Making disambigs for works that share names...

Started doing that. Gotta go do a thing...

Gotta remember to request School For Scoudrels as a disambig between the films and Sensei for Scoundrels.

Manhua.Bloodline has issues with eventual year conflict with:

https://www.imdb.com/title/tt1270282/

Among other films?

Edited by Malady on Aug 5th 2022 at 6:37:21 AM

Thinking whether this is a common enough term to use for a disambig, since at least Sparrow and Bright seems to sorta use it that way?

Or might The Time of Myths be the wrong trope, if this history book uses it to describe the Enlightenment or something?

Age Of Wonder:

Edited by Malady on Aug 8th 2022 at 8:54:26 AM

So have there been any discussions about the two Pinnochio movies coming out this year? The one by Robert Zemekis for Disney and the one by Guillermo Del Toro for Netflix?

I believe the official title for del Toro's Pinocchio is literally Guillermo del Toro's Pinocchio, since that's what the trailer advertises it as.

So, we can probably save Pinocchio (2022) for the Disney remake.

Edited by chasemaddigan on Aug 10th 2022 at 4:52:31 AM

Disambiguated The Rolling Stones already, but Pinball.The Rolling Stones has wicks. Should it be The Rolling Stones Stern or something else?

There's two Rolling Stones pinball machines: [1] [2]

Rolling Stones (1980) by Bally

The Rolling Stones (2011) by Stern Pinball

Searching on TV Tropes, "(Bally)" and "(Stern)" are both used as disambiguations for various pages.

Edited by Twiddler on Aug 14th 2022 at 12:05:59 PM

Don't forget about the Rolling Stones magazine.

That one's singular, so it doesn't need to be disambiguated. It should be listed on the disambiguation page, but nothing beyond that.

Thanks.

I'm new to this so I'd like feedback please.

I'm making pages for some Just Shapes & Beats fan-comics, two brief ones by the same artist that I wish to make without using sandboxes are It's Over For Me and its one-shot crossover spinoff Lost In Blue, both in the Webcomic/ namespace.

The latter's to-be page would collide with VideoGame.Lost In Blue. Would the right thing to do be to make the fan-comic's page Webcomic.Lost In Blue Vine Bunny (to appear as Lost In Blue (VineBunny) ) so subpages won't collide? But then, if yes, should It's Over For Me be Webcomic.Its Over For Me Vine Bunny for consistency's sake or just Webcomic.Its Over For Me since it doesn't yet collide with any work pages?

Many thanks in advance.

"(VineBunny)" yes. Fan Works get less name priority than original works.

But can keep their regular names if no collide.

Not sure how many "Asunder"-s are in the Naruto fandom. FanficRecs.Naruto For Want Of A Nail Fics has one, MoralEventHorizon.Fan Works, has another, and then there's You're Not My Father and Second Love.

Not sure if any of them are the same one as any other.

Then there's the review.

This post.

Edited by Malady on Aug 16th 2022 at 8:49:10 AM

They're all referring to something called Naruto Asunder (or Naruto: Asunder), not just Asunder, and I can't find any other fics by that title, so I assume it's the same one, this one (which the fanfic rec and the Second Love entry link to).^note The title is written with no colon in the title field, but with a colon in the chapter text. The review was moved from the fanfic recs page and mentions "Wrath", a shortening of the author's handle.

Right, I was trying to match up the quotes, and at least the You're Not My Father "Mom" and "Dad" call are split over separate lines in:

https://fanfiction.net/s/5403644/23/

But I can't source any other quoes, although I've only tried Father and Horizon, up to chapter 20?

Edited by Malady on Aug 17th 2022 at 4:48:02 AM

I searched all the chapters and couldn't find them either. Hm..

Average NOOB added the MoralEventHorizon.Fan Works example as well as the Second Love one, so I'd assume they're referring to the same one.

Maybe ~Average NOOB can help clear this up?

In even stranger things, there's two Fight For The Lost fan works, with the Characters belonging to the Roleplay.

I think Tourist Trap can be made into a disambig page since there's a film and a web original with the name

We have TV channel I.O.N and Manga I.O.N. The wikiword is correct for the latter, while the former is all lowercase letters.

We can move the former to Creator.Ion Television.

Edit: Done. I assume we are moving the manga as well?

Edited by Berrenta on Aug 28th 2022 at 11:35:51 AM

Would it be a good idea to move the manga page and its subpages to a disambiguated title by year? As in Manga.Ion 1997?

Not a great idea, there's nothing else using the name according to Wikipedia, unless you've got some indie game or something called "Ion" you wanna make a page on?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ion_(disambiguation)

Creator pages usually don't trigger disambigs because their Subpage potential is low. Especially when they're companies and not people.

So, Music.IRIS is currently about Will Ryan's (of DAGames) solo music project. Despite it being in all-caps and showing as IRIS, it clashes that of Series.Iris, which shows up as Iris.
Currently, Trivia.Iris and YMMV.Iris refer to the series, and concern for how to make subpages for the music act was brought up here.

However, some wicks for Music.Iris refer to a different music act by the same name, a synthpop duo. See here from Dark Wave:

So to break this down into steps:

1. What would the disambiguated title for the synthpop duo by Andrew Sega and Reagan Jones be? Music.Iris Band to be Iris (Band)? Any other options I'm not aware of for disambiguating music pages? Mind that a page for this music act doesn't exist yet.
2. Then there's Will Ryan's solo act. I was thinking the moved title to be Music.Iris Will Ryan to show as IRIS (Will Ryan). But if its Spotify profile and this Fandom wiki page is anything to go off of, it could be moved to the rename Music.Iris Official instead, although the songs are also shared on the DA Games channel still under just "IRIS".
3. What of the Series/ page? I Should it be moved to a disambiguated title by year, as in Series.Iris 2009, and its subpages moved accordingly? Any feedback (otherwise)?

Googling "Iris music" gives a few results which don't match either of the above mentioned music acts anyway. ^note The most prominent result appears to be the song "Iris" by Goo Goo Dolls. Or can this be disregarded from the to-be Main/ disambig entirely? Might this warrant a disambig for Main.Iris?

~eXimiusMax pinging you to this because you stated the concern with Music/IRIS clashing with Series.Iris - I haven't checked on Will Ryan's IRIS in a while, I'd appreciate if you can give feedback on what title that music act should go to please (as I've explained in #2 on the numbered steps list).

Many thanks in advance again for the help.

Multiple musical acts with the same name. Tricky.

Can they be split into something like British / American, etc? Else I'd put the Duo in "(Duo)", or "(Synthpop Duo)" if we're really concerned.

...

I'm against "IRIS (Will Ryan)". Multiple names in a page name is very confusing. I'd have the disambig just say "An alias of Will Ryan".

Edited by Malady on Aug 29th 2022 at 4:33:42 AM

Splitting between American and British may be possible, the synthpop duo is American while Will Ryan is British.

On the other hand, if we opt to Music.Iris Official for Will Ryan's solo act, then the other could be Iris (Band). Googling "Iris official" does give Will's IRIS as the first result.

Just discovered today:

We have the TV series Supernatural...and the anime Supernatural. However, aside from YMMV, there's not much presence of the anime in the subpages.

- I would also not go Iris Official, it's very confusing when we have unofficial works on this site, a.k.a Fan Works?

Edited by Malady on Aug 29th 2022 at 7:47:02 AM