ITT: Rate the above Troper's Casting Choices

8/10 pretty unusual but funny casting choices.

Wicked

• Elphaba:Zan Partizanne◊
• Glinda:Andromeda◊
• Fiyero:Pit◊
• Nessarose:Flamberge◊
• Boq:Claus◊
• The Wizard:Jay◊
• Madame Morrible:Dark Enchantress Cookie◊
• Doctor Dillamond:Loid◊
• Dorothy:Daisy◊
• Melena:Moonlight Cookie◊

bump

Looks good to me from what I know of the characters! 8.7/10

Ninjaproof...

Into the Woods

The Baker: Quasimodo◊

The Baker's Wife: Queenie Goldstein◊

The Witch: Elphaba◊

Little Red Riding Hood: Thea Queen◊

The Wolf: Scar◊

Cinderella: Supergirl◊

Jack: Anthony Hope◊

Rapunzel: Cosette◊

Cinderella's Prince: Green Arrow◊

Rapunzel's Prince: Marius Pontmercy◊

The Giantess: Eris◊

Edited by Spottedleaf on Mar 26th 2019 at 5:24:56 AM

7/10

Seems ok.

A really short version of Water Margin

Song Jiang the horrible Distressed Dude leader:

Wu Yong The Smart Guy:

Wu Song the Drunken Badass:

Dai Zong the Fragile Speedster:

Wei Dingbo the fire controller:

Dan Tingyuan the water controller:

The three girls:

Qiong Ying the rock thrower Girl Team Sixth Ranger:

9/10 Pretty good overall. I've never heard of this book, but your choices seem to fit the characters pretty well. Your descriptions of the characters help a lot, and if it means I can choose something a little less known, I think I'll do the same for this cast. Maybe for all of them from now on.

Let's try... Redwall (The first book. Partial cast.)

• Matthias◊, The Chosen One and hero.
• Cornflower◊, Matthias' love interest
• Abbott Mortimer◊, overly trusting pacifist.
• Methuselah◊, old wise man.
• Constance◊, Mama Bear caretaker.^note In the book, there's no relationship like that between Mortimer and Constance, I just think both of these characters fit those roles really well.
• Basil Stag Hare◊, comical Big Eater but badass fighter.
• Cluny the Scourge◊, fierce Big Bad warlord
• Redtooth◊, The Dragon.
• Shadow◊, Phantom Thief and assassin.
• Asmodeus Poisonteeth◊, giant murderous monster
• Captain Snow◊, antagonist who eventually joins the heroes
• Squire Julian Gingivere◊, kindly farm boy who joins the heroes.

9/10 pretty accurate casting even though I've never heard of this book before

What about a classic this time?

A Wrinkle in Time

• • Meg:Retasu "Lettuce" Midorikawa◊
  • Charles Wallace:Magolor◊
  • Calvin:Emmett◊
• • Katherine Murry:Nana◊
  • Alexander Murry:Garmadon◊
  • Sandy & Dennys:Ice Climbers◊
  • Mr. Jenkins:PS1 Hagrid◊
  • Mrs. Buncombe:Cherry Blossom Cookie◊
• • Ms. Whatsit:Hinawa◊
  • Ms. Who:Chrona◊
  • Ms. Which:Sectonia◊
• • Happy Medium:Mad Mew Mew◊
  • Aunt Beast:Grapefruit Cat◊
• • IT/The Black Thing:Reggiegiygas◊

Edited by TabbyGirl4 on Mar 28th 2019 at 3:50:22 AM

bump

Wow! I love this book and this casting works really well. I'm especially on board with Grapefruit Cat as Aunt Beast. 10/10

Let's try one of my favorite musicals, Sweeney Todd: The Demon Barber of Fleet Street...featuring only animal characters!

Sweeney Todd: Scar◊

Mrs. Lovett, Sweeney's "fangirl" who bakes people into pies: Zira◊

Anthony Hope, naive young sailor "friend" of Sweeney's and love interest of Johanna: Baron◊

Johanna, Sweeney's daughter and ward of Judge Turpin: Spottedleaf◊

Judge Turpin, corrupt Lawful Evil and horrible person: Sableye◊

Beadle Bamford, lackey of Turpin: Nuka◊

Toby, Lovett's "adoptive son": Kitten!Yuki◊

Pirelli, funny but evil Italian guy and Sweeney's first kill: No Banana Cat◊

The Crazy old beggar woman/ Lucy, Sweeney's not so dead wife: Grizabella◊

Edited by Spottedleaf on Apr 2nd 2019 at 10:57:08 AM

7/10 Pretty ok

Logan's Run

• Logan 5:Lucas◊
• Francis 7:Taranza◊
• Jessica 6:Strawberry◊
• The Cubs:Goose the Cat◊
• Mary 2:Camille◊
• Billy:Kirby◊
• Doc:Dr. Pig◊
• Holly 13:Pomegranate Cookie◊
• Box:Roblox Guest◊
• The Old Man:Noggin The Gnome◊
• The Sandman:Marx◊
• The Computer:Peni Parker◊

Edited by TabbyGirl4 on Apr 3rd 2019 at 7:47:43 AM

bump

7/10 Pretty good. I've never heard of this movie, so I had to judge based on what information I could find on the characters from the film page. Pretty accurate, I guess.

You Tube Poop (I'm going to do as many of the common YTP characters as I can, except I'm going to do Spotted's challenge and make them all animals.)

• Dr. Robotnik: Cap'n Tramun Clogg◊
• Sonic: Daroach◊
• Tails: Posset◊
• Scratch: Bad Bird◊
• Grounder: Surprised Pikachu◊
• King Harkinian: Magnus◊
• Link: Speedy Cerviche◊
• Ganon: Tamatoa◊
• Morshu: Papa Bear◊
• Spongebob Squarepants: Nice Cream Guy◊
• Squidward Tentacles: Staya◊
• Mr. Krabs: King K. Rool◊
• I.M. Meen: Capital B◊
• Dr. Rabbit: Big Chungus◊
• Gaston: Reanimated King Dedede◊
• Lefou: Reanimated Escargoon◊
• Mario: Whiskers◊
• Luigi: Skid◊
• Yoshi: Goodra◊
• Bowser/King Koopa: Rat King◊
• Weegee: Little King John◊

Thank you!

Edited by DrNoPuma on Apr 9th 2019 at 8:22:38 AM

10/10. This is waaaaay too fun for me to find any fault in it!

A while back, Vengeful Bale cast my gallery in the She-Ra reboot. While I still haven't seen the show (I don't have Netflix), reading more about it has made me quite the fan, so here's an expanded version of his casting!

Adora: Katara◊

Glimmer: Felicity Smoak◊

Bow: Oliver Queen/Green Arrow◊

Catra: Azula◊

Hordak: Shiny Mega Gengar◊

The Shadow Weaver: Zira◊

Bale's cast ended there, so....Here's where the fun begins!

Perfuma: Audrey◊

Mermista: Ariel◊

Frosta: Caitlin Snow/Killer Frost◊

Entrapa: Luna Lovegood◊

Netossa: Nyssa Al Ghul◊

Spinerella: Sara Lance◊

Sea Hawk: Anthony Hope◊

Queen Angella: Galadriel◊

Scorpia: Kendra Saunders/Hawkgirl◊

Edited by Spottedleaf on Apr 9th 2019 at 4:05:10 AM

8/10 kinda accurate

Cucumber Quest

• Cucumber:Ralsei◊
• Almond:Pistachio Cookie◊
• Lord Cabbage:Meta Knight◊
• Sir Carrot:Dark Choco Cookie◊
• Princess Nautilus:Summer◊
• The Dream Oracle:Andromeda◊
• Chardonnay:Chrona◊
• Sir Tomato:Ness◊
• Dame Lettuce:Autumn◊
• Sir Bacon:Lucas◊
• Princess Parfait:Strawberry◊
• Saturday/Princess Azalea:Chili Pepper Cookie◊
• Princess Piano:Luna◊
• Count Legato/Panpipe:Young!Lloyd Garmaddon◊
• Lute:Zero Two◊
• Mandolin:Douchebag Cat◊
• King Ruby:No Anime Penguin◊
• Princess Ametrine:Kumatora◊
• Princess Sunshine:Flamberge◊
• Cosmo:Loid◊
• Queen Cordelia:Sectonia◊
• Peridot:Creampuff Cookie◊
• The Nightmare Knight:Void Termina◊
• Splashmaster:Big Chungus◊
• Noisemaster & Mutemaster:Aeon & Venus◊
• Rosemaster:Lettuce◊
• Quakemaster:Thanos◊
• Obsidian:Hyness◊
• Mistmaster:Squid Ink Cookie◊
• Glitchmaster:Monika◊

Edited by TabbyGirl4 on Apr 15th 2019 at 6:28:50 AM

bump and edited

Oh my goodness, this is fun. Again, I can't find any fault with it. 10/10.

Edited this to be something less obscure, but:

Rise of the Guardians- but genderbent!

Jack Frost: Caitlin Snow

North (Santa Claus): Olga Stroganoff

Toothiana, the Tooth Fairy: Newt Scamander

E. Aster Bunnymund (Easter Bunny): Yellowfang

The Sandman: Fantine

Pitch Black: Eris

Jamie: Kisa Sohma

Edited by Spottedleaf on Apr 19th 2019 at 5:50:27 AM

Bumped and edited.

10/10 I really like it!

Marvel Cinematic Universe

10/10 Loved seeing Pythor as Loki and Dedede as Thor. Plus Hyness being Maw is perfect.

Mulan

• Mulan: Lucina◊

• Mushu: Discord◊

• Shang: Meta Knight◊

• Shan Yu: Ganondorf◊

• Yao: King Dedede◊

• Ling: Captain Falcon◊

• Chien Po:Gideon Gray◊

• Shi-Fu: Charles Muntz◊

• Cri-Kee: Sableye◊

• Emperor of China: Zen-Oh◊

• Army Captain: Jiren◊

• Mulan's Father: Goblin Slayer◊

Edited by VengefulBale on May 2nd 2019 at 9:44:51 AM

10/10 These are all great castings. I especially like Ganon as Shan-Yu. Good and accurate choices overall.

NiGHTS into Dreams… (using short descriptions for each character just in case)

• NiGHTS (magical and friendly hero): Clowncastarr◊
• Claris (Kid Hero): Vividria◊
• Elliot (Kid Hero): Tails◊
• Gulliwing (dragon-like boss): Beast Joka◊
• Puffy (round opera-singer-bunny-thing boss): Pancake Bunny◊
• Gulpo (giant fish boss): Orca◊
• Klawz (giant cat boss): Zeraora◊
• Jackle (magical jester boss): Jevil◊
• Reala (NiGHTS' evil counterpart): Dimentio◊
• Wizeman (godlike Big Bad): Ghadius◊

Edited by DrNoPuma on May 6th 2019 at 7:31:16 AM

10/10- OH MAN, the nostalgia. This was one of the first games I played on the Wii, though I wasn't good at it. But the casting choices here are PERFECT and just match really well with the respective characters.

Wicked

Elphaba Thropp: Caitlin Snow/Frost◊

Glinda Upland: Supergirl◊

Fiyero: Cisco Ramon◊

Boq: Seymour Krelborn◊

Nessarose: Azula◊

Madame Morrible: Bellatrix Lestrange◊

Dr. Dillamond: Baron Humbert Von Gikkingen◊

The Lion: Nuka◊

The Wizard: Snow Miser◊

Dorothy: Tohru Honda◊

Edited by Spottedleaf on May 20th 2019 at 6:08:24 AM

Oh, nice! That casting is perfectly fitting for Wicked's own.

Hercules

Edited by VengefulBale on May 30th 2019 at 11:47:35 AM

Bumping

10/10. Your list is really comprehensive, and all your choices fit really well.

Tropers: The Series (major characters)

Because after my second-to-last one, I want to try doing more out-there casts. :P I'm doing this mostly based on personality.

Edited by DrNoPuma on Jun 14th 2019 at 8:24:31 AM

Oh dude, this is awesome! Definitely out there, but really well-chosen.

Tangled. My Self-Imposed Challenge this time is that all the Snuggly Duckling thugs must be villains. They're also the only ones I could gender-bend. Also, I tried to match their hobbies as much as I can.

Rapunzel: Fantine◊

Pascal: Yuki◊

Mother Gothel: Bellatrix Lestrange◊

Flynn Rider/ Eugene Fitzherbert: Jean Valjean◊

Stabbington Brothers- Shranos◊ and Thatrick◊

The King of Corona- Superman◊

The Queen of Corona- Galadriel◊

Maximus- Javert◊ (but as a horse)

The Snuggly Duckling Thugs:

• Hook Hand Thug: Sweeney Todd◊

• Big Nose Thug: The Phantom of the Opera◊

• Shorty: Thenardier◊

• Tor: Poison Ivy◊

• Gunther: Voldemort◊

• Ulf: Reverse Flash◊

• Atilla: Mrs. Lovett◊

• Bruiser: Roxie Hart◊

• Killer: Carrie White◊

• Fang: Discord◊

• Vladimir- Leonard Snart◊

Edited by Spottedleaf on Jun 22nd 2019 at 11:53:58 AM

I find this to be a bonafide casting, in spite of some odd choices, but then again, this is truly the best that could be done with your gallery and it's admirable!

Avengers: Endgame (Spoilers Ahead! Watch at your own risk)

Edited by VengefulBale on Jun 22nd 2019 at 9:42:38 AM