora just to rile Gray up enough to put an end to his agonizing existence.
- In Yes! Pretty Cure 5 GO!GO!, Kurumi Mimino aka Milky Rose being Milk is so obvious, yet only one character figured this out for a while before the reveal. The other characters actually realized some similarities, but they still didn't figure it out for four episodes.
- In One Piece, Sabo being alive and a member of the Revolutionary Army. It is strongly implied with how he may have appeared to be shot, but his dead body was never shown, and later on Dragon finds someone injured who he wants to be taken to the med bay on the Revolutionaries' ship. In the latter part of the flashback, Sabo grows to hate the nobles and by extension the government, so it makes sense that he would become a Revolutionary. Furthermore, the flashback was mostly about Luffy and Ace growing up together - if Sabo had just been killed off to never play any role in the story again, his character's existence would almost have been Filler. In addition, one of the chapter cover arts was of an adult Sabo alongside Luffy and Ace, indicating that his role in the story wasn't finished yet. Subverted in that Word of God said Sabo was dead, and that cover was just a tease. That means the author outright lied to everyone.
- Sailor Moon: Tuxedo Mask's secret identity and the reveal of Usagi's past life were not very surprising, as their alter egos were shown countless times in the series...and, in Usagi's case, the opening of the first series and the ending of the second.
- Dragon Ball Z: Trunks is Bulma's son. While it was somewhat easier to be surprised by this in the anime (in the manga, Bulma had purple hair instead of blue), his haircut resembles his grandfather's and he wore the Capsule Corp logo on his jacket.
- In Blood-C, it's very obvious that Fumito, Saya's neighbor who made her lunches, is the mastermind behind the events of the show and that he's drugging Saya with coffee and marshmallows which results to her memory loss. It's also blatantly obvious that he's the narrator in Saya's flashbacks and the tone of his voice showed that he knew all about her. And when episode 11 rolls in, it doesn't come out as a surprise.
- Attack on Titan:
- Annie is the Female Titan. The only other female with blond hair in the military (Krista) was present during her attack, and her face was similar to Annie's. Even before the Female Titan was introduced, you could tell by Annie's facial expressions that she may have a darker moral alignment.
- Afterwards, the Armored Titan being Reiner is even more obvious, thanks to the readers having gotten enough examples of Titan Morphic Resonance to know the muscular Titan with close-cropped blond hair is going to be a muscular human with close-cropped blond hair.
- Elfen Lied: Lucy killed Kouta's father and sister. Kouta's shocked expression when he saw her for the first time in the series and the mention of his dead family put two and two together for the audience.
- The reveal in 20th Century Boys that "Yabuki Joe" is actually Kenji is so completely, ridiculously, ludicrously obvious that is most definitely an invoked example. It's so obvious in fact, that the English volumes accidentally spoil it in the translation notes four volumes before it's confirmed.
- Pokémon Adventures: Yellow is the girl who Red met and caught a Rattata for before his fight with Giovanni. Given how they share a Pokémon, compounded by how similar their designs are, you'd have to have completely forgotten the former's existence to be surprised.
- Evillious Chronicles: The reveal in Gift From The Princess Who Brought Sleep that Hanne Lorre and her sister Hedimarie are actually Elluka and Gumillia under false identities was so obvious that most of the fans took it as a given when the site went up, when the reveal itself in the novel doesn't occur until past the halfway point.
- Bleach is quite notorious for this, especially in the later arcs.
- ERASED attempts to treat the The Reveal that Satoru's teacher Yashiro is Kayo's killer as a huge twist, despite Yashiro being literally the sole character who fits the very basic information one is given concerning the culprit.
- Library War: You'll already know that Kasahara's "Prince" is Dojou long before it's finally confirmed, since the voice and hairstyle are a perfect match to the silhouetted figure in her flashback. Not to mention, all the times she wonders why "her heart flutters" the few times he compliments her. Plus, he's right there on the box cover art and is the male lead.
- Played for Laughs in the Crayon Shin-chan mini-series Crayon Shin-chan Gaiden: Aliens vs. Shinnosuke. Takosuke is very obviously an alien, due to his strange behavior and resemblance to The Greys. Characters accuse him of being an alien multiple times and he continually denies it, making it look like they're just setting him up as a Red Herring, but in the end it turns out he is an alien.
- Mobile Suit Gundam: Iron-Blooded Orphans: It's so blatantly obvious that Vidar is Gaelio Baudin in disguise that it could be argued it's not even supposed to be a secret (at least out-of-universe). They're both played by Masaya Matsukaze, Vidar knows things that only Gaelio could possibly know (like the circumstances of Carta Issue's death), and he has a deep-seated hatred of McGillis Fareed, the man who betrayed Gaelio's trust and "killed" him. Needless to say, when the mask came off, absolutely nobody was surprisednote .
- Daily Life with Monster Girl: Eventually it's revealed that Mero is actually a princess. This came to the surprise of absolutely nobody, since the foreshadowing is so blatant that it's almost impossible to miss. Most notably, almost immediately after being introduced, Centorea goes off on a tangent about Mero's "royal aura". Even in-universe, the amount of surprise is minimal.
- The End of Ends:
- Count Logan being Beast Boy would have been a huge plot twist... The only problem being that we focus on him for the first two chapters with enough information that when the slightest hint is given, it's instead a plot un-twist. For starters, Beast Boy's real name is Garfield Logan, and the story goes to great lengths to show the name. It also goes to great lengths to showcase his relation to Terra and his reason for why he became Count Logan in the first place, right down to using a clip from the show constantly, to the point where when they show it again and this time, with the names muted, it's downright obvious. Especially since one of the words that wasn't muted was Teen Titan.
- If you catch on that this is a Whole Plot Reference to Super Paper Mario, then it wouldn't surprise you that Dr. Beljar, an Expy of Dimentio in the Count's Quirky Miniboss Squad would backstab Beast Boy and remake the world in his image.
- In Curse of the Demon Pony, JusSonic makes it incredibly obvious that the titular Demon Pony is in fact Twilight Sparkle's old friend, Ben Mare. Within the story it's treated like it's a huge twist, but anyone who's been reading it up until then should've known it was him given how unsubtle it was.
- In Romance and the Fate of Equestria, Twilight's OC boyfriend, Snicker-Snack, being revealed as a villain. Many readers found him creepy and suspicious from the moment he appeared, and felt that attempts to pass him off as Twilight's Love Interest fell flat.
- Yu-Gi-Oh! The Abridged Series does this a lot but it's played purely for laughs. One notable example would be in episode 23, where Bandit Keith was being mind controlled by Marik and disguised as a rare hunter. The fact that it's Keith is made very obvious to the audience (in that Keith doesn't bother to hide his normal voice and catchphrase) but Yugi is totally oblivious to it until Keith reveals himself, leading to this gem:
Yugi: Oh my god, it's Bandit Keith! I had no idea! Super special awesome plot twist!
Films — Animation
- Parodied in Kung Fu Panda 2 where Po's father Ping reveals a deep secret to Po: he's adopted. Given that Po is a panda and Ping is a goose, this doesn't come as a surprise to the audience, or even Po himself.
Tigress: Your father, the goose?Po: (nods sheepishly)Tigress: That must have come as quite a shock.
- An in-universe example occurs in Kung Fu Panda 3 when an older panda breaks Po's dumpling-eating record and reveals that he lost his son years ago. Po tells him that he lost his father when he was a baby. They wish each other good luck and start to walk away. Everyone else who hears the exchange is completely dumbstruck.
Films — Live-Action
- The "reveal" that Count Dooku is a Sith Lord in Attack of the Clones. According to George Lucas, it was supposed to be a major twist that completely redefined the character. But the first we hear of him is Padme accusing him of trying to assassinate her, he's openly the leader of the villainous Separatist faction, he's outright said to be a disillusioned former Jedi, he's played by an actor well-known for villainous roles, and the only thing he does to try and avert suspicion is a half-hearted appeal to Obi-Wan that isn't taken seriously even in-universe. Plus, it's Star Wars, so there's got to be a lightsaber duel at the end, and, well... Who else could it have been against?
- Secrets & Lies: Monica's infertility is signposted fairly clearly by scenes in the film prior to the eventual reveal.
- Averted in the film version of The Lord of the Rings; the writers knew that they could not have Éowyn disguise herself as a common rider without invoking this trope heavily, so the movie abandoned all pretense of hiding her identity from both Merry and the audience.
- The Hobbit: The Desolation of Smaug reveals that the mysterious Necromancer is none other than Sauron, the Big Bad from the original trilogy. Everybody, even those unfamiliar with Tolkien's work, guessed it, yet judging by Gandalf utter surprise and dramatic music, it was supposed to be shocking.
- In Hide and Seek, we're supposed to be shocked that Emily's Not-So-Imaginary Friend Charlie is actually an evil Split Personality of her father David. However, the constant and ominous flashbacks shown in David's head every time just before he finds out that Charlie has been causing trouble again make it abundantly clear that at the very least, he's hiding something really big.
- Honeymoon: Bea's strange behavior would be kept mysterious through most of the film if not for the fact that the bright, descending lights pouring through her window on the first night make it pretty obvious that aliens are to blame.
- Jurassic World treats the revelation that Indominus rex is part velociraptor as a big surprise, but given that she looks just like a bigger raptor and demonstrates the trademark intelligence of a raptor, a lot of viewers were more startled that it was supposed to be surprise.
- Captain America: The Winter Soldier: The Winter Soldier is Steve's Heterosexual Life Partner Bucky Barnes. Even if you weren't familiar with the comic books (or any prior adaptations; there had been two or three), the fact that Bucky's actor played the Winter Soldier was a giveaway. Even Marvel had given up any pretense of it being secret by the time the movie premiered.
- Captain America: Civil War: Bucky killed Howard and Maria Stark as the Winter Soldier. A montage showed in The Winter Soldier heavily implied that the Starks were assassinated by HYDRA, and the Winter Soldier was the most likely to carry it out as he's an infamous HYDRA assassin. Tony calling out Steve, who had the same information as the audience, could be considered a Lampshade Hanging:
Tony: Did you know?Steve: I didn't know it was him.Tony: Don't bullshit me, Rogers, did you know?Steve: ... Yes.
- The Fugitive: The character of Dr. Charles Nichols is introduced as a colleague and friend of protagonist, Dr. Richard Kimball. He has no other plot relevant purpose for being in the film other than to be revealed as the Big Bad. He's also played by an actor known for playing villains.
- Morgan: It's pretty easy to tell early on in the film that something's off about Lee. Given the prowess with fighting and guns she shows in the climax, the reveal that she's an Artificial Human like Morgan isn't so much a twist as a "Called it!"
- Alien: Covenant: At the end of the film, we get a Cruel Twist Ending when the main character realises that the spaceship's android, Walter, has been replaced by the psychopathic David, who forces her back into cryo-sleep and plans to experiment on the other passengers in stasis. The film expects this to be a big twist, but the fact that David's first introduced with shoulder length hair, which he then cuts off so he's visually nearly indistinguishable from Walter, practically telegraphs that he's going to at least attempt a Kill and Replace; why else have the haircut?
- The Mortal Instruments is rather infamous for these, due to its very obvious use of Foreshadowing. The most hated examples were that Valentine was Clary's father and Clary and Jace weren't siblings.
- In Midnight Predator, a lot of fans figured out that Jaguar was Turquoise and Ravyn's employer before it was revealed.
- Harry Potter:
- Umbridge was responsible for the Dementor Incident in Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix. Most of this comes from Umbridge being Obviously Evil, but the real factor that made it obvious was her not-so-subtle disdain for Harry.
- When J. K. Rowling wrote that an "RAB" had already procured the Horcrux locket at the end of Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince, many fans figured out "RAB" stood for Regulus Black. Though note that this was on the strength of just a couple barely memorable mentions of him until the final book, making this more a case of the fans being just that obsessive. note
- Snape is the Half-Blood Prince. The HBP is good at potions, and Snape got promoted to Defense Against the Dark Arts professor, which is usually a dead give away that you're going to be important in a Harry Potter book.
- Speaking of Snape, his love for Lily Evans-Potter certainly counts, as fans had already made a connection between the two characters long before they were even mentioned together and the ship actually was called the "S.S. Cliched" for a time.
- The Hero of the story is The Chosen One meant to kill the Big Bad Because Destiny Says So and Prophecies Are Always Right. No, that is not just the summary of a formulaic fantasy saga - that is an actual reveal in the end of Harry Potter and the Order of the Phoenix that was supposed to be of great emotional impact to both Harry and the reader.
- Harry Potter is the last Soul Jar. Would've been shocking if a huge deal hadn't been made out of the mysterious connection between him and Voldemort, and it hadn't been all but spelled out that Voldemort had put "a part of himself" into Harry.
- In Monstrous Regiment it's fairly easy to figure out that all of the soldiers are women long before it's explicitly stated. There's quite a lot of foreshadowing for each of them, like Sgt. Jackrum saying "on my oath, I am not a violent man" while being quite violent indeed; plays like Hypocritical Humor, but she is telling at least a partial truth. Not to mention that if you know your Elizabethan history the title itself is a hint, because the title of an Author Tract against Mary Queen of Scots referred to "the Monstrous Regiment of Women."
- Double Subverted in Cirque Du Freak with The Vampaneze Lord. At first it's incredibly obvious that Steve will be returning as the Vampaneze Lord, until it turns out that Steve became a vampire hunter. Then it's revealed that he was, in fact, the Vampaneze Lord all along. It's treated as a big twist, but many readers saw through the Red Herring anyway.
- In Les Misérables, there are two instances where the author introduces a man of 'unknown identity'note who just happens to look and behave exactly like Valjean and appear just as Valjean disappears from the narration. This man of course turns out to be Valjean, and Hugo doesn't even try to act like this is a surprise:
The reader has, no doubt, already divined that M. Madeleine is no other than Jean Valjean.
- Gentleman Bastard: The second book opens with Locke and Jean, two conmen who have been True Companions since childhood, cornered by some mooks. Suddenly, Jean turns on Locke and tells the mooks that he has betrayed Locke for their master. We then flash back to show How We Got Here, leaving this shocking swerve as a cliffhanger until the end, when we find out the obvious: the conman was conning the mooks.
- In Sir Walter Scott's Ivanhoe, "Robin of Locksley"— who lives in Nottingham, is a brilliant shot with a bow, and leads a merry band of outlaws in the forest who fight against Prince John—is revealed to be the secret identity of... you guessed it, none other than Robin Hood! All right, maybe it wasn't originally quite as much of a Captain Obvious Reveal as it is today, because Scott invented several of the tropes that became stock parts of the Robin Hood legend. Still, any reader with even the tiniest familiarity with the genre must have seen it coming a mile away.
- The Lost Symbol: Mal'akh is really Peter Solomon's presumed-dead son Zachary. According to the narration, Mal'akh killed Zachary Solomon before escaping prison with Solomon money but it's not hard to figure out this is just careful wording. Dan Brown even drops a massive hint by outright mentioning Darth Vader and Luke and then having Mal'akh cut Peter's hand off but it's still treated as a big reveal.
- Several tropes got so repeated in Kamen Rider, that fans were able to guess the moment Kamen Rider Wizard premiered that The White Wizard was going to be the Evil Mentor, be connected with the Big Bad in some way, and that Koyomi would be the Living MacGuffin. Needless to say, by the show's endgame, the show confirmed all three.
- Kamen Rider Gaim has the first episode feature the disappearance of a character, a monster who appeared around the area where he dropped the Transformation Trinket, and an ominous fruit that The Hero was tempted to eat. If you'd guess by now that the fruit had something to do with the disappeared person and that chances are he became said monster, then congratulations, you've guessed along with everyone else. However, the reveal isn't the fact that the monster was this character all along, but instead the inevitable moment when this truth is revealed to the characters.
- Another subversion is found in Kamen Rider Drive where we have two characters, Chase and Proto-Drive. Both of them are similar in visual design and what they can do, and even comparisons have been made In-Universe. It's no doubt that people started calling that the two are the same. Come a three-part episode regarding An Ass-Kicking Christmas and we find out two details: Proto-Drive is dead and that Chase is actually a robot with a number that isn't a part of the 108 numbered-robots. This actually becomes Double Subverted in a Meta Twist. Three episodes later and it is revealed that Proto-Drive and Chase are one and the same.
- In Hikari Sentai Maskman, "Prince" Igam is played by a woman who makes no attempt to disguise the fact that she is one, apparently a She Is the King situation. About 3/4 of the way through the series, it's dramatically revealed that she is in fact a woman when her headgear comes off and her long hair is seen. The episode is called "Prince Igam, You're A Woman!" It's at this point that you realize it was in fact supposed to be a secret.
- In season 3 of Supernatural, a big mystery is built up over the demon who holds the contract for Dean's soul, despite there only being one important demon character still living.
- The Star Trek: Voyager episode "Scorpion, Part II" makes a big deal out of The Reveal that the Borg were the aggressors in the war with Species 8472, who were well on their way to exterminating the entire Collective before Janeway stuck her nose in. Considering it's the Borg we're talking about, the bigger mystery is why wasn't that the default assumption?
- The Flash (2014):
- Reverse Flash turns out to be Harrison Wells, who has been Ambiguously Evil to the audience since the start of the series. However, the real twist is that he isn't Harrison Wells at all.
- And in season 3, the Flash gains a new major enemy, an evil wizard who is creating new metas to fight him, and a dickish new coworker who is played by Tom Felton, best known for playing Draco Malfoy, an evil wizard. Though again, the real twist is that he is not aware of it.
- Season 3 Big Bad Savitar being an evil version of Barry from the future. The foreshadowing was not very subtle ("I am the future, Flash" actually being "I am the Future Flash", the numerous other vague statements that pointed to this conclusion, Killer Frost instantly trusting him after learning his identity, etc.). It was so blatant that fans, much like the Obito example above, immediately dismissed it as too obvious and started theorizing about other possibilities (such as Eddie Thawne or Ronnie Raymond). Hence, they weren't happy to finally learn of his rather obvious identity twenty episodes into the season, as many felt it wasn't worth the wait.
- Once Upon a Time has many of these including Regina's mother Cora being the Queen of Hearts (we saw Cora disapearing through a looking glass, the Queen of Hearts knowing Regina's father and her name means heart in latin) and Emma's childhood friend Lily being Maleficent's long lost child (Lily has a strange Birthmark of Destiny and mentioned having been found when she was a baby).
- Subverted in Power Rangers Zeo. The mysterious and powerful Gold Ranger starts appearing and helping the Rangers. Meanwhile, former ranger and current ranger tech guy, Billy, starts being mysteriously absent. Low and behold, the Gold Ranger is ..... some guy we've never seen before.
- Dexter: During Season 6, many viewers guessed that Professor Gellar was Dead All Along almost immediately. The writers were simply too obvious with nobody but Travis ever seen talking to him but still treated it like a shocking turn of events when the "reveal" came.
- Just about every single person who'd watched any previous Doctor Who guessed that Missy was a new female incarnation of the Master, to the point that some fans thought that it was too obvious and that the real twist would be that she was someone else. However, the real shock twist of the season turned out to be Danny's death in the penultimate episode, which drives the plot of the Season Finale.
- Iron Fist (2017) makes a big show of finally revealing Madam Gao's face, even though it being her was completely obvious to anyone who'd watched Daredevil, while being meaningless to anyone who hadn't. Not many people were wondering which elderly female crime boss with a cane it could possibly be - and the subtitles didn't even bother hiding her name.
- Long before it was official, people were sure Bully Ray was going to turn out to be the leader of Aces & Eights, the then latest stable trying to takeover TNA. Many people speculating flat out admitted they didn't have logical reason behind the assumption besides being used to that kind of thing happening in TNA. Furthermore, Bully Ray ended up being well received in spite of people seeing it coming, and in spite of people generally wanting the Aces And Eights angle to die.
- Generally, when something is going in an obvious direction, resulting in this, TNA (and occasionally WWE, but mainly TNA) try to pull a Shocking Swerve. It happens so often that the swerves themselves become this.
- Any time Sting would partner with "face" Ric Flair, the eventual betrayal could be seen a mile away. Actually,nearly anyone Sting partnered with in major storylines was going to turn on him, including Bully Ray above.
- Wizards of the Coast tried to hype up the "mystery" of who could be behind the disasters on Innistrad. Because the last set was about the Eldrazi, and they went out of their way to mention one of the Titans was missing, no one was surprised when it turned out to be the Eldrazi.
- Batman: Arkham Knight: The identity of the Arkham Knight is this thanks to both Genre Savvy and Foreshadowing. Anyone with some knowledge of Batman lore can have a decent ballpark idea of who it is fairly early into the game. Even if you didn't know anything about Batman, a certain character is seen several times through Batman's flashbacks who had not even been so much as mentioned in any previous game in the series. The last of these flashbacks has said character being Mind Raped by the Joker into having a grudge against Batman, then Joker supposedly shoots him dead. Guess who the Knight is?
- Rune Factory 3: When Micah reveals his secret to Daria, she reveals her own secret - she's an elf. Micah treats this as a stunning revelation, and the player is supposed to as well. This is Daria. Though it could be argued that the shock was that Daria was specifically an elf, not just non-human. Falls flat especially in the case of the legitimate surprise of Raven's reveal.
- Persona 4: Naoto is a girl. Thanks to the English voice acting this doesn't come as much of a surprise to most (although her voice is slightly deeper before The Reveal), though the Japanese voice acting does a slightly better job of hiding it. Even then, many players were able to tell her gender just by looking at her, and the twist has well and truly reached It Was His Sled levels now.
- Adachi being the killer for some people. He was the only major character who didn't have a Social Link (until an Updated Re-release—and even then it was an arcana that doesn't exist in reality), much like Ikutsuki in Persona 3. Another hint was his tendency to "accidentally" give the Investigation Team hints, mostly to cover his own ass. Another give-away that it's a common cliche in murder mysteries that the killer is perceived as a Nice Guy before the reveal while a Jerk Ass is a Red Herring.
- Persona 5: Goro Akechi is the traitor. Out of story, he hardly had shown up in the promotional material but was confirmed to be a member of the party, unlike all the other party members, who were heavily featured and even got their own commercials. In story, he is a detective when the protagonists are all considered criminals, and we are informed that one of the party members betrayed the group in the very beginning of the game. Even the game itself isn't subtle about it with some of his cameo costumes being Ideo Hazama and Mutton, both major antagonists from their respective games. All of the party members are suspicious of him at all times as well in game, since he inadvertently disproved his cover story. One dungeon after joining your party (the one that was his idea to raid), Goro betrays you and gives info on you to the police. Furthermore, his last name is "Akechi", a name not unlike "Benedict Arnold" in Japan thanks to Akechi Mitsuhide.
- However, many fans feel that invoking this trope was a deliberate choice by the creators, as it draws attention away from the real twist: The Thieves knew he was going to back-stab them, and had in fact set up their own gambit to expose him and his boss.
- Igor is actually the Demiurge. His voice is completely different and his previous Cryptkeeper-like demeanor is altogether gone, so it's not hard to guess that he's being impersonated, even if you can't initially tell who it is. Note however that this largely applies to the Western release, Igor's Japanese had passed away several years before the game was released, thus meaning the player would be less likely to suspect about the change in voice.
- Pokémon Black and White:
- "What? Are you telling me that the serious, pale-skinned man who uses a red scouter-like machine on his right eye, wears a robe with eyeballs in it and is constantly talking on behalf of Team Plasma is actually a villain and Team Plasma's real leader? And the guy who looks like a younger version of him is actually his son!? HOW WOULD I KNOW?"
- Black and White also try to pretend that N being the "official" leader of Team Plasma is a surprise until Nimbasa City. Even for players who skipped past the animation depicting his coronation that plays before the title screen every time the game is booted up, it wasn't hard to piece together that the weird kid who sympathized with Pokémon was linked to that weird organization that claims to fight against Pokémon abuse.
- Pokémon X and Y:
- The leader of the villainous Team Flare (whose stated goal is to make the world beautiful) is supposed to be a mystery. In practice, it's a no-brainer to connect said goal to a guy's ravings about how "the world should be destroyed before its beauty ceases", along with his matching wardrobe and color coordination, and conclude that the guy is their leader.
- In the same game, they also make a half-hearted attempt to hide the fact that Diantha is the champion. Even the anime pretty much introduces her as such in her first appearance there.
- In general, the regional champion has always followed a set pattern: they're uniquely designed, unique in personality, and have a significant role in the game's plot. In Generations I and II, this wasn't much of a problem, given how Generation I (the very start of the series) led the player to believe that the Elite Four was their final challenge (with the rival's champion status being a rather big twist even today) and Generation II had only just begun to experiment with this formula. Starting from Gen III, however, this formula for the champion was practically set in stone for the series, with champions becoming rather easy to pick out from the game's cast. It got to the point where Pokémon Black and White didn't even attempt to hide that Alder was the Champion. Which allowed them to use the established pattern to pull a Meta Twist: Alder isn't the Final Boss, he's actually The Unfought during the main story due to Team Plasma's plot, and is only fought as the True Final Boss
- Pokémon Sun and Moon:
- The very instant the Aether Foundation was revealed in trailers for the game, everyone suspected that they would be the story's Big Bad. In fact this is averted completely, the game opens with Lillie on the run from a bunch of malicious-looking Aether employees, thus making the reveal that the Aether Foundation had been corrupted by one of the Ultra Beasts even less of a surprise to the players.
- The Reveal that Lillie, Gladion, and Lusamine are all related is hardly surprising given that they all look so similar, especially Lillie and Lusamine.
- The fact that Lusamine is evil is blatantly obvious after the first Ultra Beast leaves during your first meeting with her, because she sports a Slasher Smile and starts muttering like a madman. The surprise is just HOW bad she is.
- Starting with Pokémon Emerald, a generation always has a post-game legendary Pokémon with a theme and/or design similar to the main mascot duo, is often close by them in the Pokédex, and is totally ignored in the main plot. Then a later game focuses on them and reveals that the Pokémon that looks and acts very similarly to the main duo is actually related to them, and they often expect you to be shocked by that. If their similarities aren't a premature tip-off, that they always play this "twist" dead straight every gen should be.
- Pokémon Black and White:
- Final Fantasy X
- All Summoners, including Yuna, will die at the end of their journey. The game is not very subtle in hiding its hints. High Summoners, the title given to Summoners who have defeated Sin, are all dead; Yuna's meaningful glances at all places, before leaving them; the tearful farewell from her village or the noticeably awkward silence, after Tidus insensitively saying that they'll do this and that, after Yuna has defeated Sin. The reveal scene itself, about halfway through the game, seems to be more for Tidus than for the player.
- Auron is an Unsent. Aside from it being It Was His Sled territory, the hints are so unsubtle (Seymour asking why Auron's "still here" and saying that he can smell "the scent of the Farplane" on him) Tidus knew what Auron wanted to say, when he revealed his status as an Unsent to him. The others get this reveal in the final scene, where Yuna performs a Sending and Auron willingly lets himself be sent, after having fought a previous Sending that affected him.
- Subverted in No More Heroes when it's revealed that Henry is Travis's twin brother. Apparently, he thought such a reveal would be one of these. How does everyone react to this news...?
Travis: That's the craziest shit I've ever heard! Why would you bring up something like that at the very end of the game?!
Henry: I would have thought that you and the player would have at least expected a twist of fate of some kind.
- Tales of Destiny 2 gives us Judas who is so obviously Leon (from the first game in the duology) that it hurts.
- Sirius being Camus in Fire Emblem: Mystery of the Emblem is practically the same as the above. Strangely though, The Reveal never actually happens. Though it's all but stated in his conversation with Nyna in the final chapter, there's no Dramatic Unmasking, as he knows full well revealing his identity would cause more harm than good for everyone.
- Fire Emblem Fates has the revelation that Odin, Selena and Laslow are actually Owain, Severa and Inigo from Fire Emblem Awakening. Even if you missed or forget the fact that previous game established The Multiverse as a thing, all three have the exact same appearances, voice actors, personalities and birthdays as their Awakening counterparts, and their supports frequently reference Awakening, so one has to wonder how much of a surprise it's actually supposed to be.
- In Fire Emblem Echoes: Shadows of Valentia, we have a red-haired masked figure who follows Celica and her party around, warning them of various dangers and seeming very concerned for Celica's welfare and seems to know she's actually the heir to Zofia, and Celica mentions more than once that she had a brother who died. It's decidedly a hugely unsurprising reveal when it turns out to be Conrad, Celica's big brother.
- From Tales of Graces, we have Richard being possessed. If his sudden headache and subsequent bloody rampage against soldiers at Wallbridge isn't enough to clue the player in, there's also his desire to take revenge on his uncle, whom he also kills in front of the party. Richard's continued aggressive behavior, including starting a war is not enough to make the party actually figure this out themselves. While the player has figured it out ages ago, one must still sit through a good 20 hours of gameplay before the idea of Richard being possessed by the Big Bad is even considered an option.
- Tales of Symphonia
- The game has an odd situation in that an actual reveal leads directly into an example. After Ozette is destroyed, the party meets a child claiming to be the sole survivor, whose name is Mithos. Over several skits, it becomes apparent that Mithos is more than he seems, and he shares many traits with the ancient hero Mithos. Then a genuine reveal occurs, as a storyteller informs you that the hero Mithos's last name was Yggdrasill, the name of the Big Bad. However, several more scenes occur before the final reveal, which should be obvious from the previous two by the transitive property: the Mithos in their group is also Yggdrasill.
- There's also the matter of Genis and Raine being half-elves. Fairly early in the game, a half-elven character compares himself to the two of them, but quickly and awkwardly retracts this comparison when Genis nervously declares them to be elves, and he realizes they've been traveling incognito. Combined with moments like Raine telling Genis "we're not like them" about a group of half-elven villains, the player may well have forgotten that their race was supposed to be a secret by the time the shocking-to-the-characters reveal arrives several plot twists later.
- Kratos is Lloyd's father. The age doesn't seem to make things work out, Kratos is stated to be 28 and Lloyd is 17 years old, so he would have had to become a father at a very young age, but the twist is still obvious. Early on, the party visits Lloyd's home and Kratos is seen standing at the grave nearby, which Lloyd reveals to be his mother's. They share similar facial expressions, a distaste for tomatoes and Kratos is a little too uncharacteristically emotional when the party meets Kvar, who gloatingly reveals how he was at fault for Lloyd's mother's death. And when the party splits up into one fighting Kvar, Kratos refuses any combination that does not involve him on that team. The reveal itself? Takes place close to the last third of the game. The age thing is also made clearer when it's revealed that Kratos is actually about four millenia old.
- Tales of Xillia 2
- Elle is Ludger's daughter from the future. Within the first hour of the two meeting in the beginning of the game, multiple hints are dropped over and over and not leaving much of a potential surprise for the player. The revelation being given to Ludger and Elle themselves? The last third of the game.
- Elle actually being from a fractured dimension. Nothing in the world of Xillia states that time travel is actually possible, but even ignoring that, the fact that Elle's father's clock merges with Ludger's is a big hint. Especially because the game states early on that the same thing cannot exist twice in the prime dimension, making it obvious that the clock (and Elle) come from a fractured dimension.
- For the second half of Bravely Default, the player is gradually given hints that Airy either isn't telling all the information, is evil, or both. Once you hit the 3/4 mark, the title screen changes the subtitle to read "Airy Lies", outright spelling out her deception. And yet, for another 20 hours or so of gameplay, the characters still can't piece it together. Even after when Ringabel remembers that she's evil and outright murdered the others in another world. When her true intentions are finally revealed, the cast is shocked, while the player is banging their head against the wall.
- Alternis and Ringabel being the same person, provided one reads the Book of D. While the narrators identity is never textually given in the entries, Alternis is very clearly shown in an illustration, make it easy to identify him as the narrator. From there, the various details, most glaring being Ringabel's lack of presence in the Book of D, makes putting two and two together easy.
- In the BlazBlue games people figured out that Phantom was really Konoe A. Mercury (aka Nine of the Six Heroes) almost four years before it was actually confirmed in the game itself.
- Super Mario 3D World attempts a Victory Fakeout at the end of World 7... which might have been a little more convincing had there not been eight worlds in Super Mario Bros., Super Mario Bros.: The Lost Levels, Super Mario Bros. 3, all 5 New Super Mario Bros. games and several others. It seems that the Grandfather Clause is obliging the Mario series to use Your Princess Is in Another Castle in every game by now.
- In Paper Mario: Color Splash, virtually nobody was surprised by Bowser being the Big Bad. In fact, most people figured it out the moment the game was shown off. Not only is there Bowser tape in Port Prisma, but during Ruddy Road, the first actual level, a Shy Guy is shown placing Bowser tape down right in front of your eyes. And yet no one suspects a thing. The reveal of the Koopalings being the main bosses only rubbed salt into that wound. Like the above example, it feels like the Grandfather Clause is obliging the series to use Bowser as the Big Bad in every game now.
- Astro Boy: Omega Factor has the reveal that Blue Knight is actually President Rag, having survived his attempted assassination. The attempted assassination that Blue Knight is shown flashing back to in an early conversation with Astro.
- In Golden Sun: Dark Dawn, many could easily guess the real identity of Arcanus because his mask covers less than half of his face.
- The Man Behind the Man in Sonic Rush Adventure is Dr. Eggman, who is completely absent from the story until The Reveal. However, given that apparent-Big Bad Captain Whisker is a robot who sports a mustache and overall looks identical to that of Eggman, roughly no-one was shocked when the twist was revealed.
- The Legend of Zelda: The Wind Waker Tetra is revealed to be Zelda. She's the only blonde female protagonist in the main story who isn't Link's sister. Also entering Tetra's room earlier on, you can see portraits of the Triforce, the legendary hero and Tetra's mother who looks like a queen.
- In Nicole, one of the four guys Nicole interacts with is a kidnapper. This could have been an intriguing mystery to solve had Jeff not begun acting like Creepy McCreeperson just two weeks into the game.
- Diablo 3 has Act 2 that involves the player character hunting for Belial, the primal evil Lord of Lies. Everything points to the creepy child emperor of the desert nation he/she is in being the obvious culprit. Everything. This kid covers every evil child cliche known to man, short of speaking parseltongue (and that too, since his personal guards are snake people in disguise). Yet the players spend the entire linear story arc going off on increasingly silly red herrings only to be told by the creepy child himself that, surprise, he was Belial the whole time. No way! For that matter, it's so obvious that even the player character had figured it out awhile ago.
- Dragonball Xenoverse 2 opens with the conclusion of Dragon Ball Z: Bardock – The Father of Goku, as the titular Bardock is enveloped in Freeza's death sphere, and is in no way related to the mysterious masked stranger with damaged armor that shows up with Towa, Mira, Turles, and Lord Slug immediately afterward.
- Thimbleweed Park turns out to be all in a video game itself. This would be quite surprising... if the two agents didn't blatantly break the fourth wall saying the dead body is "pixellating" and could ask the pigeon brothers "Should I save my game?" (and be told "This game is hard-coded not to be unwinnable") within the first fifteen minutes.
- Dangan Ronpa:
- The fact that the first culprit was Leon was made extremely obvious; the number 11037 was blatantly "LEON" upside-down on the wall. Justified in that the game was written in Japanese, where Leon would be written completely differently, although anyone with a basic knowledge of the Latin alphabet (now a required subject in Japanese schools) and the willingness to look past the numbers and view it upside-down could still easily figure it out.
- The chapter 3 culprit being Celeste isn't very surprising either, since Celeste does a terrible job diverting suspicion away from herself, despite being purportedly a good liar. It's especially obvious once it is deduced that Hifumi is the accomplice, when Celeste is the character who Hifumi interacts the most with. How intentional this actually is is up for debate.
- The reveal in Super Dangan Ronpa 2 that the main character Hinata is super student Izuru Kamukura is a possible example, depending on whether one has read Dangan Ronpa Zero. It is a fairly big revelation earlier on that Hinata was part of the talentless Reserve Course, while Kamukura is stated in the book multiple times to be a former Reseve Course student. Combining this with the statement that the Reserve Course committed mass suicide and one can easily connect the dots. If you haven't read the book (like many people who played the localization) then the fact Kamukura exists at all isn't indicated until an exposition dump just before the final trial and several details about him aren't given (likely an effort to avoid this trope) making this a jarring Shocking Swerve instead.
- The Reveal in Dangan Ronpa Kirigiri that Mikado Shinsen is the fourth 000 detective and the Big Bad would be a big twist...only Shinsen himself disappears partway through the case he's featured in. Anyone remotely Genre Savvy on detective fiction would know to be suss on any Never Found the Body scenario, all of Shinsen's scenes establish him as a mysterious figure, he's the guest given the least development and both the identities of the Committee chairman and missing 000 are referenced throughout the book and speculated to be the same person, making it obvious both will be addressed.
- New Dangan Ronpa V3: Harukawa not actually being the Ultimate Caregiver but the Ultimate Assassin. Not only does she display no traits that remotely match her being a caregiver (even being a self-admitted Child Hater), but her repeated refusal to let anyone inside her Talent Lab makes it very apparent that she's hiding something.
- Also, from New Dangan Ronpa V3, Korekiyo being the third culprit is one to a lot of fans especially since he was the one to set-up the resurrection ritual (aka the death trap that ended up having Tenko killed). What makes this trope unique is how the Word of God stated that the culprit was meant to obvious.
- In Fate/stay night, Kotomine Kirei is introduced as supposedly morally ambiguous... except his theme is a creepy organ piece, he's extremely tall and dressed in all black, and he constantly says vaguely threatening things to Shirou. It's not exactly a shock when he turns out to be evil.
- In Apollo Justice: Ace Attorney, the reveal that the amnesiac singer Lamiroir and the long-missing Thalassa Gramarye are the same person should not be shocking to anyone once Thalassa's picture is first shown. Lamiroir might cover her face nowadays, but she didn't change a damn thing about her hair.
- From the moment she was introduced in the "Black" trailer, and throughout the first season up until The Reveal, hints and clues were dropped all over the place that Blake was secretly a Faunus. Then she accidentally reveals it, and almost no viewer was surprised. Lampshaded when a tertiary character had figured it out after meeting Blake for about a minute and pointed out one of the more obvious hints to the rest of Team RWBY.
Yang: We're looking for our friend Blake.
Penny: Ooooh, you mean the Faunus girl!
Ruby: Wait, how did you know that?
Penny: Uhh, the cat ears?
Yang: What cat ears? she wears a... bow...
(tumbleweed rolls by)
Ruby: She does like tuna a lot.
- Happens again with Penny being a robot. The audience had her pegged pretty much the second she showed up (especially when a bunch of levitating swords popped out of her back). The only question was whether she was an A.I. or some form of cyborg. In the second season, we find out it's the former.
Penny: (to Ruby) You're taking this surprisingly well.
- From the moment she was introduced in the "Black" trailer, and throughout the first season up until The Reveal, hints and clues were dropped all over the place that Blake was secretly a Faunus. Then she accidentally reveals it, and almost no viewer was surprised. Lampshaded when a tertiary character had figured it out after meeting Blake for about a minute and pointed out one of the more obvious hints to the rest of Team RWBY.
- The Order of the Stick:
- Lampshaded in the strip that reveals that Nale is Elan's twin brother, referring to that fact as "semi-secret" and noting, "I mean, it's not like you couldn't have figured it out." The other characters are also completely unsurprised.
- Much later, Tarquin dramatically reveals himself and his party to be the secret rulers of three empires. A bit after that he shows up with a legion trained in "plot critical reveals", one of whom shouts this same information at them out of nowhere, which Tarquin brushes off with "Yes, yes, we did that one already."
- Lampshaded in El Goonish Shive; the title of this strip acknowledges many readers already guessed Chaos was the same Immortal that appeared to Mr. Verres and his agents 2 years previously.
- In The Adventures of Dr. McNinja the doctor teams up with a bunch of his half-baked clones against a lone villain and doesn't figure out that Conservation of Ninjutsu is holding him back until, in the words of the author's own Alt Text, a week after the readers did.
- Homestuck does this constantly, mainly due to how readily it invites theorizing. At one point the narrator even lampshades it:
But the fact that he's a slob was never exactly breaking news to anyone.
Neither is the fact that you both share a body.
I mean come on.
- This is Played for Laughs in the episode "The Sting". When Fry is killed, anyone who's not completely Genre Blind knew they were going to bring him back to life. The writers knew this from the beginning, so they kept on having Fry come back to life, but it was one of Leela's delusions. In the end, it was played straight.
- A couple of fans predicted that Leela was a mutant, and many deduced that Nibbler pushed Fry into the cryogenic tube. However, in both cases the producers left obvious clues in early episode as Easter Eggs; in the pilot episode one may spot Nibbler's eye and shadow around the table Fry was sitting on, while Leela's one-eyed parents may be spotted among the sewer mutants in a background shot.
- In the first episode of My Little Pony: Friendship Is Magic the characters are surprised that Celestia is actually the sister of Nightmare Moon from the ancient legend. The thing is, since it was already established that Celestia raised the sun (plus that Meaningful Name), not only is this obvious to the audience, it makes the main characters look pretty dumb.
- Even more so in a later episode, when it turns out that Nightmare Moon is immortalized in a yearly celebration - Nightmare Night - and that Ponyville has a large statue of her, in all her fanged glory. They really should have recognized her as "that spooky pony we sacrifice candy to every year". At least one fanfic does have the Ponyville residents know all about her, with Twilight the only one out of the loop due to being from Canterlot.
- In the Season 5 finale of Star Wars: The Clone Wars Ahsoka got framed for bombing the Jedi Temple, and committing several murders during her escape by someone who's suspected to be Jedi themselves. Most of the viewers correctly guessed that this traitor would turn out to be Barris Offee, Ahsoka's friend, who hasn't appeared for three seasons prior to this arc, where she suddenly got considerable screen-time, and most of her scenes were very clearly pointing at her guiltiness.
- Star Wars Rebels: In "Spark of Rebellion", the pilot, the reveal that Kanan is a Jedi is not much of a surprise given that the Jedi theme had been used multiple times when he was on-screen (plus we had already seen that he had a lightsaber and a holocron). It's still a Crowning Moment of Awesome though.
- In the season one finale of Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles (2012), it's finally revealed that Oroku Karai is really Hamato Miwa, Splinter/Hamato Yoshi's biological daughter who he thought died in the fire that killed his wife and Karai's mother Tang Shen. However, the large amounts of foreshadowing (for example, the use of the alias Harmony, as "Miwa" literally means "beautiful harmony"), along with the fact that several adaptions of the TMNT that use Karai explicitly state her to be the Shredder's adoptive daughter, made this blatantly obvious from the get-go.
- The 1944 Looney Tunes Wartime Cartoon Plane Daffy has Daffy trying to guard a military secret from Nazi spy Hata Mari. At the end, she reveals the secret to her superiors: "Hitler is a stinker!"
- The Thunderbolts turning out to be the Master of Evil in Avengers Assemble. Not only was it a nearly-20 year spoiler at this point, but it actually suffered from Adaptation Induced Plothole as the team gets accepted by the people despite the Avengers not being missing (the result of the battle with Onslaught sending them and the Fantastic Four getting sent into a pocket universe), the Masters of Evil only recently being introduced, the Avengers having fought them the episode prior to the Thunderbolts' debut, and the line-up not changing as the comics had well prior to that point.
- In the Star vs. the Forces of Evil episode, "The Hard Way", it's revealed that Toffee (thought to be dead following the season one finale) lives on inside a fragment of Star's wand. Many had predicted that he became a part of the wand as early as the ending to season one, owing to his smirk at the wand's destruction even when he was about to be blown up, as well as his demonstrated Healing Factor. Season 2 only made it more obvious, with Star's wand established to be corrupted, his missing finger being inside the wand, his skeletal arm clutching the wand fragment (which wasn't seen at the end of season one) forming Ludo's wand, and the build-up of Toffee as a character with importance to Star's family and the universe at large.
- Gravity Falls: Grunkle Stan has a twin brother. Given that the show deliberately includes all sorts of details and clues for fans to analyze, it didn't take them long to piece it together. Alex Hirsch even commented that he modified the way The Reveal was handled because the theory was so popular (specifically, the fact that Stan has a twin isn't the reveal, it's the fact that said twin is the guy who wrote the journals that Dipper has been following for the whole series). A few episodes later, a massive Lampshade Hanging occurs, with the characters watching an episode of Ducktective and being less than impressed with the reveal that Ducktective has a twin brother because they found it so obvious.
As it turns out, this page was describing obvious plot twists the entire time! Admit it, you're surprised.